So many experts, no use. When one colonel will dictate.Cricket, they willcoach. Economy,they will run. And,they are answerable to Noone. Not for wars, failure of economy,cricket. Nothing
Since I have been hearing, reading, and searching about Pakistan's social, economic, and political issues for a long time, and being a student I personally concluded two things: 1. Whenever Pakistan's economy grew, It was due to independence of making, implementing, and regulating policies, that is, the govt, under military dictatorship, has unbridled powers to make policies. 2. Pakistan's economy can grow at a rapid pace provided that we have had political stability and our institutions stop interfering in political affairs. Unless we have the status quo, no matter how efficient policies and debates are made, nothing will change. A country's economic stability is contingent upon its long-term political stability. Correct me if I am wrong, please
Very good discussion ... I am Indian but like economic discussions of Pakistan. In India,Media is always go for TRP or sensational news ... No knowledge based functional discussion. Learn lot from misery of Pakistan and jingoism of India.
@@vidt999 Financial news channels r also fraud. Stock brokers create artificial hype to sell stocks . I used to work at brokerage firm. If u trust Financial news channels the u will always end up loosing. Recent crash is live example of that.
@@vidt999 Godi Media is now BJP com Corporate house media. No investigative journalism left in India. Discussions r dog fighting. Speaking loudly is considered speaking right.
Dr. Abdul Sahib Asalamo o Alakum thanks for present a such a great informative knowledgeable programme with your host scholar Dr. Qaiser Bengli Sahib . Dr. Qasir Bengli Sahib beautifully and in simple way to clear some misconceptions which are very common in our country and peoples believe it as a universal truth. I heartily appriciate your efforts to give knowledge to our Pakistani peoples on facts which are majority of them have misconceptions in their minds misguided by politicians and electronic media and also social media. I personally found a large number of material present in social media are fictitious. I also admire your emotions to wish progress of Pakistan and the prosperity of Pakistani peoples. Wa Salam.
MASHALLAH always worth to watch Dr. Qaiser . . .may ALLAH bless him and may ALLAH gives him lots n lots of opportunities to serve Pakistan in his best capacity.
Thank you so much sir, Stay Blessed Dr. shb. Bangali Sir is truly blessing and an adorable teacher. I have cleared almost all of ambiguities regarding my Country's economy . thank you
Great effort and fruitful debate sir I am also an economics student and also government teacher. Sir l like your channel and I want to do research I can guide me in this regard. Please
First 30 years west Pakistan betrayed the then east Pakistan hence had made some growth. Most of Bangladesh's wealth were used to develop infrastructure of west Pakistan
Yes you are right. The money to convert Pakistan from barren land and peasant fields into cities came from the money West Pakistan stole without any shame from East Pakistan. They built Karachi, Rawalpindi and then Islamabad. The joke was that people can smell Bengal in Pakistan. Now today Pakistan join the USA to invade Afghanistan to steal their wealth but fail and now they are doing the same to the Balochistani people. There's no self respect or shame or love for the Muslim ummah.
@@amberlight5830 Pakistani journalist Hamid Mir say how you all get taught propaganda in Pakistani schools history class. Here is a video from another Pakistani intellect exposing the truth watch the video below: East-Pakistan to Bangladesh: Part 2 by Taimur Rahman. th-cam.com/video/XrENaRVuJmU/w-d-xo.html
Was Mr Qaiser Bengali ever been part/advisor of any gov't? If yes, what was his progress. I saw people deliver excellent lectures but when it comes to delivery most of times they fail to give the any good results.
I have work and met with Bengalis. They are hard working and integrated ppl. Same with Indian, they are also better compare to Pakistani ppl. I noticed, Building country also depends what kind of a civilisation or society and values a nation has. Because their leaders rise to power from such society and values. We never respected our potentials, never respected our selves and only focused on short term goals. Fighting and wasting our energy on unnecessiry wars with our neighbors and even for foreigners. Everybody claims to be true patriot but never performed his duties as citizen nor as leader. As citizens we let the morons ruin the country and as leaders who sold the country. Today we are slaves who has to act upon the will of other. Dr Bengali is absolutely right. The only best solution is Rebel against this system. That's the only choice we have. We will only lose our chains. What else left in pakistan that we have to wait for. It will get worse but will never get better. We have lost thousands of lives in terrorism due to our system's continuesly making mistakes. It was much better we would lose those lives in fighting against this currupt and unfair system. At least we would see some changes. Today we have got still have time.
worth listening but feeling so bad for our country, unfortunately we couldnt make it the state our founders dreamed of. Dr sahb expressed it right that we have to struggle to improvise the situation.
I am an Indian curious to understand why Pakistan is in such dire straits , we can also learn from pakistan's mistakes. Thanks for interviewing Dr Kaiser. But I do see many other Pakistani economists giving similar reasons, is this all in hindsight ? Why did they not come forward earlier to prevent this. Was the pakistani establishment so blind
1. They get excuse to borrow. This is fast money. They make money and run away 2. Govt know, they will be changed after two years ,three years. They come to make money 3. When loans are taken, they are spent so fast,on what? Noone can ask 4. They sell their islam, india hate,location make huge amounts. They make 80 billion in afghan war. They made billions in cpec. They made billions in drugs, in terrorism war
"The culture of borrowing with a mindset never to return is introduced during the early 1980s under military regime." Hence the term "default." To add: "Once the corruption is introduced, the destruction follows." This explains why and how Pakistan army generals destroyed Jinnah's Land of Pure.
professor kaiser Bangali didn't said 1947 - 1970 development of present Pakistan dependent on the income of East Bangal/Pakistan export of Jute and tea. The foreign exchange earned by East Bangal/Pakistan and Spaned to develop Present Pakistan .After 1971 the foreign exchange closed from East Bangal/Pakistan . So Pakistan become poor. Thank our Mukti Bahini and India to make Bangladesh . Pakistan was main creator of Bangladesh and saying bangale small size , black , and fish eater bangale babu.
What a stupid argument with fully of nonsense yand hatred noting to do with truth I have no time to argue on such ignorant minds with no history knowledge. Once I fallen into that kind of argument to a bengali she stopped talking and by knowing how wrong she was so bengali thrives on Indian given lies to justify their treacherous past.
Problem with Pakistan is its enemy is 4 times in Size, 7 times in population, 11 times economy, 25 times in forex reserve. If Pakistan agree to solve kashmir issue by declaring line of actual control , a international boundary only then it can save it self from collapse. Pakkstan can't sustain 5th generstion, hybrid warfare where majority of resources diverted to defense instead of development projects. Kashmir is not issue of Human rights, it is issue of EGo of two countries. India is not in position to negotiate with pakistan which is becoming failed state. No negotiation is better than giving kashmir on plate to pakkstan in peace talks. India will always remain state of war unless pakistan quit away from infinite game of regional dominance or pakistan become too drained to remain a state itself. So Status quo is better option for India than Peace deal with pakistan.
😂😅😂😅LOOK AT YOUR COUNTRY LOOK AT YOUR POVERTY THEN TALK ABOUT PAKISTAN THEN GIVE GAYAN TO ANY COUNTRY,😂😅AND SERIOUSLY I THINK INDIANS THINK THEY ARE LIVE IN JAPAN😂😅
@@manu.ba374 We will take Japan economy till 2030. At that time, Pakistan would definitely take over Chad, Niger burkina faso type countries in Highest poverty rste country.
@@manu.ba374 Pak problem is its Citizens r going below poverty line while Indian citizens above poverty line is increasing. Pakistan also have Issue of water scarcity and food shortage, population explosion, migrant crisis, Dollar going to pakkstan, Drug problem, budget deficit, depreciation of currency, debt trap, sectarian violence, Massive corruption in both civil and military establishment. Country cannot sustain itself if from its total budget less than 20% spend on development , yet in pakistan only 2- 4% total spend on Education and heathcare together.
@@manu.ba374 poverty in Pakistan is always more than India in relative terms. More people r poor in pakistan as of total population than in India. Even In India Lot of freebies r given to poor like 200 to 300 units of electricity, even many states provide 4 marla land for home, free food suger rice whest pulses. Healthcare is totally free for Poor. PM health card give upto 5 lac indian rs or 10 lac pk ruppes treatment for free. Recently my house maid had brain tumor her whole medical expenses was taken care by govt. Can u expect that pak poor getting similar benefits as of Indian poor. This is also reason in India that more people in sensus tell they r poor in India to take govt freebies.
Solution: End all protocols and subsidies. Politicians, ACs, DCs, Judges, IGs, Generals all live on their salaries without protocol in general public. All of them and their families should use only public buses, trains, government schools, hospitals. TA DA No, have meetings on Zoom calls. Orders online and in PDF with timer on. no paperwork. All of them love Pakistan. right? Pakistan need their help, now
Easy to say. But who will snatch power from army? Impossible. They will not give it up voluntarily. So all know the solution but nothing will happen. Generals get loans easily. They celebrate,make money and go settle in UK, Australia as billionnaires. They have luxurious life. Poor cant question. Army is termite eating Pakistan. All people have to get together, protest. Not respect army. Dont send children to army. They will be forced to give up power. All want love of their own people. When people give them gaalis,these billionnaires will not be able to take it. Who will they show off to? Their brandedclothes,handbags. Their peacocks?
One should not close the cantonment but relocate into new provinces . These new provinces will be created alongside by side on the country side to protect seapack from terrorist attacks. These provinces will be based on agriculture with targeted and specialised population
Real estate business killed innovation and new industry in India. There is no incentive for youth in real estate, there is no room for innovation (intellectual investment)with small investment.RealEstate is the game of big money. However, building industry employs a lot of unskilled as well as skilled labour. Migration to big cities is mainly due to the opportunities in building industry.
These new provinces will be free from all liabilities and will be 0:24 revenue generated, business administrated, business oriented and it's territory will be guarded by drones less security personnel and also free from politicians, influenced people. In short beside agriculture it will be a province of artificial intelligence and robotics physical science.
Nothing strange. All money was diverted to fuel terrorism, jihadis infrastructure. That destroyed Pakistan. Whole societies obsession energy was spent on celebrating plane hijacks, Osama, kasab, all energy was spent in planning executing attacks. Celebration of enemies death,destruction for 40 years. Not celebrating own achievements. .Pakistanis find it strange that other countries celebrate their acheivements. They have none. Mumbai attack can't be celebrated on global level as acheivement. They have hence no self respect
The religion should not enter administration, real colapse of pakistan when more religious people started taking higher positions rather than more educated and talent people,
Just like what’s happening in india right now. Religion is given more importance. But luckily the economic liberalization happened in 90s under congress rule. And even before that they set up these big institutes. Now, imagine, if modi had come to power before the 91 economic liberalization. I have no doubt india would’ve been a failed state right now. Imagine instead of focusing on economy in 90s, you would’ve been mired into issues of beef ban, mandir, hijab ban, CAA, demonetization, azaan ban, love jihad.. etc Be thankful that right people were in power at the right time. And stop cursing Nehru and congress in general.
پروفیسر قیصر بنگالی ہمارا قومی اثاثہ ہیں۔ آج کی نشست میں اشرافیہ سے عوامی بغاوت کا سبق شاید ایسے ہی درد دل رکھنے والے پاکستانی مخلص دانشور دے سکتے ہیں ۔۔۔۔ عوامی جمہوری فلاحی پاکستان پائندہ باد
Dr. Bengali also doesn't do proper study. Hosiery industry shifted to India where just one town Tirupur exports top brands for over $5 b and wants to double in 3 years with over 100,000 vacancies even now. India's IIT's, IIM's, IISC etc.were established decades ago and are in every nook and corner of the country serving the nation with no favours to any one. A student who fails to get admission three times in IIT goes to Ivy League in the US. Software in India is now 55 years old and top 4 out of top 10 in the world are Indian and another five do all their work in India. Mercedes and so many top multinationals do all software in India. So it takes decades of meticulous planning and execution to get world class professionals. Bagawat wont get it - army will crush as it runs the nation. Corruption has killed Pakistan. Eternal Enmity with India a much much 11 times larger economy by army won't go away. So sadly it is dooms day for Pakistan.
By proper study you meant he didn’t praise india enough, right? FYI, the discussion is about economic situation of Pakistan, not to praise india. You should compare yourself with China, not Pakistan. Outside you praise all the policies congress brought in, and within your own country you curse them and give all the credit to modi. You should feel lucky that before your economic liberalization, modi didn’t come into power. It would’ve been same as Zia coming into power and destroying Pakistan.
@@9Rehankhan19 He is giving wrong figures and doesn't even bother to check even in Google. India doesn't want to compare with any one be it China or any one else. It is only Pakistan that compares with India like fools. Your own minister says Pakistan Govt. has no money to even buy poison to commit suicide. India can give it free.
Pakistan economically already in Default Because Pakistan take loan not for development but for payment of interest of debt. as a result day by day debt will be increased , inflation will be high , currency will be devalued very fast, foreign investment almost shutdown , foreign reserve will be decreased , government most of budget expenditure will be used in unproductive sector at last majority of the people will be sufferer by the effect of economical crisis and people unable to afford basic needs "basic needs" of not just food, water, clothing and shelter, but also sanitation, education, and healthcare. this all things are already present in Pakistan, So collapse of whole structure of Pakistan is a matter of time ..
seems commited professor bengali and the pide host doesnot look like even economics teacher he seems a religious scholar. sorry but being religious scholar is noble so dont get downgraded.
Bangladesh at 50: From 'basket case' to rising economic star: Before the onset of the coronavirus pandemic, the economy was growing rapidly, recording an annual expansion in the range of 8% for years. The Asian Development Bank said that despite the hit from the pandemic, Even in coronavirus pandemic GDP growth was 4.5 in 2020. the Bangladeshi economy is recovering fast. "Bangladesh also grows enough food now to feed its 165 million people. The country has a significantly reduced maternal and infant mortality rate than many other countries in the world," Bangladesh achieved middle-income country status in 2015 and is on track to leave the United Nations' Least Developed Countries list. Currently, 98% of children nationwide have finished primary school, with more girls in secondary school than boys. Literacy rate rose to 74.9 % in 2021 from 26.8 % in 1974 According to Global Gender Gap report 2021 by the world Economic forum, Having closed 71.9% of its overall gender gap, Bangladesh is the most gender-equal country in South Asia for the seventh time in a raw. world Economic forum say the Muslim-majority nation over the years has invested heavily in the lives of women and girls. It has also made progress in combating child malnutrition and reproductive health. With a GDP of over $409 billion (€362 billion), Bangladesh currently has the world's 37th largest economy and forecasts suggest that the size of the economy could double by 2030 and Bangladesh will be the world's 26th largest economy Bangladesh has became a food sufficient Country ,the country became 4th largest producer of rice 3rd in vegetable and 4th largest producer of fresh water fish in the world . Over 97% of medicine made in Bangladesh , Currently Bangladesh export medicine more than 140 country . The garment industry emerged as one of the nation's success stories in recent decades. It is the second-largest globally, only surpassed by China, and rakes in over $35 billion a year from exports.in 2022 only RMG export crossed over 42 Billion USD The sector employs 4 million people, the majority (80%) of whom are women, contributing to female empowerment. Meanwhile, the Bangladesh government has set an overall target for exports amounting to $51 billion in 2022. Remittances also play a major role in the economy, with Bangladeshi workers employed abroad transferring nearly $24.7 billion in the fiscal year 2021. "Per capita income has increased in Bangladesh. Now it is 2550 USD higher than India .Foreign reserve almost 45 Billion USD The improvement in female education has transformed the socioeconomic structure, Providing scholarships for women's and girls' education is another factor. The women are now more articulate. Net Enrollment in primary school 97.91%. Life expectancy more than 73 years .poverty rate is decreasing less than 10 %. more than 100 million people are using internet regularly. Power sector also made huge milestone of 100% access to Electricity in the golden jubilee year. The country successfully launched its first satellite " Bangabandhu -1 "on may 12, 2018 and became 57th country to have own satellite in space. Bangladesh is not resting but building 100 Economic zone almost 11 Economic zone ready for production and also building 28 hi-Tec park for ICT export .Bangladesh has set a vision to be a developed nation within 2041 . Despite of facing cyclone, flood ,climate change effect and very harsh border with army ruled Myanmar after all this happening in each and every year Bangladesh comeback strongly effectively in every sector of the country.
Men heran hun keh Dr. Sahab jaisay logon ko economy ki ministry se door kiun rakkha Jata hay 🤔🤔??? Aisay logon se 10 saalah economical program banwa kar un per Kam kiun nahi kia jata 😮?? Obviously sirmayadaron aur Gernellon ki lambi lambi dehaariyan bandd ho jayen gi, "is liye"... So as Dr. Sahab said keh awam ko is Nizam k khilaf baghawat Karna ho gi,, aur us se bhi pehlay awam men shaoor paida karnay ki zarurat hay keh aakhir un ka istehsaal karnay walay asal men kon log hen,, aur un se chhutkara paanay ki fikar Karna lazmi hay,, because is k baghair ham apni ayendah naslon ka mustaqbil mehfuz nahi bana saktay.😢😢
I am from Banglades and always wait for Dr Kaiser Bengali sir's video. Every time there is something to learn and he explain in simple way.
Thank you for your feedback.
can you understand urdu?
@@database4074 it's very similar to hindi so it's not hard to understand. There are just a few words which are different
So many experts, no use. When one colonel will dictate.Cricket, they willcoach.
Economy,they will run. And,they are answerable to Noone. Not for wars, failure of economy,cricket. Nothing
I am Indian , but hope from bottom of my heart, Pakistan get proper democracy and a PM some one like Prof. Bangali
Points noted Jasmin Mehta. Thanks for the support from across the border.
@H G Be Positive, We are all living in global world. No one wants destroy anyone.
Are you happy to get a genocidal monster modi?
Nobody can rectify pakistan economy because mullas are indirectly ruling the country.
Since I have been hearing, reading, and searching about Pakistan's social, economic, and political issues for a long time, and being a student I personally concluded two things:
1. Whenever Pakistan's economy grew, It was due to independence of making, implementing, and regulating policies, that is, the govt, under military dictatorship, has unbridled powers to make policies.
2. Pakistan's economy can grow at a rapid pace provided that we have had political stability and our institutions stop interfering in political affairs. Unless we have the status quo, no matter how efficient policies and debates are made, nothing will change. A country's economic stability is contingent upon its long-term political stability.
Correct me if I am wrong, please
Apt. Martial law is suicide ,for economy
Dr. Vengali the great!👌👌👌
Prayers for Bengali Sb.. I wish we had more professors like him.
Thanks to the host for fine coordination and selection for such a nobleguest.
Thank you Subodh Singh. Appreciated.
Kesar Bengali Saab the Great Man Great man Came out from the Pakistani problem very well and so sensible lecture thank you sir
eyes opening info. thanks to sir Kaiser.
Good information
one of the best thing about professor bengali is he portrays a simple economic picture unlike most economic experts using finance related jargons.
Very good discussion ... I am Indian but like economic discussions of Pakistan. In India,Media is always go for TRP or sensational news ... No knowledge based functional discussion. Learn lot from misery of Pakistan and jingoism of India.
Many thanks for your valuable feedback Khushveer Singh, Stay blessed.
Then you are seeing the wrong media bro, start watching financial channels we have tons of those.
@@vidt999 Financial news channels r also fraud. Stock brokers create artificial hype to sell stocks . I used to work at brokerage firm. If u trust Financial news channels the u will always end up loosing.
Recent crash is live example of that.
@@vidt999 Godi Media is now BJP com Corporate house media. No investigative journalism left in India. Discussions r dog fighting. Speaking loudly is considered speaking right.
@@khushveersingh3297 you are really a pessimist man. There are many shows unrelated to stocks, it seems you are unaware of that.
Very good question and answer.
Many thank Muhammad Junaid.
Qaisar bengali sir you are such a great personality ..i have this video for the first time and I am really impressed from you 😌🙂
bengali saib one of great economist Pak. have.
Really, a great economist.
much Knowledgeable Discussion...!
Thannk you Atif Jeelani.
Bht awla sir.. really informative😊😊
Dr. Abdul Sahib Asalamo o Alakum thanks for present a such a great informative knowledgeable programme with your host scholar Dr. Qaiser Bengli Sahib . Dr. Qasir Bengli Sahib beautifully and in simple way to clear some misconceptions which are very common in our country and peoples believe it as a universal truth. I heartily appriciate your efforts to give knowledge to our Pakistani peoples on facts which are majority of them have misconceptions in their minds misguided by politicians and electronic media and also social media. I personally found a large number of material present in social media are fictitious. I also admire your emotions to wish progress of Pakistan and the prosperity of Pakistani peoples. Wa Salam.
What an eye opener analysis by Dr. Kaiser Bengali sahib. Sad moments for Pakistan.
Thank you Abdulqadir Shaikh
Excellent Analysis
Wonderful explanation and analysis, regards to Professor
Thank you S.R Karnik. Keep Supporting us .
MASHALLAH always worth to watch Dr. Qaiser . . .may ALLAH bless him and may ALLAH gives him lots n lots of opportunities to serve Pakistan in his best capacity.
Thank you so much sir, Stay Blessed Dr. shb. Bangali Sir is truly blessing and an adorable teacher. I have cleared almost all of ambiguities regarding my Country's economy . thank you
Jazakallah
Very informative session.. Thank you sir
Very informative, excellent lecture but missing element of external intervention
Pakistan has nice people,experts,it seems they are sidelined. A fake narrative is peddled and psycophants are encouraged
Mashallah great discussion by dr sab
Good interview....good context ....start the grand debate with public interaction instead of one on one interviews....hope sense prevails
brilliant words
Great effort and fruitful debate sir I am also an economics student and also government teacher. Sir l like your channel and I want to do research I can guide me in this regard. Please
Please tell us, how can we help you?
Excellent program
Please do a lot more like this one
Thanks for your feedback, We have a lot more available on our TH-cam Channel & Facebook Page. We will definitely continue this series.
for god sake improve your sound quality use some quality microphones
Loved this podcast.
Very informative discussion sir.
Thank you for your feedback. Keep Supporting us in Educating people.
First 30 years west Pakistan betrayed the then east Pakistan hence had made some growth. Most of Bangladesh's wealth were used to develop infrastructure of west Pakistan
Yes you are right. The money to convert Pakistan from barren land and peasant fields into cities came from the money West Pakistan stole without any shame from East Pakistan. They built Karachi, Rawalpindi and then Islamabad. The joke was that people can smell Bengal in Pakistan.
Now today Pakistan join the USA to invade Afghanistan to steal their wealth but fail and now they are doing the same to the Balochistani people. There's no self respect or shame or love for the Muslim ummah.
@@badrulhussain5545 just shut up when you are biased and have no real facts
Nonsense.
@@amberlight5830 Pakistani journalist Hamid Mir say how you all get taught propaganda in Pakistani schools history class.
Here is a video from another Pakistani intellect exposing the truth watch the video below: East-Pakistan to Bangladesh: Part 2 by Taimur Rahman.
th-cam.com/video/XrENaRVuJmU/w-d-xo.html
Please get your facts right East Pakistan wasn't part of Pakistan for thirty years 1947 to 1971 makes it 24 years .
very interesting discussion.
Thank You Syed Muhammad Waleed
Was Mr Qaiser Bengali ever been part/advisor of any gov't? If yes, what was his progress. I saw people deliver excellent lectures but when it comes to delivery most of times they fail to give the any good results.
What ll be the basic steps we can take to increase productivity??
Please rectify the volume up down issue...its annoying
Noted Haroon Ahmad for compliance. Please check our other podcasts & debates, waiting for your valuable feedback on others as well.
I have work and met with Bengalis. They are hard working and integrated ppl. Same with Indian, they are also better compare to Pakistani ppl.
I noticed, Building country also depends what kind of a civilisation or society and values a nation has. Because their leaders rise to power from such society and values. We never respected our potentials, never respected our selves and only focused on short term goals. Fighting and wasting our energy on unnecessiry wars with our neighbors and even for foreigners.
Everybody claims to be true patriot but never performed his duties as citizen nor as leader. As citizens we let the morons ruin the country and as leaders who sold the country.
Today we are slaves who has to act upon the will of other.
Dr Bengali is absolutely right. The only best solution is Rebel against this system. That's the only choice we have. We will only lose our chains. What else left in pakistan that we have to wait for. It will get worse but will never get better.
We have lost thousands of lives in terrorism due to our system's continuesly making mistakes. It was much better we would lose those lives in fighting against this currupt and unfair system. At least we would see some changes.
Today we have got still have time.
Pakistan did not get independence on 14th. Aug. 1947. It was created or came in to existence on that day.
worth listening but feeling so bad for our country, unfortunately we couldnt make it the state our founders dreamed of. Dr sahb expressed it right that we have to struggle to improvise the situation.
How will you return 80 billion loans? Impossible. Govt is planning to sell nuclear weapons
How will you return 80 billion loans? Impossible. Govt is planning to sell nuclear weapons
this fellow told more stories then economy
Thx
سنتے جائو اور سنتے جائو۔ قابل تقلید تجزیہ کار۔ جزاک اللہ
I am an Indian curious to understand why Pakistan is in such dire straits , we can also learn from pakistan's mistakes. Thanks for interviewing Dr Kaiser. But I do see many other Pakistani economists giving similar reasons, is this all in hindsight ? Why did they not come forward earlier to prevent this. Was the pakistani establishment so blind
It's a fatal disease called Islam
1. They get excuse to borrow. This is fast money. They make money and run away
2. Govt know, they will be changed after two years ,three years. They come to make money
3. When loans are taken, they are spent so fast,on what? Noone can ask
4. They sell their islam, india hate,location make huge amounts. They make 80 billion in afghan war. They made billions in cpec. They made billions in drugs, in terrorism war
"The culture of borrowing with a mindset never to return is introduced during the early 1980s under military regime." Hence the term "default." To add: "Once the corruption is introduced, the destruction follows." This explains why and how Pakistan army generals destroyed Jinnah's Land of Pure.
Great
Unmatable discussion made easy to public by unmatable personality. Shine of Our beloved country. Public badly needs his services.
Thanks alot Ghazala Shaikh. Keep Supporting us.
professor kaiser Bangali didn't said 1947 - 1970 development of present Pakistan dependent on the income of East Bangal/Pakistan export of Jute and tea. The foreign exchange earned by East Bangal/Pakistan and Spaned to develop Present Pakistan .After 1971 the foreign exchange closed from East Bangal/Pakistan . So Pakistan become poor. Thank our Mukti Bahini and India to make Bangladesh . Pakistan was main creator of Bangladesh and saying bangale small size , black , and fish eater bangale babu.
you also forgot the genocide and rapes...it's all karma of pak's evil deeds
Points noted for the next Debate Mr. Md. Sharif Hossain.
What a stupid argument with fully of nonsense yand hatred noting to do with truth I have no time to argue on such ignorant minds with no history knowledge. Once I fallen into that kind of argument to a bengali she stopped talking and by knowing how wrong she was so bengali thrives on Indian given lies to justify their treacherous past.
Please invite him again
Problem with Pakistan is its enemy is 4 times in Size, 7 times in population, 11 times economy, 25 times in forex reserve.
If Pakistan agree to solve kashmir issue by declaring line of actual control , a international boundary only then it can save it self from collapse.
Pakkstan can't sustain 5th generstion, hybrid warfare where majority of resources diverted to defense instead of development projects.
Kashmir is not issue of Human rights, it is issue of EGo of two countries.
India is not in position to negotiate with pakistan which is becoming failed state.
No negotiation is better than giving kashmir on plate to pakkstan in peace talks.
India will always remain state of war unless pakistan quit away from infinite game of regional dominance or pakistan become too drained to remain a state itself.
So Status quo is better option for India than Peace deal with pakistan.
😂😅😂😅LOOK AT YOUR COUNTRY LOOK AT YOUR POVERTY THEN TALK ABOUT PAKISTAN THEN GIVE GAYAN TO ANY COUNTRY,😂😅AND SERIOUSLY I THINK INDIANS THINK THEY ARE LIVE IN JAPAN😂😅
@@manu.ba374 We will take Japan economy till 2030. At that time, Pakistan would definitely take over Chad, Niger burkina faso type countries in Highest poverty rste country.
@@manu.ba374 Pak problem is its Citizens r going below poverty line while Indian citizens above poverty line is increasing.
Pakistan also have Issue of water scarcity and food shortage, population explosion, migrant crisis, Dollar going to pakkstan, Drug problem, budget deficit, depreciation of currency, debt trap, sectarian violence, Massive corruption in both civil and military establishment. Country cannot sustain itself if from its total budget less than 20% spend on development , yet in pakistan only 2- 4% total spend on Education and heathcare together.
@@manu.ba374 poverty in Pakistan is always more than India in relative terms. More people r poor in pakistan as of total population than in India.
Even In India Lot of freebies r given to poor like 200 to 300 units of electricity, even many states provide 4 marla land for home, free food suger rice whest pulses.
Healthcare is totally free for Poor.
PM health card give upto 5 lac indian rs or 10 lac pk ruppes treatment for free. Recently my house maid had brain tumor her whole medical expenses was taken care by govt.
Can u expect that pak poor getting similar benefits as of Indian poor.
This is also reason in India that more people in sensus tell they r poor in India to take govt freebies.
@@mariyakhankhan7826 yesss..ap kahan se?
The solution to Pakistan's plight is in the last few lines of the video.
Solution: End all protocols and subsidies. Politicians, ACs, DCs, Judges, IGs, Generals all live on their salaries without protocol in general public. All of them and their families should use only public buses, trains, government schools, hospitals. TA DA No, have meetings on Zoom calls. Orders online and in PDF with timer on. no paperwork. All of them love Pakistan. right? Pakistan need their help, now
Easy to say. But who will snatch power from army? Impossible. They will not give it up voluntarily. So all know the solution but nothing will happen. Generals get loans easily. They celebrate,make money and go settle in UK, Australia as billionnaires. They have luxurious life. Poor cant question. Army is termite eating Pakistan. All people have to get together, protest. Not respect army. Dont send children to army. They
will be forced to give up power. All want love of their own people. When people give them gaalis,these billionnaires will not be able to take it. Who will they show off to? Their brandedclothes,handbags. Their peacocks?
could you please use a complete map of pakistan
One should not close the cantonment but relocate into new provinces . These new provinces will be created alongside by side on the country side to protect seapack from terrorist attacks. These provinces will be based on agriculture with targeted and specialised population
Real estate business killed innovation and new industry in India. There is no incentive for youth in real estate, there is no room for innovation (intellectual investment)with small investment.RealEstate is the game of big money.
However, building industry employs a lot of unskilled as well as skilled labour. Migration to big cities is mainly due to the opportunities in building industry.
So basically the major problem is the foji generals
These new provinces will be free from all liabilities and will be 0:24 revenue generated, business administrated, business oriented and it's territory will be guarded by drones less security personnel and also free from politicians, influenced people. In short beside agriculture it will be a province of artificial intelligence and robotics physical science.
India has nobel lauretes in economy. Two nobel prizes
steel mills were to provide subsidized steel for engineering industry I am shocked
Nothing strange. All money was diverted to fuel terrorism, jihadis infrastructure. That destroyed Pakistan. Whole societies obsession energy was spent on celebrating plane hijacks, Osama, kasab, all energy was spent in planning executing attacks. Celebration of enemies death,destruction for 40 years. Not celebrating own achievements. .Pakistanis find it strange that other countries celebrate their acheivements. They have none. Mumbai attack can't be celebrated on global level as acheivement. They have hence no self respect
The religion should not enter administration, real colapse of pakistan when more religious people started taking higher positions rather than more educated and talent people,
same goes for India
@@mayan5600 wat about China? Communism is a religion
It is you guys who think that Pakistan is like madrassa. You have wrong information.
Just like what’s happening in india right now. Religion is given more importance. But luckily the economic liberalization happened in 90s under congress rule. And even before that they set up these big institutes. Now, imagine, if modi had come to power before the 91 economic liberalization. I have no doubt india would’ve been a failed state right now. Imagine instead of focusing on economy in 90s, you would’ve been mired into issues of beef ban, mandir, hijab ban, CAA, demonetization, azaan ban, love jihad.. etc
Be thankful that right people were in power at the right time. And stop cursing Nehru and congress in general.
🇵🇰
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
پروفیسر قیصر بنگالی ہمارا قومی اثاثہ ہیں۔ آج کی نشست میں اشرافیہ سے عوامی بغاوت کا سبق شاید ایسے ہی درد دل رکھنے والے پاکستانی مخلص دانشور دے سکتے ہیں ۔۔۔۔
عوامی جمہوری فلاحی پاکستان پائندہ باد
Dr. Bengali also doesn't do proper study. Hosiery industry shifted to India where just one town Tirupur exports top brands for over $5 b and wants to double in 3 years with over 100,000 vacancies even now. India's IIT's, IIM's, IISC etc.were established decades ago and are in every nook and corner of the country serving the nation with no favours to any one. A student who fails to get admission three times in IIT goes to Ivy League in the US. Software in India is now 55 years old and top 4 out of top 10 in the world are Indian and another five do all their work in India. Mercedes and so many top multinationals do all software in India. So it takes decades of meticulous planning and execution to get world class professionals. Bagawat wont get it - army will crush as it runs the nation. Corruption has killed Pakistan. Eternal Enmity with India a much much 11 times larger economy by army won't go away. So sadly it is dooms day for Pakistan.
By proper study you meant he didn’t praise india enough, right? FYI, the discussion is about economic situation of Pakistan, not to praise india.
You should compare yourself with China, not Pakistan.
Outside you praise all the policies congress brought in, and within your own country you curse them and give all the credit to modi. You should feel lucky that before your economic liberalization, modi didn’t come into power. It would’ve been same as Zia coming into power and destroying Pakistan.
@@9Rehankhan19 He is giving wrong figures and doesn't even bother to check even in Google. India doesn't want to compare with any one be it China or any one else. It is only Pakistan that compares with India like fools. Your own minister says Pakistan Govt. has no money to even buy poison to commit suicide. India can give it free.
Ya sab lotna pa laga ha
Models bano assumptions bano or papers published Karo or output is zero
Pakistan economically already in Default Because Pakistan take loan not for development but for payment of interest of debt. as a result day by day debt will be increased , inflation will be high , currency will be devalued very fast, foreign investment almost shutdown , foreign reserve will be decreased , government most of budget expenditure will be used in unproductive sector at last majority of the people will be sufferer by the effect of economical crisis and people unable to afford basic needs "basic needs" of not just food, water, clothing and shelter, but also sanitation, education, and healthcare. this all things are already present in Pakistan, So collapse of whole structure of Pakistan is a matter of time ..
When generals run economy,
this happens . Its not possible to remove army from the helm. So no hope for Pakistan
جناب 1977 کی سیکیورٹی اسٹیٹ کا ایک مظہر تو اپ کی داڑھی بھی ہے ۔
Tmry alfaz k samny dunia ke galeez tareen gandgi b pak nzar ati h ...
Tortured and killed Bangladeshiyo ke haay lag gayi pakistan ko... Maafi maang lo unse
kaiser bengalis is so biased against musharraf, i totally disagree with him on his take on the GDP growth and state of economy during musharraf's era.
seems commited professor bengali and the pide host doesnot look like even economics teacher he seems a religious scholar. sorry but being religious scholar is noble so dont get downgraded.
Sorry state of affairs!
No hope for the peeps at all..There is a global collat shortage..
عجیب تجزیہ ہے۔ معیشت کو سیاسی نظام سے الگ فرما رہے ہیں۔
Aur phir 80's ke baad hum PDM jesay ghobdo mai phansay
Bangladesh at 50: From 'basket case' to rising economic star:
Before the onset of the coronavirus pandemic, the economy was growing rapidly, recording an annual expansion in the range of 8% for years.
The Asian Development Bank said that despite the hit from the pandemic, Even in coronavirus pandemic GDP growth was 4.5 in 2020. the Bangladeshi economy is recovering fast.
"Bangladesh also grows enough food now to feed its 165 million people. The country has a significantly reduced maternal and infant mortality rate than many other countries in the world,"
Bangladesh achieved middle-income country status in 2015 and is on track to leave the United Nations' Least Developed Countries list.
Currently, 98% of children nationwide have finished primary school, with more girls in secondary school than boys.
Literacy rate rose to 74.9 % in 2021 from 26.8 % in 1974
According to Global Gender Gap report 2021 by the world Economic forum, Having closed 71.9% of its overall gender gap, Bangladesh is the most gender-equal country in South Asia for the seventh time in a raw.
world Economic forum say the Muslim-majority nation over the years has invested heavily in the lives of women and girls. It has also made progress in combating child malnutrition and reproductive health.
With a GDP of over $409 billion (€362 billion), Bangladesh currently has the world's 37th largest economy and forecasts suggest that the size of the economy could double by 2030 and Bangladesh will be the world's 26th largest economy
Bangladesh has became a food sufficient Country ,the country became 4th largest producer of rice 3rd in vegetable and 4th largest producer of fresh water fish in the world .
Over 97% of medicine made in Bangladesh , Currently Bangladesh export medicine more than 140 country .
The garment industry emerged as one of the nation's success stories in recent decades. It is the second-largest globally, only surpassed by China, and rakes in over $35 billion a year from exports.in 2022 only RMG export crossed over 42 Billion USD
The sector employs 4 million people, the majority (80%) of whom are women, contributing to female empowerment.
Meanwhile, the Bangladesh government has set an overall target for exports amounting to $51 billion in 2022.
Remittances also play a major role in the economy, with Bangladeshi workers employed abroad transferring nearly $24.7 billion in the fiscal year 2021.
"Per capita income has increased in Bangladesh. Now it is 2550 USD higher than India .Foreign reserve almost 45 Billion USD
The improvement in female education has transformed the socioeconomic structure,
Providing scholarships for women's and girls' education is another factor. The women are now more articulate.
Net Enrollment in primary school 97.91%. Life expectancy more than 73 years .poverty rate is decreasing less than 10 %. more than 100 million people are using internet regularly.
Power sector also made huge milestone of 100% access to Electricity in the golden jubilee year.
The country successfully launched its first satellite " Bangabandhu -1 "on may 12, 2018 and became 57th country to have own satellite in space.
Bangladesh is not resting but building 100 Economic zone almost 11 Economic zone ready for production and also building 28 hi-Tec park for ICT export .Bangladesh has set a vision to be a developed nation within 2041 . Despite of facing cyclone, flood ,climate change effect and very harsh border with army ruled Myanmar after all this happening in each and every year Bangladesh comeback strongly effectively in every sector of the country.
Men heran hun keh Dr. Sahab jaisay logon ko economy ki ministry se door kiun rakkha Jata hay 🤔🤔??? Aisay logon se 10 saalah economical program banwa kar un per Kam kiun nahi kia jata 😮?? Obviously sirmayadaron aur Gernellon ki lambi lambi dehaariyan bandd ho jayen gi, "is liye"... So as Dr. Sahab said keh awam ko is Nizam k khilaf baghawat Karna ho gi,, aur us se bhi pehlay awam men shaoor paida karnay ki zarurat hay keh aakhir un ka istehsaal karnay walay asal men kon log hen,, aur un se chhutkara paanay ki fikar Karna lazmi hay,, because is k baghair ham apni ayendah naslon ka mustaqbil mehfuz nahi bana saktay.😢😢
So basically the major problem is the foji generals