My dad passed away yesterday and now I'm making a playlist with all the songs he loved and I remember him by. This is one of them. Thank you dad for showing me the greatest artists of all times. Loved, missed and never forgotten 🤘🔥❤
I first heard this song in 1987, when I was a fifteen-year-old schoolboy. I was living at that time in a provincial Soviet village behind the Iron Curtain, and only Saint Santa knows how the cassette with U2 songs got into my remote place. It was this song that settled in my heart from the first chords and it seems like it will forever. I would like to wish everyone reading my comment a Happy New Year! May the new year bring less evil and more good. Peaceful skies above everyone. U2, thank you for this song! Thank you for the 36 years that I lived with your music.❤ Happy New Year! 02:56 January 1, 2024. Tien Shan mountains, height 3500 m above sea level.🎉🎉
@@paddydalton2373 You are right, my friend. TH-cam and the Internet have erased the boundaries between people from different countries. This is a privilege that previous generations were deprived of. It was very nice to wake up and read your reply from Ireland. Thank you for the Happy New Year wishes. I have always wanted to visit your emerald isle, wander through the ancient streets of Dublin, visit cathedrals and churches. And of course, get drunk to your heart's content with dark beer at Temple Bar. Slainte!!!🍻🥂🎄
it must be such a blessing for 4 friends to start a band at a young age, remain friends their entire lives, and produce the most magical music together. I can't even imagine the bond they must have.
Yes - I am so glad they haven’t had petty fallings out and public splits like many others. Funny how I was only thinking this the other day. They have been my musical core since I was 15 with ‘war’ and have been part of my whole life and now I’m in my 50’s. What joy they have given and what a life they have lived.
I read something a while ago when they finish a tour they go off and do there own and not talk to each other for months which is how they work so well together
Proud to be Irish U2 gave hope to us young people in the 1980 when the country was on its knees. We all owe U2 a great gratitude. Thanks for everything you done for and the world
Verdade! Eu me lembro bem, apesar de não ser irlandês, mas, amo muito a Irlanda 🇮🇪 por causa do U2. A Irlanda é encantadora, de um povo trabalhador, inteligente e dedicado, país lindo. O IRA sempre causou muitos atos terroristas àquela gente. Viva a Irlanda 🇮🇪
no screaming fans, no fancy lights, no big stadium- just an old fashioned, old time rock roll band playing with beautiful grace, passion and compassion.
But if they want it, they can fill a stadium giving a tremendous performance with all the ligths an a incredible sound!! They are both things. The magnificent band with the greatest shows I've ever seen. And this one. The simple, beautifull, organic and closely group of friends who play together since 30 years ago...
I have depression and only your songs can keep me normal. Thank you for being there because thanks to you I have the strength to get up every day and try to live
May God bless you and cure you of your depression. I've lived with it for the past 65 years. I go in and out of it. Half the time I awake I want to die, but I make it through the day. Don't be like me take care of your depression NOW. It can be done. Joe
Especially if you cry... And you don't know exactly what your crying for..... Sometimes not always...... Your crying for yourself...... Sometimes Edge makes you cry for everybody..... Haha.... You have to laugh at the madness... Xx
This has to be the most beautifully tragic song ever. Those heartbreaking lyrics and the amazing instrumentals. I can’t even begin to explain the emotions I feel when i hear this. A fucking Masterpiece.
Brilliant aren't they? And I don't think they get the recognition they truly deserve, particularly in the songwriting department. Their work is just so prolific.....more hits than the Beatles too who i loved until U2 came along!)
Bono has stated that he has a close relationship with God. He’s just a human being, a man from Ireland. Because he has a relationship with God the Father, he has the ability to put forth the purest form of LOVE. God’s LOVE for us. When we listen...to Bono’s voice & U2’s music the soundwaves travel through our ears and straight into our brain, synapses, and it becomes part of us. Feels good to get pure LOVE straight from the tap (the source) I’ve never met U2 personally but have been a lifelong fan, I’m only 41. Seen them live 5 times. They are a part of my life as I know it, part of me. 😊
I’m 21. Here in 2024. Me and the mother of my beautiful son didn’t work out. I love her so much. Everytime I hear this song, I can’t help but think about her. God I loved that woman so much.
I come back to this live version. This song may be a simple chord progression. But with that rumbling base, unique percussion, beautiful yet mysterious guitar, great vocals and melody it’s an absolute masterpiece.
March 1987 I walked into my local pub and my best mate said “have you heard U2’s new release”. He put it on the duke box (remember those) my mind was blown away, the song still gives my goosebumps 30 or so years later.
Man, this was back when music was still magic. Don't get me wrong there's still some talented people out there, GOOD music is hard to make. I grew up in the 2000's and I am glad I got to listen to songs like these through my parents. Music back than was something else. No music nowadays makes me feel this way. No songs about money, living the RICH life, no autotune. Just pure talent and love.
Music is not dead, promising new bands are on the rise, but since old bands aren’t dead the torch hasn’t been passed down. McCartney after all is still a fucking undying god. And thats okey, but music wont die, it never can
Just about sums it all up. I'm not against autotune, but it is like overused. Making every other songs sounds very similar. I think it is this that make music boring. When a Chinese guy singing in Mandarin that sounds like (very similar to) an American singer singing in English, you'll know there must be something wrong there ... just my two cents.
Bono’s vocal is just so achingly beautiful. Like all great albums ‘the Joshua tree’ still sound so fresh after all these years. A staggering piece of work and for me they’ve never got close to it since.
See the stone set in your eyes See the thorn twist in your side I'll wait for you Sleight of hand and twist of fate On a bed of nails she makes me wait And I wait, without you With or without you With or without you Through the storm we reach the shore You give it all but I want more And I'm waiting for you With or without you With or without you I can't live With or without you And you give yourself away And you give yourself away And you give And you give And you give yourself away My hands are tied My body bruised, she's got me with Nothing to win and Nothing left to lose And you give yourself away And you give yourself away And you give And you give And you give yourself away With or without you With or without you I can't live With or without you Oh With or without you With or without you I can't live With or without you With or without you
Say what you want about the band, but this is one of the most timeless songs. It transcends genre, era, culture, race, politics, nation. I’m convinced if this songs were released today it would hit the top of the charts. You can’t say that about most classics.
U2 is such an excellent and one of greatest bands ever! I have been to wow, 95 of their concerts all over the world, beginning in the 1980's. The stadium tours are the best!! Thank you U2!!
4 men together since the eighties...no replacements....tight group. We knew they were special in the 80's. The legacy builds every year. Truly icons in music. This version brought me to tears. You can only have this soul and passion if you have lived it.
I was just thinking to write that kind of comment. My would sound like that. Not any single band in planet is on scene over 35 years. Songs are legendary and they simply can´t die. We all know some singers are one night star, and then they disappear. Not U2 and even our kids are growing up with them. Special with With or without you, One love, Where the streets have no name, etc. All these songs gives us so many personal memories too, not only as U2´s songs.
I've watching and listening U2 for more than 30 years. They still outstanding. Love this band and miss so much the live shows in my country. Greetings from Brazil.
It's quite incredible that over 25 years after they originally wrote this song, they have managed to perform a completely new & brilliant version of what was already an amazing song. Fair play to them. U2 are the gr8est band of all time. U2 forever.
Lyrics: See the stone set in your eyes See the thorn twist in your side I'll wait for you Sleight of hand and twist of fate On a bed of nails, she makes me wait And I wait without you With or without you With or without you Through the storm, we reach the shore You give it all but I want more And I'm waiting for you With or without you With or without you, ah, ah I can't live With or without you And you give yourself away And you give yourself away And you give And you give And you give yourself away My hands are tied My body bruised, she got me with Nothing to win and Nothing left to lose And you give yourself away And you give yourself away And you give And you give And you give yourself away With or without you With or without you, oh I can't live With or without you Oh, oh Oh, oh With or without you With or without you, oh I can't live With or without you With or without you
This song is me and alcohol’s stronghold over me. So often I give myself away. My body is bruised and I’ve nothing to win and have nothing else to lose. To all those struggling with addiction, I send my love.
Amanda.I know exactly how u feel,you like me and thousands of ppl around the world fighting different addictions (mine drugs) do have something to win and loose.Hopefully we will win and therefore we have not lost.Good luck we all still have Dignity 🇮🇪😑
I`m in magic. Because of bono`s raw voice &charisma and the edge`s magical guitar sound, adam`s stable bass performance and larry`s the powerful & rhythmical beat of the drum.
Today I'm quiting my addiction its gonna be a struggle but I'm trusting my friends and most importantlyy my family to help me. I lost my way and I need to find the light. I lost 3 close family members in 2021. Its been a massive wake up call. Love to you all. Re edit. So the date Is 30 June 2021 at 11.11pm UK time as wrighting this. I would like to report. That I've been clean since I wrote this first post. Things are moving on up for me. I think I've found a new life in my self as well as that I think I've found love. Thankyou for all your support. Much love to you and God bless yaaa 💜💙
This is one of the best songs ever, everything is great on it the beating drums, the subliminal bassline, the outer space guitar and the heartbreaking vocals, every little piece shines by itself the perfect amount of time, perfect balance. Love this song.
Hello Violeta Rondon, How're you doing, it's been a long journey, and I'm nothing without amazing fans like you who appreciate my musical craftiness, All love to you and yours ❤️
True, but it's still a little bittersweet because it feels like they were a band that avoided the march of time for longer than most of their peers, but it all seems to have really caught up with them in the last couple years. That's not a knock, just an observation.
Robert Smith of the Cure celebrated 40 years in the band this year, is 59 and sounds the same now as he did at his peak in the 80's. But one thing I will say about Bono - dude still gives me chills when he sings. His voice has aged, but his passion remains. And the band is tight.
Rarely comment on youtube. I'm an Irish boy, my grandma was from the North Side of Dublin just like U2. I grew up in a very troubled part of Belfast. U2 helped me love being Irish again, when all I could feel around me was violence and hate. I studied in Manchester, so to hear Joy Division mixed in with this, makes me keep watching it over and over. They're so emotional. Every part of this, the guitar, the bass, the drums, the singing, the words, the emphasis on them ... it's intoxicating :)
It’s performances like these where each of them excel in their field. Bono’s vocals are fantastic, Edge’s guitar is biblical, Larry’s drums are on point and Adam’s bass is just perfect.
Adam Clayton doesn’t get enough credit for his part in this song. The bass is sensational. In fact one could say the four performers are at the height of their talents here.
@@boysymc Most famous riffs are quite easy to play..the ingenuity is in creating them for a specific tune that adds to the magic of that tune..this, i.e. creativity, is what sets the greats apart from the rest...the original poster is correct in saying the bass line is sensational
This is not just a song.. this is an emotion and the blend of all those wonderful memories.. U2 is not just a band its an emotion called love. Thank you U2.
I’m listening to this masterpiece on 25-3-2020 on covid -19 lockdown in the uk.... hoping everyone is still here with us that we all love when this is all over....Xxx
This is the song I turn to whenever life gets hard. Such raw emotion in the music, and I love Bono's voice in this performance. You can hear all his emotions with every line, it is amazing!
Another year coming here to register how much this song marks my life. This song has the power to take me and put me in such different corners of my memory, it makes me access different sensations that I can't describe in words because it's deep and sensitive, it's beyond comprehensible. Whenever I listen, I feel it passes through my heart, snuggles in an armchair, invites my spirit to dance and have wine, sometimes it makes it drunk and tearful haha. In short, it is sublime, ethereal, transcendent.
The way the song builds back up at 3:40, it makes me think of beautiful things, places and loved ones flashing quickly as time flies by. Life is so short. Make the best out of it peeps.
See the stone set in your eyes See the thorn twist in your side I'll wait for you Sleight of hand and twist of fate On a bed of nails, she makes me wait And I wait without you With or without you With or without you Through the storm, we reach the shore You give it all but I want more And I'm waiting for you With or without you With or without you, ah, ah I can't live With or without you And you give yourself away And you give yourself away And you give And you give And you give yourself away My hands are tied My body bruised, she got me with Nothing to win and Nothing left to lose And you give yourself away And you give yourself away And you give And you give And you give yourself away With or without you With or without you, oh I can't live With or without you Oh, oh Oh, oh With or without you With or without you, oh I can't live With or without you With or without you
U2, há vinte cinco anos atrás me inspirei no baixista Adam clayton pra aprender a tocar contra baixo e essa música foi a primeira que aprendi a tocar.U2 sempre! os caras são fantásticos!! Alguém curtindo junho 2020👍
É muito Admirável o respeito e união dessa banda, desde 1976 os caras estão na ativa com a mesma formação, isso é simplesmente espetacular, e Bono é coisa de louco um espetáculo a voz do cara!!!
Incredible tune, 30 years old but has gotten better with time. The way it builds and builds, the emotion Bono puts into his singing, the beautiful guitar playing The Edge does is amazing and the orchestra really gives the song a special touch as well.
my father died by the consequences of the corona virus. This was his first song at his goodbye today. What a feeling, what a song
Rip 😞
Condolence
sorry
So sorry about your dad
Sorry for your loss🖤RIP
My dad passed away yesterday and now I'm making a playlist with all the songs he loved and I remember him by. This is one of them. Thank you dad for showing me the greatest artists of all times. Loved, missed and never forgotten 🤘🔥❤
Great idea! Sorry for your loss. May he rest in peace, and may God strenghten and console you. 💞
Meus sentimentos 🙏 Que Deus todo poderoso possa confortar seu coração e da sua família 🙏😔
God bless you and your dad.
May God protect your glorious dad and all your loved ones. Sending countless love to you 💕 Rest in Peace Sir.
Nicely put - I'm sure your dad was a lovely man ❤
I first heard this song in 1987, when I was a fifteen-year-old schoolboy. I was living at that time in a provincial Soviet village behind the Iron Curtain, and only Saint Santa knows how the cassette with U2 songs got into my remote place. It was this song that settled in my heart from the first chords and it seems like it will forever. I would like to wish everyone reading my comment a Happy New Year! May the new year bring less evil and more good. Peaceful skies above everyone.
U2, thank you for this song! Thank you for the 36 years that I lived with your music.❤
Happy New Year!
02:56
January 1, 2024.
Tien Shan mountains, height 3500 m above sea level.🎉🎉
Auguri ❤
To You My Friend If It Were Not For U2 And TH-cam We'd Not Known Of Each Other😊
But May God See Our Friendship! Best Wishes From Dublin🤗
@@paddydalton2373 You are right, my friend. TH-cam and the Internet have erased the boundaries between people from different countries. This is a privilege that previous generations were deprived of. It was very nice to wake up and read your reply from Ireland. Thank you for the Happy New Year wishes. I have always wanted to visit your emerald isle, wander through the ancient streets of Dublin, visit cathedrals and churches. And of course, get drunk to your heart's content with dark beer at Temple Bar. Slainte!!!🍻🥂🎄
@@pakypici242 Grazie! Tutto il meglio per il nuovo anno!🎄🥂
Best wishes 🙏
This is one of the most uplifting and beautiful things on TH-cam. Kudos to Coldplay for connecting with ALL music lovers, hearing or not.
it must be such a blessing for 4 friends to start a band at a young age, remain friends their entire lives, and produce the most magical music together. I can't even imagine the bond they must have.
Yes - I am so glad they haven’t had petty fallings out and public splits like many others. Funny how I was only thinking this the other day. They have been my musical core since I was 15 with ‘war’ and have been part of my whole life and now I’m in my 50’s. What joy they have given and what a life they have lived.
That's a blessing! They understand each other.
@@thedorseyway tabq6wdaafaed
I read something a while ago when they finish a tour they go off and do there own and not talk to each other for months which is how they work so well together
What a great song, I love it! I put it into my "Shellshocked Radio - Recommendations" List: th-cam.com/video/Y2TN1N1FhIo/w-d-xo.html Very well done!
Proud to be Irish
U2 gave hope to us young people in the 1980 when the country was on its knees.
We all owe U2 a great gratitude.
Thanks for everything you done for and the world
So ist es! Nach dem 30.01. 1972 dem Bloody Sunday erst recht ♥️🇮🇪
Conor McGregor e safadão e vai perde a luta no UFC kkkkkk
beautiful hugs my friend
Verdade! Eu me lembro bem, apesar de não ser irlandês, mas, amo muito a Irlanda 🇮🇪 por causa do U2. A Irlanda é encantadora, de um povo trabalhador, inteligente e dedicado, país lindo. O IRA sempre causou muitos atos terroristas àquela gente. Viva a Irlanda 🇮🇪
Greetings from Egypt
no screaming fans, no fancy lights, no big stadium- just an old fashioned, old time rock roll band playing with beautiful grace, passion and compassion.
But if they want it, they can fill a stadium giving a tremendous performance with all the ligths an a incredible sound!!
They are both things. The magnificent band with the greatest shows I've ever seen.
And this one. The simple, beautifull, organic and closely group of friends who play together since 30 years ago...
We're screaming in our hearts with this beautiness
@@michael-cc9dc I know I love the fans but sometimes there screaming over the performer and can't hear them sing.
42 years ago ;)
More importantly, no mobile phones!
one of the all time masterpieces in music history
Absolutely brilliant..thanks bono.fof everything..
Thomas Mitchell. 2024.duɓĺin.1.
Its crazy how many people come back to this everyday... this song is masterpiece!!!!!
É linda demais! Amo música. Está é a minha número 01.❤️
For realll
Ppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppp0pppppppp0ppppppppppppp@@johnnylay1961
It doesn't matter when you hear this music, whether it's 20, 10, 5 years ago or today (2023) it's and will always be GREAT! 🙏🙏🙏👏👏👏
Concordo com você👍👍
Thank you so much for the moral push, it has been your love and support that has kept me at my best, may the good lord bless and guide you.❤️
Vminconnue
@play
Literally I love this song and dis band.,until I die
Just lost a best man to tis song . May he be at rest 😢
Greetings to all who listen that magic in 2024❤
Я приєднуюсь❤🎉❤🎉 до Ваших слів❤🎉❤💪✌️💅💅💅💅💅💅💅💅💅💅💅🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘👍👍👍👍👍💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪👍👍👍💓💓💓💓💓
Eles são maravilhosos 👏👏
@@anfisakorneichuk6261k
Buen artista cantante bien recuerdo increíble genio total 😊
fk yeah
Bono sings from the heart, that's why it's bring memories, bring tears in our eyes.
This band is bunch of magicians.
for sure❤😢
Аппаратуру бы им получше,,,
This is not music...it's magic.
Angela Dal Col
It’s magical music
Spot on
👍
It's effing awesome.......my favourite song of all time!!!!!
SOOO wahr :-)
October 2024?
🎉😊 desde Paraguay América del sur!!!
Yes sir 🙌
November December and all next year buddy 👍
4 octubre 2024 desde España, Granada
Forever!❤
I have depression and only your songs can keep me normal. Thank you for being there because thanks to you I have the strength to get up every day and try to live
Strongs my friend 🙏
Deus é contigo meu amigo Elton do Brasil tenha força lute já está dando tudo certo em sua vida
May God bless you and cure you of your depression. I've lived with it for the past 65 years. I go in and out of it. Half the time I awake I want to die, but I make it through the day. Don't be like me take care of your depression NOW. It can be done. Joe
@@JoeTesta-n4vAm 43 yrs and am suffering from depression. Fuck lebanon
This song is immortal, as is the band, one of the biggest and best of all times.
only until the judgement day. It is not "amazing Grace."
The best. Thanks U2
If you listen to this everyday your day will be better trust me this song is a masterpiece
yes my friend is a beautiful song, "saludos para ti" from Argentina
P
Especially if you cry... And you don't know exactly what your crying for..... Sometimes not always...... Your crying for yourself...... Sometimes Edge makes you cry for everybody..... Haha.... You have to laugh at the madness... Xx
Melhor música do planeta
Couldn't agree more
anybody listening to this gem in october 2024?
Oh yes
From Panamá 🇵🇦🇵🇦🇵🇦, never forget U2
sure! Why not?
Yes
i listening this song from2007 to now
Love will tear us apart. Ian Curtis lives on long after his untimely death. This song is sublime and The Edge is a genius …. Fact.
57 years old and still have so much emotion when he sings. this song is a masterpiece where everyone in the band shines equally!! 🎤🎶🥰❤
He is 62...
@@CapuletLeGrand This was recorded 5 years ago, he was not 62 then.
Agree
👍👍👍👊👊👊
Age is a #. And the older one gets the deeper the emotion
Noviembre 2024 => 👍
Bom viu jovem
This has to be the most beautifully tragic song ever. Those heartbreaking lyrics and the amazing instrumentals. I can’t even begin to explain the emotions I feel when i hear this. A fucking Masterpiece.
I feel so
I’ll fucken second that 👍
Exactly. The melody adds to the melancholy and nostalgia as well.
Muito top curto essa música a anos e não me canso de ouvir quase todos os dias
the bass is like a soothing smooth cream, Eargasm
How after singing this 435,987 times, does he make it sound like the first time? Every time. U2 has managed to remain young while growing old.
Brilliant aren't they? And I don't think they get the recognition they truly deserve, particularly in the songwriting department. Their work is just so prolific.....more hits than the Beatles too who i loved until U2 came along!)
It’s the soul singing and not the body
Bono has stated that he has a close relationship with God. He’s just a human being, a man from Ireland. Because he has a relationship with God the Father, he has the ability to put forth the purest form of LOVE. God’s LOVE for us. When we listen...to Bono’s voice & U2’s music the soundwaves travel through our ears and straight into our brain, synapses, and it becomes part of us. Feels good to get pure LOVE straight from the tap (the source)
I’ve never met U2 personally but have been a lifelong fan, I’m only 41. Seen them live 5 times. They are a part of my life as I know it, part of me. 😊
What’s really amazing is that he makes it sound like the first time for the listener.
It sounds nothing like the original lol. He changed the cadence like he always does lately and its super annoying
Timeless and ethereal, breaks your heart and puts it back together at the same time...a masterpiece of songwriting that will never die
also keeps us alive Daniel >>
absolutely @@patriciapaquette1199
ty daniel..to be sure x@@danielperugini19
@@danielperugini19😊
These songs give me a lot of nostalgia, I miss the teenage years, I'm Brazilian, but I love international music.
No matter how many times I listen to this song, it still has the magic that other songs can't provide. It's pure passion!
Show de bola
Totally agree1
1000 times ?
@@Junior-zs3nt ovità loco motion
@@Junior-zs3nt panaghapl:£lag
I’m 21. Here in 2024. Me and the mother of my beautiful son didn’t work out. I love her so much. Everytime I hear this song, I can’t help but think about her. God I loved that woman so much.
Meu amigo se acha que vale a pena lute ,,pelo seu amor.lue pela sua amada
Don’t give up!! Man tell her how you love her. I’m a woman and we crave that. I’ll pray she comes around 🙏🏼🙏🏼
I'm sorry...there is someone out there waiting for you. Keep searching, you will find her.
Going through something similar myself. hold that head up high man, you got this.
Vai dar tudo certo tenha fé Deus é contigo
I come back to this live version. This song may be a simple chord progression. But with that rumbling base, unique percussion, beautiful yet mysterious guitar, great vocals and melody it’s an absolute masterpiece.
I aggree almost on every point, however the vocals on this version are far from its original lp version's soul and effect.
Black Catholics and Brum say hello !😀
What a masterpiece brings back so many memories when I was younger I will always always love this song. They do such a great job on it.
Unreal. The Joshua Tree represents the pinnacle of music and this track is all time. This live version is stunning.
March 1987 I walked into my local pub and my best mate said “have you heard U2’s new release”. He put it on the duke box (remember those) my mind was blown away, the song still gives my goosebumps 30 or so years later.
you're lucky
such an amazing story man
Toby keith
@@Siimbaa2
Key largo. Toby kieth
Its sad that Bono became old. His singing was better in the 80's.
Has to be one of the most outstanding performances of this masterpiece - Bono’s voice at its best. Even better than the original
There are certain songs that will live forever and are a true masterpiece…This is one of them..❤️
Man, this was back when music was still magic. Don't get me wrong there's still some talented people out there, GOOD music is hard to make. I grew up in the 2000's and I am glad I got to listen to songs like these through my parents. Music back than was something else. No music nowadays makes me feel this way. No songs about money, living the RICH life, no autotune. Just pure talent and love.
Yeahh
You've been listening to the wrong music my friend. Money and autotune? What are you listening to pop radio looking for good music?
Music is not dead, promising new bands are on the rise, but since old bands aren’t dead the torch hasn’t been passed down. McCartney after all is still a fucking undying god. And thats okey, but music wont die, it never can
@@luquivarde7266
Yes it can , and it's dying as we speak .
SOCIETY is LOSING it's SOUL !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Just about sums it all up. I'm not against autotune, but it is like overused. Making every other songs sounds very similar. I think it is this that make music boring. When a Chinese guy singing in Mandarin that sounds like (very similar to) an American singer singing in English, you'll know there must be something wrong there ... just my two cents.
Bono’s vocal is just so achingly beautiful. Like all great albums ‘the Joshua tree’ still sound so fresh after all these years. A staggering piece of work and for me they’ve never got close to it since.
Certainly one of my all time favourite albums
The best album to have come out of the 1980s.
See the stone set in your eyes
See the thorn twist in your side
I'll wait for you
Sleight of hand and twist of fate
On a bed of nails she makes me wait
And I wait, without you
With or without you
With or without you
Through the storm we reach the shore
You give it all but I want more
And I'm waiting for you
With or without you
With or without you
I can't live
With or without you
And you give yourself away
And you give yourself away
And you give
And you give
And you give yourself away
My hands are tied
My body bruised, she's got me with
Nothing to win and
Nothing left to lose
And you give yourself away
And you give yourself away
And you give
And you give
And you give yourself away
With or without you
With or without you
I can't live
With or without you
Oh
With or without you
With or without you
I can't live
With or without you
With or without you
What a song! Anyone in November 2024?
BRAZIL
New Mexico USA ❤
México.🇲🇽
me encanta....soy de Honduras bendiciones
Midlands, UK
Just like wine. Want Bono to hit that high notes? Go and play your CD. This is life, this is live. God bless U2.
Say what you want about the band, but this is one of the most timeless songs. It transcends genre, era, culture, race, politics, nation. I’m convinced if this songs were released today it would hit the top of the charts. You can’t say that about most classics.
PINK FLOYD THE BEST BAND
Im with you,there are all time favorite boys xxx
The whole album was the same.
Agreed
U2 e aumenta o som e deixar o tempo para aí é só de cola pra Júpiter ou Marte ne
Bono and accompanied by a full orchestra provided the best sound. Wow, can't get any better than that!
U2 is such an excellent and one of greatest bands ever! I have been to wow, 95 of their concerts all over the world, beginning in the 1980's. The stadium tours are the best!! Thank you U2!!
These songs are so timeless that we sometimes forget that they're 30 and almost 40 years old. Talk about a sign of a legendary band.
4 men together since the eighties...no replacements....tight group. We knew they were special in the 80's. The legacy builds every year. Truly icons in music. This version brought me to tears. You can only have this soul and passion if you have lived it.
I was just thinking to write that kind of comment. My would sound like that. Not any single band in planet is on scene over 35 years. Songs are legendary and they simply can´t die. We all know some singers are one night star, and then they disappear. Not U2 and even our kids are growing up with them. Special with With or without you, One love, Where the streets have no name, etc. All these songs gives us so many personal memories too, not only as U2´s songs.
I've been living this passion since 1989, every single day, every single hour. U2 is an eternal inspiration.
@@volkiabi3456 There's something about the songs; so many good ones.
Try the 70's
I love this music 2024😊👍❤️ Philippines
I've watching and listening U2 for more than 30 years. They still outstanding. Love this band and miss so much the live shows in my country. Greetings from Brazil.
What a great song, I love it! I put it into my "Shellshocked Radio - Recommendations" List: th-cam.com/video/Y2TN1N1FhIo/w-d-xo.html Very well done!
It's quite incredible that over 25 years after they originally wrote this song, they have managed to perform a completely new & brilliant version of what was already an amazing song. Fair play to them. U2 are the gr8est band of all time. U2 forever.
What are you talking about? This is not a completely new version, it's just a live performance
H
That guitar solo manages to make me awestruck, like it has for so many years...
Música boa U2
I'm leaving this comment here so after a month or a year when someone likes it, I get reminded of this masterpiece ❤️
It is a masterpiece!!!!
Its a master piece x
Surely you can not forget this tune??
It's a classic alright peace and love from Ireland 🇮🇪
Not even a month
Quite simply, the most awesome band that has ever played...anywhere!
this song will never get old, a song for every emotion and every season in every age
Yes Sir!
Valor
Cadê a guitarra doada?
I lift up my hands and toes to agree with you!
@@reginaldorodriguesdasilva8633 faça a pergunta ao Lula, tenho certeza que o destino foi leiloada.
Lyrics:
See the stone set in your eyes
See the thorn twist in your side
I'll wait for you
Sleight of hand and twist of fate
On a bed of nails, she makes me wait
And I wait without you
With or without you
With or without you
Through the storm, we reach the shore
You give it all but I want more
And I'm waiting for you
With or without you
With or without you, ah, ah
I can't live
With or without you
And you give yourself away
And you give yourself away
And you give
And you give
And you give yourself away
My hands are tied
My body bruised, she got me with
Nothing to win and
Nothing left to lose
And you give yourself away
And you give yourself away
And you give
And you give
And you give yourself away
With or without you
With or without you, oh
I can't live
With or without you
Oh, oh
Oh, oh
With or without you
With or without you, oh
I can't live
With or without you
With or without you
Good for you using copy and paste
Thank You
Thank you very much.
Obrigado amigo vc é um amigo
Bom ter a tradução. Valeu! 👍
Alguém ouvindo essa em 2024?😊
Nesse momento a 01:20 do dia 22/10/2024
Aqui eu de novo 🤗🤗🤗
Só uma idiota faz uma pergunta dessa!!!!!!!!!!
Eu dia 26/10/24
Agora 26/10/2024 18:47
What a piece of an absolute masterpiece. Thank you U2.
This song is me and alcohol’s stronghold over me. So often I give myself away. My body is bruised and I’ve nothing to win and have nothing else to lose. To all those struggling with addiction, I send my love.
Hang in there kid...
Hey how are you doing? You get stronger every day.
I love these song 💕🎸
Please take care of you my friend…
Amanda.I know exactly how u feel,you like me and thousands of ppl around the world fighting different addictions (mine drugs) do have something to win and loose.Hopefully we will win and therefore we have not lost.Good luck we all still have Dignity 🇮🇪😑
I`m in magic.
Because of bono`s raw voice &charisma and the edge`s magical guitar sound, adam`s stable bass performance and larry`s the powerful & rhythmical beat of the drum.
When they sent the record from earth out of space, I hope this was on it 🥰
Today I'm quiting my addiction its gonna be a struggle but I'm trusting my friends and most importantlyy my family to help me. I lost my way and I need to find the light. I lost 3 close family members in 2021. Its been a massive wake up call. Love to you all.
Re edit. So the date Is 30 June 2021 at 11.11pm UK time as wrighting this. I would like to report. That I've been clean since I wrote this first post. Things are moving on up for me. I think I've found a new life in my self as well as that I think I've found love.
Thankyou for all your support. Much love to you and God bless yaaa 💜💙
Wish u the best on ur new way of life💕💕
Take it EZZY bro...you are not alone....PEACE from FIJI....
You are not alone, my friend. Do whatever you need to do and reach out for help. Good luck.
One step at a time into your new journey.
May God bless you and help you!!
This is one of the best songs ever, everything is great on it the beating drums, the subliminal bassline, the outer space guitar and the heartbreaking vocals, every little piece shines by itself the perfect amount of time, perfect balance. Love this song.
Their sounds do like a 3d bend to meld together and transition in the song, such craftsmenship
❤
Brilliant
Outer space guitar, perfect description for the Glorious Edge
The emotion in Bono's voice around 3 mins in. So powerful. Amazing performance!
Molyneaux ma fa cagare
Just transport me every time and never gets old.
Molyneaux realy agree
Molyneaux best I’ve heard him sing it in a long time
Giorgio Andrea Baldisserri , distinguiti, da "buon" italiano 😬
Gone 1am and still can't stop playing this on repeat. U2 😎 thank u
This should be kept in the museum.
Museum of FINE ART❤❤❤
completamentteeeee
😊😊😊😊😊😊000000p0000000⁰00p0⁰⁰⁰0😊00⁰⁰⁰⁰000000⁰0000000000000p00⁰00😊0p00000000000000😊0😊0000000000000000000
000000000000000⁰⁰⁰⁰0⁰000000000000000000000000⁰00p0000000000000⁰⁰00⁰⁰000@@darleenstrathy6394
@@darleenstrathy6394⁰0⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰00000000⁰⁰0000⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰000p000000😊000000000😊0😊😊😊0000000😊😊😊😊😊00000😊😊😊0😊
It's 2023, and this Iconic Masterpiece still evokes the same immortal feel to it. This arguably U2's signature tune...and it will live on..
Definitely my song. It doesn't matter which version it is. This is really the song of my life
Hello Violeta Rondon,
How're you doing,
it's been a long journey, and I'm nothing without amazing fans like you who appreciate my musical craftiness,
All love to you and yours ❤️
This song reminds me of my husband that passed away 5 years ago. ❤
U2 no doubt is one of the best band in the world. Still going strong n steady after 40 years..👍👍
Show de bola ⚽️ 🏐 🏈 🎊 🏀 🔮 ⚽️ 🏐 🏈 🎊 🏀 🔮 ⚽️
"Love will tear us apart again" U2 once again nailed it, just like 1987 but better!
Love will tear us apart again in Paris 1987 was one of the best
He always finds the right lyric from another song if he decides to add one to the live version of any of their songs. Wonderful
Love,Death,connection,pain.
Forever Joy Division!!!
57 year old man who has been singing for 40 years...of course his voice has aged. Time waits for no man sadly. Still great
London5369 you're right that is a very great thing :)
I love your choice of words...
It instills wisdom and understanding in those who are inexperienced immature and speculating wrongly all the time ..
True, but it's still a little bittersweet because it feels like they were a band that avoided the march of time for longer than most of their peers, but it all seems to have really caught up with them in the last couple years. That's not a knock, just an observation.
Robert Smith of the Cure celebrated 40 years in the band this year, is 59 and sounds the same now as he did at his peak in the 80's. But one thing I will say about Bono - dude still gives me chills when he sings. His voice has aged, but his passion remains. And the band is tight.
Dreadful, If you can't sing it dont play it.
Eu estou ouvindo hoje linda música
Rarely comment on youtube. I'm an Irish boy, my grandma was from the North Side of Dublin just like U2. I grew up in a very troubled part of Belfast. U2 helped me love being Irish again, when all I could feel around me was violence and hate. I studied in Manchester, so to hear Joy Division mixed in with this, makes me keep watching it over and over. They're so emotional. Every part of this, the guitar, the bass, the drums, the singing, the words, the emphasis on them ... it's intoxicating :)
It’s performances like these where each of them excel in their field. Bono’s vocals are fantastic, Edge’s guitar is biblical, Larry’s drums are on point and Adam’s bass is just perfect.
you don't find this kind of music, it finds you whenever you need it the most
nice try
Verdade
Adam Clayton doesn’t get enough credit for his part in this song. The bass is sensational.
In fact one could say the four performers are at the height of their talents here.
Just a nothing comment. One of the simplest bass lines to play
ZooTv, there you have the height of their career.
@@boysymc Most famous riffs are quite easy to play..the ingenuity is in creating them for a specific tune that adds to the magic of that tune..this, i.e. creativity, is what sets the greats apart from the rest...the original poster is correct in saying the bass line is sensational
@@boysymc hahaha literally my reaction. at least he didn't use a loop pedal though, that counts for something!
??
No
This is not just a song.. this is an emotion and the blend of all those wonderful memories.. U2 is not just a band its an emotion called love. Thank you U2.
This legend will never disappear in my life..❤❤❤
It’s 2024!! This song still hits home, what a master piece this is!! 👍👍
Eu ouvindo maravilhosa maio 2024
Never dates.
La sigo escuchando desde Buenos Aires Argentina. ❤
Inexplicável!Mágica...De arrepiar!!✨💛🌻
Hell YES!
I’m listening to this masterpiece on 25-3-2020 on covid -19 lockdown in the uk.... hoping everyone is still here with us that we all love when this is all over....Xxx
Selma Nunes ouvindo u2 porto alegre rs
U2’s songs are so timeless, and as mood booster.
Jakarta, Indonesia.
You speak the truth brother🤐👍
THE EDGE!
lahir tahun 2002 , tapi suka lagu kaya gini, love it
And also U2 can influenced PADI REBORN
3:14 One of the best song from one of the finest Rock Band ever! Rock On U2 - You are legend❤
The guitar..the drum..the bass..the singer...the lyrics...everything in this song sounds perfectttttt
Perfecto.Love guitar music!
This is the song I turn to whenever life gets hard. Such raw emotion in the music, and I love Bono's voice in this performance. You can hear all his emotions with every line, it is amazing!
It's one of the songs I turn to also. Fills my darkness with light and reminds me that there is love. Peace to you.
2019
In terms of longevity and great music,
you gotta give it to U2. They are still
together.
Rolling Stones: Let us introduce ourselves
@@limbo2587 allow me to introduce myself
But the original members of Rolling Stones are already gone. U2 have the SAME members since the 80s! U2 need NO INTRO ❤
❤❤❤❤❤
November 18 th 2024 ,here listening to my favorite song from U2!! ❤❤❤
Who is listening to this masterpiece in 2021 ???❤🇮🇪😘
Me. Lol
Me too!
Yes, the best!!!!
🥰💚🍀✨All time fav!!!
Yo!!! 🙋♂️ 🇦🇷
Another year coming here to register how much this song marks my life. This song has the power to take me and put me in such different corners of my memory, it makes me access different sensations that I can't describe in words because it's deep and sensitive, it's beyond comprehensible. Whenever I listen, I feel it passes through my heart, snuggles in an armchair, invites my spirit to dance and have wine, sometimes it makes it drunk and tearful haha. In short, it is sublime, ethereal, transcendent.
Thats a great description of how music has the power to gift you with the power to transcend our earthly bounds right?
@@bobfruge7233 definitely that
Who’s here? This song will never die!!❤
No creo k. U2. Será lo. Último de perra vida y. Oy. Toda. Via la. Escucho donde en. Todos lo. Vivas
Yes never die
Hola mi Reyna
Greetings from Brazil
Я здесь. Точно подметил. Творчество на века.
Wooow!
U2……..I love this Band!
With or without you….Amazing Song!
If you still listen to this in 2021, your a true icon❤️
Bom
This is awesome Alex!!
Same❤️
U2 is fantastic this song is obe of my favorites😊
U2.... lo mejor
The way the song builds back up at 3:40, it makes me think of beautiful things, places and loved ones flashing quickly as time flies by. Life is so short. Make the best out of it peeps.
See the stone set in your eyes
See the thorn twist in your side
I'll wait for you
Sleight of hand and twist of fate
On a bed of nails, she makes me wait
And I wait without you
With or without you
With or without you
Through the storm, we reach the shore
You give it all but I want more
And I'm waiting for you
With or without you
With or without you, ah, ah
I can't live
With or without you
And you give yourself away
And you give yourself away
And you give
And you give
And you give yourself away
My hands are tied
My body bruised, she got me with
Nothing to win and
Nothing left to lose
And you give yourself away
And you give yourself away
And you give
And you give
And you give yourself away
With or without you
With or without you, oh
I can't live
With or without you
Oh, oh
Oh, oh
With or without you
With or without you, oh
I can't live
With or without you
With or without you
It is a timeless song that will stand the test of time.
how many times have they played this masterpiece? does it ever get old? or does it just heal the soul and soul over and over?
Never gets old
Son geniales...
Never ever timeless 😊
Jamais 👏👏👏
It is very hard when you miss someone that you will never see again. someone is listening to it in 2021?
HELLO , YES EVERY DAY. CHILLING , I LOVE IT SO MUCH. JUST THE SONG I'LL ASK TO LISTEN TO TO SAY GOOBYE TO THIS WORLD,
yes... Me
ALWAYS
This piece is timeless.
Will listen in 2022, 2023, 2024.......
I miss my mother and grandmother a lot (((
I can see why they are considered one of the best bands of all time
This song will forever be on the album of the best ever made.
Amazing version, stunning strings. They should make a orchestral live album.
buralarda türk görmek güzel :)
Ben de 1994 doğumluyum :)
And DVD!
Hop
Probably already...
U2, há vinte cinco anos atrás me inspirei no baixista Adam clayton pra aprender a tocar contra baixo e essa música foi a primeira que aprendi a tocar.U2 sempre! os caras são fantásticos!! Alguém curtindo junho 2020👍
Simplesmente a melhor..........
Я с молоду обожаю Ю2 ! Сегодня 05, 02,2022 год, мне 55 ,и я их все равно слушаю!
É muito Admirável o respeito e união dessa banda, desde 1976 os caras estão na ativa com a mesma formação, isso é simplesmente espetacular, e Bono é coisa de louco um espetáculo a voz do cara!!!
Geniales los ❤️ esta canción es inolvidable quien no creció escuchándola ? Saludos de chile 🇨🇱 U2❤️❤️
Oi alguém aí ouvindo essa música. ❤
@@sandras9136 Claro q sim!!
I don’t know if you felt the same but this song has a good feeling, my body gets goosebumps when I hear it ❤️👌🏾
insane performance, Bono's voice is like aged wine, just keeps getting better and better
I disagree but this thankfully was an amazing version. He definitely can't always do that.
Incredible tune, 30 years old but has gotten better with time. The way it builds and builds, the emotion Bono puts into his singing, the beautiful guitar playing The Edge does is amazing and the orchestra really gives the song a special touch as well.
jnb432 if you say so, but what a shame that they’re massive egotistical pricks...
Bono the best
Bono the best
@jack G - Yeah Ty for the typical common-as-muck Brit view. What the fk is is with you Brits. Just can't stand uppity Paddys with opinions can you?
Jnb432 - Couldn't have said it any better! This is awesome!