Just brilliant. You are the rare host who can create the right space for any guest to talk naturally and at length, and your preparation for these sessions, along with your authentic interest, makes the quality of discussion incredible. The professor was wonderful, frankly it goes without saying, and we sincerely hope he will be back again so we can learn more from him. The Pakistan Experience has become such a precious space for Pakistanis to learn and laugh and talk sense. Eagerly awaiting more content like this!
Every Pakistani needs to listen to this podcast. We have this habit (including me) about our country keh 'yahan kuch nahe ho sakta', whereas Dr. Asim is literally experimenting and showing us, with hard proof, keh sab kuch ho sakta hai. There's so much more than that in this podcast. Must watch. Shehzad, bravo on this interesting podcast!
why do u need to listen to an economist when you have great "scholars" like hafeez sayeed zakir naik etc. Just keep reading kuran 5 times a day and do what you are already good at :P
Another great podcast. Thank you The Pakistan Experience Team. Honestly, bringing on such guests who're not fear mongering and telling people that Pakistan is doomed but instead actually pin point the "symptoms" as Dr. Asim rightly points out and then provide suggestions and solutions to such is great. Kudos to you guys. Keep up the great work.
Indepth and insightful analysis in light of academic and pragmatic approaches in the context of Pakistan. Relevant questions and candid responses though a bit longish but very aptly put many of our national and societal issues in perspective. Nevertheless, very interesting and illuminating views. Appreciate a lot for sharing it.
Dear Asim sir, you are a life enlightened. Thank you so much for your broad thoughts, ideas and projects that you are continue to engage with. Thank you Shehzad for being Dr Sahab at TPE. There should be a sequel to this
i have an exam tomorrow yet i am hooked to this.... Ive always beleived that when my generation (which is very politically aware of things due to works of guys like shehzad sir) grows up we will be able to make a better pakistan together but yet... people like Asim sir Atif sir should come out jon such platforms more and educate us more... I am very hopeful about the future of pakistan❤
A wonderful spirit lifting talk!Rarely have heard had an economist so engaging , so patriotic and spontaneous. He may belong to an elite set up but has seen the grassroots up front or closely.Looking forward to more.Subscribing to "the Pakistan experience."
Best conversation I've ever heard pertaining to economics! Economics ki integration with ikhlaq, incentives, and such intelligent thoughts elucidated for the common man. Loved this!!!
This is the best podcast on your channel which I have seen. I have not watched all your podcasts but this was the dose of optimism I needed after weeks of pessimism about this country. Thank you for this!
Such wonderful mindset and ideas shared by Sir Khawaja. I agree with him that Pakistan has immense potential we only need strategic clarity of what to do and how to do. I would like to thank Shahzad for bringing such distinguished guests and sharing their thoughts and ideas. Shahzad would love to see a couple of economists together sometime.
The homework and research shehzad does about his guest he is inviting is absolutely mind-blowing.... Asim applauded him for that and so did Istiaq Ahmed...This shows in order to successfully carrying the podcast for a longer interval the interviewee undoubtedly has to be on the same level if not above the level of the guest...
This was a great guest because he actually had experienced first hand how things work in Pakistan. Most qualified economists living abroad from well-connected families have no clue about life of average tax Payer in Pakistan. As your guest himself noted several times that the things he learned on the ground made him alter his approach to various programs he was conducting. I think Pakistan has a lot to learn from Egypt's economic meltdown. Egypt also has lots of highly qualified economists from well-connected families who live in foreign countries. But have no clue about the life of average taxpayer of Egypt, therefore, their policies failed.
I am a big fan of Dr. Asim Khwaja. I wish he had talked about what happens to graduates of our high school , college and even professional graduates. A doctor graduate after passing all the exams and by the time he finishes all the exams and training , gets 70 to 80,000 Pak Rupees. My nephew works 12 hours a day and is 2 years out of medical college and still has 2 years to pass all the exams , for foreseeable future he will not be able to survive without help from parents. 25 Million children never went to any school. Dr. Khwaja bigger point on importance of education is right on point and he has some excellent ideas. However, i agree with ex Finance Minister Mr. Miftah Ismail- Pakistan is, has been and would remain for 1% of Pakistanis unless some major fundamental changes are made.
I belong to a middle class family ... Without these podcasts i would have never got the exposur of the world for the elite class ... Thanks to internet and people like shehzad people like me can be open minded and devlope themselves and others ...
sir this micro thing you said about education how we are focusing on eduction at lower grass root level and specially in villages, this hits so close to home, my uncle retired the highest possible position a scientist can reach almost same level as Abdul Qadeer Khan cant name him, same my dad and my other uncle all achieved greatness in their fields, they moved to cities made homes there. Recently, I got the oppertunity to visit my village and its hard to believe how this family of ours was able to remove the shackles of poverty, it was eduction they literallly had to walk 7 to 8 kms to reach school, my grand mother was so forward thinking at the time, she took loans from many people so her kids can study and it paid off so much so much i cant explain. and people used to say "parha k kia krlo g" kahen mazdoor laga do. She said no they will study whatever they want. One time my uncle took high level delegates to our village they wanted to open a research lab and though that location could be a suitable place but at that point one friend who was from Karachi said this to my uncle "yar **** tu yahan say yahan tk ponhcha ha, yakeen ni hota" it sums it up nicely. how education changes generations.
An interesting discussion. Pakistanis thing that one Economist will come to Pakistan, will make some macro level adjustments and all economic issues will be solved which is not the fact. We need to improve a very strong linkage between our educational institutions and the industry which will bring productivity at the firm level. Enhancement of citizens and local government interaction will be key in economic growth of Pakistan. .......
It was so pleasant and full of knowledge conversation. The theory of friction to promote competition and improvement and having a multiplier effect was an eye opener.
Ease of doing business india improve by more than 75 place it's now under 50 Unicorn 100 startup movement E education revolution due to jio All he mentioned india is implementing Kudos 👌
Asim - I’m responding to your comment about why politicians are unable to harvest data and information to improve services and social welfare. I am of the opinion that the majority of our traditional politicians consciously or unconsciously lack vision, empathy and the motivation to deliver public service. Instead their prerogatives is to make money by hook or by crook for their personal welfare.
It is so disheartening that certain politicial parties are trying to induce FUD in the Pakistan just to further their political agendas. Rather than trying to address the issue at its core they are just running once again spreading fear. My vote is revoked forever. Such type of selfish political strategy is beyond despicable. This is great podcast, need to think about remedies not spread panic.
Y is every project or study is lahore centric. I am sure if u do it not so big cities or cities other than the ones in punjab you will find different kind of data
Hi Shehzad I have seen many times you are taking about production quality camera quality lighting but it’s very disappointing watching your video quantity and camera quality when you do live video chat with overseas guests you can compare yours video quality with Kushal Mehra from India it’s look like your were using old VGA webcam or laptop webcam. I’m professional videographer if you need any help in terms of lighting and camera let me know I would like to help you but you need to improve your camera and lighting during podcast with overseas guests.whole world is watching you and listing you taking about production quality I think you should improve yours video quality too no issue with ur studio setup BTW
an economist cant be emotional because economics doesnt teach emotions instead it teaches about the economy and Fiscal policy.. 🤣🤣🤣 Focus on Demand and Supply... even if you don't know macro economics, Pakistan needs to make a long term fiscal policy not based on individual (Imran gadha) but focused on mass(Pakistani Citizen).. because in long term everyone is dead...
Dr asim..Your point of education not being a vote getter is so important. It is the reason because of which better education is not being given to the constituents. Check out AAP in New Delhi . They are winning elections because of better education being given to children. And yes education is their most important item in their manifesto.
@@ThePakistanExperience indeed Shehzad. It is barely possible to find illustrious academics on mainstream media. It is almost a barren land for viewers to watch guests like Sir Asim Ijaz Khwaja. Bringing them on podcasts,knowing their views on chronic issues of society, economy and politics, and learning from their million ideas is not less than a miracle. I hope you may have an endless litany of distinguished guests on our platform.🙏🙏🙏
But where is quality in Pakistan. Guy seems over optimistic as quality that Pakistan poses is not even comparable to 3rd standard of other progressing countries. All the best for future
@Tic a poet sings a poem irrespective of others like poetry or not. It's not done for others. A poet sings a poem because it comes naturally to him. Look there is a difference between being strong and being hateful.
Academics know nothing abt running a country - kawazi kwartem experience in UK should be a lesson Education point is also crap. He doesn’t understand what investment in education really looks like
Such a mediocre discussion, just a decorated name no solid content. Those who are praising Asim Ijaz must have not listened to real economics before. Waste of time. Shehzad as always good job though.
Such project on which he is working should also be executed in other big/small cities, every thing (safe city, tax acknowledgment, police upbringing, etc) all appear to be Lahore based nothing for Karachi, Quetta, Faisalabad, Gawader, Multan.
![[UNCUT] The Loyal Pin ปิ่นภักดิ์ EP.7 (1/4)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/2rPGOyKs0VE/mqdefault.jpg)
I am a lecturer in UK university, and the information and critical analysis you shared..... Just wow.... I will definitely share this in my class :)
Just brilliant. You are the rare host who can create the right space for any guest to talk naturally and at length, and your preparation for these sessions, along with your authentic interest, makes the quality of discussion incredible. The professor was wonderful, frankly it goes without saying, and we sincerely hope he will be back again so we can learn more from him. The Pakistan Experience has become such a precious space for Pakistanis to learn and laugh and talk sense. Eagerly awaiting more content like this!
100% agree. This is the first podcast I've seen on this channel, n I've already become a fan.
Every Pakistani needs to listen to this podcast. We have this habit (including me) about our country keh 'yahan kuch nahe ho sakta', whereas Dr. Asim is literally experimenting and showing us, with hard proof, keh sab kuch ho sakta hai. There's so much more than that in this podcast. Must watch. Shehzad, bravo on this interesting podcast!
Agree with you. And we should have more podcasts like this 😊
He is so optimistic that he wants to move back here.
why do u need to listen to an economist when you have great "scholars" like hafeez sayeed zakir naik etc. Just keep reading kuran 5 times a day and do what you are already good at :P
@@indipacifician3693
Sure. Anything else you wanna say?
@@SuperZain121 You can also thigh 6 year old children and consummate at the age of 9
Another great podcast. Thank you The Pakistan Experience Team. Honestly, bringing on such guests who're not fear mongering and telling people that Pakistan is doomed but instead actually pin point the "symptoms" as Dr. Asim rightly points out and then provide suggestions and solutions to such is great. Kudos to you guys. Keep up the great work.
Excellent, thought provoking at a deep level
Indepth and insightful analysis in light of academic and pragmatic approaches in the context of Pakistan. Relevant questions and candid responses though a bit longish but very aptly put many of our national and societal issues in perspective. Nevertheless, very interesting and illuminating views. Appreciate a lot for sharing it.
Dear Asim sir, you are a life enlightened. Thank you so much for your broad thoughts, ideas and projects that you are continue to engage with. Thank you Shehzad for being Dr Sahab at TPE. There should be a sequel to this
I am speechless. What an amazing guest, what an amazing podcast, what an amazing discussion.
Loved it.
i have an exam tomorrow yet i am hooked to this.... Ive always beleived that when my generation (which is very politically aware of things due to works of guys like shehzad sir) grows up we will be able to make a better pakistan together but yet... people like Asim sir Atif sir should come out jon such platforms more and educate us more... I am very hopeful about the future of pakistan❤
A wonderful spirit lifting talk!Rarely have heard had an economist so engaging , so patriotic and spontaneous. He may belong to an elite set up but has seen the grassroots up front or closely.Looking forward to more.Subscribing to "the Pakistan experience."
I’ve been following you since the Zarrar Khuhro podcast. This is without doubt the best podcast so far.
It seems he loves Pakistan too much. Giving local people examples with true spirit. Love it, from a learned person to be humanistic.
Best conversation I've ever heard pertaining to economics! Economics ki integration with ikhlaq, incentives, and such intelligent thoughts elucidated for the common man. Loved this!!!
By d way he is excellent Pak needs more such people all d best for your future growth and development and keep doing such podcaste
Thank you for introducing me to Asim Ijaz Khwaja. His perspective is different and refreshing. I hope he gets to scale his projects.
Wonderful discussion, even a layman like me understood a lot of things.
This is the best podcast on your channel which I have seen. I have not watched all your podcasts but this was the dose of optimism I needed after weeks of pessimism about this country. Thank you for this!
Such an amazing and humble person, I could keep listening to Dr Asim for hours and not get bored. Amazing podcast
The anode and cathode store the lithium. The electrolyte carries positively charged lithium ions from the anode to the cathode and vice versa
The gentleman is so articulate and speaks so much sense that one thinks that why we don't utilize such superb talent...
Amazing podcast with realistic approach. Thanks for conducting a thoughtful interaction.
🙌
Very impressing and knowledgeable interview, thank you very much Shehzad and Asim Ejaz sahib, God bless you and increase your knowledge Ameen
Totally valid points. 36:50 onwards was a mater peace.
It took me 3 days to sum up this podcast. Amazing Shehzad Bhai. Keep calling Economist on your show.
I am currently a student of system thinking in solving wicked problems, and Asim khawja Nailed it :)
🙌
Such wonderful mindset and ideas shared by Sir Khawaja. I agree with him that Pakistan has immense potential we only need strategic clarity of what to do and how to do.
I would like to thank Shahzad for bringing such distinguished guests and sharing their thoughts and ideas. Shahzad would love to see a couple of economists together sometime.
The homework and research shehzad does about his guest he is inviting is absolutely mind-blowing.... Asim applauded him for that and so did Istiaq Ahmed...This shows in order to successfully carrying the podcast for a longer interval the interviewee undoubtedly has to be on the same level if not above the level of the guest...
Thank you!!!
What a brilliant conversation. Loved every minute of it, especially his thoughts on "insaniyat" more than anything else.
Great discussion. Thanks Ghias for bringing such brilliant people. We don't even know they exist. Realy thanksfull.
This was a great guest because he actually had experienced first hand how things work in Pakistan. Most qualified economists living abroad from well-connected families have no clue about life of average tax Payer in Pakistan. As your guest himself noted several times that the things he learned on the ground made him alter his approach to various programs he was conducting. I think Pakistan has a lot to learn from Egypt's economic meltdown. Egypt also has lots of highly qualified economists from well-connected families who live in foreign countries. But have no clue about the life of average taxpayer of Egypt, therefore, their policies failed.
I am a big fan of Dr. Asim Khwaja. I wish he had talked about what happens to graduates of our high school , college and even professional graduates. A doctor graduate after passing all the exams and by the time he finishes all the exams and training , gets 70 to 80,000 Pak Rupees. My nephew works 12 hours a day and is 2 years out of medical college and still has 2 years to pass all the exams , for foreseeable future he will not be able to survive without help from parents. 25 Million children never went to any school. Dr. Khwaja bigger point on importance of education is right on point and he has some excellent ideas. However, i agree with ex Finance Minister Mr. Miftah Ismail- Pakistan is, has been and would remain for 1% of Pakistanis unless some major fundamental changes are made.
MashaAllah Great personaility with alot of sympathy
Excellent format and fascinating discussion. Earned yourself a subscriber. Thank you
“I would rather have questions that can't be answered than answers that can't be questioned.”
Richard Feynman
Excellent program and excellent guest, hats off to you Shahzad, keep up the good work
I belong to a middle class family ...
Without these podcasts i would have never got the exposur of the world for the elite class ...
Thanks to internet and people like shehzad people like me can be open minded and devlope themselves and others ...
❤❤❤
sir this micro thing you said about education how we are focusing on eduction at lower grass root level and specially in villages, this hits so close to home, my uncle retired the highest possible position a scientist can reach almost same level as Abdul Qadeer Khan cant name him, same my dad and my other uncle all achieved greatness in their fields, they moved to cities made homes there.
Recently, I got the oppertunity to visit my village and its hard to believe how this family of ours was able to remove the shackles of poverty, it was eduction they literallly had to walk 7 to 8 kms to reach school, my grand mother was so forward thinking at the time, she took loans from many people so her kids can study and it paid off so much so much i cant explain. and people used to say "parha k kia krlo g" kahen mazdoor laga do. She said no they will study whatever they want.
One time my uncle took high level delegates to our village they wanted to open a research lab and though that location could be a suitable place but at that point one friend who was from Karachi said this to my uncle "yar **** tu yahan say yahan tk ponhcha ha, yakeen ni hota" it sums it up nicely. how education changes generations.
Very thoughtful discussion. Waiting for more informative sessions. 👍
Amazing conversation Brother, ♥️ from 🇮🇳
what a man, very thought-provoking podcast, brilliant
Amazing podcast! such a breath of fresh air Dr. Asim is!
@ Dr. Asim Ijaz Khwaja is a quite religious guy. Amazing to keep religion upto the mark in a western society where science and logics are everywhere.
He needs his community and can't dare to be a heretic but he gets his income in a non religious society.
Your guests & your questions 💯 simply awesome ❤
May God bless you with manymore
I love, love curiosity level of Dr. Khwaja.
Brilliant talk!
Loved it! Keep the quality content coming. Stay blessed Shahzad :)
I have been trying to leave this podcast for 15 mins ... Now I really have to work 😃 but I can't turn it off .. 😸
An interesting discussion. Pakistanis thing that one Economist will come to Pakistan, will make some macro level adjustments and all economic issues will be solved which is not the fact. We need to improve a very strong linkage between our educational institutions and the industry which will bring productivity at the firm level. Enhancement of citizens and local government interaction will be key in economic growth of Pakistan. .......
What a friction-ed yet beautiful podcast
It was so pleasant and full of knowledge conversation.
The theory of friction to promote competition and improvement and having a multiplier effect was an eye opener.
Another reason of not exporting mangoes to USA is that they have a certification called FDA which is really expensive for a manufacturer
Ease of doing business india improve by more than 75 place it's now under 50
Unicorn 100 startup movement
E education revolution due to jio
All he mentioned india is implementing
Kudos 👌
Asim - I’m responding to your comment about why politicians are unable to harvest data and information to improve services and social welfare. I am of the opinion that the majority of our traditional politicians consciously or unconsciously lack vision, empathy and the motivation to deliver public service. Instead their prerogatives is to make money by hook or by crook for their personal welfare.
Thanks that Shahzad did not label the guest as Right Wing Economist.
Brilliant take. Great work on the podcast.
Bro love your work!
Please use a dark background for the side by side video feeds next time. This green is really jarring on the eyes, thanks!
Great conversation. Love it.
Brilliant. Wanted to follow him on twitter but he doesnt seem to have an account😪
One of your rare good interviews
Dr Asim is brilint and inspiring
Your podcasts have created my interest in Economics 😁😁
🇧🇩 Is this the flag of Japan
ڪمال جي گفتگو آ ...مولا آباد رکي ..اوهان کي
Great
Dr Asim Ijaz and Atif mian great
Great great podcast 👍👍👍👍
What a gem . MashAllah
My IQ just went up a few points I think. Simply phenomenal.
Keep up the great work bro.
Please bring a real economist like miftah and atif the next time.
Shehzad bhai Urdu ka use zyada kiya kery na please
English seekh lo bhai zyada tar parhy likhy log english me hi baat karty haen kyun k wo Abroad Study kar ky aty haen ya job karty haen
Refreshing to listen to a "micro" economist
Amazing! Please publish on Google podcasts also
Couldn't find it 😣
Why isnt this being watched by every Pakistani?
Best podcast
It is so disheartening that certain politicial parties are trying to induce FUD in the Pakistan just to further their political agendas. Rather than trying to address the issue at its core they are just running once again spreading fear. My vote is revoked forever. Such type of selfish political strategy is beyond despicable. This is great podcast, need to think about remedies not spread panic.
Y is every project or study is lahore centric. I am sure if u do it not so big cities or cities other than the ones in punjab you will find different kind of data
salute!
Wow lovely analysis, love and respect Mr. Ijaz
Lost for words to laud!
is it just me or the title isnt supposed to be what it is
ALSO BIG UPS TO U SHAHZAD!!
I'm learning more about economics from TPE's podcasts than my A level book😭🤣
Loved it
reminds me of Banerji & Duflo
Hi Shehzad I have seen many times you are taking about production quality camera quality lighting but it’s very disappointing watching your video quantity and camera quality when you do live video chat with overseas guests you can compare yours video quality with Kushal Mehra from India it’s look like your were using old VGA webcam or laptop webcam. I’m professional videographer if you need any help in terms of lighting and camera let me know I would like to help you but you need to improve your camera and lighting during podcast with overseas guests.whole world is watching you and listing you taking about production quality I think you should improve yours video quality too no issue with ur studio setup BTW
an economist cant be emotional because economics doesnt teach emotions instead it teaches about the economy and Fiscal policy.. 🤣🤣🤣
Focus on Demand and Supply... even if you don't know macro economics, Pakistan needs to make a long term fiscal policy not based on individual (Imran gadha) but focused on mass(Pakistani Citizen)..
because in long term everyone is dead...
Dr asim..Your point of education not being a vote getter is so important. It is the reason because of which better education is not being given to the constituents.
Check out AAP in New Delhi . They are winning elections because of better education being given to children. And yes education is their most important item in their manifesto.
AAP isn't winning elections it's just MCD which has nothing to do with education and most educated people in Delhi voted for BJP not AAP
🇧🇩 Is this the flag of Japan
An eminent guest.
@@ThePakistanExperience indeed Shehzad. It is barely possible to find illustrious academics on mainstream media. It is almost a barren land for viewers to watch guests like Sir Asim Ijaz Khwaja. Bringing them on podcasts,knowing their views on chronic issues of society, economy and politics, and learning from their million ideas is not less than a miracle. I hope you may have an endless litany of distinguished guests on our platform.🙏🙏🙏
Just from this podcast, as I have not read this gentleman’s research, he seems completely naive
❤️❤️❤️
But where is quality in Pakistan. Guy seems over optimistic as quality that Pakistan poses is not even comparable to 3rd standard of other progressing countries. All the best for future
I as an indian, wish people of pakistan well.
Some time destruction is needed for new beginning
@Tic we are not them.
@Tic a poet sings a poem irrespective of others like poetry or not. It's not done for others. A poet sings a poem because it comes naturally to him.
Look there is a difference between being strong and being hateful.
Please invite Dr.Zulfiqar bhutta
Awesome. Kindly ask your guest's favourite book related to his field.
سر، لگتا ہے یہ پروگرام اردو والے جو آنگلش نہیں سمجھتے ، ان کے لئے نہیں لگتا
Way too religious for my taste. Sorry Shahzad.
Curiosity and religion in the same breath was too much for me. Sorry.
Who is this maulana sahab??
Academics know nothing abt running a country - kawazi kwartem experience in UK should be a lesson
Education point is also crap. He doesn’t understand what investment in education really looks like
Trying hard to be optimistic. But 44% of kids are out of school.
Such a mediocre discussion, just a decorated name no solid content. Those who are praising Asim Ijaz must have not listened to real economics before. Waste of time. Shehzad as always good job though.
Such project on which he is working should also be executed in other big/small cities, every thing (safe city, tax acknowledgment, police upbringing, etc) all appear to be Lahore based nothing for Karachi, Quetta, Faisalabad, Gawader, Multan.
allhamdulila
Tum Islam or profit k age nhi badh paoge