ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 มิ.ย. 2024
- Dr. Tara Stoinski, President and CEO and Chief Scientific Officer for the Dian Fossey Gorilla Fund, talks to WIRED about each great ape featured in the new 'Planet of the Apes' trilogy.
Visit the Dian Fossey Gorilla Fund for more info on saving Gorillas gorillafund.org/
For more info on ape distribution go to:
Chimpanzees >> www.iucnredlist.org/species/1...
Bonobos >> www.iflscience.com/plants-and...
Western Gorillas / Eastern Gorillas >> www.iucnredlist.org/species/9... / www.iucnredlist.org/species/3...
Sumatran Orangutans / Bornean Orangutans / Tapanuli Orangutans >> www.iucnredlist.org/species/1... / www.iucnredlist.org/species/1... / www.iucnredlist.org/species/1...
Still haven’t subscribed to WIRED on TH-cam? ►► wrd.cm/15fP7B7
Listen to the Get WIRED podcast ►► link.chtbl.com/wired-ytc-desc
Want more WIRED? Get the magazine ►► subscribe.wired.com/subscribe...
Follow WIRED:
Instagram ►► / wired
Twitter ►► / wired
Facebook ►► / wired
Tik Tok ►► / wired
Get more incredible stories on science and tech with our daily newsletter: wrd.cm/DailyYT
Also, check out the free WIRED channel on Roku, Apple TV, Amazon Fire TV, and Android TV.
ABOUT WIRED
WIRED is where tomorrow is realized. Through thought-provoking stories and videos, WIRED explores the future of business, innovation, and culture.
5:22 "Koba acts very un-bonobo-like"
*Wielding a machine gun riding horseback*
That's sooooo un-bonobo like
That just shows how f'ed up he got in that lab. To me that makes his character more intriguing. A naturally peaceful animal that was abused so much it turned into a brute.
Ahhaha
@GRAPHENE IS IN THE MASKS, SWABS and PCR TESTS!!! Bro stfu, you just one the prize for the dumbest conspiracy theory
@GRAPHENE IS IN THE MASKS, SWABS and PCR TESTS!!! It's mocap, dumbass, not a rubber costume.
Me at 11PM: I need some sleep
Also me at 3AM: mm yes monke
😂😂
Makes me wonder what happened to all the monkeys. I bet they all died in the zoos because no one was there to feed them
Downfall Hitler monke
lol definitely me rn
Chimpanzee: The violent
Bonobo The Chill guy
Gorilla: The Chad
Orangutan: The Wise guy
Human: The Crazy one
Gorilla Chad...
That is definitely a new level.
Humans have all those traits though
Human : The Main Enemy
Human..the planet destroyer
Chimps are impulsive, not violent.
Koba in the movies, pointing out scar after scar, saying "human, human, human" was really heartbreaking. :(
The fact that bonobos are generally passive goes to show just how badly those scientists treated Koba prior top the movie for it to make him as aggressive as he was.
Yeah, and the whole massive experimentation on their brainpower and emotional responses probably didn't hurt the change 😂
Lol ratas
i was going to say the same thing.. i feel its shown pretty clearly that koba is the way he is because of his upbringing.
or how little the writers knew about apes cause it's just a movie
Wait are you serious
Me: I'm bored
Wired: Here's a video about all apes in the Planet of the Apes franchise.
Me: Interesting.....
Literally
Cool story
me rn
Plizz listen to ''Via Vallen - Sayang'' !!
This is how everything on the internet works... What was the point here?? What were we to learn??
I love the fact that the dominant male gorilla takes in orphans. I didn't know that. Reminds me of a video I saw on TH-cam of the big, dominant gorilla in a wild troop enjoying some quiet time cuddling with a couple of very small juvenile gorillas. It's so freaking adorable.
I'm pretty sure I saw the same one, it was awesome.
mind sharing the link to the video
@@nur-gw5po i think he's talking about this vid th-cam.com/video/w5ZXH1VkILY/w-d-xo.html
You should see the female orangutan who drives a golf cart around the preserve (by herself mind you and better than most humans )… sometimes she even brings her buddy, a dog, along for the ride. Someone set her driving to The Sopranos music and it’s absolutely hilarious. Especially when she drives by the tiger cage and speeds up and gives the biggest FU smirk of all time.
Her name is Rambo and they even got her a new electric vehicle that looked so cool. Their intelligence is amazing !
@@marquisdelafayette1929 I have seen that! I go back and rewatch it every now and then. She's got one hand up holding the roof like a dad driving to the next golf hole. It's amazing. Orangutans are my favorite.
I LOVE Maurice. His relationship with Nova makes that 3rd movie SO good.
I just introduced my boyfriend to the trilogy before we see the new one... He became very emotionally invested in Maurice.. almost teary when he was going into the cabin to discover the little girl: "oh no, is something bad going to happen to Maurice? 🥺
Fun fact: Orangutan is an abbreviation of "Orang Hutan" Which literally means, *people of the forest* in Indonesian.
or to be exact, jungle folks.
Ya
@@lil_jong-un6668 that, or forest men, yeah we got the picture hahah
@@ardi.wibowo oh it's similar to utan in hiligaynon (one of the Philippines languages) which means vegetables
So interesting
Yeah my mom taught me that when we lived in indonesia
She was really fluent in bahasa indonesia
Koba being an hyper violent bonobo is a real testimony to how much suffering he must have been through before meeting Cesar.
...Or just bad writing.
@@themenagerie5247 bruh. What even is good writing anyways? Without suspension of disbelief every single story ever told or written is completely bonkers. Nowadays real life doesn't even seem real.
@GRAPHENE IS IN THE MASKS, SWABS and PCR TESTS!!! can't you and @ty the guy enjoy or appreciate things?
@GRAPHENE IS IN THE MASKS, SWABS and PCR TESTS!!! The character isn’t even a person in a rubber ape suit.. it’s a CGI animation based on motion capture. What are you talking about? You’re going after somebody when you have no clue what you are talking about yourself.
i never knew Koba was a Bonobo
The way she said that orangutans rely a lot on fruits does break my heart, knowing that the deforestations are still massively happening in Indonesia, esprecially in Kalimantan/Borneo.
OrangUtans also eats small insects like butterflies and termites.
They're almost gone in Borneo anyways, it's gonna be just Sumatra pretty soon.
@@fil4648 really?
A thought just occurred to me, that in this post apocalyptic setting the Orangutans might not be getting this very often in North America... outside of maybe berries
@@fil4648 I think the ones in Borneo are actually the more well off in numbers at 70-100 thousand individuals
Its the newly discovered Tapanuli Orangutans that have the smallest population at 800 because they're isolated to one mountain range.
In the films, the human DNA in the retrovirus not only affected their intelligence, but also caused some small morphological changes. This explains why they were able to speak and walk upright more comfortably.
It's fiction
@@joshuataylor3550 Yes. And I described what happened in that fictional story.
And it is a logical explanation too! The whole point of the virus was to reverse Alzheimer’s and the way it degrades every neural part of our body. So it probably has the ability to restore motor control and speech abilities, since they can be lost under the affects of the disease. So the idea of human-like animals without such degradation getting this boost and being able to walk better and be able to start talking isn’t too insane
@@Daniel-Strainchefs 👨🍳👌. I’m late but that reply was chefs kiss 😂😂😂
What a ratio@@joshuataylor3550
Orangutan is solitary, peaceful, non aggressive, intelligent, and the most fury among great apes that looks like cape -- Dude, Orangutan fit perfectly into the old wizard/guru/Jedi archetype.
yes, i feel that too. in movie he take a role as guru in group. because he only caesar mate who have same intelegence as him. he is act like adviser for caesar. it make me chill to the spine about their interaction. also maurice is borneo orangutan
In the wild. When the weather is raining, they take some of the branches and leaves and use it as an umbrella... And there is one orang utan that copied human washing clothes using soap
In the Discworld books, an orangutan wizard is a librarian.
He was human once, but was transformed in an accident. He refuses to turn back.
On contrary, after humans, male orangutans are the most violent and territorial creature in Borneo. It's a strong reason why they're solitary.
i love orangutans!!!!!
So refreshing to hear an articulate, intelligent and deeply knowledgeable scientist offering her insights, I could listen to Dr. Stoinski for hours, and remain so grateful for her efforts as a conservationist.
Her eyes freak me out
What an articulate way to earn yourself a simp title
@@skankhunt-wy9wy Wow I didn't know everything is a simp nowadays. I guess we can never admire people the way we used to....
Plize listen to ''Via Vallen - Sayang'' !!
@@Clumsy-xd5cj Wow I didn’t know everyone was a snowflake these days. I guess we can never make jokes the way we used to….
5:38 bonobos literally being like, "make love, not war" 😂
Koba fits so nicely into the slot of "Beautiful Evil" his actions are totally understandable and his hatred is pure for justifiable reasons, so much so that he's not entirely wrong in his assumptions; with the third film basically proving his point. One of the best antagonists ever put to screen.
He is a masterpiece
Excellently informative! My one quibble is that Koba wasn't meant to be a typical bonobo, but one who had been tortured so much and so often that he lost his essential nature--underlined by his demise when Caesar says, "Koba not ape."
Plizz listen to ''Via Vallen - Sayang'' !
@@thankuslay6766 dafaq
@@depunish3793 Plizz listen to ''Ghea Youbi - Gak Ada Waktu Beib'' !
@@thankuslay6766 paan si norak tolol. Embarassing.
@@revenant3516 Plizz listen to ''Nining Meida - Kalangkang'' !!
The tie-in novel "Rise of the Planet of the Apes: Firestorm" does a good job of showing how Koba's bonobo-like playfulness was crushed by the years of mistreatment he suffered.
Plizz listen to ''Via Vallen - Sayang'' !!
I didn’t even know Kobo was a bonobo for longest time
I didn’t know about this book, would you recommend it?
@@nohandleXD Absolutely!
@@nohandleXD its kinda trash tbh
the fact koboa is a bonobo i think adds more to his character. it shows how much trauma he went through, to change a normally peaceful species into a murderous villain
Learning that male gorillas adopt the little ones that lose their mom, feels good man.
I learned that Tarzan had it right when Kerchak had taken Tarzan in as his own. Wow thank you.
Plizz listen to ''Via Vallen - Sayang" !!
Kerchak originally killed Tarzan parents tho
@@Aristocratic13 I'm sorry but kerchack didnt kill kis parents it was the tiger who killed his parents
@@haroldthegamer7846 * Jaguar not Tiger
@@fangirldreamer748 oh sorry my bad
I could've listened to the full 14 minutes just talking about orangutans. Love them!! 🦧❤️
I actually “adopted” an orangutan and get updates on a cute one cared for by the BOS foundation in Indonesia and get updates on her progress frequently. I highly recommend it because they get many orphans and the contribution through “adoption” allows them to pay for the caregivers, the food, and the medical staff. Many of the orangutan also get released into protected areas after they are taught essential life skills. Good luck! I hope you find a great orangutan to adopt!
Maurice is my #1 character in the movies. lol
I love all apes, except Chimps.
Chimps wake up and choose violence.
@@hadrian270 omg I love the bos foundation
@@thankuslay6766 paan si
As a spaniard it really shocked me to hear her mention Snowflake. According to my mom, people were very sad when he died. In spanish his name was "Copito de nieve" which does indeed translate to snowflake, but the cuteness of the original name is lost when you translate it. The name would be better translated as Little snowflake, or Small snowflake
Yo espanyol, do you lika Taccos, Burritos n Churooos
7:56 Bonobos when a mild inconvenience occurs between them and another Bonobo
Ahahhahahaha, so true, lmao
Bonobos are the origional "I'm a lover, not a fighter" and i can dig that
They were even nicknamed hippie chimps for a reason decades ago
my memory is absolutely shite, as far as i was concerned i was watching this vid for the first time, scrolled down after seeing the bit about bonobos only to find I'd already said what i was going to say
Searxh up for some books of Frans de Waal. He has described them tons and tons of time
I believe they explained Koba’s atypical behavior in the movie. He had severe PTSD, which he acquired during his time living with humans. He showed no sign of aggression until the humans appeared.
I think she was just explaining their natural selves
@@jessop5125 yes, that's why I said his “atypical” behavior.
@@Reggy2000 Ah, I thought you were comparing him to the other apes in the movie. Sorry!
@@jessop5125 No problem, I should have written my first comment clearer, but I tried to keep it short.
@@Reggy2000 Don’t be silly it’s alright (:
Eight species of great ape (Hominidae), the smartest group of animals in the animal kingdom:
• Sumatra orangutan
• Borneo orangutan
• Tapanuli orangutan
• Common chimpanzee
• Pygmy chimpanzee (aka, the bonobo)
• Western lowland gorilla
• Eastern lowland gorilla
• and us, anatomically-modern humans.
The fact that gorillas take care of kids that aren’t always their own. So sweet 💜
Maokey
Simps
After killing the father. So sweet ❤
The CGI still really holds up. This is personally my favorite trilogy but I still have a lot of love for other trilogies but this one just really clicked with me.
It holds up because these movies are recent, it's not like they came out in the 90s
@@bopmoo 100 percent. But I’d argue war for the planet of the apes is still the best looking cgi film still and that’s been out for 5 years. It’s all a matter of opinion of course.
@@bopmoo someone actually pointed me to this video on cgi and why it doesn’t potentially look improved in some cases. It’s really interesting
th-cam.com/video/LM2s-McYNWM/w-d-xo.html
Ehh, I've seen better
LOTR: "Hold my oliphaunt!"
I like how human changed both kobas and ceasers natural instinct. Kobas a bonobo who tend to be gentle, was tortured by human all his life and became violent and dangerous. While ceaser a chimpanzee who tend to be violent and dangerous, was raised by humans and became a caring leader.
sadly in reality, when a human raises a chimp like a human, well, things don't usually end up well... for the human especially...
Definitely put that way on purpose by the writers
This video has some really good and funny editing, also really informative
I found this documentary so fascinating I learned so much. Thank you
This woman needs to be hired in future movies, her knowledge can provide the films with a lot of accuracy and facts to learn.
She wont make the movie exciting and produce multi millions. She’d make the movie an ape documentary that would have a few hundred thousand viewers😂
@@elijawashington3522 Funny right? Every Movies and Shows need one or other type of assistance in basing their lore in reality. Like why would they hire physicists in Interstellar (okay it's a different sci-genre which needs to be accurate to be believable on scenes though gets my point across)
@@elijawashington3522 😂
Jurassic movies
Company: hire some expert
Also company: dont listen to the expert
@@wryly8762 Atleast original Jurassic PARK movies tried their best and acknowledged where they were wrong. World on the other hand
Yes, the trilogy may be slightly unrealistic in terms of communication, behaviour etc… however, in the trilogy they’ve had the R-12 drug! They won’t act exactly the same as real life apes. Ceaser grew up around humans and so picked up much of the behaviour and habits of those people, which he then passed on to his tribe of apes.
Great video though! Interesting to compare the movie’s apes to real life ones.
Plizz listen to ''Via Vallen - Sayang'' !!
Yeah they were genetically engineered apes. Colliding science fiction with real zoological fact is the idea in these films
that was my first reaction too
"well duh they don't act like wild irl apes, they are all high on NZT" lol
As other commented have said, Koba’s atypical Bonobo behavior actually enhances his character because it indirectly demonstrates just how poorly he was treated by humans.
So, she’s not saying this movie should’ve done more research. She’s discussing how real life apes are similar or different to these movie counterparts. There’s a lot of people that would probably go and see these movies and assume that all apes act like Caesar and the others. She’s disputing this and telling us how they would really act.
This is really neat to learn about so thank you for your time in explaining the differences
Very informative. I like this lady. Never once I felt bored watching such a long video
I swear this trilogy needs to be talked about more, it’s one of those times where prequels are as good and arguably better than it’s predecessor film. And also Serkis’ performance as Caesar is spectacular.
One of the best trilogy of films for sure
Today years old when I found out Silverback isn't a species of Gorilla.
this suddenly got me interested in studying about these great apes.❤️ how beautifully she explains!!
Ive come back to watch again, since the announcement, of Kingdom of the Planet of the Apes..
This is so informative. Please do another.🦍
What a wonderfully gentle human she seems
Her stare kinda scares me lol
strange way to put it but yea shes cool
@@thugnificent863 that was the point
@@thugnificent863 fine too 😌
@@john.jai.sullivan would smash
“Chimps communicate just like we do”
Chimp to orangutan: Top of the morning to you mate
Orangutan: *tips fedora*
Lol
I genuinely thought this video was OLDER!!! But then, she mentioned TAPANULI ORANGUTAN!! Boomed, yes, mindblown! I love all the descriptions in the video and how informative you sound. Thank you
Dr. Stoinksi - Thank your for a very informative video! Really enjoyed it!!
I love when actual scientist get a chance to rip movies apart
big faxx
@Not RickRoll 👇ᨆ no
Movies are still great though
she didn’t rip the movie apart at all
she didn't you dumbass
love this trilogy! orangutan literally means man of the jungle.
Plizz listen to ''Via Vallen - Sayang'' !!
@@thankuslay6766 norak
@@danurkresnamurti3598 Plizz listen to ''Nining Meida - Kalangkang'' !!
@@danurkresnamurti3598 Plizz listen to ''Sony Josz - Terminal Madiun Ngawi'' !!
@@danurkresnamurti3598 Plizz listen to ''Nella Kharisma - Sebelas Dua Belas'' !!
what a wonderful Day
Very interesting and informative video 😊
Adversities can really change a creature. Last year during lockdown I saw all the street dogs ganging up together and attacking and killing a stray pig for food. These dogs were otherwise really passive and used to sit outside shops being fed by passersby.
Plizz listen to ''Via Vallen - Sayang'' !!
That's actually pretty sad
Seeing how much people love pork too, can't blame them for doing that. oink oink
They just want to help with the hog problem
@@yoboikamil525 In Texas feral pigs are designated an invasive species. You can kill them any way but poison year round.
Idk if she forgot the fact that these are genetically enhanced apes but I'm glad she makes the good comparison to natural real apes.
Right it's not bashing fiction merely separating what the filmmakers did to give it that cinematic flare to reality
@Clément BRAVIER c ededs
Yea
This is a really good video I learned a lot thanks
Great report!!!, thank you for such pro explanation, helps a whole lot!.
I need a full series of zoologists reviewing animals in movies, it's so interesting!!
Yes, I definitely agree‼️
I think there are some other videos on insider where a zoologist talks about animals in movies
I can imagine “shark biologist reviews jaws”
@@Sledge447 they did this one and it’s awesome!!
Literally just started rewatching the trilogy a few days ago, what amazing timing lol
th-cam.com/video/a5q2tS5iTO8/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/g6XFiDoRctw/w-d-xo.html \/
Plizz listen to ''Via Vallen - Sayang'' !!
@@thankuslay6766 th-cam.com/video/a5q2tS5iTO8/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/g6XFiDoRctw/w-d-xo.html |
@@crubbythebeagle57 Plizz listen to ''Siti Badriah - Lagi Syantik'' !!
@@thankuslay6766 no and I never will
Wow thanks for the information great video
Love these films. So underrated.
This franchise is kinda underrated. The first one isn't, but the rest of the movies IMO are.
th-cam.com/video/a5q2tS5iTO8/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/g6XFiDoRctw/w-d-xo.html \/
The second is the best
@@gustavosauro1882 I think so as well
Plizz listen to ''Via Vallen - Sayang'' !!
@@thankuslay6766 please stop requesting that garbage song please.
"Apes stronger together"
Means allot when you realize that can include us too.
That's how humanity went so far
@Only The truth ten human body builders... heh, puny humans...
Very interesting video. Thanks!
amazing video; thank you Dr.Tara! i love your intelligence and enthusisam about animals🙏
This lady knows way more about these species than I know about my family members.
😂😂
I love Apes so much. We need to protect our cousins. I was fortunate enough to go on a Gorilla Trek in Rwanda recently while working in Kigali, and it changed my life.
Plizz listen to ''Via Vallen - Sayang'' !!
In such cosmic civilization term, apes should be our second cousins if humanity got destroyed or demolished by sort of advance alien civilization.
Apes are always my type of humanity.
Agreed that these amazing creatures need to be protected. Although, they are not our cousins.
@@michaelb9500 We share over 90% of our genomes with gorillas. Even more with Chimpanzees. That makes them very closely related IE cousins.
@@jackl45 With respect, I didn't say there were no similarity. But similarity doesn't prove relation. You'd have to have common ancestors. And we do not.
The planet of the apes movies will always be remember as a masterpiece to me and amazing video :]
this was dope- and i really enjoyed the way she spoke as well. she needs a channel
Maurice is my faaaavorite! So calm & full of love & understanding. I get why he immediately latched onto Nova. I feel he was so important to Caesar... He kept him grounded.
My favorite too🥹
Videos like this are what make me want to become a zoologist. Animals are so unique and interesting. Yea I'm going back to school
Good luck bro
Wishing you the very best
wish you the best in your career.
Go for it!!! I am a primatologist in the making too ❤️
it aint for everyone. dont be afraid to quit and finding an easier alternative.
Really helpful the edditor used pictures of both chimpanzees and bonobos at random during their respective segments
im obsessed. i love that makes gorillas literally adopt baby gorillas that are vulnerable☹️
“They’ve been seen trying to use sticks to stab bush babies” *googles bushbabies* 😭😭😭😭
It's only the females that so it because the patriarchy of chimp society refuses to share large game with the females.
That’s what I did lol that are savages
they also eat other chimp kids when they attack other groups.
Then you should also Google how bobo a silverback gorilla keeps a bushbaby as a pet. Saw an image of that not long ago
Edit: gorillas are awesome. Never forget harambe
@@kjugirl Oh yea I forgor 💀
I still get chills every time I watch the first movie when Cezar says “No!”
The fact that humans are also considered Apes adds more meaning to "Apes Together Strong!"
That intro was a mouth full
I love this lady’s way of teaching. I learned so much without getting bored, i was not expecting all of that
So for this Universe, here are the roles:
Chimpanzees: Skilled Workers, Food, Gathering, Scouting, Workforce
Bonobos: Governing, Settling Disputes
Gorillas: Warriors, Law Enforcement
Orangutans: Teachers, Record Keepers, Skilled Workers and Tradesmen
What about humans?
Good commentary. I'm looking for a palaeontologist talking about all the micro adaptations that were required to allow our last common ancestor with chimps / bonobos to develop into us. Not just brain size, but also brain organisation. The multitude of adaptations to make large scale sociality possible. Changes to the hyoid bone and bones of the inner ear to allow us to make human speech sounds and to hear them accurately...
Imagine if they had Gigantopithecus in Planet of the Apes.
Where we get the myth of the Sasquatch, Yeti and Bigfoot
Her: *Orangutans, Gorillas, Chimpanzees, Bonobos.*
Me: *Monkey.*
Monke
Zeke
Zucchini *
Ap
@@jediorlos9084 😐
Planet of the Apes trilogy is the GOAT movie trilogy. No debates.
Plizz listen to ''Via Vallen - Sayang'' !!
I agree, it's better than the dark knight trilogy in my opinion and I like that trilogy but I give the apes trilogy a notch above it
110% agree
yep one of the few good trilogies.
Lotr?
Planet of the Apes was a good movie to explain to people that Apes and us are the same and they speak just like we do and they live just like we do
Awesome video!!!!
Bonobo boy scares the crap out of me. Awesome.
Plizz listen to ''Via Vallen - Sayang'' !!
@@thankuslay6766 why ?
Ironic that the villain Koba of the series is a bonobo, which are the most peaceful of great apes.
This really helped me understand myself thank you
The perfect video doesn’t exi…… how have I not found this until now?!
This was actually very interesting and the way she articulated everything made it so easy to understand. She didn’t make me feel dumb but made me feel like I came to a college class to learn about apes xD
Now I know how passive bonobos are, it only breaks my heart more knowing why Koba acts the way he does.
This was very interesting video. This lady gives us a lot of interesting facts.
Can we get a longer version of this
Unlike all the other apes in the films Maurice knew sign language and how to communicate with it before he was even infected by the virus.
Subtle way for them to show how intelligent orangutans are.
12:51 "People forget that humans are apes"
13:57 "What's amazing to me is that no apes were involved in the filming of this movie"
😂
This is the best video on youtube
I absolutely loved their adaptation of this movie!
Doesn’t really matter the subject, it’s always interesting listening to an expert on something they’re passionate about
"Apes Together Strong"
~ Caesar
awesome video
5:39 wait does that include when two males get aggressive? 😳
Uhh, yea maybe...
Me when see Monke : *MONKES.... ASSEMBLE*
@its fine agreed habibi
Hamood
ape* 🦧
@@TILLO_MUSIC Monke
@@TILLO_MUSIC no
Finally some real journalism
These are my FAVORITE movies and I’m so glad people actually know what they are!
Very well explained..