During the cold darkness of my 30s this song gave me peace. I am no 66 and can see how much fucking pain I was in . Without the crutch of boose or drugd
I'm the opposite LOL. I lost my wife April 2022 and U2, particularly Beautiful Day, got me through. Listened to it probably a thousand times that year.
Hang in there lost no my x married someone else I got to live with it he eats dinners with my children pain sure but Iam. Strong Iam weak but Iam alive live on folks with or with out pain it will all be ok , no Iam not baptised , Iam a free highlander I talk to the the one and only free spirit it’s a Scottish thing
The Edge!!! Just lays down haunting guitar parts. Totally awesome. Completely unique. Suuuuustainnnnnn forever....... infinite sustai. This is a song you want to go on forever
Hauntingly beautiful live version that is a masterpiece of lyrics/story telling and singing/music.This has it all.Absolutley love it❤.Love to get in the zone with my best mate and sing along.We have both been there with former partners,as may have you,if this song gets deep into your soul.
Reminds of my college days at DUMZVILLE. When alternative songs is all you can hear every friday night kahit aling bar sa DUMA. Di mawala sa akong list na tukaron ni nga song every time naa koy gig before. Those were the days😊nakakamiss ang DUMAGUETE
was in LA in 1987 on my way to SLO and stopped and saw them shot the video from the roof top. Ever since then..... the greatest band I've ever seen....cept the EAGLES in TAMPA stmd. july 4 1976 yeah I'm old!
What a rare and beautiful version, of their best song. 12,000 views… part of me wants to say “deserves more”, part of me is glad there are only so many of us that have been graced with this version. How raw and powerful his voice was here. How tight the arrangement was. How young they were. Miss you ❤
I don't think this has been available on TH-cam for that long, probably why its views aren't that high. I know it says it was uploaded 13 years ago but I remember looking for this particular concert and not finding much. It might have been taken down for a period.
This isn't the official Vevo Channel or the official U2 Channel so it's not going to have a high number of views, although it's up to 62,105 now it's higher on the official Channels apart from some re-releases of older tracks and yes this track has been on this Channel for 14 years that's why it says so next to the views, although if someone doesn't have an explanation of why the views are so low then they just make things up rather than admit that they don't know, I had only just been recommended this Channel while watching an official Vevo version of Vienna by Ultravox from the 1980's, the next one up is U2 Sunday Bloody Sunday on the official Live Aid Channel ..🤷🏻♂️
@@kevnwarriner8819 You talking to me? You can speak directly, you don't have to be a passive aggressive little soyboy... I didn't "make things up." I specifically searched songs from this concert and couldn't find anything for a period, even though I had before... So if they weren't temporarily removed, they were definitely suppressed by the algo for whatever reason. So stfu.
When Edge comes in with that guitar (1:50) - that was my favourite thing in the world at the time. In fact, it probably contributed to this damn tinnitus
Never seen this before until this moment...wow, fantastic! Love from England to everyone who appreciates this fabulous band and this greatest of songs! 🙂
J'y étais.. première partie les Pogues. Depuis je ne peux écouter cette chanson sans mettre le volume au maximum et retrouver les vibrations des basses. Thanks for this moment.
His mood here reminds me of the RTE appearance when they sung Springhill Mining Disaster. The biting rage in his eyes that night too. These are the moments when you know this ain't no ordinary rock singer and it ain't no ordinary band. The fury wasn't an act. He had the rage and you wanted to experience it in his performances. Age has calmed it, maybe his health wouldn't even tolerate it now.
@ObamaFromKenya You are right, he does sometimes go for a melodic talking version of his singing. For me it is definitely fun to watch out for moments where the (rage) full energy still rears it's head :D. I think it is normal to slow down with age of course as these song are VERY hard to sing energy wise and he deserves a little respite (don't know if that is the right word), cause boy did he gave it his all for so long at this point.
Yes Indeed 💯 they were on 🔥 & the World 🌎 was theirs, the Joshua Tree Tour was one if the Most Successful Tours in my Opinion in Music History. I saw them twice in Chicago & Once in LA & they had to come back to the 🇺🇸 & hit the Cities they missed the first time around 🎶 🎵 💙👏🤟🤘😁
Insane to think that they hadn’t even started the second US leg of the tour here…. they weren’t quite global sensations here but they were blowing up every day!!! They were like a tidal wave here, building and building with every show!!!
J'y étais. Il faisait super chaud. C'était en juillet, et si je me souviens bien, la première partie était Paul Young, et les Pogues. J'allais sur mes 22 ans
Une chanson qui vous donne autant d’émotions chaque fois….Quelle belle version….Elle vous transporte, elle vous fait chavirer et vous procure une énergie….grandiose….Merci éternel !
La mejor canción de U2 y su mejor versión con el estribillo final de joy division una fuerza vocal y musical inalcanzable...me sigue emocionando tras más de 35 años es la canción de mi vida y esta su mejor interpretacion❤❤❤❤
I remember my brother telling me about U2 on the old grey whistle test and seeing & hearing it myself “ tearing down those dollar bills billls” magical
Mood for a dream!!! Is my parfum!!! Thank you Douglas!!! 😂❤❤❤!!! Michael Matthias Frohn Mühlstroh und Jesus Christus!!! 😂❤❤❤!!! Overwehlming und Wunderschön und Wunderbar!!!
Isso sim é um vocal digno dessa canção! Sem firulas, direto como na versão de estudio, mas claro na energia da pegada ao vivo! Hoje o Bono cantando essa música fica difícil de ouvir, uma voz totalmente anasalada, nao sei que aconteceu com a voz dele, claro que se passaram muitos e muitos anos, Mas esse desempenho aqui é fantástico!
" I was strolling down past Paris way, I walked through the streets in the light of the day. I knew that someone had arrived, when I saw your eyes. When I see you. When I hope that it was good, As it was good for me, As it was good for you, Then it was good for me . "
🎉yes l am , bladed the drums in a Dubliners band at the same time that u2 took off. Went to school just down the road from mount temple. Funny thing was me Dad played golf with Bonos Dad at Forrest little golf club. Best wishes to u2 , in the right place at right time.
U2 is just as great as the Beatles and the rolling stones, after maybe better, they brought peace to Ireland and love to the world. They became the world's band. They brought peace just as Bob Marly did to Jamaica.
Hermosa 🎸canción en una 🎸 gran banda U2. 🎶
Mitici!
without or without you and one carried me through so many bad times but also so much of my best times.
I miss my father, and my dearest sister she passed away from me with no words to me RIP both of u 😢😢
i feel wih you!
I have the same situation
I don’t know ya at all: But, they are proud, because, YOU go on!
Stay blessed dear
That is sad, my heart goes out to you
Amazing ❤❤❤❤❤
j étais a ce concert j avais 21 ans.....cette chanson me hante encore aujourd hui........paris france janvier 2024
ARE YOU STILL LISEN TO THIS MASTERPIECE ON,2023 U2
2024
Masterpiece
2024
2024
Einfach super mit solch einer Inbrunst singen geht unter diehaut
Joshua Tree With or Without You, best of all time
Joshua Tree and Achtung Baby are the best albums of all time
Joshua Tree and Dark side of the moon
Not even!
We dont have words to say abaut this song, simple it's marvelus
My forever song until I the day I die
And mine ❤
During the cold darkness of my 30s this song gave me peace. I am no 66 and can see how much fucking pain I was in . Without the crutch of boose or drugd
Best version of this song
Love this group for standing up for the people.
Canción de canciones. Himno entre himnos. Pasan los años. Cuando muera quiero hacerlo escuchando algo tan bello como esto...
I can't listen to this any more after losing my husband
I lost husband as well, but this comforts me because he knows it
I'm the opposite LOL. I lost my wife April 2022 and U2, particularly Beautiful Day, got me through. Listened to it probably a thousand times that year.
Hang in there lost no my x married someone else I got to live with it he eats dinners with my children pain sure but Iam. Strong Iam weak but Iam alive live on folks with or with out pain it will all be ok , no Iam not baptised , Iam a free highlander I talk to the the one and only free spirit it’s a Scottish thing
ㄴ@@scottclark58763❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉😂
So sorry dear 😢 ❤that's the way it is
My favorite album of u2 is the unforgatable fire
Happy New year bono, edge, Adam and harry
Gilles from paris France
When music as Musicians where more for Fans then themselves.....damn those times
The Edge!!! Just lays down haunting guitar parts. Totally awesome. Completely unique. Suuuuustainnnnnn forever....... infinite sustai. This is a song you want to go on forever
Hauntingly beautiful live version that is a masterpiece of lyrics/story telling and singing/music.This has it all.Absolutley love it❤.Love to get in the zone with my best mate and sing along.We have both been there with former partners,as may have you,if this song gets deep into your soul.
God bless U2 I love you
Reminds of my college days at DUMZVILLE. When alternative songs is all you can hear every friday night kahit aling bar sa DUMA. Di mawala sa akong list na tukaron ni nga song every time naa koy gig before. Those were the days😊nakakamiss ang DUMAGUETE
ИДЕАЛЬНО ВСЕ!!!И как теперь к вам на концерт попасть...Мечта жизни )))
was in LA in 1987 on my way to SLO and stopped and saw them shot the video from the roof top. Ever
since then..... the greatest band I've ever seen....cept the EAGLES in TAMPA stmd. july 4 1976 yeah I'm old!
I so love this performance I can’t even express it. There are no words, just passion.
infinitamente espectacular e inolvidable , contigo o sin ti, agosto 2023
What a rare and beautiful version, of their best song. 12,000 views… part of me wants to say “deserves more”, part of me is glad there are only so many of us that have been graced with this version.
How raw and powerful his voice was here. How tight the arrangement was. How young they were.
Miss you ❤
I don't think this has been available on TH-cam for that long, probably why its views aren't that high. I know it says it was uploaded 13 years ago but I remember looking for this particular concert and not finding much. It might have been taken down for a period.
This isn't the official Vevo Channel or the official U2 Channel so it's not going to have a high number of views, although it's up to 62,105 now it's higher on the official Channels apart from some re-releases of older tracks and yes this track has been on this Channel for 14 years that's why it says so next to the views, although if someone doesn't have an explanation of why the views are so low then they just make things up rather than admit that they don't know, I had only just been recommended this Channel while watching an official Vevo version of Vienna by Ultravox from the 1980's, the next one up is U2 Sunday Bloody Sunday on the official Live Aid Channel ..🤷🏻♂️
@@kevnwarriner8819 You talking to me? You can speak directly, you don't have to be a passive aggressive little soyboy... I didn't "make things up." I specifically searched songs from this concert and couldn't find anything for a period, even though I had before... So if they weren't temporarily removed, they were definitely suppressed by the algo for whatever reason. So stfu.
Indeed
I danced to this song on my wedding day: it was magical!!
The best, I didn't think anything was better than the Beatles and Mike jagger
When Edge comes in with that guitar (1:50) - that was my favourite thing in the world at the time. In fact, it probably contributed to this damn tinnitus
This is my most favorite song .I can't stop listening to it
This all come up tonight for me, you are ace, beautiful ❤️
Never seen this before until this moment...wow, fantastic! Love from England to everyone who appreciates this fabulous band and this greatest of songs! 🙂
That was beautiful
J'y étais.. première partie les Pogues. Depuis je ne peux écouter cette chanson sans mettre le volume au maximum et retrouver les vibrations des basses. Thanks for this moment.
This is totally incredible! I could listen to this again and again and again...and I have, and I will.
Same here, even i set this song as my wake up alarm and the magic is that I can enjoy this song until it runs out until I really wake up.
Una y otra vez y otra vez
Y otra vez Y otra vez
His mood here reminds me of the RTE appearance when they sung Springhill Mining Disaster. The biting rage in his eyes that night too. These are the moments when you know this ain't no ordinary rock singer and it ain't no ordinary band. The fury wasn't an act. He had the rage and you wanted to experience it in his performances. Age has calmed it, maybe his health wouldn't even tolerate it now.
@ObamaFromKenya Still rage more controlled through understanding and wisdom. An old man can still rage, as it is not age related.
@ObamaFromKenya You are right, he does sometimes go for a melodic talking version of his singing. For me it is definitely fun to watch out for moments where the (rage) full energy still rears it's head :D. I think it is normal to slow down with age of course as these song are VERY hard to sing energy wise and he deserves a little respite (don't know if that is the right word), cause boy did he gave it his all for so long at this point.
The Best, my favority...Forever!!!
Superb rendition of this song - Bad is so Good!
This song is like a national anthem to me👌
I love this song ❤❤😢😢
Beings back so many memories when I was young 🙏💖
I saw them live in 1987 in NYC....Great memories. And no tear gas interruption....
@ObamaFromKenya Sort of...But no major crimes happened in Madison Square Garden. People were there to enjoy the band.
I thought we had enough tears in this song!
Yes Indeed 💯 they were on 🔥 & the World 🌎 was theirs, the Joshua Tree Tour was one if the Most Successful Tours in my Opinion in Music History. I saw them twice in Chicago & Once in LA & they had to come back to the 🇺🇸 & hit the Cities they missed the first time around 🎶 🎵 💙👏🤟🤘😁
Named my oldest Joshua..after I saw the Joshua Tree in Nevada Vegas ..He is now 28. My favorite song.
My one favorite song and band U2 ,,,
Wow what an amazing performance!
GOOD MUSIC IS ANOTHER LEVEL, THEY ARE ETERNAL. EXCELLENT.BRAZIL 07/13/2023.
WOW!!! JUST WOW!!!
Insane to think that they hadn’t even started the second US leg of the tour here…. they weren’t quite global sensations here but they were blowing up every day!!! They were like a tidal wave here, building and building with every show!!!
Yep best version of this song
Shoooo
❤❤❤❤❤❤
I was at that tour 87. Meadowlands N.J. 1 of the best Shows I've ever been 2. And I've Seen Many.
Was i right or rong ?
J'y étais. Il faisait super chaud. C'était en juillet, et si je me souviens bien, la première partie était Paul Young, et les Pogues. J'allais sur mes 22 ans
Very cool!
@@hoderharris Yep! You are totally right!
J y étais également oui il faisait super chaud ...Et c était ub40 et les Pogues avant eux....quelle belle journée...
@@vincentkazmierczak4325 😎👍
Une chanson qui vous donne autant d’émotions chaque fois….Quelle belle version….Elle vous transporte, elle vous fait chavirer et vous procure une énergie….grandiose….Merci éternel !
This performance is the very best! Every moment has me locked in.
La mejor canción de U2 y su mejor versión con el estribillo final de joy division una fuerza vocal y musical inalcanzable...me sigue emocionando tras más de 35 años es la canción de mi vida y esta su mejor interpretacion❤❤❤❤
I remember my brother telling me about U2 on the old grey whistle test and seeing & hearing it myself “ tearing down those dollar bills billls” magical
Always loving this group.❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤.
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤RIP Scott gone but never forgotten love always 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻😇😇😇😇😇😇. Thanks Vogt watching over me and the girls I know when it’s you ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Absolutely incredible version of this song!
I was in college life when I came to hear and love this song until now. Love it. Thank you 🥰
Да мы до сих пор слушаем этот шедевр!!!
One of my favorites...👍u2 song
Mood for a dream!!! Is my parfum!!! Thank you Douglas!!! 😂❤❤❤!!! Michael Matthias Frohn Mühlstroh und Jesus Christus!!! 😂❤❤❤!!! Overwehlming und Wunderschön und Wunderbar!!!
Isso sim é um vocal digno dessa canção! Sem firulas, direto como na versão de estudio, mas claro na energia da pegada ao vivo! Hoje o Bono cantando essa música fica difícil de ouvir, uma voz totalmente anasalada, nao sei que aconteceu com a voz dele, claro que se passaram muitos e muitos anos, Mas esse desempenho aqui é fantástico!
I love this song it's my all time favorite ❤❤❤ l love this band
Best live version I've ever heard!!
Well done on finding this gem!
Sensacional alguém em 2023 pirando ♡
Somos dos
j’étais à ce concert trop bon souvenir :D
Adam singing backup vocals is very unusual.
SIMPLY THE BEST IN THE WORLD .
A veces pienso que naci en la época equivocada que calidad de musica son unos Astros
They give it ALL away. How wonderful ❤️
Que buena versión de este tema .tan bello .❤❤
" I was strolling down past Paris way,
I walked through the streets in the light of the day.
I knew that someone had arrived,
when I saw your eyes.
When I see you.
When I hope that it was good,
As it was good for me,
As it was good for you,
Then it was good for me . "
Probably the best snippet ever sung by Bono. Love will tear us apart, again.
Thank you! I was trying to write it down! Bless you!
Aaaaaaaaa
Adam singing backup was very unusual.
@@mitchkent68 he did a lot of it during the original Joshua Tree Tour.
I first heard this song when it was live and still heard now in the eighties and year now as old boy old man likes most of U2
This one of the best performances of this song!!🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻 0:00
Infinitamente, linda! É para ouvir , sentir um milhão de vezes!Bravo!👏👏👏👏
Браво не то слово ❤❤❤❤ привет из Карелии
Absolutely beautiful!
Essa música marcou minha vida num momento de alegria misturado com tristeza, lembra filha? Não me canso em ouvir, simplesmente única e maravilhosa!
spontaneous poetry is Bono's forte
Someone in 2024?
Sure💜
Yes! 🎉
❤
At least once a month. They also still play it in the radio.
Forever❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤U2
Just noticed that Bono is wearing an Elvis guitar strap!
They all love Elvis!
He is very big on honoring forerunners.
I'll wait for you.....❤️🔥
such emotion! gawd I love him!
🎉yes l am , bladed the drums in a Dubliners band at the same time that u2 took off. Went to school just down the road from mount temple. Funny thing was me Dad played golf with Bonos Dad at Forrest little golf club. Best wishes to u2 , in the right place at right time.
U2 is just as great as the Beatles and the rolling stones, after maybe better, they brought peace to Ireland and love to the world. They became the world's band. They brought peace just as Bob Marly did to Jamaica.
El soundtrack de mi vida, gracias U2!
Thank you. Thank you very much.❤
Fue elegida la mejor canción de los 2000
Pues no sé cómo si es de 1987
J'y étais 😊
Beautiful ❤ ❤ ❤
No me canso de escuchar tan bella canción me hace recordar bellos momentos
Pra mim, será sempre uma das melhores músicas da banda, simplesmente, demais!!! Abraços!
J' avais 20 ans et j' y était....
Very super song very super singer very super band 🎀🌺🦋
what are you on?
2024, love you U2 ❤️
Indudablemente todo tiempo pasado fue mejor, música insuperable ❤❤❤
The band with best lircs and the best songs i love salmo 40
I love this group
Great band will always love u too
GROSSARTIGE BAND ....FEELING PUR...❤😂
Another Amazing Artist tonight ❤️