Brilliant. Dismissing this man will go down as one of the biggest mistakes Khan's government made. Pakistan is worse off without this man at the helm of its economic policy.
@@skullduggerygillen This could be th biggest mistake, because Pakistani youth is not inspired by economists like him, then it would hard to produce any world class economists in the future.
@@ather1276 - Pakistani youth unfortunately is inspired by the likes of Maulanas , Maulana Ye Maulana Wo. , there are plenty of them around in Pakistan.
Three problems of Pakistan that need to be tackled before any economic (or political) reforms can happen: 1) Mullahgardi; 2) Foujgardi; 3) No Rule of Law
This was wonderful. Thanks Prof. Atif Mian. Now I understand the background of why Pakistan has to frequently go to IMF for a bailout. I wish Pakistan will heed his advice and head to a prosperous future.
Atif Mian is brilliant at simplifying a complex problem. I found Dr Munis Farooqi's first 14 minutes difficult to stay focussed on (sorry). Consider starting to listen from 14 minutes when Dr Mian comes on. The transcript is invaluable for this important talk. Thank you for posting it on TH-cam.
As an Ahmadi, my parents left Pakistan After 1974 because of persecution. Here in Germany My brothers and sisters became doctors in different fields and commissionars...we will serve now Germany with loyality...Atif Mian should do same...our grand children may be will come back to Pakistan if there will be better time
@@ahmedraza9672 Ooy KHOTE DE PUTT tell me something. You are going to tell IMF the agency Pakistan is begging for money , THEY SHOULD CHECK THEIR BELIEVES ? KHOTE DE PUTT ?
You left Pakistan as economic asylum seekers and told fabricated lies about persecution in Pakistan to to get immigration to settle in Germany & other countries. You Ahmadi’s are the biggest Liars You could have gone to India,Afghanistan or any neighbouring country. Your pure goal Wes economic reasons
Thank you Prof. Atif Mian. Pakistan had an opportunity of having you to set it's economic right during beginning of Imran Khan's regime but Pakistan lost you just because the coward Imran khan could stand against the insane pressure from some non entities . He not only lacked all the 5 Cs of good economic governance identities by you in this brilliant lecture but also any plan or even a will to fix the economy. For a first Pakistan was really on the brink of bankruptcy had he continued in office even for a month more beyond May 22. You just gave the exactly right economic course ,the tax on land being the key. On the contrary Imran khan not only gave amnesty to the investment in real estate sector from any question being asked about the source of investment but also gave this most unproductive sector tax immunity. As a result the real estate sector became the safest haven for black money and rent seeking. His regime was unparalleled in external borrowing and misgovernance of every sector of economy and rule of law. Please sometimes let Pakistan benefit from your critique of the economic management by the current federal govt in pakistan.
I am pakistani but I hate my kachra ghatiya bekaar bakwas chuttiya harami country wese hamary kutte dalle benchod log indians ko galiyan dete khud in ki un se bhi ziyada kafaro wali adadatein hai i am feel shame to be a Pakistani kash allah g tu is ghatiya napaak kafar mulk Pakistan ko tabah kr de is chuttiya harami gandu mulk ka is dunia mein koi o o nishan na rahe ameen sum ameen
unfortunately the religious bigots have taken the center stage in pakistan. it is very sad that an economist like Atif is unable to serve in his own country.
As a successful Indian if I may give you a valuable advice, honestly build a strong and positive friendly relation with India. It will help building Pakistani reputation in the region for investors. If America, Russia or even China can understand the importance of India how could Pakistan be so fool?
Well you think India will do friendship with Pakistan? I think India wants to keep one enemy to feel that they have someone to fight with. I think they feel that they are more organized, educated and much settled and they don’t want Pakistan’s friendship.
Horrible sound! It seems the incompetence the good doctor talked about has crept into Berkeley from Pakistan! Kindly print up a transcript or summary of what he has said and circulate. Thanks.
I am agree with the comments made by kamil kashif don't waste your energy on pakistan. waite sometime until .............................................
How can an ideological state survive? Fundamentals. Hard choice is change of constitution that is not ideological. Forget myopia as ideological state this is partial blindness no option but accept things will not change or get expert help to change of profession or break up the state like former Yugosalvia. Sorry sometimes terminal illness do not have cure. Ignorance and denial
total BS. Tell mr Atif that, Pk is not interested in welfare of its people nor any increase in domestic capacity of its people and nation. Their only interest is to increase their domestic capacity of jihad and build more capacity madrasas. The whole idea of Pk was built on this paradise. He himself was kicked out of govt. and still in a dream land. Tell him to conduct a free and fair elections in his own country and have a true democracy. Make that institution workable before talking all this S***.
Brilliant. Dismissing this man will go down as one of the biggest mistakes Khan's government made. Pakistan is worse off without this man at the helm of its economic policy.
Common. Don't be that childish now.
Atif mian is great on what he does but common, its too much what you are saying
@@skullduggerygillen This could be th biggest mistake, because Pakistani youth is not inspired by economists like him, then it would hard to produce any world class economists in the future.
@@ather1276 - Pakistani youth unfortunately is inspired by the likes of Maulanas , Maulana Ye Maulana Wo. , there are plenty of them around in Pakistan.
Three problems of Pakistan that need to be tackled before any economic (or political) reforms can happen: 1) Mullahgardi; 2) Foujgardi; 3) No Rule of Law
retarded comment
@@PH0T0N not really
True.
well said!
Yes we have tackle Pakistan problem on 27 February 2019
This was wonderful. Thanks Prof. Atif Mian. Now I understand the background of why Pakistan has to frequently go to IMF for a bailout. I wish Pakistan will heed his advice and head to a prosperous future.
Thanks Atif mian for great effort for Pakistan
Atif Mian is brilliant at simplifying a complex problem. I found Dr Munis Farooqi's first 14 minutes difficult to stay focussed on (sorry). Consider starting to listen from 14 minutes when Dr Mian comes on. The transcript is invaluable for this important talk. Thank you for posting it on TH-cam.
As an Ahmadi, my parents left Pakistan After 1974 because of persecution. Here in Germany My brothers and sisters became doctors in different fields and commissionars...we will serve now Germany with loyality...Atif Mian should do same...our grand children may be will come back to Pakistan if there will be better time
You should question your believes than Pakistan.
@@ahmedraza9672 it is just like you a jahil Mulla who is ever ready to declare people KAFIR !
@@ahmedraza9672 Ooy KHOTE DE PUTT tell me something. You are going to tell IMF the agency Pakistan is begging for money , THEY SHOULD CHECK THEIR BELIEVES ? KHOTE DE PUTT ?
@@ahmedraza9672 so should you! is everything you believe in perfect?
You left Pakistan as economic asylum seekers and told fabricated lies
about persecution in Pakistan to to get immigration to settle in Germany & other countries.
You Ahmadi’s are the biggest Liars
You could have gone to
India,Afghanistan or any neighbouring country.
Your pure goal Wes economic reasons
Thank you Prof. Atif Mian. Pakistan had an opportunity of having you to set it's economic right during beginning of Imran Khan's regime but Pakistan lost you just because the coward Imran khan could stand against the insane pressure from some non entities . He not only lacked all the 5 Cs of good economic governance identities by you in this brilliant lecture but also any plan or even a will to fix the economy. For a first Pakistan was really on the brink of bankruptcy had he continued in office even for a month more beyond May 22. You just gave the exactly right economic course ,the tax on land being the key. On the contrary Imran khan not only gave amnesty to the investment in real estate sector from any question being asked about the source of investment but also gave this most unproductive sector tax immunity. As a result the real estate sector became the safest haven for black money and rent seeking. His regime was unparalleled in external borrowing and misgovernance of every sector of economy and rule of law. Please sometimes let Pakistan benefit from your critique of the economic management by the current federal govt in pakistan.
I am pakistani but I hate my kachra ghatiya bekaar bakwas chuttiya harami country wese hamary kutte dalle benchod log indians ko galiyan dete khud in ki un se bhi ziyada kafaro wali adadatein hai i am feel shame to be a Pakistani kash allah g tu is ghatiya napaak kafar mulk Pakistan ko tabah kr de is chuttiya harami gandu mulk ka is dunia mein koi o o nishan na rahe ameen sum ameen
Very very informative. Thanks you.
unfortunately the religious bigots have taken the center stage in pakistan. it is very sad that an economist like Atif is unable to serve in his own country.
Exactly
Our establishment which control government is secular no economist can work
I guess BJP are very egalitarian non-religious party ruling india?
Imrove audio quality 😏😏
✅
Thank you atif bhai.
WE,VE ALREADY ENOUGH INCOME COMING, AND WELL DEVELOPED ECONOMY OF PAKISTAN DURING LAST 4 YEARS OF PTI.INSHALLAH.
As a successful Indian if I may give you a valuable advice, honestly build a strong and positive friendly relation with India. It will help building Pakistani reputation in the region for investors. If America, Russia or even China can understand the importance of India how could Pakistan be so fool?
Well you think India will do friendship with Pakistan? I think India wants to keep one enemy to feel that they have someone to fight with.
I think they feel that they are more organized, educated and much settled and they don’t want Pakistan’s friendship.
عاطف میاں 🐅 ہے چیتا۔۔۔۔۔زندہ باد۔
shukar hai k Atif mian is not finance minister of Pakistan, warna he would have been blamed for Pakistans bad economy.
Those who would have blamed him are blaming the PTI Govt despite the previous Govt being largely responsible
@@UmerMohammed no. actually God is to blame. He has been since ever.
Horrible sound! It seems the incompetence the good doctor talked about has crept into Berkeley from Pakistan! Kindly print up a transcript or summary of what he has said and circulate. Thanks.
I am agree with the comments made by kamil kashif don't waste your energy on pakistan. waite sometime until .............................................
Giving up due to sound quality
Jazakullah pakistani moulvi jaloos nikal dy gy .
It’s 2020, why would you find it acceptable to post this video with such crappy audio. Why? Please do better.
Sound is horrible. U r talking about very crucial economic and financial problems of Pakistan,pls invest urself on decent sound system first.
Atif bhai don't waste your energy on this country anymore. You should work for someone who values your worth.
Shut up yaar. Ek tou ajeeb log. Fix hona zaroor hai
@@nabeel7597 LPC.
@@kamilkashaf2766 haan ab yahi reh jata hai. Gaaliyan dedo. Mein tou roast ho gya yaar.
@@nabeel7597 Qadyanio ko galiyan k ilawa kuch ni ata
@@touseefashraf1 kese pata ye qadiani hai?.
Need subtitles 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
TOTTALY NONSENSE PEOPLE, AND NOT TRUSTWORTHY PEOPLE.
poor audio
Isas .improve the voice system .for God sake
How can an ideological state survive? Fundamentals. Hard choice is change of constitution that is not ideological. Forget myopia as ideological state this is partial blindness no option but accept things will not change or get expert help to change of profession or break up the state like former Yugosalvia. Sorry sometimes terminal illness do not have cure. Ignorance and denial
I am not sure If he said anything new or talked about a magic bullet that could fix Pakistan's economy.
total BS. Tell mr Atif that, Pk is not interested in welfare of its people nor any increase in domestic capacity of its people and nation. Their only interest is to increase their domestic capacity of jihad and build more capacity madrasas. The whole idea of Pk was built on this paradise. He himself was kicked out of govt. and still in a dream land.
Tell him to conduct a free and fair elections in his own country and have a true democracy. Make that institution workable before talking all this S***.
Hey, Last Mile don't have the balls to be a bigot in public ,using pseudonym
Never trust Mia endeing
A Qadyani Non Muslim Economist
Chutiyay economist hai, tera behnoi nae hai jo tujhay iss bat ki itni fikar hai.
@@kamilkashaf2766 jiske hath me bahan ka rista nahi de sakta uske hath me country kaise de dega 😀😀😂😂 sahi soch hai uski😂😂
@@kamilkashaf2766 Lanat ho Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadyani pr us k aulad py aur us k parkaro py.
@@touseefashraf1 Mai Qadyani to nahi hun, magar tu Israr Ahmad ka khabba tatta zarur hai.
@@touseefashraf1 same to you