Thank you for a run through of both programs. It shows the progress made in them over the last 30 odd years. To draw this to manufacturing in an hour is magic. However what I am looking for is a salesman or program designer's overview to show the similarities and differences. I have yet to find such a video. Thanks again.
Thanks for another interesting and clearly explained video. Please can you say how the fillet is added between the blades and the main disk (visible at 0:29) - do you have to select each blade in turn or is there a shortcut? Also, is it possible to add a fillet on both sides of the blade - I am getting errors on some blades but not on others and I wonder if your model behaves the same?
Great question. I'm using FreeCAD 0.18 in this video and you can download my model at the link in the description if you'd like to compare. It was a case for me of selecting every edge individually
Ah, thanks again. Interestingly, I am able to fillet on the 'back' of the blade (as yours is), but not on the 'front' side for some blades only. For example, the original blade that was drawn before the Polar Pattern. I tried to set refine = true for both the Polar Pattern and the Revolution, but no change. Your model behaves the same, as do both 0.18 and 0.19. It seems to be something with the Revolution because if I set the Polar Pattern as the tip, then I can still fillet on both sides of all blades. Not something I am likely to need, but interesting to know!
@@iwbnwif Agreed I ran into that too. SolidWorks could fillet that. Interestingly however, I've had cases where the exact same part would fillet in FreeCAD but would not in SolidWorks.
@@JokoEngineeringhelp A minor quibble: when you say merge points, it implies that it makes a single point from 1 or more. I think the proper term is make them coincident. I.e. multiple point objects having the same x,y,z coordinates. As opposed to, for instance Blender, where point objects can be coincident or merged to a single point object. As for the fillet, FYI for another data point: I am using FreeCAD 0.19 and I selected the "hub" wall face and it fillets both sides of the fins. (...could be 0.19 handles fillets better, or a different selection) It of course is also dependent on the fillet radius chosen, to big and it can't resolve to a manifold solid.
No. It's got the worst UI I have ever seen on a 3d program. I guess they have some kind of "no floating windows" policy, so everything shoved into a cell phone sized window on the bottom right of your monitor (or overlays that block your view ports). If you have 2 or 3 monitors, they are completely wasted by this UI design. Having multiple settigns opened at the same time is impossible with tis idiotic design. It's absolutely horrid and idiotic and the person responsible should be beaten severely.
You move too fast for a tutorial. Slow down. Explain what you’re clicking on. Use constraints instead of math. Rectangular blur in the second half doesn’t help either.
on the other hand, the tutorial is already almost half an hour long and it would be unbearably slow if he went slower. You can always pause the video and watch the mouse when you get confused, since he says what keys he's pressing.
I actally watched this sped up to 1.25x speed. Just watching as a comparison of the two programs. You can slow the playback speed as well in YT if you want to use as a play along tutorial.
The video was made to compare platforms which shouldn't require a slow pace to do so. If you're looking for some specific instruction of some kind, I would suggest going to another video instead of one that is intended to highlight workflows.
Thank you for a run through of both programs. It shows the progress made in them over the last 30 odd years. To draw this to manufacturing in an hour is magic. However what I am looking for is a salesman or program designer's overview to show the similarities and differences. I have yet to find such a video. Thanks again.
Something not mentioned in the video is Fusion's timeline which is extremely powerful and useable as you learn the program more in depth.
Я так долго искал эту модель. Я тебя обожаю❤️)
Autodesk visually draws graphics really beautifully
What are these blurry rectangels?
Great video thank you! And I really appreciate you letting us know the shortcut keys used as you use them.
My pleasure
I dont know what is the rectangular blur at the center of the video @24:00 to 28:00. Is it due to some youtube glitch?
Thanks for another interesting and clearly explained video. Please can you say how the fillet is added between the blades and the main disk (visible at 0:29) - do you have to select each blade in turn or is there a shortcut? Also, is it possible to add a fillet on both sides of the blade - I am getting errors on some blades but not on others and I wonder if your model behaves the same?
Great question. I'm using FreeCAD 0.18 in this video and you can download my model at the link in the description if you'd like to compare. It was a case for me of selecting every edge individually
Ah, thanks again. Interestingly, I am able to fillet on the 'back' of the blade (as yours is), but not on the 'front' side for some blades only. For example, the original blade that was drawn before the Polar Pattern. I tried to set refine = true for both the Polar Pattern and the Revolution, but no change. Your model behaves the same, as do both 0.18 and 0.19.
It seems to be something with the Revolution because if I set the Polar Pattern as the tip, then I can still fillet on both sides of all blades. Not something I am likely to need, but interesting to know!
@@iwbnwif Agreed I ran into that too. SolidWorks could fillet that. Interestingly however, I've had cases where the exact same part would fillet in FreeCAD but would not in SolidWorks.
@@JokoEngineeringhelp A minor quibble: when you say merge points, it implies that it makes a single point from 1 or more. I think the proper term is make them coincident. I.e. multiple point objects having the same x,y,z coordinates. As opposed to, for instance Blender, where point objects can be coincident or merged to a single point object.
As for the fillet, FYI for another data point: I am using FreeCAD 0.19 and I selected the "hub" wall face and it fillets both sides of the fins. (...could be 0.19 handles fillets better, or a different selection) It of course is also dependent on the fillet radius chosen, to big and it can't resolve to a manifold solid.
PS: Nice video!
Great thanks!!
What would you use in FreeCAD to achieve the same result as Fusion 360's (face) offset?
Datum plane in freecad
@@j4ckfl4ash33I think you may have misunderstood the question.
👍 👍 👍 👍 👍
Is blender good?
I think it's a great software. It's not parametric and is designed for art/graphic design more than engineering so I haven't gone very deep with it.
No. It's got the worst UI I have ever seen on a 3d program. I guess they have some kind of "no floating windows" policy, so everything shoved into a cell phone sized window on the bottom right of your monitor (or overlays that block your view ports). If you have 2 or 3 monitors, they are completely wasted by this UI design. Having multiple settigns opened at the same time is impossible with tis idiotic design. It's absolutely horrid and idiotic and the person responsible should be beaten severely.
@@MAGAMAN after 1 year of using blender, you are the first person i saw that does not like blender.
You move too fast for a tutorial. Slow down. Explain what you’re clicking on. Use constraints instead of math. Rectangular blur in the second half doesn’t help either.
on the other hand, the tutorial is already almost half an hour long and it would be unbearably slow if he went slower. You can always pause the video and watch the mouse when you get confused, since he says what keys he's pressing.
You need to watch his videos in order maybe.
I actally watched this sped up to 1.25x speed. Just watching as a comparison of the two programs. You can slow the playback speed as well in YT if you want to use as a play along tutorial.
certainly not a teacher........too fast
The video was made to compare platforms which shouldn't require a slow pace to do so. If you're looking for some specific instruction of some kind, I would suggest going to another video instead of one that is intended to highlight workflows.
thank you
@@JokoEngineeringhelp
There's a pause button