His voice was shaking when he did the killing curse... EDIT: and YES, I know he didn't want to do it, I just wanted to point out Alan Rickmans phenomenal acting skills.
@@ummjoe But didn't Bellatrix tell harry that you have to truly want to do the unforgivable course in order for it to work? If he wasn't determined to kill Dumbledor, It wouldn't have worked.
Bellatrix: *shoots the dark mark in the sky* The others: Great success now let's get out of here before Bellatrix's cheering gets us caught! Me: I don't know when she's happy she goes crazy with her
I now realized that when Dumbledore said "Severus...please" was not about please do not kill me, or do not do this, but begged him to kill him because otherwise, their plan to destroy the Dark Lord would not have happened. Severus was the victim here, he was not a bad man, he was brave to take the most difficult decision ever..to go over to the dark side and to kill a friend
Actually I think that it wasn't about Dumbledore at all. I think what the headmaster actually meant was "Please, take good care of Harry in my stead and explain to him what actually happened." They both looked down, and both knew Harry was there and was watching.
No he was begging to kill him it was explained in the books, they had it all planned out. Dumbledore knew that Draco was not able to kill him and besides he didn’t want him to be a murderer, so Snape should do it. In this way he proves himself loyal to Voldemort and the Elder Wand loses its power.
@@escapetherace1943 bruh. How can you even say that? I’d like to see you write better than that. Are you sure you just don’t remember them? because I’m rereading them currently and I occasionally stop simply to admire the brilliance and skill of JK Rowling
@@finny9125 she used the same phrases repeatedly, and by repeatedly some of them are used 30-40 times, same half sentences or so, across a short series to begin with multiple instances of this somebody did a huge dissection of her writing years ago, go look it up I can't be bothered
The fact that Dumbledore saying, "Severus, please." Is not begging for him not to kill him, but for mercy and the greater good. The fact that you have to "mean it" when you do the killing curse, confirming that Snape did it as a mercy kill.. Still gets me years later.
It wasn't a mercy kill... what you mean is, Dumbledore didn't ask for mercy, he wanted to be killed because it was part of the plan, to both save draco's soul and to get tom's trust, since he only had 1 year left anyway.
Even when you look at Dumbledore's eyes as he says Severus Please His eyes aren't filled with fear it's a relief look and he basically giving him the go ahead, it's alright I need you to do this now. And Severus at the end sounded like he was gonna cry, it broke his heart to have to do it
I don’t think it was the curse that killed dumbledore. It was the fall that killed him. That’s my opinion. Snape didn’t want to kill him so his heart wasn’t it in and for the curse to work I think you have to mean it.
@@dazzamcg2369 This is backed up in the book. In the book Dumbledore had cast a Body Bind Curse on Harry (because he knew Harry would try and defend him) and that spell didn't end when Dumbledore was hit by the Avada Kedavra, but when Dumbledore hit the ground.
@@ymck7246 Not in western culture. Most people even call their boss by their first name. I’m not sure how it’s disrespectful or ignorant it’s just a name
@@simplyzed8966 In Brazil we call our teachers by their first name, it's normal here. Same with bosses. But most of the time when talking to those older than us or in a position of authority we address them as "sir".
The pain in Severus's eyes when he had to kill the only man who trusted him. Albus Dumbledore, the man who just gave in his whole life and never took anything in return. He is truly the greatest wizard ever.
Are you kidding me? He took everything from Snape with interest. He made him do things he didn’t want to things he couldn’t bare yet he did. He even says sometimes you ask too much of me. He forfeit his life the moment he did as Dumbledore asked of him.
He took Snape's almost blind loyalty, knowing the enormous risk Snape would be taking. However, Snape offered his loyalty to Dumbledore of his own free will the moment he learned that Voldemort planned to kill Lily. Nothing true there was an exchange of interests. There were no victims of manipulation. At that point, Snape was already a smart enough guy to not let himself be manipulated.
That’s a great way to put it because not only will he mourn for dumbledore but Albus was the last one to know the real him. Luckily Harry got his memories or he would’ve been remembered as a villain forever.
“Years ago, I met a boy who made all the wrong choices.” Dumbledore could have been referring to himself, Grindelwald, or Voldemort with that sentence.
السؤال أود أن أستشيركم في رأيكم الشرعي حول الأخوات المسلمات عند استخدام مواقع التواصل الاجتماعي المختلفة يستخدمن صورة لفتاة أخرى قد تكون فنانة مشهورة، أو أي شخصية أخرى ، هل يجوز هذا؟. الإجابــة الحمد لله والصلاة والسلام على رسول الله وعلى آله وصحبه، أما بعد: فهي سيئات جارية و لا يجوز وضع صور النساء بحيث يطلع عليها الرجال سواء في مواقع التواصل أو غيرها، وسواء وضعت الفتاة صورتها أو وضعت صورة غيرها، فكل ذلك من أسباب الفتنة، وقد ثبت في الحديث الصحيح عن أسامة بن زيد ـ رضي الله عنهما ـ قال: قال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم: ما تركت بعدى فتنة هي أضر على الرجال من النساء. ويتأكد المنع في الصور الفاتنة، أو صور المتبرجات، وفي هذا من المفاسد ما لا يخفى. والله أعلم. لا تكتم علما ، بلغ الرسالة
RIP Sir Michael Gambon (October 19, 1940 - September 27, 2023), aged 82 And RIP Alan Rickman (February 21, 1946 - January 14, 2016), aged 69 You both will be remembered as legends.
2 of the greats who left us too soon. It breaks my heart to see so many of the original HP films passing to the beyond. We love, cherish and hold them all close for what they gave to us
"Draco. Years ago I knew a young boy who made all the wrong choices. Please let me help you." Wow. Powerful. And the look on Draco's face. It's heartbreaking! Such an awesome scene!
wallflower grandma That's not necessarily true. Dumbledore didn't explain further, and his words could relate to Grindelwald, Snape, or even himself...That's called good writing.
I hate how everyone got mad at Snape, he was following orders. He also made possible for Harry to defeat Vodimort. Then ultimately sacrificing himself, my favorite character in the series.
Yes, most of us know all this, but still, in my opinion (and also in J. K. Rowlings) Snape just wasn't a nice person. I mean, think of all the things he did to Harry and Neville just because Harry's father stole his girl and because Neville could have been the other Chosen One, which would have meant that Lily would have survived. He just straight up abused them, just to make himself feel better. I know that Snape was very brave and died kind of a hero's death, but he really was not a nice person at all, which is why he is not really one of my favourite characters. I hope you can understand my thoughts ^^'
Everyday Girl he did so to toughen them up because he knew what was going to be asked of them. He made them tough because Snape knew Voldimort was coming back and it was the only way for them to fight him.
Rest In Peace, Sir Michael Gambon. You'll always be remembered as Albus Percival Walfrick Brian Dumbledore. He died peacefully in hospital at 82 of pneumonia with his family by his side.
Both actors are AMAZING here. They give you the hint. Dumbledore's "please," is more like, "You promised." And, when Snape casts the spell, you can hear the sadness. So well done!
He looks troubled, but it's not because he's afraid of death, everything is proceeding as he planned and he knows Voldemort thinks everything is proceeding according to his own plan, but as he dies, everything becomes a bit of a gamble, as even tho he can give advice as a "picture" on the wall, he can not step in to protect anyone anymore. He was the leash that hold Voldemort back, with his death, the beast is free to roam as he wishes.
@@kogerugaming If Snape wasn't such a brilliant Occlumency, Voldemort had for sure realized that Snape was lying to him and that he was always Dumbledores spy.
since ur a human this shouldnt affect ur real life. This is a movie and is fantasy. Just cuz it makes u fell a certain way doesnt mean that it is real. Differentiate what is fantasy and real life and them and only them can u come close to something true.
"Don't feel sorry for the dead, Harry. Have pity on the living. And especially those who live without love." Farewell, Sir Michael Gambon 1940-2023 🌟 | | |
*”Severus…please…”* - In the books, the reason he says this isn’t just to save Draco’s soul, it’s revealed he had a conversation with Snape about how the death eaters will likely torture him and kill him slowly if given the chance, he tells Snape that he’s scared and would like to die with some dignity, so when he says “Severus…please…” he’s asking Snape to please kill him quickly and get it over with…just makes this whole scene much sadder with that knowledge in mind.
@@cammy399 Yeah he definitely could if he wanted to but he was planning to die that night anyways, he was sacrificing himself either way, so of course he was afraid of a slow and painful death he knew they would give him if given the chance, he says something along the lines of *”It won’t harm your soul to help an old man avoid pain and humiliation”* when talking to Snape months prior to this, so when he says “Severus…please…” in this scene that’s the context behind that in the books along with saving Draco from having to do anything that will tear his soul apart. Under normal circumstances Dumbledore wouldn’t be afraid of anyone, but in this situation he knows death is imminent and that this needs to happen, he knows he’ll let himself be disarmed and be completely at their will…
@@cammy399 Yes he cud have but he was already dying from the curse and the longer he lived the more painful it wud get. He realised it was Harry's fight not his, the longer he stayed, the longer it wud take for voldemort to die putting a lot of muggle lives to stake. He finished his last deed by telling Harry abt hocruxes and finding one(fake) with him. He died in hands of Snape so that Snape wouldn't die, and help Harry when he needed it.
he is 150 and by the time he got his hand curse he already accept his death. he maybe think about harry condition and want snape to finish the job fast so death eater can leave the hogwarts
Dumbledore's last words were "Severus, please." Snape's last words were "You have your mother's eyes." Sirius' last words were "Nice one James!" Dobby's last words were "Harry Potter." And Fred's last words were "You're actually joking! You haven't joked since you wh-" 😢
I just love how well written this story is. Dumbledore asked Snape to kill him because he was already dying and he wanted to stop draco from being pushed to the other side completely. Draco killing Dumbledore would have made that happen. Even with Malfoy family's affiliation with the dark side, Dumbledore knew draco was just a kid and a student. He needed to be given a chance to remain the same despite his father's choices. Draco was a product of his family's wealth, history and culture. Dumbledore understood this. That's why in a way he spared Draco. We know Dumbledore as wise character, but this much wise? J k Rowling did an amazing job.
it was a plan to achieve an ultimate goal , a mercy to a boy who clearly couldn't handle killing someone let alone someone he secretly respected, and lastly...draco was a damn child, the adult should pave the way for the future generation. All around it was just touching to watch as much as it was tragic.
Even more, Voldemort would get the ancient wand easily if Draco killed him, since to get a wand which answers to you completely you need to disarm/kill its owner. Draco was going to get the wand and Voldemort was going to kill him since he wasn't match for him, so he would get a full power wand for himself.
He also knew that if Draco killed him, Voldemort would have to kill Draco to get the elder wand. But if Snape kills Dumbledore bc Dumbledore wants him too, it’s a suicide and not a murder, so the elder wand chain is broken and it stays allied to a dead man
@@thescriptingshow1950 not really she doesn’t like the fact that people like Draco despite her writing him to be redeemable and understood by the audience… she also has said other things that just don’t make sense at all and contradicts her own writing, kinda making me think a lot of it was simply an accident on her part and it just happened to be good.
The fact that Snape didn't actually want to kill Dumbledore (sincere desire to kill is a mandatory part of the spell), but still managed to use the death curse really shows how strong this man was
I also read somewhere that Snape obviously didn't want to kill Dumbledore, but when the terminally ill Dumbledore begs him to end his life here and now and carry on with the plan, Snape does it as an act of mercy towards his old friend, thus the "desire to kill" is real albeit for completely different reasons.
@@ahmadsherbeny5609 it had nothing to do with keeping Draco from going to the dark side. It had everything to do with making Snape the true master of the Elder Wand to give Harry a fighting chance to defeat Voldemort. Dumbledore knew that once Voldemort had the wand that it would not work to its full strength if he was not the rightful owner. The killing curse that he used on Harry in the forest after Harry surrendered rebounded on Voldemort because Harry was his unintentional horcrux and Voldemort had to be the one to destroy the horcrux so Harry would have the chance to destroy Voldemort.
@@frattie84 you don't remember what happened in harry potter deathly hollows 2? basically Draco disarmed dumbledore which made him the owner of the wand then Harry disarmed draco in the room of requirements so basically harry was the owner
@@frattie84 If I remember correctly, Dumbledore and Snape thought that the wand would not pick a new master since it's last owner, Dumbledore that is, was supposed to die undefeated, but this of course didn't happen since Draco disarmed him and the wand changed it's allegiance to him.
We cant blame Snape for the death of Dumbledore. He only did it to protect Draco from getting killed by Voldemort and also Dumbledore said Snape should be the one to kill Dumbledore.
OR Snape and Dumbledore could have sided and fought Voldemort and his followers since he vanished. You can't tell me that Potter was able to find the Horcruxes with Hermione and Ron in a few months or so but Dumbledore and Snape couldn't do it in the past 14 years where Voldemort was gone. I mean I know that Harry himself is a Horcrux and so was this snake, but they could have destroyed the rest. Snape could have acted as a spy for Dumbledore, giving him information about what's going on amongst death eaters. But no, they just waited for everything to develop (more or less). Plus there was a lot of plot bending to make the story go the way it did. 1.) Voldemorts rebirth could have never happened if they wouldn't have decided to go against all the rules of the TRIwizard tournament, where Harry was a FOURTH contestant. It should have never been possible anyway but plot thought otherwise. 2.) A little more "Avada Kedavra" from the good guys would have helped A LOT. They could have killed so many figures that played an important role in the comeback of Voldemort, but nooo, we're the good guys, we don't use this speel even when it means to let people live who will bring back one of the greatest threats the wizarding and muggle world has ever seen. Harry or Cedric could have killed Peter Pettigrew back on the graveyard and then they could have quickly run away with this crippled Voldemort, locking him away for all eternity and everything would be fine. But then there wouldn't have been a great finale.
Levi Ackerman the Avada Kedavra spell isn't easy to cast you will need a lot of effort and skill to cast it and also its illegal any uses of the three unforgivable curses earns 1 way ticket to azkban
Levi Ackerman and there isn’t a lot of it in the movie but in the book, Dumbledore basically just found about tom’s horcruxes, which in itself is a plot hol
Dumbledore would have died either way, that shrivled hand was the doing of one of the deathly hallows, the ring that brings back dead people. That would have eventually killed him.
We have returned once again, to pay homage to a well beloved actor, who was part of this series that is a part of us all. Rest in Peace, Dame Maggie Smith.
Actually Draco was the owner once he disarmed dumbledore... It's funny actually that scenario you commented. If Draco owned the elder wand I wonder if Voldemort would have actually even been able to kill him after this. Maybe something similar would happen as did when he tried to killl Harry when Harry was the owner (except in this instance voldy wouldn't be using the elder wand against its true owner so the spell might not actually backfire since it would still have been in ddores tomb). If that makes sense.
@@1st_b I could be wrong (haven't read the books) but I recall reading/hearing about how Dumbledore also wanted Snape to do it for obvious reasons AND because it would 'sully' Draco. The boy clearly wasn't "bad to the bone" and was caught in between all this with his father's influence and legacy. While he was a death eater by Lucius' affiliation, Dumbledore knew he was just very lost and didn't wish him to kill another being which would solidify that status (of which Draco was internally reluctant about) or obviously traumatize him further.
I love how Alan Rickmans delivery once you know the twist with his character is so perfect for this moment. He doesn’t shout out the killing curse with pride and contempt toward dumbledore, but rather more hesitantly and scared as he’s likely instantly hating himself for his decision to kill a friend, no matter how noble the cause is
I can still hear the crack breaking up my heart when I saw this scene. I knew it. I had already read the book (twice), I had prepared myself. But.... Snape's face. Harry's gaze. His slow, angelic fall. Snape's cracking voice in "Avada Kedavra." And... that "please." I'm shattered.
Hatty Tarrant Same, I figured I wouldn't cry at any of the deaths since I read the books. Boy, was I wrong. Spoiler! I still can't get through Dumbledore and Snape's deaths without crying.
1:10 Alan Rickman's performance is amazing. It's just a silent "shhh," but his facial expression says everything. It's this very haunting look of caring but also complete fear. He knows this is the moment. This is the moment he has to kill Dumbledore, this is the moment he has to completely go undercover and act as if he is completely loyal to Voldemort. He knows what hes about to do is going to cause Harry to hate him. I love that they have this moment in the movie. I love that they didn't go the way the book was where Harry was stunned. Here Harry completely puts his trust in Snape. Snape knows this and even though he "has come to care for the boy," he now has to betray him. It's so good and has so many layers.
RobertDarcy that doesn't matter if you picture a puppy in your head getting tortured etc you might cry as well even though it's not real just because it's in your head doesn't make it any less real
yeah but the thing that replaced it was rather fitting with the students coming out in their pajamas and finding Dumbledore's body lying in the courtyard
I just realized; when Dumbeldore said, "Severus, please..." he meant that he wanted Severus to kill him, he was asking for it. And it wasn't because Dumbeldore was begging Severus NOT to kill him, he was begging for him to KILL him.
the brilliance of this series , it started with colours and gets darker and darker and darker , you can litterally feel the sadness , the fear as the chapters go forward , what a brilliant storyline and the writer J.K Rowling has a cathedral of imagination and adventure miss harry potter alot
It really gets dark at this point... so much that it's almost painful to watch the 6th film. 150 minutes of pure darkness, shadows and sorrow. A nearly uncomfortable experience but it carries the mood of the characters and their universe. I haven't read the books, when I saw this scene after such a dark film (as well as the previous one) my thought was: damn, things were already dark and now Dumbledore died... how much darker will this get???
Dumbledore is dead either way. Remember the ring he wore, the ring contained a curse that was slowly killing him. So to both fool the Dark Lord and to end the curse coursing his veins Dumbledore tells Snape to end his life.
The movie was preparing us for this. With just the movie's tone of color pallet, I knew dark times were coming. Dumbledore, with his presence, always transmitted us a sense of security and hope. With him gone, the remaining of this movie and Deathly Hallows felt like all hope was lost. BTW, I watched the movies before the books, so I was shocked the first time.
Even if you had read the books first, you would've been shocked. There is no mention of Dumbledore's and Snape's plan in the Half-Blood Prince, although in the order of the Phoenix there was a great activity of Snape as a servant to the Order.
Just watched this iconic scene and it just felt like yesterday. Paying tribute to the two finest actors (Snape & Dumbledore). So much shown with so little words. Including the interplay of villains, anti-hero, hero, half-villain and half-hero. A phenomenol performance, indeed.
What started with tears of sadness turns to tears of rage when they completely left out Dumbledore's Funeral!!! I still haven't forgiven David Yates for this...
The actors did such an amazing job with their voices and facial expressions. Especially Snape, where you can see that his voice was shaking when he said: "Avada Kedavra" and the painful look on his face. Draco, too. His voice was shaking and it really shows that's he's just a kid who's scared.
Came here after I just found out the passing of Sir Michael Gambon (Dumbledore). Rest In Peace, Legend. Tonight, I’m pointing my wand replica skyward. Thank you for everything, Legend. May you rest peacefully forever along with everyone who was a member in the cast of this amazing franchise. You all will be deeply missed but never forgotten.
“DON’T-” screamed Snape, and his face was suddenly demented, inhuman, as though he was in as much pain as the yelping, howling dog stuck in the burning house behind them, “CALL ME COWARD!”
I wish he took them all out instead and we really got to see his power in full swing. We needed to see him in full power, really striking fear into the hearts of the death eaters and voldemort. It would have been so satisfying. Also imo I think a better ending would have been, dumbledore finding a way to cure the curse on his hand, then going into battle with voldy, fatally wounding voldy but then maybe dying to protect someone else here like Harry or Draco. At least then we would see dumbledore go down in a fight
He had to let himself die to protect snape. Voldemort was starting to lose trust in Snape, so this murder was the only "proof" that snape is loyal to voldemort.
A lot of people make that argument in a hyperbolic way (not saying you, just a lot of people in general). But no, it actually really is a legitimate claim. He's up there with the all-time greats.
One of the finest character actors of his generation - no question. Although he gives a classy, layered performance of astonishing skill without much action or dialogue to work with, I also love him for his near-unique ability to properly ham it up and yet make it work. Just occurred to me how much I'd have loved to have seen him play the Doctor. I'm sure he'd have adored it too if it was available when he was either too young or too successful - by all accounts, despite his record, he always preferred playing the hero to the villain.
This is the most powerful scene in the whole movies. Severus is the most bravest wizard of all time, you can hear the pain in his voice when he gives the killing curse. RIP Alan Rickman.
"i have to kill you or he's going to kill me" actually, if you kill him, you just gave Voldy all the reason to kill you because in his eyes, you own the elder wand and that's what he wants.
Nole I just realized that by doing the deed himself, Snape actually saved Draco's life not once but twice. Draco was unable to bring himself to kill Dumbledore and would've been killed by Voldemort if Snape hadn't stepped in to do it himself. It ended up paying off even more for Draco when Voldemort came to the wrong conclusion that whoever kills the master of the Elder Wand becomes the wand's next master. If Draco had ended up killing Dumbledore, he still would get killed by Voldemort eventually due to Voldemort's belief that killing the owner was how you earned the Elder Wand, not disarming them.
Aleksander Järvinen the battle was left because they wanted to save all the action for The Battle of Hogwarts in Deathly Hallows Part 2. They didn't put Dumbledore's funeral in because they thought the scene was too sad and depressing
+SuperJackster01 That's such a stupid argument. It's like cutting the Battle of Helm's Deep from The Two Towers, or the Battle of Geonosis from Attack of the Clones. Movies should stand out on their own, and not need another to provide their climax.
Assuming Snape never killed anyone in his years as a Death Eater, his first and only kill was Dumbledore, his one and only friend. The man who redeemed him. You can see his soul being torn to pieces 💔
I think Snape probably still went to a pleasant afterlife when his time came, as Dumbledore had given Snape his blessing to kill him, to spare him from a slow, agonizing death with no hope of survival. It wasn't homicide, it was a mercy killing. That doesn't scar the soul the way murder does.
Severus Snape such a bravest character of all time Who die for his love Who refuse to look like good character Who always protect Harry Potter Who teach Expellairmus to Harry Potter that He won duel with Voldemort Who sacrifice himself for Harry Potter
Love how Dumbledore let’s Draco disarm him, and then tries everything to show him that there is a better way.... it’s because he knows he just gave Draco the power to wield the Elder Wand (: Genius
Michael Gambon and Alan Rickman both having the best time up there now I bet. RIP to two of the greatest actors I grew up with. "Don't feel sorry for the dead, Harry. Have pity on the living. And especially those who live without love."
R.I.P Michael Gambon 😢 This 2023 the actor who played Albus Dumbledore passed away, so now this scene is more real than what we saw. Both the character and his actor died, without forgetting that others such as Robbie Coltrane (Rubeus Hagrid) and Alan Rickman (Severus Snape) also died before him, and many others.
1:05 the expression on Snape's face though... 'I.. I never wanted any of this Potter, stay silent and hidden, please, for Lily's sake, save yourself anyhow' And the moment his wand fires the spell... his trembling voice and his pained face.. Alan Rickman was great. Irreplaceable.
Its sad that in real life he too pass away. No avada kadabra this time. Just sickness n life. Thank u for the memories RIP man, Harry potter is belove by millions, each actir deserves praise for their work n contribution to great movie legacy
The only man Voldemort has ever feared is dead.Gone but forever in our wizards heart. Years and years of knowledge and wisdom would never be dead. RIP Micheal gambon.
Rest in peace Michael Gambon. Uniquely played Dumbledore and kept us with childhood memories. 😢
Literally crying watching this
R.I.P Micheal Gambon 😭
You will be missed 😭❤️
Michael and Alan did a masterpiece scene here! They will be missed. 😢
He did a masterpiece on acting he should’ve been killed in the latest like wakanda forever
R.I.P Micheal Gambon/Albus Dumbludore
RIP Richard Harris, Richard Griffiths, Michael Gambon and Alan Rickman. You will all be missed.
"I don't want your help!" cries Draco.
He lied. He wants Dumbledore's help. He's just too afraid to ask for it.
He actually does need help. He needs to find his skis. He appears to have misplaced them.
Help will always be given at Hogwarts to those who ask for it - Dumbledore.
Dumledore helped him by not letting draco kill him also severus was loyal to Dumbledore otherise he wouldn't die in place of draco for the elder wand.
@Tyleah Morales you are my mirror
Dumbledore did help them just unknowingly he helped him by making sure that he wasn't the one who had to kill him. That Snape killed him in his place.
Everyone, raise your wands. Rest in peace, Michael Gambon. To Richard and Michael, thank you for being our Dumbledore ✝️
And why did put catholic cross? 😂
It still brings a tear to my eye, even though I never got to meet him
@@MetroCop2077- The cross is a sign of death all throughout the world. It’s used even in places where Christianity isn’t the dominant religion.
@@MetroCop2077crosses are used to symbolize dead people
@@MetroCop2077seriously bro
-Severus, please. don't kill me.-
*Severus, please. Kill me, according to plan.*
badass dumbleDOOR
Severus: *writes name on Death Note*: Jump backwards as though as you've been hit
Anon Ni Moose that's what happens everytime Avada Kedavra is cast on a person they also jump back
Severus, please.
I can't-
Why doesn't Snape teach Herbology?
Sir please don't-
Because his Lily di-
AVADA KEDAVRA
@@anonnimoose7987 looool
His voice was shaking when he did the killing curse...
EDIT: and YES, I know he didn't want to do it, I just wanted to point out Alan Rickmans phenomenal acting skills.
Yeah such great acting from the late alan rickman may he rest in peace
That's cause he didn't want to kill him
@@ummjoe But didn't Bellatrix tell harry that you have to truly want to do the unforgivable course in order for it to work? If he wasn't determined to kill Dumbledor, It wouldn't have worked.
Bellatrix: *shoots the dark mark in the sky*
The others: Great success now let's get out of here before Bellatrix's cheering gets us caught!
Me: I don't know when she's happy she goes crazy with her
Kourosh Rm7 only for the crucio curse.
The fact that now these two magnificent actors passed away makes this scene more heartbreaking
These two made my childhood 😕
So did Bellatrix' actress 😢
@@persxstdo you mean Narcissa? Or Hagrid? Bellatrix’ actress didn’t did
@@JFclips yes narcissa, my bad dude, I'm really sorry
And now maggie smith is resting with them 😢
I now realized that when Dumbledore said "Severus...please" was not about please do not kill me, or do not do this, but begged him to kill him because otherwise, their plan to destroy the Dark Lord would not have happened. Severus was the victim here, he was not a bad man, he was brave to take the most difficult decision ever..to go over to the dark side and to kill a friend
He left the dark side when he was 20. This was not murder, it was mercy killing. Dumbledore was dying already.
Actually I think that it wasn't about Dumbledore at all. I think what the headmaster actually meant was "Please, take good care of Harry in my stead and explain to him what actually happened." They both looked down, and both knew Harry was there and was watching.
No he was begging to kill him it was explained in the books, they had it all planned out. Dumbledore knew that Draco was not able to kill him and besides he didn’t want him to be a murderer, so Snape should do it. In this way he proves himself loyal to Voldemort and the Elder Wand loses its power.
Duh
Snape may have not been evil but he was not a good man eather
Only Severus knew what dumbledore truly meant when he said “please.”
Lots of the comments are about that
Yay first reply🥳
no shat bro maybe if you would have read the books you would have known why.
@@extrage3061 the books are awful if you're over the age of 10, they're written amateurishly
@@escapetherace1943 bruh. How can you even say that? I’d like to see you write better than that. Are you sure you just don’t remember them? because I’m rereading them currently and I occasionally stop simply to admire the brilliance and skill of JK Rowling
@@finny9125 she used the same phrases repeatedly, and by repeatedly some of them are used 30-40 times, same half sentences or so, across a short series to begin with
multiple instances of this
somebody did a huge dissection of her writing years ago, go look it up I can't be bothered
The fact that Dumbledore saying, "Severus, please." Is not begging for him not to kill him, but for mercy and the greater good. The fact that you have to "mean it" when you do the killing curse, confirming that Snape did it as a mercy kill.. Still gets me years later.
It wasn't a mercy kill... what you mean is, Dumbledore didn't ask for mercy, he wanted to be killed because it was part of the plan, to both save draco's soul and to get tom's trust, since he only had 1 year left anyway.
Even when you look at Dumbledore's eyes as he says Severus Please His eyes aren't filled with fear it's a relief look and he basically giving him the go ahead, it's alright I need you to do this now. And Severus at the end sounded like he was gonna cry, it broke his heart to have to do it
I don’t think it was the curse that killed dumbledore. It was the fall that killed him. That’s my opinion. Snape didn’t want to kill him so his heart wasn’t it in and for the curse to work I think you have to mean it.
also notice how the color of the spell is blueish instead of green. that's because of the intent. Snape never fully meant to kill him.
@@dazzamcg2369 This is backed up in the book. In the book Dumbledore had cast a Body Bind Curse on Harry (because he knew Harry would try and defend him) and that spell didn't end when Dumbledore was hit by the Avada Kedavra, but when Dumbledore hit the ground.
I love that Bellatrix and Dumbledore are on a first name basis.
@@ymck7246*B R U H*
@@ymck7246 nice essay
@@ymck7246 Not in western culture. Most people even call their boss by their first name. I’m not sure how it’s disrespectful or ignorant it’s just a name
@@simplyzed8966 In Brazil we call our teachers by their first name, it's normal here. Same with bosses. But most of the time when talking to those older than us or in a position of authority we address them as "sir".
Me to
RIP Alan Rickman You will always be missed as one of the best actor of HP movies
Always
Always (2019)
always
Always ⚡
After all this time
The pain in Severus's eyes when he had to kill the only man who trusted him. Albus Dumbledore, the man who just gave in his whole life and never took anything in return. He is truly the greatest wizard ever.
Are you kidding me? He took everything from Snape with interest. He made him do things he didn’t want to things he couldn’t bare yet he did. He even says sometimes you ask too much of me. He forfeit his life the moment he did as Dumbledore asked of him.
never took anything in return?
what lol
did you not see snape's memories correctly?
@Waryck that's what I said-
He took Snape's almost blind loyalty, knowing the enormous risk Snape would be taking. However, Snape offered his loyalty to Dumbledore of his own free will the moment he learned that Voldemort planned to kill Lily. Nothing true there was an exchange of interests. There were no victims of manipulation. At that point, Snape was already a smart enough guy to not let himself be manipulated.
That’s a great way to put it because not only will he mourn for dumbledore but Albus was the last one to know the real him. Luckily Harry got his memories or he would’ve been remembered as a villain forever.
“Years ago, I met a boy who made all the wrong choices.”
Dumbledore could have been referring to himself, Grindelwald, or Voldemort with that sentence.
Think he meant Voldemort, since he knew Draco would think of Tom rather than Grindelwald or himself.
It also ties back to his speech earlier in the movie where he told the hall about Tom Riddle and said “their greatest weapon is you”
And snape
Or Snape
He meant you know who 👎
"Do you cry even after all these years seeing him get killed?"
"Always"
Oh hell yeah...
All these years?? Snape died the next year-
It’s awful seeing him go
السؤال
أود أن أستشيركم في رأيكم الشرعي حول الأخوات المسلمات عند استخدام مواقع التواصل الاجتماعي المختلفة يستخدمن صورة لفتاة أخرى قد تكون فنانة مشهورة، أو أي شخصية أخرى ، هل يجوز هذا؟.
الإجابــة
الحمد لله والصلاة والسلام على رسول الله وعلى آله وصحبه، أما بعد:
فهي سيئات جارية و لا يجوز وضع صور النساء بحيث يطلع عليها الرجال سواء في مواقع التواصل أو غيرها، وسواء وضعت الفتاة صورتها أو وضعت صورة غيرها، فكل ذلك من أسباب الفتنة، وقد ثبت في الحديث الصحيح عن أسامة بن زيد ـ رضي الله عنهما ـ قال: قال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم: ما تركت بعدى فتنة هي أضر على الرجال من النساء. ويتأكد المنع في الصور الفاتنة، أو صور المتبرجات، وفي هذا من المفاسد ما لا يخفى.
والله أعلم.
لا تكتم علما ، بلغ الرسالة
No cuz I laughed at Dumbledore's death
RIP Sir Michael Gambon (October 19, 1940 - September 27, 2023), aged 82
And
RIP Alan Rickman (February 21, 1946 - January 14, 2016), aged 69
You both will be remembered as legends.
Don't forget Hagrid's actor!
So many harry potter legends died but we will remember them
2 of the greats who left us too soon. It breaks my heart to see so many of the original HP films passing to the beyond. We love, cherish and hold them all close for what they gave to us
It makes me so depressed knowing they're dead. Loved these characters
"Draco. Years ago I knew a young boy who made all the wrong choices. Please let me help you."
Wow. Powerful. And the look on Draco's face. It's heartbreaking! Such an awesome scene!
He was talking about Tom.
Or Snape. Or Grindelwald...
He was talking about Tom.
Super Saiyan Goku He was talking about Tom.
wallflower grandma
That's not necessarily true. Dumbledore didn't explain further, and his words could relate to Grindelwald, Snape, or even himself...That's called good writing.
I hate how everyone got mad at Snape, he was following orders. He also made possible for Harry to defeat Vodimort. Then ultimately sacrificing himself, my favorite character in the series.
Yes, most of us know all this, but still, in my opinion (and also in J. K. Rowlings) Snape just wasn't a nice person. I mean, think of all the things he did to Harry and Neville just because Harry's father stole his girl and because Neville could have been the other Chosen One, which would have meant that Lily would have survived. He just straight up abused them, just to make himself feel better. I know that Snape was very brave and died kind of a hero's death, but he really was not a nice person at all, which is why he is not really one of my favourite characters. I hope you can understand my thoughts ^^'
Everyday Girl he did so to toughen them up because he knew what was going to be asked of them. He made them tough because Snape knew Voldimort was coming back and it was the only way for them to fight him.
+Lyle Schoepflin same. 😌
He still cared for Harry though. Its not like he wished him harm or anything.
Lyle Schoepflin I'm so Mad at snape he kills dumbledoor
Rest In Peace, Sir Michael Gambon. You'll always be remembered as Albus Percival Walfrick Brian Dumbledore. He died peacefully in hospital at 82 of pneumonia with his family by his side.
While I wouldn’t say pneumonia is a particular peaceful way to die, it’s nice to know his family was there.
Both actors are AMAZING here. They give you the hint. Dumbledore's "please," is more like, "You promised." And, when Snape casts the spell, you can hear the sadness. So well done!
Yep the scene hits me on a different level when I rewatch the movie compared to when I was unaware of what that “please” really meant.
Yeah I can tell snape didn't want to do it but in the end he had a mission. He had no choice.
Yeah you can hear his voice wavering as he says it. Amazing acting from both
Snape is the ultimate double double agent.
pause at the exact moment and you can see the sadness in his face..
1:23 The last look Dumbledore gave Harry...
Always gives me goosebumps
He looks troubled, but it's not because he's afraid of death, everything is proceeding as he planned and he knows Voldemort thinks everything is proceeding according to his own plan, but as he dies, everything becomes a bit of a gamble, as even tho he can give advice as a "picture" on the wall, he can not step in to protect anyone anymore. He was the leash that hold Voldemort back, with his death, the beast is free to roam as he wishes.
@@kogerugaming If Snape wasn't such a brilliant Occlumency, Voldemort had for sure realized that Snape was lying to him and that he was always Dumbledores spy.
since ur a human this shouldnt affect ur real life. This is a movie and is fantasy. Just cuz it makes u fell a certain way doesnt mean that it is real. Differentiate what is fantasy and real life and them and only them can u come close to something true.
@@macdoodlechamp Shut up.People can feel emotions because of a movie.
"Don't feel sorry for the dead, Harry. Have pity on the living. And especially those who live without love."
Farewell, Sir Michael Gambon
1940-2023
🌟
|
|
|
🙏
And RIP Alan Rickman
🌟
l
l
l
Rip
When I saw this quote the first time when he passed it broke my heart and it still does...
*”Severus…please…”* - In the books, the reason he says this isn’t just to save Draco’s soul, it’s revealed he had a conversation with Snape about how the death eaters will likely torture him and kill him slowly if given the chance, he tells Snape that he’s scared and would like to die with some dignity, so when he says “Severus…please…” he’s asking Snape to please kill him quickly and get it over with…just makes this whole scene much sadder with that knowledge in mind.
Can’t he fight the death eaters? Dumbledoor was the most powerful wizard of that time right?
@@cammy399 Yeah he definitely could if he wanted to but he was planning to die that night anyways, he was sacrificing himself either way, so of course he was afraid of a slow and painful death he knew they would give him if given the chance, he says something along the lines of *”It won’t harm your soul to help an old man avoid pain and humiliation”* when talking to Snape months prior to this, so when he says “Severus…please…” in this scene that’s the context behind that in the books along with saving Draco from having to do anything that will tear his soul apart.
Under normal circumstances Dumbledore wouldn’t be afraid of anyone, but in this situation he knows death is imminent and that this needs to happen, he knows he’ll let himself be disarmed and be completely at their will…
@@cammy399 Yes he cud have but he was already dying from the curse and the longer he lived the more painful it wud get. He realised it was Harry's fight not his, the longer he stayed, the longer it wud take for voldemort to die putting a lot of muggle lives to stake. He finished his last deed by telling Harry abt hocruxes and finding one(fake) with him. He died in hands of Snape so that Snape wouldn't die, and help Harry when he needed it.
@@Ivbo stop inventing stuff
@@therealdrachi12 read the books casual, he isn't inventing stuff, its canon
Snape is such a brilliantly written character.
R.I.P Michael Gambon, worthy successor for Richard Harris
Harris was better but both were good actors
It's not a comparison act, Gambon made the role his own and I loved every minute of how performed it@@joemercedeschannel196
@@joemercedeschannel196nah harris didnt really do much
I always wondered what his last thoughts were as he stood there about to be murdered.
Dakota Wynchester I really think he accepted this for a long time. I think he is glad to see his sister again
Dakota Wynchester I am a fictional character. Or I was better in the singing detective
he is 150 and by the time he got his hand curse he already accept his death. he maybe think about harry condition and want snape to finish the job fast so death eater can leave the hogwarts
TheFlash31406 Suparrolegends bahahaha!
You're both wrong. Dumbledore was 116 when he died.
Poor Draco, that "I have to kill you, or he's gonna kill me." Gets me emotional, Tom Felton was really good with keeping the emotion in his voice.
Pug Ren he got himself into this I have no sympathy for him because he willingly joined the death eaters of his own volition
@@thomasraines1396 he was forced because of his parents
@@user-br4ms5vs2x no he wasn’t.
@@thomasraines1396 yes he was .
@@user-br4ms5vs2x no he wasn’t, he joined of his own volition.
Just heard the news about Michael Gambon. Rest in peace. Thank you for making so many of our childhoods magical.
so did i :( r.i.p. michael aka dumbledore :(
Dumbledore's last words were "Severus, please."
Snape's last words were "You have your mother's eyes."
Sirius' last words were "Nice one James!"
Dobby's last words were "Harry Potter."
And Fred's last words were "You're actually joking! You haven't joked since you wh-"
😢
You've only seen the movies Snape's last words were 'Look...at...me...'
Sirius's last words were 'Is this the best you can do?!'
Dont forget cedrics last word.... oh right nvm
WHY DID FRED DIED!?
Here the tears come...😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Sirius's last words in the book are to Bellatrix "Is that the best you've got"
I just love how well written this story is. Dumbledore asked Snape to kill him because he was already dying and he wanted to stop draco from being pushed to the other side completely. Draco killing Dumbledore would have made that happen. Even with Malfoy family's affiliation with the dark side, Dumbledore knew draco was just a kid and a student. He needed to be given a chance to remain the same despite his father's choices. Draco was a product of his family's wealth, history and culture. Dumbledore understood this. That's why in a way he spared Draco. We know Dumbledore as wise character, but this much wise? J k Rowling did an amazing job.
it was a plan to achieve an ultimate goal , a mercy to a boy who clearly couldn't handle killing someone let alone someone he secretly respected, and lastly...draco was a damn child, the adult should pave the way for the future generation. All around it was just touching to watch as much as it was tragic.
Even more, Voldemort would get the ancient wand easily if Draco killed him, since to get a wand which answers to you completely you need to disarm/kill its owner. Draco was going to get the wand and Voldemort was going to kill him since he wasn't match for him, so he would get a full power wand for himself.
He also knew that if Draco killed him, Voldemort would have to kill Draco to get the elder wand. But if Snape kills Dumbledore bc Dumbledore wants him too, it’s a suicide and not a murder, so the elder wand chain is broken and it stays allied to a dead man
I understand your point, but something important to mention is that Rowling meant for Draco to be evil
@@thescriptingshow1950 not really she doesn’t like the fact that people like Draco despite her writing him to be redeemable and understood by the audience… she also has said other things that just don’t make sense at all and contradicts her own writing, kinda making me think a lot of it was simply an accident on her part and it just happened to be good.
The fact that Snape didn't actually want to kill Dumbledore (sincere desire to kill is a mandatory part of the spell), but still managed to use the death curse really shows how strong this man was
I would argue Dumbledore died due to the fall.
@@chelmano0 was the fall in the books? I can’t remember
@@dequasont1063 yes, it was
I also read somewhere that Snape obviously didn't want to kill Dumbledore, but when the terminally ill Dumbledore begs him to end his life here and now and carry on with the plan, Snape does it as an act of mercy towards his old friend, thus the "desire to kill" is real albeit for completely different reasons.
@@jacobking4504 Really? cause I thought they were in front of the castle's door, so outside
When Hermoine said on the first movie “As long as Dumbledore’s around you’re safe,” I knew that he was going to die.
and today we lost him 💔makes that quote painful
The power in her voice at 1:58 sends chills down my entire body every time... Helena’s acting is magnificent.
Helena is brilliant indeed
To live in the chaos and darkness you can hear it in there. Power eek
1:59
One of the best acting performances in the movies, I think she, McGonagall, and Hermione had the best acting
Made me hate her even more. Great acting
Rest in Peace Michael Gambon! Just heartbreaking to know, that both the Actors of Snape and Dumbledore are gone
Don't forget Robbie Coltraine!
"severus, please" that scene made me cry as fuck
He was asking him to do instead of draco, so freakin draco won't go in the dark side ...
@@ahmadsherbeny5609 it had nothing to do with keeping Draco from going to the dark side. It had everything to do with making Snape the true master of the Elder Wand to give Harry a fighting chance to defeat Voldemort. Dumbledore knew that once Voldemort had the wand that it would not work to its full strength if he was not the rightful owner. The killing curse that he used on Harry in the forest after Harry surrendered rebounded on Voldemort because Harry was his unintentional horcrux and Voldemort had to be the one to destroy the horcrux so Harry would have the chance to destroy Voldemort.
@@frattie84 you don't remember what happened in harry potter deathly hollows 2? basically Draco disarmed dumbledore which made him the owner of the wand then Harry disarmed draco in the room of requirements so basically harry was the owner
@@CabassosML I know. I reread it and watched the scene a few more times before I caught on.
@@frattie84 If I remember correctly, Dumbledore and Snape thought that the wand would not pick a new master since it's last owner, Dumbledore that is, was supposed to die undefeated, but this of course didn't happen since Draco disarmed him and the wand changed it's allegiance to him.
We cant blame Snape for the death of Dumbledore. He only did it to protect Draco from getting killed by Voldemort and also Dumbledore said Snape should be the one to kill Dumbledore.
OR Snape and Dumbledore could have sided and fought Voldemort and his followers since he vanished. You can't tell me that Potter was able to find the Horcruxes with Hermione and Ron in a few months or so but Dumbledore and Snape couldn't do it in the past 14 years where Voldemort was gone. I mean I know that Harry himself is a Horcrux and so was this snake, but they could have destroyed the rest. Snape could have acted as a spy for Dumbledore, giving him information about what's going on amongst death eaters. But no, they just waited for everything to develop (more or less).
Plus there was a lot of plot bending to make the story go the way it did.
1.) Voldemorts rebirth could have never happened if they wouldn't have decided to go against all the rules of the TRIwizard tournament, where Harry was a FOURTH contestant. It should have never been possible anyway but plot thought otherwise.
2.) A little more "Avada Kedavra" from the good guys would have helped A LOT. They could have killed so many figures that played an important role in the comeback of Voldemort, but nooo, we're the good guys, we don't use this speel even when it means to let people live who will bring back one of the greatest threats the wizarding and muggle world has ever seen. Harry or Cedric could have killed Peter Pettigrew back on the graveyard and then they could have quickly run away with this crippled Voldemort, locking him away for all eternity and everything would be fine. But then there wouldn't have been a great finale.
Levi Ackerman the Avada Kedavra spell isn't easy to cast you will need a lot of effort and skill to cast it and also its illegal any uses of the three unforgivable curses earns 1 way ticket to azkban
@@LeviAckerman-ln8kt agreed
Levi Ackerman and there isn’t a lot of it in the movie but in the book, Dumbledore basically just found about tom’s horcruxes, which in itself is a plot hol
Dumbledore would have died either way, that shrivled hand was the doing of one of the deathly hallows, the ring that brings back dead people. That would have eventually killed him.
We have returned once again, to pay homage to a well beloved actor, who was part of this series that is a part of us all. Rest in Peace, Dame Maggie Smith.
If Severus didn't kill Dumbledore, then Draco would've been killed, since SNAPE got the elder wand and Draco would've gotten killed by Voldemort.
AndreaTejada stupid voldy didn't know that allegiance doesn't change with killing
Yeah, it does. It can change with disarming or killing. The Deathly Hallows taught us that it can change with killing.
Actually Draco was the owner once he disarmed dumbledore...
It's funny actually that scenario you commented. If Draco owned the elder wand I wonder if Voldemort would have actually even been able to kill him after this. Maybe something similar would happen as did when he tried to killl Harry when Harry was the owner (except in this instance voldy wouldn't be using the elder wand against its true owner so the spell might not actually backfire since it would still have been in ddores tomb). If that makes sense.
@@1st_b He could still kill him as long as Voldemort wasn't trying to use the Elder Wand.
@@1st_b I could be wrong (haven't read the books) but I recall reading/hearing about how Dumbledore also wanted Snape to do it for obvious reasons AND because it would 'sully' Draco. The boy clearly wasn't "bad to the bone" and was caught in between all this with his father's influence and legacy. While he was a death eater by Lucius' affiliation, Dumbledore knew he was just very lost and didn't wish him to kill another being which would solidify that status (of which Draco was internally reluctant about) or obviously traumatize him further.
Alan Rickman's acting is just breathtaking here.
He’s amazing actor 😎
@@francheskajulien8799 was 😔 RIP to my all time favorite actor/Person.
His acting was cold af. Gives me chills
Phenomenal actor
so breathtaking it took the breath out of dumbledore.
Devastated. Thanks for all the childhood memories. An amazing Dumbledore and a lovely human being. Rest in peace Michael Gambon. 🪄
I love how Alan Rickmans delivery once you know the twist with his character is so perfect for this moment. He doesn’t shout out the killing curse with pride and contempt toward dumbledore, but rather more hesitantly and scared as he’s likely instantly hating himself for his decision to kill a friend, no matter how noble the cause is
Oh shut up
STOP CUTTING THE ONIONS GOD DAMMIT!
Lol
kieranhendy wtf
Give them a moment, for pity's sake!
Who keeps doing that????!!!!
lol
*Rest in Peace Sir Michael Gambon (1940-2023)*
I can still hear the crack breaking up my heart when I saw this scene.
I knew it. I had already read the book (twice), I had prepared myself. But.... Snape's face. Harry's gaze. His slow, angelic fall. Snape's cracking voice in "Avada Kedavra."
And... that "please."
I'm shattered.
Hatty Tarrant Same, I figured I wouldn't cry at any of the deaths since I read the books. Boy, was I wrong.
Spoiler!
I still can't get through Dumbledore and Snape's deaths without crying.
I feel his pain when he said Avada Kedavra . Alan Rickman such an great actor of all times
1:10 Alan Rickman's performance is amazing. It's just a silent "shhh," but his facial expression says everything. It's this very haunting look of caring but also complete fear. He knows this is the moment. This is the moment he has to kill Dumbledore, this is the moment he has to completely go undercover and act as if he is completely loyal to Voldemort. He knows what hes about to do is going to cause Harry to hate him. I love that they have this moment in the movie. I love that they didn't go the way the book was where Harry was stunned. Here Harry completely puts his trust in Snape. Snape knows this and even though he "has come to care for the boy," he now has to betray him. It's so good and has so many layers.
Snape’s complicated backstory makes him more interesting 🤔
When I read it I cried sooo much, unintentionally covered half the page with tears actually.
If you're not out of the closet already you are now!
+Amaris Torres So you're like Hagrid when his spider died!
ME TOO! I'm glad I'm not the only one!
It's not real
RobertDarcy that doesn't matter if you picture a puppy in your head getting tortured etc you might cry as well even though it's not real
just because it's in your head doesn't make it any less real
I wish they didn't cut Dumbledore's funeral from the movie. Kinda sad tbh
yeah but the thing that replaced it was rather fitting with the students coming out in their pajamas and finding Dumbledore's body lying in the courtyard
U have to remember this is not a marvel franchize where they have long funeral scene lol
@@nickpenaranda725 I didn't even mention Marvel like hello? It could have been a 1-minute scene
@@arturs_ when did i say that u mention it?
That would have been horribly long and full of unnecessary cast.
Forever in our hearts. Rip prof. Dumbledore. Thank you for making our childhood amazing 🕊
I just realized; when Dumbeldore said, "Severus, please..." he meant that he wanted Severus to kill him, he was asking for it. And it wasn't because Dumbeldore was begging Severus NOT to kill him, he was begging for him to KILL him.
No shit
Wow, we have a sherlock holmes here, bring him an oscar
Yes
Wow i didnt know that LOL
Better late than never hahah
the brilliance of this series , it started with colours and gets darker and darker and darker , you can litterally feel the sadness , the fear as the chapters go forward , what a brilliant storyline and the writer J.K Rowling has a cathedral of imagination and adventure
miss harry potter alot
It really gets dark at this point... so much that it's almost painful to watch the 6th film. 150 minutes of pure darkness, shadows and sorrow. A nearly uncomfortable experience but it carries the mood of the characters and their universe.
I haven't read the books, when I saw this scene after such a dark film (as well as the previous one) my thought was: damn, things were already dark and now Dumbledore died... how much darker will this get???
Raise your wands for Dame Maggie Smith, rest in peace.
What's great is you know what dumbledore meant when he said Severus please
Dumbledore asked Severus to kill him by saying “please”. He thought Severus wouldn’t able to do that. Such a wonderful character. 😭
no dumbledoor was asking Severus to take care of harry
Dumbledore is dead either way. Remember the ring he wore, the ring contained a curse that was slowly killing him. So to both fool the Dark Lord and to end the curse coursing his veins Dumbledore tells Snape to end his life.
@@lexusdriver1963 thank you for telling everyone my plan
Sad that he had to die though : (
The movie was preparing us for this. With just the movie's tone of color pallet, I knew dark times were coming.
Dumbledore, with his presence, always transmitted us a sense of security and hope. With him gone, the remaining of this movie and Deathly Hallows felt like all hope was lost.
BTW, I watched the movies before the books, so I was shocked the first time.
@Clodagh straum why not? Lol
Even if you had read the books first, you would've been shocked. There is no mention of Dumbledore's and Snape's plan in the Half-Blood Prince, although in the order of the Phoenix there was a great activity of Snape as a servant to the Order.
@@ralphmalasakit9543 because the movies ruined the books that's why. Lol
@@ananyabhagat7052 nobody cares about the book.
@@ngmmngw9027 actually most real potterheads do but ok
Just watched this iconic scene and it just felt like yesterday. Paying tribute to the two finest actors (Snape & Dumbledore). So much shown with so little words. Including the interplay of villains, anti-hero, hero, half-villain and half-hero. A phenomenol performance, indeed.
Half villain, half hero and the Half blood Prince
this is the saddest part of all of the movies
Yeah....in the books is even more sad...dumby was the best
I cried when sirius died, not dumbledore though
@@OrigoZ yea everyone has different taste
Saddest.
Tell me about it! Me and my grandma cried our eyes out in the theater when we first saw it.
I can hear the pain in Snapes voice when he kills Dumbledore
Rest in Peace Michael Gambon 💔💔
What started with tears of sadness turns to tears of rage when they completely left out Dumbledore's Funeral!!! I still haven't forgiven David Yates for this...
Good thing David Yates doesn't give a fuck.
killer92173 J.K Rowling is the one to blame
Film Fan how come?
killer92173 Because she's the one who originally wrote it
Green Filter exactly! that's why I'm mad that they didn't include it!
The actors did such an amazing job with their voices and facial expressions. Especially Snape, where you can see that his voice was shaking when he said: "Avada Kedavra" and the painful look on his face. Draco, too. His voice was shaking and it really shows that's he's just a kid who's scared.
Came here after I just found out the passing of Sir Michael Gambon (Dumbledore). Rest In Peace, Legend. Tonight, I’m pointing my wand replica skyward. Thank you for everything, Legend. May you rest peacefully forever along with everyone who was a member in the cast of this amazing franchise. You all will be deeply missed but never forgotten.
“DON’T-” screamed Snape, and his face was suddenly demented, inhuman, as though he was in as much pain as the yelping, howling dog stuck in the burning house behind them, “CALL ME COWARD!”
Now we know why he was in such state poor guy
I CRIED SO MUCH MORE while reading the book about his death then watching the movie.
Wow way to take a shit on everyone who doesn't read books 😒
not his fault it is better in the books. The scene itself is much better. They also left out dumbledores funeral.
+Kratos2591 dumbledores funeral was when Harry decided he was going to track down the Horcruxes & Ron & Hermione would go with him
In movie harry could have stoped and disobey and could saved Dumbledore, but in book he was freezed by Dumbledore when he was in invisibility cloak
"To the well-organized mind, death is but the next great adventure.” - Dumbledore, Albus. Rip Michael Gambon.
The fact that harry lowered his wand after snape told him too just goes to show that he had trust in snape
I will always remember wheb I first read this scene in the book.
Because I screamed and threw said book out of my window.
woooouuuu I hope you got that book back after.
Damien Loxely he was joking
Or was he? Some say the book is still falling to this day.
Who hit the ground first Dumbledore or The book?
SAME IM NOT KIDDING
That fact the Dumbledore could have taken them all out even without a wand is what really makes this scene even more selfless.
I wish he took them all out instead and we really got to see his power in full swing. We needed to see him in full power, really striking fear into the hearts of the death eaters and voldemort. It would have been so satisfying. Also imo I think a better ending would have been, dumbledore finding a way to cure the curse on his hand, then going into battle with voldy, fatally wounding voldy but then maybe dying to protect someone else here like Harry or Draco. At least then we would see dumbledore go down in a fight
He had to let himself die to protect snape. Voldemort was starting to lose trust in Snape, so this murder was the only "proof" that snape is loyal to voldemort.
He was dying anyway tbf. There was no point.
These two arguably are the most powerful wizards they could have easily token down all the death eaters but it was for a greater cause :( 🥺
Severus Snape is the most well-written character ever.
A lot of people make that argument in a hyperbolic way (not saying you, just a lot of people in general). But no, it actually really is a legitimate claim. He's up there with the all-time greats.
@@MiketheratguyMultimedia he's my favourite antihero.
@@rudraakram3879In fact he is a hero, a martyr even....
And the most well- played....
This hurts so much now that Sir Michael Gambon is no longer with us, RIP 🪦💔
When Draco needs help
*Help will always be given to those who ask for it*
When Harry needs help
*Help will always be given to those who deserve it*
I’m glad Snape helped Dumbledore out and carried out the task set upon him and saved Draco’s life by doing it for him 💚
That "Severus, please" always gets me, especially because of the fact that he's actually asking Severus to kill him, not the opposite
And this is a clue for what truly happened: Dumbledore begged Snape whereas he never pleaded an enemy before.
The look on Snape’s face once he’s killed Dumbledore was amazing. Rickman really showed the full range of emotions in this moment.
One of the finest character actors of his generation - no question. Although he gives a classy, layered performance of astonishing skill without much action or dialogue to work with, I also love him for his near-unique ability to properly ham it up and yet make it work. Just occurred to me how much I'd have loved to have seen him play the Doctor. I'm sure he'd have adored it too if it was available when he was either too young or too successful - by all accounts, despite his record, he always preferred playing the hero to the villain.
Snape is an unsung hero. He always had the most difficult tasks. By difficult I mean difficult by heart.
The hardest thing Snape has ever done.
This is the most powerful scene in the whole movies. Severus is the most bravest wizard of all time, you can hear the pain in his voice when he gives the killing curse. RIP Alan Rickman.
This was a very intense scene. Malfoy and Snape being the victims. None of them wanted this. But, this was essential for the greater good.
I agree
Omigod Rickman’s acting! You can hear the hurt in his voice when he says Avada Kedavra. Poor Snape
RIP Michael Gambon, he was excellent as Dumbledore. Last year, we lost Hagrid and now Dumbledore. 😞
"i have to kill you or he's going to kill me"
actually, if you kill him, you just gave Voldy all the reason to kill you because in his eyes, you own the elder wand and that's what he wants.
Nole I just realized that by doing the deed himself, Snape actually saved Draco's life not once but twice. Draco was unable to bring himself to kill Dumbledore and would've been killed by Voldemort if Snape hadn't stepped in to do it himself. It ended up paying off even more for Draco when Voldemort came to the wrong conclusion that whoever kills the master of the Elder Wand becomes the wand's next master. If Draco had ended up killing Dumbledore, he still would get killed by Voldemort eventually due to Voldemort's belief that killing the owner was how you earned the Elder Wand, not disarming them.
Yeah draco would be screwed even if he did kill dumbledore because we all saw what happened to Snape since he killed dumbledore.
I still hate that they didn't put the battle in the movie. It was important and they left it out, just like Dumbledore's funeral.
Aleksander Järvinen the battle was left because they wanted to save all the action for The Battle of Hogwarts in Deathly Hallows Part 2. They didn't put Dumbledore's funeral in because they thought the scene was too sad and depressing
Too sad and depressing?! WTF is that bullshit
There was already enough drama as it was.
+SuperJackster01
That's such a stupid argument. It's like cutting the Battle of Helm's Deep from The Two Towers, or the Battle of Geonosis from Attack of the Clones. Movies should stand out on their own, and not need another to provide their climax.
Assuming Snape never killed anyone in his years as a Death Eater, his first and only kill was Dumbledore, his one and only friend. The man who redeemed him. You can see his soul being torn to pieces 💔
I think Snape probably still went to a pleasant afterlife when his time came, as Dumbledore had given Snape his blessing to kill him, to spare him from a slow, agonizing death with no hope of survival. It wasn't homicide, it was a mercy killing. That doesn't scar the soul the way murder does.
Severus Snape such a bravest character of all time
Who die for his love
Who refuse to look like good character
Who always protect Harry Potter
Who teach Expellairmus to Harry Potter that He won duel with Voldemort
Who sacrifice himself for Harry Potter
Don’t forget he protected and looked out for Draco and saved his life by killing off dumbledore
He doesn't sacrifice himself for Harry
He sacrifice all those things only for lily
When did he win the duel with Voldemort?
@@MistahSquid i think he meant harry won the duel with voldemort using the spell snape taught him
@@legalkags359 ok
Love how Dumbledore let’s Draco disarm him, and then tries everything to show him that there is a better way.... it’s because he knows he just gave Draco the power to wield the Elder Wand (: Genius
RIP Michael Gambon. He was legendary as Albus Dumbledore.
This hits even harder now. With every passing of a Harry Potter cast member these films are getting harder and more hurtful to watch. 😢
Michael Gambon and Alan Rickman both having the best time up there now I bet. RIP to two of the greatest actors I grew up with.
"Don't feel sorry for the dead, Harry. Have pity on the living. And especially those who live without love."
R.I.P Michael Gambon 😢
This 2023 the actor who played Albus Dumbledore passed away, so now this scene is more real than what we saw. Both the character and his actor died, without forgetting that others such as Robbie Coltrane (Rubeus Hagrid) and Alan Rickman (Severus Snape) also died before him, and many others.
Thanks for everything Sir Michael Gambon.
We will never forget you.
Rest in Peace.
Wands Up for you Albus Dumbledore 1:42
R.I.P Michael Gambon 💔😭
Severus Snape is definitely the bravest character of all movies in all time
Your so right
Sam from lotr
@@ThePixelPodcast he is definitely brave. But not as much as Severus Snape.
Relax
Sir Gambon's recent death made this scene even sadder. 😢
May he RIP (1940-2023)
1:05 the expression on Snape's face though... 'I.. I never wanted any of this Potter, stay silent and hidden, please, for Lily's sake, save yourself anyhow'
And the moment his wand fires the spell... his trembling voice and his pained face.. Alan Rickman was great. Irreplaceable.
1:42 R.I.P. Alan Rickman
So sad that both these amazing actors have now left us..
The scene at 1:53 when Dumbledore falls and the look on his face fall makes my heart cry
Snape and Dumbledore truly the bravest men in HP's universe.
Harry too.
Its sad that in real life he too pass away. No avada kadabra this time. Just sickness n life. Thank u for the memories RIP man, Harry potter is belove by millions, each actir deserves praise for their work n contribution to great movie legacy
So Dumbledore said "Please" as in "Please Do It". Because Snape didn't want to kill Dumbledore. He was Following His orders.
R.I.P Dumbledore. (For real this time.) :(
The only man Voldemort has ever feared is dead.Gone but forever in our wizards heart. Years and years of knowledge and wisdom would never be dead. RIP Micheal gambon.