🔴 General Amazon link*: geni.us/thequantifiedscientist 🔴 Galaxy Watch 5 link*: geni.us/SamsungWatch5 🟢 Instagram: instagram.com/quantified_scientist/ 🟠 Shorts: studio.th-cam.com/channels/cpARGzXNaC62UQWns2dh2Q.html 🔵 Newsletter: www.robterhorst.com 🟡 Twitter: @QuantifiedRob * Affiliate (paid) links support the channel by earning me a commission on any sale, and it doesn't cost you any more! My opinions are completely my own, and this content is not sponsored. ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬ 👇 $30 off any new WHOOP membership, affiliate* (paid) link, supports the channel!👇 join.whoop.com/QuantifiedScientist ($30 off any new WHOOP membership)
I don't know how to give this man appropriate credit for his reviews. Outlets like cnet and tomsguide/Android authority and the multitude of TH-camrs just seem to copy each other's reviews, yet no one tells me how well the sensors work and certainly not in such a controlled and repeatable/well documented manner. Good job man. I hope you get the visibility your content deserves.
Wow, that seemed almost like a quality investigative journalism. It's actually an outrageous, big news that Samsung try to sell us mostly the same or even (!) a bit downgraded watch and call it "new". Thank you for your research!
A guy in the internet doing 1 test verifies that the new model is less accurate XD interesting, you probably get fooled around pretty easily i suppose. No new tech model downgrades electronic parts ever XD, new tech is always slightly better (very marginal changes but changes nonetheless).
Your videos are fantastic but as others say I can't believe that you're the first person on youtube to actually try and test the specs and not just trust that the measurements are 100% correct from these smart devices. You're doing great work!
I think there is a need for more software development. As seen the Watch 4 has improved over the time magnificent, it would be good to test the 5 again in 1 year or 1,5 years to see if the software gets better.
I am soooo glad I find this video.. I just got the watch 4 a few days ago. I was considering returning the 4 & getting a 5. I'll save my money. THANK YOU‼️
I've had the GW4 for about a year and I mostly agree with everything you found. The outlier for me was the GPS accuracy, i noticed that polling rate seems to differ between apps. On strava for example I can actually see instances where I swerved to avoid a pothole and I'd say the accuracy is within 1-2 meters. Also distance tracking while running has a +/-10% difference, Strava looking to be spot on while Samsung health for some reason is losing some info.
Thank you so much for your review! You're the only TH-camr out there who actually talks facts rather than personal opinions when it comes to wearables and that is much appreciated! I was waiting for the Watch 5 for months and I'm more than disappointed but I'm grateful for your review as you've saved me quite some money! I'll be now waiting for the Pixel watch... hopefully coming in October 2022. Once again, thank you very much for your hard work!
Bro this is probably the most amazing channel ever because of how detailed you test these watches. I dont think another channel could beat this! Thank you so much for your work!
I'm thinking software updates will fix it. samsung is known for having issues at launch. the GW4 is much older, and has a bunch of its kinks worked out already. So, im hoping the GW5 will get that same love.
Bought a GW4 Classic less than a month ago (during a special sale), so shortly before the GW5 announcement. Kicked myself initially, but your videos have been great to make me feel I made the right choice after all.
Thank you once again Rob for these amazing reviews! I am not surprised at all with the results. The watch fit of my dad performed better than my previous gw4, but is way more affordable. Samsung makes one of the best smartphones out there but the opposite is true with their smart watches. More on features (including experimental ones) and aesthetics, but with less accuracy.
@@TheQuantifiedScientist you're welcome. Your reviews are of great help especially to those who don't know much about the technical side of these gadgets.
You're the best tester out there, thank you. I got the Watch 4 Classic pre-release last year. Samsung has the marketing clout and Wear OS to convince users. They used to have the turning bezel, which was my convincer. Currently in my market I can get 3.95 Watch 4s for the price of one Watch 5 Pro. Samsung is, apart from HRM more sensor galore than accuracy, is my take. I particularly would like it to track my deep sleep much better.
I’ve been binge watching some of your videos, they are fantastic. One way I was thinking you could compare the accuracy between two or more plots in the time vs hr of any activity (cycling, running or weightlifting) is by doing some numeric analysis. Subtracting area between of each wearable and the polar and comparing the residual areas can be a way of determining how accurate are they to the reference plot.
With the GPS test did you use the "more accuracy" option on the watches, and also when doing the step test did you update within the app which hand the watch was worn on?
@@ThatWanderingNomad The sensor on the back has been changed slightly for more skin contact on the GW5, maybe the software isn't optimized for the new sensor design yet since they both sit slightly differently on the skin. Will be interesting to see where the GW5 sits after some updates (the GW4 also took some time to get more accurate)
Great video as always! I really hope samsung will not be trying to make the GW4 worse by releasing downgrading updates to push sales of the new watch. Not so unlikely when you think about
Bedankt Rob. Fantastische videos! So far for the promised "improved" sensor unit on watch 5. Can't believe it's also still not possible to automatically track cycling on watch 5.
I'd like to offer a counter point that software improvements for the 4 after launch are an indication that the watch 5 is a long term sure bet. It will get an extra year of improvements, if not more due to the platform change. Now you can only review what's already there, but as a consumer it'd be a worthwhile consideration. Though for me I really don't see the value of these and other two day battery life watches. Seems like a lot of annoyances for little benefit over a Garmin or Huawei. In any case thanks for the video.
There's a saying "buy tech for what it IS, not what it could be, and especially no for what the company said it will be", I can't count how many times companies promised updates, new features, etc..and never delivered, or delivered less than promised, or 3 years late, or paywalled the update The most glaring example is Tesla Full Self driving kit, you choose to pay 10k more, for something that's "right around the corner" since 2016, yet people still choose to pay now 15k more, with absolutely no certainty that their car won't die of old age before it can "drive itself, become an appreciating asset"
Hi Rob, Looking at the differences with the step count, I can't help to ask myself, did you change the watches and also change the setup in the app e.g. from/to dominant hand ? this could account for the difference, it's very odd that both watches are so accurate for the first half of the test and are off for the second..
Hi. First off your tests are awesome. Always watch your reviews before getting a smartwatch. So I was checking out the Huawei watch D and the options look awesome in that watch. The most attractive thing about that watch is the micro pump and air pouch that actualy uses proper method to measure stats. But you haven't checked out the accuracy of that watch, is there some reason why you haven't checked that watch or have you just not gotten around to it?
From my experience owning 7 different smart watches HR watches you get much better results wearing the watches on the inside underneath the arm instead of like a regular watch. You should do a video testing that out..
The thing that gets me, is that the GW4 still has major bugs. My watch has the issue where it will periodically remove itself from my Wear App, requiring a full reset to reconnect. I hope that the GW5 doesn't mean they abandon updates for the GW4
Exactly! Samsung made a change to their bio sensor design and clearly needs time to fine tune it. This is no surprise. Watch 5 become more accurate and better with updates.
@@Overlord6196 I mean look even the watch 4 was terrible at battery after launch but it has improved a lot after the updates Also chigz tech review told he got 3 days of battery life out of the watch pro and that both the watch 4 and 5 adapt to your battery usage in the first 2 days and then gives you the claimed amount of battery life
I compared both my watch 4 vs watch 5 pro and got diff.results f.e my SPO2 reading is higher and more correct on the 5. Also last year I have compared watch 4 with Apple watch as well Garmin watch and believe in most parameter the Samsung watch is better than the Apple.
@@Overlord6196 pls share me your result once done just curious, bec. my testing results differ from this channel(where Apple watches are way above Samsung even Garmin) ...what about yours will be interesting to hear🙏🏻😊
At 9:59 there is another data point for the "GalaxyWatch4" showing better accuracy with a correlation around 0.8. Can you please clarify the difference in testing parameter between the "GalaxyWatch4" data point and the "Galaxy Watch4 2022" data point?
Thanks so much for your super, super detailed videos. I got a watch 4 44mm bt for $190, and this was nice to see lmao - normal people are sad that it's not much of an upgrade, I'm secretary happy XD
Sir i have a query! Huawei watch gt3 has a better heartrate senson trueseen5+ While huawei watch fit 2 has trueseen 4 But the results of the huawei watch fit are more accurate. Why is that? And if its the software then if the huawei gt3 is updated will it be a better option to buy?
Dear Rob .. First . We greatly appreciate the great work you do. I have an great concern about calories calculation accuracy,on smart watch. Can you please do a test for that?! Thanks again
Man lucky to found out your channel. Best for smart watches and bands. 💯 I'm searching a good smart watch /band for my dad. Need a good heart rate accuracy and blood pressure monitor (if possible). Currently there's offer on galaxy watch 4.
Your vids are so useful and i cant believe that go through all of this just for us! Would you say that the conclusion would be the same between the galaxy watch 4 pro vs the watch 5 pro?
Since watching your research, i went to go with the Huawei watch. i've never had a smart watch and have an Android. Unfortunately, Apple watches are out of my realm because of that. I later realized in the United States, you can't get a Huawei now due to the ban. So im left with Galaxy Watches next i guess (sigh). this video did help me decide to go with the Galaxy 4 i think i'm going to jump on that and maybe later in the future these can get better or the ban on Huawei will go away for us here in the states.
As much as I love Samsung phones, I will be upgrading from Garmin Venu to one of the Huawei GT3 watches, not to the GW4 or 5. Thank you for an objective review.
When My fitbit versa 2 died at best buy the 46 mm galaxy watch 4 classic was on sale for 279 dollars so I bought it two weeks later the galaxy watch 5 came out . I'm not disappointed with my purchase.
Really need a performance testing video for fire boltt brand smartwatches, which got good customer reviews for its accuracy in amazon than some of same or more priced hauwei and mi brand watches/bands, so want to know where it is going to get place in your performance chart for heart rate monitoring especially
Probably the Watch 5 sensors and battery life, will become more accurate in the coming months from updates, also better integration with WearOS, but, for now, at least, surely you're better off using GW 4 if you already own one and not splash the money on basically the same product, mostly.
Your reviews are fantastic. This seems about right. My watch 4 had terrible battery life when it was a new release. We are two updates and one week(adaptive battery ai) from good battery life... boo!!! because I traded my 4 in for a pro 5.
Will you do a review of the Fitbit inspire 3? It seems to be the start of Google's ecosystem influence on Fitbit's bands. And I'm curious to see if they kept the good sleep tracking performance.
One of the best among the three in terms of heart rate accuracy, especially and in general The choice is difficult, is it the Samsung Watch 4 Classic, the Galaxy Watch 5 or the Huawei Watch gt 3
Thank you for such a great review! I have now cancelled my Galaxy watch order and gone with another company. The last thing I need on my wrist is a huge inaccurate mini-phone :)
@The Quantified Scientist: what is the name (or possibly even link) of the brown strap you had on the watch. Looks super cool! BTW: I admire your work!
the battery life test is a surprise ! bigger battery on GW5 but the tests show that it is almost same drain vs GW4 ? i thought GW5 could last 3-4 days vs GW4 of 1-2 days.
Thanks a lot for your great work, as always. Is it possible that you could test the Xiaomi Watch S1 in near future. Im curious if its perform as good as the Mi Watch. Thanks a lot again.
¿El sensor que mide la composición de masa muscular en el watch 4 y 5 podrías comprobar con algún equipo profesional? Muchas gracias...excelente video!!!
Yo no confío en relojes de Samsung o de Apple para cosas tan avanzadas. Un Garmin de los muy caros deben de ser excelente para eso. Lo que si querío es por lo menos un rastreo de dormir más preciso
Hey Man, Thanks for the fantastic job, I was thinking of buying a Garmin 255, but after your scentific research, I gave up on buying Garmin 255. Can Watch 5 be improved with the updates? Is the problem software or hardware?
How about the watch 5 pro? I think it would perform better in gps since Samsung claims that watch 5 pro is made for outdoor sporting eg hiking. Hope you will also test it, I would like to know are there any differences between watch 4 , watch 5 and watch 5 pro. Thanks for your efforts again, it helps a lot when I considering buy the new galaxy watch or not.
What do you mean by the 2022 in parentheses near the Galaxy watch 4? Do you mean that some special newer models were released o rit's just the 2022 software updates?
🔴 General Amazon link*: geni.us/thequantifiedscientist
🔴 Galaxy Watch 5 link*: geni.us/SamsungWatch5
🟢 Instagram: instagram.com/quantified_scientist/
🟠 Shorts: studio.th-cam.com/channels/cpARGzXNaC62UQWns2dh2Q.html
🔵 Newsletter: www.robterhorst.com
🟡 Twitter: @QuantifiedRob
* Affiliate (paid) links support the channel by earning me a commission on any sale, and it doesn't cost you any more! My opinions are completely my own, and this content is not sponsored.
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
👇 $30 off any new WHOOP membership, affiliate* (paid) link, supports the channel!👇
join.whoop.com/QuantifiedScientist ($30 off any new WHOOP membership)
Can you check Wahoo strap accuracy? Or Wahoo Tickr Fit arm band?
I don't know how to give this man appropriate credit for his reviews. Outlets like cnet and tomsguide/Android authority and the multitude of TH-camrs just seem to copy each other's reviews, yet no one tells me how well the sensors work and certainly not in such a controlled and repeatable/well documented manner. Good job man. I hope you get the visibility your content deserves.
Wow, that seemed almost like a quality investigative journalism. It's actually an outrageous, big news that Samsung try to sell us mostly the same or even (!) a bit downgraded watch and call it "new". Thank you for your research!
the same with mobiles, samsung a52(2021) is better, and of course cheaper than a52(2022)
@@howtogetawaywith8896 tf you on? A52 is not better than A53. A52s is
To stay in your tone: Tf you on? He didn‘t even mention the A53.
Doesn't apple do that every year? Nothing much changes with the apples watch and the iphones, 😂??
A guy in the internet doing 1 test verifies that the new model is less accurate XD interesting, you probably get fooled around pretty easily i suppose. No new tech model downgrades electronic parts ever XD, new tech is always slightly better (very marginal changes but changes nonetheless).
Your videos are fantastic but as others say I can't believe that you're the first person on youtube to actually try and test the specs and not just trust that the measurements are 100% correct from these smart devices.
You're doing great work!
Thanks for watching!
This channel should be the gold standard going forward with these smart devices-reviews. Keep up the good fight Mr Quantified ;) 👊🏼
The amount of hardwork you put in your videos is just next level.
Keep up the good work. Love from India 🇮🇳
I think there is a need for more software development.
As seen the Watch 4 has improved over the time magnificent, it would be good to test the 5 again in 1 year or 1,5 years to see if the software gets better.
so its better to buy the watch 5 in a year as a finish product at half the price. thats what i did with gw4
I am soooo glad I find this video.. I just got the watch 4 a few days ago. I was considering returning the 4 & getting a 5. I'll save my money. THANK YOU‼️
I've had the GW4 for about a year and I mostly agree with everything you found.
The outlier for me was the GPS accuracy, i noticed that polling rate seems to differ between apps.
On strava for example I can actually see instances where I swerved to avoid a pothole and I'd say the accuracy is within 1-2 meters.
Also distance tracking while running has a +/-10% difference, Strava looking to be spot on while Samsung health for some reason is losing some info.
Thank you so much for your review! You're the only TH-camr out there who actually talks facts rather than personal opinions when it comes to wearables and that is much appreciated! I was waiting for the Watch 5 for months and I'm more than disappointed but I'm grateful for your review as you've saved me quite some money!
I'll be now waiting for the Pixel watch... hopefully coming in October 2022.
Once again, thank you very much for your hard work!
Bro this is probably the most amazing channel ever because of how detailed you test these watches. I dont think another channel could beat this! Thank you so much for your work!
I'm thinking software updates will fix it. samsung is known for having issues at launch. the GW4 is much older, and has a bunch of its kinks worked out already. So, im hoping the GW5 will get that same love.
Bought a GW4 Classic less than a month ago (during a special sale), so shortly before the GW5 announcement. Kicked myself initially, but your videos have been great to make me feel I made the right choice after all.
😄🍻
This what a real comparison looks like. Hat's off
You're awesome! Thank you for the comparison
Glad it was helpful Adam!
Thank you once again Rob for these amazing reviews! I am not surprised at all with the results. The watch fit of my dad performed better than my previous gw4, but is way more affordable. Samsung makes one of the best smartphones out there but the opposite is true with their smart watches. More on features (including experimental ones) and aesthetics, but with less accuracy.
Thanks Ken!
@@TheQuantifiedScientist you're welcome. Your reviews are of great help especially to those who don't know much about the technical side of these gadgets.
hey, do you mean the Huawei Watch Fit?
@@TheMr82k yes. Huawei watch fit
@@DAIliganCycling But depending on what you are looking for, the Huawei watches appear to be very off in sleep tracking.
You're the best tester out there, thank you. I got the Watch 4 Classic pre-release last year. Samsung has the marketing clout and Wear OS to convince users. They used to have the turning bezel, which was my convincer. Currently in my market I can get 3.95 Watch 4s for the price of one Watch 5 Pro. Samsung is, apart from HRM more sensor galore than accuracy, is my take. I particularly would like it to track my deep sleep much better.
@Rob, do you consider retesting Fitbit devices (e.g. the first Sense), including the new ones (Sense 2)? You're doing a great job. Best!
I’ve been binge watching some of your videos, they are fantastic. One way I was thinking you could compare the accuracy between two or more plots in the time vs hr of any activity (cycling, running or weightlifting) is by doing some numeric analysis. Subtracting area between of each wearable and the polar and comparing the residual areas can be a way of determining how accurate are they to the reference plot.
With the GPS test did you use the "more accuracy" option on the watches, and also when doing the step test did you update within the app which hand the watch was worn on?
I believe the 5 will get better with updates. I remember the 4 was terribly inaccurate when it was released.
So are you telling me Samsung uses its customers as beta testers but expects them to pay for the whole thing?
But everything is the same so what's the reason for the inaccuracies?
@@ThatWanderingNomad The sensor on the back has been changed slightly for more skin contact on the GW5, maybe the software isn't optimized for the new sensor design yet since they both sit slightly differently on the skin.
Will be interesting to see where the GW5 sits after some updates (the GW4 also took some time to get more accurate)
@@sirlagzalot3146 ohh I didn't know that! Makes sense...
@@sirlagzalot3146 so its better to buy the watch 5 in a year as a finish product at half the price. thats what i did with gw4
Can you please test these watches for skin tone and arm hair (considering the light might have troubles in hairy men and especially dark skin tones)
shave hair in the spot where the watch tuch the skin 😉
@@markQ08 😂😂
Lmao that gon look so ugky
Yeah only when you take the watch off
Great video as always!
I really hope samsung will not be trying to make the GW4 worse by releasing downgrading updates to push sales of the new watch. Not so unlikely when you think about
Scumbag tactics. Garmin is worth every penny though, imo.
@Jason Garmin at there price was horrible for me. Venu 2. Battery life great though.
@@ahefner33 my mother tried to get a Vemu 2, the NFC payment would only work with Santander in the UK so it was useless to her
I hope Samsung is watching.
why does he keep skipping BIA and ECG?? I'm only upgrading my watch for BIA, and it's completely ignored in his videos.. I don't get it
Yeah interesting
Bedankt Rob. Fantastische videos! So far for the promised "improved" sensor unit on watch 5. Can't believe it's also still not possible to automatically track cycling on watch 5.
Dankjewel! Hopefully things will improve!
New Fitbit devices are here people, and Rob is the only reviewer I trust.
I'd like to offer a counter point that software improvements for the 4 after launch are an indication that the watch 5 is a long term sure bet. It will get an extra year of improvements, if not more due to the platform change. Now you can only review what's already there, but as a consumer it'd be a worthwhile consideration.
Though for me I really don't see the value of these and other two day battery life watches. Seems like a lot of annoyances for little benefit over a Garmin or Huawei.
In any case thanks for the video.
There's a saying "buy tech for what it IS, not what it could be, and especially no for what the company said it will be", I can't count how many times companies promised updates, new features, etc..and never delivered, or delivered less than promised, or 3 years late, or paywalled the update
The most glaring example is Tesla Full Self driving kit, you choose to pay 10k more, for something that's "right around the corner" since 2016, yet people still choose to pay now 15k more, with absolutely no certainty that their car won't die of old age before it can "drive itself, become an appreciating asset"
Amazing review, thanks for the hard work 👍
Thanks for the coverage and comparison, keep making video about these two watches!👏🏼😃
I really enjoy your videos. It is twice usefull because I want a SmartWatch and I am learning English. Thanks :)
Hi Rob, Looking at the differences with the step count, I can't help to ask myself, did you change the watches and also change the setup in the app e.g. from/to dominant hand ?
this could account for the difference, it's very odd that both watches are so accurate for the first half of the test and are off for the second..
Absolutely best scientific reviews of the smartwatches.
Hi. First off your tests are awesome. Always watch your reviews before getting a smartwatch.
So I was checking out the Huawei watch D and the options look awesome in that watch. The most attractive thing about that watch is the micro pump and air pouch that actualy uses proper method to measure stats.
But you haven't checked out the accuracy of that watch, is there some reason why you haven't checked that watch or have you just not gotten around to it?
you are a legend with those tests ... incredible man ... hats off
Amazing review, thanks for the analysis. Glad there are some reviewers like you out there
From my experience owning 7 different smart watches HR watches you get much better results wearing the watches on the inside underneath the arm instead of like a regular watch. You should do a video testing that out..
The thing that gets me, is that the GW4 still has major bugs. My watch has the issue where it will periodically remove itself from my Wear App, requiring a full reset to reconnect.
I hope that the GW5 doesn't mean they abandon updates for the GW4
wear app?
I personally believe when the watch 5 receives the same amount of updates like the watch 4 then it would might be more accurate
Great video btw
Exactly! Samsung made a change to their bio sensor design and clearly needs time to fine tune it. This is no surprise. Watch 5 become more accurate and better with updates.
@@Overlord6196
I mean look even the watch 4 was terrible at battery after launch but it has improved a lot after the updates
Also chigz tech review told he got 3 days of battery life out of the watch pro and that both the watch 4 and 5 adapt to your battery usage in the first 2 days and then gives you the claimed amount of battery life
I compared both my watch 4 vs watch 5 pro and got diff.results f.e my SPO2 reading is higher and more correct on the 5. Also last year I have compared watch 4 with Apple watch as well Garmin watch and believe in most parameter the Samsung watch is better than the Apple.
@@vrenews good to know. my gf has apple watch series 7 and im picking up my GW5 40mm tomorrow so ill be comparing those
@@Overlord6196 pls share me your result once done just curious, bec. my testing results differ from this channel(where Apple watches are way above Samsung even Garmin) ...what about yours will be interesting to hear🙏🏻😊
I bought galaxy watch 4 40mm a week ago and i like it, so far so good , thr price 150€
Thanks for the comparison!
Thanks for the great work and scientific approach....much appreciated
Please review the Huawei Watch D
Can you please review xiaomi band 7 pro?
Incredible content! So much work put into your videos! Not buying any wearables before seeing your reviews.
Did you re-test the watch 4 or used old data from the review last year? It could be that software updates made some changes
Underrated content
U are awesome
At 9:59 there is another data point for the "GalaxyWatch4" showing better accuracy with a correlation around 0.8. Can you please clarify the difference in testing parameter between the "GalaxyWatch4" data point and the "Galaxy Watch4 2022" data point?
Hey Rob! I really hope you do a detailed analysis of Garmin venu sq 2.
Good vid. But I also feel that the watch 5 will perform better later down the road when they send out new updates.
I imagine those updates would also go into the Watch4 given the similar hardware?
@@philth7587 yeah I have both 4 and 5 now, but samsung promises years of update for both watches
@@sparklywiggleskan6707 How many years do Samsung watches gets updates on an average ?
Damn i almost clicked buy now on watch 5.
Thanks a lot
Please do a complete review for the Huawei GT3 please 🙏🏼!!
Thanks so much for your super, super detailed videos.
I got a watch 4 44mm bt for $190, and this was nice to see lmao - normal people are sad that it's not much of an upgrade, I'm secretary happy XD
Thank you so much for theses high quality videos! Could you also do one on the watch 5 pro vs the watch 4 classic?
Sir i have a query!
Huawei watch gt3 has a better heartrate senson trueseen5+
While huawei watch fit 2 has trueseen 4
But the results of the huawei watch fit are more accurate. Why is that?
And if its the software then if the huawei gt3 is updated will it be a better option to buy?
can you use a heart rate chest monitor/strap use for tha watch?? i wanna buy a new sportwatch. but i prefer a external chest heart rate device.
Dear Rob ..
First . We greatly appreciate the great work you do.
I have an great concern about calories calculation accuracy,on smart watch.
Can you please do a test for that?!
Thanks again
Man lucky to found out your channel. Best for smart watches and bands. 💯 I'm searching a good smart watch /band for my dad. Need a good heart rate accuracy and blood pressure monitor (if possible). Currently there's offer on galaxy watch 4.
Your vids are so useful and i cant believe that go through all of this just for us! Would you say that the conclusion would be the same between the galaxy watch 4 pro vs the watch 5 pro?
Hi Daniel! I still need to test the Watch5 Pro, so I cannot say anything yet :-). Have a great day!
I don't think you're going to be on the Samsung Christmas card list! Gut gemacht!
I appreciate ur work
As someone who has a galaxy watch 4, I'm happy to see the software has improved!
Since watching your research, i went to go with the Huawei watch. i've never had a smart watch and have an Android. Unfortunately, Apple watches are out of my realm because of that. I later realized in the United States, you can't get a Huawei now due to the ban. So im left with Galaxy Watches next i guess (sigh). this video did help me decide to go with the Galaxy 4 i think i'm going to jump on that and maybe later in the future these can get better or the ban on Huawei will go away for us here in the states.
i clicked on a random video and i loved every second of it. great job. you actually test those products :) thank you for the info
As much as I love Samsung phones, I will be upgrading from Garmin Venu to one of the Huawei GT3 watches, not to the GW4 or 5. Thank you for an objective review.
Incredibly through. Nice work 👍
Excelent comparison! Thanks!
When My fitbit versa 2 died at best buy the 46 mm galaxy watch 4 classic was on sale for 279 dollars so I bought it two weeks later the galaxy watch 5 came out . I'm not disappointed with my purchase.
Question:
Did you see any battery improvements on the GW5 vs the GW4. It has a larger battery which is what I'm looking for TBH
It's in the review as well. He didn't, based on his short test.
Really need a performance testing video for fire boltt brand smartwatches, which got good customer reviews for its accuracy in amazon than some of same or more priced hauwei and mi brand watches/bands, so want to know where it is going to get place in your performance chart for heart rate monitoring especially
Probably the Watch 5 sensors and battery life, will become more accurate in the coming months from updates, also better integration with WearOS, but, for now, at least, surely you're better off using GW 4 if you already own one and not splash the money on basically the same product, mostly.
Your reviews are fantastic. This seems about right. My watch 4 had terrible battery life when it was a new release.
We are two updates and one week(adaptive battery ai) from good battery life... boo!!! because I traded my 4 in for a pro 5.
Thanks for your video, as always its great
Will you do a review of the Fitbit inspire 3? It seems to be the start of Google's ecosystem influence on Fitbit's bands. And I'm curious to see if they kept the good sleep tracking performance.
One of the best among the three in terms of heart rate accuracy, especially and in general The choice is difficult, is it the Samsung Watch 4 Classic, the Galaxy Watch 5 or the Huawei Watch gt 3
Will you check out the watch 5 pro as well
Great analysis, very impressed, thanks 👍
Not related to both watches; will you test the new Fitbit watches and bracelet?
Great comparison. How about testing the two watches in the pool
Great video as always!
Thank you for such a great review! I have now cancelled my Galaxy watch order and gone with another company. The last thing I need on my wrist is a huge inaccurate mini-phone :)
@The Quantified Scientist: what is the name (or possibly even link) of the brown strap you had on the watch. Looks super cool! BTW: I admire your work!
Very good info. Thank you.
the battery life test is a surprise ! bigger battery on GW5 but the tests show that it is almost same drain vs GW4 ? i thought GW5 could last 3-4 days vs GW4 of 1-2 days.
Thanks a lot for your great work, as always. Is it possible that you could test the Xiaomi Watch S1 in near future. Im curious if its perform as good as the Mi Watch. Thanks a lot again.
Awesome, thank you!
¿El sensor que mide la composición de masa muscular en el watch 4 y 5 podrías comprobar con algún equipo profesional? Muchas gracias...excelente video!!!
Yo no confío en relojes de Samsung o de Apple para cosas tan avanzadas. Un Garmin de los muy caros deben de ser excelente para eso. Lo que si querío es por lo menos un rastreo de dormir más preciso
The best smart watches reviewer
Amazing comparison! Could you do a comparison between Galaxy watch 4 classic 46mm and Galaxy 5 Pro please?
Thank you for your awesome work
Hey Man,
Thanks for the fantastic job,
I was thinking of buying a Garmin 255, but after your scentific research, I gave up on buying Garmin 255.
Can Watch 5 be improved with the updates?
Is the problem software or hardware?
What strap is this? Thanks for the great review!
How about the watch 5 pro? I think it would perform better in gps since Samsung claims that watch 5 pro is made for outdoor sporting eg hiking. Hope you will also test it, I would like to know are there any differences between watch 4 , watch 5 and watch 5 pro. Thanks for your efforts again, it helps a lot when I considering buy the new galaxy watch or not.
Are you going to bring the 5pro review? I really would like to see the body composition sensors reliability
Great analysis 👍 thx u
great review!!
very disappointed GW5...
Do you plan on GW5 PRO?
Please test the Garmin forerunner 255 music....please....
Do galaxy watch 4 classic vs galaxy watch 5 pro
What do you mean by the 2022 in parentheses near the Galaxy watch 4? Do you mean that some special newer models were released o rit's just the 2022 software updates?
On your heart rate analysis you have the Galaxy Watch 4 listed Twice. One low and one at the top. Is a updated difference?
Good question