Three former Supreme Court judges and Kapil Sibal in conversation about Supreme Court and more
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- #livelaw #kapilsibal #cji #cases #supremecourt #supremecourtofindia #formerjudge #justice #law #legal #legalupdates #legalawareness
LiveLaw brings you the latest legal news and updates from India and beyond.
We are into fact based legal journalism.
Endeavour of LiveLaw is to play an active role for a transparent and democratic legal ecosystem, in the larger public interest.
This video is an intellectual property belonging to LiveLaw Media Pvt Ltd. Any unauthorised usage of this video/script in any format is prohibited and will be subject to prosecution.
Stay updated. Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/2pskgB3
Support Us: bit.ly/35qFj6A
Visit Our Website: www.livelaw.in/
hindi.livelaw.in
Facebook: / livelawindia
/ livelawhindi
Twitter: / livelawindia
/ livelawh
Instagram: / livelaw.in
/ livelawhindi
Linkedin: / livelaw
/ livelaw-hindi
Live Law app is India's fastest legal news app that will keep you updated on the latest law/legal news from India and across the world. Download now.
Android: bit.ly/2toaimp
iOS: apple.co/39dQ0vh
![[🔴LIVE] งานประกาศรางวัล MAYA TV AWARDS 2024 : มายามหาชน](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nwmWYXXVwBY/mqdefault.jpg)
![[TH] FS vs BME - VCT Ascension Pacific - Lower Bracket Final](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wnygqsR2Fig/mqdefault.jpg)
Excellent conversation indeed , Mr Kapil Sibal , senior Supreme Court advocate ! Kindly carry it on . The citizens of this country will get an opportunity to know how the esteemed judges of our constitutional courts , High courts and supreme courts think about the multiple problems and issues of the people and how serious and committed they are in their efforts of giving justice to them against all odds.
Really enlightening perspective from the former forbearers of the institution of Justice. Great issue taken in hand. 🙏🙏
Please keep doing such sessions sir…I have recently joined Supreme Court Bar & such session are of great value to us. What I was more disappointed by just keep looking at clock that “oh, now only 5 minute session is left”…. I wish to watch such for whole day
Bhai Sambhal Ke ......Itna pyaar mat de warna aise videos ko Paid ke peeche rakh denge
Bhai Sambhal Ke ......Itna pyaar mat de warna aise videos ko Paid ke peeche rakh denge
Sir, I am just a layman, however your conversation speaks a lot and you all care for correct & transparency judiciary. All the best, wish to hear more alongwith implementation of right things. Thank you Adv. Kapil Sibal Sir.
Wonderful conversation highlighting the current state of affairs in Supreme court. Thank you Mr. Sibbal
Such an enlightening conversation Sibal sir ! Kudos !
Thanks Mr. Kapil Sibbal for starting this discussion in public domain.
Really great opportunity given to us people AND citizens and of course as said by one of the participants judge nobody brother after retirement. Let's take the benefits of such a wonderful and great experience of the judges. Great show. We like again to see more supreme court judges. Thanks LIVE LAW.
Thank you Mr Sibal. Please continue to highlight the plight of our judicial system.
Such an informative & lucrative debate is necessary in order to save the judiciary & solemn institution. As the point raised by Mr. Sibbal regarding the the brother judges who always maintain angelic silence. If brother judge feels to disagree he must do the so .
Sare reforms judges ko retirement ke baad dhyan me ate hai , judge rehte Hue kabhi bhi koi Kutch nai karta
Absolutely 💯 right observation.
Veey great judges with sibbal sahab on the most important issue of differnce of opinions of judges in passing a public issue but solution is only the constitution, s mandate even vide mandate of article 375 of the constitution ,, basically if supreme court judges will deviate from mandate of preamble and mandate of article 21 ,, 14,, 19 ,,, and press into judgement their own views ,, there would be anamolies ,, it is not that a person with experience of years as judge is fit to become a judge of a superior court ,, having taken oath in the name of constitution does not change the orginal charector
Admiring attitude of these Gentlemen makes me to feel that we were privileged. Really a great attempt by Kapil bring them to a public platform atleast their interaction definitely will help us how the prestigious top court was functioning/ to function
Very insightful especially for a civilian like myself.
Do hope Kapil gets a good sound engineer for these recordings. Not very audible unlike the rest.
Thumbs-up to the panelist.Reflects they are deeply worried about the Judicial process.Great initiative, at least Hon'ble CJI's must watch and prevail course of correction. Judiciary democracy at cat on the wall.
It is very good for the people of India. Such discussions need to be held more frequently
Very engaging discussions. 👍🏼👍🏼
Every knowledgeable person listening this wonderful conversation ❤ I am wetting next episodes
Pl share more videos like this .....very interesting.
Very good initiative Mr Sibbal sir, It is the need of the hour
Wonderful conversation. Such initiatives will definitely help and make Judiciary stronger.
I wish I can go back and go to a law school. I hope it is not too late to take up law.
Aptly covered the most burning issues in the legal fraternity about the rotting in the judiciary because of some judges . The public is well aware much in advance as to what will be the outcome of the case on the basis of appearing contesting parties
Very good initiative
If possible, Please ask Sr. Adv. Dusyant Dave to join. Would love to hear his views too.
I will understand, as he's still not retired, if it doesn't happen.
Thank you for enlightening us about the law judges
In my opinion, difference in looking is grown up in sc judges due to the cause of avoiding art 13 of IC, which is too much unfortunate situation for the citizens of india. How to overcome needs to be looked into.
❤❤❤ EXCELLENT
INDEED---- LEARNED
WHOLE CONVERSATION WAS RELEVANT
WISH YOU ALL EVERY HAPPINESS!🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺
With Regards
Osama Aziz (Petitioner-in-person)
Great discussion…
congratulation Sir for organising excellent conversation ! Hope our judiciary function can be improve and citizen right matter will be address sou motu at earliest as suggested by the Ex Judges !
This is what Nation wants to hear spilling beans… I appreciate the initiative that’s being taken up by Mr Great Sibal 🫡
Good idea to start this Live interviews. Keep it coming Sir.
Thank you sibal sir for such a wonderful session
Mr. Sibbal, kudos for bringing the discussion by the expert judiciary to the common man. Great discussion at the intellectual and professional level. Please try to make your discussions more palatable for the common man.
Very interesting points are on the table.
The services of the retired supreme court judges should be utilized in capacities that will help to maintain the ethical and moral standards of the judiciary.
Credit goes to Sibal advocate to raise issues concerning justice in courts. Why judges wants to leave it to executives or government which would scuttle down to courts to follow in their dictates. It is high time to improve judiciary and its administration so that people start believing in courts rather than netas
Well done
Trying to fight the evil. I congratulate you. May God give you the strength and the direction to win.
very good initiative and great conversation
Such informal discussion helps judicial system and common man to understand the problem with the administration of justice.
Well timed beginning for this intellectual analysis 👍
Excellent conversation between the eminent jurists
Nice job
Excellent discussion. 🙏🙏
Justice Madan Lokur , Justice Ananga Patnaik, & Justice Deepak Gupta were the guests today.....read about them
The room acoustics needs correction. The echo level is high.
Superb conversation 🙏
Wisdom has dawned after 75 years… what a way to go.
Great lawyer,great spokesman, great MP
sir fix the auido
Awesome 👍
Great initiative
Insightful talk
Is court fixer charge true? Are Judges also biased? Is there any mechanism to identify such incidents and take appropriate action to improve the Judicial system.
Brilliant initiative!
Excellent
This is ideal discussion in ideal situation as how to administrativey make Courts workable. The Men's Rea of judges come into picture. Sam ,Dam, dand, bhed policy of Executive play its destructive role to disturb the ideal state of affairs. Human beings are amenable everywhere now a days. Reverred Harishchanderas n Vikramadityas are not available now. Now people follow the culture n saying of Yudhishtra n Krishana "Ashavthama mara gya" just to win the war n to kill the opponent. Nostalgic.
quality of this conversation 💫
Respected sir please this program in hindi more people can not understand the English thank you very much
In 🇮🇳 INDIA Country Holy Heavenly 🙏Father We 🇮🇳 Pray 🙌 for OUR Chief Justice of Supreme Court to give all Diven Wisdoms from above to 🇮🇳 SAVE Democracy of HUMANS Freedoms Rights 👑⛑👒🎩OFF for 🇮🇳✌for great 👍Discussions tanky 👍Sirs
This is the problem of common law. We need to train our lawyers with the principle based legal system rather than precedent based legal system.
Good initiative!
Justice- Michael Sandel
They must put a limit on the number of adjournments by the lawyers and the judges.
Also, taking the court to people is also important. Why a poor pliant has to go to New Delhi to fight his case often against rich corporates?
SC should have zonal benches to deal with bails and civil cases. Delhi bench should only deal constitutional matters. Similarly every HC should also have regional benches.
Main role of master of rooster is to ensure allocation of cases as per knowledge strength of a judge on such category of the case
Excellent conversation on matters of extreme importance.What a relief from the uncivilised din on the media,
Justice Arun Mishra in matter of Land acquisition, section 24, totally change the law made by Parliament and rule in favour of Govt..favoring Bjp in all matters..earlier judgments declared per incuriam
The judiciary is the most ineffective institution in India. 5 million cases pending for dates and judgments. There are no riots or protests to speed up court decisions. Justice is thus denied to 5 million cases. Justice delayed is justice denied. Indian democracy with 150 crores survives and progresses without a judiciary. Rich advocates like Kapil Sibel can get dates, bail, and judgments at lightning speed. Judges are granting bail liberally citing the constitution but no accountability when several incidents of accused criminals attacking and killing the victims or witnesses while on bail, have been occurring. Recently, the Honorable President of India appealed to the CJI to speed up the decades-old cases of illiterate, innocent Tribals from her home state. The judiciary does not accept technology to bring in efficiency and reduce staff. Long vacations, few working hours, Judges appointing judges as appointing authority which is an executive role, YOUR HONOR, and CONTEMPT OF COURT culture are adding to ineffectiveness. These debates with retired judges by an advocate Kapil Sibel 🤣are not intended to improve the judiciary but for publicity and bring pressure upon the sitting judges.
well said
Well said
Nice one
WHEN HATRED takes over logic and REASON dissolved and disappear
Great interpretation 12:56
What's wrong with the audio? Could be much better. Too much echo. Please take a look.
Lutyens gang
Wow ! You have opened a Pandora's box !
I sincerely doubt the motive of Ad. Kapil Sibal in initiating this discussion though some good points were discussed here about the collegium selection of Judges etc.
All said, individual views of the judges can't be overlooked ,thius objectivity of the verdict suffers
This is right job choosen by Sibbal ...
Please quote USA in full. There supreme court exist in each state. Hence there is basic disconnect in the structure here and USA. Quotes can be very good story. There judges are not appointed from 15 families unlike in bharat. These stories are from people who are retirees from an unjust system and now spending a life of luxury out of tax payer's money where govt is feeding 80 cr people.
If you guys are that True,, why not on mainstream media ????
Pls don't say it's due to Modi ji that the media doesn't entertain you...😂
They don't entertain because the generation has understood what you guys were, what you guys are and what you gonna be if the Generation keeps following you.... Seek forgiveness from the God, they might forgive you but not the JANTA....!!
Advocate Mr Kapil sibal sir very great lawyer ❤
For minorities and Khangress 😅
*सत्ता के पैरो में घुँघरू से कम नहीं हैं भारतीय न्यायपालिका, हर फ़ैसला सत्ता के पंक्ष में दिया जाता हैं या लंबित हैं सत्ता के पक्ष में दिये जाने के लिए, सरकार से पेंशन पाने वाला कोई भी भारतीय भारत के जनमानस के साथ न्याय नहीं कर सकता*
वाह हमारी न्यायपालिका नकल की है अकल की नहीं… justice delayed is justice denied…Courts are Courts, lower Court,, High Court Supreme Court negates the very basic of the sovereignty of our justice system.
Human beings are human. यहाँ छोटा बड़ा न कोई सब बराबर हैं यहाँ । सभी सम्मान, प्रेम व न्याय के अधिकारी हैं । सम्मान, प्रेम व न्याय पर सिर्फ़ पैसे वालों का ही हक़ नहीं। निर्धन भी समान न्याय, प्रेम व सम्मान के अधिकारी हैं।
Investigation need to be carried out and exposed to the citizens of Maharashtra of the Expenses, organizers for the trip from Mumbai to Surat to Guwahati to Goa to Mumbai. Let the citizens of Maharashtra know
Very unhealthy judicial system judges themself say that some judges are not good at particular criminal branch like criminal law, tax law or others ultimately who suffers ? There is nothing ahed to supreme court and is ahed to supreme court we know.....
I am surprised at sibbal expressing his displeasure over judges who differ in their views on a particular matter. This is how it has been going on for the last several years. And this is why the common man is unsatisfied and the lawyers like sibbal have been going around with billions in one pocket and favourable judgement in another. Remember the case of Manish kashyap in SC. Sibbal was able to convince the judges that Manish was the rogue element who must be put behind bars and yhe SC judges were more than happy to oblige him. Since this program involves retired judges but my vie is that they should not have talked to this person called sibbal who have been labelled as court- fixtures. While I have no objection to judges discussing how the courts function , they should not have talked to sibbal as he is a practicing lawyer and widely believed to be one of the most influential court-fixtures of our times. Now a days he is very sad because the judges refused to give a favour. This is a good sign which will enhance the prestige of the courts in the eyes and mind of common man and will deter the court- fixtures like sibbal in future.
Sobal jaise vakil ko itna kyon highlight kiya jaata hai ...yeh vakil to tab jeeta karta thaa jab congress ki sarkar thi ....ab to sabhi caseb haarta hai ...
Why are Judge not given bharat Ratna >?
Audio issues
😮😮
Present
Need to improve audio quality. Use targetting mics. They are essentially holding a podcast, better make it so.
u guys have to improve the mic setup. too much transient noise
common man doean't understand their language. Kapil should have framed question in a manner to evolve simple responses.
Sitting with retired judges of own choice. What more could be expected.
It is important for a multi ethnic, multi linguistic, multi cultural country lile india where communities do not and cannot trust each other and does not see eye with each other it is important that there is established multiple supreme courts with ambit of jurisdiction over their respective subjects and not over others.
This is very importsnt for india and this does not mean it should be statewise too, for example I do not recommend same supreme court for Bengali community of west bengal and gorkha community or tribal community of west bengal. Similar and much more complex divisions exist in other places. For example i am sure much of the problems of mistrust in judgemets snd judged will get resolved if supreme courts for each caste based communities are setup in many placed of north india which cuts across state boundaries, so maybe one for brahmin community of bihar and eastern up and one for dalits (which itself is an umbrella term) of those places or maybe one for muslims for those places.
It is important to understand that once suspicion creeps in on judges and their integrity the widening fussures will be thoroughly exploited by individuals whether politicsl or not.
It is important to understand that the weakest part of india, the underbelly, is its multi demographic nature even though that makes the place appear colourful or exotic to outsiders.
How can there be different views of gudges when law is one.
the question is! who will decide master of roster accountability!!!
Hai frindes uniform use nahi sir,desh ache technical workers nahi,mana desh ka development ache. 10 yteares after uniform like Balaji raju
What agreatchange
This discussion should be in hindi. Other wise very common man will not connect to the purpose