The Best of the Dumpster Fire: Acolyte Episode 5 Review

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 ก.ย. 2024
  • Only 3 left after this. And I fear this was the peak

ความคิดเห็น • 9

  • @littlebman545
    @littlebman545 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    Tbh the choreography of the lightsaber duels was top notch. W video

    • @TheWhyWing
      @TheWhyWing  3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Thank you. I really appreciate it

  • @MAXXWORX
    @MAXXWORX 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Review was good. Thanks.
    I couldn't care less about the damn rule of two or Tenebrus or any of them. Some dipshit somewhere in the galaxy who might discover such powers, or comes across holocron, or somehow heard about the sith being the enemies of the jedi, might never heard of that stupid rule. It is no galaxy wide fact everybody knows. Personally i am not familiar with the stories about that, so i would wonder how the jedi, i e Yoda and Windu knew about it, if the sith are so super secretive.
    Same with the stuff Mae said "Jedi pull THEIR sabers only to kill" is no rule, it is just a lie somebody fed her with. Same with the shit dipshit tells her on the beach. All lies. Same as the crap Headlund tells. That is why the line is in there, that the jedi won't imprison her, if she tells them everything. Because it probably happened to her with the trial of her former boss.
    Also Smilo could have been fed lies as well. Same as headlund is making the jedi liars...
    Man i hate what Disney became and what it is doing to all the franchises.
    I can't say how i would want to the show to end so that i am happy... i wanted to make a rewrite of the story so it fits more of what i think is starwars, after the show ended and hopefully all infos are there and not hundreds of questions are left open. But what is presented is so convoluted, basicly everything else is better. So even i can make a better story out of the bits i know of the show 😅
    (but can't watch it, don't have disney+)

    • @TheWhyWing
      @TheWhyWing  2 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @MAXXWORX Thanks for watching!

  • @caitlinbrewer4843
    @caitlinbrewer4843 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    One of the benefits of dabbling in stage combat classes in college is that i can better understand the issues with fights like in 1v6 fight. If I had to guess:
    1) those extra werent giving as much time and training.
    2) that fight wasnt given as much time rehearsal time as the other 1v1 and 2v1 fights.
    3) from a safety perspective, a 1v6 fight is a lot more dangerous to film and perform.

    • @TheWhyWing
      @TheWhyWing  3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Having to watch this I would assume it's more of a curse than a benefit. Lol

    • @caitlinbrewer4843
      @caitlinbrewer4843 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@TheWhyWing it can be tbh, though it does let me think of the ways I would have done it to improve things.
      For example, while 6v1 fights are cool in theory, they are impractical in live action for a lot of reasons. So I would take it off and replace it with a sort of Predator homage of the Jedi being scattered in the jungle and Qimir hunting and killing them all in a serious of 1v1s or 1v2s.
      Alternatively, change the setting of the fight from a... Cave? Under a tree? To somewhere Qimir could convincingly use the environment to his advantage in the fight.
      Or, if we have to have to keep the 1v6, break it up into smaller stages by having Qimir disable some fighters so he can focus on other. Stuff like Kord's leg wound putting him down. Maybe use the Force to tangle some of them in vines or push them away or something.

    • @MAXXWORX
      @MAXXWORX 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Since they have no real swords, but glowing baseball bats, it is not that dangerous, but in the normal starwars universe i would say you have to be more careful were you put your lightsaber instead of a metal sword. The lightsaber is more likely to do damage than a metal sword.
      But this fight should have been not a fight at all. Since they show they can use the force on each other in combat, all of them should have just used the force to hold him in place and capture him.
      Sure, wouldn't be much of scene, but the same should have happened with Trinity and Mae, she just could have broken her arms and/or legs with the force and be down with her, or make her fall over, throw something in her face and knock her out. But no. This introduction of old Kung Fu movies moves in Starwars annoyes me. Especially Vader and Reeva... horrible.