Glock 43 vs Lc9s Pro vs M&P Shield...Battle Of The Single Stacks Part 1
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ก.ย. 2024
- Joint the Shot Team here and get access to some awesome perks
/ hegshot87 Check out the USCCA here and see what they can do for you!
uscca.com/hegsh...
Check out the Tulster Oath and use the code heg87 for 15% off
tulster.com?afmc=Heg87
Self Defense Liability Insurance Disclaimer
The USCCA is not an insurance company. A policy has been issued to the USCCA by Universal Fire and Casualty Insurance Company. That policy provides the association and its members with self-defense liability insurance, subject to its terms, conditions, limitations, and exclusions.
uscca.com/hegsh...
Follow me on Instagram
/ hegshot87
Check out the Tulster Oath and use the code heg87 for 15% off
tulster.com?afmc=Heg87
Like our work? Considering supporting us on Patreon for as little as a buck per month!
/ hegshot87
Non sale items for OLIGHT use discount code heg87 for 10% off
bit.ly/3cK261N
Protect your firearms and other keep moisture away with Firearm Guard. Mention hegshot87 for free shipping.
bit.ly/3dZ5m90
Follow me on Facebook
/ hegshot87
Subscribe to my motorcycle channel
/ @hegshotrides
Check out 1776 United and use the discount code Hegshot87 for 10% off of everything on the website!
bit.ly/2kZII99
After you get your holster, keep your pants up with Kore essentials belts and save 10$ per belt with the discount code hegshot87
Check out our review of the Kore Essentials belts here!
www.youtube.co...
Equipment I use to produce videos
Camera #1- Nikon D5500 amzn.to/2ZuOXSp
Camera #2 Nikon D3300
amzn.to/32d1Cv1
Go Pro 7 Black
amzn.to/2HsDooy
Go Pro Seeker Book Bag
amzn.to/2EbeuYe
Go Pro Arm
amzn.to/2RIm98F
Rode Mics
amzn.to/2zqy5kN
Dell XPS 15
amzn.to/2zhIT4W
DIsclaimer- Our videos are done for educational and entertainment purposes only.
All music licenses bought from Envato, is credited from owner with permission or is in the TH-cam library.
Please Note! We do NOT sell, advertise the sale of or promote the sale of any firearm or ammo. Our videos are for educational and entertainment purposes only. Also there are no links to any website that sells firearms or ammo. Please understand that firearm safety is the most important thing to follow when handling any and all firearms. All of ours have been safety checked and we are in a controlled and safe environment when using them. Follow the rules of firearms safety as it is all of our responsibilities to do so. Our firearms are secured and kept in safes and/or locked up as they should be.
Please Note: We do NOT condone nor promote the modification of any firearms or accessories. ATTENTION: All Firearms Shown Have A Mag Limiter In Place because of TH-cam's policy on magazines. No mags shown exceed the limit placed by TH-cam
Love the LC9 s Pro with Extended mag Crimson Trace Laser, Talon Grip , with 50 grain Liberty Civil Defense Load . Perfect CCW combination
That's the LC9s, not the LC9 and it IS rated for +p. You shouldn't use +p in any of these small pistols regularly though. It shortens the life regardless of the brand. They each state this in their owner's manuals.
@@chuckjcarter it just mostly wears down the barrel right?
I love the Lc9s with a easy thumb-sweep safety and the 9 rd extended mag for a full palm grip instead of a 2 finger grip. It allows for a no-fumbling panic draw and still tucks well and 10 rd capacity.
After handling all three and checking as many reviews as I could, it was a no brainer - M&P Shield in 9mm.
I own the shield and the LC9S pro and for sure the better carry is the LC9 When I took the Ruger to the range for the first time I was AMAZED with how much smoother the trigger was and I have an APEX trigger on my shield. I also feel carrying the shield is now like a brick and I can't figure out why. I live in NYC and actually have the impossible to get CCW and Im not LEO nor have ever been, here you are only allowed 1 gun on the license and you can bet your sweet ass its the Ruger LC9SPro
I thought NYC only gave permits to politicians and rich elite? Did you see the John Stossel special where he applied for his permit in manhattan? Also, thanks for the comparison. I was severely torn between the two but your input was helpful.
Hard to get, you need to have a significant daily cash business. Cant just carry for protection. Home licenses are rarely ever denied. only if you have a major conviction on your record. Its all media lies and hype coupled with idiots that do not live in the city perpetuating the lie because they hate NYC.
Yes its a lot of paperwork, cost several hundred dollars is a pain in the ass and takes time but the ability to own a handgun in NYC is not nearly as impossible as everyone makes it out to be.
Stay safe.
IMHO the lc9s is far more comfortable to carry than either the shield of the glock have owned all 3. The trigger is far better too.
I've had significant time with all three guns and let me tell you, the Ruger LC9s is my all time favorite gun. It's thin, fits great in the hand, carries 8 rounds, good crisp trigger, and it's just a blast to shoot. I advise everyone to pick all three up and feel the guns for yourself, maybe you'll have a different opinion than I do.
Off the shelf for me it's the Shield, higher capacity and I like the trigger and point of aim. This is a personal preference. I just shoot the gun better so it's what I carry.
What a great review 3 handguns in one review. You covered a lot of material in one video. It was not boring at all Great Video Thanks.
+dale lima Thank you!
The thing that drives me nuts about the Glock 43 is that the standard mags hold 6.8 rounds, I can't believe they wouldn't extend the length just by the slightest to get that 7th round.
Great review, I agree with 99% of it. I put a bigger negative on the G43 because it was only 7+1. You can get the 9+1 for the lc9s.
(makes it about same size grip as M&P)
You should invest in shooting lessons, if you need that much ammo. Plus if you go with the Glock 26, you can use G19 mags in it. And carry spares......
I wound up buying the Ruger LC9s after watching your video and going down to my local gun shop with a leather inside the pant holster a 2 extra mags. I don't regret it at all. Love the gun, the trigger, the weight and can't even tell I'm wearing it and have to check to make sure it's there. Nice well made product that's pretty darn accurate.
I had the 43 and then shot the LC9s pro. Well I then sold the 43 and now carry the LC9s pro best out of the box trigger and by far the most comfortable to carry.
Dude that was long, but very informative. i did stick it out till the end ,& you helped me make my choice. Now to save up the money, but first im gonna check out more of your vids. Take care , stay safe.
I have the lc9s, super pleased with accuracy and crisp trigger, the size and shape of the hand grip carries well at the 2, 3 or 4 o'clock in concealed carry. No issues with feeding and the price is right.
lc9s pro is sick. just got it. highly recommend over glock43.
I too just bought the lc9s pro and you are exactly right. It is fantastic. I reviewed all three of these guns before I made my purchase. The gun show where I bought it also had the Glock for only 425 so I didn't get the Ruger for the price savings. I believe it to be the better weapon for concealed carry. He's right to, it is extremely accurate for such a small gun.
john brandenburg its not plastic rails. It’s steel.
john brandenburg sorry aluminum, i knew it was metal, not plastic. Plastic would not hold up against a steel frame designed for +P 9mm ammo.
great video......im giving the lc9 a better look now....thank you
dominick johnson I bought one. fantastic right out of the box..
Very good video. Thanks for the review. I have an lc9s pro and love it. Keep up the good work.
Brian Carrington Thanks Brian!
We just got the Shield 9mm with safety for my wife, and the mag release can be switched to left handed. I think the easiest way to tell is probably to look at the included mags and see if the notch is on both sides.
Thanks for the video. I am going to give serious consideration to LC9s
No problem
Good review, I picked up a LC9s about a month ago and love it so far. Took my CPL class with it and everyone was pretty shocked at how accurate it was given its size. The one mag only thing does annoy me along with the disconnect which I will be removing sometime here in the near future. Overall very happy with it and would buy it again.
I see the holster in your video is similar to one I ordered from a different company. Mine is by Raw Dog Tactical and has leather on the back side versus being all kydex. Much more comfortable than the Alien Gear I have.
+platinumjason Thank you. Congrats man the Lc9s is awesome
Thanks Hegshot87 for the tip on Sportsman's Guide $20 off. I just purchased myself a Ruger AR 5.56 and a Ruger LCP2!
Hegshot makes excellent videos! I'm an long time leoo an have a sig 226 tactical, several glocks, hk's and a couple of and this video helped me get the LC9 for ccw.
john williams Thanks man! Im glad you found something you liked
Great review. If you are concerned about people watching the videos to the end, I have suggestions.: 1. Turn the music down or off. 2. If you want to show a still - stop moving, panning and zooming on the stills, it really doesn't enhance anything IMHO. 3. Plan what you are going to say and how long you're going to take to say it. 4. Shoot for 10 or 15 minute max. Link the videos. All the best to you and yours and thank you for the review.
Can you get your hands on a H&K P30 SK ? Would love to see how it compares to this field.
Ketema Harris I just picked up my first HK but it's not that new lol. I can try but unfortunately the way we do it is buy and sell to get newer things on the table. We were very fortunate to have all 3 of these at once but our newest video explains the reason for the newest gun we have :)
Yes the LC9 melts like butter ! ITW I carry both M&P Nice vid , very informative
I carry the Lc9s pro for my concealed and I love it. Granted I'll be getting and extra mag but overall really slick and carrys well!
I have the shield in 9mm and the lc9s and love them both, great ccw pistols.
I have just purchased the Shield, 9mm. You asked what I thought of it, and I just fired my first almost 100 shots. I like it a lot! I did notice while shooting the flush magazine that there were a couple of baubles, or failures to cycle. My brother-in-law said it was because of "limp-wristing." I tightened up on my grip and that seemed to solve the problem. The trigger is rather stiff, and I will have to put in more range time to prevent it from messing up my aim. Overall I like the shield. Thanks for helping me with my research on getting a carry gun.
+Douglas Davenport i just got a .40 on the shield. i love it man, conceals easy, shoots nice, im very happy with it,about 200 rnds through it and the trigger keeps getting better and better. next up is some night sights and maybe a custom light set up.
the lc9s. is a great value
Enjoyed the video, great in depth comparison of the three, looking forward to the shoot off
Curt Richardson Thanks bro
I'm ex-law enforcement w/Sheriff's Dept.,here on the Mississippi Gulf coast.In the Academy,From day 1 (in 1993) thru around the 3rd week anyway ,I carried m my dads S & W .357 mag.,and shot the only perfect score that class of 56 or the S.O.'s class that yr. (but only in the stagnant targets,prone/left handed, barricades,etc..)But,tactically with,(our academys Hogans Alley/Mach-up town,obstacles,etc...)and all physical/speed,and upcoming courses,A hand cannon,6shot,speed-loaders or not,just wouldn't cut it.so,at 1st weeks brake,it got the Glock 22. 40 cal. And then 2yrs later another Glock ,but the Glock 23. 40 cal. And when graduated & Finished top of my class,my dad's gift...his .357 mag. My point to all this trivial info. Is basically when it's an ABSOLUTE MUST,when it comes to the 3 MOST IMPORTANT attributes of a concealment,personal defense (Mine anyway...) weapon. #1.-RELIABILITY/QUALITY: i,e; If you CAN'T feel confident/comfortable in having your life or the lives of your loved one's LITERALLY in the hands of the product...Don't even consider the purchase. #2.-ACCURACY/FUNCTIONALITY: i,e.; The speed,accuracy,location of options and ability to QUICKLY utilize them #3.- Finally ,CONCEALMENT/COMFORT. when it comes to being unseen,NO IMPRINTING,It's sleek,thin comfortable feel,shape,and too+many other reasons to list,as to why my ABSOLUTE FAVORITE OF ANY 9mm and/or concealment weapons is,and has been since coming out ,is......my 2- Smith & Wesson 9mm M & P Shields. 1-(mine) w/built-in rod spring laser system. And 2nd one ,was 1st model with safety is my daughters. SO MY WEAPONS CHOICES ALWAYS unwavering,And....My heritage,being of the fatherland,but my father an officer of the U.S. Navy 23yrs. But i was born on u.s. naval base Virginia along with unsurpassed dependability and durability,ALWAYS my DUTY weapons GLÖCKS. and weapon of choice for carry.unseen or not off the job... my U.S. Made Smith & Wesson M&P 9MM SHIELD. good vids,I like and subscribed.all reading this,I recommend the same.And remember...when on target down range,to any wishing you or loved ones harm,but only When needed..."Shoot straight & true"...but to all wishing you & yours well..."ALWAYS,STAY TRUE and BE STRAIGHT". God bless,and keep up the informative vids.
Impressive review, worth watching, straight to the point not overly extended. Nice job!
+chgofirefighter Thanks man
Reliability with hollow point ammunition and concealability is really all that matters with these guns.
I have an Lc9s and is very easy to shoot and acurate with low recoil. is slim and without sharp edges. 21 oz. w/full mag of 115gr jhp. This Gun is by far better than glock 43 which is to square.
Great video for sure.The Ruger wins hands down.
You forgot to mention the LC9S has steel sights and a steel trigger where the Glock is plastic...... IMO the LC9S is the winner of all three for my carry
+chechatonga no, the G43 is better..
+Arron Geatches Why? Because it costs more? Oh and it's a GLOCK! Pffft
ruger lc9s pro definitely takes the cake for me.
White Dorito
I would either go with the shield or Ruger. The 43 leaves alot to be desired. Low round count out the door. Crappy plastic sights. Yeah it's small but that's about it. I'm not a complete glock hater I wouldn't mind a G19 but that's about it.
I love my shield way better than I thought it would be I had the Lc9s I sold it ... was rough on the hand a little the shield so awesome up there with my glocks
::: Actually grip size of LC9s is smaller than Glock-43, smaller than M&P shield. We cold carry LC9s all day long and whole week with the feeling exactly like carrying a mobile phone. Especially those shorter guy like me, or slim female for personnel protection. And 7 round 9 mm magazine is too enough for personnel emergency protection case. Certainly, LC9s is absolutely NOT enough for professional service person's duty job, NOT enough for service person combat operation.
That little bit of extra grip length on the LC9s gets you an extra round (great trade off)
+James Wallace Very true
Great review bro. I have sent this video on to my friend who doesnt have time to review 20 guns.
I just got the glock 43 today. I was torn between the glock 43 and the Shield. What made me get the glock over the shield was the trigger. The Shields trigger just felt spongy to me and had a longer reset. I like it other wise it felt good in the hand and everything. I also like the pinky extension on the g43, because it is an angled extension it seems to have little effect in its printing at least with how i carry inside the pant waste band. I dont think you could go wrong with either one really. I honestly didn't even look at ruger, are they actually a decent gun now. I remember my father having a ruger and it just seemed cheaply made, poor milling, loose all over like nothing was in spec. It worked none the less but it seemed very under polished.
I like the ruger lc9s. that's the one I carry. m&p shield to much muzzle flip I sold my. the glock does not feel as good as the ruger to me.
I agree I own lc9s pro and have shot my buddies shield I don't like the shield trigger or how it sgoots
The Ruger which I own has a great trigger and in my hands shoots better then the others. The price is fantastic and easy to carry. You can get 10 round capacity mags. The biggest negative is the take down procedure. I prefer the LC9s with safety. I also have a Glock 19. But I'd like to get a Sig P320.
Great review. One thing that wasn't mentioned, isn't the Ruger just a traditional blued pistol versus the other two having durable coatings?
Good review - the Glock really needs an extension magazine. A 2 shot extension changes the pistol greatly!
Got to shoot the glock 43 and lc9s pro yesterday. The glock felt easier to shoot, as it had less recoil to it. The lc9s is pretty snappy and feels like it wants to jump out of my hand, but still controlable. Glock's magazines are easier to load and has two, so that made things easier. I'm new to guns so the sight was not an issue. What really annoyed me about the glock was having such small magazine. Even though the lc9s has just one extra round, it makes it feel bigger. As far as accuracy, I had a tighter group with the lc9s, which really surprised me given how much I liked shooting the glock. I only got to put a couple docen rounds on each, so take it for what it is. I was so torn between the two when I was going to make my purchase, ended up with the lc9s because how nice the trigger was and bigger magazine. Now that I got to shoot them I found the trigger to be a tad longer than I like and the glock trigger to be more to my liking.
An interesting review of these fine CC weapons,I have the Shield & I'm real happy with it,I think when you do the shooting test you'll find the Shield has the lowest felt recoil because of the weight & S&W installed powerful springs in this gun...duel recoil & strong mag springs.The APEX trigger makes it easy to get accurate hits & double taps.
I haven't held or shot the Ruger,but I'm sure it'll run as well.I don't have the G43 cause I have two 26's to serve the CC role.
Save all your brass cause someday you can reload 'em all & shoot for about 1/3rd the cost of new ammo.
...Later,bro.
Appendix carry has a major PITA factor. Too many times a guy will go, "Man, it's just too hot to put that damn holster on. I'll just carry my .32 Colt in my pocket today." So I pocket carry because I am often perspiring.
For that reason I ruled out both the Glock and the M&P because both of them print too much. They SCREAM, "HEY! There's a gun in this pocket."
But I didn't get an LC9s because the sights present too much of a risk of hanging up my pocket draw. So I got the Ruger *_EC9s_* and put a Crimson Trace Laser Red Dot on it. I couldn't be more satisfied with my decision.
NOBODY has ever noticed it in my pocket, and I can get a 2" group at 10 yards under pressure.
Total setup including a 9 round spare mag that goes in a knife case on my belt:
Thanks for making a great video review. I've watched it 3 times. Good info and unbiased. Shield has good values, G43 has good balance, Ruger has good concealment.
Awesome thanks for watching
Stock trigger pull on my 43 was 8.5 lbs. Way heavier than any of the other Glocks I've owned. After installing a Ghost Edge connector and doing a little polishing, I got it down to 6.1 lbs which I believe is pretty good for a carry pistol. It may drop a little more after putting more rounds through it, but I'm pretty happy with it as is. Thanks for the video. Enjoyed it.
V4MuscleBike Yeah that's great for a carry gun for sure. It doesn't feel as heavy when i pit rounds through it but definitely needs to be lightened up a little. Thanks
I bought my wife an LC9, she didn't want to even consider it. She got her TX CHL with her older gen 3 Glock 19 and won't consider anything else. It's her choice, and not a bad one. She is familiar with it, used to it, happy with it, shoots well with it. So LC9 went in safe, where it still resides today. I'll stick with my Glocks myself for the same reasons.
I've used all 3, and chose the shield. It feels the best in my hands...After purchasing the shield I installed the apex aluminum trigger and duty carry kit, along with the ameriglo I dot night sights. Now this shield is on a totally different level. Awesome and I wouldn't change a thing
Please address issue with GLOCK 43 Magazine not being able to insert at slight angel. It hits the mag release because it is single stack and the mag release is not well designed for single stack. The magazine if inserted at a slight angle to the right it hangs. It causes it to stop and could be an issue. Please address as very few people have addressed it. My first gun was a Glock 17 great so I like Glock but being fan boys is not what people are looking for and more a critical review on any product is what is needed. Hope you can address the real issue. It is real to all Glock 43 including the one I have and you have. A few people are addressing the issue just thought you might look into it too.
I have a glock 43 and i just tried to push the mag in at all sorts of diffrent angles and could not get it to get stuck or caught. In fact its a very good fit and doe snot allow for very much play. Maybe because mine is newer it was already addressed?
Nothing wrong with the Ruger's sights, have them on my LC380 and they work great and all that is needed to adjust windage on the rear is an allen wrench (no real reason to adjust the height on the front sight of a carry gun meant for short range).
The Ruger needs to ship with 2 mags and figure out a way to take down without the use of a plastic retainer on the frame. Add $30+ for extra mag
The Glock needs to add a round to the magazine and use metal on the sights. Add $50+ for metal sights.
The S&W needs to slim down and look less busy.
Totally agree with all I've handled. Can't speak for the Walther, but the others. I went with the LC9s because it is uber easy to conceal. That and the Glck was over priced when I was looking. The awful Mass compliant S&W trigger pushed me away from the Shield. 10.5 lbs. The LC9s is snappy for a 9, just a bit small on the grip. It feels like a .40 to me.
Where I live it's hot almost all the time so I wear light shorts. The best CC holster I've found for that is a Sneaky Pete external Concealed carry holster.
You can reverse the mag release on the shield.
two of my local shops recently bought back 6 Glock 43's over the last few weeks.For one reason or another.To be fair, they do sell more than they get back.
I had 5bGunworx stipple my Glock 43 now it’s an awesome gun to hold...Really love how it feels with the Hyve plus one mag extension.
Great video man thanks for the comparison
Only one is American made and not Sellout&Wesson. Ruger wins this hands down. Perfect concealed carry gun.
D K sellout ????
I love Ruger, I'm so glad they fixed their trigger and action. I've wanted one when they first came out, that is up until I got to look at the old trigger mechanism. It use to look like the trigger mechanism you find in toy cap guns. Definitely a great improvement. Nice review man, could have added the Kahr, but I don't really like Kahr that much anyway.
Great vid. I started it thinking that I'd give a minute or two and move on. Not, so. You have a nice presentation style, which kept me interested to the end. Kudos.
+RDB Jr (Bob) Sweet man thank you. We do new vids every week
For me the Shield 9 wins hands down. I have the 7 & 8 round mags. Don't bite on the false reset. Practice and work through it. Muscle memory will win the day. LC9s does have a fantastic trigger. I am a Ruger fan as well.
I don't mind long videos, you do a great job and breaking the firearms down.Justin Opinion also does a nice job.Yet another reason i picked up the P320sc.Thanks again! Btw, back on topic...The Shield for the record
CWB1863 Thanks bro
It's not so easy to find a LC9S Pro new anymore. It's the same as the LC9S, only has no manual safety or magazine disconnect. I found one online and bought it. Cost me $330. I feel I over paid for it, but I wanted it. I could have found one used for $250, but I don't like buying used guns. You never know how many thousands of rounds went through one. So I get my pistol and guess what ? It's defective. The magazine release gets stuck and you have to play with it to release the magazine. I had not even fired it. Makes me think that it got passed over by many due to this, and because I didn't get to see it until after I bought it, it was my problem. Probably why it was still available. Ruger was pretty nice about it, sending me a Fedex person to pick it up and send it back. It took about 2 weeks. The repair note stated that they replaced the release spring. My question to them was how could they have sent this out from the factory like this ? What kind of quality control do they have ? And they noted that they shot the pistol 21 times to test it. And guess what ? They never cleaned it after they fired it. That was not right. After not having the pistol for 2 weeks and having to be home all day for 2 days to sign for the pistol, now I had to start cleaning it. But I do love the pistol.
I have the Ruger with pinky extension. My Glock is clumsy by comparison for a small CC weapon
Where i live the shield cost $349, ruger $319, and glock $469. The only thing i like about the glock is the reversable mag release. Being a lefty, i really like that, but im not gonna pay $100+ for that feature. All companies are well reputable, and you really cant go wrong with none. But the best bang for you buck is hands down the shield. Woulda chose the ruger, but i comes with only one mag.
I love my lc9s, but my wife doesn't like the small grip. On the other hand she loves her shield 9mm perfect carry gun for her. On the upside if your an American, you can own them all. I love both the shield and lc9s we have.
There is an issue with the First GLock 43 MAG CATCH Mag could get stopped if pushed at a slight right angle. "MAG Stopped by mag catch sticking too far in"
I contacted GLOCK USA a couple of days ago and they knew about the problem with the MAG CATCH and are sending me a new catch so it is a problem. They should have made a recall at least they did mention that the new guns will have the NEW MAG CATCH. It is a clear issue why not so many people mention it is strange to me. Keep the nice videos coming.
arsenalnoesis Thanks for the info that and thanks for watching
Very good info! Presented lots of info and good comparisons with no bias. Was hoping for your "keeper" disclosure... but will have to watch the next video after the range session! I'm leaning toward the Ruger now. Thx!
Got the Ruger LC9sPro and love it!
S&W made a good move by making the new Shield Plus. I would get the Shield Plus these days. Its the same size as the old Shield but it is now consider a high capacity gun. The Glock 43 is still one of my favorites though and will always keep one.
Great job. I have tired all three and for the most part have come to the same conclusions that you have. I also tried the Walther PPS and ended up buying it over all three of these. It has an excellent trigger, larger steel sites and comes with a seven and eight round magazine. My second choice would have been the Ruger.
Google User Thanks man. Yeah the PPS is nice as well
These are all great carry guns. The Shield gets the edge with me because it can be easily modified with the new Apex flat faced trigger giving it a trigger pull and reset that can never be matched by the others. Faster and more accurate follow up shots than the other two.
The Ruger doesn't need a modified trigger so.....
Great review. I now own a Glock 26 and a Kahr CM9. The Glock 26 is a great shooter but a little bulky for CC. The Kahr is much smaller and a great shooter also but I'm not too happy with the double action trigger. I don't know what it is but I don't like the Shield at all. I want to trade the Kahr for either the Glock 43 or the Ruger LC9s Pro. Really tough decision but maybe after watching the shooting video the choice will be clear.
+Dennis courey Thanks man. Yeah to me the LC9s has the best trigger of all 3
This video was great all around!!!- and the sound was fine. THANK YOU!!!!!!!!!!!
+John Morten Thanks bro
Great video, very informative but I didn't catch the name of the kydex holster that could be used for all 3?
+Sanford Bates Ted Cori holster...Thanks
The glocks magazine release is a little on the bigger side. not a big fan of glock sights. feels really good in the hand though. trigger is a little stiff. Ruger's new lc9s striker fire trigger is a definite improvement of the original hammer model. good review. I would choose Ruger if it was me. Shields size would make me just decide to carry a double stack at that point... say springfield xdm sub compact or sr9c.
I hate glock sights. always have, I just don't like that giant white U shape.
awesome video, I love how detailed you are with each! wish you would do a comparison between the glock 43 and xds-9
A whole bunch of good info in one video.
Thanks for checking it out
It's all personal preference..imo.. after extensive TE. I chose the SHIELD9 ext.safety. magGuts +2.Cap.10+1/9+1. Viridian green laser. It eats all ammo. High quality. Fun 2 fire, easy 2 maintain, comfortable 2 carry. UsA made. Awesome firearm.
Outstanding Video...could you do a hammer vs striker fired concealed carry. Thanks Jim
the ruger's nice and rounded... round smooth edges. being a little bit smaller i like the ruger the best. choice out, i'd choose a sig 226 .357sig, but who wants to haul that...... i don't. this little ruger i'm liking and i may buy one? we'll see? the ruger LC9s-Pro is $349 locally. that's a good price.. 8 rounds single stack thin profile. i choose the ruger. thx4vid!
Winners:
(please note: I took specifications off of the manufacturer web sites. The width, for example, is incorrectly quoted when comparing notes with the manufacturer website. This is probably due to Hegshot87 being biased towards Glock which is not uncommon. Below each gun gets a point when mentioned for overall score.)
Capacity: Tie LC9S + M&P Shield (both 7+1)
Concealability: LC9S (the ruger is shorter and not as wide. glock wins in height only.)
Side Slide Serrations: 3 way tie
Trigger: LC9S 5:21
Sights: M&P Shield
Magazine Release: M&P Shield 9:59
Take down: Tie M&P Shield + Glock 43 11:39
Comfortable to carry: LC9S 17:50 and 23:29
Weight: LC9S
Accuracy: LC9s 23:21
Balance: Glock 43 24:56
Value: M&P Shield (due to extra mag + price 27:49 )
**********************************************************
Scores:
1st place LC9s (7 points)
2nd place M&P Shield (6 points)
3rd place Glock 43 (3 points)
I don't think there's a question in the reliability of all 3 firearms. But when you're calling on a weapon, it's for a purpose. In the case of these 3 firearms that purpose if primarily for concealed carry. The LC9s wins in concealability, trigger, comfort, weight and accuracy. Then it ties for capacity. The LC9s wins hands down for the purpose you're calling on it for. But the other two guns are great firearms.
+Corey Stein Opinions bro that's all!
I agree that what you like in the end comes down to opinion. But things like measurement dimensions, capacity, cost, take down, weight and most of the things we're analyzing are just facts.
Thanks for the info. Next time please put the pistols on the table in the order you have the info written on the paper. It's just easier to look at and understand. Thanks.
I jus got the glock 43 yesterday my first glock ever my first gun ever was the ruger security 9
Great video sir. I just ordered a PC S&W Shield 9mm for $370.00. Love your videos man.
I have the shield and I love it, I haven't shot the other two but I help than pulled the triggers and the shield just felt perfect and I love the extended clip, I can get my pinky on it and its really not noticeable while carrying,
Good info. Waiting for my Shield, trying to get a 43 is like trying to catch a unicorn.
Joseph Kondrat Thanks...Yeah they are tough to get right now for sure
Nice video. For me, I think the Shield is the best value as well. I can get one at my LGS for $369, and the fact that you get two mags with it makes it a much better value than the LC9s. I have to admit that I did like the LC9s when I handled it, but I'd probably never carry one, especially given the fact that I already have the Shield, G43 and G42. I got my G43 for $425 (LEO/Military discount). I do carry the G19 EDC, and I back it up with the Shield. Mine has the safety b/c I bought it before they came out with the non-safety version.
I think any of the guns will do well for EDC, but I'd pick the Shield and G43 over the Ruger every time. In fact, I did. LOL I just don't see the Ruger being as good a value. I believe it is a nice option for someone who does not want to buy a Glock, but when one can get a Shield for essentially the same as the Ruger, it seems to be a no brainer for me, unless the 3oz makes that much of a difference. I have to agree with everything you stated in the review, with the exception that the LC9s has the best trigger. It is nice, but I don't think it is better.
I carry mine in the INCOG Eclipes or BladeTech Klipt Ambi-hostler. Great IWB options providing very low profile carry with one hand on/off operation. I do carry the G19 for my EDC/GP pistol, and I back it up with the Shield. My wife carries the G43 and G42. The Shield is actually her gun, but she prefers to carry the Glocks due to weight. I does make a difference to some. For me, the Shield is a great option for concealment in the INCOG system. Again, nice video!
I've handled all 3 of these guns. I personally like the Glock and +1 mag extension barely sticks any further than the stock plate. Really I don't get why they didn't just design it with a 7 round mag. Ruger is nice but in my experience with other Rugers they won't hold up in the long haul like the Glock or M&P. Just personal preference, I like Glock, But I think all these guns are quality. I have seen the G43 on sale at Academy for $479 so price has gone down.
Hands down best review of these guns. Well done and I just subbed.
+Common Sense Camper Thanks man!
Great video. I know what you mean by the terrible slide serrations on the G42. Only thing I don't like about it. I have an LC380 and really like it. I want to add a 9mm - either a used LC9 or an LC9s, LC9s PRO - to stay with the Ruger lineup.
gene814100 Thanks...Yeah Lc9s pro or the regualr Lc9s is a great option
Great review! Thanks for comparing all three without any bias. One question, does the LC9s really have plastic rails on the frame? The one I picked up felt like metal.
leedew59 Yeah that's my mistake. They are aluminum from what I understand. Thanks for watching!
+Hegshot87 Thanks for two great videos! I'd been eyeballing these 3 single stacks for about a month. This gave me all the info I needed. Been carrying the G26 for a few years as my edc, and like most most Glock fanboys was thinking the G43 was the best thing since sliced bread. But after shooting the Ruger... I was sold.
+TurdFergusson318 Awesome man thanks!
great review. sound attenuation is super annoying though. would be great if that could be turned off.
We have since upgraded equipment and no longer have that issue
+Hegshot87 good to hear! (no pun intended)
Hands down the shield is way better than both of them in my opinion that is. The glock trigger is mushy and the Ruger has a reset that is all the way out to the start of the pull and with that being said shield is a better trigger and you can switch the magazine release button to the left hand side
Everyone forgets or just dont know how good the Glock 43 is. The S&W is good too however its heavier. The Ruger has a safety switch which is bad ju ju for a civilian self defense gun and a big no go for me. The Glock 43 is the lightest best quality of the bunch and may I remind everyone that it has a polygonal barrel which DOES make a difference.
Great vid brah
+GTL5427 Thanks man
talk about the Diamondback db9 gen4
Great vid, yes a little long but very informative. What I would like to see and what I hate that nobody does is when you shoot them be as accurate as possible and show us the group size. Just in case anyone cares. Thank you though.
R.J. L. Yeah we typically do that on our shooting reviews and we will do it with this one as well. Thanks for checking the video out :)
Hegshot87 XS big dots on the 43 you cant go wrong that takes that gun from great to perfect. I put the extended slide lock, and the ghost trigger and it is perfect glocks dont come perfect but you can make them perfect.. And i think your wrong about the 43 made in Austria its made in there Georgia plant im not sure if all of them are but i know some of them have been at least.. great video thanks for the INFO!
Franklin Bohanan These are definitely made in Austria as of right now. From what I have found out they made the 42 in America cause they couldn't have it imported because of restrictions. They also some of there other models here but these firsr Glock 43s are made in Austria. Thanks for watching man