There will be NEVER democracy in Pakistan..whatever you do. This is karma. There is a curse. From Bangladesh. The day they didn't respect democratic results of 1971 elections..democracy was buried..no one can revive. RIP democracy.
“I am the girl who spends hours huddled in a corner of a library, trying to find what you love the most about Marlowe, just so I can write you a poem worthy of Shakespeare. I've made books my lovers, hours my enemies and you the only story.” ―
برطانوی راج کے دوران ہی لاہور کے انگریز ڈی سی یا کمشنر نے ریلوے سٹیشن کی منظوری روک دی تھی۔ جب اس کو ٹھیک ٹھاک رشوت دی گئی تب اس نے منظوری دی۔ یہ میں نے رضوان رضی کے ایک ویلاگ میں سنا تھا۔
بہت خوب تیمور صاحب۔ جو آپ نے یہ بات کلئیر کی کہ صرف سرکاری ملازمین خاص کر نمبردار، پٹواری اور برٹش گورنمنٹ کو ٹیکس دینے والے لوگ ہی ووٹ دے سکتے تھے۔ عام بندہ تو ووٹ ڈال ہی نہیں سکتا تھا
" West Pakistan mein 3 percent non Muslim the" ..why Pakistanis propagate this false narrative.. please refer to 1941 census conducted under British rule..the Hindu and Sikh population was around 30-35: percent in in almost all districts of Punjab and Sindh...
Extremely beautiful way of presenting everything in detail. I watched the video with utmost attention. Please keep sharing knowledge and always be blessed. Thanks a billion for providing us with such great content. Great respect for you, sir.
Hlo brother System not Matter people matter If Peoples are Corrupt inside the system then No System(Islamic or secular) Work If you Said Secular is a Key Of Success then Why Africa, India (Ground level)etc not successful. People matter if Pakistan become secular Nothing change except System name Because People are Corrupt inside the system So Focus on people not System if Pakistani Peoples become Honest U Automatically see change Thanku
Wow ! Awesome podcasts, 1 hour 22 minutes of gripping talk . Full of logic, agreeable arguments and both the guys matched each other’s energy level . I heard professor Taimur for more than 50 hours on TH-cam! A very talented and a classic academician. Nevertheless like any other leftist or communist from any part of the world. His diagnosis of current economic disaster and predictions of hopeless situation in future also if remedial actions aren’t taken , is perfect, wonderful and eye opening for one and all in Pakistan or other developmental societies across the world. Right now the need is to create awareness on these issues beyond political rhetorics and electoral maneuvers. He is right when he says that people should hit the streets in massive numbers without being lead by political entities. Chattar khaana band karnaa hi padega . Best wishes for May Day🎉🎉
Do you have any book recommendations on the electoral history of Pakistan, and the role of the British bureaucracy in acting as a roadblock for democracy in the Indian subcontinent?
You are just too optimistic I believe Dr Taimur. Pakistanis in particular and South Asians in general have never been able to do any revolutionary things period. It is not in the DNA of you Punjabis to revolt against the ruler. Please accept it.
Who was Guru Gobind Singh ji , Dulla Bhatti , Maharaja Ranjit Singh , Lala Lajpat rai , Kartar Singh Sarabha , Bhagat Singh and and and .... ? Who forced 5 Pandvas to take shellter in Panjab ? Read History without Gobar Mootar Sewan plz .
I like baghawat. I own it. Because why should not be not be Baghi against a horrible system. To rebel is just. Only fuddy duddies are scared of the word baghawat because they are scared of a baghawat against the present system. So they prefer "independence" because it implies that that struggle ended with 1947. Whereas I consider it just one phase in our rebellion against capitalism.
Recommendations are only minority-centric, and there is no viable way given to tackle the menace of fragile democracy. Another lecture is needed to show how democracy can be strengthened.
Taimur bhai Adaab Sat Sri Akaal🙏 Hamesha ki tarah hi bahut Shaandaar✊👍🙏
Balochistan was never part of all that happened in the past to India,,,
Balochistan is not Pakistan
The thesis statement "We got independence by the British but again enslaved by the elites, bureaucracy & the military
Sir bring a one hour long lecture on ir theories this will set a base to understand international world
Excellent
From India
There will be NEVER democracy in Pakistan..whatever you do. This is karma. There is a curse. From Bangladesh. The day they didn't respect democratic results of 1971 elections..democracy was buried..no one can revive. RIP democracy.
*Political Parties mai khud democracy nahi hen? Pakistani political parties democratic nahi hen*
Zia-ul-haq ka 90 din KY andar intakhabat ka jhoot 20th Saadi ka sab sy brra jhoot tha..,😅
“I am the girl who spends hours huddled in a corner of a library, trying to find what you love the most about Marlowe, just so I can write you a poem worthy of Shakespeare. I've made books my lovers, hours my enemies and you the only story.”
―
برطانوی راج کے دوران ہی لاہور کے انگریز ڈی سی یا کمشنر نے ریلوے سٹیشن کی منظوری روک دی تھی۔ جب اس کو ٹھیک ٹھاک رشوت دی گئی تب اس نے منظوری دی۔ یہ میں نے رضوان رضی کے ایک ویلاگ میں سنا تھا۔
بہت خوب تیمور صاحب۔ جو آپ نے یہ بات کلئیر کی کہ صرف سرکاری ملازمین خاص کر نمبردار، پٹواری اور برٹش گورنمنٹ کو ٹیکس دینے والے لوگ ہی ووٹ دے سکتے تھے۔
عام بندہ تو ووٹ ڈال ہی نہیں سکتا تھا
" West Pakistan mein 3 percent non Muslim the" ..why Pakistanis propagate this false narrative.. please refer to 1941 census conducted under British rule..the Hindu and Sikh population was around 30-35: percent in in almost all districts of Punjab and Sindh...
Extremely beautiful way of presenting everything in detail. I watched the video with utmost attention. Please keep sharing knowledge and always be blessed. Thanks a billion for providing us with such great content. Great respect for you, sir.
Pakistan ka sabse bada problem wahan ke Ashraf logon ka ashrafiat hai ,jinme hardam conflict of interest hota rahta hai.
My favorite. No one can defeat sir taimoor in teaching method, knowledge, clarity of thoughts and intellectual capabilities.
Hlo brother
System not Matter people matter
If Peoples are Corrupt inside the system then No System(Islamic or secular) Work
If you Said Secular is a Key Of Success then Why Africa, India (Ground level)etc not successful.
People matter if Pakistan become secular Nothing change except System name Because People are Corrupt inside the system
So Focus on people not System if Pakistani Peoples become Honest U Automatically see change
Thanku
Wow ! Awesome podcasts, 1 hour 22 minutes of gripping talk . Full of logic, agreeable arguments and both the guys matched each other’s energy level . I heard professor Taimur for more than 50 hours on TH-cam! A very talented and a classic academician.
Nevertheless like any other leftist or communist from any part of the world. His diagnosis of current economic disaster and predictions of hopeless situation in future also if remedial actions aren’t taken , is perfect, wonderful and eye opening for one and all in Pakistan or other developmental societies across the world.
Right now the need is to create awareness on these issues beyond political rhetorics and electoral maneuvers. He is right when he says that people should hit the streets in massive numbers without being lead by political entities. Chattar khaana band karnaa hi padega . Best wishes for May Day🎉🎉
Great ❤
Do you have any book recommendations on the electoral history of Pakistan, and the role of the British bureaucracy in acting as a roadblock for democracy in the Indian subcontinent?
Read 'The Pakistani Voter, Electoral Politics and Voting Behaviour in Punjab' by Andrew Wilder
Same question
19:59 kya cover kiya hai bhutto ko sir, kamaal hai sara kasoor dictator ka bhotto ka koi kasoor nahin lol
بہت اعلی تجزیہ اور نظریات اور پیشکش
Sir please upload the slides of this video....
Sir failures of democracy per bi ak video bnae...
Excellent lecture very informative! Thank you for enlightening me……❤
Love you sir
Resource of this book??
👍❤️
You are just too optimistic I believe Dr Taimur. Pakistanis in particular and South Asians in general have never been able to do any revolutionary things period. It is not in the DNA of you Punjabis to revolt against the ruler. Please accept it.
Apart from ethnic politics but we must accept that punjabis always welcomed invaders like Muhammed bin Qasim ghaznvi and others
@@Sindh000 What about East India Comp ? Have they Started in Lahore , Amritsar or Bengal ?
@@raviinder6406 historically Bengal
Who was Guru Gobind Singh ji , Dulla Bhatti , Maharaja Ranjit Singh , Lala Lajpat rai , Kartar Singh Sarabha , Bhagat Singh and and and .... ? Who forced 5 Pandvas to take shellter in Panjab ? Read History without Gobar Mootar Sewan plz .
@@raviinder6406 these were brave sons of Punjab. I am my not talking about them i am talking about colonial era
Great sirrrr
Nice sir
Well addressed 👍
Was partition a right descion??
It was the right decision at that time.But the way it happened was not right.Pakistan should have made peaceful relationship with India.
Yes
Sir Pori dunya Jang e Azaadi Keh rhi, Ap Baghawat word use kr. Rhy? Isn't this a hypocrite attitude?
I like baghawat. I own it. Because why should not be not be Baghi against a horrible system. To rebel is just.
Only fuddy duddies are scared of the word baghawat because they are scared of a baghawat against the present system. So they prefer "independence" because it implies that that struggle ended with 1947. Whereas I consider it just one phase in our rebellion against capitalism.
Recommendations are only minority-centric, and there is no viable way given to tackle the menace of fragile democracy. Another lecture is needed to show how democracy can be strengthened.