To be honest, since the start of MAGA 6 minutes is a stretch for the length of time one can hold the average Americans attention span. CNN likely should dumb it down quite a bit further to reach the MAGA group of Americans. Perhaps they could handle 2 minutes so long as there were no big words or references to the unprepossessing looks on their faces.
@@roberthaynes488 "To be honest"... "the length of time one can hold the average" British "attention span" is less than 30 seconds. A tiny island that is no longer (since like 1951) a world power. Still haven't comprehended how insignificant they are.
The over 600k casualties for Russia is nothing considering how much population they have gained from the occupied territories and the fact they could stomach losing 25 million people in ww2. The don't value life like the Anglos do, so never think high casualty rate is something that bothers the Russian leadership.
@@lilacfloyd I don't get anything but I'm sure most of the comments on here of the kind "Absolutely the finest military analysis I have ever heard" are paid for by someone. Ukrainian psyops or perhaps Clarkies colleagues at RUSI
Zelenskyy is the reason why Putin doesn't have Ukraine. He is also the reason why we Americans have gotten behind Ukraine. Ukranians should understand that. I have nothing but respect for the guy who said he didn't need a ride. Any other leader would've left the country.
@@RyanBrown-nx8dwRyan, have you been smoking RT propaganda? Negative comments without supporting data. We learned this in high school back in old days. Zelensky was the best president Ukraine ever had, possibly the best I have seen worldwide since Reagan.
I think you like the sound of his voice than what he is actually saying . He is a certified fraud as a war analyst , according to him Ukriane should of been on the border of Crimea end of summer 2023
Haha Honorable 😂 old man is getting paid handsomely to spread lies about Russian losses and hide Ukrainian losses. He never mentions Ukrainian losses which is more easy to get the information as they are on same side. Cope!!
his goal to help but unfortunately he is over optimistic and don't analysis base on battlefield for this reason always his opinions are more wishes rather than a way or prediction and usually he were wrong and the situation get worse, again i know he is good guy and want to help but lack of battle experience and right analysis made his opinion just basic and wishes unfortunately,
@@s0ycapitan Both highly respected in their fields, highly qualified with very impressive and long CVs while you post clickbait for a potato. Very impressive work. Your controller will soon be feeding stray dogs in Kursk. 👏 👏 👏
@@s0ycapitan Well that was a bit harsh... This isn't my go to sources of news but its good to hear all the voices... and I'm glad they're talking about it.
@@davefave4351I am not sure about highly qualified, but qualified may be. Highly qualified expert like Mearsheimer can still be wrong. World renowned geopolitical expert, Mearsheimer, still argues NATO was at fault for triggering Ukrainian invasion by Russia for threatening Russian security. Mearsheimer forgets or disregards self determined will of Ukrainian people. Does security need of regional power override will of truly democratic people? Nobody outside the top military decision makers of Ukraine knows what the objective of Kursk counterattack. I would consider General Hodge or exCIA director Patreaus as highly qualified, yet they state they don’t know what is the objective and has different opinion than Clarke. I would take Clarke’s concern as a concern
reporting from ukraine is 100 times better .. maybe you should look around before you start thinking clarke is napoleon bonaparte for speaking common sense
Well the slow walking of everything doesn't help , Let's just say, no you can't have x system , for a year or 2 , when you could make best use of it . And then finally hand it over in dribs and drabs , Give Ukraine the tool to win , when they need them ..
Ukraine has been strategically foolish. 1/ virtually no border defenses in Kharkiv. 2/ Digging straight line trenches amateurish. 3/ Producing no Tanks, some tanks are better than no tanks. 4/ Tank stores can be eliminated.
Ukraine is not a member of NATO, so its «partner» are in no way forced to help it. A «victory» of Ukraine under its actual condition will provoke its total destruction. Ukraine should think about its condition of victory.
The weak minded 'escalation managers' remind me of Robert McNamara in Vietnam who lost that war. USAF for instance wasn't allowed to attack SAM sites until the were operational!
Occasionally I realise just how lucky we are to have access to videos like this. Most of the time I take it for granted but boy wouldn't I miss it if it suddenly wasn't there. Two first class people in this one
Let´s always remember Putin calls leveling a city of 70.000 people to the ground, 70.000 lives, children, women, elderly, he calls it "denazification". Let´s never forget this!
@@s0ycapitan No there were still a great many civilians left in every city Russia has flattened. In particular Mariupol where estimates of civilian casualties range from 20, 000 to 100, 000. The estimations are so varied because Russia won't allow access to outside observers.
I don't think the oligarchs are going to allow Putin to come back next spring for another campaigning season. This is costing them too much economically & politically at home. I think we'll see negotiations some time after November 1st.
You dream a lot. You know, one funny thing about you westerners is the folly of judging other people and society through the lens of western society. As far as the Oligarchs are concerned, they have no say in Putin's decision to stand up to the arrogant West.
The oligarchs work for putin and manage his assets for him. They work at his behest. Once you get that, you will realize that the oligarchs have no interest in replacing putin. The replacement, the chaos, and the changing of guards will not be good for their health. They really don't care what happens as long as they get their cut.
I think the oligarchs are too scared of windows to tell Putin what to do. But there is the possibility that some might to think I need to get him before he gets me.
@@campion04 I m guessing you don't have an answer to my question. That's ok. I don't either, but I think there should be mechanisms in place to protect people.
You had no problem with what USA were doing to Irak ? With what Ukraine was doing in Donbass either ? Who said «Their children will starve in cave» ? Putin ? You can't expect a whole people to die without them trying to defend themselves. Calling Russia to help was their right.
Kursk allows Ukraine to move missiles and drones closer to vital military infrastructure and to Moscow. Experts have consistently under estimated Ukraine and it’s pretty rich to then say they "may not really understand their objective in Kursk". They took a good size chunk of Russia that they will be able to hold. By the time Putin moves assets there in serious numbers, they will be dug in like ticks and all winter long they will hammer Moscow with their new missiles.
They can't dig in like tics because Russia is nailing them them. I doubt Ukraine hold all the ground it claims - most reports are small sqauds of Ukranian infantry in some jeep. Racing to as many undefended towns to pose for selfies putting up new flags. The Russian army is like a Machine that Ukraine cant stop. The machine industry of Russia is supplying them with 10-1 artillery advantage, 6-1 atleasat for drones, They have more men, more ammo are better paid, They have total air superiority above the areas of significant combat. If you have made it this far just let me say, there is a whole side of the war you don't see. Information is power and anyone who hides information from you is doing you harm.
Do you have any idea how many Patriots and HIMARS ukraine lost after Kursk? That too in Sumy region and were meant to support their troops inside Kursk. Btw if you ever looked at map, invading Bryansk would have allowed Ukrainians more possiblities to target Moscow or Norther cities like Bryansk. I guess they just wanted to reach Kursk NPP.
How can Zelensky possibly show the Americans that he "has a route to a settlement which would be a victory ..." when the Americans refuse to allow him the weaponry, and the freedom to use it. which could make that possible? That's like expecting to win a lottery without buying a ticket.
Fighting with aid against an enemy with much of everything, how do you expect dem to win. You are clueless. Russia and united state are the two lost powerful nuclear power. What do you think will happen if the untied and nato Helo defeat Russia? You think Russia will just pack up their bag and call it a day? Lol unfortunately Europe, United and Russia won’t exist anymore. Total destruction
@@Ode-to-Odysseus Millions left Russia, economy is on the floor. His country is ruined and it's basically all his fault. The state will adapt and see Putin as a traitor to the Russian people in time. Future Russians will look on him in disgrace as well as his hero Stalin someday.
Clarke says Zelenskyy's not popular last report he had dropped in popularity but was dtill around 65%. As for "insisting " full mobilisation he was pushed many times and eventually the bill passed but it is fo over 25 year olds. Tough conditions and misinformation from russia infect Ukraine.
That isn't full mobilisation. He needs to get 18-24 year olds into uniform, not 60 year olds. He should also be mobilising women and encouraging 16-17 year olds to volunteer. In WWII Britain had 14 year olds serving by lying about their age. Doctor Who was caught lying about his age when he received a medal at 14. The general giving out the medal shook his hand and said "well done lad, I did the same thing myself."
My lady friend works in a pharmacy right next door to the institute in Poltava that was hit with missiles. She was still in shock a week later. We are talking about thousands of people who were not killed or even wounded but were terrorized by these missile strikes. It’s terrible
If the doubling of the Czech ammo program actually arrives, then the Russian salient toward Pokrovsk is in for a pounding. All this time I certainly hope that electrical transmission ties between Ukraine and friendly neighbors have been increased. Generating plants require more time to repair than transmission systems. There has been time for the West to build small generating systems the size of shipping containers that can be set up in a distributed fashion and connected to the electric distribution system where most needed. They cannot provide power to all customers all the time, but getting several hours a day to heat water, do laundry, cool down the refrigerator, etc. is still helpful and good for morale. I doubt the Russians have been preparing this capability for this coming winter. Ukraine and Europe together can be shaping the future of the European electric energy system through this conflict.
The Russian «salient» is actually 50 km wide of defensive lines and elite troops with superior artillery, drone support and logistic. Easy to draw a line on a map, more difficult to do it.
@@dalecrocker3213 Zombie. And the Katyn forest massacre was made by the Nazis. We all know how the Stalinist tricks are back. I pity you, if you are not a bot. But a human bot, anyway.
Military aid sent to Ukraine compared to each country's defense budget Danemark: 71% Sweden: 68.8% Estonia: 47.8% .... USA: 3.9 % Source: Kiel Institute for the World Economy - SIPRI
Northeastern European nations should do more since they are getting free soldiers for their own defense. America can do more but America does so much more everywhere too. How much are NE Euros supporting war in Israel and Philippines? How much were NE NATO members spending for the real defense? Real defense as in infrastructure, weapon systems, and trainings, not including salaries and buildings. Not even 1% for half century. People like Tristan divide and weaken NATO.
@@kulkrafts3143 Northeastern european nations spend about 5% of their GDP in defense. So, they are doing more than the USA w.r.t. their GDP. And in their support to Ukraine, they are above 35% of their military budget when USA is below 4%.
I love how so many people say the U.S is not giving them enough aid, rediculous! We should give them all out money, who cares that they carton of eggs is 4 bucks. Maybe I'd ot was your money you would keep giving them money. Ukraine is still very corrupt. I know for a fact that a lot of that mone😊t is going into a lot of people's bank account
Maybe Ukraine's army suffers from the Soviet doctrines that dominated. It hasn't had time to chnage since the first invasion in 2014. Ukraine wanted to move toward the West but it was also burdened by Soviet style corruption. Both military tactics and civil institutions have been attempting to improve while under fire. When I think that they only gained independence in 1991 had two citizen uprisings chased a Russian puppet president out faced a takeover in Crimea and russian backed separatists in Donbas, elected a young inexperienced president and faced a full on invasion of their sovereign territory, I wonder how they have dine so well. This is the basis of every story ever told. Facing insurmountable odds and against all expectations with so many doubters critics traitors and usurpers, the Ukrainians keep going. We are witnessing in real time the forging of a new nation but more we are witnessing resilience and the strength it takes to survive. We cannot let them down because we would be giving up on a very intrinsically human idea.
The Russian backed separatists weren't backed as much as didn't exist until Russian Espionage created them by paying gangsters to form the nucleus and then bolstered them by recruiting the jobless. To that we can add FSB agents such as Igor Girkin who immigrated into the area after having done the same in Tranistra Moldovia. Russian espionage has corrupted western right wing jounalism just as it corrupted politics in Georgia, Ukraine etc.
Russia is already going thru a demographic crisis. The population is shrinking because of lack of natural reproduction (not enough kids) and people fleeing the country (one million men since 2022).
The kursk offensive IS successful in removing manpower from the donbass. Not only is every single man sent to kursk not sent to pokrovsk, nor is any other man who will now be sent to other parts of the border to prevent future incursions. Does it have an immidiate effect? Yes, to some extent in some less prioritiezed areas of the fronrline. But in the long term, yes! I believe, that if Ruzzia do not mobilize, they will find themselves to be streched quite thin, and thereby have a hard time to find reserves to replenish their losses.
Russia has a special recruitment offer on six month for those that want to fight only in Kursk. Basically 25000 men signed last month. They are building an task force ad hoc to put the Ukrainian away. The force they diverted from donbass didn't even affected the rotation of the troops there. They have too much men for the entire front.
Anyone arguing Russia will "win" at this point (whatever that means these days) is basically a parody, and should be laughed out of any serious discussion on the conflict. The Ukrainians are taking settlements in Kursk in dominating fashion from the Russians, and the Russians may (eventually) take Pokrovsk, and that's supposed to be a big momentum changer? Just accept you've lost Russia. This is just dumb.
Settlements in Kursk? Look at Kursk on Google maps there's nothing there but tiny villages and farmland, Sudzha the largest settlement captured had a population of 5000, Russia is capturing cities, towns and fortifications in Donetsk that stood since 2014.
@@dalecrocker3213 "most mineral-rich pieces of land in he world" -- That's good, for the Russian Oligarchs, shame the average Russian won't feel the effect of this magnificent "liberation"
Russian troops are better equipped than a lot of NATO ones. Look at what they have in the kharkiv oblast for exemple. They have basically more drone, more shell, more ammo, more vehicles. Their logistics work.
@@ad-ko5iy You are free to believe what you want. If Russian soldiers are equipped better than NATO, and Ukrainian soldiers are fighting with old donated weapons from NATO, then Ukrainian soldiers must be super hero’s and Russians soldiers are weak little girls. Three day special operation is almost three years and Ukrainian is taking Russian mainland now.
@@kulkrafts3143 what mainland it kursk is wilderness The war is not a war of aggression like operation desert storm, it is a war of attrition where men and resources are grinded till the end. Russia is already the biggest country in the world why would they want to defend more territory
Well according to Times Radio, which you clearly believe they have lost more men than have actually been involved in the war. So they must have lost already.
When rebuilding starts ,i would like to see localised ,house by house independance with water, electricity ,and food grown ...the tech is available for this now ...i often think that if all the clever ideas for recycling and production of our needs were shared ,we could survive. And thrive despite putin style idiots wrecking everything
If you listened to Clarke since the beginning of the war, you'll know that he has consistently made over-optimistic assessments, sometimes untethered to on-the-ground reality. This approach to narrative over fact has made the loss worse, imo.
For russia to declare war due to the kursk incursion would mean they have the right to use nuclear weapons. Putin knows that thats why he wont but rather calls it a counterterrorism operation. The nukes are for america and nato not for ukraine.
I didnt know that a comedian is on radio show too. LOL I will come here if i want to laugh when i am feeling down. This guy is great at talking nonsenses. :)
The Russians are in the same boat , regarding the winter. If a Ukrainian push to the reactor in kursk is made, they can force a cold shut down there, severing the electricity to a vast swath of the Russian south from Rostov southward. And with Ukrainian drones picking off Russian oil and gas facilities the Russians won't find winter pleasing as the roads leading south are now in direct fire of Ukrainian missiles and drones. So truck delivery for oil and gas ,along with arms will effectively be neutered.That plus the bottleneck in Sudzha to the west now in Ukrainian hands, Russia will pray for a very light winter. However, that will not occur. And with exports down and Ukraine having a hand on the shut off valve, Russia will freeze.
@@ailinofaolin8897 Sigh, power lines are extremely easy to bring down. In fact, power lines are not even defensible. In WW2, it was hard to hit them. Many drones are designed specifically to inspect power lines. Many are fairly autonomous. How would you like to be the repairman on a high-tension line and watch an FPV drone approaching you?
@rajeshkanungo6627 You're talking about disrupting a nuclear power station inside Russia, the complete lack of self awareness on the insanity of such an endeavour from yourself is astounding.
@@ailinofaolin8897 , no one is talking about attacking a nuclear power station itself except for the Russians who are messing around with one. They also dug trenches in Chernobyl. I bet the Ukrainians are far brighter than the Russians. The attack entails disrupting the grid by destroying the outgoing power lines. One doesn’t need to be close to the power plant. Ukraine is close enough to toy with the transmission lines. The Russians did hack Ukraine’s power grid in 2018. It is just a shock to the Russians that someone would actually attack them.
The main goal is to stop Russian infrastructure. At present the interim goal is the kursk power plant. The kursk power plant is the provider for the vast southern area of Russia. And with cooler weather approaching, a sizable disruption in provision would make an elegant buffer for Ukraine against further incursions or build-up coming from rostov von don which is the Russian southern command area as power would be a measured asset for the russians in the southern regions. The resultant power projection would be neutered and with subsequent destruction of the road/rail bridge into Crimea, any movement along the southern Ukrainian border is delayed, permitting a development of further defense fortifications. It is a peer, pat poker hand. Russia cannot retreat without embarrassing the military or political agenda but must or lose the military stationed there as they cannot resupply them. And in a transitional environment like a war, effective supply and replenishment is an essential commodity. But fortifying a defensive parimeter around kursk and forcing the plant in a cold state while disabling key non serviceable portions, it delays repair and this at a time during winter. Further hampering Russian citizens and making plain the assertion that the strike is commercial, environmental and most importantly economical. Especially with the devastation of the oil service facility in Rostov Oblast. The winter months will be critical for Russian citizens in the south. The base premise for this, is the vast oil reserves under the Luhansk Oblast and Donetsk Oblast provinces. Which russia sees as an economic choke point for their ability to make money. At present there is no competition. But with the eventual end of hostilities, russia's loss of these Ukrainian oblasts would hamper the economy of russia (and oligarchies) control of fuel to the west. Remember the older soviet transport fuel lines (and newer russian lines) are already in Ukraine . By keeping these oblasts and Crimea they gain the warm water ports of the black sea and by fiat a negotiated easement of passage thru the Turkish held straits without recourse. The real reason for this war. Money.
Yes, for his "Efforts", but not the facts. Propaganda, that will push the world into the 3rd World War. How many conflicts the US started at the same time? Because of this, how many countries got the courage to distance themselves from US expansionist acts?
Russia invaded a weak country 1/5th its size that hasd been kept disarmed and neutral by the west. Ukraine fought back and its allies started to help. Now there are Russians complaining about being bullied by NATO and its so unfair for 28 (now 30 counters)
I would walk on my lips through broken glass to spend 10 minutes in her presence. Kate is gorgeous, and so sharp. And thank you, Michael Clarke, for your depth of knowledge, and incisive commentary.
Putin though it would be easy to invade a nation 1/5th Russia's size that had been kept disamred by western nations to placate Russian demands. But the Ukrainians fought back (they remember 1922 and 1932) and Ukraine allies helped. Now Russians complain of being bullied by NATO. How pathetic and how delusional.
@@stephenlyon1358 Russian soldiers will be cold. We've already seen how poorly equipped they were last winter. There is no reason to believe this will improve this year. Meanwhile, Ukrainian soldiers will continue to receive a ton of aid, including things to keep them warm.
@@stephenlyon1358 The Ukrainians will be served hot meals from Ukrainian homes. The Russians are far away, and their logistics can be attacked. Think of the Winter war in Finland. Look up the Sausage War.
exactly, i don't Care he is talking because he wants to help but he is over optimistic and analysis not base on reality and battleground so he always wrong and his analysis is more like wishes rather than predicting
Was prof Mikhail Clarke wrong when he said that russia won't have this when we went into Kursk? He said they'd be gone in 2 weeks. 2 months on, we're still there! I think he's learning!
Brit realist here. An interesting assessment and commentary. But let’s face it; Russia occupies about 18% of Ukrainian territory. The Ukrainian incursion into Kursk has occupied only 0.0076 of Russian territory. The Russians occupy about 108540 sq km of Ukraine; Ukraine occupies about 1300 sq km. It’s been a fantastic propaganda move, but, in relative territorial terms, it’s little more than a fleabite. Putin knows he’s going to get it back at some stage anyway, that’s merely a matter of time. So he’s prepared to put up with a bit of a media setback (all exaggerated by the western press anyway, in the interest of clickbait titles) in order to concentrate his efforts on the really big prize, the Donbass. If he gets that (and probably keeps Crimea) then he can claim he’s achieved his objectives and won the war, and that will maintain him in power until his death. Ukraine is doing an amazing job in this war, especially emasculating the Russian Navy and knocking out oil depot after oil depot, etc…. and that’s a great long-term strategy, but whether they can keep that up to make a strategic difference will only become apparent in the future. And even if the individual Russian is now suffering, it’s also little more than an inconvenience, and most of the older ones had it much worse before in Soviet times. Even if the economy is temporarily set back to pre 2014 levels, that’s still infinitely better than anything they had under Soviet rule. Russia made massive leaps forward in the first 15 years of Putin’s rule, as I saw myself during many visits; that’s not going to go away. It's up to the west to stop pussyfooting around and do what they should have done from the start; support Ukraine in order to win the war.
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 85 | คู่เอก "ยอดเหล็กเพชร vs ผึ้งหลวง"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Qq_19bnnxEo/mqdefault.jpg)
Good questions asked, clear answers given. As always a pleasure to listen.
Times getting more out of Clarke in a 1/2 hour interview than CNN with its 6-minute newsbites. Thanks for the interview!
To be honest, since the start of MAGA 6 minutes is a stretch for the length of time one can hold the average Americans attention span. CNN likely should dumb it down quite a bit further to reach the MAGA group of Americans. Perhaps they could handle 2 minutes so long as there were no big words or references to the unprepossessing looks on their faces.
What a con former Marshall this bloke is😅. When ever Russia gains territory its always a loss a thousand men and 100s of vehicles!!! 😂
@@roberthaynes488 "To be honest"... "the length of time one can hold the average" British "attention span" is less than 30 seconds. A tiny island that is no longer (since like 1951) a world power. Still haven't comprehended how insignificant they are.
The over 600k casualties for Russia is nothing considering how much population they have gained from the occupied territories and the fact they could stomach losing 25 million people in ww2. The don't value life like the Anglos do, so never think high casualty rate is something that bothers the Russian leadership.
If only any of it were true...
Thank you for your insights Professor Clarke.
So good to see, and hear from Kate Gerbeau again. She's such a good interviewer.
Professor Clarke was interesting.
How much do you get paid to write this drivel?
@@s0ycapitan Less than you.
@@lilacfloyd I don't get anything but I'm sure most of the comments on here of the kind "Absolutely the finest military analysis I have ever heard" are paid for by someone.
Ukrainian psyops or perhaps Clarkies colleagues at RUSI
@@s0ycapitan I reckon you'd be better off listening to Konashenkov's drivel, my dude.
@@lorenzcassidy3960 maybe people don't like banderite propaganda....my dude
Brilliant analysis. Thank you again Kate and Mr. Clark. God Bless you both.🌻💜🌻💜🌻
Zelenskyy is the reason why Putin doesn't have Ukraine. He is also the reason why we Americans have gotten behind Ukraine. Ukranians should understand that. I have nothing but respect for the guy who said he didn't need a ride. Any other leader would've left the country.
Ur not very smart r u😂😂😂😂😂
@@RyanBrown-nx8dwRyan, have you been smoking RT propaganda? Negative comments without supporting data. We learned this in high school back in old days.
Zelensky was the best president Ukraine ever had, possibly the best I have seen worldwide since Reagan.
@@RyanBrown-nx8dw just look at her face. Untermensch
Excellent comment (original post). Ignore the Russian bots.
@@RyanBrown-nx8dwagree Ryan, they are delusional 😂😂
Thanks for this brilliant analysis
A pleasure to listen to honourable professor Michael Clarke. Thank Timesradio
I think you like the sound of his voice than what he is actually saying . He is a certified fraud as a war analyst , according to him Ukriane should of been on the border of Crimea end of summer 2023
Haha Honorable 😂 old man is getting paid handsomely to spread lies about Russian losses and hide Ukrainian losses. He never mentions Ukrainian losses which is more easy to get the information as they are on same side. Cope!!
his goal to help but unfortunately he is over optimistic and don't analysis base on battlefield for this reason always his opinions are more wishes rather than a way or prediction and usually he were wrong and the situation get worse, again i know he is good guy and want to help but lack of battle experience and right analysis made his opinion just basic and wishes unfortunately,
Kate & Mike are the best Ukraine current War Information Source, when combined as can ever be found on Planet Earth !!!
No they aren't.
Clarkie is wilfully ignorant a lot of the time and Kate would be better suited to celebrity gossip.
@@s0ycapitan
Both highly respected in their fields, highly qualified with very impressive and long CVs while you post clickbait for a potato.
Very impressive work. Your controller will soon be feeding stray dogs in Kursk.
👏 👏 👏
@@s0ycapitan Well that was a bit harsh... This isn't my go to sources of news but its good to hear all the voices...
and I'm glad they're talking about it.
@@davefave4351I am not sure about highly qualified, but qualified may be.
Highly qualified expert like Mearsheimer can still be wrong. World renowned geopolitical expert, Mearsheimer, still argues NATO was at fault for triggering Ukrainian invasion by Russia for threatening Russian security. Mearsheimer forgets or disregards self determined will of Ukrainian people. Does security need of regional power override will of truly democratic people?
Nobody outside the top military decision makers of Ukraine knows what the objective of Kursk counterattack. I would consider General Hodge or exCIA director Patreaus as highly qualified, yet they state they don’t know what is the objective and has different opinion than Clarke. I would take Clarke’s concern as a concern
reporting from ukraine is 100 times better .. maybe you should look around before you start thinking clarke is napoleon bonaparte for speaking common sense
Now we know where Mr Nathanho learn who to lie this is a good professor
The problem with UFA is not lack of strategy, but lack of western support.
😮 $200 billion is not enough? 🤦
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Well the slow walking of everything doesn't help ,
Let's just say, no you can't have x system , for a year or 2 , when you could make best use of it . And then finally hand it over in dribs and drabs ,
Give Ukraine the tool to win , when they need them ..
Ukraine has been strategically foolish.
1/ virtually no border defenses in Kharkiv.
2/ Digging straight line trenches amateurish.
3/ Producing no Tanks, some tanks are better than no tanks.
4/ Tank stores can be eliminated.
Ukraine has been foolish in many areas, producing no tanks is just one.
Great interview, the two top people in their fields.
The greatest problem for ukraine is the weakness of it's partners in nato who have not seriously unified and given ukraine the ability to win
as described since the beginning by General Hodges who has the uncanny ability to be right before anyone else
Ukraine is not a 'partner' of any Nato nation none of whom have any obligation whatever to supply them with anything.
Ukraine is not a member of NATO, so its «partner» are in no way forced to help it.
A «victory» of Ukraine under its actual condition will provoke its total destruction. Ukraine should think about its condition of victory.
I hope You already signet as volunteer?!! Before ask to go and day same one else...
The weak minded 'escalation managers' remind me of Robert McNamara in Vietnam who lost that war. USAF for instance wasn't allowed to attack SAM sites until the were operational!
Bill Slim. Good call. Exactly the right inspirational leadership for such an appalling situation.
Slava Ukraine 🇺🇦
God Bless 🙏🙏🙏 Ukraine with Victory and Justice ⚖️⚖️⚖️
Satan will bless Ukraine we all know it whats wrong with you ?
Ukraine woould be very unwise to change Zelenski
I reckon Ukraine needs to stop fcukin around and go full mobilisation, total war footing, everywhere is a target.
Zelensky should have let the democratic process happen and hold an election - he is essentially a dictator.
Best so far for any Ukrainian presidents. May be the best president in last several decades on the planet.
@@kulkrafts3143 yep the best one at destroying his country 😂
Constitution keeps the president until Ukraine de-occupied!
What a bunch of garbage .. does anyone believe that ?!
JAKE SULLIVAN allow Ukraine to conduct the war and you sit down and shut up. Just give them what they ask for.
An American.
AGREED!!! 💙Slava Ukraini!!!💛
I am sure your comment on youtube will make a difference
The vagueness of Russian commentators is so widespread it's obviously deliberate
@@Matty94 His comment is better than yours!!! NEVER TRUMP/MAGA/RUSSIA!!!
Sullivan and scholz are just the 2 most miserable creatures living in west!
Occasionally I realise just how lucky we are to have access to videos like this. Most of the time I take it for granted but boy wouldn't I miss it if it suddenly wasn't there. Two first class people in this one
Thanks ❤Amazing interview!
Slava Ukraine! AMERICANS STAND WITH UKRAINE!🇺🇦🇺🇸
America is blocking for Ukraine to use long range missiles against russia unlike fx Denmark. Get your finger out America..
smart Americans don't )
@@VadimBolshakov
i see u are also not blind like me
:)
most stand for peace not Ukraine!✌
Let´s always remember Putin calls leveling a city of 70.000 people to the ground, 70.000 lives, children, women, elderly, he calls it "denazification".
Let´s never forget this!
The civilians have left before the heavy artillery move in.
Currently the roads out of Pokrovsk are jammed with evacuees.
@@s0ycapitan No there were still a great many civilians left in every city Russia has flattened. In particular Mariupol where estimates of civilian casualties range from 20, 000 to 100, 000. The estimations are so varied because Russia won't allow access to outside observers.
Some people stay because they have nothing else, even the elderly 😢
Animals ,people will continue to died even after the war.
@@s0ycapitanRight, Russia targets civilian buildings in populated cities across Ukraine. Give your head a shake.
Best stand up comedy. THanks.,
A bit scary for shift workers, isn't it?
They are losing but grinding forward 😂
Excellent. Authoritative. Informative analysis.
It wold be great to have a debate between Michael Clarke and Donal MacGregor becaues that would ultimately reveal things.
You are always so informative Mr. Clarke.
I don't think the oligarchs are going to allow Putin to come back next spring for another campaigning season. This is costing them too much economically & politically at home. I think we'll see negotiations some time after November 1st.
You dream a lot.
You know, one funny thing about you westerners is the folly of judging other people and society through the lens of western society.
As far as the Oligarchs are concerned, they have no say in Putin's decision to stand up to the arrogant West.
The oligarchs work for putin and manage his assets for him. They work at his behest. Once you get that, you will realize that the oligarchs have no interest in replacing putin. The replacement, the chaos, and the changing of guards will not be good for their health. They really don't care what happens as long as they get their cut.
I think the oligarchs are too scared of windows to tell Putin what to do. But there is the possibility that some might to think I need to get him before he gets me.
This is so informative, thank you.
Just wait a week and all words here are worth nothing !
How does the world think it's ok for one country to do this to another? Just insane.
You going over to stop them?
@@campion04 I m guessing you don't have an answer to my question. That's ok. I don't either, but I think there should be mechanisms in place to protect people.
@@arau8310 All what countries can do in today’s world is get nuclear wapons, in case they sit down at negotiating table! Sad, isn’t it?
You had no problem with what USA were doing to Irak ? With what Ukraine was doing in Donbass either ? Who said «Their children will starve in cave» ? Putin ? You can't expect a whole people to die without them trying to defend themselves. Calling Russia to help was their right.
You mean atrocities of USA toward Indians? or Britain in China and Africa?
Kursk allows Ukraine to move missiles and drones closer to vital military infrastructure and to Moscow. Experts have consistently under estimated Ukraine and it’s pretty rich to then say they "may not really understand their objective in Kursk". They took a good size chunk of Russia that they will be able to hold. By the time Putin moves assets there in serious numbers, they will be dug in like ticks and all winter long they will hammer Moscow with their new missiles.
They can't dig in like tics because Russia is nailing them them. I doubt Ukraine hold all the ground it claims - most reports are small sqauds of Ukranian infantry in some jeep. Racing to as many undefended towns to pose for selfies putting up new flags. The Russian army is like a Machine that Ukraine cant stop. The machine industry of Russia is supplying them with 10-1 artillery advantage, 6-1 atleasat for drones, They have more men, more ammo are better paid, They have total air superiority above the areas of significant combat.
If you have made it this far just let me say, there is a whole side of the war you don't see. Information is power and anyone who hides information from you is doing you harm.
🤣
Thankfully they were stopped taking the nuclear power station
good chunk
very funny
it less than 1 percent of Rus
Do you have any idea how many Patriots and HIMARS ukraine lost after Kursk? That too in Sumy region and were meant to support their troops inside Kursk.
Btw if you ever looked at map, invading Bryansk would have allowed Ukrainians more possiblities to target Moscow or Norther cities like Bryansk. I guess they just wanted to reach Kursk NPP.
Professor Michael Clarke is the best. Thank you.
Yes, He has best stand up comedy in the world. Thanks.
0:54 Thank you for your confidence in the ukrainian army ! Mike ! Rubble
How can Zelensky possibly show the Americans that he "has a route to a settlement which would be a victory ..." when the Americans refuse to allow him the weaponry, and the freedom to use it. which could make that possible? That's like expecting to win a lottery without buying a ticket.
The lack of consistent western aid if forcing Ukraine to build its military arsenal.
😔
Fighting with aid against an enemy with much of everything, how do you expect dem to win. You are clueless. Russia and united state are the two lost powerful nuclear power. What do you think will happen if the untied and nato Helo defeat Russia? You think Russia will just pack up their bag and call it a day? Lol unfortunately Europe, United and Russia won’t exist anymore. Total destruction
Ukraine would have won this war in the first year if it had gotten all the neccesary aid immediately
@@christiandauz3742 It's possible. However, many of Ukraine's generals were taught by the Soviet Union and continue with that practice.
Bill Slim. Thanks.
People who think that Ukraine is winning are living in denial. They seek comfort in subjective reality and ignore all the facts
Very balanced overview by a real expert. Far better than some of the hurray henry's interviewed on this channel. Thank you.
Russia has already lost... They can never take Kyiv.
Exactly but they aren't that smart.
@@Ode-to-OdysseusIs lost ?
? Ukraine can never take Moscow. But ya full conquest is off the cards I guess.
@@Ode-to-Odysseus Millions left Russia, economy is on the floor. His country is ruined and it's basically all his fault. The state will adapt and see Putin as a traitor to the Russian people in time. Future Russians will look on him in disgrace as well as his hero Stalin someday.
@@petervanwyngaard4788Both.
Great job Mike!!!
More synthesis from Professor Michael in 30 minutes than in weeks of indie TH-cam.
I agree. Although I would sooner call it AI TH-cam instead of indie TH-cam. :)
Excellent review ☺️
Slava Ukraini 💙💛
Clarke says Zelenskyy's not popular last report he had dropped in popularity but was dtill around 65%. As for "insisting " full mobilisation he was pushed many times and eventually the bill passed but it is fo over 25 year olds. Tough conditions and misinformation from russia infect Ukraine.
Higher rating than most Western leaders in their own countries, I‘m sure! :/
That isn't full mobilisation. He needs to get 18-24 year olds into uniform, not 60 year olds. He should also be mobilising women and encouraging 16-17 year olds to volunteer.
In WWII Britain had 14 year olds serving by lying about their age. Doctor Who was caught lying about his age when he received a medal at 14. The general giving out the medal shook his hand and said "well done lad, I did the same thing myself."
Ukraine needs more ammunition and weapons compared to soldiers
NATO should pardon convicts in exchange for them volunteering in Ukraine for 2 years
Zelensky is an idiot.
My lady friend works in a pharmacy right next door to the institute in Poltava that was hit with missiles. She was still in shock a week later. We are talking about thousands of people who were not killed or even wounded but were terrorized by these missile strikes. It’s terrible
I was in the military walking 600 meters day under fire is not my idea of surging.
😂😂👍
You never fought in a peer to peer war then
@@DS9TREK If you plan on fighting a fair fight in a war you are the idiot.
@@DS9TREK I thought Russia was the 2nd best army in the world? They seem to be the second-best army in Kursk.
@@DS9TREK How many Peer-to-Peer enemies have you fought on your PC? War Thunder can be tough when you don't have Mountain dew and a bag of chips.
Exceptional❕
How can we in the West let this go on???? Innocent civilians 😢
That's what I keep wondering!
Very easy answer, Exactly the same as the West allows the genocide in Gaza to go on totally unopposed.
well, west has started it, so idk how... They said themselves that they will fight till last Ukranian
What would you do.
If the doubling of the Czech ammo program actually arrives, then the Russian salient toward Pokrovsk is in for a pounding.
All this time I certainly hope that electrical transmission ties between Ukraine and friendly neighbors have been increased. Generating plants require more time to repair than transmission systems. There has been time for the West to build small generating systems the size of shipping containers that can be set up in a distributed fashion and connected to the electric distribution system where most needed. They cannot provide power to all customers all the time, but getting several hours a day to heat water, do laundry, cool down the refrigerator, etc. is still helpful and good for morale. I doubt the Russians have been preparing this capability for this coming winter. Ukraine and Europe together can be shaping the future of the European electric energy system through this conflict.
Long before the war Ukraine was ALWAYS a massive tech hub. Lots and lots of computer scientists and engineers.
Smart people.
The Russian «salient» is actually 50 km wide of defensive lines and elite troops with superior artillery, drone support and logistic. Easy to draw a line on a map, more difficult to do it.
You have been winning since day 1 so whats the problem
The Mariupol bombing was against the Theatre, being used as a shelter, with the inscription 'Children' on the ground outside.
A PR stunt. It was blown up from the inside by the Azov Brigades.
Yes it was Horrific! These 'people' are no better than the German Nazis.
Absolute crazy..give proof before making such assumptions. @dalecrocker3213
@@dalecrocker3213 Zombie. And the Katyn forest massacre was made by the Nazis. We all know how the Stalinist tricks are back. I pity you, if you are not a bot. But a human bot, anyway.
I suppose you'll say Bucha was a case of mass suicide?
Military aid sent to Ukraine compared to each country's defense budget
Danemark: 71%
Sweden: 68.8%
Estonia: 47.8%
....
USA: 3.9 %
Source: Kiel Institute for the World Economy - SIPRI
oh interesting, how is germanys input
@@chaitai2533 Germany' number is about 16%
Northeastern European nations should do more since they are getting free soldiers for their own defense.
America can do more but America does so much more everywhere too. How much are NE Euros supporting war in Israel and Philippines?
How much were NE NATO members spending for the real defense? Real defense as in infrastructure, weapon systems, and trainings, not including salaries and buildings. Not even 1% for half century. People like Tristan divide and weaken NATO.
@@kulkrafts3143 Northeastern european nations spend about 5% of their GDP in defense. So, they are doing more than the USA w.r.t. their GDP.
And in their support to Ukraine, they are above 35% of their military budget when USA is below 4%.
I love how so many people say the U.S is not giving them enough aid, rediculous! We should give them all out money, who cares that they carton of eggs is 4 bucks. Maybe I'd ot was your money you would keep giving them money. Ukraine is still very corrupt. I know for a fact that a lot of that mone😊t is going into a lot of people's bank account
Maybe Ukraine's army suffers from the Soviet doctrines that dominated. It hasn't had time to chnage since the first invasion in 2014. Ukraine wanted to move toward the West but it was also burdened by Soviet style corruption. Both military tactics and civil institutions have been attempting to improve while under fire.
When I think that they only gained independence in 1991 had two citizen uprisings chased a Russian puppet president out faced a takeover in Crimea and russian backed separatists in Donbas, elected a young inexperienced president and faced a full on invasion of their sovereign territory, I wonder how they have dine so well.
This is the basis of every story ever told. Facing insurmountable odds and against all expectations with so many doubters critics traitors and usurpers, the Ukrainians keep going.
We are witnessing in real time the forging of a new nation but more we are witnessing resilience and the strength it takes to survive. We cannot let them down because we would be giving up on a very intrinsically human idea.
You need to face reality, it's over, even the Foreign minister is high-tailing it, leaving Z with a bunch of yes-men in the bunker.
@@ciaranryan5265 You are very optimistic about Russia's future.
Would you mind if I use your last 2 paragraphs in a paper?
The Russian backed separatists weren't backed as much as didn't exist until Russian Espionage created them by paying gangsters to form the nucleus and then bolstered them by recruiting the jobless. To that we can add FSB agents such as Igor Girkin who immigrated into the area after having done the same in Tranistra Moldovia. Russian espionage has corrupted western right wing jounalism just as it corrupted politics in Georgia, Ukraine etc.
That was a good read
💙💙💙
💛💛💛
Only about 1800 boys are born each day in Russia, Putin is throwing away 1100 men a day in a senseless war. This is devastating for Russia.
Russia is already going thru a demographic crisis. The population is shrinking because of lack of natural reproduction (not enough kids) and people fleeing the country (one million men since 2022).
For purposes of balence, could you relay the same statistics for Ukraine please.
@@sirwavellBalance? One of the leaders has a choice, the other doesn't. Wake up.
@@sirwavellreally comrade.
@@noloveforthehaters exactly.
Nice interview
Kamyshin's hairstyle is actually quite traditional old Cossack style.
The kursk offensive IS successful in removing manpower from the donbass.
Not only is every single man sent to kursk not sent to pokrovsk, nor is any other man who will now be sent to other parts of the border to prevent future incursions.
Does it have an immidiate effect? Yes, to some extent in some less prioritiezed areas of the fronrline.
But in the long term, yes!
I believe, that if Ruzzia do not mobilize, they will find themselves to be streched quite thin, and thereby have a hard time to find reserves to replenish their losses.
Russia has a special recruitment offer on six month for those that want to fight only in Kursk. Basically 25000 men signed last month. They are building an task force ad hoc to put the Ukrainian away. The force they diverted from donbass didn't even affected the rotation of the troops there. They have too much men for the entire front.
Anyone arguing Russia will "win" at this point (whatever that means these days) is basically a parody, and should be laughed out of any serious discussion on the conflict.
The Ukrainians are taking settlements in Kursk in dominating fashion from the Russians, and the Russians may (eventually) take Pokrovsk, and that's supposed to be a big momentum changer?
Just accept you've lost Russia. This is just dumb.
Settlements in Kursk? Look at Kursk on Google maps there's nothing there but tiny villages and farmland, Sudzha the largest settlement captured had a population of 5000, Russia is capturing cities, towns and fortifications in Donetsk that stood since 2014.
Is this sarcasm ?
Kursk is a sideshow. This war is about the possession one of the most mineral-rich pieces of land in he world - the Donbass.
@@dalecrocker3213 "most mineral-rich pieces of land in he world" -- That's good, for the Russian Oligarchs, shame the average Russian won't feel the effect of this magnificent "liberation"
Capturing parts of Kursk is not helping Ukraine defend the Donbas lines.
The Russians should be worried about Ukraine being afraid of the winter when they themselves can't even supply their troops with adequate equipment.
Russian troops are better equipped than a lot of NATO ones. Look at what they have in the kharkiv oblast for exemple. They have basically more drone, more shell, more ammo, more vehicles. Their logistics work.
Are these russians in the same room with you right now?
@@ad-ko5iy is that what Vlad told you to say? 🤡🤡😂😂
@@ad-ko5iy You are free to believe what you want. If Russian soldiers are equipped better than NATO, and Ukrainian soldiers are fighting with old donated weapons from NATO, then Ukrainian soldiers must be super hero’s and Russians soldiers are weak little girls. Three day special operation is almost three years and Ukrainian is taking Russian mainland now.
@@kulkrafts3143
what mainland it kursk is wilderness
The war is not a war of aggression like operation desert storm, it is a war of attrition where men and resources are grinded till the end.
Russia is already the biggest country in the world why would they want to defend more territory
Such a good analyst, so much better than Sean Bell.
NATO need to step in immediately.
Nato is a defensive alliance, it cannot 'step in'.
The USA won't follow. France and Germany either. They have no interest in Ukraine.
Their losses just keep going, and going and going.... How much more can they loose?
Well according to Times Radio, which you clearly believe they have lost more men than have actually been involved in the war. So they must have lost already.
When rebuilding starts ,i would like to see localised ,house by house independance with water, electricity ,and food grown ...the tech is available for this now ...i often think that if all the clever ideas for recycling and production of our needs were shared ,we could survive. And thrive despite putin style idiots wrecking everything
Reminds me of Germany after WW2. They rebuilt everything in West Germany to higher standards.
Russia's borders are so huge, easy to get through. The problem is returning . Very few succeed, whether French, German or whatever
the blind and deaf capitalist pigs do not realize that though
Nice to hear General Slim being appreciated. From Australia 🇦🇺
If you listened to Clarke since the beginning of the war, you'll know that he has consistently made over-optimistic assessments, sometimes untethered to on-the-ground reality. This approach to narrative over fact has made the loss worse, imo.
Maybe he wants to be part of the MIC 😂
exactly these analysis without relation to battlefield and without any related experience made many Ukrainians confused and they are loosing
Slava Ukraini!
So acording to you Ukraine is winning?
What in the gaslighting is this ?
For russia to declare war due to the kursk incursion would mean they have the right to use nuclear weapons. Putin knows that thats why he wont but rather calls it a counterterrorism operation. The nukes are for america and nato not for ukraine.
MICHAEL CLARK . ABSOLUTE LEGEND
Oops I mean PROFESSOR SIR MICHAEL CLARK
I didnt know that a comedian is on radio show too. LOL I will come here if i want to laugh when i am feeling down. This guy is great at talking nonsenses. :)
The Russians are in the same boat , regarding the winter. If a Ukrainian push to the reactor in kursk is made, they can force a cold shut down there, severing the electricity to a vast swath of the Russian south from Rostov southward. And with Ukrainian drones picking off Russian oil and gas facilities the Russians won't find winter pleasing as the roads leading south are now in direct fire of Ukrainian missiles and drones. So truck delivery for oil and gas ,along with arms will effectively be neutered.That plus the bottleneck in Sudzha to the west now in Ukrainian hands, Russia will pray for a very light winter. However, that will not occur. And with exports down and Ukraine having a hand on the shut off valve, Russia will freeze.
Have you seen the fortifications around the Kursk NPP? They're already kilometres deep.
@@ailinofaolin8897 Sigh, power lines are extremely easy to bring down. In fact, power lines are not even defensible. In WW2, it was hard to hit them. Many drones are designed specifically to inspect power lines. Many are fairly autonomous.
How would you like to be the repairman on a high-tension line and watch an FPV drone approaching you?
@rajeshkanungo6627 You're talking about disrupting a nuclear power station inside Russia, the complete lack of self awareness on the insanity of such an endeavour from yourself is astounding.
@@ailinofaolin8897 , no one is talking about attacking a nuclear power station itself except for the Russians who are messing around with one. They also dug trenches in Chernobyl. I bet the Ukrainians are far brighter than the Russians.
The attack entails disrupting the grid by destroying the outgoing power lines. One doesn’t need to be close to the power plant. Ukraine is close enough to toy with the transmission lines.
The Russians did hack Ukraine’s power grid in 2018. It is just a shock to the Russians that someone would actually attack them.
The main goal is to stop Russian infrastructure. At present the interim goal is the kursk power plant.
The kursk power plant is the provider for the vast southern area of Russia. And with cooler weather approaching, a sizable disruption in provision would make an elegant buffer for Ukraine against further incursions or build-up coming from rostov von don which is the Russian southern command area as power would be a measured asset for the russians in the southern regions.
The resultant power projection would be neutered and with subsequent destruction of the road/rail bridge into Crimea, any movement along the southern Ukrainian border is delayed, permitting a development of further defense fortifications.
It is a peer, pat poker hand. Russia cannot retreat without embarrassing the military or political agenda but must or lose the military stationed there as they cannot resupply them. And in a transitional environment like a war, effective supply and replenishment is an essential commodity.
But fortifying a defensive parimeter around kursk and forcing the plant in a cold state while disabling key non serviceable portions, it delays repair and this at a time during winter. Further hampering Russian citizens and making plain the assertion that the strike is commercial, environmental and most importantly economical. Especially with the devastation of the oil service facility in Rostov Oblast. The winter months will be critical for Russian citizens in the south.
The base premise for this, is the vast oil reserves under the Luhansk Oblast and Donetsk Oblast provinces. Which russia sees as an economic choke point for their ability to make money. At present there is no competition. But with the eventual end of hostilities, russia's loss of these Ukrainian oblasts would hamper the economy of russia (and oligarchies) control of fuel to the west. Remember the older soviet transport fuel lines (and newer russian lines) are already in Ukraine . By keeping these oblasts and Crimea they gain the warm water ports of the black sea and by fiat a negotiated easement of passage thru the Turkish held straits without recourse.
The real reason for this war.
Money.
Kursk wasn't only about Pokrovsk.
No one know what it was about. even the Ukrainian…
@@ad-ko5iy 😁 they still figuring that out
Why is it always someone giving advice who haven’t been in combat
Michael Clarke ought to receive The Military Cross for his reporting efforts.🎖️
I thought he already received the purple heart from his service at Rourke's Drift 🤔
@@Erime who would give these idiots anything 🙄 😒
Yeah, and Les Dennis deserves the Victoria Cross for his performance on Strictly Come Dancing.
Yes, for his "Efforts", but not the facts. Propaganda, that will push the world into the 3rd World War. How many conflicts the US started at the same time? Because of this, how many countries got the courage to distance themselves from US expansionist acts?
It's unbelievable that "CIVILIZED" Occident countries don't interfere in these atrocities comited by Russia.
Bullies can fail completely when they have punched back
Russia invaded a weak country 1/5th its size that hasd been kept disarmed and neutral by the west. Ukraine fought back and its allies started to help. Now there are Russians complaining about being bullied by NATO and its so unfair for 28 (now 30 counters)
It is Kursk that is the “retaliation” not the other way round.
I would walk on my lips through broken glass to spend 10 minutes in her presence. Kate is gorgeous, and so sharp. And thank you, Michael Clarke, for your depth of knowledge, and incisive commentary.
You a FREAK lol
I have the hots for her too. She's mine! Stay away! Lol
Those are the thoughts you're supposed to keep inside.
Times Radio, ur content is so clean
They have a good hoover
2.5 years for a 3 day war , what was Putin thinking ?
I don’t think he’s capable of intelligent thinking. He’s just caused massive misery and a mess of Russia.
He was thinking of forcing a negociation to NATO. He was clearly deluded. He learned the lesson.
@@ad-ko5iy it could be that he's suffering from delusions of grandeur.
Putin though it would be easy to invade a nation 1/5th Russia's size that had been kept disamred by western nations to placate Russian demands. But the Ukrainians fought back (they remember 1922 and 1932) and Ukraine allies helped. Now Russians complain of being bullied by NATO. How pathetic and how delusional.
He wasn't thinking
Why is this expert always incorrect 😂
Winter is coming again😁😁😁😁😁
Always great commentary
Украинцы бегут из украины. Они не хотят Zelenskyy . Они хотят жить.
Bill Slim The Legend.
Russians are going to have a cold, dark, winter. Unfortunately for Ukraine, bad weather is very bad for drones.
I thought it was Ukraine that was having power outages? I have not heard of it happening in Russia sorry - who will be cold ?
@@stephenlyon1358many entire apartment blocks in cities outside Moscow don't have electricity at all ever!
@@stephenlyon1358 Russian soldiers will be cold. We've already seen how poorly equipped they were last winter. There is no reason to believe this will improve this year.
Meanwhile, Ukrainian soldiers will continue to receive a ton of aid, including things to keep them warm.
@@stephenlyon1358 The Ukrainians will be served hot meals from Ukrainian homes. The Russians are far away, and their logistics can be attacked. Think of the Winter war in Finland. Look up the Sausage War.
@Mike-if1nn Poorly equipped last winter? They were storming Avdeevka during the winter and that became a rout.
Russia apparently produces 250k of artillery shells per month which is staggering.
This prof has proved time and time again that he hasn't got a clue.
exactly, i don't Care he is talking because he wants to help but he is over optimistic and analysis not base on reality and battleground so he always wrong and his analysis is more like wishes rather than predicting
Was prof Mikhail Clarke wrong when he said that russia won't have this when we went into Kursk? He said they'd be gone in 2 weeks. 2 months on, we're still there! I think he's learning!
This guy hasn't been right even once since this started
Britain : a little country with a little army and its largest cities governed by Pakistani Muslims with their own Shariah Muslim courts
"Surge towards..."?? Barely any movement in the last two days.
That's because Pokrovsk was a giant bear trap and Magyars birds were waiting for them. Around 200 Russian vehicles BARBECUED since Monday.
I think a 'surge' can meet stiff resistance and still be a surge.
@@memirandawong barely any movement blows your point out of the water
@@colinobrien3806 Who said "barely any movement"? 😂😂
For Ukraine it still reminds me of, "The Blitz" for the British in WW2 (historicaly speaking).
It’s kind of funny that Russia trolls are powering your TH-cam channel. I don’t think they understood the assignment
😂😂😂😂
Quiet day in St Petersburg?
TH-cam if very Russian troll friendly.
Ignorance is a bliss.
keep urself happy in ignorance
8 to 1 advantage in Artillery ' yet Russia looses more
Pull the other leg
UK propaganda is so banal
Brit realist here. An interesting assessment and commentary. But let’s face it; Russia occupies about 18% of Ukrainian territory. The Ukrainian incursion into Kursk has occupied only 0.0076 of Russian territory. The Russians occupy about 108540 sq km of Ukraine; Ukraine occupies about 1300 sq km. It’s been a fantastic propaganda move, but, in relative territorial terms, it’s little more than a fleabite. Putin knows he’s going to get it back at some stage anyway, that’s merely a matter of time. So he’s prepared to put up with a bit of a media setback (all exaggerated by the western press anyway, in the interest of clickbait titles) in order to concentrate his efforts on the really big prize, the Donbass. If he gets that (and probably keeps Crimea) then he can claim he’s achieved his objectives and won the war, and that will maintain him in power until his death. Ukraine is doing an amazing job in this war, especially emasculating the Russian Navy and knocking out oil depot after oil depot, etc…. and that’s a great long-term strategy, but whether they can keep that up to make a strategic difference will only become apparent in the future.
And even if the individual Russian is now suffering, it’s also little more than an inconvenience, and most of the older ones had it much worse before in Soviet times. Even if the economy is temporarily set back to pre 2014 levels, that’s still infinitely better than anything they had under Soviet rule. Russia made massive leaps forward in the first 15 years of Putin’s rule, as I saw myself during many visits; that’s not going to go away.
It's up to the west to stop pussyfooting around and do what they should have done from the start; support Ukraine in order to win the war.
They are deaf and blind.
They will not realize