I've always felt there was a was a sense of mysticism in the series, right from when Claire and Frank landed in Scotland. Geills and Claire had a bond so it's no wonder she could sense it was her, to live between two worlds, two time periods. To be able to live Claire's life, wow!!!! To see the Castle in it's ruin state only to come back and see it in it's heyday!!
@@NyuTenshi yes, when they examined the bones, Geillis still alive in twenty century.. and Claire didn't know yet that Jamie was alive...to go back to the past to him... and kill Geillis... Geillis was alive in presente, would travel to the past and be killed there by Claire, who had examined her bones while she was alive in present...what a mess....🤪
Everyone is commenting on spoilers, I have to admit I haven't read the book but I came on to TH-cam knowing there would be spoilers if I watched clips from a series I haven't seen yet it's just common sense. So for the ones who are sarcastically saying 'thanks' u really should thank yourselves
Even in the books ,I couldn't successfully wrap around it,am I to believe Claire clearly knew whose skeleton it was whilst not having been to the Caribbean at this space;time;reality. Let's face it she appeared guilty as it comes when Dr Abernathy confronted her. I mean she's preparing to go back through the stone and not gone yet.
She didn’t know it was Gailis or that she had actually killed her herself in the past. She just had a time traveler spidey sense about it. They don’t call her The White Witch for nothing.
I have never read the books but as soon as this scene happened I guessed it was gaelis. just seemed obvious to me, I always had a feeling she was going to come back at some point. out of 100 wrong guesses of whats going to happen in the show, I got 1 thing right, so im aloud to boast and be proud about it lol
Gabaldon gives you that impression in Outlander. However, Dougal MacKenzie saves her from the flames and she's pregnant with his child, but we find this out much later. Geillis is a notorious sorceress in Paris, while Jamie and Claire are there, but they don't encounter her. She is known as Madame Melissande and is acquainted with Raymond and the Compte Saint Germain. J&C hear of Madame, but don't realize that she and Geillis are one and the same. Madame is not received in polite society.
Geillis doesn't appear in "Dragonfly." In a later book, possibly "Voyager" or even later, we learn of her Parisian life in the shadows. Geillis and Jamie and Claire moved in completely different circles during their Paris period. It's been so long since I read the books, I've forgotten exactly where this is revealed.
I am new to this show just watched season 1&2 on Netflix and I love it. Never read the books. When I saw gaelis in the final episode of season 2 I must say I was surprised cos I assumed she was excuted after being convicted of witchcraft.
I’m actually quite confused as to how this time travel thing works. Those bones are geillis’s we know that know. But how did Claire receive them first in 1968, without first going back to the 18th century🤔 and killing her first. In addition to time travel in reading and watching, I’ve understood that destiny has already been written by a higher power and you can’t stop it, but one has to first physically complete the action.
it's closed loop time travel. Here Claire is seeing the effects of what she WILL do she just doesn't know it yet... it's explained better in the books but Claire, Jamie, Bree, and especially the kids have all exhibited a certain level of SECOND SIGHT Jamie and Briana have dreams occasionally Bree's children have a sort of telepathy with each other. Claire most often ignores hers but she gets these kind of waves of SENSING like when she picked up the skull... Sorry that was really long but it's the way I understand the set up I hope it helped
Not a book reader here. Just wondering if Geillis was burned at stake in her 20's in the tv show, how could she be in the Caribbean 20 yrs later to be murdered?
I'm confused! so she goes back after this scene and she kills Geillis after she goes back. But how does she know so much about these bones before she even went back and killed Geillis??? I'm so confused.
It's part of her gift/powers, in the books, Joe says Claire is one of the best diagnosist he's met. She even had a flash vision of green eyes in the book, Geillis' eyes she'll realize later. Even the Master Raymond/apothecary music in the background helps portray the fact that Claire has more mystic power than she realizes
EmSePet20 ohhh I see! It's just so confusing for people that haven't read the books. Me and my friends were all talking about this scene and we were all clueless. Thanks!
@@Sophia-qp2pf Yeah, I don't think the show did this scene very well. Then again, it's hard to SHOW what someone's thinking when they're trying to hide their thoughts from someone. The book makes it more clear that Claire knew the deceased was a "pretty lady" from the high cheekbones and symmetry of the face, and sensed that the dead woman was surprised by her death, which made Claire the deceased "didn't want to die" and therefore was murdered. And she saw a flash of green eyes. But she didn't know the identity of woman yet so there's no reason for Claire to be acting so weird and cagey.
You may want to change the title Ella for the non-book readers. Or put the spoiler in the description box, cause I have a feeling people are going to get upset. lol
Oh my lord.... I thought for sure this was going to be a mistake so I went to the comment section to figure out why the author would just assume it was Geillis. This is insane! I've read the first two Outlander books and have learned that no small detail is unimportant. I always wondered why this would be included in the book as a past review and wondered even more why the show made it so important with that eerie background music. It wasn't casual at all and they made it painfully obvious that it was more important than just a bone review. I DIDN'T REALIZE THIS WAS GONNA EVEN BE A THING.
Terminal Velocity yes the time travel thing always sucks... In Harry Potter part 3 too.. if harry saw his father first time saved him in the forest then he time travelled he saved himself not his father... Then in Harry Potter part 7 they tell us it's actually Professor Snape who created that spell for harry to protect him... So confusing time travel thing...😂
Im confused. How did Claire know that this was Geillis from the very first moment? Did she just felt it or assumed it? I haven't read Voyager so please try not give away anything. I only know that in the end Claire is somewhat responsible for this. Please can someone explain to me? How on earth did she knew?
basijuu I already know that. That's not what Im asking. She killed her after she went back to find Jamie. At this scene she is in 1968 before she leaves and she already knows about the bones?
So sorry for the spoiler i thought i changed it, but it i didn't! i fixed it now, sorry again!
I've always felt there was a was a sense of mysticism in the series, right from when Claire and Frank landed in Scotland. Geills and Claire had a bond so it's no wonder she could sense it was her, to live between two worlds, two time periods. To be able to live Claire's life, wow!!!! To see the Castle in it's ruin state only to come back and see it in it's heyday!!
When i first saw this scene i was like can that be her bones 😳 she touching her own bones i was freaked out lol i forgot all about Gelis
Isn't it twisted that Geillis is still alive in Scotland at the same time that Claire is checking her bones? Like...there are two Geillis at once
Ringeryl ooooooo yea that creepy lol
@@NyuTenshi yes, when they examined the bones, Geillis still alive in twenty century.. and Claire didn't know yet that Jamie was alive...to go back to the past to him... and kill Geillis...
Geillis was alive in presente, would travel to the past and be killed there by Claire, who had examined her bones while she was alive in present...what a mess....🤪
Omg I thought the same 😂😂
It wasn’t Claire’s bones
Imagine if they search her dental patterns... they would knew she traveled in time..
I am disappointed they did not point out the state of the teeth.
Everyone is commenting on spoilers, I have to admit I haven't read the book but I came on to TH-cam knowing there would be spoilers if I watched clips from a series I haven't seen yet it's just common sense. So for the ones who are sarcastically saying 'thanks' u really should thank yourselves
exactly!
Exactly like what do you expect
Even in the books ,I couldn't successfully wrap around it,am I to believe Claire clearly knew whose skeleton it was whilst not having been to the Caribbean at this space;time;reality. Let's face it she appeared guilty as it comes when Dr Abernathy confronted her.
I mean she's preparing to go back through the stone and not gone yet.
SHIRLEY Shine wasn’t Gesa in the Caribbean married and widowed by a Mr. Abernathy. ?? Dr. Abernathy is related to the same I bet.
She didn’t know it was Gailis or that she had actually killed her herself in the past. She just had a time traveler spidey sense about it. They don’t call her The White Witch for nothing.
She knows.. but doesn’t know either! This beautiful 😍
ah hello there Geilis Duncan Bones fancy seeing you here creepily foreshadowing the 2nd half of the season
Never read the books not there yet but watching this scene I thought perhaps it was Claire's bones especially when she reached for her neck
Kalani Landgraf I thought it might be at first but then I realised the age would be wrong.
Read them they have more than TV is showing they are great
Oh my gosh same!✋but it turns out to be Gellis.
@@carolinesalv Spoiler Bitch?
@@schnubbel76 Yes asswipe!
I have never read the books but as soon as this scene happened I guessed it was gaelis. just seemed obvious to me, I always had a feeling she was going to come back at some point. out of 100 wrong guesses of whats going to happen in the show, I got 1 thing right, so im aloud to boast and be proud about it lol
She came back into the show as bones 🤣
This was definitely in Voyager the book. Those bones are significant and this is very spooky!
indeed it is!
It was in the book. But she didn't know that the bones was from Geilis. Claire killed her later (in the 18th century) in the cave.
Gabaldon gives you that impression in Outlander. However, Dougal MacKenzie saves her from the flames and she's pregnant with his child, but we find this out much later. Geillis is a notorious sorceress in Paris, while Jamie and Claire are there, but they don't encounter her. She is known as Madame Melissande and is acquainted with Raymond and the Compte Saint Germain. J&C hear of Madame, but don't realize that she and Geillis are one and the same. Madame is not received in polite society.
lemorab1 why don't I remember this :'(
It's been so long since I read the books that I have forgotten lots, including Geillis being in Paris.
Geillis doesn't appear in "Dragonfly." In a later book, possibly "Voyager" or even later, we learn of her Parisian life in the shadows. Geillis and Jamie and Claire moved in completely different circles during their Paris period. It's been so long since I read the books, I've forgotten exactly where this is revealed.
I am new to this show just watched season 1&2 on Netflix and I love it. Never read the books. When I saw gaelis in the final episode of season 2 I must say I was surprised cos I assumed she was excuted after being convicted of witchcraft.
livelove &laugh it’s bc the 60’s wereGaelis’s original time
I’m actually quite confused as to how this time travel thing works. Those bones are geillis’s we know that know. But how did Claire receive them first in 1968, without first going back to the 18th century🤔 and killing her first. In addition to time travel in reading and watching, I’ve understood that destiny has already been written by a higher power and you can’t stop it, but one has to first physically complete the action.
it's closed loop time travel. Here Claire is seeing the effects of what she WILL do she just doesn't know it yet...
it's explained better in the books but Claire, Jamie, Bree, and especially the kids have all exhibited a certain level of SECOND SIGHT Jamie and Briana have dreams occasionally Bree's children have a sort of telepathy with each other. Claire most often ignores hers but she gets these kind of waves of SENSING like when she picked up the skull...
Sorry that was really long but it's the way I understand the set up I hope it helped
The skull belong to Geillis,when she was decapitated by Claire
Not a book reader here. Just wondering if Geillis was burned at stake in her 20's in the tv show, how could she be in the Caribbean 20 yrs later to be murdered?
Dougal mckenzie saved her from the stake
kristienification WHOA!!!!! I'm a fairly new Outlander fan and have started Voyager. WOW!!!! Now I can't wait to find out more!!
Wait and see what’s going to happen it’s a journey😱🤐🤐🤐🤐🤐
Gellis escaped w Dougal at cranesmrere. Then she traveled back through stones
I'm confused! so she goes back after this scene and she kills Geillis after she goes back. But how does she know so much about these bones before she even went back and killed Geillis??? I'm so confused.
It's part of her gift/powers, in the books, Joe says Claire is one of the best diagnosist he's met. She even had a flash vision of green eyes in the book, Geillis' eyes she'll realize later. Even the Master Raymond/apothecary music in the background helps portray the fact that Claire has more mystic power than she realizes
EmSePet20 ohhh I see! It's just so confusing for people that haven't read the books. Me and my friends were all talking about this scene and we were all clueless. Thanks!
@@Sophia-qp2pf Yeah, I don't think the show did this scene very well. Then again, it's hard to SHOW what someone's thinking when they're trying to hide their thoughts from someone. The book makes it more clear that Claire knew the deceased was a "pretty lady" from the high cheekbones and symmetry of the face, and sensed that the dead woman was surprised by her death, which made Claire the deceased "didn't want to die" and therefore was murdered. And she saw a flash of green eyes. But she didn't know the identity of woman yet so there's no reason for Claire to be acting so weird and cagey.
Geillies bones
It was really shocking for me knowing that the bones were Geillis
You may want to change the title Ella for the non-book readers. Or put the spoiler in the description box, cause I have a feeling people are going to get upset. lol
you're so right! i'm sorry changing it now!
Yes, please do. I don't read the books and this was just spoiled for me. I'm very upset now.
It's still up.
Yep, I haven't read the books yet because I'm enjoying watching the series unfold, but you just spoiled this for me.
Oh my lord.... I thought for sure this was going to be a mistake so I went to the comment section to figure out why the author would just assume it was Geillis. This is insane! I've read the first two Outlander books and have learned that no small detail is unimportant. I always wondered why this would be included in the book as a past review and wondered even more why the show made it so important with that eerie background music. It wasn't casual at all and they made it painfully obvious that it was more important than just a bone review. I DIDN'T REALIZE THIS WAS GONNA EVEN BE A THING.
Yes I agree, you should change the title. I've read the books and know, but would hate to ruin future episodes of the story for others.
Why are they not looking at the bones in a medical office...?
Spoilers in the comments for those who haven't read the books! Also you should really change the title of the video.
How she could identify Geilis bones, although she still hadn't changed history regarding Geilis fate
Is this skeleton Claire's??? Found in Caribbean cave (may be it's abandawe the sacred cave)... As a fortune teller said to her abandawe devour ye..
Terminal Velocity
yes the time travel thing always sucks...
In Harry Potter part 3 too.. if harry saw his father first time saved him in the forest then he time travelled he saved himself not his father...
Then in Harry Potter part 7 they tell us it's actually Professor Snape who created that spell for harry to protect him... So confusing time travel thing...😂
Lady Jane und Jo 💖💖💖
Does he think she was alive over a century ago and murdered someone?
Im confused. How did Claire know that this was Geillis from the very first moment? Did she just felt it or assumed it? I haven't read Voyager so please try not give away anything. I only know that in the end Claire is somewhat responsible for this. Please can someone explain to me? How on earth did she knew?
PopyStella Tsitou Claire killed her in that cave
basijuu I already know that. That's not what Im asking. She killed her after she went back to find Jamie. At this scene she is in 1968 before she leaves and she already knows about the bones?
That is good question. I don't know it yet :)
basijuu thanks anyway :)
In the books, all Claire saw was a vision of green eyes and the emotions that came with them, but not necessarily who's they were.
you should warn for the spoiler nor everybody read he book
the*
oh well thanks for the spoiler mate -___-
sorry sorry and again sorry i always forget!
Claire is a White Lady after all lol
Those are Geillis dead bones
SPOILER ALERT!!!!!???
geillis duncan 😨
This is a big spoiler