Voldemort: *watches a 14 year old boy on a firebolt* I want that Potter boy dead, but MY GOD he is good on a firebolt. Also Voldemort: *gets put on a register*
Oh my gosh that was so hilarious! Awesome impression, too! My favorite part was primrose Everdeen! I totally makes sense that Wormtail would be the one to place the imperious curse on Percy Weasley because who would know him better? Excellent theory and it totally makes me read the last four books in the Harry Potter series differently!
Imagine if 200 years later, the Weasly surname becomes the equivalent of “Smith” in the muggle world everyone in gryffindor is a Weasly or a distant relative.
weird.. now that you mention it: what if the weaslys are decendents of griffindor? The sorting hat does put ron into griffindor based on his name I think
I kinda like the idea that every Weasley could have been in Sytherin to an extent. Bill and Charlie get good and respectful jobs followi g their passions, Percy is Percy, Fred and George are ambitious to start their own business and sneaky to boot, Ron dreamt of being head boy and quidich captain and ginny... well... she wanted to marry harry...
Uhhhh this is awkward... How are you breaking the fourth wall and commenting on this video? Oh and as I see you are still a child so I must warn you of- wait consequences...😮😮😮
I kind of love the sad fact that Fred Weasley's last laugh comes from Percy's joke about his "resignation" when he transfigures Thicknese into a Sea Urchin.
But with the sorting- I think Percy was less ambitious at the start, that's why he was chosen into Gryffindor. I think he grew into that ambition, *and Dumbledore himself said that he wished you could be sorted later* when talking to Snape.
Me when I read the title of your videos: "Yeah right that's ridiculous no way." Me when I finish the video: "Perkins Weazelby definitely had a Time Turner and was under the imperius curse!!!!"
I've always thought that, sure, he might have been a Ministry sycophant at the beginning, like 5th, possibly 6th, year, but at some point he must have realized what was really happening and where things were heading. By Deathly Hallows, I think he was staying where he was because he knew his family were considered blood traitors and the best way to protect them was to maintain appearances and keep ahead of any possible moves against them.
I literally gasped when you reminded me that Scabbers used to belong to Percy. I love this theory. Its one of the most believable HP theories I've ever heard
Are we gonna forget the fact that in the book Harry Potter and the goblet of fire; mad eye moody (BC jr) casts the imperious curse on Harry. And Harry "shakes" it off. So Harry has actually been able to "shake off" all 3 of the unforgivable curses.
@@tavadaardendrian319 I don't know anymore who suggested it, but the argument goes as follows: As Bellatrix (?) stated in The Order Of Phoenix you really need to mean it, if you want to use the Cruciatus Curse. As Voldemort didn't think that Harry was alive anymore as he casted the curse on him, he didn't cast it correctly, therefore Harry didn't feel any pain. Do you get what I mean?
What if someone put a jinx on Percy so that everyone forgot his name? I mean it sounds like something Fred and George would do. Especially since they butted heads so often, him being a prefect and them being loveable dastardly pranksters. Also, the farts every time his name is said wrong had me dying.
Honestly, the sadest part is that I don't think anyone ever knew he was under the imperius curse, including himself, so coming back to his family after so long, regardless of what he is doing at that moment, they would have to think that the past 3 years were of his own choice, which had to leave some sort of mark on them
I'm unconvinced he was under the Imperius during the second task because he's so emotional that he runs straight at Ron when he's pulled from the lake, so he's biased to give Harry full marks. He might love rules but this is the same guy that bet ten galleons he DIDN'T OWN on a Quidditch match, he's not completely strait-laced.
I have two theories for the second task thing:- Peter Pettigrew was away looking for Voldemort as a rat. He may have been too focused on that or just forgot about Percy. Percy at the sight of seeing his brother almost drown, shook of the curse and without wasting any time jumped in after him.
I also think it makes a worse story if he is under the imperious curse. People can get stuck in their ways and make poor decisions and then find it hard to return to the right side. I don’t know I’ve just always liked Percy’s arc
@@celinavivian1162 Same! It’s much more interesting to have someone who’s genuinely misguided and messes up but in the end is able to reflect enough to change his ways. I have too many thoughts on the topic so I’ll leave it at that, haha.
@@jennisfalling1379 Well people also hate the idea that maybe the Weasleys and Percy had very toxic relationships so it really was just a matter of time before he would've cut them out of his life. Seriously can you actually find a single time that either his siblings or father actually acted like they even liked him?
I think Percy wasn’t placed under the Imperius Curse until after Voldemort had returned and after it was discovered that Crouch Sr was killed and Jr got the Dementor’s Kiss.
I love how Crouch keeps calling him Weatherby. So insulting. Maybe that's part of why Percy didn't want to believe Crouch was not himself. He finally felt seen by his boss, something he wanted so badly that it blinded him to the painfully obvious truth: something is very wrong with Barty Crouch, Sr.
And how do you explain all the other people that would've known Crouch for longer than a year? Why didn't they know something was wrong? They would be more knowledgeable of him than an 18 year old who has only worked for him for less than a year.
@@1993digifan Maybe he was part of the "quiet quitting/work from home" craze? Or maybe no-one wanted to step on his toes by questioning such a hothead...
@@brandiarmstrong2902 You do know the series canonically takes place in 90s so there no Muggle fad for him to follow right? Plus that won't explain why Percy was left to do all the work if Crouch Sr. was just working from home.
I think Percy was just a bit of a prat at this stage in his life. Glad he grew out of it. Plus, wizards are often a bit touched in the head. Very obvious things often elude them. Probably why Snape's protective measure for the sorcerer's stone, though not shown in the film, was a shelf of seven potion bottles and a riddle that ran on pure logic. 2 bottles contained poison, 3 contained wine, one had a potion to go back through the fire you just passed, and one to pass safely forward through the next wall of flames. The riddle told exactly which bottle contained what, but was written in such a way that those who don't possess a whit of logic within them would be hopelessly lost trying to figure it out. My guess? At least half of that department would be among those who never made it out of that challenge.
@@brandiarmstrong2902 You are right, coming from an emotionally abusive family it makes sense that Percy would be desperate for just a sliver of validation from literally anyone since he LONG AGO gave up expecting any genuine support from his blood relations. You people want me to believe that it was so horrible for Percy to pick a well paying job over his blood relations than PLEASE find how many times his "loving siblings and pappy" weren't insulting, backhanded complimenting, dismissing his personal wishes, supporting the mistreatment of him by others, betraying a simple promise, or really just anytime that acted if they even liked him before he walked out on them. So was it really something to "grow out of" or was it just an abuse victim going back to the abusers since the bar for his personal happiness is so low they are least worst choice at this point?
someone: "ay remember that kid's poem that's like 'one fish, two fish, red fish, blue fish' ?" me: " do you mean 'he cursed, she cursed, we cursed, me cursed' ?"
A bundle of walking sticks was floating in midair ahead of them and as Percy took a step toward them they started throwing themselves at him. “Peeves,” Percy whispered to the first years. “A poltergeist."
Actually that's a good point. I wonder why they don't install something similar in the ministry, I guess it could be goblin magic which they won't part with
I so agree! They could convince me that the Sun is actually a burning s'more thrown out there by some giant creature. I never get tired of how they go about convincing us.
Ministry Staff: Hey umm what was that redhead freckle covered assistant called? I believe he works for crouch. Some other ministry staff: Oh umm I believe it was perpendicular wall shelf
Your description of the imperius curse had me so relaxed, then you told me to subscribe. I actually laughed out loud! Too late. 😆 That's how I found this video in the first place!
literally no one: … My Friend : What is Ron's ministry loving, family disowning brother's name? Me being me: Oh, do you mean Peruvian Wall clock or is it pinkie Wannabe
You do know that Luna's mother died from a cauldron exploding? Seems like the stability of cauldrons is valid concern. But since it's not a happy funny thing people like you ignore it, just like you whine about car inspection.
I figured that Percy was under the Impirious Curse, but watching this it just hit me about his connection to wormtail. Now it all makes complete sense.
Because you can't imagine Percy walking out on the people that treat him the same way the Griffins treat Meg? No, no, no people like you support abusive and toxic relationships as long as you get to laugh at the misery of the family punching bag.
I like this theory, but as for him being a Slytherin, I can see him having the choice like Harry did. His two older brothers and parents were Gryffindors, and everybody sees Slytherin as the evil house, so I can see him asking the hat to put him in Gryffindor because he wants to be the "good guy" and also wants to share the house with his family.
While I enjoyed this video, I don't believe this theory. I see Percy as more of a parallel to Hermione's arc. They are both type-A personalities and their characters are how JK Rowling decided to showcase how differently people who live by rules react to chaos in their lives. Hermione learned that rules can be bent or broken when the need arises and that sometimes, it makes your life better. On the other side, Percy couldn't see a life without rigid rules and just wanted to hold onto any sense of normalcy that he could and he lost his sense of morality in the process.
Theory: Percy only was under the imperious curse for a year but he thought his family will hate him since they did not know he was under the curse but after two years he worked up the courage to talk to them
Or he left an extremely toxic environment only being willing to be around them because of what was basically the end of the world. Don't believe they were toxic? Please find anything in last four years before he walked out where you could actually believe his siblings or father even liked him or that his mother only liked him because he did what she wanted.
You know, one potential nickname for Harry could be “The Great Forgiver”, one account of the fact that he is the only wizard who has shrugged of EVERY unforgivable curse. Harry Potter: The Boy Who Lived The Chosen One The Master of Death The Great Forgiver It’s Something to consider. Isn’t that right Parsley Worcestershire?
@@ChitenBugMan I never got why they split the book into two movies, it seems so unnecessary. No hate meant, I'm just venting because IT'S ONE BOOK, NOT TWO BOOKS, AND LAST TIME I CHECKED THE BOOK WASN'T TWO PARTS! Sorry for venting and bothering you!
Friend: What was the name of Ron's older brother who worked for the ministry? Me: Petrified wombat* *Substitute with Painkiller Whippersnapper, Paper Wakanda, or Pacing Wagonette
You make a compelling argument. Percy loves his family, but Wormtail would know precisely how to coerce Percy into turning on them. The Imperius makes you think that doing what the caster wants will solve all the world's ills. Percy has always wanted to be a success and his father has never really wanted to do more than work in the Misuse of Muggle Artifacts Office. His doing the work of a Department Head as a first year intake should have been suspicious, but his ambition may have been well known in the Department of International Magical Cooperation. Even though Crouch never bothered to learn the kid's name, his hard work would still have drawn attention. That Percy came back to his family after Wormtail's death strengthens the argument. You did a great job presenting your arguments. Good job!
"when Voldemort and Wormtail went to rescue his son, Barty Crouch Jr." I heard that with the missed context that Voldemort was actually Crouch Jr's real father.
Honestly it feels more like Percy had built up resentment of their family not having the best financial situation and a mixture of middle child syndrome. Growing up with Fred and George's antics would eat up a lot of their parents attention and then when Jenny Comes Along being not only the youngest but the only girl that his mother always wanted probably meant that especially with him being so well-behaved responsible and great in school he was easily pushed aside and ignored most of his life by his family or made fun of.
On the Wizarding World app it said “the maps magic includes the homonculous charm- this enables the user to track the movements of Hogwarts’ inhabitants” (Wizarding Weekly edition No. 4- discover Hogwarts, slide 7/ the marauders map)
Misnaming Padfoot Wormtail like that each time is going to become a new hobby of mine. It reminds me of my favorite British actor, Battlefield Counterstrike.
In Percys defense: He's literally the odd one out. Arthur - Molly Bill - Charlie Fred - George Ron - Ginny Which just leaves Percy who kinda gets left out, especially if most of them don't have the interests he does.
His pair was the 8th (3rd?) Weasley Child, between Charlie and Percy, who was killed during the first war. Explains Mr. Weasley's explanation (in the after math of the attack at the world cup) of the fear of the time, and the terror of seeing the Dark Mark above your home and knowing what is likely to be found inside. Also explains Bill's conspicuous silence and understanding to this explanation (He would have been old enough to remember the child...age 3-4 at birth, 5-6 and death).
@@benjaminjohannessanchez3310 I saw it once online years and years ago. Haven't been able to find it since. All I get is fanfiction stories when I look for it.
Found it... Missing Weasley Child theory, paired with Imperio'd Arthur Weasley theory. skelkins.com/hp/archives/000128.html (There are other theories here as well, some disproven.)
The one issue I see with this is that at the end of the second task, Percy literally runs into the water to make sure his brother is alive and warm. This doesn't seem like something someone under that curse would do.
@@klaudiagrob Well you can believe whatever you want, it's fictionnal anyways. You could even argue that dumbledore is the reincarnation of dark vador that went through a tardis that went through a wormhole in space and acquired the quintessential power of Cthullhu, it would still be believable. Because, fiction.
@@GreyPunkWolf Well, no. Fiction isn't just an anything goes wonderland lol It has to make sense within the rules of that universe Which none of that would
personally i dont think he was under the curse for many reasons. one of which is he still expressed concern and love for his family, even if it sometimes was misguided. like the letter he wrote ron, telling him to stay away from harry. obv it was wrong but from his pov he was warning his little brother of a dangerous life. why i think he choose the ministry is simply bc he was tired of never being appreciated, always being misunderstood, and having his hard work go not only unnoticed but also mocked by his family. so, instead, he chose his out. he choose to believe the sweet lies being fed to him instead of more questions and mockery from his family. thats quite understandable in my opinion, not good, but understandable. and i get why people dont see justification of his words or actions he used against his family, but i understand where he was coming from. not completely, ofc, a lot of things he did were completely out of line. however i have said terrible things to my family because i felt secluded from them, they not only didnt get me but they also never wanted to listen to me when i told them what they were doing hurt me. so i became a prat to them honestly. i feel percy did the same. he was more than tired at that point and i think the final straw was that his own father didnt think he could get a job like that in the ministry, instead, from his prospective, his father didnt believe he could do it on his own merit. and ofc from our perspective its obvious he was just being used as a spy, from his he finally got his big break, his talent finally recognized. which is quite sad. the boy was desperate for any appreciation and felt he got none (which, from what we read, he doesnt from anyone but his mum. which is complicated) which is partly why i defend percy, or at the very least share his pov. the weasleys are amazing people, wonderful and kind. but they never understood percy and i dont believe they ever tried to, 'sides molly. the twins were cruel to him, i will say, their relationship is very complex and we dont have an exact reason why or who started to feel animosity. but anyway, alls that to say i personally just think percy deserved better and if you can forgive characters who made even worse decisions than his, i think you can forgive him aswell.
Regarding why Percy is a Gryffindor: he was sorted 4 years before the audience meets him. People can change. And as much as I love Fred and George and hate to point the finger at them, I wouldn't doubt that they are at least partly why Percy was burdened with being "the responsible one" once he went to Hogwarts. As for being on the side of Umbridge, that's simple: he just didn't know what she was actually like. When Scrimgeour was trying to get on Harry's good side, he brought up Umbridge, which I can only take to mean that Umbridge didn't see fit to tell her coworkers about her habit of carving up people's hands, because Scrimgeour doesn't seem like he's dumb enough to intentionally bring up someone that he knows Harry would hate.
I swear the Weasleys are my favourite family in Harry Potter! Ron Weasley, Ginny Weasley, Fred Weasley, George Weasley, Charlie Weasley, Molly Weasley, Arthur Weasley, Bill Weasley and of course, Polychromatophilia Wappenschawings (That's an actual word)
How did Snape (or anyone) CREATE a spell? Like do they concentrate on what they want it to do and say it enough (maybe with the wand movements) until it works or something? Idk
I think this level of magic needs at least a Bachelor in magic to explain. Unfortunately the books never go past high school level. Try sending an owl to an MM (Magus Maximus) and see if they can give an explanation. I doubt these Squibs without any formal education could make a proper video about it.
@@tmorris7329 Except it's outright stated that Severus Snape created Sectumsempra. And the fact that the notes for it were in the margins of his Potions Textbook would tend to indicate that he created it while he was a student at Hogwarts. That's also why he and he alone knew the counter for it to save Draco and protect himself from it when Harry tried to use it on him.
@Phoenix137 It's probably very complicated and involved and requires a Witch or Wizard of extraordinary power. And we know that Snape fit all of those categories.
I'll be honest, Percy is one of those HP characters that I forget even EXISTS a lot of the time. I mean, he'll be gone for a while, then he'll show up and I'll go "oh, I forgot he was in this one".
Oh yeah, so horrible the exact same kind of sweater that he got the moment he stopped growing. So horrible to not want something from the toxic family. PROVE the Weasleys weren't a toxic family to him, find anytime that you could genuinely believe his siblings and father even liked him or that his mother didn't just like him because he did what she wanted.
Jonathan Maderos we cant be sure if this is accurate because it is Sirius that says this and he was no killed by the killing curse he was killed by the veil
anna fuller well the Movies went off in a different way in that area. Lestrange Hit him with the killing curse and he fell into the veil rather than just being hit by a curse and the veil taking him. So perhaps he meant the movies not the books.
I also think Percy’s rule following shows how a susceptibility to authority figures which seems like it might also make him more susceptible to a curse that gives someone authority over his choices…
lol im imagining effie trinket calling Primrose Weverdeen at the reaping and percy stepping forward and then katniss saying "boi u can go die in the hunger games"
I actually dislike this theory. I feel that Percy's Arc of trusting the wrong people and making mistakes but owning up to it and apologizing is important. So few people it seems can do that today.
Takes away from his character development and the narrative tensions within the Weasleys. If he was under the curse it would ruin the narrative at the end with Fred. I don't think J thinks about narrative and character development when he makes videos in favor of wanting to explain anything that doesn't make sense to him.
Agreed. I see the merit for the theory, but yeah, I think the only spell he was under was the spell of the allure of money and power. As a guy from a poor and underappreciated family, he saw a way to success and respect (which he got none of at home).
I know this is an older video, but i do want to address something. Crouch does not use Percy's proper name, but he does consistently call him "Whetherbee" unlike Slughorn who used different names for Ron. I think Percy either goofed in his introduction, or intentionally used a different name. I am more inclined to believe the former because Crouch clearly respects Arthur.
I think it works better for him NOT to be under the curse. Sometimes people screw up and make bad choices. It's important to be able to see your mistakes and seek forgiveness.
People also walk out on their toxic family and yet they are the ones in the wrong for no longer pretending that there was anything healthy in the entire relationship. Can you actually find any moment in the first 4 books where you could truly believe that Percy's siblings or father even liked him?
I think everyone, even J.k. Rowling herself, did Pencety Witthernings(Percy Weasley) dirty. She made him do all those things and then he didn't have much that redeemed him. So, I agree that it is possible he was under the imperius curse. If he wasn't, then everyone did him dirty.
The Weasleys did nothing to redeem themselves as a healthy family. If they weren't toxic do you really think it would've been so easy for him to cut them out for three years? Oh please, I beg you and everyone like you, PROVE the Weasleys didn't deserve to have Percy walk out them. PROVE that at any point before he had enough of them that his siblings or father even liked him.
More like Dionysus intentionally miss-saying his name cause he doesn't like heroes and he's gone WAYYY too long without a glass of wine, but the same idea.
It was frightening how much I enjoyed your voice and the feeling it gave me as you were describing what the imperious curse felt like. The tingles down my spine as I just gave in... it was .. . bliss . . .
Or is it an abuse victim just accepting his abusive family and their treatment of him that went on LONG before he walked out on them because the narrative says they are best simply because the worship Main Character?
![How Does Harry Resist The Imperius Curse? [Harry Potter Theory]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/mPwEmtZ1AAU/mqdefault.jpg)
![How Does Harry Resist The Imperius Curse? [Harry Potter Theory]](/img/tr.png)
Ok I'll start:
Pumpernickle Weslton
Peppermint Waffleby
Packthread Wallaby
Purple Whiskey
Porcelain Washcloth
Poultry Watermelon
Placid Wedgie
Hi j
putrid wellingtons
pickle weasel
Pumpkin Where
Purple washcloth
Pratface Whiney
Someone: Hey, what's Ron's snobbish brother's name?
Me: Oh, you mean P. Sherman 42 Wallaby Way Sydney?
Just keep hexing. Just keep hexing. Hexing. Hexing
Bonderito this made my day
You win. Bravo 👏
Best comment that is his name now
Bonderito there’s a street in my town called Wallaby Way 😆
"I want that potter boy dead but MY GOD he is good on a firebolt."
Gold.
When Voldemort starts fangirling cause he might finally meet his favourite young Quidditch player.
Voldemort: *watches a 14 year old boy on a firebolt* I want that Potter boy dead, but MY GOD he is good on a firebolt.
Also Voldemort: *gets put on a register*
Joseph Jones love it 🤣🤣
Oh my gosh that was so hilarious! Awesome impression, too! My favorite part was primrose Everdeen! I totally makes sense that Wormtail would be the one to place the imperious curse on Percy Weasley because who would know him better? Excellent theory and it totally makes me read the last four books in the Harry Potter series differently!
@@brinmoody I guess that's why Voldemort wanted to touch him
HP fans: One simply can't find more HP theories...
SCB: Hold my butterbeer!
I'm here before this gets 1k likes
HOLD IT!
I can hear J saying this inside my head
There's a secret to it...
Accio theory!
Hold my Firewiskey
Pretty sure it just went:
Sorting Hat: Mhm? Red hair? Hand-me-down clothes? This must be a Weasley. GRYFFINDOR!
Imagine if 200 years later, the Weasly surname becomes the equivalent of “Smith” in the muggle world everyone in gryffindor is a Weasly or a distant relative.
weird.. now that you mention it: what if the weaslys are decendents of griffindor? The sorting hat does put ron into griffindor based on his name I think
I kinda like the idea that every Weasley could have been in Sytherin to an extent. Bill and Charlie get good and respectful jobs followi g their passions, Percy is Percy, Fred and George are ambitious to start their own business and sneaky to boot, Ron dreamt of being head boy and quidich captain and ginny... well... she wanted to marry harry...
@@sophiathefurbst thats possible considering they breed like rabbits lol
@@sophiathefurbst omg- lol
“I want that Potter boy dead but my god he’s good on a fireblot.” Best line and impression of Voldemort ever. Great job
Uhhhh this is awkward... How are you breaking the fourth wall and commenting on this video? Oh and as I see you are still a child so I must warn you of- wait consequences...😮😮😮
@@chrispj713 what do you mean
@@lilyevans3023 they’re referring to your username and picture
She has a time turner, shes from the past 😂
Lily no-
*reads title*
"I don't believe that at all! But I will in 12 minutes!"
Me all the time watching these kind of vids, lol. In the end, they make so much sense!
Yeah. In the end it always seems so right with these videos.
ACTUALLY 12:38
For a fact!
Exactly
I kind of love the sad fact that Fred Weasley's last laugh comes from Percy's joke about his "resignation" when he transfigures Thicknese into a Sea Urchin.
I do feel it is rather appropriate that the brother who the twins were always giving the hardest time was the one who had... "the last laugh."
But with the sorting- I think Percy was less ambitious at the start, that's why he was chosen into Gryffindor. I think he grew into that ambition, *and Dumbledore himself said that he wished you could be sorted later* when talking to Snape.
Me when I read the title of your videos: "Yeah right that's ridiculous no way."
Me when I finish the video: "Perkins Weazelby definitely had a Time Turner and was under the imperius curse!!!!"
Me too!!
*oi perkins*
This is so true! U think it’s clickbate but it always holds up!
I have always liked the theory he separated himself so that he wouldn't be asked to spy on his family and Harry
That's a pretty good theory!
That's what I felt like too
MEG4nerd it’s an ok theory but I don’t think he’d ever go as far as he did
I've always prescribed to that idea.
I've always thought that, sure, he might have been a Ministry sycophant at the beginning, like 5th, possibly 6th, year, but at some point he must have realized what was really happening and where things were heading. By Deathly Hallows, I think he was staying where he was because he knew his family were considered blood traitors and the best way to protect them was to maintain appearances and keep ahead of any possible moves against them.
My sister : Its Percy Weasley
Me : No, its Pickleface Willingham
Pastor Weasley
lol
Pumped Whale
Peppered wellington
it was the devils number(666) i had to change it
I literally gasped when you reminded me that Scabbers used to belong to Percy. I love this theory. Its one of the most believable HP theories I've ever heard
No everything that Percy did was his own free will.
Are we gonna forget the fact that in the book Harry Potter and the goblet of fire; mad eye moody (BC jr) casts the imperious curse on Harry. And Harry "shakes" it off. So Harry has actually been able to "shake off" all 3 of the unforgivable curses.
How do you shake off the Cruciatus Curse? I’m actually curious, I haven’t read the books for awhile
@@tavadaardendrian319 i cant exactly remember but i think it has to do with accepting or ignoring the pain, like focusing on something else
@@tavadaardendrian319 I think it’s because he’s been hit by the curse a few times and so it affects how Harry shakes it off.
@@tavadaardendrian319 I don't know anymore who suggested it, but the argument goes as follows: As Bellatrix (?) stated in The Order Of Phoenix you really need to mean it, if you want to use the Cruciatus Curse. As Voldemort didn't think that Harry was alive anymore as he casted the curse on him, he didn't cast it correctly, therefore Harry didn't feel any pain. Do you get what I mean?
I’m pretty sure that J does know that, but he just didn’t mention it because it wasn’t relevant to the point he was making at that moment
J: he curse she curse we curse me curse
Me: dr Seuss is that u?
beatles is that u?
(I am the walrus)
He, she, we, WUMBO
Voldemort is the Cat in the Hat.
"Primrose Weverdeen"
LOL
I loved this one!! lol
Primrose everdeen
The hunger games reference is on pointttttt
I can’t 😂
7:41 in particular
I loved it!
What if someone put a jinx on Percy so that everyone forgot his name? I mean it sounds like something Fred and George would do. Especially since they butted heads so often, him being a prefect and them being loveable dastardly pranksters. Also, the farts every time his name is said wrong had me dying.
Who's Percy?
@@unitds27-delta Pencilcase Washingmachine. You know he worked for the ministry
@@unitds27-delta parsnip washcloth! The person that has red hair and works at the ministry! 😁
@@unitds27-delta Parselmouth Wrinkledshirt, you know, the guy who works under Crouch?
@@Somirage143I thought he was Peselator Winkleberry
I’m just imagining J and everyone else behind the scenes trying to figure out different PW names... lol
He actually asked the folks on discord for help
We had a lot of fun with it
Go to
Patreon.com/SuperCarlinBrothers
To join us
Que The Sparkle I want to so bad... but I’m broke
Que The Sparkle also we need more interactive youtubers!!
Comet Craft what does all think about the inrtro
Just me or is it scary
Honestly, the sadest part is that I don't think anyone ever knew he was under the imperius curse, including himself, so coming back to his family after so long, regardless of what he is doing at that moment, they would have to think that the past 3 years were of his own choice, which had to leave some sort of mark on them
They never cared about him before why would they after?
I'm unconvinced he was under the Imperius during the second task because he's so emotional that he runs straight at Ron when he's pulled from the lake, so he's biased to give Harry full marks. He might love rules but this is the same guy that bet ten galleons he DIDN'T OWN on a Quidditch match, he's not completely strait-laced.
I have two theories for the second task thing:-
Peter Pettigrew was away looking for Voldemort as a rat. He may have been too focused on that or just forgot about Percy.
Percy at the sight of seeing his brother almost drown, shook of the curse and without wasting any time jumped in after him.
I also think it makes a worse story if he is under the imperious curse. People can get stuck in their ways and make poor decisions and then find it hard to return to the right side. I don’t know I’ve just always liked Percy’s arc
@@celinavivian1162 Same! It’s much more interesting to have someone who’s genuinely misguided and messes up but in the end is able to reflect enough to change his ways. I have too many thoughts on the topic so I’ll leave it at that, haha.
@@jennisfalling1379 Well people also hate the idea that maybe the Weasleys and Percy had very toxic relationships so it really was just a matter of time before he would've cut them out of his life. Seriously can you actually find a single time that either his siblings or father actually acted like they even liked him?
I think Percy wasn’t placed under the Imperius Curse until after Voldemort had returned and after it was discovered that Crouch Sr was killed and Jr got the Dementor’s Kiss.
"You know Ron's stuck up brother?"
"Pinocchio Walrusberry?"
bless you.
Someone: “hey who’s Ron’s stuck-up older brother”
Me: oh you mean Perennial Worcestershire
Hehee
You misspelled it.
His name is Porpoise Weedlord
*purple washcloth*
Wuh-stuh-sure is how it's pronounced
It’s Purple Whisky!
Someone: where’s Percy weasley?
Me: sorry I don’t know a Percy weasley I only know a pickled witherwings
Fasion D.I.Y GoLD
I don't know any percy weasly I only know Percy Jackson
Who the heck is pickled witherwings?! I know a guy named putrid watermelon if that’s who you mean
Donut And Ava yeah him
Yeah pickles Buckbe-- i mean Witherwings
poor pissy waffles, under the imperious curse
for three years 😔
Thats a good name I'm a name my first kid Pissy Wafles
PISSY WAFFLES I SCREAMED
Dude don't let yputuber here this but put a u instead of an i
And I thought mine was good
@Thomas Laity-Cash well who wouldn't be on the news?
I love how Crouch keeps calling him Weatherby. So insulting. Maybe that's part of why Percy didn't want to believe Crouch was not himself. He finally felt seen by his boss, something he wanted so badly that it blinded him to the painfully obvious truth: something is very wrong with Barty Crouch, Sr.
And how do you explain all the other people that would've known Crouch for longer than a year? Why didn't they know something was wrong? They would be more knowledgeable of him than an 18 year old who has only worked for him for less than a year.
@@1993digifan Maybe he was part of the "quiet quitting/work from home" craze? Or maybe no-one wanted to step on his toes by questioning such a hothead...
@@brandiarmstrong2902 You do know the series canonically takes place in 90s so there no Muggle fad for him to follow right? Plus that won't explain why Percy was left to do all the work if Crouch Sr. was just working from home.
I think Percy was just a bit of a prat at this stage in his life. Glad he grew out of it. Plus, wizards are often a bit touched in the head. Very obvious things often elude them. Probably why Snape's protective measure for the sorcerer's stone, though not shown in the film, was a shelf of seven potion bottles and a riddle that ran on pure logic. 2 bottles contained poison, 3 contained wine, one had a potion to go back through the fire you just passed, and one to pass safely forward through the next wall of flames. The riddle told exactly which bottle contained what, but was written in such a way that those who don't possess a whit of logic within them would be hopelessly lost trying to figure it out. My guess? At least half of that department would be among those who never made it out of that challenge.
@@brandiarmstrong2902 You are right, coming from an emotionally abusive family it makes sense that Percy would be desperate for just a sliver of validation from literally anyone since he LONG AGO gave up expecting any genuine support from his blood relations. You people want me to believe that it was so horrible for Percy to pick a well paying job over his blood relations than PLEASE find how many times his "loving siblings and pappy" weren't insulting, backhanded complimenting, dismissing his personal wishes, supporting the mistreatment of him by others, betraying a simple promise, or really just anytime that acted if they even liked him before he walked out on them. So was it really something to "grow out of" or was it just an abuse victim going back to the abusers since the bar for his personal happiness is so low they are least worst choice at this point?
Percy: hello I’m Percy Percy Weasley
Me: hi Pennywise nice to meet you
Hello Percypercy. I'm Jamesjames Bond.
Wow the name go's hard
someone: "ay remember that kid's poem that's like 'one fish, two fish, red fish, blue fish' ?"
me: " do you mean 'he cursed, she cursed, we cursed, me cursed' ?"
HAHAHAHAHA
Its funny that i see that and he says it at the same time
One shell, two shell
Red shell, Blue shell
Death on swiftwings
Come for you shell
Penedict Wumberbatch is my least favorite person in his family
People: It's Percy weasley
Me an intellectual: NO, it's *Poltergeist Wizzlebits*
Lol
Wait then am I Ron Wizzlebits.....?
@@Lucy-gr4yt yes.
@@accio_firewhiskey8256 sad 😢
A bundle of walking sticks was floating in midair ahead of them and as Percy took a step toward them they started throwing themselves at him. “Peeves,” Percy whispered to the first years. “A poltergeist."
@@Lucy-gr4yt Of course not. You're *Wren* Waffleshnitz.
So Percy is the new Benedict Cumberbatch?
I'm game.
Who is that?
Do you mean Benedrill carrotcatch?
Centurion Quincy no i think he means bumidum cucumber
Percedict Weaselbach
Bendyerdick Humpinsnatch?
Guys, guys, It's Bumblebee Cabbagepatch
There’s another way to get out of the imperious curse - the thief’s downfall in gringotts.
Oh yeah, that works too, I guess
Actually that's a good point. I wonder why they don't install something similar in the ministry, I guess it could be goblin magic which they won't part with
But I seriously doubt that Percy tried to break into Gringotts.
NerdCraft 101 that’s not my point,
A magic nullifier in the front door of the ministry does seem very useful
You could literally tell me that Harry Potters grandfathers cousin is Andy’s dad and I’d believe you
New theory video!!! Lol
I so agree! They could convince me that the Sun is actually a burning s'more thrown out there by some giant creature. I never get tired of how they go about convincing us.
Umm his grandma is a black
I believe that would be his third cousin twice removed
Don't give them any ideas.
Someone: "Hey, what's Ron's ambitious snobbish brother's name?"
Me: Do you mean Pterodactyl's Whiskers?
yes indeed
J: talking about what the curse actually does
Me (anxiety and depression issues): dude, somebody curse me, fam
same tho
YES PLEASE MAKE ME DO MY SCHOOL WORK
@@amberandrews6692 You first
Ok IMPERIO!
Same
Ministry Staff: Hey umm what was that redhead freckle covered assistant called? I believe he works for crouch.
Some other ministry staff: Oh umm I believe it was perpendicular wall shelf
Ok thats a good one
Ministry staff 1: I thought it was parallel.
I read assistant as "croissant". Don't ask why, I don't know, myself.
I forgot what his actual name was halfway through.
Sumedha Surubhotla purple washcloth? No, no.. primrose weverdeen? Hm..
@@Diddd4444groot the funniest part for me is when he sats weasly to seconds earlier and still says some random last name.
@@Diddd4444 And in odds may the ever be your favor.
Your description of the imperius curse had me so relaxed, then you told me to subscribe. I actually laughed out loud! Too late. 😆 That's how I found this video in the first place!
Me too… ROFL
No one:
Not a soul:
Not even Voldemort:
Pumpkin Witherwings: *cAuLdROn BoTtOMs*
I heard that Hunger Games reference. Primrose Weverdean 😂😂😂
Edit: Omg thanks for all the likes! I've never gotten this many before!
Where!?
7:42
@@azzabynes5707 thx
OMG I just noticed!!!!
me too
Such a good theory!!!
PS, Purple Washcloth killed me
my only problem is
why wouldn't be tell his family that he didn't really mean the things he said, and that he was under the curse
@@sophieosu because Death Eaters have been milking that story so it’s hard to believe anyone who’s actually under it anymore
literally no one: …
My Friend : What is Ron's ministry loving, family disowning brother's name?
Me being me: Oh, do you mean Peruvian Wall clock or is it pinkie Wannabe
I dunno... to me, "cauldron bottoms!" is something you'd say when you needed to curse but there were young children present....
Oh I need to remember to use that! Love it!
😂😂😂😂
You do know that Luna's mother died from a cauldron exploding? Seems like the stability of cauldrons is valid concern. But since it's not a happy funny thing people like you ignore it, just like you whine about car inspection.
He’s my favourite GoT character: Petyr Waelish
The assistant to Bartemious Crouch: Persnickety Whippets
That sounds like distorted Lemony Snicket
@@shiaseedsalad2726 You got it, that's what I was aiming for
@@Nenjax_Anguis I knew it!
Alexander Hamilton If Lemont Snicket wrote the Harry Potter books
I figured that Percy was under the Impirious Curse, but watching this it just hit me about his connection to wormtail. Now it all makes complete sense.
Because you can't imagine Percy walking out on the people that treat him the same way the Griffins treat Meg? No, no, no people like you support abusive and toxic relationships as long as you get to laugh at the misery of the family punching bag.
You: Percy Weasley
Me: Penedict Wumberbatch
Peterborough weatherspoons is very brave I can see why he’s in griffindor
The College arm or The Drapers arm? I dont understand what you mean
What?
ha ha ha ha ha ha
god all this is so funny
i can't stop laughing
*P Sherman 42 Wallaby Way Sydney
Peterborough Weatherspoons is the perfect description for a lot of his behaviour actually 😂
Primrose Weverdeen 😂😂 that just made my day
Same me to👊🏻
I love how he’s not allowing himself to call Prefect Percy a Weasley😂😂😂
I like this theory, but as for him being a Slytherin, I can see him having the choice like Harry did. His two older brothers and parents were Gryffindors, and everybody sees Slytherin as the evil house, so I can see him asking the hat to put him in Gryffindor because he wants to be the "good guy" and also wants to share the house with his family.
While I enjoyed this video, I don't believe this theory. I see Percy as more of a parallel to Hermione's arc. They are both type-A personalities and their characters are how JK Rowling decided to showcase how differently people who live by rules react to chaos in their lives. Hermione learned that rules can be bent or broken when the need arises and that sometimes, it makes your life better. On the other side, Percy couldn't see a life without rigid rules and just wanted to hold onto any sense of normalcy that he could and he lost his sense of morality in the process.
Theory:
Percy only was under the imperious curse for a year but he thought his family will hate him since they did not know he was under the curse but after two years he worked up the courage to talk to them
Or he left an extremely toxic environment only being willing to be around them because of what was basically the end of the world. Don't believe they were toxic? Please find anything in last four years before he walked out where you could actually believe his siblings or father even liked him or that his mother only liked him because he did what she wanted.
You know, one potential nickname for Harry could be “The Great Forgiver”, one account of the fact that he is the only wizard who has shrugged of EVERY unforgivable curse.
Harry Potter:
The Boy Who Lived
The Chosen One
The Master of Death
The Great Forgiver
It’s Something to consider.
Isn’t that right Parsley Worcestershire?
I used Worcestershire too in mine
when has he used the killing curse tho?
Don't you mean Porcelain Wingding?
@@longinuscyclone213 he had the killing curse used ON him. Twice, once as a baby once in DH:2
@@ChitenBugMan I never got why they split the book into two movies, it seems so unnecessary. No hate meant, I'm just venting because IT'S ONE BOOK, NOT TWO BOOKS, AND LAST TIME I CHECKED THE BOOK WASN'T TWO PARTS! Sorry for venting and bothering you!
Friend: What was the name of Ron's older brother who worked for the ministry?
Me: Petrified wombat*
*Substitute with Painkiller Whippersnapper, Paper Wakanda, or Pacing Wagonette
Are you talking about Premium Wheelchair?
I thought it was porcupine whizbee?
@@roberthrenko5466 no it's Pudding Whisper
Gretal S Oooooh! Puppy Winner! Thanks for telling me. It was really embarrasing for me to think it was porcupine whizbee XD
Primrose weatherdeen
I actually really like this theory. It makes a lot of sense.
Pebblessnuff Wheatleaks
Your kind do hate the idea of your fantasy replacement family having any hint of being so toxic one of them just walks out on them.
You make a compelling argument. Percy loves his family, but Wormtail would know precisely how to coerce Percy into turning on them. The Imperius makes you think that doing what the caster wants will solve all the world's ills. Percy has always wanted to be a success and his father has never really wanted to do more than work in the Misuse of Muggle Artifacts Office. His doing the work of a Department Head as a first year intake should have been suspicious, but his ambition may have been well known in the Department of International Magical Cooperation. Even though Crouch never bothered to learn the kid's name, his hard work would still have drawn attention. That Percy came back to his family after Wormtail's death strengthens the argument. You did a great job presenting your arguments. Good job!
"when Voldemort and Wormtail went to rescue his son, Barty Crouch Jr." I heard that with the missed context that Voldemort was actually Crouch Jr's real father.
Seasunshld I’m sure Jr would have loved that.
Who wouldn’t want to look like a snake when they grow up?
Syntax errors are fun, aren't they?
Pisces Wimbledon being under Wormtail’s Imperius curse specifically is actually really tragic.
can u imagine being under ur pet rats curse
Colin Nguyen Pesky Wingtips
Wait a minute..... his true identity is perskins wormtail, he is related to wormtail confirmed
@@reallugia97 I'd write the fanfic
Yeah, I mean it was his pet
I litterally cried in the last book when Percy FINALLY admits that he had been a pompous prat
Percy? You mean Parsley?
Gretal S I cant tell if you’re joking or not
@@squippites7356 joking? You mean jorking?
...
@@squippites7356 ...? You mean .............?
Honestly it feels more like Percy had built up resentment of their family not having the best financial situation and a mixture of middle child syndrome. Growing up with Fred and George's antics would eat up a lot of their parents attention and then when Jenny Comes Along being not only the youngest but the only girl that his mother always wanted probably meant that especially with him being so well-behaved responsible and great in school he was easily pushed aside and ignored most of his life by his family or made fun of.
He turned on his family because they stood by Dumbledore and Harry.
You need to make a video about “how” the Marauder’s made the map. I want to know how the map sees everyone on the Hogwarts grounds.
Seamus Gorman made a great video about it. Check it out!
The Grim Creeper Im def interested in the topic, but I jus kinda dont like Gorman some reason
I am presuming that the authors wouldn't be on the map, but Serius was, so again Percy/Ron sleeping with a dead dude ...
Leo Velli same, it’s odd, isn’t it?
On the Wizarding World app it said “the maps magic includes the homonculous charm- this enables the user to track the movements of Hogwarts’ inhabitants” (Wizarding Weekly edition No. 4- discover Hogwarts, slide 7/ the marauders map)
Percy has turned into the Wizarding World's Benedict Cumberbatch
You mean parsnip has turned into the wizarding worlds Babylon cucumber?
@@MBoioi Pretty sure it's Brittleshin Castiron
Cumberland Bumberbatch?
Huh ?
Backyardstuff Coolkitchenpack?
this definitely explains a lot about Porcupine Weathersly
Lol
Or just trying to whitewash the way his father and siblings treated him which would have always resulted in them driving him way.
Misnaming Padfoot Wormtail like that each time is going to become a new hobby of mine. It reminds me of my favorite British actor, Battlefield Counterstrike.
I don't get it. his name is Pinkie Weaselsmith. who is Percy Weasley?
Pumpkin wistle
*Porky Willowshire
You're all wromg, his name is Potato Worm.
@@bri5033 pepper well
@@user-cn8xi4el6h
Paddlestick widdlesniffins.
In Percys defense: He's literally the odd one out.
Arthur - Molly
Bill - Charlie
Fred - George
Ron - Ginny
Which just leaves Percy who kinda gets left out, especially if most of them don't have the interests he does.
His pair was the 8th (3rd?) Weasley Child, between Charlie and Percy, who was killed during the first war. Explains Mr. Weasley's explanation (in the after math of the attack at the world cup) of the fear of the time, and the terror of seeing the Dark Mark above your home and knowing what is likely to be found inside. Also explains Bill's conspicuous silence and understanding to this explanation (He would have been old enough to remember the child...age 3-4 at birth, 5-6 and death).
@@rebeccageist1703 that's unfortunate 😔
@@rebeccageist1703 Never heard of that particular sibling...
@@benjaminjohannessanchez3310 I saw it once online years and years ago. Haven't been able to find it since. All I get is fanfiction stories when I look for it.
Found it... Missing Weasley Child theory, paired with Imperio'd Arthur Weasley theory.
skelkins.com/hp/archives/000128.html
(There are other theories here as well, some disproven.)
The one issue I see with this is that at the end of the second task, Percy literally runs into the water to make sure his brother is alive and warm. This doesn't seem like something someone under that curse would do.
If Percy was under curse why did hey not try break into the order
@@klaudiagrob Well you can believe whatever you want, it's fictionnal anyways. You could even argue that dumbledore is the reincarnation of dark vador that went through a tardis that went through a wormhole in space and acquired the quintessential power of Cthullhu, it would still be believable. Because, fiction.
If Ron drowned, Harry would be too depressed to continue. Wormtail understands love, even if he has never experienced it.
@@GreyPunkWolf Well, no. Fiction isn't just an anything goes wonderland lol
It has to make sense within the rules of that universe
Which none of that would
@@GreyPunkWolf😂😂😂
personally i dont think he was under the curse for many reasons. one of which is he still expressed concern and love for his family, even if it sometimes was misguided. like the letter he wrote ron, telling him to stay away from harry. obv it was wrong but from his pov he was warning his little brother of a dangerous life. why i think he choose the ministry is simply bc he was tired of never being appreciated, always being misunderstood, and having his hard work go not only unnoticed but also mocked by his family. so, instead, he chose his out. he choose to believe the sweet lies being fed to him instead of more questions and mockery from his family. thats quite understandable in my opinion, not good, but understandable. and i get why people dont see justification of his words or actions he used against his family, but i understand where he was coming from. not completely, ofc, a lot of things he did were completely out of line. however i have said terrible things to my family because i felt secluded from them, they not only didnt get me but they also never wanted to listen to me when i told them what they were doing hurt me. so i became a prat to them honestly. i feel percy did the same. he was more than tired at that point and i think the final straw was that his own father didnt think he could get a job like that in the ministry, instead, from his prospective, his father didnt believe he could do it on his own merit. and ofc from our perspective its obvious he was just being used as a spy, from his he finally got his big break, his talent finally recognized. which is quite sad. the boy was desperate for any appreciation and felt he got none (which, from what we read, he doesnt from anyone but his mum. which is complicated) which is partly why i defend percy, or at the very least share his pov. the weasleys are amazing people, wonderful and kind. but they never understood percy and i dont believe they ever tried to, 'sides molly. the twins were cruel to him, i will say, their relationship is very complex and we dont have an exact reason why or who started to feel animosity. but anyway, alls that to say i personally just think percy deserved better and if you can forgive characters who made even worse decisions than his, i think you can forgive him aswell.
Very thorough explanation. Just not entirely kind I'd say
The killing curse is arguably longer lasting than the imperius curse
Not really. Death takes an instant, and as we can see in Book 7, it doesn't *keep* you dead.
@@ovni2295 it keeps everyone except Harry dead
@@ovni2295 Dying takes an instant, death takes forever.
James Surovik forever forever
Agreed. Death lasts forever. Unless you have a certain stone
J: oH i WaNt ThAt PoTtEr BoY dEaD bUt My GoD hEs GoOd On A fIrEbOlT
Me: * dies of laughter*😂🤣
Percy, comes home for Christmas:
Mrs. Weasley: PickleyTickley Weeserton WhErE hAvE yOu BeEn?!
I'm weezing
“No note, beds empty, car gone.” “Mum, I was at school.” “You could’ve died.” “Good point, it is Hogwarts.”
@@racingfuel28 LOL
PickleyTickley omg 🤣
I read that in her voice 😂 especially the “BeEn” part lol
Regarding why Percy is a Gryffindor: he was sorted 4 years before the audience meets him. People can change. And as much as I love Fred and George and hate to point the finger at them, I wouldn't doubt that they are at least partly why Percy was burdened with being "the responsible one" once he went to Hogwarts.
As for being on the side of Umbridge, that's simple: he just didn't know what she was actually like. When Scrimgeour was trying to get on Harry's good side, he brought up Umbridge, which I can only take to mean that Umbridge didn't see fit to tell her coworkers about her habit of carving up people's hands, because Scrimgeour doesn't seem like he's dumb enough to intentionally bring up someone that he knows Harry would hate.
I swear the Weasleys are my favourite family in Harry Potter! Ron Weasley, Ginny Weasley, Fred Weasley, George Weasley, Charlie Weasley, Molly Weasley, Arthur Weasley, Bill Weasley and of course, Polychromatophilia Wappenschawings (That's an actual word)
Do you mean Peedileedileedileddle Wangwot?
Or maybe polarnotnobodycares whatinthewod
Or or Popplerpicklerpimplepeck Winklewhatwhywhenwhere
"The hardest thing you'll ever do, is tell someone you're sorry"
"Prozle Weaseltown is a very..."
"Weselton! It's Weselton."
Sorry. I'm hyped for Frozen 2 coming out!
Was about to make that same joke! 🤣
@@salemstowaway7927 you have a good taste then, my friend!
Yas!! I was waiting for a comment like this!
Im excited too!
Ronin 28 my son was in frozen jr as Olaf
Guinea Pigs Unite I’m exited too
Someone. What's the name of that very smart Weasley? Me. Oh, you mean Peanut Brittle Wiskers?
How did Snape (or anyone) CREATE a spell? Like do they concentrate on what they want it to do and say it enough (maybe with the wand movements) until it works or something? Idk
Spells can’t be created, you just discover lost/forgotten ones
@@tmorris7329 Then how did they become lost/forgotten? Who created them originally?
I think this level of magic needs at least a Bachelor in magic to explain. Unfortunately the books never go past high school level. Try sending an owl to an MM (Magus Maximus) and see if they can give an explanation. I doubt these Squibs without any formal education could make a proper video about it.
@@tmorris7329 Except it's outright stated that Severus Snape created Sectumsempra. And the fact that the notes for it were in the margins of his Potions Textbook would tend to indicate that he created it while he was a student at Hogwarts. That's also why he and he alone knew the counter for it to save Draco and protect himself from it when Harry tried to use it on him.
@Phoenix137 It's probably very complicated and involved and requires a Witch or Wizard of extraordinary power. And we know that Snape fit all of those categories.
5:50
One curse
Two curse
Red curse
Blue curse
You forgot about purple washcloth
Yeah
I'll be honest, Percy is one of those HP characters that I forget even EXISTS a lot of the time. I mean, he'll be gone for a while, then he'll show up and I'll go "oh, I forgot he was in this one".
Tht how he is for me
Same
I was actually heartbroken when Pink Wallaby sent back his Weasly jumper in the fifth book, but now i'm happy that it was just the imperius curse. :)
Oh yeah, so horrible the exact same kind of sweater that he got the moment he stopped growing. So horrible to not want something from the toxic family. PROVE the Weasleys weren't a toxic family to him, find anytime that you could genuinely believe his siblings and father even liked him or that his mother didn't just like him because he did what she wanted.
"He cursed, she cursed, we cursed, me cursed"
Why can't I stop laughing?
The Killing Curse doesn’t cause you pain, it just kills you.
Ethan Devall
Quicker than falling asleep
Jonathan Maderos we cant be sure if this is accurate because it is Sirius that says this and he was no killed by the killing curse he was killed by the veil
anna fuller well the Movies went off in a different way in that area. Lestrange Hit him with the killing curse and he fell into the veil rather than just being hit by a curse and the veil taking him. So perhaps he meant the movies not the books.
KucklePuff yeah perhaps I was just saying. Especially because most people consider books = canon. But yeah in the movies it could be that way!!
Yeah. There isn’t even any forensic evidence left. It just ends your life with no other cause of death
Certainly seems like Pinky Wishies could’ve been under the Imperious Curse.
I also think Percy’s rule following shows how a susceptibility to authority figures which seems like it might also make him more susceptible to a curse that gives someone authority over his choices…
lol im imagining effie trinket calling Primrose Weverdeen at the reaping and percy stepping forward and then katniss saying "boi u can go die in the hunger games"
Rons snobby brother??
Oh! You mean Pretty Princess Wilber of Wadger Way??
Yes him
I actually dislike this theory. I feel that Percy's Arc of trusting the wrong people and making mistakes but owning up to it and apologizing is important. So few people it seems can do that today.
Same. Imerpius curse seems like a cheat and takes away his character development
Takes away from his character development and the narrative tensions within the Weasleys. If he was under the curse it would ruin the narrative at the end with Fred. I don't think J thinks about narrative and character development when he makes videos in favor of wanting to explain anything that doesn't make sense to him.
I agree that percys arc is important but I still think they did great research
Agreed. I see the merit for the theory, but yeah, I think the only spell he was under was the spell of the allure of money and power. As a guy from a poor and underappreciated family, he saw a way to success and respect (which he got none of at home).
Ya i can see that
I know this is an older video, but i do want to address something. Crouch does not use Percy's proper name, but he does consistently call him "Whetherbee" unlike Slughorn who used different names for Ron. I think Percy either goofed in his introduction, or intentionally used a different name. I am more inclined to believe the former because Crouch clearly respects Arthur.
I think it works better for him NOT to be under the curse. Sometimes people screw up and make bad choices. It's important to be able to see your mistakes and seek forgiveness.
People also walk out on their toxic family and yet they are the ones in the wrong for no longer pretending that there was anything healthy in the entire relationship. Can you actually find any moment in the first 4 books where you could truly believe that Percy's siblings or father even liked him?
Friend: It’s Percy Weasley!
Me: It’s Public Whippersnapper!
*Peckerhood Winklestein
*parchment wangsoleman
Ferfect one
Purple Weaselbean?
Plastic War? Potato washer? Pickled Willow?
Got a kick out of the mispronunciations of Parrothandle Wasobi.
You mean Parsley Worcestershire?
*Peckerhood Winklestein
hooray poop noises
Peeper Worplay you mean?
I think it's pronounced Pickle Wylashes
Padomp westlebee
Perty wallumbee
Pooty wadumoop
These were the funniest names I could think of lol 😂
Whats Ron's brothers name again? The head boy:
Others: Percy Weasley
Me: Perzle Westleplum
Hmm.... yes.
Pomegranate Waffles.
Actually, that sounds pretty good right now. . .
That's sounds delicious.
Percy wetherbee for goodness sake
No no it is wentleman porefanmick
Oh yes! 😂😂😂😂
I think everyone, even J.k. Rowling herself, did Pencety Witthernings(Percy Weasley) dirty. She made him do all those things and then he didn't have much that redeemed him. So, I agree that it is possible he was under the imperius curse. If he wasn't, then everyone did him dirty.
The Weasleys did nothing to redeem themselves as a healthy family. If they weren't toxic do you really think it would've been so easy for him to cut them out for three years? Oh please, I beg you and everyone like you, PROVE the Weasleys didn't deserve to have Percy walk out them. PROVE that at any point before he had enough of them that his siblings or father even liked him.
I love how j could have piced any other video or pic of bardy crouch/moody but no he picks the ferret/malfoy 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Seamus: Hermione is not under the imperious course
SCB: Percy is under the imperious curse
Edit : lol TH-cam is broken or something I got 117 likes
they go together
Perry Johanson
Peter Johnson
(Those are actually all fake names for Percy Jackson, but like, who cares?)
More like Dionysus intentionally miss-saying his name cause he doesn't like heroes and he's gone WAYYY too long without a glass of wine, but the same idea.
Schnuller
I like it, you know your Percy Jackson stuff!
Bad Boy Supreme!!!!!!!
Schnuller 😍
You must save Olympus Pedro!
It was frightening how much I enjoyed your voice and the feeling it gave me as you were describing what the imperious curse felt like. The tingles down my spine as I just gave in... it was .. . bliss . . .
I happen to like paramount waffles. Perpetual Window takes a bit of getting used to, but he has a redemption arc.
Or is it an abuse victim just accepting his abusive family and their treatment of him that went on LONG before he walked out on them because the narrative says they are best simply because the worship Main Character?