ہم ایسے قابل لوگوں پر خخخخخخائی تھو تھو اسکے چاھنے والوں پر تھو تھو اسکو لانی والوں پر تھو تھو تھو انکے بڑوں بڑوں پر تھو تھو تھو تھو اور تیری جیسے بیغیرت پر تھو تھو تھو
Absolutely candid,to the point,real economic giant,he should be at the helm of affairs for Pakistan.I love his views,he has inculcated each and everything in simple n straightforward manners.
@Maz Oh! Such talent is *abundant* in Pakistan. Dr. Farrukh Saleem (Economist) is Prime example of such talent. Mian Atif is a Fake-Muslim (Qadiyani) so, who can accept his fake-economics. U r ignorant & blind. 😎😎😎 Terrorists are only found in Wahabism. I am not Wahabi. But, since u r stupid & ignorant *how would you know the difference*.
U certainly do have a very pathetic mindset, and u should be ashamed of it. Islam grants everyone, be it muslim, hindu, jew, or of any other religion, equal rights. I get it, he is an ahmdai, but it is for some reason that he is considered amongst top 25 IMF economists. You calling him stupid is a joke, because i am sure that u urself dont even have a clue about economy and the finance sector. He is actually much smarter than u. As for the fact, that u say since he is not muslim he should not be in the cabinet, then tell me how come sadiq javed is the interior minister of UK when he is a muslim, how come omer alghabra is a Secretary in canada, and how come arif alikhan served in the obama administeration in the US, so please grow up. The Prophet said, "U have ur religion and I have mine". Pakistan was made by muslims but not just for muslims. It is a country for people from all races and religions a quaid e azam himself said, "U are free to go to ur mosques, church, and temples", so please,kindly grow up. I request u to end this hatred on the basis on religion and allow good intelligent people to serve our beautiful country and take it to the next level. Please, i urge u to rethink.
One can feel that deep love for Pakistan in his eyes. Such a humble person. If Imran Khan gets another turn, he should try to educate people, to never listen to religious fanatics when it comes to politics and financial matters of the country. How many of those fanatics have sold out their personal properties/ cars etc. to settle off Pakistan's debt? It is a challenge, just a single such example would be enough to prove my point wrong.
@@azratasneem7210 dost, pakistan needs all the economists of the world at the moment. We also faced such situation of crisis in 1991 and Dr. Manmohan Singh came on the scene as the crisis manager in chief, Later on he went on to become third longest serving PM of india so Pakistan has to learn to utilize, respect and award talents if they really want to be a successful democratic state.
Imran Khan has done a great mistake by removing this man from such a crucial position. His personal beliefs have nothing to do with the state affairs. 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
And ironically he removed him based on the pressure from the same religious fundamentalist parties; which are now sitting in opposition and complaining about poor economy and inflation. By his decision to not back Atif Mian Imran Khan pretty early in his term proved that he is not the same man who would stand by his selection against all odds and opposition. I knew right then that Imran Khan left his backbone on a cricket pitch somewhere and finally become a lousy politician.
No political leader has the courage to get him here.He is safe and better outside in a safe society. Can't afford to lose him in this intellectual waste land, driven by religious and sectarian bigots.
For the very first time I have taken a great pleasure listening to someone. And I m so sorry that our ##### religious leaders are curse on our country. No nation or culture or civilization can be destroyed or conquered unless it's morally corrupt and lazy from inside.
It was premier who took back the charge from Mr Atif .People of Pakistan demands many things but its premier's decesion that should be honoured by all Pakistanis.
@@asifhashmi3051 so if the premiere gives the order to shoot down your entire family. Should that also be honoured? I don't think you fully appreciate how silly your argument comes across. Now, I get that there was a tremendous pressure on Imran and since he had to make tough economic choices from early on given the state of the economy he inherited, it wouldn't have made sense for him to not take the politically expedient route and to burden himself with more unpopular decisions, especially ones that were easily avoidable and not directly related to the economy itself and had more to do with politics, especially religious politics. Even though it felt like a gut punch, the choice he made regarding atif Mian at the end still exculpates him of the charge of bigotry against ahmadis in my view, given the circumstances he faced at the time.
Hashmi sahib you are exactly true that Pakistani leader should rethink for the betterment of country and peoples the time they had and there are loosing will not come back
Look Atheist call themself non_muslim But qadiyanis being non_muslims and after being declared non_muslims call themself a muslim. Thats the main issue.. the Islam they represent to the world is based on lies.... come on yar.. go and read the books of mirza qaidiyani malhoon.. and then come in support of atif mian
@@lahoriravian4610 he who bow to the dead bodies are gumrah .. thats what we call them... and as i told you that you better worry about yourself.. end of conversation
Yes we seek help from atheists as they completely deny what we believe instead of trying to modify our belief unethically. It is as same as some local restaurant claims to be a branch of McDonald's unethically.
@@aliasjad381 You making a big mistake by comparing Islam with a brand...Islam is not a brand it is a faith, and to determin who is right or wrong that right has only Allah! So don't try to play god! Learn from the past Isa a.s. was accused by the jewish scholars to have commited blasphemy. But Allah knew that Isa a.s. is a true prophet!
He is a talented and deserved to be minister or advisor of finance. We should respect and prefer talent and foresight about economic crisis of Pakistan despite religion extremism. D
Haan bhai Dollar ke liye to hum Islam beech de..jaise america aur china jinhone muslims ko afghanistan aur xinjiang main maara. Hum dono se bheek maangte hain. DOLLAR is powerful than Allah mian.
@@mosin682 abay chutiyay mei khud qadyanio ko muslim nahee samajta par ghazwae badr kay baad jin kafiro ko rasool pak nay hukam diya tha kay 10 musalman bachay parhao aur azaadi hasil karo unho nay hadith ya quran toh parhana nahee tha bacho ko.Kya woh ashiq e rasool thay? MEINAY ATIF MIAN KO KABHI MAZHAB PAR BAAT KARTAY NAHEE DEKHA AUR TUNAY USAY GHUSTAKH BHEE BANA DIYA ( WOH KAFIR HAY).AB RIZVI NAY TOH ECONOMY SAHI KARNI NAHEE HAY INKAY HEE MASHWARAY LENAY PARAY GAY KYU KAY HUMARAY MOLBIO NAY HUMARI AWAAM KO JAHIL RAKHA AUR AAJ HUM QADYANIO SAY MASHWARAY LENAY PAR MAJBOOR HAY
@@mosin682 bewaqoof insaan *jab ek company ka CEO/malik jobs deta hai* apni company mein logon ko toh woh jobs apply karne walon mein *SABSE ZADA QABIL logon ko select karta* hai taake uski company ka na sirf nuqsaan na ho balke aage jaaye aur behtreen kaam kare, *jis company mein sabse zada qaabil log hon aur unki qaabliyat ka behtreen istemaal bhi company kare toh WOHI company sabse aage hoti hai!* *AUR YAHI EXACTLY CASE HAI EK MULK KA BHI*
@@mosin682 Is zamane mein mulk ki taraqqi ke liye (jaise kisi bhi company ko bhi) brilliant minds behtareen damaghon aur achi policies aur law (including implementation of law) ki zaroorat hoti hai!
@@mosin682 ab agar companies ke CEOs mazhab, firqe, nasal, imaan ke level ya rang roop ya family ya kapre dekh kar jobs dein toh woh companies top per nahi aa saktin aur issi liye western countries waise jo marzi unke kuch politicians doosri qaumon ya Islam ke khilaaf kehte rahein LEKIN woh inhi countries ke behtreen damaaghon ka istemaal karke apni taraqi karte hain. iske muqaable mein Pakistan ki jahil awaam kehti hai ke kyunke hum falane falane ke mazhab/aqaaid se ikhtalaf rakhte hain unhein kafir maante hain toh unse kaam nahi lena. inteha darje ki jahilana aur bewaqoofana soch hai.
Wish he was born in India 🇮🇳, we would have nourished his talents and he would be a jewel in our country like our beloved Ex president Late APJ Abdul Kalam
Most of my fellow country men saying that Religious Extremists did not let the gentleman in question to serve in Pakistan due to his religious beliefs but None of these people raised or stood against those Extremists ppl. Majority of Pakistanis either they are belong to upper class, middle class or working class have the same beliefs as Religious Extremists. We all are Religious Extremists & intolerant people.
We all stand united against qadyani scums who are trying to create a rift in the muslim ummah. We are not religious extremists but we are on one page and are extremely intolerant when it comes to these qadyani scums. Qadyani murdabad
It takes a lot of courage to introspect and admit one's own faults. But that is the only we can collectively become a better person, society, and country.
hammad durrani mein hon Qadri Suni Brelvi deobondi tan tan tanatan labaik labaik ya jahil awam labaik speaker waje speaker confirm janati ha wo confirm lanati ha tue
By Bernd Debusmann Jr BBC News October, 10, 2022 US immigration: Why Indians are fleeing halfway around the world The latter group range from Muslims, Christians and "low-caste" Hindus to members of India's LGBT community who fear violence at the hands of extreme *Hindu nationalists*.
@@أنا-أهل-السنة sir ye ahmadiya log b naki pak S.a.w ko mantay hain clear.. And the second thing is that what you people like mullah mindset had done for your nation? Just spread terrorism? Hah?
This guy said a very key point here. You got the point right? Use the money you borrowed on project that will generate money which will help to return the borrowed money and will keep generating money. But if you use that money on something that will not generate money and you also dont have other that much permanent resources to pay off your loan you are doomed. This is that simple. So PTI government hired as finance adviser Abdul Hafeez Sheikh the same guy who served in PPP government as a finance minister and obviously country went under more debt then so I dont understand why IK would hire the same person again.
It is sheer tragedy that such a brilliant brain was not allowed by the extremist religious groups to work in Pakistan. And the only reason was that he is Qadiani. Most most unfortunate. 😐
@@usmankhaki, yes and if I am not totally out of memory, he was invited to Pakistan by IK as part of economic advisory comittee. But our mullahs and media started protesting that hi was Qadiani and should not be included in it.
@@nzubr wo controversy m ne suni hy..... Lakin history ajkal research kr raha ho many western historian and Muslim historian ko parh ka yeha idea howa business, development, social reforms m jab politics or religion ajaye wo qoom tabahi ka sabab bbnti hy. M ajkal Caliph usmania par research kar raha ho tb jang mazhab k name pr hoti hy same ajke Pakistan and India k same halata hy.... M parh raha tha Catholic jo k romi empire k neeche parwan char raha tha full control tha us par.... Or protenst par kafi pressure tha dono Christianity k sects hy.... Unka aqeeda tha k jab tak qustuntunia par hakomat rahe ge tb rk qayamat or zawal nai aye ga room ko.... Us waqt turko ke سلطنت bbe expand hoti ja rahi the... Us waqat Sultan ke shahi toop banae wala bhe Christian tha jo ziada salary k lalich m Sultan k pass aya tha. Wo pehlay khud gaya tha room k badshah k pass lakin unho ne series nai lia..... Us toop dunia ke sb say bari jang ka پانسہ palt dia.. History ko hame remember rakhna chahye.... Wo economist hy... Hamre country m oor bhe hy is ke ham pala... Jo k arab m kam kar rahe hy.. Sirf baaten ka maqsad history sy hame seekhna or talent ke qadr krni chahiye bila امتیاز.....
@@fbbadsha7177 . Ji bilkul .yeh to duniya ka sab se be waqoof banda hei . Agher yeh genious hota to eik sacha musalman hota .aur sachey musalman ki pehchan yeh hei keh us ko tammam islami kalma jaat ka pata ho ya na ho usko yeh to lazmi pata hona chahiye TERI BAHAN DII SIRI O DALLEYYYYYYYYYYYY O KANJRIANNNN O BEI GEIRATTTTTTTTT Ye 4 buniyadi baatein jis ko zubani yaad hon woh pakka musalman aur pakka jannati
@@lahoriravian4610 bilkul ya 4 bunyadi baten zaror yad honi chahiya ta k hr jhutty kazaab ko is kalamaat sa nawaza ja sky sahi waqat pa . Agr 18vi sadi waly ya kalmat yad rkhty to ya fitna phelta e na
This is the second lecture of this personality l have heard.Being a student of economics I have ernest desire that his such lectures deliverd of and on . Thanks by the host.
I agree he is a non muslim but he is a competent man and thats why moula Ali A.S said : Kufar ka nizaam chal sakta hay zulm ka nahee. Aaj woh baat kitnee sach sabit ho rahee hay UK,USA,Norway all are doing well however Pakistan,Egypt,Afghanistan are struggling so badly kyu kay yaha zulm ka nizaam hay
I have a lot of respect for Dr Atif Mian. Unfortunately, our country and coward leadership is afraid of religious fanatics and extremists. In fact, our country is in staunch grip of these extremist minds and religious,political and military demagogues.What a shame, we are living in a society so backward and narrow-minded that they judge people not by its qualified abilities but its faith and religion. Indeed, my Islam is not in danger from anyone but these extremist Mullahs.
Brilliant suggestions for Pakistan: 1- State capacity: strong and professional leadership and delegation of authority. 2-Environment: Harmony among people for trade and own capacity building in order to attract investments. 3-Education and skills development. Every government prefers shortcuts like foreign aids to artificially stabilize the economy, and the current government is not doing anything different. Environment change is a big threat to current fundamentalists who hold the country's policies and receives funds for these activities. Education and skills are again the big threat to traditional politics and fundamentalists. Therefore, there seems no chance of real economic growth.
He is very good brain. What ever his belive this is his personal matter. Imran Khan should get advice from him. and he should give advice to prime minister.
@@mosin682 , Everyone is answerable in their own grave about their faith. You worry about yours and let others worry about theirs. You dont have to HATE someone in order to go to heaven on the day of judgement. Allah is giving Qadyanis EVERYTHING. He has given them life, money, children etc.. Are you bigger than Allah to take everything away from them?
Pakistan missed the opportunity to take advantage of this able man just because of religious difference. To me he is a True Muslim because Ahmadiyyat is the true form of Islam which prophet Muhammad PBUH founded nearly fifteen hundred years ago.
It's very unfortunate that a leading economist is not considered by the country because of his religious background. It's time for the country to consider the ahmadiyya community being considered as non Muslim should be reverse. They are as pakistani as the rest of us. Any body should not be excluded because of his gender, color, religion etc. This is what quaide axam has also said.
Mai atif mian ko non Muslim manta hon lekin is bat me koi shak nahi k talented hai ye aur dua krta hno in k liay k ALLAH inko real islam me dakhil kry aur Pakistan k liay khidmat le in se. Aameen
M waqar Wiki . aap mujhe kuch ikhlaq waale lagte ho .Hum Ahmadi musalman hein leikin aap ka aqeeda musalmanon wala nahi hei .mein sabit ker sakta hoon.. Kahan se shuru krein ? Quran se sabit kroon ga .with translation... leikin final terjuma aap hi ka mana jae ga . Theek hei ?
@@lahoriravian4610 quran aur hadees me prophet mohammad ko khatim ul nabiyyeen kaha gya hai. Un k bad kisi aur insan k zilli nabi ya zilli rasool hony k bare me quran ki ik b waziha ayet nahi hai.
@@mwaqarwiki1289 . hum aap ko hadees dikha sakte hein leikin aap kahein ge keh yeh to zaeef hei .hum sirf Quran per focus kerte hein. 1 . Quran ne Hazrat Eisa AS ko nabi aur rasool.bola hei aur nabuyat ko inam kaha hei .aap Eisa AS ka intezar ker rahe ho .ab aap hi bataein keh Eisa AS ko nabi ke taur per maanein ge ya geir nabi .ummati hona nabuyat ke inam se bra inam nahi hei .kyon keh ummati to Nawaz Shareef , zardari , Rana Sanaullah wageira bhi hein. Agher nabi nahi maana to Quran ki taleem hei jis ne kisi eik nabi ki nabuyat ka inkar kiya , us ne sab nabiyon ka inkar kiya . Ab aap hi bataein aap ka kone wala aqeeda hei ?
@@lahoriravian4610 pehli baat tw ye hai k hazrat eesa aen gy ya nahi isi baat me ikhtilaaf hai muslims me kuch scholars k nazdeek nahi aen gy. Agar wo aen gy b tw nabi ki hasiyat se nahi blky prophet Mohammad k ummati bn kr aen gy . Aur ragi inaam ki baar tw wo pehly nabi ki hasiyat se aa tw chuky hain inaam already ho chuka hai aur jb phir aen gy tw nabi nahi hno gy wo lekin inaam yafta bando me se tw hno gy hi . Ap is baat se mirza ghulam ahmed k haq me daleel sabit nahi kr skty ap log tw unko imam mehdi b b manty ho , eesa b manty ho aur kahien jagha wo khud ko Mohammad saww ka hi dosra janan kehty hain . NaAozbillah , aur khud pr wahi nazil hony ka b dawa kia . Ye sab kufar hai. Agar 1400 saal bad ik nabi ne ana hota tw quran naam le kr btata unka . Lekin quran me eesa AS ka zikr milta is bare me lekin kisi aur k any ka zikr ni milta ho ga.mirza ghulam ahmed k apny dawon me b koi same baat nahi hai kahien wo kuch dawa krty hain kahien pr kuch.
@@mwaqarwiki1289 . aap logon ko khud apne aqeede ka pata nahi hei .mazhab mein agher magher nahi hota hei . . Hazrat Eisa AS agher nabi bn ker nahi aate hein to Quran ki roo se woh Allah aur Allah ke Rasool SAW ki attaat se khud hi bahir ho jaate hein. Quran mein likha hei . Jo Allah aur Allah ke Rasool SAW ki attaat lerta hein woh un logon mein shamil hein jin per Allah ne inaam kiya yani anbiya , Shuhdaa, suhalehein , aur siddique . . Aur yeh kitne achey rafique hein... ab Quran ki ias aayat ke hote hue jis mein sab kuch tafseel se likh di gae hei keh jo bhi Allah aur Allah ke Rasool SAW ki sahih attaat kre ga un ko nabuyat bhinmil.sakti hei , unko shahadat ka derja bhi aur suhalehein aur siddique bhi .agher aap in inamon mein se kisi eik ke bhi munkir ho jaate ho to phir aap ke haath se sab kuch chala jata hei .na hi aap shaheed ho ge aur na hi Allah ki nazer mein aap sualahe aur siddique kehlao ge . Jab ueh sab kuch nahi raha to is mazhab ka kiya faida phir . 2 ... jis trah ka aap Quran mein Eisa AS ke baare mein Quran ki ayaton ka terjuma kerte hein is trah se to Hazrat Eisa AS khuda ka beta sabit ho jata hei . Quran mein Eisa AS ki Allah ne misal di hei sirf .
Mr Imran Khan could invite Dr Manmohan Singh to help plan a economic model for Pakistan. I am sure Dr Singh would pour out all his heart into helping Pakistan
I have read almost 40 comments and everybody is supporting Sir Atif.But my question is ,where were all these people when stupid mollas and conservative minds were protesting against this great personality?Why no one took stand for him?
Yes, that's the point... It's easy to suggest anything but practical are difficult. India has the skills. Pakistan has 30,000 to 40,000 and Pakistan can't export any while India export every one they produce.
Those who leave negative comments about atif mian and his believes haven't understood the core lesson from history...to prosper in any field you need a Tolerant Society!!! That comes first, before corruption and other things. To bow down before extremists is also a kind of corruption, because you don't want to lose votes/popularity!
Thank you BBC and Atif Mian sb, Please serve the country by giving weekly video suggestions on your tube and BBC, these will help your countrymen and poor people.
What a pragmatic and viable approach to our problems. I feel sad that people of such calibre have been rejected by myopic decision makers. USA invited immigrants from worldwide to come and build it to be a super power. As long they were competent they rose up to levels in their respective professions, regardless of their ethnic and religious backgrounds. We need to honour such professionals and rise up from petty religious differences.
His webinar at Princeton University is a gem. Especially real estate and sugarcane farming economy. Learning experience for everyone interested in economy of developing countries.
Quaid e Azam cabinet was including Qadyani, Hindu Cristian, and Parsi ministers, that meritocracy also reflects in his 11th September speech, but later on, all Quaids vision was buried along with his historical speech. Now you can only see Mr.Jannah on currency notes....
I am sorry sir you can't help us because of our extremist fanatics they have nothing to do with our lovely religion i as proud sunni Muslim ashamed that we can't resist them
Yar we dont have any problem with Atif Mian as finance minister if he accepts that he is non_muslim.. Qadianis[ahmadis] dont accept that they are non_muslim.
@@aquagemsandjewellery9145 . Why are you de gtading the Holy Quran by putting your own words in other's mouth .. I know you never ever touched Holy Quran . In Quran it is written.. " THERE IS NO COMPULSION IN RELIGION . You are not above Quran .How dare you people reject what Allah says in his Holy book Quran
![BOWKYLION - วิงวอน (ex-change) [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/cLdnZWDaO-w/mqdefault.jpg)
افسوس کہ پاکستان آج ان جیسے قابل لوگوں سے بہت دور ہے ،
ہم ایسے قابل لوگوں پر
خخخخخخائی تھو تھو
اسکے چاھنے والوں پر تھو تھو
اسکو لانی والوں پر تھو تھو تھو
انکے بڑوں بڑوں پر تھو تھو تھو تھو
اور تیری جیسے بیغیرت پر تھو تھو تھو
Stunning anaylsis by Atif Mian Such a brilliant man
Great personality ATIF SIR I salute you♥♥💖💖🎖🎖
simply brilliant May Allah bless him
Pakistan needs a leader like Atif Mian.
Brilliant Dear Atif Mian. We are so proud on you. Sad Pakistan is no seeking you advise.
The great atif mian, surely a man needed badly by pakistan finance think thank.
@Muhammad Saad really...so how is the economic situation going on right now ???
@Muhammad Saad
Where are these intelligent brains????
Absolutely candid,to the point,real economic giant,he should be at the helm of affairs for Pakistan.I love his views,he has inculcated each and everything in simple n straightforward manners.
Maschallah
Very nice sir
Jamaat Ahmadiyya zindabad
Zindabad
We should get advice from this gentleman regardless of his beliefs.
You expect this from a country that chased away its own Albert Einstein(Abdus Salam)...let's hope we have learned
@Maz
Oh!
Such talent is *abundant* in Pakistan.
Dr. Farrukh Saleem (Economist) is Prime example of such talent.
Mian Atif is a Fake-Muslim (Qadiyani) so, who can accept his fake-economics.
U r ignorant & blind. 😎😎😎
Terrorists are only found in Wahabism. I am not Wahabi.
But, since u r stupid & ignorant *how would you know the difference*.
U certainly do have a very pathetic mindset, and u should be ashamed of it. Islam grants everyone, be it muslim, hindu, jew, or of any other religion, equal rights. I get it, he is an ahmdai, but it is for some reason that he is considered amongst top 25 IMF economists. You calling him stupid is a joke, because i am sure that u urself dont even have a clue about economy and the finance sector. He is actually much smarter than u. As for the fact, that u say since he is not muslim he should not be in the cabinet, then tell me how come sadiq javed is the interior minister of UK when he is a muslim, how come omer alghabra is a Secretary in canada, and how come arif alikhan served in the obama administeration in the US, so please grow up. The Prophet said, "U have ur religion and I have mine". Pakistan was made by muslims but not just for muslims. It is a country for people from all races and religions a quaid e azam himself said, "U are free to go to ur mosques, church, and temples", so please,kindly grow up. I request u to end this hatred on the basis on religion and allow good intelligent people to serve our beautiful country and take it to the next level. Please, i urge u to rethink.
@Maz
Sassti *choot* waalay 😜😝😛
Talha Yousuf Allah has never given anybody the right to declare anyone a Muslim or not. So when u call ham a fake Muslim, you take Allahs authority!
Brilliant man. So sad our country mullaa did not understand this talent.
Brilliant mind.. Pakistan need him
Abid Lyallpuria عابد لائلپوریہ kafir hai bhai ya
@@nadim.9571 ap k use karny wali 90 percent cheezy kafro ki he banai hoi hain
@@rafiahmad7292 wajebull khatala ha
@@naseemajee6937 himat ha tu kar lo.auhkaar lo jo auhkaarna ha
@@naseemajee6937 acha g? Aida toun Mujahid...lol
Ahmadis are best people in Pakistan I know of.
Such a humble and intelligent man
Tell imran khan
اگر یہ ذہین ہوتا تو مرزے کو نبی نہ مانتا بلکہ خنزیر مانتا
@@biku9984
تو مرزے مسرور کو بتا پہلے کہ یہ قادیانی کسی کام کا نہیں مرزے کا پوجاری ہونے کی وجہ سے
Such a brilliant mind. Pakistan need him.
One can feel that deep love for Pakistan in his eyes. Such a humble person. If Imran Khan gets another turn, he should try to educate people, to never listen to religious fanatics when it comes to politics and financial matters of the country.
How many of those fanatics have sold out their personal properties/ cars etc. to settle off Pakistan's debt? It is a challenge, just a single such example would be enough to prove my point wrong.
Any pakistani can be loyal irrespective of hir her religious beliefs.
@@redbaron9029 but any non-fanatic loyal Pakistani is always dumped by fanatics.
Religion is a problem when it interferes with your state matters.
Atif Mian is a Great Asset for Humanity
He seems to be a great economist, We indians should utilize his knowledge if our neighbour doesnt want him.
We really want him....but due to some extremist people he was not added in EAC....but Undercover he is working for Pakistan 😉😉
@@azratasneem7210 dost,
pakistan needs all the economists of the world at the moment.
We also faced such situation of crisis in 1991 and Dr. Manmohan Singh came on the scene as the crisis manager in chief, Later on he went on to become third longest serving PM of india so Pakistan has to learn to utilize, respect and award talents if they really want to be a successful democratic state.
@@azratasneem7210 how do u know that he is working undercover??
@@azratasneem7210 He is definitely proving Pakistani govt get rid of good people.
@@azratasneem7210 And believe me without any financial compensation. Why ? WE AHMADI MUSLIMS LOVE PAKISTAN. Tell that to Mulla Diesal !
I'm sure one day such Great Brains will change our destiny.
by name I think u r kashmiri.....
Not possible bro in our life time
Imran Khan has done a great mistake by removing this man from such a crucial position. His personal beliefs have nothing to do with the state affairs.
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
very right
Right brother
And ironically he removed him based on the pressure from the same religious fundamentalist parties; which are now sitting in opposition and complaining about poor economy and inflation. By his decision to not back Atif Mian Imran Khan pretty early in his term proved that he is not the same man who would stand by his selection against all odds and opposition. I knew right then that Imran Khan left his backbone on a cricket pitch somewhere and finally become a lousy politician.
No political leader has the courage to get him here.He is safe and better outside in a safe society. Can't afford to lose him in this intellectual waste land, driven by religious and sectarian bigots.
For the very first time I have taken a great pleasure listening to someone. And I m so sorry that our ##### religious leaders are curse on our country. No nation or culture or civilization can be destroyed or conquered unless it's morally corrupt and lazy from inside.
Overall it was it was a wonderful interview thnx bbc to bring mian atif.
It brings me shame to no end that we lost atif Mian who should've been our finance minister if Pakistani people weren't bigoted towards ahmadis.
It was premier who took back the charge from Mr Atif .People of Pakistan demands many things but its premier's decesion that should be honoured by all Pakistanis.
@@asifhashmi3051 so if the premiere gives the order to shoot down your entire family. Should that also be honoured? I don't think you fully appreciate how silly your argument comes across.
Now, I get that there was a tremendous pressure on Imran and since he had to make tough economic choices from early on given the state of the economy he inherited, it wouldn't have made sense for him to not take the politically expedient route and to burden himself with more unpopular decisions, especially ones that were easily avoidable and not directly related to the economy itself and had more to do with politics, especially religious politics. Even though it felt like a gut punch, the choice he made regarding atif Mian at the end still exculpates him of the charge of bigotry against ahmadis in my view, given the circumstances he faced at the time.
Advisor*
@@TheBaaz07 The Premier is not mad like the whole khalfite of Qadyanis He is way senseible than absent mind qadyanis
Hashmi sahib you are exactly true that Pakistani leader should rethink for the betterment of country and peoples the time they had and there are loosing will not come back
Such a brilliant person.👍
I respect him due to his abilities, no matter if he is an Ahmadi. Aren’t we seeking help from atheists? I mean Chinese 🇨🇳 ?
Look Atheist call themself non_muslim
But qadiyanis being non_muslims and after being declared non_muslims call themself a muslim. Thats the main issue.. the Islam they represent to the world is based on lies.... come on yar.. go and read the books of mirza qaidiyani malhoon.. and then come in support of atif mian
@@lahoriravian4610 he who bow to the dead bodies are gumrah .. thats what we call them... and as i told you that you better worry about yourself.. end of conversation
Yes we seek help from atheists as they completely deny what we believe instead of trying to modify our belief unethically. It is as same as some local restaurant claims to be a branch of McDonald's unethically.
@@aliasjad381 You making a big mistake by comparing Islam with a brand...Islam is not a brand it is a faith, and to determin who is right or wrong that right has only Allah! So don't try to play god! Learn from the past Isa a.s. was accused by the jewish scholars to have commited blasphemy. But Allah knew that Isa a.s. is a true prophet!
Ali Asjad what is wrong with you? Islam does not give certificates on being Muslim or not, nor is it a franchise company.
God bless Atif mian 🤲💐
Tum par Allah aor us kay Rasool ki lanat ho
Super
Out class teaching but regret
No one want to learn in Pakistan
Because every leader hungry
He is a talented and deserved to be minister or advisor of finance.
We should respect and prefer talent and foresight about economic crisis of Pakistan despite religion extremism.
D
Haan bhai Dollar ke liye to hum Islam beech de..jaise america aur china jinhone muslims ko afghanistan aur xinjiang main maara. Hum dono se bheek maangte hain. DOLLAR is powerful than Allah mian.
Good analysis which should be considered by Pakistan government .
kia ek gustaakhe rasool aqle qul ha dont want it
@@mosin682 abay chutiyay mei khud qadyanio ko muslim nahee samajta par ghazwae badr kay baad jin kafiro ko rasool pak nay hukam diya tha kay 10 musalman bachay parhao aur azaadi hasil karo unho nay hadith ya quran toh parhana nahee tha bacho ko.Kya woh ashiq e rasool thay? MEINAY ATIF MIAN KO KABHI MAZHAB PAR BAAT KARTAY NAHEE DEKHA AUR TUNAY USAY GHUSTAKH BHEE BANA DIYA ( WOH KAFIR HAY).AB RIZVI NAY TOH ECONOMY SAHI KARNI NAHEE HAY INKAY HEE MASHWARAY LENAY PARAY GAY KYU KAY HUMARAY MOLBIO NAY HUMARI AWAAM KO JAHIL RAKHA AUR AAJ HUM QADYANIO SAY MASHWARAY LENAY PAR MAJBOOR HAY
@@mosin682 bewaqoof insaan *jab ek company ka CEO/malik jobs deta hai* apni company mein logon ko toh woh jobs apply karne walon mein *SABSE ZADA QABIL logon ko select karta* hai taake uski company ka na sirf nuqsaan na ho balke aage jaaye aur behtreen kaam kare, *jis company mein sabse zada qaabil log hon aur unki qaabliyat ka behtreen istemaal bhi company kare toh WOHI company sabse aage hoti hai!*
*AUR YAHI EXACTLY CASE HAI EK MULK KA BHI*
@@mosin682 Is zamane mein mulk ki taraqqi ke liye (jaise kisi bhi company ko bhi) brilliant minds behtareen damaghon aur achi policies aur law (including implementation of law) ki zaroorat hoti hai!
@@mosin682 ab agar companies ke CEOs mazhab, firqe, nasal, imaan ke level ya rang roop ya family ya kapre dekh kar jobs dein toh woh companies top per nahi aa saktin aur issi liye western countries waise jo marzi unke kuch politicians doosri qaumon ya Islam ke khilaaf kehte rahein LEKIN woh inhi countries ke behtreen damaaghon ka istemaal karke apni taraqi karte hain.
iske muqaable mein Pakistan ki jahil awaam kehti hai ke kyunke hum falane falane ke mazhab/aqaaid se ikhtalaf rakhte hain unhein kafir maante hain toh unse kaam nahi lena. inteha darje ki jahilana aur bewaqoofana soch hai.
Atif mian great man
Brilliant mind he our Government should get advice from him.
@@M.Shahbaz.Taqi2 Atif Mian
Wish he was born in India 🇮🇳, we would have nourished his talents and he would be a jewel in our country like our beloved Ex president Late APJ Abdul Kalam
He learned under abhijeet benerjee
Badkismat pakistanio ne is zaheen insaan ko dhakay Mar ke bhair Nikal diya jhail Molla ke khauf se
Mashallah great personality Allah Tala in ko Salamat Rakhe
How great... Great speaker .... Yeah he is...
@mark vaz and you are burning in hell
Haha Allah ise jahanum main dale ga.
@@AhsanSaleem99 Khuda ko apka mashwara nhi chahian, Khuda Apki marzi ka mohtaj nhi hai
@@hadiahmed4157 Konsa mashwara diya main ne. Lagta hai zindagi main kabhi quran ko hath nahi lagaya?
Most of my fellow country men saying that Religious Extremists did not let the gentleman in question to serve in Pakistan due to his religious beliefs but None of these people raised or stood against those Extremists ppl.
Majority of Pakistanis either they are belong to upper class, middle class or working class have the same beliefs as Religious Extremists.
We all are Religious Extremists & intolerant people.
We all stand united against qadyani scums who are trying to create a rift in the muslim ummah. We are not religious extremists but we are on one page and are extremely intolerant when it comes to these qadyani scums. Qadyani murdabad
It takes a lot of courage to introspect and admit one's own faults. But that is the only we can collectively become a better person, society, and country.
hammad durrani mein hon Qadri Suni Brelvi deobondi tan tan tanatan labaik labaik ya jahil awam labaik speaker waje speaker confirm janati ha wo confirm lanati ha tue
He was not allowed to be FM NOT because of his faith. It was because he will call out the ills of the country and it starts with the military.
By Bernd Debusmann Jr
BBC News
October, 10, 2022
US immigration: Why Indians are fleeing halfway around the world
The latter group range from Muslims, Christians and "low-caste" Hindus to members of India's LGBT community who fear violence at the hands of extreme *Hindu nationalists*.
Talented Brain Atif Mian proud of You!
Atif mian is the great And Nice person
کاش ہم لوگ اس بندےکی دانش سے فائدہ اٹھاتے
Kya tumhain Nabi Pak Hazrat Mohammad (S.A.W) ki hurmat is fitne se badh kar hai.
@@أنا-أهل-السنة sir ye ahmadiya log b naki pak S.a.w ko mantay hain clear..
And the second thing is that what you people like mullah mindset had done for your nation?
Just spread terrorism? Hah?
یہ بندہ بہت فائدہ دے سکتا تھا لیکن کچھ عناصر اسکو کام کرنے سے روک لیتے ، لیکن پھر بھی عاطف میاں پاکستان کی خدمت بغیر کسی عہدے کے کر سکتا تھا۔
bilkul sahi bat hy jin logon ko saoor hy wohi in logon ko samjh sakty hain. ye bohat faida dy sakta tha pakistan ko
⌨️you kno he Ahmadiyya Muslim
This guy said a very key point here. You got the point right? Use the money you borrowed on project that will generate money which will help to return the borrowed money and will keep generating money. But if you use that money on something that will not generate money and you also dont have other that much permanent resources to pay off your loan you are doomed. This is that simple. So PTI government hired as finance adviser Abdul Hafeez Sheikh the same guy who served in PPP government as a finance minister and obviously country went under more debt then so I dont understand why IK would hire the same person again.
Alaas! we lost such a wonderful economist
Later they will also loose a beautiful country
This person should be the part of Pakistan's economist
Bhai tu idr b??😆
I agree with you
شان دار تجزیہ ، کاش ہمیں عاطف میاں کی خدمات حاصل ہوتیں -
Awesome thanks atif bhai alhumdolilah you are marvellous
May Allah bless you forever 💖
This guy got skills but unfortunately he’s a victim of extremism by his own country
He shares thoughts as mine. Brilliant
edda to newton
Dr atif mian. A nice personality
It is sheer tragedy that such a brilliant brain was not allowed by the extremist religious groups to work in Pakistan. And the only reason was that he is Qadiani. Most most unfortunate. 😐
When mullah has deep penetration in society this happens.
He ia atif mian
@@usmankhaki, yes and if I am not totally out of memory, he was invited to Pakistan by IK as part of economic advisory comittee. But our mullahs and media started protesting that hi was Qadiani and should not be included in it.
@@nzubr wo controversy m ne suni hy.....
Lakin history ajkal research kr raha ho many western historian and Muslim historian ko parh ka yeha idea howa business, development, social reforms m jab politics or religion ajaye wo qoom tabahi ka sabab bbnti hy.
M ajkal Caliph usmania par research kar raha ho tb jang mazhab k name pr hoti hy same ajke Pakistan and India k same halata hy....
M parh raha tha Catholic jo k romi empire k neeche parwan char raha tha full control tha us par.... Or protenst par kafi pressure tha dono Christianity k sects hy.... Unka aqeeda tha k jab tak qustuntunia par hakomat rahe ge tb rk qayamat or zawal nai aye ga room ko....
Us waqt turko ke سلطنت bbe expand hoti ja rahi the...
Us waqat Sultan ke shahi toop banae wala bhe Christian tha jo ziada salary k lalich m Sultan k pass aya tha. Wo pehlay khud gaya tha room k badshah k pass lakin unho ne series nai lia..... Us toop dunia ke sb say bari jang ka پانسہ palt dia..
History ko hame remember rakhna chahye....
Wo economist hy... Hamre country m oor bhe hy is ke ham pala... Jo k arab m kam kar rahe hy..
Sirf baaten ka maqsad history sy hame seekhna or talent ke qadr krni chahiye bila امتیاز.....
sad indeed
Great Man Atif Mian
Yaar Agur aj Atif bhai Imran Khan or Pakistani ki khidmat krte tu humay boht khushi hoti😭
tu dfa ho aur tyra bhai b dfa ho...taaaj dar a ktham a nabouat zinda bad...
@@siddiquemuhammad6042 ووہی ختم نبوت جس میں ایک نبی آنا باقی ہے محمّد نبی کے بعد یعنی اسرائیلی نبی؟
@@siddiquemuhammad6042 اگر نبوت ختم ہوگی ہے تو اسرائیلی نبی کے آسمان سے اترنے کا انتظار کیوں کر رہے ہو
Brilliant. Someone should listen to him.
Now Saudia Arabia have it as their ecomic advisor.
Really????
Yes
mtlb ???
Such brilliant mind..Sad can't serve Pakistan bcz pf fanatics
He is Qadiyani and Qadiyani never in the favour of Pakistan and Islam.
They say something and think somethink else.
@@مرزاقادیانیپرلعنتبےشمار sai kaha agr ya itna e genious hota to ya pahchan leta k mirza qadiyani jhuta tha
@@fbbadsha7177 . Ji bilkul .yeh to duniya ka sab se be waqoof banda hei . Agher yeh genious hota to eik sacha musalman hota .aur sachey musalman ki pehchan yeh hei keh us ko tammam islami kalma jaat ka pata ho ya na ho usko yeh to lazmi pata hona chahiye
TERI BAHAN DII SIRI
O DALLEYYYYYYYYYYYY
O KANJRIANNNN
O BEI GEIRATTTTTTTTT
Ye 4 buniyadi baatein jis ko zubani yaad hon woh pakka musalman aur pakka jannati
@@lahoriravian4610 bilkul ya 4 bunyadi baten zaror yad honi chahiya ta k hr jhutty kazaab ko is kalamaat
sa nawaza ja sky sahi waqat pa .
Agr 18vi sadi waly ya kalmat yad rkhty to ya fitna phelta e na
@@fbbadsha7177 ..mere khayal mein aap me mera poora comment nahi perha hei
Dr abdus salam zindabad
Sir zaffar ullah khan zindabad
Atif mian zindabad
Mujeeb ijaz zindabad 🤲🤲🤲🤲💫❤
Feeling very disappointed to see the genious out of game on this crucial time just because of religious extremism, khan should hire him at any cost...
Atif Mian great personality of Pakistan blessings of Allaha keep you always happy
A lot of positive comments here...
This is the second lecture of this personality l have heard.Being a student of economics I have ernest desire that his such lectures deliverd of and on . Thanks by the host.
Love for all Hearted for none
Brilliant economic expert , he should be given an appointment in Pakistan even though he is a non Muslim.
I agree he is a non muslim but he is a competent man and thats why moula Ali A.S said : Kufar ka nizaam chal sakta hay zulm ka nahee. Aaj woh baat kitnee sach sabit ho rahee hay UK,USA,Norway all are doing well however Pakistan,Egypt,Afghanistan are struggling so badly kyu kay yaha zulm ka nizaam hay
Bilkul
@@israrbaloch1349 . Zabardast
🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕
He is an Ahmadi Muslim..
Can you pls tell the definition of a Muslim according to Quran karim and Hadith???
Very well saying....
what a gem.
I have a lot of respect for Dr Atif Mian. Unfortunately, our country and coward leadership is afraid of religious fanatics and extremists. In fact, our country is in staunch grip of these extremist minds and religious,political and military demagogues.What a shame, we are living in a society so backward and narrow-minded that they judge people not by its qualified abilities but its faith and religion. Indeed, my Islam is not in danger from anyone but these extremist Mullahs.
Agreed. You are absolutely right
Prayer won’t help. Pakistan needs a revolution and it will happen when India shows the way to development and becoming a super power.
V. Good anaylsis and suggestions.
One of informative discussion of Pakistan Economy.
Brilliant suggestions for Pakistan:
1- State capacity: strong and professional leadership and delegation of authority.
2-Environment: Harmony among people for trade and own capacity building in order to attract investments.
3-Education and skills development.
Every government prefers shortcuts like foreign aids to artificially stabilize the economy, and the current government is not doing anything different.
Environment change is a big threat to current fundamentalists who hold the country's policies and receives funds for these activities.
Education and skills are again the big threat to traditional politics and fundamentalists.
Therefore, there seems no chance of real economic growth.
He is very good brain. What ever his belive this is his personal matter. Imran Khan should get advice from him. and he should give advice to prime minister.
thanks favouring a pig
@@mosin682 why r u watching ahmedia?
Go watch some mullah taliban
@@just_a_woman-h9s chaliye aap baar ke raani hon ge aor qadiyanio ke izzat get off n think day of judgment
@@mosin682 , Everyone is answerable in their own grave about their faith. You worry about yours and let others worry about theirs. You dont have to HATE someone in order to go to heaven on the day of judgement.
Allah is giving Qadyanis EVERYTHING. He has given them life, money, children etc.. Are you bigger than Allah to take everything away from them?
@@just_a_woman-h9s Haha Allah will only give them everything in this world but they will burn in hell for sure alongside you.
what a brilliant mind he is .....
bahaut badhiya knowledge diya aap ne
inko koi bada ministry ka haq milna chahiye
mulk ke liye fayada bahaut hoga
Pakistan missed the opportunity to take advantage of this able man just because of religious difference.
To me he is a True Muslim because Ahmadiyyat is the true form of Islam which prophet Muhammad PBUH founded nearly fifteen hundred years ago.
Slam hay Appki AZMAT ko Dr Sahib
It's very unfortunate that a leading economist is not considered by the country because of his religious background. It's time for the country to consider the ahmadiyya community being considered as non Muslim should be reverse. They are as pakistani as the rest of us. Any body should not be excluded because of his gender, color, religion etc. This is what quaide axam has also said.
Mai atif mian ko non Muslim manta hon lekin is bat me koi shak nahi k talented hai ye aur dua krta hno in k liay k ALLAH inko real islam me dakhil kry aur Pakistan k liay khidmat le in se. Aameen
M waqar Wiki .
aap mujhe kuch ikhlaq waale lagte ho .Hum Ahmadi musalman hein leikin aap ka aqeeda musalmanon wala nahi hei .mein sabit ker sakta hoon..
Kahan se shuru krein ?
Quran se sabit kroon ga .with translation... leikin final terjuma aap hi ka mana jae ga .
Theek hei ?
@@lahoriravian4610 quran aur hadees me prophet mohammad ko khatim ul nabiyyeen kaha gya hai. Un k bad kisi aur insan k zilli nabi ya zilli rasool hony k bare me quran ki ik b waziha ayet nahi hai.
@@mwaqarwiki1289 . hum aap ko hadees dikha sakte hein leikin aap kahein ge keh yeh to zaeef hei .hum sirf Quran per focus kerte hein.
1 . Quran ne Hazrat Eisa AS ko nabi aur rasool.bola hei aur nabuyat ko inam kaha hei .aap Eisa AS ka intezar ker rahe ho .ab aap hi bataein keh Eisa AS ko nabi ke taur per maanein ge ya geir nabi .ummati hona nabuyat ke inam se bra inam nahi hei .kyon keh ummati to Nawaz Shareef , zardari , Rana Sanaullah wageira bhi hein.
Agher nabi nahi maana to Quran ki taleem hei jis ne kisi eik nabi ki nabuyat ka inkar kiya , us ne sab nabiyon ka inkar kiya .
Ab aap hi bataein aap ka kone wala aqeeda hei ?
@@lahoriravian4610 pehli baat tw ye hai k hazrat eesa aen gy ya nahi isi baat me ikhtilaaf hai muslims me kuch scholars k nazdeek nahi aen gy. Agar wo aen gy b tw nabi ki hasiyat se nahi blky prophet Mohammad k ummati bn kr aen gy . Aur ragi inaam ki baar tw wo pehly nabi ki hasiyat se aa tw chuky hain inaam already ho chuka hai aur jb phir aen gy tw nabi nahi hno gy wo lekin inaam yafta bando me se tw hno gy hi .
Ap is baat se mirza ghulam ahmed k haq me daleel sabit nahi kr skty ap log tw unko imam mehdi b b manty ho , eesa b manty ho aur kahien jagha wo khud ko Mohammad saww ka hi dosra janan kehty hain . NaAozbillah , aur khud pr wahi nazil hony ka b dawa kia . Ye sab kufar hai. Agar 1400 saal bad ik nabi ne ana hota tw quran naam le kr btata unka . Lekin quran me eesa AS ka zikr milta is bare me lekin kisi aur k any ka zikr ni milta ho ga.mirza ghulam ahmed k apny dawon me b koi same baat nahi hai kahien wo kuch dawa krty hain kahien pr kuch.
@@mwaqarwiki1289 . aap logon ko khud apne aqeede ka pata nahi hei .mazhab mein agher magher nahi hota hei . .
Hazrat Eisa AS agher nabi bn ker nahi aate hein to Quran ki roo se woh Allah aur Allah ke Rasool SAW ki attaat se khud hi bahir ho jaate hein. Quran mein likha hei .
Jo Allah aur Allah ke Rasool SAW ki attaat lerta hein woh un logon mein shamil hein jin per Allah ne inaam kiya yani anbiya , Shuhdaa, suhalehein , aur siddique . . Aur yeh kitne achey rafique hein...
ab Quran ki ias aayat ke hote hue jis mein sab kuch tafseel se likh di gae hei keh jo bhi Allah aur Allah ke Rasool SAW ki sahih attaat kre ga un ko nabuyat bhinmil.sakti hei , unko shahadat ka derja bhi aur suhalehein aur siddique bhi .agher aap in inamon mein se kisi eik ke bhi munkir ho jaate ho to phir aap ke haath se sab kuch chala jata hei .na hi aap shaheed ho ge aur na hi Allah ki nazer mein aap sualahe aur siddique kehlao ge . Jab ueh sab kuch nahi raha to is mazhab ka kiya faida phir .
2 ... jis trah ka aap Quran mein Eisa AS ke baare mein Quran ki ayaton ka terjuma kerte hein is trah se to Hazrat Eisa AS khuda ka beta sabit ho jata hei .
Quran mein Eisa AS ki Allah ne misal di hei sirf .
Mr Imran Khan could invite Dr Manmohan Singh to help plan a economic model for Pakistan. I am sure Dr Singh would pour out all his heart into helping Pakistan
How nice would that be
Sir Singh you should also visit Pakistan
@@riffathussain5059 Okey bro.
@@fahadsayed6104 I would love to visit Pakistan when Allah gives me a chance
@@gurindersingh8109 Sir when ever you visit Pakistan be my guest
Excellent interviewer questions
Dr. Atif who truly understand the structure of Pakistan economy, his services are dire need to revamp the growth model of Pakistan.
I have read almost 40 comments and everybody is supporting Sir Atif.But my question is ,where were all these people when stupid mollas and conservative minds were protesting against this great personality?Why no one took stand for him?
Exactly
Bhai agar Jo enka side leta us gareeb par be Wajib ul qatal ka elan ho chuka hota.
Because "the establishment" was against him. Period.
Excellent program
What a brilliant brain!
Excellent review.👍👍. True, beside other measures focus on increasing the export on priority i.e. manpower, services and value added products.
It is good to suggest.... What to export ???
Export would increase in 5 years. According to IMF it would raise to $36 billion in 2020.
@@mukhtiarghani terrorism, taliban Haqqani Lashkar-e-Taiba Jaish-e-Mohamad
Bhejo India Kashmir Afghanistan iran
& earn dollars
Terror economy
@@mukhtiarghani Imran khan - 30000 40000 armed trained terrorist in Pakistan
Manpower & skills both u have
Yes, that's the point... It's easy to suggest anything but practical are difficult. India has the skills. Pakistan has 30,000 to 40,000 and Pakistan can't export any while India export every one they produce.
Such an humble and intelligent person. I have heard that he studied ahmadiyyat for many years before accepting it.
Great suggestion 👍
i love you atif 😘😘😘
Excellent Analysis !
Great mind
Those who leave negative comments about atif mian and his believes haven't understood the core lesson from history...to prosper in any field you need a Tolerant Society!!! That comes first, before corruption and other things. To bow down before extremists is also a kind of corruption, because you don't want to lose votes/popularity!
@tariQ, so true
Mian atif is really great brilliant and intelligent man...!
It's our badluck that our govt remove this intelligent person from our politics...
Thank you BBC and Atif Mian sb, Please serve the country by giving weekly video suggestions on your tube and BBC, these will help your countrymen and poor people.
Mascha,Allha Allah in ko salamat rakhe.
Ap kn ho
03167569388
Mjse rabta kren
superb Analysis
Nicely summerized paks economic situation and its solutions.
انتہائی دانشور اور قابل بندے سے صرف مذہبی منافرت کی وجہ سے یہ ملک محروم ہو گیا
Our country India should take advantage of such a great personality.
Great Patriot of Pakistan
He is competent but Pakistan has several such competent people... more important is leadership
Uturn and a hypocrite Leadership has never been a good Leadership. We should learn from History.
Lots of love and respect to him. We should focus on the rule of law for sustainable Pakistan.
What a pragmatic and viable approach to our problems. I feel sad that people of such calibre have been rejected by myopic decision makers. USA invited immigrants from worldwide to come and build it to be a super power. As long they were competent they rose up to levels in their respective professions, regardless of their ethnic and religious backgrounds. We need to honour such professionals and rise up from petty religious differences.
His webinar at Princeton University is a gem. Especially real estate and sugarcane farming economy. Learning experience for everyone interested in economy of developing countries.
I totally agree
Impeccable knowledge.
Quaid e Azam cabinet was including Qadyani, Hindu Cristian, and Parsi ministers, that meritocracy also reflects in his 11th September speech, but later on, all Quaids vision was buried along with his historical speech. Now you can only see Mr.Jannah on currency notes....
Pakistanio ko gazwa e hind karna hai chahe uske like halwa e pakistan kyun na ban jaye
Plz share such program that clearly explain pak economic crisis and its solution.
I am sorry sir you can't help us because of our extremist fanatics they have nothing to do with our lovely religion i as proud sunni Muslim ashamed that we can't resist them
Please , dont be so dishearted . Our prays are with Pakistan. We will solve electricity problem.for ever very soon. invented .
Yar we dont have any problem with Atif Mian as finance minister if he accepts that he is non_muslim.. Qadianis[ahmadis] dont accept that they are non_muslim.
@@aquagemsandjewellery9145 . Why are you de gtading the Holy Quran by putting your own words in other's mouth ..
I know you never ever touched Holy Quran .
In Quran it is written..
" THERE IS NO COMPULSION IN RELIGION . You are not above Quran .How dare you people reject what Allah says in his Holy book Quran
@@lahoriravian4610 you better read Mirza Qadiani's books.
@@lahoriravian4610 Qadiani kafir hy
Long live Atif Main.