Ginny Should Have Been In Slytherin | Harry Potter Film Theory
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ส.ค. 2020
- Hurry to upstart.com/scb to find out HOW LOW
your Upstart rate can be!
Today Ben dives into the Wizarding World of Harry Potter to discuss why Ginny Weasley should have been sorted into Slytherin!
Popcorn Culture ::
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
open.spotify.com/show/2fGZ1JL...
#SuperCarlinBrothers #HarryPotter
Carlin Brothers Coffee ►► www.CarlinBrothersCoffee.com
Super Carlin Brothers Merch ►► www.SuperCarlinBrothers.Store
J vs Ben ►► bit.ly/2I5xHee
Harry Potter Theories ►► bit.ly/2K2Rtru
Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
FOLLOW US:
P A T R E O N ➜ / supercarlinbrothers
J's V L O G➜ / jonathancarlin
T W I T T E R➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
I N S T A G R A M➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
F A C E B O O K➜ / supercarlinbrothers
G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Want to send us something?
Super Carlin Brothers
PO Box 4339
Roanoke, Virginia 24015
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Intro Music Created by RKVC
/ @rkvc
Intro Animation Created by J. Cutt Productions
/ @j.cuttproductions
Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..) - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
![Why Harry & Hermione Should Be Together [Harry Potter Theory]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/2J5AoNkTams/mqdefault.jpg)
![[HIGHLIGHT] หมีLIVEปะ? | EP.171 เห็นแต่ในจอ วันนี้มาต้องขอคารวะ](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/gPWLxa0e_Z8/mqdefault.jpg)
Who is the most redeemable Slytherin?
DRACO FIGHT ME edit: first comment can I have a cookie 2nd edit: Thank you for all the likes most I ever got 3rd edit: Sing it with me SNAPE SNAPE SEVRUS SNAPE
Narcissa Malfoy?
Draco
Draco for sure
Slughorn as he never did anything wrong really.
The sorting hat probably got so tired of sorting weasleys so he didn't bother to check if she really should go in gryffindor
Yeah.
"another Weasley eh? I know just what to do with you... GRYFFINDOR" yea definitely too tired
A few generations later it's renamed the weasley house and the colors are changed to Orange and gold
Most definitely lol. The sorting hat was probably like okay gryffindor like the rest of them.
Why didn't it put Percy in Slytherin? It should have been less tired of the Weasleys back then, lol.
“Harry Potter is aimed for younger audiences like from 6 to 100” yes very young
😉
To the queen that is very young
It’s true though
nice profile picture
@@SuperCarlinBrothers Random question: could you make a Percy Jackson video sometime?
I would appreciate it.
Am now a passionate Ginny-in-slytherin activist. Just think of the *slow burn* with her and Harry, or how Luna would have been one of the first to accept Ginny and not care about her house...
Me too, it would have been more interasting.
@@katrinaillig4355 lol, I was hoping someone would recommend a fic. Thanks
Yeah it would make sense in many cases. Like why harry and ginny didnt get together earlier than the 5th book despite her liking him would be much easier explainable with houses between them. Ginny getting together with him in the 5th part is with her being a weasly and therefore likey to be in Dumbledores army still the expected outcome after harry getting to know her not as weasly or slytherin but individual. I like this scenario much more, since it explains the akwardness while having a better build up to overcoming these houses/lines.
Also even Ron being annoyed of her dating would work fantastic with her dating fellow slytherins :D
Or how she could be friends with Malfoy, Like the first years the will definitely hate each other but Starting from Dracos 4th year where they get along and In Ginny's 4th year she will be friends with Malfoy. That would make it more interesting
@@katrinaillig4355 I too would like to tbhank you. I was holding there was a fic with this scenario
"There are no good Slytherins"
Merlin: That's fine, I'm great.
Technically, Merlin was hand picked by salazar, not sorted by the hat. I guess we'll never know where he would've been sorted into.
@@sheirmicrobe1957 Slytherin. The hat is basically a quasi-horcrux with all the founders imprinted on it. How the hat sorts is how the founders would have sorted, special cases like Harry's aside.
Snape !! Have you seen the last movie or read the book because he is good
@@GreysAholic he really only fixed his own own errors with a ton of people dying. Also he leaked the prophecy to voldemort. Also he continuously abused possibly 100s of students as a teacher. If I save you from drowning after throwing you in water am I in that case a hero? No. Neither is Snape. He fixed his biggest mistake but all in all, he has caused more harm than good. I am willing to hear counter arguments
@@GreysAholic Except for the fact that in the book he wasn't doing good things because he is good, he was doing them out of selfish reasons (i.e. his love for Lilly). And even ignoring that, he was a still a Death Eater/practiced Dark Arts for a solid while, so no, he does not classify as a good Slytherin
"We never get any Slytherins who aren't ever bad."
Andromeda Tonks who literally abandoned her family and their pureblood ideals to marry a muggleborn: "Am I a joke to you?!?"
@Feef the Beef yes
@@sirmurford2737 what are you talkng about ....
@@dog-md7wh someone deleted their reply
@Brooks Parsons Nymphadora, Andromeda's daughter, was a Hufflepuff.
@Elizabeth Dooley see response to Brooks. Andromeda was a Slytherin. Nymphadora was a Hufflepuff.
Also why wasn’t Percy in Slytherin like he’s the most ambitious and cunning of all the Weasley‘s it would’ve been amazing representation to have a good character be a Slytherin
And he wouldn’t have had as much pressure on him since he was only the third son
TheNinthGeneration yesss
"a good character". Yeah right Percy was straight up a traitor.
HAD848 Games That’s true but according to one of the super Carlin brothers theories they believe he was under the imperious curse which I also believe what I just meant was that he had very few Gryffindor characteristics and would’ve done better in Slytherin in my opinion
agreed. I think Percy had a lot more slytherin in him than he did gryffindor.
ok but literally everyone ALWAYS forgets Andromeda Tonks (Black), she was a slytherin and a very good one, she didn't like her family's morals and always fought against them. i love her and think her character is very interesting
And Regulus Black
@@frankg2790 regulus black turned into a death eater and was very supportive of his family. in the seventh book kreature talks about how he only took the horcruxe out of anger to the dark lord for almost killing kreature and trapping him. he realized the dark lord really didn’t care about anything but himself. but i also just read that part in the book and i used to think he was better than is shown in the books
She basically is a extra character, only got 2 line of dialogue she is forgettable
@@abhishekroy4945 true, and i don't remember her being in the movies. but i still think she deserves some credit
So what? One person had to totally reject all the "pure blood mania nonsense" to escape being just as evil as Bellatrix? And that's the argument that not all Slytherins are evil? OK. But, Slytherin House is totally racist and evil, even if there are some good Slytherins (a distinct minority) who rebel against all that teaching and manage to become good people.
Forget about Ginny - I always thought *Dumbledore* should be a Slytherin, especially knowing how ambitious he was during his childhood, when he was sorted. It would be even better than with Ginny, finding that DUMBLEDORE, the literal perfect, wise, good role-model, turned out to be a Slytherin in the sixth book or something. It would also give Harry a good deal to think about after Dumbledore's death. It would just be so perfect!
I love this theory
That would be good
honestly my headcanon is that Dumbledore did the same thing Harry did and asked not to be put into slytherin; or to be put into gryiffindor
It’s bc he’s a descendent of Godrick
Whenever I thought of that I always thought of Harry's line to Albus being changed in a way. You were named after two headmasters of Hogwarts, they were in Slytherin but were the bravest people I knew. I like to think that Hermione would smack him in the head and Ron would laugh.
Ben: “Very funny, popular, tough, charming...
Harry: “and she’s got nice skin.”
Abdulrahman Tabbaa 😂
Lest we forget! Haha!
Ron: yOu liKE mY sIStEr beCaUSe shE’s gOt nICe sKIn
"My best friend's sister reminds me of my mom so much. I'm gonna tap that so hard!" ~Harry, apparently.
@@cristinaaliperti1410 "I mean it's a contributing factor."
F to pay respects to Ginny. Cause of death: the movies killed her character.
boy did they ever....
How right you are
Fffffffffffffffffff they ruined her character!
They made her so awkward and annoying ugh! Why couldn’t we get book Ginny :(
@@lynebeth because we never got book Snape
Could you just imagine Ginny and Harry competing with each other to catch the snitch?! Iconic.
Ginny’s s*** talk would have been much better than Malfoy’s.
But wouldn't ginny be chaser and malfoy be seeker?
@@ruhika9435 You're probably right. Although poor Malfoy is always seen as a bad seeker just because HARRY IS SO MUCH STINKING BETTER THAN HIM. Poor Malfoy though bless him bless him.
@@ruhika9435 Yeah, like the previous comment, if Ginny had been in Slytherin, she would have replaced Malfoy as a Seeker. She is simply better, and I think Flint and Warrington would have placed Malfoy as Chaser instead. Malfoy is good, but Ginny is not only better, but also would have had a psychological advantage, after all she is the sister or crush of half of Gryffindor Quidditch team, not their most hated schoolmate like Draco Malfoy.
If you want to see Harry and Ginny competing for the snitch, I'd recommend watching SuperCarlinBrothers "What if Harry was in Slytherin?" series.
Technically Harry should have been in slytherin but then again he wanted to be in griffindor so this was probably the same case for Ginny as she wanted to be with her siblings and crush.
You could argue the main four kind of map each of the houses into Griffyndor: Ron is Griffyndor-Griffyndor, Hermione is Griffyndor-Ravenclaw, Neville is Griffyndor-Hufflepuff, and Harry is Griffyndor-Slytherin
Nah harry definitely shouldnt have been in slytherin, the sorting hat was only considering that because of voldemorts soul, the sorting hat wouldnt have put him in gryffindor if he really didnt believe it was the right place for him though.
@@mreevee7785Very good point however that doesn’t take away from the fact that the sorting hat doesn’t take your choice into consideration, so my point remains with Ginny!
From the books, it becomes obvious that the sorting hat sensed the part of Voldemort inside Harry.
@@just_me0719 neville wasn't a hatstall. He just briefly argued with the hat before it shut him up by placing him where it preferred
If she preferred Gryffindor over Slytherin then the Sorting Hat probably took that into account, like it did for Harry. And why wouldn't she? All her brothers and her crush are in that house. But yeah, thematically it would make a stronger story, and allow the books to grow beyond the stark good vs evil setup (which they did a little bit in the later books). And also really cement Harry as a well-developed character that overcame initial prejudices and learned to trust those he once wrote off as bad (again this growth is demonstrated somewhat in the later books with befriending Slughorn, and realizing Snape's role in his destiny, but for a childrens series could have been more overt).
@They_Call_Me_ Pebbles and screw Albus
There could have been motivations for her to prefer a house that her family wasn't from. Wanting to stick out and not conform with the expectations of her etc. But it wouldn't have worked unless they reworked the story a lot to accommodate things. Even Ron had issues with feeling invisible in his huge family. It wouldn't be unreasonable for someone in the family to want to become their own person rather than a product of their family's legacy.
the sorting hat does not acually take into account what you want. It makes it seem like it does but he the hat really doesnt
Mr. HoneyComb the sorting hat is a fraud lol
mmmmm so true.
Alternate Title: Ben mocking Harry Potter characters for 13 minutes straight
Everything wrong with harry potter characters in 11 minutes or less, BEN edition
13 minutes
lol
Molly Clare
3:53
5:18
6:48
8:19
No no that’s the name of the CHANNEL
We just need the Carlin Bros to write an entire “What If” Harry Potter series where everything is as it should have been.
I would've loved a slytherin ally. Additionally, I would've liked to see more dark wizards from various houses. The only house that probably would have the least or no dark wizards would've been hufflepuff. Bravery and Justice take too far turns into a crusade or witch hunt. Knowledge taken too far turns into Dr Mengele or Unit 731. I supposed loyalty and love taken too far would be what happened to Queenie, so even hufflepuffs have a weakness to darkness.
Ambition when channeled right can be a force for good.
loyalty and love when given to the wrong person can be very dangerous. My headcanon is that Belatrix could've/should've been a hufflepuff because of how loyal she is to voldemort and that would show that when given to the wrong person, loyalty can lead to evil
Loyalty is literally the most likely to be manipulated into evil than any of the others.
Only Slyrherins being evil is indicative of Rowlings 6th grade understanding of basic morality and human psychology.
Hogwarts Legacy did a much better job making the houses seem somewhat nuanced.
I'm just imagining about how Ginny would be in Slytherin and how the other Slytherins are like "I know she's a Weasley, therefore, extremely poor and loves muggles so much, but she IS a pureblood" and, like, accepts her being in the house but not accept her as a part of the house. I would actually not be surprise if Ginny ended up spending her years in Hogwarts striving to prove that her family isn't as bad as what her fellow Slytherins may think. I also think that she may attract the attention and respect of some of her housemates. Which she could potentially use to convince some Slytherins to fight for Hogwarts because that was what's right.
That's pretty great as an idea.
Shame that, by the way the Sorting Hat works, it was pretty much a foregone conclusion that she'd end up in Gryffindor, even if she happened to be similarly suited (or even more suited) for Slytherin. The pressure of her entire family behind her would make her lean towards Gryffindor, especially hearing the bad rep they have. It might be different if her home life was unpleasant, but as pointed out by Ben, she comes from a fairly loving and fun family. TBH, she'd have to be either an actual bad person, or just a really contrary person to 'switch sides' as it were, at the age of 11.
Just one of those cases where it would be thematically interesting and work well in that respect, but just wouldn't make sense in the context of the setting it takes place in.
@Brian Cairns yeah, it would have probably been more meaningful, like, they know all Death Eaters are Slytherins but what if those with non-Death Eater parents that was convinced by Ginny to help fight for Hogwarts? Having all four houses fight against one foe probably like their founders before Salazar parted ways with the others.
How many here that commented is SLYTHERIN house?!?... ;)
It’d be funny if Malfoy was the only one who initially had a problem with her. Then their relationship would improve starting with him noticing her Quidditch potential.
And I'm convinced she would actually thrive eventually in Slytherin. She's strong, determined and sticks up for herself. So I believe that she would find friends in Slytherin that share some of her beliefs in the end.
Harry:*exists*
Snape: “Ima bully this child”
hippty hoppity your childhood is now my property XD
Always
Turn to page 394
Not so fast potter
'loss if limp is not going to be an excuse, potter'
Tbh I see a lot of similarities between Ginny and Bellatrix. Good vs evil aside, they're both very powerful female characters, extremely dedicated to their respective causes, highly intelligent and skilled witches, and both incredibly confident and witty. And I absolutely agree with everything you said in this video.
Edit: Also Fred & George Weasley were such an incredible fit for Slytherin. Going after their dream despite their mother's anger? Hiss hiss b*tches!
Yes, Ginny could have been put in Slytherin, mostly because of her personality traits of which link up harmoniously with Slytherin traits but also since she technically is a pureblood of which is a highly-priced thing in Slytherin house.
Yep.
Highly priced.
Pure-bloods, starting at 100 Galleons. Make your bids.
3300
A character who was in Slytherin who wasn't bad initially I would argue is Andromeda Black. Yes we don't know much about her but she grew up in one of the worst supremacist pure-blood families with Bellatrix and Narcissa as her sisters and being brainwashed but she realised that muggleborns were just like them and even married one, Ted Tonks. She let Harry, Hermione and Ron stay at her house during the second wizarding war and raised Remus' and Tonks' son. I would love to know more about her, but I believe she is a good example of a good Slytherin.
Omg yes i completly forgot about her. There is a fan film on yt the sisters of house black so you can check it out if you like Andromeda
And theres also this song on yt that i used to listen to like 100 times a day about "the noblle and most ancient house of black" but you probs dont care lol
@@marina1036 I've actually seen the film and loved it! All three of the Black sisters were super interesting. Will definitely listen to the song you recommended :)
@@Katmiobeth yeah they played characters so good in that movie like-
I agree. She never cared about a lot of her family’s beliefs just like Sirius.
“By the time we get to the Cursed Child -” yes, but I thought we agreed never to speak of that
Thank you
Always.
There is no Cursed Child in Ba Sing Se
The play which must not be named
Ben said later that it didn't count
You guys literally made the PERFECT case for Ginny to be in Slytherin and I couldn't agree more! It would have made so much sense for the plot and story line, to prove that Slytherins are not all bad, it would have been fun to see one of the Weasleys sorted in to a different house and Harry and Ginny's relationship would be so much better!!
Same I agree
there was a deleted scene when Draco throws Harry a wand when he comes back to life. But J.K made them cut it.
Which literally makes no sense seeing as they had a scene in go deathly hallows pt 1 where he took draco's wand
Good.Then there's actually one thing "good" jk did in supervising the crappy movies.
And she made the right desition Drako never help Harry, Harry had de wand hidden, and really DRako wasnt a real deatheather yes thats true but he wasnt brave,
"We dont have any Slytherin who hasnt been bad"
The disrespect to Andromeda Tonks is high
More than that to Hagrid
@@vishakhakumari1243 no?
@@vishakhakumari1243 Hagrid is a gryffindor
Tonks was Hufflepuff, at least according to Harry Potter: A Hogwarts Mystery game
Edit: realized a few comments down, you were talking about her mother.
Not to mention Horace Slughorn, who was the freakin Head of Slytherin House before Snape. He wasn’t evil
Ben: We never get a fully good Slytherin
Andromeda Tonks: Am I a joke to you?
True
oh yeah...
I thought she was a Hufflepuff, or have I been reading too much fanfic? Is there a canon source that she was in Slytherin?
Robin Baylor yes she’s definitely a slytherin
@@robinbaylor2672 Her husband was a Hufflepuff. So was her daughter. But she was a Slytherin.
I love the idea of Ginny in Slytherin. Imagine the changes in the chemistry of their relationships.
Love it...Harry and Ginny could also have had the whole Romeo and Juliet archetype of lovers from rival houses instead of whatever cringe they had going on with her tying her shoelaces and feeding him cookies like his grandma or something. I feel like both Percy and Ginny should have been Slytherins on second thought. Would have made the Weasleys less one note too. It's just so weird how everything in Harry Potter is family this lineage that. Very hivemind.
Idk, I feel like Percy should've been a Ravenclaw. Yes, Percy is very ambitious but Slytherins have this quality of sticking together till the very end. Now, we all know about Percy...
TH-cam getting real comfortable with these double double ads.
Ikr
It’s free content, so I feel bad complaining
I got zero ads
@@keithmarlowe623 lucky I want that
TH-cam Is Doing Coffee Ads,Now?
Out of context but I was thinking:
If Mad-Eye can see the Bogart inside the cupboard (5th book) then he is the only one that knows the true form of the Bogart.
Yeah i thought of that too many times and i think yes coz bogart cant see him so cant turn into his fear
Wizards think muggles are dumb, but all they’d have to do to see the true form of a bogart is put a camera in with it 💀
Yeah ive always thought about that when reading that scene
Tbh, I kinda support this. If Ginny was a Slytherin, Chamber or Secrets could’ve been so much more epic and understandable. It also would’ve been nice to see Ginny play Seeker against Harry and possibly blindside him, thus gaining some respect.
Heck, maybe she even could’ve been a door for other Slytherins when Dumbledore’s Army was meeting.
At this point I think there needs to be a mass fan-fic rewrite of the Harry Potter series
I'll do it!
@@Pizzaonda_water Have you started? :P
@@veni5126 Actually... I forgot abt this the entire time. But I managed to get an AO3 acc, so maybe. Schoolwork and other things are keeping me busy tho. I'll try!
Battle of Hogwarts, Harrys jumping around dodging curses, back up against the wall, all hope lost. "Expelliarmus! Training for the ballet Potter?" "Malfoy?"
"It's Draco, and don't sound so surprised"
oh no, here come the fanfics
but for real why didn't this happen, actually would have been iconic
@@Chaimelo I can feel them being written already! Definitely should have happened!
It didn't happen because Rowling hates the idea of Draco being a good character
This gave me goosebumps!
And then they kiss. And shag. Here come the fanfics
"Harry Potter is aimed for younger audiences, like from 6 to 100"
That feeling when you're 101 but still like Harry Potter... #OldAgeProblems
Ikr man
No you're not allowed to like hp anymore
@@lilyofthevalley9566 J.K. Rowling may be a transphobe and yes it's horrible, but you can still like the HP series
@@KeepCalmContemplateYourChoices I'm pretty sure they're joking
@@pinetree1767 yeah i'm pretty sure now too, it was 2 am when I wrote that don't judge me
This theory could still work in the books, if we remember the Sorting Hat takes into consideration your choices. Ginny could have been a prime candidate for Slytherin but because she chose to be in Gryffindor, if she was between two houses like a lot of the main cast.
Edit; I do still love the idea the theory has of actually placing her in Slytherin as how cool it could have been in the narrative.
honestly i do wish jk rowling did try and add some more "good slytherins" instead of making them all sound like villains. as for ginny i think she could have done well in slytherin . i have been re-reading the entire series and i feel hermoine should have been in ravenclaw she shows more traits to ravenclaw then she does griffyndor, fred, george, and sadly percy should have been in slytherin as well. the twins were clever, determined and resourceful. percy had more leadership skills and ambition, so i feel that if jk rowling had done this it would have showed the lesson i got out of the book. it is your actions that define who you are not the house you come from. interesting video
Another good way that the books could have done the "there are good Slytherins" thing, is by making the other Hogwarts champion a Slytherin during the Triwizard Tournament. Just think about it, after Harry gave them the clue about the dragons they would like throw a note a Harry giving him a tip about the mermaids cause they have seen them under the lake swiming past their common room windows every now and then since they were 11. The Slytherin Champion would also not agree to a tie, but just happen to touch the cup at the same time and fight with Harry until they couldn't. At the end of year feast the Slytherins would morn and the next year this would cause some of them to realize that Voldy was actually back. Some of them could even join the DA and the next year they could even teach some of the first years how to act like they were under the cruciotis curse, so they didn't have to get hurt. The Slytherins could also band together with the rest of the school when Voldy attacks. (like imagine some of the kids facing off against their parents, so cool!) Hogwarts isn't just home to three of the houses it is home to all four.
Disclaimer: This isn't my original idea, it was originally posted by stabatha-says
This would have been awesome!
I like this idea better than the idea of Ginny Weasley ending up in Slytherin.
Someone should make a fanfic about that lol
I think your idea is really good but at the same time I love that it was a Hufflepuff. I feel that is it was a Slytherin then everything is just Gryffindor v Slytherin. I wish we got to see more of the Ravenclaws.
I already knew this idea. I really like Cedric as a champion representing Hufflepuff's strenghts. But a Slytherin would be so much more bridge-building. When he got killed by Voldemorts. This would encourage Slytherins to join the fight against Voldemort even though their fathers might be deatheaters. Additionally, Harry and the other Gryffindors would hate Slytherin less?
Harry never had classes with Ravenclaws because he was not in the honors or advanced track. Just my thoughts on the matter.
Or we were reading in our dorm/magicing the knowledge directly into our heads
I went to 4 high schools, 3 Jr. Highs and a dozen elementary schools. It's not as uncommon as people might think.
Hermione has arithmancy and ancient runes or stuff with ravenclavs.
@@kathzemiau7234 aka the advanced track core curriculum
@@chrisbeaty3572 I agree, I have been in advanced classes for school in third grade and we get our own separate class so that people under our level don't get left behind and we are not being held back.
If she was in Slytherin then i feel when Molly says “Not my daughter you **tch” it would have had a great impact to ginny like her mother didn’t care what house she was in and she meant a lot to her regardless.
I think the only reason that Ginny was not sorted into Slytherin, was because- like Harry- the sorting hat took their preferences into consideration when they could have been a good fit for either house. Due to all the things you mentioned, Ginny would certainly have had a psychological aversion to Slytherin.
To add to your theory:
Had Ginny been sorted into Slytherin, she could have convinced that entire house to stand up to the Death Eaters, during the Battle of Hogwarts. Along with knowing how to perform a Patronus charm, she could have rallied her entire house, making the conflict a lot more fascinating for the fans.
And she'd join DUmbledore's Army, I'm sure of that. Given that she'd probably still be popular, she would be able to convince other Slytherins to join it as well and it could change a lot.
I'm here for this theory
i would not say he could rally entire house, but most likely half of them
Yeah, I always wanted someone good to be in a slytherin house especially when they first formed the Dumbledore's army... Why is there no Slytherin in there...?
@@zellrang if you're looking for an interesting fan fic that includes this, check out Dumbledores Army and the Year of Darkness where a Slytherin joins in year 7.
That could've been a mirror of Snape and Lily, but this time, Ginny being able to uphold good values. and the two of them, finally ending with each other.
OMG YES
Yesssss
snape doesn’t deserve lily, he disrespected her wishes on multiple occasions and even called her a mudblood. he also abused her one and only son ✌🏾
@@jesussaves5692 Like James deserved Lily? Pretty sure Snape deserved her more than James did
@@andersphilipsen4352 well... just one of them wasnt a death eater so...
It always made me feel a little weird that every single main hero character was in Gryffindor. I know Gryffindor has manty heroic traits and all but it wouldve been cool to see at least on ene of the main bunch in a different house. Ginny has many Slytherin traits and I think she would've been awesome in Slytherin but she probably wanted to be a Gryffindor, all her family had been in taht house for ages. Instead of putting all the hero's in Gryffindor, I wish they did better with houses like Slytherin, especially for a character as ambitious and powerful as Ginny. I was so relieved that Luna was a ravenclaw
Yeah, but I think the problem would be that people usually stick with whoever they're put with. So idk if Hermione was put in Ravenclaw, she probably wouldn't become close friends with Harry. So since the main character is in Gryffindor, he'd still take most of the screen time. But Ginny as his love interest from Slythering could be in my opinion totally awesome.
I'll be honest I think it could add a lot more depth and background to the characters in Slytherin. Y'all should do a What if Ginny was in Slytherin!
Honestly a lot of the weasely’s could’ve fit into Slytherin. Fred and/or George would’ve fit in there given how they’re very ambitious about starting their shop and pranks and since they were often very “left out” from the family due to their different “ambitions”. Percy is very Slytherin about getting into high job in the ministry. And from a storytelling point Percy being a slytherin would’ve made his betrayal and subsequent return very poetic in my opinion
point about Percy is kinda cool
Woah woah spoilers
Ok but imagine, it’s the battle of Hogwarts and Harry gets backed up against a wall and Draco runs past Harry and they sorta lock eyes and Draco hesitates. Harry then think he’s gonna run off but instead Draco disarms Harry’s opponent, and then helps him up saying, “scared potter?” and Harry replies, “you wish,” and that’s the start of dracos redemption arc.
Edit: people seem to like this so imma add some more ;)
After this, Draco and Harry run together trying to find Ron and Hermione. They eventually run into the two and when Ron and Hermione see that the two boys are together and civil, Hermione drops the basilisk fangs that she is holding and Ron brandishes one as a sword, both of their mouths are wide open in shock.
“Can we, uh, talk about this later?” Harry asks sheepishly, Ron and Hermione slowly nod their heads before coming out of shock, Hermione is the first of the two to say anything,
“It seems like you both are finally embracing inter-house unity,” she says with small smile.
“It seems we are Granger,” Draco says slowly, “Trust me when I say, my father won’t hear about this,”
They all share a small laugh together before splitting up and going to fight for their freedom...
Omg thats wonderful!!!!!
Only a dream ;(
yessss and then this would bring it back from cos I would love that do much
If only 😭😭😭
this is perfect. please suggest this to JK Rowling
I think this would have made a much more interesting character development! I honestly wish they’d fleshed out the other houses waaaay more than they did.
Maybe all the Ravenclaws go to special classes, and that is why Harry never goes to classes with them
Ben: “There were no actually true good Slytherin.”
Merlin: Am I a joke to you?
Also Mad-Eye and Andromeda Black Tonks
Who's Merlin? Doesn't exist.
Tico Tran okay,nice,bye
Tico Tran Merlin's Beard!
How do you know he was good?
I don’t know about Ginny just yet, but Percy is definitely a Slytherin.
Definitely, he is a weasel
@@methos9167 I think you mean wertherby
I thought you meant Percy Jackson and got extremely confused.
I also thought Percy Jackson 😅😅
Nah Peter Johnson is a hufflepuff. Because I said so. And annabeth is 100% a ravenclaw. Sue me
Me: Tries to sleep
Also me: Thinks of Voldemort
My brain the next second: DE HE HE HE
When you know, you know
I imagine after the 19 years later scene, when Harry, Ginny, and Lily leave King's Cross, Ginny tells Harry that the Sorting Hat considered putting her in Slytherin but she took chose Gryffindor. Something she had never told anyone, either.
*Ben with an annoyed voice* : “Always”
Love it
Yes! This gives me so muvh live!
Wasn’t Tonk’s mother a Slytherin? She was a Black before marrying her muggle born husband. She was a nice pure blood who also showed you did have to follow your family’s ideals.
Luis Nava andromeda was a slytherin
and is a huuuuuge part of the main plot
I think she started out sharing her family's ideals though, so wasn't good from the start. She changed after meeting Ted and realizing her family was wrong
Yeah and while at one point she may have agreed with her family she did help in the war and had to have been a decent person to even consider giving Ted a chance. Even if she was mean at one point I think she’s an example of a good slytherin that I’d have loved to see more of in the books and movies.
When you said " fizzing whizbeez!" I heard it in my head with the inflection of Dr. Brown saying " Great scott!"
I think the Ravenclaws have advanced learning classes so they aren't with the other students.
Ya know I personally think the twins wouldve been slytherin, i mean they did like start a busness and worked really hard. or even better, one was in slytherin one was in gryffindor and they just liked switched ties and still pulled pranks all the time. And it'd just show some love to slytherin and it'd show inter house friendships
I think they would've fit well in ravenclaw. They were incredibly brilliant and the existence of Luna proves that you don't have to be the stereotypical bookworm to be a ravenclaw.
While that would be fun, they were presented as always inseparable (like, their entire lives), so I don't think they would've accepted being sorted into different houses
Here’s a question: If Harry’s parents were killed Halloween night; Uncle Vernon goes to work the next morning (seeing the funny people in robes, the owls, and etc) but Harry isn’t on the doorstep. In the third book Hagrid speaks how he found Harry in the ruins and pulled him out. (Pg 206) That was Halloween Night, The first book starts on (Nov 1) but Harry is left on the step that night and found (Nov 2) Where was Harry for those 24 hours? Was he chillin with Hagrid? 😅 (May be a plot hole but might be interesting?)
maybe it was the travel time or maybe they wanted to get Harry checked out at St Mungo’s? I think it seems a plausible thing Dumbledore and McGonagall would do
I think they say it took them a day to get their
If they placed him on the doorstep between 3-5 am, where most people sleep. It was a freezing autumn night. And the next day was a sunday. How long do muggles sleep on sundays? Irresponsible
@@kathzemiau7234 fine day, sunday. Why is that, Dudley?
@@connieknight9077 No post?
*"All hands on deck, Granger."* Is my favourite HP movie quote. That being said, I also think Horace Slughorn is the most redeemable Slytherin.
Someone at Carlin Brothers discovered Stable Diffusion and is having a field day with the new thumpnails. Really good stuff guys, keep them coming =)
The sorting hat just heard the name Weasley and put every single one of them in Gryffindor.
“Story telling BLAH”
Me explaining the technical parts of my writing.
The reason Jinne didn't get into slytherin is the same Hermione didnt get to ravenclaw, or Harry to slytherin, they just didn't want to. The sorting hat never ignores your wish to avoid a house!
Exactly
In the cursed child.
I thought Hermione was fine with Ravenclaw or Gryffindor
Great video! Keep up the good work😃
I think Ginny being in Slytherin would have been such an interesting storytelling point. Not only would it add more dynamics to the story, but I think it would also open many more doors for character relatability. Personally, I didn't like Ginny as much as a character (she's cool but she isn't my absolute favorite). If she was sorted into Slytherin, she could have challenged any and all views that Harry had about Slytherin. And for me personally, him falling in love with her because of her prowess would make their love feel less forced; she wouldn't feel like a convenient romantic option. Given, yes, even in Gryffindor she had her own way of showing her prowess, but I don't know...she didn't really stand out to me.
If you're interested in this, I'd really recommend the fanfic Changeling which does exactly this and tells a story of the 7th year at Hogwarts. I really enjoyed it as there are enough changes that it feels like a different story, but doesn't disrupt book canon in terms of major events. It's here: m.fanfiction.net/s/6919395/1/The-Changeling?__cf_chl_jschl_tk__=b267775311b5b13d07f99637b7498b184d37f19f-1610015434-0-Afe4eUxpkmGa2WKFsz0wXAl1o9xeiump510GVmwojNHy4JuWJlg59gaarVx6wNfmKQSl82IEWZDmWdK1P_c5JDK5BKCzwDbr_EsSBAYCmneO0N4-zTU0Q1GX27jwJGJ_slxkf3oVjcTLi17k-v33xHOowrEu77oft5Ch7Dy06QfDio7pXwhpgJXuZRpBx5wC8ffM4NH0e9Z6MRvYMkiKW79dxK-f1xsO0-ECKb1hcLHzC0nPhYWq7Z1PpwMRmDX1dO0oBCsCwzX8VHf2hbNzgHWCrHyGGjszYfUvYIg_lB2LqzWVwm8_NMsyNv-Lz7xashR8K5b-3vyuW7HtB9lHMD6FLRHhsnwPDD_uNCTyfyBq_b0uZTDbo26uDr2IfzdTiL9H6OYoYm83mug6hs1QlW4
@@annaruddock6931 I started reading it
I mean.... if ginny was In slytherin I might actually ship her with Harry
I agree. In the books we are told several times that Ginny did something cool or interesting after the fact (for example Slughorn saying that he saw her cast a particularly good bat-boogey hex on the train) but when things are actually happening she isn't shown/said to really do much.
I doubt you read the books, If you read the books you would know how intresting Ginny was.And the relation between Harry and Ginny are not forced(in books), it was one of the most interesting relationship in the whole Harry potter series.Ginny was one of my favorite character,In the books she was brave, clever, confident, talented, and beautiful (even appreciated by the Slytherin girl Pancy Parkinson). I never forgive the dump movies for making her bad as much as possible by changing her into a new character. (SHOELACE)
Ginny- "if you've got enough nerve" also could mean bravery....
But continue.
Zero Wolf agreed. Could you imagine how brave she had to have been to break into the quidditch closet knowing the temper of molly Weasley? Total griffindor that child is.
@@bethanyplatt3882 I believe she could have gone either way. Cause she would also have to have been cunning to not let anyone know about it.
I believe she could have been a hat stall if she wasn't a "weasley" and fine with being a weasley. Where as sirius didn't seem happy at his family and didnt like them, which probably prompted the hat to choose gryffindor for him. It takes guts to split from that type of toxic family.
When I read this title, I was sure the video would be about the fact that Ginny was probably starting to be under Voldy's control at her sorting ceremony. She already had the diary, probably tried it out, and may have fallen slightly under its control by then. Also, would being slightly possessed by an evil spirit have been enough to set off the main hall ceiling's deception detector?
I wish there had been more of a redemption story for Draco, like a Zuko type of long form redemption
The sorting hat isn't about what the child's traits are but what they value above all. This is why Ginny and Hermione were sorted into Griffindor rather than Slytherin or Ravenclaw, respectively.
Then Percy should have most definitely been in Slytherin
Lets be honest here, they were sorted to be close to Harry :P
It's something that he thought would make sense and improve and add to the plot
riiigght because hermine doesnt value knowledge/learning above else...
i mean sure she has courage but give her the choice between the courageus thing and the smart thing to do and she will 100% pick the smart thing.
“Slytherin’s aren’t necessarily bad” -said by a Slytherin. Honestly in the base books it’s really quite a hard stretch to say a slytherin isn’t evil or bad. IF they weren’t all bad, there should have been many more diverse Slytherins in Harry’s year. It’s one of the weakest parts of the writing and the overall continuity. I think the books went horribly wrong with the direction it went for both slytherin and hufflepuff and it would have been much more interesting if this main friend group came from different houses. If Harry loved someone from a different house. I find it so hard to believe JK Rowling when she talks about adoring the other houses because if that was true, you’d think she would have written more about them.
This might be because of sampling bias. Outside of Draco and his group, how many Slytherins do we see from Harry's year?
Remember, almost all of the Slytherin students came back to help defend their school at the Battle of Hogwarts.
And my apologies for replying a month later. I just got this video in my feed. :)
Absolutely agree. It woulda been way better if we’d seen some more of the other houses like it would have been so interesting to see Harry befriend one of the slytherins (for example Theodore nott or Daphne Greengrass who I don’t really remember having a big part in the books) while still having a rivalry with Draco. Would have also been nice to see either Ginny or Ron in a different house. She was absolutely biased towards gryffindors and I wish the main group had not just been in the same house or we had seen more friends from other houses.
SCORPIUS
@@jan.akisa.
Wasn’t albus a slytherin too? I don’t really know much about cursed child but he seemed good
But Harry did love Cho.
Everytime I watch your videos, I update my head- and wishcanon! This would have been awesome!!!
“We never get a fully good slytherin” did you forget about slughorn?
Percy should've been in slytherin too.
I mean come on! He is the living example of ambition, and power hungry! (Nothing against slytherin)
Crimson Bishop im-Percy-us!!!
To be honest, the only House that didn't match Percy at all was Hufflepuff. Both Ravenclaw and Slytherin would have been more suitable for him than Gryffindor.
No offense taken
“There were no actually good Slytherins."
Yeah, that's because certain sOmEoNe hates Slytherin, so it kinda reflects on the characters.
If you actually look at the characters, there are some good Slytherins and it would make sense that a lot of bad guys are in Slytherin,if you look at the traits that they value a villain would most likely have them,now I am not saying that everyone with those traits are evil at all (you need to have at least some ambition in your life) or that all villains have them (a lot of them do but not all),and the only house with zero villains in it is Hufflepuff.
@@melindamelton5612 i'm pretty sure there are bad Hufflepuff too but JK Rowling lied because that's her favourite house, they just don't say it because they want to be taken seriously and the others think they useless. They would be awesome death eaters, truly loyal and hard-working. Voldemort worked with Greyback and Pettegrew, he would have taken some Hufflepuff, there are the best spies ever ! No one suspects a Puff. If you think of Bellatrix, she claimed herself as the most loyal, the most faithful to the Dark Lord. We know she had worked hard to be useful to her master. She wanted to be the best not for her own archievement, that second, she wanted to be the best to help her master's purpose. She became his first lieutenant because she put Voldemort before herself, before her freedom, before her care. That's NOT a Slytherin thing. Diligence
= Yes, Dedication = yes, Fairness, in her view of blood purity, yes, she truly thinks mudblood are less than pureblood. After her, it's fair pure blood have privileges because they are born in a magical family. Patience and Kindness, do you see her with Narcissa ? She's not the same person. That's the problem with people like her, she kind with people who deserve her kindness. She agreed to ask Snape's help for her sister, so yes. Modesty ? Do you see her with Voldemort ? Yes. Loyalty, yes.
If you look for a truly bad Hufflepuff Zacharias Smith. So there are good Slytherin, there are bad Hufflepuff.
@@priscillaayoub9362 Also you do realize that she wrote the books and the world in it,so if she really wanted to,she could have made it so there where no bad Hufflepuffes. Sorry,if this sounds mean,I am going by what's in the books and online.
@@melindamelton5612 HP4, first lesson of herbology =
“This’ll keep Madam Pomfrey happy,” said Professor Sprout,
stoppering the last bottle with a cork. “An excellent remedy for the
more stubborn forms of acne, bubotuber pus. Should stop students resorting to desperate measures to rid themselves of pimples.”
“Like Eloise Midgen,” said Hannah Abbott, a Hufflepuff,
in a hushed voice. “She tried to curse hers off.”
“Silly girl,” said Professor Sprout, shaking her head. “But
Madam Pomfrey fixed her nose back on in the end.”
It's the second day of Hogwart, 2nd september and Hufflepuff students pushed another one to that extreme point, seriously one day with her fellow hufflepuff, one ! How much the harrasment was ? She cursed herself off, she blew up her face ! Hannah laugh about it like it was not a big deal, and Sprout doesn't say anything against Abbot but "yeah it's the girl who is harrassed who is silly, normal thing". Do we want to speak about the second year and how McMillan is so mean with Harry ? How all Hufflepuff were against Harry during the goblet, with the bagde ? Hufflepuff are not bad because JK Rowling said it ? She wrote otherwise. And even if you use Harry's point of view, Harry isn't well know about the death eater, he knows about Voldemort and very few death eaters, so it doesn't really count to know the death eaters were in which house. Not saying something doesn't mean it doesn't exist and that likely the motto of Hufflepuff. I don't say all Hufflepuff are bad of course but there are none of the houses who has NONE bad guys.
@@priscillaayoub9362 yess exactly, the idea that you can sort school children into 'good' houses and 'bad' houses is ridiculous and something only jk is capable of to be honest
I love the video, and you make a valid point, but I just want to point out that Andromeda Tonks was in Slytherin but she left her family, married a muggle, and devoted a lot of her time (and her house) to helping the Order of the Pheonix.
It makes sense. I was thinking about who in Harry's friends represents what Slytherin House means. Hermione = Ravenclaw. Ron = Hufflepuff, and Ginny = Slytherin, while Harry is all Griffindor
The fact that Draco doesn't have a redemption arc is honestly so awful to me. Like, it would've been so easy and interesting and uplifting. But noooooo, instead, we got Snape's, a character who, while very well written and interesting, is ultimately an awful person to redeem witha very bad reason for redemption. Instead of an ACTUAL CHILD, who didn't know what he was doing until he was too scared to stop.
FINALLY! YES, I TOTALLY AGREE.
Also, he was in this impossible situation just as much as Harry was. Just on the other side. It was obvious that as awful and mean as he could be, he was this really scared kid. We saw that in the sixth book and film.
In canon, it didn't make sense for him to have a redemption ark, but from a writers perspective, he should have gotten it.
Moonstone305 how did it not make sense in canon? I mean he did lie about harry in Malfoy mansion and left his family for a woman who didn’t hold those morals. It would have made a lot of sense for him to get over those believes when he realised what they really are in the half blood prince. He never wanted to be a death eater, he did that stuff to impress his father.
@@mandelade He wasn't scared of his parents, and he did indeed hold a lot of similar views until the end of the book series. He was never scared of his parents, so there's nothing like that going on. My personal opinion, is that he wasn't fleshed out enough in canon for any redemption ark to take place
When I first saw the title: "What? You are stretching for this one Benjamin." By the end of the video: "Of course Ginny should have been a Slytherin!"
I still think this quite a stretch to put Ginny in Slytherin
Ginny actually would've done well in Slytherin or Gryffindor. She's very brave, bold, courageous and she's got nerve like all the other Gryffindors. She's determined, cunning, ambitious like any Slytherin. I personally think Ginny is better as a Gryffindor because she values bravery and getting in on the action, as we learn in Order of the Phoenix when she decides to go to Department of Mysteries with Dumbledore's Army, in Chamber of Secrets, she along with all the other Weasleys depises the Malfoy family (and other Slytherins). In Order, she is very brave to help Harry and the others face the Death Eaters. And also, according to Wikipedia, Ginny is feisty, forceful and isn't afraid to speak her mind or stand up for herself.
I think the adventurous side of Ginny is better than her ambitious side!
I actually didn't think it was a stretch initially, but definitely not now. I do think that she might have had to be written slightly differently, but she is the character that would have fit in Slytherin best and I think he made some really good points about why it would have made the story that much stronger. Like he said, his point wasn't to prove that she fit the character traits more than Gryffindor it was to say it would have made the story better and he was right. So I don't think it's a stretch.
Totally agree! Though my head-canon is that the sorting hat wanted to place her I Slytherin but she asked not to be just as Harry did.
11:50 "Even this could be *yewsed* to explain how different one Slytherin can be to the next."
I think all the weasleys ask to be in gryffindor. The book talks about how their parents are proud gryffindors and how they would be disappointed if their children weren't. I don't think they actually would be disappointed but I do think their children would think this, especially after Bill and Charlie both go to Hogwarts and get sorted into gryffindor. I think after Bill and Charlie, Percy should have gone to Ravenclaw or Slytherin and Ron should have gone to Hufflepuff. Along with worrying about disappointing their parents I think that we clearly see that they are looked down on a lot by the pure blood world and a lot of other wizards too so their parents would extra worry about them staying together so they have each other. I think the sorting hat sees all this and takes it into account.
I so agree with this. And the twins according to me should have gone to Slytherin, so they and Ginny could all have gone to Slytherin together
I say this is the world if the sorting hat was actually doing it’s job and not just picking what house the person already desired in the first place.
J.K. Rowling makes all Slytherins basically evil, except Slughorn and Merlin.
rickeymariu1
Andromeda and Regulus too.
But that makes things simple for children who needs a world in black and white. On basis these people in red are good guys and people in green are bad guys. With age people understand that things aren't actually that simple.
Draco turns out okay in the end.
I mean it's a children's book. Also I guess back when the first book come out stories isn't known to for too much complexity? Like nowadays you really need some insane conflicts and twists to make a story interesting, I think older stories tend to be simpler.
@Jimmy Bob
She could be thinking of her daughter who was a hufflepuff but andromeda was a slytherin or Sirius wouldn’t have been the first black in another house.
Beautiful idea, never thought about it, adds so many possibilities to the entire story and side-plots, great job 👌🤟🎩😎
After watching this video, I totally agree. Not only because it would’ve made such a cool story element with so much potential, but also because it would give us a genuinely good Slytherin, helping kids understand that you can be in a place with a bad rep, but still be a good person, just like Serious.
“Another Weasly, eh?I know just what to do with you!
*SLYTHERIN* ”
Noice
*laughing in Ravenclaw*
@emma oslund my friend, u just replied to another ravenclaw’s comment, so I’m laughing with u lol
Sundorian Canvas lolololol
Sorting Hat: "I'm tired of putting you all in Gryffindor! Off to Slytherin you go."
Anyone else miss "THESE SOCKS ARE AMAZING" at the end of videos
Now that you mention it
i do
Yes
Petition to bring it back #bringbackthesesocksareamazing
Yes
I hadn't thought about this, but from a story standpoint you have a point here.
Can we also remember that Slughorn dueled against Voldey himself? You know, the teacher that 'understood' him the most? By the way, if I had to give a core material guess for Ginny's wand, I would say Unicorn Hair. I do study wandlore and I have to say that it is always interesting to see the difference in wands. Check out Cherry wands, Neville had a wand of Cherry with Unicorn, and Lockhart had a Cherry with Dragon wand, literally different spectrums.
Andromeda Tonks (nee Black): * exists *
Them: * in a high pitch * Not a single good Slytherin.
P.S- Severus Snape wasn't a good person. He wasn't a bad person either. He lived and died a true Slytherin
Was she in Slytherin though?
@@thequacker she was
Nah Snape was a bad person. I mean like his personality and that.
Snape did what he did for himself whether or not it is good or bad. He did more bad than good but in the end died a hero. Though his overarching character is horrible and he is not a good person and doesn’t show much positive growth. Though you can not deny he was not a true Slytherin doing everything for himself
Neville Longbottom knew exactly who tortured his parents into insanity, yet his biggest fear was one of his school teachers. Severus Snape was a bad person.
Here’s a random “theory” I came up with a couple weeks ago: The golden trio might have been able to use Accio on Hufflepuffs cup, instead of dealing with the curses it had. You might bring up the locket as a counterargument, which didn’t get summoned by Harry in the cave, but there’s a key point which disproves that counterargument. Harry tried to summon a horcrux and not a locket. So since there was no horcrux to summon, since the locket was a fake, nothing happened. As Dumbledore said, it’s not a bad idea to try the simple things first. So it’s possible that in the Lestranges vault they could’ve tried “Accio Horcrux” and it possibly would’ve just be summoned towards them, since there was a horcrux to summon in the first place.This theory probably isn’t true, but I think it’s an interesting thing to think about.
Yeah it does make sense
maybe it is true and maybe not, Gringotts could have made arrangements against these spells
He tried it in the books..didn't work
In any case I'd probably try to accio the thing that the horcrux is in. Imagine you accidentally rip it out of the vessel and it just flies its snake face through you and leaves.
Leon B Did he specifically try to summon “locket” or did he summon “horcrux”? I forget the specific word he used. But the way Accio works you need to have a very specific thing in mind, so it’s possible that the limitations of the spell wouldn’t let Harry summon the Black locket if he was concentrating on the image of the Slytherin locket. I don’t think the spell needs you to be that specific though, it probably would’ve allowed Harry to summon it (if there were no other protections around it).
Although I believe this could've opened up a lot of good and interesting plot points for the story and yes I think she does embody Slytherin traits it was important for her to be in griffindoor. It is crucial for the Weasleys to be a united front and though Molly and Arthur wouldn't have loved her any less, her being in a different house would've caused a separation of her and her family for the reader. The Weasleys are our rock, Harrys rock too; we feel safe when harry is with them (another reason why the death eaters crashing the wedding was important, that showed us that the stability we are accustom to is gone and the trio is on their own.) despite their financial troubles they are stable, loving, and the family Harry never had. So yes I think it would've been cool to see the possibility but it's important for her to follow in her family's footsteps.
All the Weasleys but Molly would fit pretty well in Slytherin. Especially Arthur, Percy, Fred, and George.
Can We Just Talk About How Ron Thought He Had A Shot At Being In Ravenclaw?XD
Well, Ron does prove that he is intelligent with his strategy, so he has potential to be in Ravenclaw
KL _144 Yeah, he’s good at Wizard Chess.
his attitude was so much more Slytherin-so much more ambitious and traditional . He may have been decently bright but he wasn't curious enough to be Ravenclaw
Not even Hermione can beat him at chess.
I recently realized I've gotten to old for Harry Potter:
I turned 101 last Tuesday 🙂
😆
um na you are never to old to watch Harry potter
Happy BDay
Give or take a few :)
Don't worry, you are still younger than Dumbledore.
Trait wise, Percy would be the best Weasley option for Slytherin.
2:45 anyone else notice slytherins colors match the avada kedavara curse and gyrfindor matches expeliarmus so in that shot it looks like priori incantatum
If she was in Slytherin, how could she have ever stolen Riddle’s diary back from Harry’s dormitory?
Obviously, as a cunning slytherin, she’d figure it out.
She’s got 4 gryffindor brothers, I’m sure siblings can occasionally find excuses to visit each other
Angela Hsiao
I don’t think the gryffindors would ever allow a slytherin to enter their common room. That goes against all their morals. Even if it’s one others sister.
Take for example Padma and Parvati Patil: one is in Ravenclaw while the other is in Gryffindor. And they are twins. So I honestly doubt it
@@samueljacobs2484 Although you see them both in the Gryffindor common room at times
Uncle Stinkbug
That’s in the movies, in the movies they are both Gryffindors. And by the way, wasn’t it such a huge deal that they were sneaking into another house common room in the second book and that they don’t even know where the other common rooms are.
Regulus Black should've had his own book, "Regulus Black and the Dark Lord".
Someone write this please
😍😍😍
Ima put this down in my fanfiction to-write pile, thnx for the idea.
I'd read it
Revisiting this 3 years later to request a full treatment of this what if. Please and thank you!!