Just watched the Dave Grohl interview from a couple months ago... When he said as a child he could hear how Carly and Mick's voices combined made a "chord" when he heard this song on the radio, I said to myself... "They must have played a different "duet" version in his radio market, because as far I was concerned, Carly was the only person singing on this song." Of course now it became incredibly obvious why some people succeed very well with music and others struggle. The fact that he could hear that when he was 7 or 8 years old in his mother's Maverick completley blows me away, because those cars (like most in the 70's) were mono and had one crappy speaker in the dashboard... Simply amazing.
Like any other skill or language, ear training can be learned. You didn't hear Mick's voice because you did not expect to hear it. If you expect to hear Nagger "ghosting" the chorus on this song, I bet you will hear it. I will say that we all have different brains that give us a natural affinity for certain disciplines.
My lady loves to do Sudoku. She reads Calculus textbooks for fun! 😑 She has a "Math" brain. I have a mental block against Mathematics. If I am forced to do it, I can do it on the 2nd or 3rd try as I did in college when I took Algebra & Trigonometry 3 x! I think my mental block to math started with my math teacher, Mr. Caspari, in 7th grade.
Mick’s name is in the credits on the album as backup vocals and as well as Paul and Linda McCartney and other people mentioned as backups on various songs in the No Secrets album. Remember ?
I can only discern Mick's voice in the chorus, and that was because I was consciously trying to hear it. If no one told me that Mick Jagger sang on this track, I would have gone to my grave not knowing that, and that would've been fine with me. He is so buried in the mix they could've gotten anyone to sing it and it would still be a great song. It's all Carly! 😍
Just heard this song for the first time a few days ago. As soon as I heard it I was hooked. As a Stones fan, as soon as I heard the chorus, I knew that was Mick’s voice. His vocal timbre is so unique, I’ve never heard someone with a sound even close to his. So cool to hear how well they blend in isolation. Their voices really complimented each other.
I can hear the differences in their delivery. Carly ends each line smoothly sliding to the finish, dragging out the note a bit. Mick delivers his line staccato, with a sharp attack and sudden ending like a machine gun.😎
Could someone please put the timestamps, on when Mick’s voice actually comes in background. From what I can determine, its only a very very small fraction of the song. I think the song would’ve been number one with or without Mick’s very faint background singing.
Another song you can listen to to hear vocal "ghosting," is The Doors song "Riders On The Storm." If you listen carefully to the chorus, you will hear Jim ghosting himself. He clearly sings "Riders on the storm," and then he "whispers," "riders on the storm." That's another one where once you hear it, you will never "unhear" it. 😉
The whispering you hear on Riders on the Storm was Jim Morrison's last recording with The Doors. His overlay was his last track. He died a few weeks later in Paris. Once you hear it, you can't unhear it. Incredible song.
This was played all the time on AM radio (there was no FM yet) when I was a kid. That's right no internet, no cell phones, no pushbutton phones And no FM. My son thinks I'm joking. 🤔
There was always FM, but most of the pop stations were AM. FM stations started popping up in the late 1960s as music started to break from the template of songs 3 minutes or less.
What’s even more interesting is how Carly once explained in an interview that she found herself falling into singing “you’re so vine” as opposed to ”you’re so vain” due to being influenced by Mick’s verbal twang while they were singing….
And to think the night before her wedding to James Taylor, Bianca Jagger called to let James know that her husband and Carly were having an affair. The most shocking thing in that story to me is that Bianca had James Taylors' phone number..lol
what a horrible idea that was mick was edited out in a lot of it, there is a few areas where you can make out micks voice, the guy is no soprano and could not harmonize with anybody that was the difference between the Beatles and The stones, the stones was flat out raunchy rock and roll, the beatles were about Harmony
What is that sound at 1:22? Sounds like a disgusted 'ugh'. "When you said we were such a pretty pair, UGH, never leave." 🙀 Absolutely never heard that sound in the song before. I love it MORE now 😻🤣😻🤣
This is NOT Mick Jagger's "isolated vocal track". As such, this TH-cam vid is a SHAM. It is Carly Simon's vocal track, with Mick Jagger's voice buried deep down in the mix. Forget it.
The title read, "Isolated vocal track: Mick Jagger singing on Carly Simon's "You're So Vain" (1972)" Notice the colon " : ". It is not the same as using the preposition " of ". The rest of your assessment is correct as one can barely discern Mick's voice. The video is not a sham, but your fake indignation is.
@@RandallJacques Are you O.K. in the mind department? If I use the colon, it has a distinct meaning: it explains what went before. Just like the colon I just used thirteen words before. Your fake comments is just that: fake. Oops, I used a colon here.
Just watched the Dave Grohl interview from a couple months ago... When he said as a child he could hear how Carly and Mick's voices combined made a "chord" when he heard this song on the radio, I said to myself... "They must have played a different "duet" version in his radio market, because as far I was concerned, Carly was the only person singing on this song." Of course now it became incredibly obvious why some people succeed very well with music and others struggle. The fact that he could hear that when he was 7 or 8 years old in his mother's Maverick completley blows me away, because those cars (like most in the 70's) were mono and had one crappy speaker in the dashboard... Simply amazing.
Same! I’m like, huh?!?! Is he mistaken? Let me look this up lol
I hear layered harmony vocals. I wonder how often Dave hears three voices when there are only two?
I never had a problem to identify Mick Jagger's voice in the song.
It was a no brainer.
Like any other skill or language, ear training can be learned. You didn't hear Mick's voice because you did not expect to hear it. If you expect to hear Nagger "ghosting" the chorus on this song, I bet you will hear it.
I will say that we all have different brains that give us a natural affinity for certain disciplines.
My lady loves to do Sudoku. She reads Calculus textbooks for fun! 😑 She has a "Math" brain. I have a mental block against Mathematics. If I am forced to do it, I can do it on the 2nd or 3rd try as I did in college when I took Algebra & Trigonometry 3 x! I think my mental block to math started with my math teacher, Mr. Caspari, in 7th grade.
DEFINITELY, Unmistakenly, Mick in the background.
Especially every time he belts out, “Doan Chew, Doan Chew, Doann CHEWWWW..?”.
👍
.
Can't wait to share this to my X, he didn't believe me when I told him I heard Mick in this song.
Thx for the opportunity for a "told you so" moment.
Rise above it, allow the cream to come to the top!-)
..sometimes it's more fun to swallow the cream
Mick’s name is in the credits on the album as backup vocals and as well as Paul and Linda McCartney and other people mentioned as backups on various songs in the No Secrets album. Remember ?
I wonder if Mick, Carly and other celebrities go on TH-cam and watch videos of themselves?
Whenever you add a spoon of Mick, everything tastes better.
Billy burr brought me here
Could you link the vid?
I can only discern Mick's voice in the chorus, and that was because I was consciously trying to hear it. If no one told me that Mick Jagger sang on this track, I would have gone to my grave not knowing that, and that would've been fine with me. He is so buried in the mix they could've gotten anyone to sing it and it would still be a great song. It's all Carly! 😍
🌴🌴< < < PERSONALLY I DIDN'T HEAR NICK'S VOICE OR MICK JAGGERS > > > 🌴🌴
@@TRICK-OR-TREAT236 With all those people you think you'd hear some of them
@@hyzercreek Nick Jagged rocks.
Oh gosh I always heard Mick even before I knew. I think he's VERY obvious
That wasn't me. I typed "Mick's" and smart-ass AUTO-CORRECT changed it to "Nick's." Computers are very FAST and very STUPID! 😅@@TRICK-OR-TREAT236
Mick's voice and style is so distinctive
Just heard this song for the first time a few days ago. As soon as I heard it I was hooked. As a Stones fan, as soon as I heard the chorus, I knew that was Mick’s voice. His vocal timbre is so unique, I’ve never heard someone with a sound even close to his. So cool to hear how well they blend in isolation. Their voices really complimented each other.
DEFINITELY, Unmistakenly, Mick in the background.
Especially every time he belts out, “Doan Chew, Doan Chew, Doan CHEWWWW..?”.
👍
.
Their voices surly did, Compliment one another. I loved this!❤
How could anyone not know it was Mick! Dang - her voice and performance sounds great.
Wonderful, Beautiful, Amazing 👏🏽 😍
I can hear the differences in their delivery. Carly ends each line smoothly sliding to the finish, dragging out the note a bit. Mick delivers his line staccato, with a sharp attack and sudden ending like a machine gun.😎
Could someone please put the timestamps, on when Mick’s voice actually comes in background. From what I can determine, its only a very very small fraction of the song. I think the song would’ve been number one with or without Mick’s very faint background singing.
Mick's vocals takes this song to a higher level of ear-pleasure to me.
I'm a bigggg fan of Carly Simon and Mick J. The sound and
blended together sooo well. This is the 1st time I've heard this, I loved it!!!
Don't think Mick comes in until the 2nd chorus. You can hear him clearly - especially on headphones 🙂
Brilliant harmonized singing!!!!
Grohl Brought me here
Just phantasmagorical !
Natuerlich hat Mick damitgemischt.....😃😃😙
TY . i've always struggled to actually hear MJ's distinctive vocals , they shud've been placed more prominently in the audio mix .
You can hear Mick Jagger better on the regular record
I quickly recognized the vocal as being Mick Jagger when wearing headphones on first listen when the song and album were originally released. 🤷
Deffo Mick Jagger there !!
I can't hear it for all the over dubbing of Carly Simon interfering
Another song you can listen to to hear vocal "ghosting," is The Doors song "Riders On The Storm." If you listen carefully to the chorus, you will hear Jim ghosting himself. He clearly sings "Riders on the storm," and then he "whispers," "riders on the storm." That's another one where once you hear it, you will never "unhear" it. 😉
The whispering you hear on Riders on the Storm was Jim Morrison's last recording with The Doors. His overlay was his last track. He died a few weeks later in Paris. Once you hear it, you can't unhear it. Incredible song.
i heard his voice on a hunch and it led me here lol
I thought it was me. Damn
I could hear Mick Jagger better without the Isolated voice.
I always thought that part was sung by James Taylor, but it's absolutely Jagger. Thanks for posting it.
Kann ich mir gut vorstellen,vdass Carly ins Beuteschema von Mick Jagger gepasst haette???
This was played all the time on AM radio (there was no FM yet) when I was a kid. That's right no internet, no cell phones, no pushbutton phones And no FM. My son thinks I'm joking. 🤔
There was always FM, but most of the pop stations were AM. FM stations started popping up in the late 1960s as music started to break from the template of songs 3 minutes or less.
Play him the song AM Radio by Everclear!
I just watched Ms. Simon on a CBS morning show 2015, comment that it is indeed Mr. Jagger.
Things go better with Mick!!! Not Coke.
How did you isolate these voices from the recording?
splitter.ai/
WOW!!
Jagger may have been there but Carly's voice soared right over his
She's an amazing singer but to be fair he was a back up singer. Back up singers shouldn't be the main focus of a song.
Of course it soared over his, he is the back up singer here...what did you expect?
Yes but ...
That's because it was mixed that way.
as it was supposed to.
Total eclipse of the sun.
What’s even more interesting is how Carly once explained in an interview that she found herself falling into singing “you’re so vine” as opposed to ”you’re so vain” due to being influenced by Mick’s verbal twang while they were singing….
All TH-cam version of Micks voice are buried. In a car & on the radio Mick comes through. Radio taped Mono versions? Car speakers separate more?
I know it’s not about me. I hate to watch myself gavotte.
And if you have high blood pressure, you could be really Vein
🙄
The Reverb tail on Carly's voice in verse is abruptly short. Otherwise, ty 4 track.
And to think the night before her wedding to James Taylor, Bianca Jagger called to let James know that her husband and Carly were having an affair. The most shocking thing in that story to me is that Bianca had James Taylors' phone number..lol
what a horrible idea that was mick was edited out in a lot of it, there is a few areas where you can make out micks voice, the guy is no soprano and could not harmonize with anybody that was the difference between the Beatles and The stones, the stones was flat out raunchy rock and roll, the beatles were about Harmony
What is that sound at 1:22? Sounds like a disgusted 'ugh'. "When you said we were such a pretty pair, UGH, never leave." 🙀 Absolutely never heard that sound in the song before. I love it MORE now 😻🤣😻🤣
I knew it! Lol
Jagger damned autocorrect! 😣
Mick's
no, i am a lymph vessel...
Knowing that Mick sang on a track, i hear it right away!
This is why so many people think the song is about him. It's not; it's about Warren Beatty.
Carly said it's about three men and just the second verse is about Warren.
I've heard it's about three guys -- Mick Jagger, Warren Beatty, and David Geffen.
Great!
Song is about mick
Nein, tut er nicht.
Sounds like he's saying 'me' towards the end
I don't hear it, but it would have been clever of him.
@@ericdailey8587
Very clever, yes. Perhaps I just wanted to hear it 😂
I can’t really say that it amounts to much. It could be almost anyone singing there with her. Although CARLY SIMON can say that she out-sung MICK J.
Almost forget, THANKS for posting this. It has a certain NOSTALGIA value.
Not really that difficult. Mick never had a potent or resourceful voice, he made up for it by putting a lot of personality on his singing
It's called a backing vocal for a reason. It's backing. If it was two lead vocals, it would be a duet.
he is not supposed to out sing her don'
t you think ?
I always thought that was James T!
This is NOT Mick Jagger's "isolated vocal track".
As such, this TH-cam vid is a SHAM.
It is Carly Simon's vocal track, with Mick Jagger's voice buried deep down in the mix.
Forget it.
The title read, "Isolated vocal track: Mick Jagger singing on Carly Simon's "You're So Vain" (1972)" Notice the colon " : ". It is not the same as using the preposition " of ". The rest of your assessment is correct as one can barely discern Mick's voice. The video is not a sham, but your fake indignation is.
@@RandallJacques Are you O.K. in the mind department? If I use the colon, it has a distinct meaning: it explains what went before. Just like the colon I just used thirteen words before. Your fake comments is just that: fake. Oops, I used a colon here.
I can hear his accent when he says Don't Chew🙂
The title is misleading. "Mick Jagger singing on" should be deleted from the title.
remove head from sphincter then speak