Jon Favreau Hates George Lucas
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 ก.ย. 2024
- Jon Favreau Has decided to join in on the destruction of Star Wars. How sad.
Head over to squarespace.co... to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain using the code robothead
Jon Favreau hits a new low (If that's possible) in The Mandalorian season 3 episode 3. The New Republic is now worse than the Empire. Nice Work Kathleen Kennedy, Lucasfilm, and the team behind The Mandalorian. Well done!
You can find me on Twitter and Instagram, but only if you are nice!
#starwars #themandalorianseason3
![ได้เวลา! พาน้องแฝดฉีดวัคซีนครบ 1 เดือน🫣 [cc] แดนแพทตี้ SS2 | EP.52 |](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IzeLtaXBLNE/mqdefault.jpg)
Hi All. Here we go again. This week Mando gets booted from his own show! You can find me on Twitter and Instagram. And do the “Like”, “Subscribe” and “Bell” thing so you don’t miss a video. Cheers!
Hi Robot Head. I already follow you on Twitter and I would do it again if I could. Love when you fight with all these pricks who defend Disney Star Wars. :D
Have you not read Legacy Star Wars
I can’t wait to see your video on the 5th episode. It was so bad I decided to unsub and delete Disney+. Don’t have time for their stupid crap anymore.
Oh f you.
"The Game" is only bad if you need to take it literally.
Films which are as good are extremely rare.
Especially during a time of Marvel heroes.
I bet you yerk off to all that she it.
When you going back on FNT?
The old EU also had leftover Imperial factions. Which makes sense - do you think the entire Imperial military just disappeared after Endor? The difference between the old EU and Disney, however, is that the old EU showed PROGRESS happening after ROTJ, as the New Republic emerged as a major Galactic power that fought against various Imperial remnant factions. Unlike the Disney canon, which just RESETS the Galaxy back to Empire vs. Rebels, wiping out all prior progress.
still even with imperial remants,,who give they money,support,logistics etc...
I agree but I think there setting up for thrawn and he is the imperial warlord
having Imperial remnants is fine. The idea that Starwars is like the end of WW2 is silly since the Rebels did not completly beat the Empire.
Best way to handle the story was the Rebels killed Palpy and the Empire fractured because thats what happens when you kill the head honcho and there is no Plan B. Each Major player carved out their own Nitch. Rebels attacked and captured the Capitol like in Legends and any world was allowed to join the New Republic. Imperial Control of the Core Worlds was mostly broken and the Rebelion fought to allow as many worlds to join as possible. Imperial remnants thus only controlled worlds who legit supported the Empire or were simply resource worlds without real population who would want to revolt.
But lots of worlds remain independent.
Thats how you world build. unfortunately, Disney does not know how to do that.
@@MrChickennugget360 actually the Nazis weren't defeated during WW2.
They assimilated into the allied countries. So this was actually spot on
@@FULANODETAL In legends it was established that a great number of star systems were self sufficient in that they had their own minor or major ship building and resource gathering and processing facilities to one degree or another. The local moffs, grand moffs, and admirals that kept those sectors in line continued their operations mostly uninterrupted when the emperor was killed. Without a head of state and senate the admirals and moffs basically resorted to power struggles or alliances. So in the end the Galaxy was divided into factions consisting of independent worlds, the new republic, and numerous system factions forming the imperial remnant. Not every sector of the galaxy was in favor of rebelling against the empire so they remained loyal to their governing body. And not every world with rebel elements was successful in gaining independence. The old EU did this aspect of world building quite well imo. It opens up a lot of avenues for storytelling and puts into perspective the entirety of the state of the galaxy while still being able to focus on characters. This is why the fans who enjoyed Legends still love and treasure the Expanded universe rather than discard it in exchange for Disney or simply not defend it and move to a different franchise altogether.
Anyone remember that one click where Mark Hamill said that when opening scene for Darth Vader we should mention he's evil, but George Lucas said no, it's fine we'll dress him in black and have the background white and we'll play evil music. Good times
In that same scene, aside from his appearance and music doing most of the heavy lifting, his evil nature is characterized by his direct approach. As soon as he's on board Leia's ship, he's interrogating crew members with strangulation as an intimidation tactic. He's trying to figure out where the Death Star plans went ASAP and will resort to anything that will get him to his goal quicker. Efficiency with no regard for the value of human life; effectively branded evil without anybody ever muttering the word.
Why show when you can tell? George is such a n00b
"Show, don't tell" is one of the most important keys to good onscreen storytelling.
@@ioncewasmikeyQuite so, ESPECIALLY in film!
Vader’s opening shot establishes a lot about him. First, his black outfit, armor, and mask are all distinct from the Stormtroopers, marking him as someone of clear importance.
He strides into battle with an aggressive, confident gait like a hunter. You can’t see his face due to the mask, so body language is absolutely key,
He interrogates the Rebel troopers by strangling them with his bare hands and tossing them like ragdolls.
In just a brief amount of time, you can tell he’s not someone to mess around with. When Vader gets angry, people DIE! And this is BEFORE we see him strangle a guy with his mind, or his terrifying personal combat prowess.
Dr. Pershing was doing a Crappy Ted Talk🤮
"Who's going to be the Top"😆😂🤣
Hey man, she'd be good looking if she was a chick🤣
We could have had Boba Fett and Cad Bane developed in Book of Boba Fett, but we got 2 episodes of Mandolorian. We could have had a nice flashback to the invasion of Mandalore, but get a bland unimportant side story. Why Lucas Films? Why? Instead of all these awful plotholes, why not put love and care into honoring George's work? More importantly, why take George Lucas out of Lucas Films. I am sad, Robot Head, I am truly sad.
1:00
TBH, in the old EU the writers had an understanding on how basic politics work and the aftermath wasn't that bright as the end of RotJ showed. There were still imperial fleets, garrisons and governors left throughout the galaxy and several imperial loyalist planets. What followed was an intense period, filled with imperial warlords and with a civil war, where several strong candidates named themselves the heirs of Palpatine. Including the old version of Thrawn.
What the old EU writers actually understood, that the New Republic, what fought against the Imperial Remnant and the Warlords wouldn't be an absolute clown and they wrote them as not always right, but objectively positive.
There is really no comparison here, for at least one reason. It being that back then the corporations didn't hold every author by the balls. As a result we had plenty of very creative work being done. Not just books and graphic novels, but also video games were putting the word "expanded" in the Expanded Universe. You mention Timothy Zahn's Thrawn. I'll add to that Karen Traviss with her Republic Commando series, that brought an unexpected character, a beautiful father figure, mandalorian instructor to the clone army, named Kal Skirata. But wait, there's more! We got three great games set in the Old Republic era, some 3000+ years before Luke Skywalker, and still fans gobbled it all up and asked for seconds. Now, when Old Republic era was really explored and fleshed out, nothing is stopping Lucasfilm to capitalize on that, and create an Old Republic SW show, where the Sith Empire battles the Republic across the galaxy. But this would require the corpo world to release the gorilla grip on the already unnaturally swollen and colored gonads of the creative directors. Not to mention current political climate being what it is...
@@tomasz9429 Yeah the problem is, people in charge doesn't even know how to recognize talent.
@. Sure your not talking about the fans? Because none of This would've happened with Star Wars if the Fans kept their mouths shut and be satisfied!
@@erikbihari3625 yes..let’s blame the people watching, not the ones creating this trash. Your logic is par excellence.
@@matthewparker235
I think they're referring to fans like RLM trying to ruin George Lucas's legacy by trashing the prequels and spreading lies. I do believe that the prequel hate bandwagon - led by Mr. Plinkett - directly led to George selling the company.
Mando died the moment it tried to connect to the Sequel Trilogy. This was never going to end well.
Mando died after episode 1.
Mando was dead on arrival when they opted not to make the show about Boba Fett
Mando was stillborn mate
@@meal_team_six what? Nah. Not every show and story has to be of a character from the movies. If anything , we need more stories that are detached from the main movies and story.
@gribblenibble I don't get the worship for either of them. The last good thing Favreau did was 25 years and 200 pounds ago.
All they need is a laugh track on all these episodes and perfection would be achieved.
Hey, you are not supposed to put the Robot out of work. Brilliant idea, though.
It's hilarious how under Disney they made the Galactic Empire into the competent good guys.
How is the empire good in Disney canon
Have you watched Andor? Lmao
I don’t think we watched the same show
Wtf
@@NoManSlyno
I love the "Star wars is meant for kids" stupid excuse, episode 4 had the burnt corpses Luke's uncle and aunty and dismemberment, ahh the era where parents raised their own children.
Ep 3 had a burned corpse, too. but that one was still crawling and screaming
@omikron6218 I remember being in school back when it came out and me and my mates talking about how you could see anakins' skin drip from the lava burns😂 now they'd be discussing his pronoun use
Star wars was mean for adults also, but Disney wants to watered it down and make it extrictly for only lil kids
They forget that it is adults who made star wars popular when movie/s premiered back in 70's. Haha indeed for kids... Xd lol
Rancor eating people alive.
In a writers room far far away,
some rubbish was written.
The End. -Disney Star Wars
Did you write that? Its better than Rise if Skywalker. Probably too much for Rian Johnson to direct tho, he'd find a way to ruin it by the end of act 1
Best comment 😂😂
Disney to Writers, "We need more merch to sell."
Writers, "oh fuck, just give them a long coat and walk through the train. I have to figure out how Grogu fits in all this AGAIN!"
Just love this kind of comment.
You sir, have nailed it. I do apologise if i have misgendered you...(thats got to be worth a few virtual signaling points for my future social credit score). Mind you its 50/50 due to there only being two genders...(damn it, back to zero on my future social credit score).
You were the chosen one! You were meant to save Star Wars, not leave it in ruins! You were my brother, Favreau!
Lol bruh you're a clown if you thought Favreau was your brother who was going to save Star Wars lul
Fax
Well then you are LOST!
Favreau: You underestimate my fanservice!
I wish there was a laugh 😂jaja
That whole episode was probably an alegory for how disney treats the star wars fans, the cookies are fan service and the fans are the trusting doctor going right into their trap and at the end you would wish you could get your memory wiped.
That or the memory wipe could signify how they want you to to just forget cannon so you can consume product and then get excited for next product.
I liked how the device at the end had a control where safe settings were only the first 1/8 of a turn and everything after that was torture.
I’m a normie! I left “the force awakens“ theater with a strange feeling. I couldn’t place it, but it just felt weird. I didn’t have the vocabulary, it just felt off. Then season 8 of GOT opened my eyes to a world of fandom that helped me articulate the frustration. I originally liked season 7 (and the previous seasons) but season 8 was SO awful it set me on a cathartic TH-cam path lol. Then I discovered why “the force awakens” bugged me so much! I never spent a dime on Disney Star Wars after TFA and channels like yours helped clarify and vindicated my gut read.
@Robot thank you for your therapy hahaha!
ahah GoT season 8 i think i watched hundred of critics video about it, it was gold mine for youtubers as much of disney SW is. Even Andor which is well written have mega flaws in the "concepts", it's really tedious to depict resistance movement as cold hearted terrorists ready to use same method as empire if even worse methods (what happen to imperial family we don't even know, they killed them???) because that's the way many fascist regime depict resistance organisations. "Kleyah" say "that's how revolutions are done" hummm no sorry, you don't need to be a terrorist necessarly and if you take this path your "revolution" might not interest that much people and you could actually give reason to your ennemy. In Andor that's the resistance who have spies in the empire and is ready to betray anyone in reality like french resistance that was Nazi that had spies in the resistance... Luthen also ready to sacrifice 31 rebels just to an hypothetic better occasion... all this fucked up. Those rebels i would never want to join them. And the final episode was just a stupid funeral riot... What a mess.
The Force Awakens was treated like a reboot of A New Hope but with the writing style from an episode of Lost, they crammed as many unanswered questions as they could then added some nostalgia to exploit the audience who had been starved of content for years. It wasn't until The Last Jedi that I realised the extent of the rot.
I also didn't watch the last two sequel movies after seeing the first. Could see where that was going.
Went to Rogue One only because the directors had said they wanted to make a "war movie" and it piqued my curiosity. An okay movie, but I suspect the Kennedy clan's interference probably neutered it to some extent with the infamous "creative differences" interjections.
You dodged a bullet if you skipped The Last Jedi. It was the film that really ruined everything.
I'm betting there was an actual plan for season 3. Perhaps a plan that included good stories. I wonder how much was salvaged and how much was scrapped due to somebody deciding that Grogu needed to be put back in the show.
Or that Rangers of the New Republic had to go.
Thing is, this whole season seems to be setup, and just building the Children of the Watch as a community. I don't think it's gona actually pay off to anything this season.
I'm gonna guess that plan had to do with Gina Carano...
@@mpnuorva I just hope they have a proper follow up plan and get right into filming season 4 to get it out quick. Cobra Kai is the best at this so far
I don't remember if it's WDW Pro or Echo Base or another channel that pointed that Filoni took over the Mandalorian in season 2. KK apparently requested from Chapek that he was to be the one to supervise Star Wars. We all thought that as long as KK wasn't directly involved and Favreau was free to do what he wanted, the Mandalorian would be safe. We weren't wary enough of Filoni. Fans were under the assumption that Favreau was the one taking over, but in reality, Filoni has been imposing his vision while playing nice with KK. And Favreau has to bend to Filoni.
Stop reaching - Disney SW is never going to have anything good.
I like this channel. We have standards don’t we? Not like every other Star Wars channel that has basically said “ehhh, oh well, it is what it is, let me consume it like a drone”
Yes you like to complain a lot. Let’s call it “standards”
Best Star Wars channel is hello greedo. On a completely different level.
@@litjellyfish Hello Greedo thinks TLJ is good. Gtfo 💀
@@lessalazar9068 well it has its moments. I love parts. And hate parts. I actually did an edit some years ago that ended up rather ok. Of course I cut away more than half of an hour of material which shows how much so so it was there. But for sure I prefer it over ROS.
Remove some silly humor. The light speed attack the whole casino scene and there is a lot of great stuff in it
If you think robot head is the only star wars channel that doesnt criticize disney star wars, maybe youre the drone.
Grand Admiral Thrawn in Heir to the Empire is a good example of how to do an Imperial Warlord correctly. There's enough characterization in the novels for the reader to understand how he's able to maintain a large force and avoid capture by the New Republic. Disney Star Wars seemed like they were trying to do that at the beginning of this show with Moff Gideon, but that's been dropped because it's easier to just have random bad guy show up for a scene.
When they jumped off of that moving bullet train I couldn’t stop laughing. If anyone tried that irl it wouldn’t matter how cushy the surface you landed on is, your body is going to rag doll for a good fifty feet or so from the horizontal momentum 😂 like dude, wtf am I watching
yer thats was terrible
The effects in the filler episodes are shockingly cheap looking also Grogu seems to have half the motion he did in the first season. They're getting cheap on their prime show now 😔
Bro, this is an other planet. Physics doesn't work like ours!!! /s
I'd also argue that trying to use magic force powers wouldn't work irl, but its not real, it it?
@@ItsBoltify these two characters don’t have force abilities… but I guess you are right; Being impaled by a lightsaber in disney star wars is naught but a flesh wound, now. People should be able to slam their heads against steel walls without consequence as well, I suppose?
As soon as I saw the glasses, something was off. Lucas specifically wanted Earthly inventions like rimmed shades/lenses excluded from the entire galaxy. Seeing them onscreen immediately breaks the spell of that "Star Wars magic".
Same for zippers.
Thank you. I immediately noticed this too and it just felt slightly off
Lasers that destroy planets but using them for medical purposes is a step to far
@@FerunaLutelou And yet Luke does up the zipper on his flight suit in Empire and there's glasses in the clone wars. I think there's a little more wiggle room here.
I mean the line from Han in ESB saying “then I’ll see you in hell!” Always made me feel weird
I feel really annoyed by the fact that eye glasses are now seemingly a thing. Even that opens up a whole new set of completely unnecessary questions. Do the aliens also wear corrective eye lenses? Are there shops? Do Mon Calamari, Sullustan and Rodians shop there? Must be a huge store. Are there contact lenses? How do Hutts put those into their eyes?
Glasses were apparently something George Lucas did not want any characters in Star Wars to have because they were too “earthly.” It’s implied in the Star Wars galaxy that eyes can be easily corrected to not need glasses.
@@falkenlaser Good choice. Having glasses in an universe where entire limbs can be replaced just feels like hipster vanity to me.
@@TheRenofox this could make a pretty good in universe explanation 🤣
Disney doesnt give a faq about making things look otherworldly some of the blasters in the shows are literally AK-47s 😂😂😂 like they couldn’t be bothered to use an old star wars prop they actually chose something new on purpose that looks like an AK-47. Shattered my immersion in the show immediately.
If you want the glasses anesthetic, than just make them like a HUD computer nerd thing.
I went back and started watching The Clone Wars animated series, and it is indeed pretty woke, long before its time. Ahsoka is steady telling multiple Jedi Masters how to do their job, actively doing what she shouldn't and never being punished for it. I personally believe the reality is, it was never good, many of us were just too young to see the difference.
I watched it as an adult and think about 20 episodes were very good (mainly maul episodes). The rest could be skipped.
Actually, she was punished for it, she was demoted to library duty at the Jedi Temple. Remember?
You have to watch all of it
@@peterkrochmalni673 Well, did she learn anything from it? No, she didn't as she was still impatient long after the episode.
@@gordonschnick12 No, if he were, he would realize more and more issues with the writing, characterization, and inconsistencies.
You know I keep thinking that I'm not capable of becoming a writer for Star Wars then I remember who the current writers are.
"Remember when..."
Yes. It was called the expanded universe and one of the reasons were mad at disney is because they removed all of it only to cherry pick bits and pieces to give us an inferiour copy.
And yes, the EU included and roughly 15 year war between the new republic and various imperial factions that only ended with the Pallaeon-Gavrisom treaty where the empire retained control of several systems in the outer rim.
and thats got no sense...
Which are the best EU books to read about war and the development of the post OT Republic?
@@georgeh4171 Although it's not canon, i would recommend Heir to the Empire - Timothy Zahn, its the first in the Thrawn trilogy, expanding on what happened after the war
@@georgeh4171 I'm no expert but off the top of my head;
The Thrawn trilogy is seen as one of the best SW products produced, Rogue squadron follows Antilles and his men as they fight Imperial warlords, Dark Empire is the original "somehow palpatine returned" but has a lot of info on Luke and his new jedi, Crimson Empire is good, at least I liked it.
Didn't know that; and sounds 1000000x more interesting. Could literally have become a political drama on the Game of Thrones caliber if they'd retained the expanded universe. *sigh*
I mostly put the blame on Kathleen Kenedy because she was the reason of why grogu was back in the Book of Boba Fett. Maybe they already had a plan for season 3 but because of this one change they were forced to change it last minute. I also heard rumors that jon threathened to quit because kenedy was medling in his story or somthin like that
She's done that with all of them. It's the KK modus operandi.
Stop blaming it all on her and give John some responsibility too
@@guilhermehank4938
No Kennedy has her stench in everything negative that’s comes from Star Wars
@@guilhermehank4938 this is a bad take. If your boss tells you to do something you really don't have a choice. Sure he is responsible for the shit product too but is he really to blame if his boss KK is forcing herself into the writing room to add shit plot points
YOU heard rumours? Sounds like you're tight with people on the inside that are in the know.
We now live in a world where those once seen as heroes are villains and the villains they fought are just fighting to have their side of things understood
Just like the clone wars.
Begun, the clown wars have.
They were never heros
Just like in Star Wars, that's the story of Anakin.
That's often been the case. The problem is, people take stories of Good vs Evil, simplified ideas for the sake of being, y'know, _fun_ to watch, and muddying it. Is it more nuanced and realistic to have grey areas? Yes, but it doesn't make a story "better" automatically.
People seem to think it's more mature, smarter, for a story to have that kind of nuance and that isn't always the case. The prequels are one such exception, but Palpatine's evil is hard to dispute: the grey-areas just come from the "good guys" being very flawed.
Who in show business doesn’t hate George at this point, they all seem keen on disrespecting him
You're all acting like Lucas was an infalliable being incapable of screwing up and wrote the best thing since Shakespeare. He's not. He's honestly not a great director. In fact he didn't even direct the best of the Star Wars movies-The Empire Strikes Back. Irvin Kershner did. We've seen what happens when Lucas has full creative control, we get the mess that was the Prequels.
This video is proof that ripping into a show for not explaining something before all the episodes are out is just attention seeking and not factual at all.
"Officer They and Dr. Glasses" 😂
Truly the characters of all time.
“Who is this bloke?” - was my Dads reaction when he first saw Officer They in this recent episode.🤣🤣
I heard the Dr's name was Space Fauci
It's gotten to the point where someone named something like Officer They, but spelled cheekily like The, The'i, or something Star Wars-y, I was just accepting it as the character's actual name after a while.
Sounds transphobic...
@@hidesbehindpseudonym1920 Nah. Dig deeper and look up what "phobia" means and check back
in season 1 the imperial warlord thing made sense cuz it was basically one grumpy old mof with like 10 muddied up stormtroopers hiding on a backwater planet. but then we got huge imperial bases and ships and whole armies appearing out of nowhere. they had ironed uniforms and not a trace of a scratch or damage on their armors, which is just ridiculous
Except that what you describe wouldn't be - couldn't be - described as an Imperial 'warlord'. He would just be an insignificant rag-tag criminal.
Warlods makes perfect sense and has always been part of Star Wars from legends with the og Thrawn trilogy
It would have made sense if it was made clear from the outset that the War between the New Republic and the Empire remained at full swing even after the latter lost their Emperor, like how it happened in the old EU: The Empire was on the decline after, but it was a very slow and drawn out process and they did manage to regain the initiative a couple of times... and they retained a substantial amount of production facilities and resources for the entire duration of the Civil War.
When we were writing in 5th grade, the teacher forced us to use the "show it, dont tell it." method and it made our writing way better.
Somehow Hollywood has forgotten a 5th grade lesson…
Imagine if these 'writers' wrote books?? 🤮
@@MikeWhiskyTango Yeah lol. That sounds horrible, but i guess that's basically what the high republic series is lol.
Some one should have told that to the writers of and/or.
@@firestick4991 and renamed it was / were
@@MikeWhiskyTango Coloring books...
My 8 year old is questioning the story line 😂
While I will agree, this episode is fundamentally slow. There are elements that are not completely well thought out. Your assessment, but it is destroying George Lucas, on purpose, is not even naïve, it’s vindictive. You want Lucasfilm to fail. It is your expressed intent to highlight even the most minor faults in each show.
You would be too ignorant to know that, but when the fighter pilots are flying, and they are engaging, multiple bogeys, they most definitely communicate with each other, and tell each other which way to go so they can coordinate their attack on those bogeys, especially when they’re out numbered. This is how dog fights are fought. It is taught at every high-level flying academy in the US military. Your ignorance of it does not make it bad. It makes you look up fool.
Also, during a dogfight, a pilot will call out if they’ve been hit where they’ve been hit how bad the damages, they will also call out if they have hit any targets, and how many bogeys remain. Your utter ignorance of air combat tactics, protocols for pilots during close in air attacks, your ignorance of coordinating an egress from a combat zone, in a coordinated directed fashion, does not make that seem bad. If anything, it means that scene as realistic as it could possibly be. So your analysis comes across simply as ignorant.
Hey man, I’m sure you seem to be driving from saying this is ruining George Lucas on purpose, clearly demonstrates an ignorance of the relationship Jon Favreau, and George Lucas have. They have a very tight, knit relationship. The fact that you are completely unaware of that, is further proof of your ignorance.
If you would pay closer attention to things that are going on in this season of the Mandalorian, you would understand that Jon Favreau, Dave Filoni, and all the other contributing riders are building out from enjoying being out on his own, and just worrying about Grogu, toy, much much bigger galaxy, impact on a larger group of people by the actions of those involved in the storyline so far, and expanding the world building, it started out, simplistic, grew with more characters working together, expanded the level of enemies, and now has a question of how the hell does she get off that freezer. Because she was on the bridge and it was clearly stated in the last episode of season two that everyone on the bridge was killed. So, you have to wonder who is planning this.
But instead of looking at this story, as opening new chapters into a much larger story, you are so enthralled and delighted and overjoyed with what you perceive as the deconstruction of George Lucas in the Star Wars world building, but your spite, your ignorance, your hatred has so overcome you that you simply cannot see the forest for the trees.
This is the equivalent of daytime talk show trash TV. Why you may ask because it is baseless first of all. It lacks any knowledge of anything that’s going on. You break down a close in dogfight as if you had any idea what actually takes place during a close in dogfight , when you are criticizing, the very actions that actually happened during such a bug bite. And if you don’t think you were not meant to be left, guessing where all those short range tie interceptor’s came from, then you are an utter fool.
If you want to write trash, maybe you should write some novels that will sell five copies. But to artificially pitch Jon Favreau against George Lucas, based on at best conjecture, is the height of hubris.
As for the Doctor purging scene, he possess technology that the imperial remnant and warlords which existed in legends as well. If you had any knowledge of Star Wars, needed to complete their cloning experiments. So they needed Dr. Purshing to buy into the ultimate value of his work, versus the perceived, Tierney of not allowing him to continue work they could save billions if not trillions of lives. And he was so stupid. He fell right into the plot. And just to make sure he didn’t say anything is “Communications officer” turn the mind flayer all the way up, simply to make sure her tracks are covered. Wow leaving question open has to do and how she was rescued from Moff Gideons cruiser.
And by the way, escaping those tie fighters by following change Din Djarin had given set up, obviously his reinstatement into the way. It also allows Bo Catan to enter into this group as well. And also allows her to slip to the Armorer that she saw the one beast that made the Mandylor, the Mandylor.
This sets her up with a way to game a ruling position without having to kill fight or engage with Din Djarin, by going back into the living waters, and killing the beast. Which, in truth is how the Mandylor became the Mandylor.
Maybe if you weren’t spending so much time, hating on the show, hating on Jon Favreau, sharing for the failure of these shows, you may open your eyes ears and mind long enough to pay attention to very subtle and very blatant world building story points.
But no, you have let your rigid distain and couples with your ignorance of how things are done running your imagination, rampant in the most absolutely empty, minded, biased, ignorant, possible way
This was written so poorly it was hard to follow. But I love how you start with "You're ignorant of how professional pilots operate in dogfights" when, A, these are not members of the air force, B, this is a tv show and writing media has it's own rules, and C, you're not going to just say "We've been hit" when your ship has just rocked and something blew up. No shit! If he had identified what was hit and started DOING something, sure, but just stating the obvious makes him look like an idiot. Much of the rest of what you added was, ironically, as much supposition as you accuse Robot Head of; you're inventing plot for the writers to try and cover up their holes.
@@BWMagus You are correct. It is poorly written. Then again, I spent all of 3 to 4 minutes writing it.
This is not a scholarly publication. This is not a scientific journal. This is not a journalistic endeavor. This is not a presentation to a military tribunal. If it had been, I would have been obligated to include hundreds of citations, and the document would have been dozens of pages deep. It would have also contained photos, graphs, data sets, charts and graphs, and detailed data analysis.
However, this is TH-cam. I was not going to take 20 to 30 hours to compose a proper reply.
Yet, there is no supposition here.
Imagine standing in front of a giant room probably full of people from alderaan and people who lost everything because of the empire and complain about your mother passing of natural causes lmao.
My problem with the scene is we have no idea why he's there. It doesn't read as "complaining" to me, more like he's explaining his motives. It's not "wah my mommy died pitty me ;-;" it's "My mom died to organ failure that could have been prevented, I became a doctor to stop other people from having to lose their family in the same fashion. My work was abused by the Empire and I regret my part in that."
If anything, he's complaining the evil empire was evil. Which, ya know, I think most people could agree on that. Especially people from Alderaan.
@@nananamamana3591 which is still hilarious when talking to peoples who planet was destroyed by the empire. It's still funny
It's so weird. Lol. Coruscant is so big, that could literally just be an open mic for TED Talks that lots of elites love to visit on Saturdays.
But they literally don't explain it at all lmfao. Which is double weird considering Disney explains LITERALLY EVERYTHING ELSE like we're 5 years old.
@@GiuseppeGaetanoSabatelli Probably because they don't have a clue either
@@nananamamana3591 Yes this^^^ thats how i took it.
I have Lucas' six films and the pre-Filoni/Fav EU. That is Star Wars. I'm happy with that now and am at peace with the fact that there will be no more.
I never appreciated the old EU enough until it was gone. Comparing it to everything the Clone Wars and onwards actually made me realize how much better those old books and games tie in with the feel of the movies while maintaining their own identity.
Robot Head please make a video ranting about the new Rey movie... as if anyone's really going to pay for more Rey lmfao
I can't watch any star wars product these days.
I feel like I am being skull-fusked by Disney executives, not watching entertainment.
These videos are the only thing keeping me sane.
"Consume product, like brand, get booster, support the current thing 🇺🇦 🇹🇼"
They're making me lose my mind. Pushing a dumb narrative as to what George Lucas wanted the New Republic to be, even though he never actually released his version of the New Republic, and when he did discuss what it would have been like, it's exactly what The Mandalorian did.
Pretty much the same for me. RobotHead and these pills are the only things keeping me from launching a full assault on my neighbors garage and new gazebo
@@BurnDoubt assault the system, not the victims of it
@@godofthecripples1237 can you go into more detail about how and where he described new republic?
To be fair, Imperial warlords existed in the old EU as well. They tended to be based out of a holdout world or fleet that refused to surrender, and there was the Imperial Remnant that was allowed to exist because it was in the best interest of the new government to not just start another war, or somesuch reason.
Yeah, agreed, and I want to add a fun little thought about the New Republic allowing the small piece of Empire loyalists to exist: isn't it also an ultimate display of DEMOCRACY to not just attack someone over their shameful past, but give them a voice in the senate, or at least leave them alone to taste "freedom" after 2+decades under a tyrannical regime? 😂
Was the comment I was looking for.
I really dont understand tho, its like a new threat emerging but this so happens to be NEW one from an old relic.
Its like Russia doing what they want in Ukraine and you know, USA doing fuck all about it lol.
You could literally pretend Russia was a Neo Nazi state, USA still wouldnt do shit lol.
So YES there can be empire warlords doing their own thing. In fact it wouldnt make sense if the empire completely dissapeared. Knowing Robot Head he'd complain and say "ohhh yehh nahh look do the writers really think the empire would just dissapear after EP6? They were a powehouse with Millions of troops like how did they just die off without a trace heuheueh. More dumb disney writing yehh nahhhh euhehehe" fkn hell man.
This guy just complains about everything. Literally very video is an overly sarcastic whinny tone of voice. He views everything the same nihilistic lens, thus he can also make leaps in logic
And no im not a disney fan boy, thats (Robot Heads go to counter claim.) I dont like anything they have produced haha.
This is not the mando that Favreau wanted to do. He originally wrote it to have Gina Carano's character be more involved and have it build up to Rangers. It was not suppose to have grogu and to have mando going on a much bigger redemption adventure of him rejoining the watch. That's not what we got. It's because of Kennedy's firing of Gina Carano, and having him do a huge rewrite of season three. Which is why it pushed it's release date back by a month and a half.
That woman seems to destroy everything she touches!
@@CyberLou Andor enters the chat
KK has destroyed StarWars
Jar Jar Binks is so damn likeable in comparison to kennedy
@@Aochso ironically Lucas also had to do something similar with jar jar, which resulted in a massive rewrite of ep2 which is why the movie turned out strange and oddly paced
What I thought was really stupid was that the season started out with Mando needing to find a robot which is somehow crucial to him being able to find the waters, so he goes to get his first robot partner, who is now a statue but could be fixed with a special part. So he goes to get the special part from the lady on Tattooine, who gives him an R2 unit instead. Mando then goes to Mandalor, tells the R2 unit to go scout the mines for the water. When robot vanishes, Mando decides to go himself and tells Grogu that the robot wasn't really necessary in the first place, Mando was just too lazy to do the work himself, making the first two episodes a complete waste of time.
The thing that has annoyed me about JF's writing since the beginning is that all he does is send Mando off on one side quest after another. Now he's sending Mando off on side quests that aren't even necessary in the first place.
clearly u know nothing about star wars legends
The Mandalorian was the last of current Star Wars that I actually liked, but even The Mandalorian fell victim to the absolute dumpster fire that is the Disney selected writer's room. Season 2 had it's problems, sure, but it was still overall pretty great. But the quality of this season just fell off the cliff. I hate that the people in charge of Star Wars just don't give a shit about Star Wars.
The quality never fell, it was not good since the begining of the season 1 ....
@@vortex1603 nah man first 3 or maybe even 4 episodes where great
Andor?
It’s because they are no longer hiring writers based on talent.
@Spacetrooper I once heard somewhere that that she supposed to be the new character that will replace Gina Carano as the strong female character.
Showing the scene where the scientist and the spy stroll around slurping on the inexplicably glowing popsicles and not commenting on it was a perfect demonstration of how you can trust an audience to recognize idiocy without drawing a map to it.
Wait, I feel like I might be missing something here.
The idiocy was that it was glowing, right?
@@purpleemerald5299 I am going to respect your intelligence by not answering!
@@jmoountfort5204 OH NO!
@@purpleemerald5299 they mean it was a good example of how to show stupid writing and how the guy making this video didn’t even have to talk about the stupid “popsicles”
@@jmoountfort5204 but didn’t you just disrespect them anyways? Why are you an asshole? I’ll tell you why, it’s because you think you’re so smart and so above them that you feel like you don’t even have to explain something so simple. It’s not their fault they couldn’t understand you, let alone how awful you explained it. I’m pretty intelligent and I couldn’t even understand you. A drunken monkey could’ve explained this better than you. You’re not smart, sorry ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ As Albert Einstein once said ““If you can't explain it simply, you don't understand it well enough.” So sit tf down you egotistical wannabe
To be fair, most of the audience these days don’t have the attention span of a fridge. The writers and producers know most people are on their phones most of the show, so they have to describe the action for those not watching the screen.
My thoughts too. Sounds like the writing was made for smartphone addicts who can't keep off their social media for an hour or two.
Just happens to be the same crowd they've been trying to appease with The Message.
@@NefariousKoel Bingo
But the problem is, when they do it like this, I don’t have the attention span to watch it, whereas I do have the attention span to watch Andor for example, because it actually develops the audiences connection with the characters well, and shows more than tells/uses subtext in speech
That doesn't make sense since a fridge is a constant...something erratic would've been a better example.
“To be fair?”
Han Luke and Leia never accomplished anything in this new canon. Everyone is a failure. Legends Leia helped rebuild the new republic. Luke rebuilt the Jedi order on Yavin. Han became a respected diplomat, father, and hero.
I hate Disney Star Wars.
i gotta disagree.... this episode was the only one i really enjoyed so far. you complain about it being about 2 characters we have no connection to? if they were famous SW characters you'd complain about pointless cameos and fanservice. the idea of an ex-imperial scientist who takes part in an amnesty programm is actually kinda smart and interesting. and you know what else this episode had? Stakes! we dont know what will happen to those characters. they dont have plot armor, they dont have the force, they dont have another season guaranteed....they can die or be captured at any moment. Dr. Pershing is a good concept. maybe not executed perfectly, but at least SOMETHING! still better than exposition-dump Bo Katan or "Save me"-Djarin!
''Somehow palpatine for another timed.'' such wisdom. much writing.
someone who actually makes sense, thank god these videos exist
He's best in biz
@@mmaboxingclips2407sooo true
I’m so tired of all the Star Wars channels like Ekhart and SWT eating this up like it’s a good show.
I watched this episode on Wednesday and have already forgotten it! Thanks for reminding what didn’t happen in this episode. Season 3 has no direction at all.
None of the seasons of any of these shows have any direction, stop deluding yourself.
@@Liberty_or_Dedim baffled how many ppl think these shows add anything to this universe. The first season was ok because it felt like it atleast was a step in the right direction while season 2-3 is just bad writing galore made by ppl who doesnt understand Star Wars
I'm behind on the Mandalorian, and tbh, I'm finding it hard to continue to watch it as opposed to the first 2 seasons where I never missed an episode. The Bad Batch is the only good thing from Disney Star Wars right now and that show is being carried by Crosshair's story arc as opposed to the main cast episodes that have been mostly filler this season.
Seriously...stop watching this crap so they stop making it. When will you lot learn? Stop paying them. Stop watching
@@Liberty_or_Ded I get what you mean, season 1 and 2 were just cameos tbh
Star Wars IS for kids. I loved the originals AS A KID. My kids like the Mandalorian. It's just a TV show.
The first 18 seconds of this video is Disney Star Wars in a nutshell. A woman tells the man to follow her lead and he tells her she is better than him. And of course she looks like a pure blooded lesbian. Pretty much sums it all up.
the answer to what age is apparently 8. In this season I fell asleep in episode 1 and 2, my wife and 11 year old dipped out permanently after episode 2 and the only one left that wants to watch it is my 8 year old. Such a shame after really good first season and pretty good second season.
Update, my son and I just watched episode 3... He spent the whole episode asking "where's Mando? Is this a different show? Who are these people" because of this I had trouble sleeping 😴
I think we all know where doctor glasses' research is going; "somehow palpatine returned"
Boba Fett: How does it fell when someone steals an episode of your show, Din Djarin?
Season 3 is fuckin sick as. But I guess it’s the only starwars out at the moment and robot head got bills to pay😅
The Star Wars galaxy is like Mexico, you got Cancun planet, half the planets are desert, the government only controls the city planets, most people believe in the force, and there’s a bunch of rebels and criminals.
They should give Lucasfilm back to George for free at this point. I know he doesn't really want to make any more films at this point but maybe he could create his own studio, hire film makers he likes and just oversee it, maybe get his family involved
If only you idiots didn't bully him out of it
He doesn't wanna make more because he thinks star wars is finished. All he wanted to do was tell anakins story. Disney might not be george lucas but I think it's impossible for star wars to be bad and people complain about the bad which isnt that bad and don't recognize the good.
@@owengrube9127 I'd rather have had star wars end for good then let Disney buy it and ruin it, same goes for Marvel.
@PJ-gm1hb never could get into marvel even before disney but the new black panther movie was the worst of them all in my opinion. However the mandolorian is a great show I don't put much thought into the way technology works because hyperspace is pretty unrealistic in general, all I care about is the storyline and seeing Luke's temple being built while training grogu was cool and so were the grogu order 66 scenes. Luke surviving the beast in jabbas palace, the snow beast and calling for Leia with one arm is just as bad as Palpatine surviving in my opinion.
Lol. And why would Disney to that
The big problem in season 3 is that there’s no real plot, we need something to guide the story because at the moment it doesn’t feel like any happening really matters. It just feels bland and boring at the moment
Favreau apparently wanted to move on from Jin and focus on Bo Katan reuniting the Mandalorians. It was the whole point of introducing the Dark Saber. but Kennedy jumped in to bring Grogu back and F everything up. Favreau was so pissed he threaten to quit and the only way they kept him was to give him full control over Ashoka. He checked out of Mando season 3 and it definitely shows.
There is a plot (or at least seems to be), but it's buried under a metric ton of bloat. I showed someone how easily the main storyline from the first 4 episodes could have EASILY been shown in a single episode. Every season of Mandalorian has like 2 to 3 episodes worth of actual story, and the rest is pointless filler.
The Mandalorian is like if they took each of the 2 episode acts from Kenobi and stretched it into an entire 8 episode eason
Jon Favreau's a hack, just like everyone else as DisneyFilm these days.
Nothing in Disney Wars is canon, simple as.
I interpreted the torture scene differently than you… I thought that the “therapy” was genuine and they were really trying to help him and giving what’s-her-face the opportunity to dial up the juice and kill him. Terrible writing even if this is the case because who would ever be allowed to leave when administering therapy with a dangerous tool. The resulting scene leaves the new republic incompetent rather than evil but it’s still terrible.
I just want to point out.. George's wife helped him far more than you'd give her credit for.. George made good movies but you can see the loss in quality after she left him.
It seems like in this episode, Jon Favreau was trying to bridge the OT to the sequels by showing how evil and stupid the new Republic was and how they fell within 20 years.
Yep, but no explanation why they went same path, but hey, maybe that's a story for another spin off!
Sounds like they're desperately trying to retcon the sequels into making sense.
@Not Gordon Freeman it does not make sense
@@Feark its ONE episode. game of thrones took like 7 fuckin years to tell a story (which they messed up badly at the end)
@@daveeol1987 Hence the word "trying."
Nothing these days with Star Wars news surprises me.
season 3 has been a disappointing mess so far :(
You nailed it with this review. There isn’t anyone at LFL capable of handling Star Wars.
We now know that there is no good or evil in Star Wars… so that explains everything
'Who's gonna be the top?' LMFAO😆
Anyone could find this funny, but as a gay man myself, it tickled me extra 😂
You mean Faveru is just taking a paycheque and doesn't care!? Wow....I mean how could we have realised this sooner from a guy who was fired from being a director on a movie but remained working in the movie as an actor because he wanted money?!
What movie was he fired from?
I believe Placeholder is referring to Iron Man 3.
@@nathank2289 He was the director for Iron Man and Iron Man 2 was supposed to do Iron Man 3 but was fired for Shane Black as they wanted a different thing than him.
He didn't leave the MCU though, likes the money he gets from them too much for that.
@Placeholder oh I didn't read anything about him getting fired, just that he left to work for Disney, ironic. That might help explain why IM3 was such a shit show though.
@@UncensoredScion IMO Robert Downey Jnr used his star power to get his old pal Shane Black in. Downey owed Black for giving him a fresh break in Kiss Kiss Bang Bang. Without which his MCU career might never.
I still like to believe this is all happening because of kk’s interference with Grogu being sent back to mando. If I remember right Gina carrano was gonna get her own show and that was gonna expand on the new republic.
These had to of caused problems in the writing room. Especially since his overlords are wanting people to like the sequels but don’t have the rangers of the new republic to flesh that out.
Mando season three just feels like they were meant to be doing this without grogu but we’re forced to add him in taking away the storyline of mando accepting what happened and finding new meaning (it’s obvious that they want him to become the new mandalore). I just have a very strong suspicion that the rangers show that was gonna happen would involve the scientist at some point. It all just feels compressed.
Its all on Disney and lucasfilm they just needed mando to succeed and in some or many ways have interfered with it. I mean the rumour of Jon favreau threatening to quit while it was already in production should show it affected what happened.
"Dry biscuits is as deep as this show is going to go." LOL perfectly said about all of the Disney Star Wars series.
Robothead people do have the attention span of a fridge these days though lol
😂
This show started so well 😢
I have spoken
This is the gay.
@@celozzip i laughed way more than i should have, thanks anon
It really didn't.
In hindsight it was just "good" but not great, but for "any port in a storm" it was amazing at that time.
It was good compared to what we had at the time, in retrospect it isn't very good. We just had hope it could fix things and it didn't.
1:58 - Well, big universe is a valid argument. The Empire spanned across the entire galaxy so it's not gonna be wiped out as quickly.
And, uh... regarding WWII... take a look at the post-war governments of Japan and Spain...
Dr Pershing action fiqure plz
😂 genius
Just read Heir to the Empire instead of watching Mando.
It’s a novel that takes place 5 years after ROTJ that gives you the OT gang you know and love and unlike Mando, the New Republic and Imperial remnant are shown to be competent and not idiots.
I have a theory, they are making there movies accessible to the blind and partially sighted. The writing sounds like Audio Description.
The disabled already have systems that do that for them, especially with big mainstream studio content like this. But I think you're close. They're no longer producing exclusively for Americans, but for a worldwide audience, including less developed places with masses that aren't terribly bright. In other words, they're targeting the least common denominator on a global scale.
It’s as if shows can’t be about their main characters anymore.
The glowing ice creams and how one was red to foreshadow her intention needed a mention.
To be fair, i dont think it was george writing for subtle emotion in the original. If he was 100% in charge, luke would have probably scream ''noooo'' looking at his family death. Never forget those wonderfull line like ''youre breaking my heart anakin''
Mandalorian really tried pulling an Andor, except instead of making a decent story they pulled up a pile of shit
Semi-decent, to be more specific.
@@FMK03not really
Welp here we are at the end, was a very good run I guess, I can just headcannon the show ended when Mando and Grogu parted ways and he simply became mandalorian no more.
Don't forget Filoni too, not just Favreau
disney star wars is dumb and NOT canon !!!!!
If he hates Lucas, then why did he bring him to the set of seasons 1 and 2? Hell, Kamran Pasha even said on G+G in 2020 that he heard from some of his friends that Favreau hated TLJ, and is the reason why he wanted to get involved with SW.
I mainly place the blame of season 3 disappointing fans on the "firing" of Gina, and TBoBF undoing the season 2 finale of Mando. Both sins of Shitleen Shilledy.
So Robot Head, maybe do a little more research.
I actually really liked the idea of a show that follows ex imperials trying to make a life for themselves in the new republic. Star Wars desperately needs a story of the villains working for redemption. But then the "bad guy" got tortured to death by his bad friend. Welp back to Disney level of writing again.
You know, you’d think for a show called the Mandalorian, it would be about just that, not catch up with everything else StarWars, which the sequel movie should’ve at least attempted a lil
@@johnchief270 your explanation sounds like *The kardashians* show 😅, there will be no one in this show except Kardashians 😂😂.
The EU showed that even with the Emperor being dead it would still be a long road to freeing the galaxy of the Empire’s influence, after fighting various Imperial factions and Warlords including Grand Admiral Thrawn they eventually settled on a peace treaty between the factions and New Republic years later. (Also in the EU Timeline, the New Republic wasn’t pathetically stupid like in the Disney Timeline and actually got shit done even if it was a uphill battle for them)
I'm thinking of becoming a professional writer, check this out:
"they exploded my house"
"that ship is flying and shooting lasers"
"I blew up that ship now there is one less ship"
"turn left and I will also turn left"
"those ships are from a guy that has ships and is a meanie head"
"science bad, smart people bad, rich people bad, government bad, law enforcement bad"
I've been practicing
The only entertainment I get from Disney Star Wars is RobotHead videos that take a huge robot dump on Disney Star Wars.
Thanks Robot Head.
And thanks Disney.
The fact that Robot Head can monetize these robot dumps makes the whole thing even sweeter.
I love your natural Star Wars logic. The truth is that you should be the guy hired by Disney to say "Yeah that's a shit idea and doesn't make any sense", but of course Disney would have zero desire for that kind of person :)
That's the kind of thing a producer is supposed to do, well a good producer that is
"Officer They" and "Doctor Glasses". 😅🤣
RobotHead is GOATed. Great video.
Officer "They" 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Man, you had me rollin' on that one, Disney is trash! I would never pay money to see this garbage.
The whole scene where dr glasses and dr they were walking around the fair or whatever was so boring and drawn out
Only a matter of time until they brought alphabets people into star wars, i’m not surprised but god damn am i disappointed.
The Force Is She-Male. Officer they/them with the taped down breasts. Yuck 🤮
I watch these shows bewildered and confused but I need Robot Head to explain why I'm not the idiot, the writers are
how many times do we have to say, Star wars died, until people realize Starwars died.
Officer They is obviously evil.
The attention-span of teenagers, ergo the supposed target-audience of this show, have gone so backwards thanks to excessive TikTok and TH-cam-shorts consumption that shows and movies have to constantly state facts happening so the viewers remember.
Actors emote with their facial expressions. You put a helmet on them, and you cut out a major part of their "character" - unfortunately some writers feel that the way to get around this is by giving them more dialogue. But I agree that this dialogue doesn't actually have to be as obvious as they're making it.