For mixed , I preciate SeungKwan's voice, among idol gen 3, he always makes me impressed. But for overall technique, I have to say that Yoseob is the best. He can handle any genre of music and make his voice suit with that song so well
I’m glad some fans still know Yoseob. For those who don’t, he is a really great vocalist from Highlight/BEAST or actually all the members are great vocalists. A few hits of theirs I recommend is Fiction, 12:30 and Good Luck. Seungkwan and other SVT members are their fans too.
yoseob voice is so high thats why he can hit 14 high notes back then and his unbelievable lung capacities plus his voice so unique. you will reconize him right away after heard his voice once...sorry fireplace cat haha you cant hide your identity
isn’t it Yoseob > Baekhyun > Seungkwan overall i remember yeoseob being really really good back in the day at one point i think it was him and hyolyn who were the best like female and male vocalists so that says something bc he still has it baekhyun has always been good since debut like and he’s just constantly improving honing his skill
once you hear yoseob sings, i do not think anyone could forget that voice. So outstanding and unique. Our king of singers. i do not see any song by him that have other better version like- he even killed many original masterpieces out there...
@@ReggieVu I don’t think Baek resonated that C#5. I can hear a lot of throatiness, pushing and tightness with a high larynx. It’s not a bad performance since it’s extremely high but far from relaxed and supported.
@Lab Grassroots you see only my showcase series where all the notes listed are supported/resonant, while the for the battles it’s a display of set of notes and just see who hit it better ^^ just like the BadaTaeyeonWendy and LinaHyeanaLuna vids ~
Solely for mixed, Seungkwan seems the best here. His resonance is very consistent. His control is nice. I guess the G4 is really his place. His resonance in G4 is quite big. He has the most balanced mixed here. He seems the best in mid to upper 4th octave. That thing that hinder him to become a proficient vocalist is his lows, his mixed is now in the proficient level. He seems the most consistent up to G#4/A4. Carats should appreciate his vocals more, seeing Seungkwan rank 2nd or even 3rd is just a bit off. The gap between him and DK isn't that large but it is pretty pretty noticeable. Second is Baekhyun, the thing with Baekhyun is that he usually likes to pushed too much, also his mixed is quite unbalanced. His resonance seems very nice. The ease in the 5th octave tho. Healthiest technique in the 5th octave. He is consistent up to G#4/A4. Third is Yoseob, he's quite consistent up to G4/G#4 with resonance. He has fair issues with nasality. He might be the least technical skilled in mixed here but overall it's the other way around. His lows and headvoice is the best here, that reason gave him the boost. His lows are well developed, consistent support in headvoice up to C#5. Only for mixed: Seungkwan>Baekhyun>Yoseob Overall technique: Yoseob>Baekhyun>Seungkwan For Above Average to Proficient, is it now like Yoseob>Baekhyun/Onew>Seungkwan>Rokyun>G.O?
@@ReggieVu Seungkwan is last due his lows right? Even though his mixed is competent worthy, his lows still drag him down. Who has better upper register DK or Seungkwan? Seungkwan seems more relaxed to me. Both of them seems have a connected headvoice, Seungkwan's falsetto seems more relaxed?
@@wushyringg oh Seungkwan has a head voice? I still haven't heard him connect one haha, mostly a relaxed falsetto. I've seen DK use a head voice on a more consistent basis but yeah his falsetto doesn't seem to be as relaxed as Seungkwan. They're somewhat tied? but I assume the gap is very minimal if there's any.
Baekhyun is my ultimate bias and my favorite belter but dang Seungkwan is such a great belter at such a young age he got me shook lol, it gets me pissed when carats say that DK is better than him.
@Pinkii Lights yeah same I always see people praise them because of their sync but individually not that much praise but Dino being better than Taemin that's really shocking !!!! then he's that good wow, and woozi too I always wonder why he's not in the dance line like he's really good but I thought that Sehun and Yuta are the best lead dancers in Kpop and yes Seungkwan is the best vocalist out of the groups who debuted after 2015 fallowed by NCT's Taeil if I'm not mistaken, Like look at the amount of talent Seventeen has.
@Pinkii Lights well I don't know that much about dancing techniques but wow you seem to know so much and some infos you said got me shook like woozi being better than Taeyong and Hoshi that makes the fact he doesn't have a dance position even worst like what's up with you Pledis ?!! Dino being the best male idol dancer ever and Shotaro a better dancer than Kai, wow that's so much shocking infos 😂
@Pinkii Lights OK yes the gap between Seungkwan and DK is really big and what about Ten is he good I don't see a lot of people talk about his dancing skills, another thing what do you think about Aespa's Karina ? she got a lot of hate because of her dancing, is she that bad ?
Bro I was skeptical about watching ranking or comparison videos like this but I'm glad I found yours. I like how the comment section has more of objective facts than personal opinions. I love all of their voices and I'm a beauty before I was a carat, but as a "mom" carat (because I literally started stanning them during seventeen tv days so that's before their debut), I love how my "son" is compared to his two big sunbaes and that alone is a big feat. Also, how incredible it is that the notes they hit are comparable considering Seungkwan is younger and has fewer years of experience as an idol. Loved the video during seventeen tv and most of his vids coming from unofficial covers or 'playful' clips, those vids compared to the videos shown here for Baek and Yoseob which are all videos after their debut and most are from concerts or music show performances is a big comfort and pride for us carats. Thank you for this video 😌👏
Hi guys! I'll be taking a break from making videos due to personal stuffs anddd to fully focus on the male ranking. I'm still not sure when's the release, could be within the next few weeks or longer, but it's already on the way. I'll still be checking comments as usual and update you guys if there's anything noticeable regarding KPop vocal. Thank you for the continuous support and as usual, stay tuned!
Seungkwan easily wins this battle, although Baekhyun isn't too far behind (he mainly needs to work on his issue of push-yness and resonance consistency above G4). Yoseob is good, as always, he's just not as good as the other two.
Seungkwan is not counter tenor. Besides counter tenor is not a voice type to begin with. It's a voice role. Any tenor with a bright and light voice can play it . Seungkwan is a lighter tenor
I miss when seungkwan was this consistent, hopefully he's rested well even if It's a short and he'll comeback with some open belts in their october comeback 🙏
I don't know why I found myself watching this again tho lol. But yeah, Seungkwan was still fine even on 2020/2021 especially on his vlives, idk what happened after that year tho.
@@doroshiya He didn't regressed but somehow he's been thinning out. The last time I've heard him produced "resonance" was around 2021, and his Lee Mujin Service wasn't a good material for him imo. I hope he would release a new cover that would require him to belt and impress us again. Either way, their songs (the group songs and BSS) don't really showcase his capabilities at all so I wouldn't be surprised if there is some decline on his belting later on.
@@doroshiya Also, it seems like he didn't put that much effort in recent years, he still sound the same in their recent Pinwheel performance as he did in 2017-2019.
@@whynot-sr8wn I don't necessarily identify as a man. I identify as a boy (I know it's confusing 🥴🥴) I don't like getting called "Mr" "Sir" and all sorts of female and male formalities
Who is the higher tier among these four? Line them up in order from the top! ・ Kim Bum Soo ・Naul ・Park Hyo Shin ・lee soo ・ha hyonwoo ・ Kang Kyun Sung ・Kyuhyun ・jung dongha ・K.Will ・yoo hweseung ・Kim Yeon Woo Please choose from the following 🙏
@@ReggieVu thank you. To think that Kang Kyun-sung's rank is so low...! Also, is Park Hyo-shin a match for So-hyang? Also, if you rank the vocalists listed above in descending order of technique, how would you rank them?
@@yanyan.wonwom Kang Kyun Sung's order looks a bit low because the ones above him are just more advanced, he actually has shown quite a number of improvements over the years. If I had to make a guess, I'd probably say he is around Average or Average to Above Average. His approach up to G4/G#4 isn't bad at all PHS for me is the closest example to an Excellent Male Tenor, but Sohyang still has upper hands due to her extensive technique in Mix and Head voice and yes the ranking above is already based on Technique
@@ReggieVu I see... I thought Kang Kyun-sung would be good up to A#4 ^^.Sohyang has the upper hand after all! I have a question for you who know a lot about K-pop vocalists! Are there any men with a higher vocal tier than Hyoshin? Also, what would happen if Eunkwang and EXO's Chen were included in the above?
@@yanyan.wonwom when Kang Kyun Sung ascends above G#4, there is a clear shift in his technique where he relies more on squeezing the throat which produces tension, which from what I've grown accustomed to, not a good sign And no, I don't think there are any male vocalists who could be ranked higher than PHS. The trinity has always been PHS, Jung Dongha and Naul If Chen was here, he would be slotted right below Kyuhyun If Eunkwang was here, I would put him right below Kim Bum Soo
I want to ask how good Moonbyul’s cover is. I saw a lot of people recommend this video th-cam.com/video/ZjhctbeifW0/w-d-xo.html And Moonbyul vs gfiend Eunha Yuju vs hwasa And Is there support for D5 in the video? Solar's OST th-cam.com/video/MmB66Ox0QQo/w-d-xo.html
the cover is exactly how I've always anticipated her general approach to be. 0:10 A3, she was able to produce tone here; 0:25 F3 with tone again but done on a lowered larynx; 0:58 G4 and F#4, all sung with throat tension; 2:06 I hear a high larynx on this G4; 2:17 strained A4; 2:17 relaxed falsetto. As usual, she wasn't truly supporting her voice here. the answers to these can be found in my ranking vid~ Solar's OST: 2:11 that's a strained and shouty D5 for me; 2:13 resonant B4; 2:16 still too much pushing and tension on this D5; 2:20 resonant B4; 2:30 slightly closed throat due to the vowel, followed by resonant B4s; 2:48 strained D5. She remains the same for me.
@@ReggieVu (B2)It seems that it was when Solar first came out (downward bass (? I don’t understand haha) th-cam.com/video/BnvlPaVH1Q4/w-d-xo.html 1:24 (B5)th-cam.com/video/X4wj4SYDTh0/w-d-xo.html 5:13 (Eb7 2014Flip)th-cam.com/video/K7l6Ic59aXQ/w-d-xo.html
Lmao the fact that everybody had serious singing clips and then theres Seungkwan just fooling around but still singing so good I'm so impressed. Also his resonance like whattt? I never knew he was THAT good and consistent with it tysm for making this video it helped open my eyes even more about their singing capabilities
Lol baekhyun will eat all the other guys (maybe not seungkwan as a whole) becuz he's a full lyric tenor and have the tessitura as just as high as the other higher voice guys (seungkwan sound light lyric tenor who's bordering full lyric while yoseob sound like very high and small tenor/tenore contraltino).
someone who’s more familiar with him told me that he has B2/C3 - A4 - D5/Eb5 with resonance, so I don’t think it’s enough to be higher than Competent to Good.
@@b.1295 sorry for the late reply. I'm not exactly good with sub voice fachs but from what I've heard, the weight in his approach and his output volume don't resemble a full lyric tenor.
Aside from jongho, are there any higher than standard 4th gen bg main vocalist? And who are the 4th gen bg main vocalists you considered to be a stand out?
@@ReggieVu now that i have listened to him, he really sounds solid and his agility is nice too, am i right? I find his run decent for how he takes more complicated runs
The video is not fair to me since you hardly put notes or Baekhyun's best high notes, you only put the notes of your favorite cante, for me Baekhyun is better and of course he has better notes, only you don't put them.
@Carat4life He is noticeably better. Seungkwan produces resonance regularly while DK can have issues with tensing his muscles even within his usual supported range.
@@ReggieVu I don’t agree. Dk can convey more emotion and is better at belting and high notes while making it sound natural. Dk also has a wider range and has unbeatable falsetto. I will admit that seungkwan has better technique but Dk is still amazing
@@anyway8691 DK is better at belting and high notes? hmm give me DK's F4-A4 just like how clean and resonant Seungkwan in that range. Wait, in the last sentence, we didn't say he isn't amazing tho, we just say Seungkwan is technically, objectively better than DK. Emotions are too subjective.
@@cutedog9185 just to be sure EXO's vocal line also includes Suho and Xiumin right? but still EXO's vocal line is slightly better because Suho supports while Moonbyul doesn't. As a group the other members really drag the overall rating down so MMM wins.
@@ReggieVu but isn't the gap really big ?! like Baekhyun the last techinqual vocalist in EXO's main vocals is still better than Wheein the best in MMM although I agree as hole group but I find it unfair to compare a 9 member group to a 4 member group.
![[Belting Battle] B1A4's Sandeul vs Super Junior's Kyuhyun (F#4-C5)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZaRwjDVfP2o/mqdefault.jpg)
![[ENG] BAEKHYUN from EXO talks on the life of K-pop Idols🌟 His Delight-ful Mindset |#YouQuiz](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/7yATwITvmsM/mqdefault.jpg)
For mixed , I preciate SeungKwan's voice, among idol gen 3, he always makes me impressed. But for overall technique, I have to say that Yoseob is the best. He can handle any genre of music and make his voice suit with that song so well
Baekhyun does that as well. His album is literally rnb heaven, his ballad is great, he has done amazing rock & funky pop is just easy for him CBX.
I’m glad some fans still know Yoseob. For those who don’t, he is a really great vocalist from Highlight/BEAST or actually all the members are great vocalists. A few hits of theirs I recommend is Fiction, 12:30 and Good Luck. Seungkwan and other SVT members are their fans too.
yoseob vocal range is no joke damn impressive
I started listening to kpop from the 2nd gen and Beast is one of my fav groups. Yoseob is such an amazing singer.
yoseob voice is so high thats why he can hit 14 high notes back then and his unbelievable lung capacities plus his voice so unique. you will reconize him right away after heard his voice once...sorry fireplace cat haha you cant hide your identity
No matter how many other singers i listen to i dont feel the emotions. power and smoothness as when i listen to yoseob. Yoseob is the best
Yang Yoseob will always be my # 1. ❤️🥰
Of course, Yoseob is the best
my og bias king yoseob being appreciated 🥺😭💕
isn’t it Yoseob > Baekhyun > Seungkwan overall
i remember yeoseob being really really good back in the day at one point i think it was him and hyolyn who were the best like female and male vocalists so that says something bc he still has it
baekhyun has always been good since debut like and he’s just constantly improving honing his skill
overall skill set wise yes that should be correct. But the gap between Yoseob and Baekhyun is not too noticeable I believe.
Yoseob w/stability and less/almost no auto tune❤️..
Yoseob
Seungkwan’s resonance holy cow
Seungkwan’s ease always impresses me
I was absurdly impressed already by the first note out of Yoseob.
YOSEOB
once you hear yoseob sings, i do not think anyone could forget that voice. So outstanding and unique. Our king of singers. i do not see any song by him that have other better version like- he even killed many original masterpieces out there...
yoseob
i didn’t know seungkwan is that resonant like he surprised me a lot, i love baek’s c#5 in that hynn song
Yep Seungkwan is consistently THAT resonant
@@ReggieVu I don’t think Baek resonated that C#5. I can hear a lot of throatiness, pushing and tightness with a high larynx. It’s not a bad performance since it’s extremely high but far from relaxed and supported.
@Lab Grassroots Oh no of course he didn’t resonate it. The support/resonance in this vid only extends up to A4 hahaa.
@Lab Grassroots you see only my showcase series where all the notes listed are supported/resonant, while the for the battles it’s a display of set of notes and just see who hit it better ^^ just like the BadaTaeyeonWendy and LinaHyeanaLuna vids ~
@@ReggieVu Ah I thought the original comment said Baekhyun’s resonance on that note was surprising. Read it too quick. Oops
Yoseob for me :)) but seungkwan has the best technices
Baekhyun has tone, tecnique, emotion.. everything
lol that pic of Seungkwan is a gem
baek’s heady mix is really an advantage in the 5th octave.
Solely for mixed, Seungkwan seems the best here. His resonance is very consistent. His control is nice. I guess the G4 is really his place. His resonance in G4 is quite big. He has the most balanced mixed here. He seems the best in mid to upper 4th octave. That thing that hinder him to become a proficient vocalist is his lows, his mixed is now in the proficient level. He seems the most consistent up to G#4/A4. Carats should appreciate his vocals more, seeing Seungkwan rank 2nd or even 3rd is just a bit off. The gap between him and DK isn't that large but it is pretty pretty noticeable.
Second is Baekhyun, the thing with Baekhyun is that he usually likes to pushed too much, also his mixed is quite unbalanced. His resonance seems very nice. The ease in the 5th octave tho. Healthiest technique in the 5th octave. He is consistent up to G#4/A4.
Third is Yoseob, he's quite consistent up to G4/G#4 with resonance. He has fair issues with nasality. He might be the least technical skilled in mixed here but overall it's the other way around. His lows and headvoice is the best here, that reason gave him the boost. His lows are well developed, consistent support in headvoice up to C#5.
Only for mixed: Seungkwan>Baekhyun>Yoseob
Overall technique: Yoseob>Baekhyun>Seungkwan
For Above Average to Proficient, is it now like Yoseob>Baekhyun/Onew>Seungkwan>Rokyun>G.O?
yeah that sounds accurate.
I don't follow G.O. much these day but if he still has the head voice then imo Yoseob > Onew~Baekhyun~Rokhyun > G.O.~Seungkwan >=Seunghwan
@@ReggieVu Seungkwan is last due his lows right? Even though his mixed is competent worthy, his lows still drag him down. Who has better upper register DK or Seungkwan? Seungkwan seems more relaxed to me. Both of them seems have a connected headvoice, Seungkwan's falsetto seems more relaxed?
@@wushyringg oh Seungkwan has a head voice? I still haven't heard him connect one haha, mostly a relaxed falsetto. I've seen DK use a head voice on a more consistent basis but yeah his falsetto doesn't seem to be as relaxed as Seungkwan. They're somewhat tied? but I assume the gap is very minimal if there's any.
1 question, who has better lows Onew or Yoseob?
Baehkyun's voice is the reason of my existence----
@Pinkii Lights Just facts
I love baekhyun's belt kn the 4th octave, they're light yet full and with a great amount of resonance, they're so pleasing
I love Baekhyun, but Yoseob's voice is so beautiful too
I prefer Seungkwan but like they all slay
My Yoseob 🥺
Yoseob's vocals are always the best...
Baekhyun is my ultimate bias and my favorite belter but dang Seungkwan is such a great belter at such a young age he got me shook lol, it gets me pissed when carats say that DK is better than him.
@UCgLTjj9Jde5NaoYokHl45qA yeah he didn't get the fame he deserves because of his talent, they always see him as the happy virus of the group :(
@Pinkii Lights yeah Dino also is a great dancer like seventeen is a group full of talented idols.
@Pinkii Lights yeah same I always see people praise them because of their sync but individually not that much praise but Dino being better than Taemin that's really shocking !!!! then he's that good wow, and woozi too I always wonder why he's not in the dance line like he's really good but I thought that Sehun and Yuta are the best lead dancers in Kpop and yes Seungkwan is the best vocalist out of the groups who debuted after 2015 fallowed by NCT's Taeil if I'm not mistaken, Like look at the amount of talent Seventeen has.
@Pinkii Lights well I don't know that much about dancing techniques but wow you seem to know so much and some infos you said got me shook like woozi being better than Taeyong and Hoshi that makes the fact he doesn't have a dance position even worst like what's up with you Pledis ?!! Dino being the best male idol dancer ever and Shotaro a better dancer than Kai, wow that's so much shocking infos 😂
@Pinkii Lights OK yes the gap between Seungkwan and DK is really big and what about Ten is he good I don't see a lot of people talk about his dancing skills, another thing what do you think about Aespa's Karina ? she got a lot of hate because of her dancing, is she that bad ?
I dont understand a thing but i love SK, im here for him
Oh okay, that's good to know
@@willianesantos3303 just to note, he is the best on belting between these 3, if we talk abt other thing, then it would be a different story..
@Pinkii Lights how low does seungkwan supports? he’s still a above average to proficient vocalist, prolly lower than prime taemin tho
@@cutiieeepatootieee2002 usually around Eb3
Same hahah
wow seungkwan I didn't know you're that talented
seungkwan's voice is the best
Bro I was skeptical about watching ranking or comparison videos like this but I'm glad I found yours. I like how the comment section has more of objective facts than personal opinions. I love all of their voices and I'm a beauty before I was a carat, but as a "mom" carat (because I literally started stanning them during seventeen tv days so that's before their debut), I love how my "son" is compared to his two big sunbaes and that alone is a big feat. Also, how incredible it is that the notes they hit are comparable considering Seungkwan is younger and has fewer years of experience as an idol. Loved the video during seventeen tv and most of his vids coming from unofficial covers or 'playful' clips, those vids compared to the videos shown here for Baek and Yoseob which are all videos after their debut and most are from concerts or music show performances is a big comfort and pride for us carats. Thank you for this video 😌👏
Hi guys! I'll be taking a break from making videos due to personal stuffs anddd to fully focus on the male ranking. I'm still not sure when's the release, could be within the next few weeks or longer, but it's already on the way. I'll still be checking comments as usual and update you guys if there's anything noticeable regarding KPop vocal. Thank you for the continuous support and as usual, stay tuned!
Take ur time ^^
@Pinkii Lights I will wait but not patiently lol------
You will be missed, but understandable. I can't wait to know the ranking haha.
I'm gonna wait *patiently* for the ranking to be posted, if I can 💅..
@Pinkii Lights *a lot* indeed
Amongst yoseob's king of masked singer performances which would you say is his best stage vocally?
Bus Station
ヨソプの歌声がほんとに好き
지금이 한창인 3세대 아이돌 메인보컬들과의 비교대상으로 꼽는 2세대 아이돌이란거군요
11:13 요섭 Eb5
Yoseob💛
Yoseob is the indisputable king 👑 seungkwan and baekhyun are really good at their craft as well
Seungkwan easily wins this battle, although Baekhyun isn't too far behind (he mainly needs to work on his issue of push-yness and resonance consistency above G4). Yoseob is good, as always, he's just not as good as the other two.
Oh and I forgot to mention Baekhyun's ease in the 5th octave LOL. His is even greater than that of some sopranos haha.
@Pinkii Lights yes, because of his heady mix in his upper belting range (his lower is very chesty tho).
You are wrong. yoseob low and head voice is the best here. Only for mixed he is behind. Overall ranking is yoseob > baekhyun > seungkwan
@@dongnipongni3964 this video specifically focuses on mixed voice lol.
Los 3 son mis favoritos, pero seungkwan me transmite mucho cuando canta 🥺💙
10:55 *wig has left the chat
l like baekhyun sing ❤️❤️❤️
Seungkwan’s has the best belts with most power, most relaxed, most stable… I mean he is counter tenor range what do you expect.
Seungkwan is not counter tenor. Besides counter tenor is not a voice type to begin with. It's a voice role. Any tenor with a bright and light voice can play it .
Seungkwan is a lighter tenor
@@vampiregaming9820 I know that that’s why I wrote “range”
@@MultiStan1516 that doesn't mean any shit either 🤦🏽♂️😂
@@resurgingflame embarrassing
@@vampiregaming9820 aren't they all light tenors?
I miss when seungkwan was this consistent, hopefully he's rested well even if It's a short and he'll comeback with some open belts in their october comeback 🙏
I don't know why I found myself watching this again tho lol. But yeah, Seungkwan was still fine even on 2020/2021 especially on his vlives, idk what happened after that year tho.
@@wushyringg what's different with him from 2021 onwards? is he regressing somehow?
@@doroshiya He didn't regressed but somehow he's been thinning out. The last time I've heard him produced "resonance" was around 2021, and his Lee Mujin Service wasn't a good material for him imo. I hope he would release a new cover that would require him to belt and impress us again. Either way, their songs (the group songs and BSS) don't really showcase his capabilities at all so I wouldn't be surprised if there is some decline on his belting later on.
@@wushyringg ah, i understand it better now. thank you for answering
@@doroshiya Also, it seems like he didn't put that much effort in recent years, he still sound the same in their recent Pinwheel performance as he did in 2017-2019.
10:55
BbhGANTENG
GANTENG
GANTENG
YES HE IS HANDSOME
WKWKWK
Me straining all notes above D#4 in mix will beat every Vocalist out there😗🙄✊
Me straining C#4s: 👁👄👁🔫
you are a man?
@@JS-st8pp we better than Sohyang
@@whynot-sr8wn I don't necessarily identify as a man. I identify as a boy (I know it's confusing 🥴🥴)
I don't like getting called "Mr" "Sir" and all sorts of female and male formalities
@@mamamoobestgroup4376 okay, so you are a boy right?
Baekhyun recently is the best for me
Yay New video💙💙💙
baekhyun!!!!!
0:22
Was that a good run? It sounded beautiful to me
it was kinda slided imo~
@@ReggieVu really? I thought it was beautiful
that sounds like a weird trill if you ask me
How can you compare baekyhun is one of the best vocalists in the kpop Industry but no one seems to mention him
i'm a little embarassed to say that this video was how i found out seungkwan had vibrato
What 😭 he uses vibrato a lot, far more than DK
@@debutriah2854 sorry 😭😭
For belting, Baekhyun is the best amongst these three.
Ithink there some tier B AA-P
But yoesob little beat
Can you make a video about 4gen male vocalist? I haven't seen any so i think it will be interesting
there will be some 4th gen idols in my upcoming 3rd gen ranking vid ^^
@@ReggieVu thanks
@@dancingintherain3798 lol keeho is p1harmony (?) Im not sure
I see what you trying to do with putting those 3 againsteach others (although I may be reading too much into it lol )
Yeah chances are you’re overthinking it 😅
@@ReggieVu you're doing a male ranking as a video format? With categories?
@@BAZVOCALS yep I am. Wait why you're suddenly asking this lol I'm just curious ~
@@ReggieVu cause i know there will be some ranks i won't agree on :D
@BAZISSINO 94 Oh that’s totally expectable lol
Who is the higher tier among these four? Line them up in order from the top!
・ Kim Bum Soo
・Naul
・Park Hyo Shin
・lee soo
・ha hyonwoo
・ Kang Kyun Sung
・Kyuhyun
・jung dongha
・K.Will
・yoo hweseung
・Kim Yeon Woo
Please choose from the following 🙏
for me:
PHS
Jung Dongha
Naul
Kyuhyun
Ha Hyunwoo
Kim Bum Soo
Kim Yeon Woo
Yoo Hweseung
Kang Kyun Sung
Current KWill
Lee Soo
@@ReggieVu thank you. To think that Kang Kyun-sung's rank is so low...! Also, is Park Hyo-shin a match for So-hyang? Also, if you rank the vocalists listed above in descending order of technique, how would you rank them?
@@yanyan.wonwom Kang Kyun Sung's order looks a bit low because the ones above him are just more advanced, he actually has shown quite a number of improvements over the years. If I had to make a guess, I'd probably say he is around Average or Average to Above Average. His approach up to G4/G#4 isn't bad at all
PHS for me is the closest example to an Excellent Male Tenor, but Sohyang still has upper hands due to her extensive technique in Mix and Head voice
and yes the ranking above is already based on Technique
@@ReggieVu I see... I thought Kang Kyun-sung would be good up to A#4 ^^.Sohyang has the upper hand after all! I have a question for you who know a lot about K-pop vocalists! Are there any men with a higher vocal tier than Hyoshin? Also, what would happen if Eunkwang and EXO's Chen were included in the above?
@@yanyan.wonwom when Kang Kyun Sung ascends above G#4, there is a clear shift in his technique where he relies more on squeezing the throat which produces tension, which from what I've grown accustomed to, not a good sign
And no, I don't think there are any male vocalists who could be ranked higher than PHS. The trinity has always been PHS, Jung Dongha and Naul
If Chen was here, he would be slotted right below Kyuhyun
If Eunkwang was here, I would put him right below Kim Bum Soo
I want to ask how good Moonbyul’s cover is. I saw a lot of people recommend this video
th-cam.com/video/ZjhctbeifW0/w-d-xo.html
And Moonbyul vs gfiend Eunha
Yuju vs hwasa
And
Is there support for D5 in the video?
Solar's OST
th-cam.com/video/MmB66Ox0QQo/w-d-xo.html
Solar has B2 in good luck
B2-B5-Eb7(Tweeter duel)
Wheein C3-F#5-C#7(F6 head voice in my star)
(C#7 Tweeter duel)
Hwasa C#3-E5-A6
the cover is exactly how I've always anticipated her general approach to be. 0:10 A3, she was able to produce tone here; 0:25 F3 with tone again but done on a lowered larynx; 0:58 G4 and F#4, all sung with throat tension; 2:06 I hear a high larynx on this G4; 2:17 strained A4; 2:17 relaxed falsetto. As usual, she wasn't truly supporting her voice here.
the answers to these can be found in my ranking vid~
Solar's OST:
2:11 that's a strained and shouty D5 for me; 2:13 resonant B4; 2:16 still too much pushing and tension on this D5; 2:20 resonant B4; 2:30 slightly closed throat due to the vowel, followed by resonant B4s; 2:48 strained D5. She remains the same for me.
@@sunstar_moomoo221would you mind giving me some timestamps for these notes?
@@ReggieVu (B2)It seems that it was when Solar first came out (downward bass (? I don’t understand haha) th-cam.com/video/BnvlPaVH1Q4/w-d-xo.html 1:24
(B5)th-cam.com/video/X4wj4SYDTh0/w-d-xo.html 5:13
(Eb7 2014Flip)th-cam.com/video/K7l6Ic59aXQ/w-d-xo.html
Wheein F6 2:55-3:05
Hwasa A6? th-cam.com/video/jAmVJ3YI4UM/w-d-xo.html 4:09
(Solar A5) 3：17
is it weird that I like baek's throaty vocal belts?? huhuhahaahha
Hi, may I know if I can share this on tiktok?? and ofcourse with proper credit😊
No problem! Feel free to share with me here the tiktok link after you have uploaded as well
I guess the problem with the likes came back 🤣
oh I actually forgot to turn that on haha ty~
Lmao the fact that everybody had serious singing clips and then theres Seungkwan just fooling around but still singing so good I'm so impressed. Also his resonance like whattt? I never knew he was THAT good and consistent with it tysm for making this video it helped open my eyes even more about their singing capabilities
vs 말고 x 해놓고 셋이 노래 같이 부르라고 하자
ㅇㅈㅇㅈ
I'm not quite sure who yoseob is but my personal favourite is seungkwang.
he's the main vocalist of a 2nd gen group B2ST/Highlight. They got some iconic stuffs back then haha.
He has a pretty timbre.
Okay his timbre is prettier than I thought.
I mean..... You didn't put "Slaying belts" in the thumbnail for no reason hahah.
Hello .
Goodbye
hello fen CM
@@ReggieVu fen CM? ._.
@@ellieenjoyer he's my friend lmao
@@ReggieVu Oh I got it lol
Lol baekhyun will eat all the other guys (maybe not seungkwan as a whole) becuz he's a full lyric tenor and have the tessitura as just as high as the other higher voice guys (seungkwan sound light lyric tenor who's bordering full lyric while yoseob sound like very high and small tenor/tenore contraltino).
Mee too. Baekhyun's belts sounds very rich and full.
Many people said that he's a light lyric but I believe baekhyun is actually a full lyric.
Dưa cho em hỏi bài Seungkwan hát ở 3:22 là bài nào hay ở fancam nào được k ạ???
bài Merry Go Round nha b mình lấy từ vid này nè th-cam.com/video/tRZI1F9hHok/w-d-xo.html
À với mình chỉ là mem collab thui nha chứ ko phải Dưa đâu :v
@@ReggieVu huhu em xin lỗi vì đã đã nhầm ạ :'( cả em cảm ơn ạ
where can I watch 1:52 3:22 ?
th-cam.com/video/tRZI1F9hHok/w-d-xo.html for both of those timestamps
@@ReggieVu thank you so much!
Can you rate Ha hyun woo? I Think he is good or good to great
someone who’s more familiar with him told me that he has B2/C3 - A4 - D5/Eb5 with resonance, so I don’t think it’s enough to be higher than Competent to Good.
@@ReggieVu Okay, thank you
@@ReggieVu Do you think he is a full lyric tenor?
@@b.1295 sorry for the late reply. I'm not exactly good with sub voice fachs but from what I've heard, the weight in his approach and his output volume don't resemble a full lyric tenor.
@@ReggieVu Oh you don't have to apologize. Thanks for answer.
please make doyoung vs taeil, who has better mixed? overall?
The overall ranking is out in about 6hrs ~
@@ReggieVu woah it will make my day! just 2 more hours to go!!
@@ThaoThu-nu1vo I'm havong some troubles with the file so I'm not sure if it can be out on time TT but definitely within the next 24hrs at worst
@@ReggieVu oh, it's so bad. hope you can solve it soon. take your time!
Aside from jongho, are there any higher than standard 4th gen bg main vocalist? And who are the 4th gen bg main vocalists you considered to be a stand out?
Well if Keeho’s indeed a Baritone then he might be above Standard as well. Other than these two I haven’t noticed anyone else~
@@ReggieVu keeho? What group does he belong?
@@starandmoon1055 p1harmony~
@@ReggieVu dang...they also have good dancers
@@ReggieVu now that i have listened to him, he really sounds solid and his agility is nice too, am i right? I find his run decent for how he takes more complicated runs
The video is not fair to me since you hardly put notes or Baekhyun's best high notes, you only put the notes of your favorite cante, for me Baekhyun is better and of course he has better notes, only you don't put them.
Which note for example?
Could you please add Dk from seventeen next time? Thanks for the high questions video😀🙏
Included in this video? or make another comparison? I don't think DK's mixed is good enough to be included in this video.
@@wushyringg so are you saying seungkwan is better than Dk?
@Carat4life
He is noticeably better. Seungkwan produces resonance regularly while DK can have issues with tensing his muscles even within his usual supported range.
@@ReggieVu I don’t agree. Dk can convey more emotion and is better at belting and high notes while making it sound natural. Dk also has a wider range and has unbeatable falsetto. I will admit that seungkwan has better technique but Dk is still amazing
@@anyway8691 DK is better at belting and high notes? hmm give me DK's F4-A4 just like how clean and resonant Seungkwan in that range. Wait, in the last sentence, we didn't say he isn't amazing tho, we just say Seungkwan is technically, objectively better than DK. Emotions are too subjective.
Who's a better vocal group between MMM and EXO?
And would you be able to add explanations?
you mean as a whole group or just the vocal line?
@@ReggieVu both?
@@cutedog9185 just to be sure EXO's vocal line also includes Suho and Xiumin right? but still EXO's vocal line is slightly better because Suho supports while Moonbyul doesn't. As a group the other members really drag the overall rating down so MMM wins.
@@ReggieVu but isn't the gap really big ?! like Baekhyun the last techinqual vocalist in EXO's main vocals is still better than Wheein the best in MMM although I agree as hole group but I find it unfair to compare a 9 member group to a 4 member group.
I don’t understand the comments here literally only baekhyun is hitting the notes effortlessly??
You didnt see the video and just commented, right? 🤣🤣
@@햄찌파-n4p no I saw it and he is the only one hitting the notes easily
@@smilekaki6510 lmao that's just you, denying
@@햄찌파-n4p only one here denying is you
that's not effortlessly lol look at his throat