Why is Pakistan expelling Afghan refugees? | Inside Story
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ส.ค. 2024
- Hundreds of thousands of Afghans are being forced to leave Pakistan as part of a government crackdown.
Many have lived there for decades and consider it their home.
But the Pakistani government blames Afghans for a surge in attacks by armed groups.
Human Rights groups say the deportations violate international law and that many refugees face dangers-- if they're forced to return to Afghanistan.
Is this politically motivated?
And how will Taliban officials deal with it?
Presenter: James Bays
Guests:
Nilofer Afridi Qazi - Social Worker by trade who's also a Public Policy Specialist.
Faiz Zaland - Professor of Political Science at Kabul University, who's also the Chief Executive of the Peace, Development and Democracy Organisation.
Devon Cone - Senior Advocate for Women and Girls at Refugees International.
Subscribe to our channel: bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter: / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook: / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
Check out our Instagram page: / aljazeeraenglish
Download AJE Mobile App: aje.io/AJEMobile
#Pakistan #Afghanistan #AfghansInPakistan #AfghanistanMigrants #AfghanistanRefugees #Torkham #PakistanAfghanistanBorder #IllegalMigrants #UndocumentedMigrants
Arab nations won't take a single Palestinian refugee but make videos about Pakistan shame on you
why would they take palastine has own lasnd and it was being invaded by US UK and here afghanistan also have their whole big land
Whhhhy not take the Palestinians.....maybe there is a reason ..... Let's check history......
@gurey3439 Christians of Nagorno-Karabakh was in there land why they left? Bengali Hindus in 1971 why they left there land? Why kashmiri pandits left there land? Why Buddist left Afganistan? Why Zorastrian left Persia?
@gurey3439 Why currently Sudanese leaving there land?
On the day of judgement,Pakistan is answerable for its deeds, not MBS, not Qatar, not Iran, Iraq, or Afghanistan!! So we should stop looking at what others are doing and should grow a backbone to stand up straight and stop being a puppet!!
Aljazeera saudi arabia and doha is empty please allow them.
Many countries were allowing them at that time but pakistan was reluctant to give them refugee so that they can have labour's in their factories and when funds would arrive for afghan refugee from other nations they would go straight into your politicians pockets
The best movements why afghan go to arab countries kpk and pashthon belt of balochistan were part of afghanistan for thousands of year and the pakhthon s of pakistan and pakhthon of afghanistan r one nation separated by birtish inveder made durand line so afghan refugees have right to l7ve in kpk and in pashthon belt of balochistan which is pakhthon land not punjabi sindhi hindustani or baloch land
@@baz4566 even whole afghanistan is a province of Pakistan.
Ghulam bikkari need a dollars 💸 lol😅
@@baz4566 But who will stop them in pakhtoon areas they have made huge slums outside every city of Sindh Punjab even they have made huge slums in Islamabad which was city without slums before them
Pakistan have hosted more than 4 million refugees for 4 decades....
Now Afghanistan have a government, its time to go back....
Go back to authoritarian sharia country?
they dont want that, especially the womens
Still this there home and they getting kicked out
@@RecondarkGames its not their home . Never was !
@@astronerd11 it is and who are you to say this
@@Isa46300well it’s not their home anymore
Stop worrying about Pakistan's issue. If you have so much problem kindly send them to some rich arab countries. They weree here since last 30 years. Our own economic condition is in shambles..
doha and saudi arbia is empty . i hope they will allow them.
Not 30, but nearly 50 years.
It started after the Soviets invaded Afghanistan in the late 1970s, that's nearly 50 years.
Not 30, but nearly 50 years.
It started after the Soviets invaded Afghanistan in the late 1970s, that's nearly 50 years.
Don't burn your neighbor's house or they will come to your house! I am sure you guys are young to talk, about 30 or 50 years! Pakistan itself is 70 years old! Pakistan's Punjab, and Sind is a centre of terrorism created by east India company to serve the colonial ambitions of western powers. The Pakistan military and establishment is supported, trained, and funded by the British. The brits divided two nations "India and Afghanistan" to make up for a base that can continue terrorist operations. This is no longer the case for Pakistan! They can't milk the western governments anymore and can't create "terrorism" to attract funding from the west. The new world powers in Asia are China, Russia and India who are aware of Pakistan's existence! Propaganda against poor people of Afghanistan no longer works. The whole world knows that Pakistan is a terrorist training camp! from extremist Arabs, to being a base for extremist groups, and the leader of Al Qaida! So, everyone knows what Pakistan military is doing! Pakistan will and is in the verge of breaking apart! The military leaders are using the same tactic that right wing politicians use in the west use! blame the migrants for all the wrongdoing, shortcoming, and corruption of military. Good luck to the people of both nations! also, there is a long distance between Arab countries and Afghanistan! if no one knew geography! also, Parts of Pakistan historically culturally belongs to Afghanistan and Punjab and Sind is India! this is history lesson 101.
Kashf shabbir the economic conditions of pakistan is not detorated due to afghan refugees the economic situation of pakistan is detorateddue to the politicians of pakistan who r theif and due to aramy general s of pakistan who make islands after retirement in Europe so stop bhakwas pakistan eat dollars in afghan wars fro all over the world whole world know this
Now its time for Afghan refugees to take part in the development of Afghanistan.
Because it's their country every country has its rights
May all be free from sorrow and the causes of sorrow; May all never be separated from the sacred happiness which is sorrowless; And may all live in equanimity, without too much attachment and too much aversion, And live believing in the equality of all that lives. --Traditional Buddhist Prayer
Should the UK be able to kick out all the Pakistanis ?
No didn't think so........double standards again !
Because the Generals in Pakistan were instructed to do so by their Bosses in Washington in order to put pressure on the Taliban government
Not this one sir, it's built half on India half on pakistan 😂😅 given the charge to 2 curupt families to steal and retire abroud
Yes but Pakistan is illegally deporting people and leaving them in the middle of a desert with no food water aid shelter or electricity Pakistan should not call itself an Islamic country but soon the Emirate of Islam will take over the Pakistan government as they did with the Durant border Zindabad Emirate of Islam Loy Afghanistan Free Imran Khan Free Palestine
Because illegal afghans without proper documentation are a security risk and have been involved in major incidences in the past
Have you forgotten your Ummah....
@@edytha2090 what does ummah mean according to you
It's not their fault. Nadra and our government should have made a better effort to register them in government records. Why should they suffer? We helped the US invade their country, and now we're kicking them out because we couldn't accommodate them? This is utter injustice for these poor people. Stop defending our govt and its policies.
It's a shame!
Gandu when your isi and pork army was feeded dollars then you wont say documentation and security risk now that dollar banned on porks army you are barking documents
@@edytha2090 these afghan never see any ummah when they boom themselves in public places of Pakistan
because its their country and they have right to do so
It's not lol your dumb they are terrorist and drug dealer
Every country should protect their borders and stop following every single international laws no need to follow every single international laws look at uk Canada France Sweden they are struggling because they follow every single international laws and give illegal migrants easy citizenships and now all are facing problems
Everyone criticizing Pakistan but you don't know that Pakistan has allowed them to stay for years,they opened their boarders for years since the beginning but now Pakistan economy is deteriorating and badly suffering as the population has immensely increased but their are limited sources of income making it difficult for even the Pakistani to survive
Now they have an independent state so they should go back and build their country
same in iran!
There is no war in Afghanistan now. US troops have been pulled back. I don't see any reason for Pakistan to keep hoarding the refugees. I don't see this illegal at all. Pakistan gave them sanctuary and it was more then any other nation did for them. These people should return to their homeland to help develop their nation.
The war on Afghans was imposed by Pakistan by giving arial route and ground supply to US. People can't simply leave their livelihood and move to other places. That's why there are international laws around refugees. It is not a layman decision. Plus Pakistan was paid by US and Arab countries for those refugees 40 years ago. So you cant just refuse after getting paid
@@mohammadkhan7895Afghan always in wars even before 1947 too. Now your country stable so why not go to there?
@@ikramulhaq7431 that is not true there was no war in Afghanistan prior to 1980. Please don't talk about something you have no idea of
No such payment was made
@@nomanhameed5835 there was. Look at Pakistan GDP. The highest growth was during Zia and Musharsf time. Such payments are not announced on media. The one such payment that was made formal was in relation to aiding people in Waziristan by after 2007 Pak Army made up drama of TTP. And we all know how Pak government used that money.
What about the 90,000 Pakistanis who they've killed in thier terrorist attacks in our country?
And also afgan government doesn't want to help Pakistan for eradicating bla terrorists Pakistan isn't an angel its economically weak .
@@abdulrehmanzahidshah there's just countless destruction that these criminals have done to our country, and yet they blame us for not hosting them, absurd!
Bro, The figure you mentioned which is 100% correct but those Number of Pakistanis were surrendered in 1971🤣🤣
@@jhouseoman bro your discussion have no sense and now it is confirmed that you are indian what the discussion is about and what are you talking about
@@abdulrehmanzahidshahwhat did u expect from him? Everything is a joke to them, just like their existence.
I am Pakistani pashtun and I want that every Afghan should be sent to their country Afghanistan. Take a visa bro!
Pakistan has welcomed and accommodated the largest number of refugees in the world for decades with open arms
Since US withdrawal Afghanistan is no more in a state of war, so its logical for people to return to their homeland
Exactly
Lie….Pakistan used to get money from UN for every Afghani that they have taken ….so u have not done any favour on them…but u did it for money
@@usa5682Every Afghan. Afghani is the local currency so its confusing to say money when you're talking about ppl. It's like saying every Dollar speaks English when you mean every American.
@@yasminea7149 ok
Pakistan is a British establishment 1947 in occupied Southern Khorason Afghan land. Pakistanis in reality are all illegal Indian settlers who were led by the British to illegally and immorally invade Afghan territory and they successfully occupied. Then Pakistan expanded just like Israel 1948 ! Pakistan has been ruled by western Zionist leaders since 75 years !
Islam, religion of peace. Qatar, Saudi,Iraq, Oman,etc.etc. must allow these refugees to stay in their own countries being Islamic.
If you won't help you neighbor solve their problem, then it will definitely be your in the near future
It’s been a problem for decades. They are going home, it’s a good thing
I am Pakistani but in reality feeling embarrassed by Government actions. I only ask Afghans brother and sister forgiveness by my side. May ALLAH protect my brothers and sisters who are being thrown out.
Why you feeling embarrassed?
They are illegal migrant n involved in robberies n crimes in our country ..
If you got too much sympathies for them better move with them
Apni baji dede Afghanio ko
Stop this BS. They need to go back to their country. Pakistan let them live as refugee during a difficult time. There should be an end.
@@ghazanhussain2070Afghan Allah ke Bande hai....sacche Muslaman gain who.....tumhare taraha jahil nahi.......Punjabi
@@EntropyInfo90,000 Pakistani tere baap ne mare Hain ya in dehshatgardon ne?
Taliban saying it violates law is hilarious
Ummah is long dead.
Sorry but we are not part of any ummah we are Pakhtuns and we are happy on our own side 😊
You are cow worshipper endian 🤣🐄@@Isa46300
Blasphemy wtf
@@prashpatel6436
✝️rash
Because they're namak harams
Thank you 👏👏👏👏👏
Thank you.
majority of fuckistanis are namak haram,even you dedicted your sister to the Americans, yes we are namak haram becuase we gave our air and land sanctuary to the american against fuckistan and still utlize our air and land sanctuary to the american against fuckistan.
what namak harmitub i show that we did against fuckistan?
A guest came, asked for refuge and you had let them stay for 4 decades but when everything was good and you told them to please leave voluntarily they just gone mad and accusing you of injustice....
We helped in everyway we could to liberate Afghanistan and we lost 90k Pakistani nationals in the process but Talibans just stabbed us in the back as they side with India and support TTP against Pakistan.
Al Jazeera should talk to the local Pakistani nationals who faced all these problems in these years.
I just don't get why these people are here to represent Pakistan?
It is a lie afghani refugees have been involved in political activities separatism have been involved in terrorist activities.
The afghan analyst called it durand line instead of Pak afghan border.
With this mentality you can't expect good will and openness
Should you not mention when they do leave they break their houses brick by brick and dont leave the building purposefully standing when they leave 😮
You want there bricks as well 😂😅 your dirty police already take there money and jewlary, no shame, PanjabiStan
@@zachazia443don’t worry, they are coming home. You can enioy their company :)
Afghan namakharaam
As a Muslim African we condemn this Pakistani unIslamic and hostile move. This is a unIslamic move.
💯 👍🇦🇫
Bring them all to your country NOT our !
You are Afghan!
Pakistan have given refuge to all those skilled Turkmen Afghan who makes Afghan carpet. In addition, it has given refuge to all the elites and entrepreneurs who have created jobs there. They are sending Afghans who are poor and needy. This is against Allah's command to migrate and the Sunnah of the Prophet PUBH to welcome refugees. Their strategy is not Islamic but purely economical for worldly gain. Anyway they fail to realize that when you do good - God returns in abundances. Their strategies are purely materialistic . So, let them have their plans, God too has a plan and God is the best of planners.
Earning money is not haram and Secondly it's they are liability providing nothing to economy so shutup
Firstly, these people are not registered, and have been here for over 20 years. Secondly, we are supposed to help the poor and needy who don't bite our hands.
You should tell this to Saudi Arabia, they might take them in
So you mean that Allah commands to perform terrorist activities and not expell terrorists? are you kidding me
The families should not be deported like this. As a Pakistani I am against the deportation of families with children. They have lived here and deserve citizenship and a good life.
on what grounds?
take those wahshis into your home
Will suadi Arabia , Qatar ,UAE grant citizenship even after living whole life there ?? No ! Right ? Then why is the blame on Pakistan only ?
If you are disheartened you can go to with them also
you can also get out of here we do not need Pakistanis like you, brainwashed idiots
The Pakistanis have been very hospitable and friendly to the Afghans over for decades. They hosted them they fought for them they fed them they treated them like equal citizens all need for the Afghans to turn on their own benefactors. And if that is not in gratitude at its best and I don't know what else is.
The Government gave more than enough time for them to get documented and be a citizen of Pakistan. But they remained undocumented and were found in terrorist activities. So Now the undocumented illegal settlers are being kicked out, which is the right of every country. And secondly, it's not only Pakistan, Iran, Germany and other countries that are also sending these illegal afghanies. Why no one talking about them?
It seems you didn't watch the program. After 2007, PAK no longer issued POR cards. Thus, there was no way fit them to obtain citizenship. Even if an Afghan man marries a Pakistani woman, he cannot obtain citizenship. Only an Afghan woman marrying a Pakistani man can get citizenship. Afghan men married to Pakistani women now must return, this will cause family separation.
As a Pakistani I feel bad for Afghan brother sisters and children. It's not the terrorist attacks as these were record high during ashraf Ghazi gov.
It's a action by Pak Army to arm twist Taliban in order to subdue them and follow US directions directly or indirectly by US owned Pak Army Gernails.
Exactly. These people have been living in our country for ages now. It's now their home as much as yours and mine.
How's the kabuli tea 🍵 !lol😅
@@iamzee111
Your Amy forced them from there country and used them against powers and Osama was a hero for your country and got billions of dollars on Afghans blood and and you people was celebrating and supporting Talibans for Afghans and you people want sharia low for Afghans but you people don't want it for yourself lol so too much to say but now you people blaming Afghans instead of fixing your wardi wala/Army so leave us in peace ✌️
Will suadi Arabia , Qatar ,UAE grant citizenship even after living whole life there ?? No ! Right ? Then why is the blame on Pakistan only ?
@@watchmelondon33 Either you're brain-damaged or you lack understanding because you have absolutely no idea what I meant. And about Sharia law, there is no country in the world where Sharia law has been practiced so stop with ur bullsh*t propaganda and get a life.
I hope next time Aljazeera news channel should invite well informed Pakistani officially representative with good verbal response.. for correction afghan refugee came during war , and now the war is over so they should leave our country. Most of these afghan refuges are involved in criminal activities . That is very concerning.. I should also add that Pakistan is deporting illegal migrants. But in phase 2 we will deport registered refugees too. Inshallah
Muslim Punjabi always afriad of Pathan....Learn something from Maharaja Ranjit Singh😂😂😂
@@EntropyInfoafraid ko Pthan How?
Pashtuns Are Also Pakistanis Like Us❤
@@MuhammadAli-sd2bo Punjabis are driving Pathan out of Pakistan........ Punjabi fear Pathans will overtake Punjabis in every field.....
Because American said to do that to Pakistan without American dollar just like Israel and Ukraine Pakistan can't survive
Yet Palestinians beg Israel and the United States to feed their people in Gaza.
Ain't no way a pratham is telling us that.
boring, blame the great satan
This is the simple truth people can’t get it
@@SatoYuqi12 he ain't wrong. You've been surviving on American aid since your creation
If someone was not able to return home in 47 years how can he settle himself in 6 olmonths? Now these decaying tactics will not work anymore.
This is against Moslem brotherhood and the Ummah. Why do Pakistanis give only lip service to Palestinians in Gaza, but when it comes to real help, they don't help their Moslem brethren Afghanis.
Because we only spit words. We have no balls to accept the responsibility for what we did and unless we don't learn from our mistakes we will keep embarrassing ourselves.
This is very sad to see Pakistan is doing this to poor people, blaming afghans for there failed government, that has never done its full term since it's birth 1947.
We are hosting them for fifty years still they hate our country and talk about breaking it everyday
@@ghazanhussain2070yes, they are born to spread hatred
Pakistan is not rich like Qatar we have lots of Pakistani poor people they need our help too
They are creating problems for us they need to go back to their homeland.
I stand with pakistan
01- The origin of the crisis is when Russia tried to invade Afghanistan in early 1980s and Afghanistan was a battleground of super powers including USA, NATO Countries, Pakistan and India. So, all these countries should come forward to resolve this issue.
02- These refugees have been in Pakistan for more than 35 years, Pakistan provide them humanitarian assistance with internal resources as well as from the support of International community.
03- Now, Pakistan think that some proxies in Afghanistan including TTP are the security threat to the people and Pakistan state, it has been proven that TTP has been involved in terrorist activities in Pakistan for killing civilians, security personnels and destroying the infrastructure.
04- Pakistan have been providing solid proof to international community that Afghanistan land has been used for terrorist activities in Pakistan.
05- International Community and UN should come forward and recognize the legit Govt. in Afghanistan to build peace, re-build infrastructure that has been destroyed during wars in Afghanistan and empower local people for a long term and long lasting peace and stability.
I think that it is foolish and mean of Pakistan to be expelling these Afghans, but the story is unfair in claiming that Afghanistan is dangerous for returning refugees. Crime is way down in Afghanistan since the Taliban retook the country. The streets are safer than in most parts of Pakistan.
Pakistan is a British establishment 1947 in occupied Southern Khorason Afghan land. Pakistanis in reality are all illegal Indian settlers who were led by the British to illegally and immorally invade Afghan territory and they successfully occupied. Then Pakistan expanded just like Israel 1948 ! Pakistan has been ruled by western Zionist leaders since 75 years !
Islamophobia is rising alarmingly in Pakistan.
Where are you from?
They (Pakistan) destroyed Kashmiri and Afghan people. My sympathies for Afghan people From Kashmir India
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Allow 1 lakh Afghan to live in Kashmir. After 10 years India and Kashmir won't exist..
May all be free from sorrow and the causes of sorrow; May all never be separated from the sacred happiness which is sorrowless; And may all live in equanimity, without too much attachment and too much aversion, And live believing in the equality of all that lives. --Traditional Buddhist Prayer
😂😂😂😂. You like them? You take them then? No? What a surprise 😂
😅😅😅1 lakh afghan live in India delhi@@aliso5987
Ashamed of my country. The most powerful muslim nation is not only forcefully throwing out Afghans but also refusing to provide any useful support to Palestine.
Most powerful muslim nation??
This is evil and unacceptable. As a Pakistani, I wish my government treated children born in Pakistan with respect instead of throwing them out.
Lanat ho pathano par
@@ghazanhussain2070 vo bhe Pakistan ka hissa hn... ye kya fuzool bkwas rhe ho?
Wrong timing from Pakistan!! They know Afghanistan is in trouble by so many economical sanctions and Pakistan is just adding more weight on them to deal with or want to twist its arm to obbey them,Pakistan had no problem for 40 years!! It's all too fishy from Pakistan's end. Very,very wrong timing!!!
We have more economical problems than them . We are always on the edge of default they are not
This is our own fault! Not there's! We dont have a backbone left! Always bent in front of the west instead of Allah!! There is barakat in sharing your bread if you have faith. Besides, Allah bless more if you make things easy for your fellow Muslim brother! Unfortunately, there is no morality left in our decision-making class!
Would you do the same with your brother? Kick him out of the house if you don't have enough to eat??? Ohh wait, that's actually what's happening in our society. How sad!!!
Allahuma Arhamni 🤲
Will suadi Arabia , Qatar ,UAE grant citizenship even after living whole life there ?? No ! Right ? Then why is the blame on Pakistan only ?
@@MK-qm2nu Afghans consider us as their enemy not their brother . Even Afghans are not allowing us to come to Afghanistan without passport.
Only illegal afghans are suppose to leave Pakistan
And this lady who says I’m from Pishin , yes she is, however, ask her what their influential family has done for the well being of the people of that area. They have accumulated large amount of money from that town and fled to Islamabad. Collected money instead spending again in that area were brought to Islamabad and foreign country. People of her own area are not at all happy with them and now she is advocating for the rights of Afg refugees. Shame
Pakistan long made profits off Afghan blood ! Pakistan and USA created Taliban to destabilize Afghanistan and assist western military industrial complex war profits !
Pakistan is a British establishment 1947 in occupied Southern Khorason Afghan land. Pakistanis in reality are all illegal Indian settlers who were led by the British to illegally and immorally invade Afghan territory and they successfully occupied. Then Pakistan expanded just like Israel 1948 ! Pakistan has been ruled by western Zionist leaders since 75 years !
She just admitted on live television Army is permanent power in Pakistan as if we don't know that already .. 🤣😆
no one discussing how many years we Pakistanies with open heartly host them even they were without any legel document although we are not happy with this decision bu we are facing serious security issues and afghan gov. is also no co-operating not any country allow any one without any legal document to enter 😘
Most of the comments here miss the actual point.
1.Even Afghans, including the Taliban, dont argue that PAK is not allowed to send the refugees back to AFG. In fact, now there is peace and stability in AFG and most of the refugees should return and develop AFG.
2. The problem is how PAK goes about the process and the Afghan man alludes to it.
3. The return should be better managed. 10K returnees a day is too many to handle and organize, especially by a poor and war damaged country like AFG. PAK doesnt work with the Afghan govt to better manage the returns like Iran and Turkey do.
4. The refugees should be allowed to take their property, vehicles, and livestock with them but PAK takes it all and only allows them about $170. That is theft and against Islam and international law.
5. On top of that, PAK forces every person to pay $830 exit fee, regardless if they return to AFG or leave for another country bc of asylum, etc. When they don't have the money, they jail family members or force them to take debt. This is against Islam and international law.
6. Even ppl with legal documents are forcefully deported, forced to pay bribes, or jailed and assaulted.
6. Due to the haphazard and unorganized manner of return, families get separated, ppl lose their children, women are returned while their husbands, sons, etc., are jailed or vice versa.
7. Instead of getting upset, Pakistanis should ask their govt to manage the return in a more humane manner so there will be less criticism.
8. Finally, the international community, instead of just pointing their fingers at an economically struggling country like PAK, should recognize the govt of AFG, lift all sanctions and help them rebuild their country so more refugees will want to return to their own country. The majority of Afghans wanting to leave AFG now do so for economic reasons and the west actually hinders econimc growth in AFG.
So long Afghanis. It was lovely having you over but its time to go. Godspeed be with you . Amen
Afghanis is money, like Kaldara or Dollars. If you mean the ppl it's Afghans.
No need to send kids womens and old people back
What will they do without their men ?? If war is over they should go and live happily there. They need to work for the prosperity of their own country. They live in Pakistan but hate Pakistanis and in return Pakistanis too have complaints.
This is all doing of the corrupt army generals and non-elected extremely corrupt politicians who are in power at the moment. Peoples' elected leader Imran Khan would never have have taken such steps, in contrast to this he would have given citizenship to these Afghanis/Pakistanis (which they rightfully deserve) as they were born and raised in Pakistan and are as much Pakistani as anyone else.
Because Afghanis belong to Afghanistan.
Afghanistan requires the collective effort of all its citizens to return and contribute to national development. The country is rich in natural resources and minerals, making this an opportune moment for Afghans to unite, set aside their differences and internal conflicts, and concentrate on rebuilding and progress.
Pakistan long made profits off Afghan blood ! Pakistan and USA created Taliban to destabilize Afghanistan and assist western military industrial complex war profits !
Pakistan is a British establishment 1947 in occupied Southern Khorason Afghan land. Pakistanis in reality are all illegal Indian settlers who were led by the British to illegally and immorally invade Afghan territory and they successfully occupied. Then Pakistan expanded just like Israel 1948 ! Pakistan has been ruled by western Zionist leaders since 75 years !
Pak itself are struggling with cost of living.
Afghan should thanks Pak for their decads of hosting despite of their own problem.
Pakistan is a British establishment 1947 in occupied Southern Khorason Afghan land. Pakistanis in reality are all illegal Indian settlers who were led by the British to illegally and immorally invade Afghan territory and they successfully occupied. Then Pakistan expanded just like Israel 1948 ! Pakistan has been ruled by western Zionist leaders since 75 years !
Pakistan's conspiratorial establishment has settled Afghans in Karachi, Hyderabad and other Sindh regions, especially to convert Sindhis into a minority, which has been going on for years. These foreign Afghans are involved in drug and illegal arms trade, kidnapping, terrorism. Occupy the land, occupy the business of the Sindhi people. The Government of Pakistan is patronizing foreign Afghans. Sindh is severely affected but sadly, There is no representation of Sindh in this program. No political leader who was agitating in Sindh to expel foreigners and no civil society person of Sindh was taken a stand, this is shameful, this is not journalism but complete terrorism. Due to illegal foreigners in Sindh, Sindhi people are being massacred like Palestinians, in this process your broadcasting world TV channel is also involved.
Strongly agree sir but comparing palestine with sindh is an exceptionally bold statement u r comparing us with a nation that has been victim of genocide for more then 7 decades.....
asan ja pehnja afal ehra hin stop blaming others pathan sindh mai rozgar lai lade tha achan rozgar aahe tadehn tha achan ni asan wara sindhi hotel te wehi sajo dehn zaya kanda and at the end they would blame punjabis and pakistan for being poor that's absurd
Pakistan long made profits off Afghan blood ! Pakistan and USA created Taliban to destabilize Afghanistan and assist western military industrial complex war profits !
Pakistan is a British establishment 1947 in occupied Southern Khorason Afghan land. Pakistanis in reality are all illegal Indian settlers who were led by the British to illegally and immorally invade Afghan territory and they successfully occupied. Then Pakistan expanded just like Israel 1948 ! Pakistan has been ruled by western Zionist leaders since 75 years !
Pakistan long made profits off Afghan blood ! Pakistan and USA created Taliban to destabilize Afghanistan and assist western military industrial complex war profits !
Pakistan is a British establishment 1947 in occupied Southern Khorason Afghan land. Pakistanis in reality are all illegal Indian settlers who were led by the British to illegally and immorally invade Afghan territory and they successfully occupied. Then Pakistan expanded just like Israel 1948 ! Pakistan has been ruled by western Zionist leaders since 75 years !
Either you are with us or with our enemies, ball is in afghanistan court now.. We can not tolerate double policies anymore..
I have never seen such a biased program. shame on Al Jazeera
Because AlJazeera usually spits bias against non Muslim countries, so it's viewers are fine with it. But this is a unique situation where its a Muslim vs Muslim.
Pakistan is a British establishment 1947 in occupied Southern Khorason Afghan land. Pakistanis in reality are all illegal Indian settlers who were led by the British to illegally and immorally invade Afghan territory and they successfully occupied. Then Pakistan expanded just like Israel 1948 ! Pakistan has been ruled by western Zionist leaders since 75 years !
Lol Nolfar knows nothing about the Afghan problem she looks like a clown and very contradictory. Lol
What international law is being violated here?
Rich, Qatar and the other gulf countries criticising others. How many refugees have they taken in? Nil! Even an expat who has spent his whole life in the gulf countries has zero rights.
When we dont go to other countries we do it to eachother
As a Pakistani, i think our government must take some good steps for the rights of those afghan refugees who have been living here in pakistan since 30 to 40 years .....
Forced evacuation of those refugees is not a good idea......
Thank God , all the Pakistanis are talking sense and talking about Afghan expulsion .
Pakistanis, not only Pashtuns but all nations, are one of the best people in the world. But Pakistani governments always have Afghans for 2 major reasons.1- to use Afghan refugees against Afghan governments to destabilize Afghanistan, even turn into Pakistani fifth state.2--- to get tens of billions of $ from different international sources apparently for Afghan refuges.
It’s because Pakistan is a client state. It can’t survive without begging the west for aid. Even if they have to manufacture a problem and sell them the solution. Truly the most despicable government
I think Pakistan Vs Afghanistan is not Jews Vs Muslim, is it Muslim Vs Muslim???
afghan citizens are involved in mostly terrorist attack in pakistan.
I think because Afghanistan now is safe under taliban
Your deporting afghans with Pak nationality
@@afghanman2155anyone with Pak nationality cannot be deported
@@afghanman2155 that’s just more of a propaganda. The main concern is that there are afghans who were born in Pakistan and should have given Pakistani Nationality in accordance to the Pakistani law, but Pakistani government argument is that when they agreed on hosting refugees they made it clear that their nationality laws will not apply to them and they will have to leave once the war is over.
Doha and Dubai can take these Afghans.
fun fact, pakistan supported the talib terrorists for decades, but now the old friend is now a enemy.....thats karma!!!
Imagine Europe doing that and the whole world goes crazy with violent protests.
That’s the price of being Europe. Nothing is free in this world. You should know that by now
why would Europe do that??? europe attacks muslim nation and it's the responsibility of Europe to take rafugees.
Europe doesn't have guts.
@@ridhamatri9447 Mozart was black. Medieval knights were black. In the future, all Europeans will once again be black.
This issue of Afghan refugees needs to be seen in it's factual perspective.
Back in late seventies, millions of these brethren refugees were welcomed here.
Now, the realities are almost completely changed. From the last couple of years, Pakistan is facing worst financial crunch of it's history. Secondly, Pakistan is the target of a lethal campaign of terrorism, both in terms of loss of precious human lives as well as a constant threat to law & order situation and stability. Every time the responsibility of these inhumane attacks is claimed by the terrorist groups operating from the soil of Afghanistan.
It is because of these compelling factors, Pakistan is now left with no choice but to ask the refugees to return back to Afghanistan where there is a stable government of their own.
There doesn't exist any law called "International law ". If you are powerful enough then there is no International law to be followed. Israel attacked Iranian consulate in Syria and this Israeli attack was a brazen violation of International law. America after 9/11 attacked Iraq in clear violation of International law. The question is whether Pakistan should follow the so-called International law or ensure its security? The answer is very clear that the Afghans are no more refugees and they must go back to their own country and Pakistan cannot afford to bleed at their hands.
How could we justify the eviction of thousands of people who have been living on this land for decades? Our government should have made a better effort to register them in government records. It's just sad man!
Will suadi Arabia , Qatar ,UAE grant citizenship even after living whole life there ?? No ! Right ? Then why is the blame on Pakistan only ?
@@Ninipeall The countries you mentioned in your comment are not the ones we were told to follow by Almighty Allah. We must look after our brothers and sisters. How long before we stop fighting each other?
@@iamzee111 the brothers are sisters who hate us ?? And have doomed our name due to their terrorist activities ?? Due to whom we have been living in fear ?
@@Ninipeall should have thought about it before giving our land for the US invasion. What else do you expect? And you reckon they will start to love us for what we are doing now? It will divide us further.
@@iamzee111 it's the rule of the world that every country protect itselfs. Afghanistan should have been strategic. it's a simple fact that we can not afford war with country like US .Afghanistan started this war and they are the ones to take the whole blame.
It is shocking what Pakistan’s government is doing. It is very sad how they are pushing people who are living more than decades in Pakistan. It is unlawful and shameful they are forcing people from their homes.Afghan people have contributed hard work to stabilise Pakistani economy.They are lots of other security measures to put in place to keep country safe. ❤ Afghanistan
Marg bar Afghanistan
Yes its illegal to live in country without any documentation
what about terrorism?
They will stand still but again its Afghanistan.. but they need money, big things
I as muslim pakistani have no problem with afghans living in paikstan.Our security agencies have to rethink.Late general Ziaul haq if was alive and in power would not do deportation with the present situation.
Will suadi Arabia , Qatar ,UAE grant citizenship even after living whole life there ?? No ! Right ? Then why is the blame on Pakistan only ?
As a Pakistani, I must say that I disagree with this policy. This kind of mass deportation of Afghan families is unacceptable. As the panelists said, many of them have been born here and have been living in Pakistan for more than 40 years with established businesses and jobs. Even if some had to be deported, they should've had a strict criteria where those individuals were actual security threats but deporting in this way cannot be supported.
The newer arrivals of 800,000 Afghans since 2021 could've been vetted more strongly since they had not yet developed any real ties to Pakistan. Many of those Afghans who served in the security forces or NATO translators could've been sent to Western countries. But nobody has the right to disrupt families' lives in this way. But our "Permanent Powers" apparently don't care about humanity or human rights, unfortunately.
Because thousands of Pakistanis are waiting for there interviews different categories for USA but Pakistani were not given importance untill afghans started to be deported Aur send back to there home
May all be free from sorrow and the causes of sorrow; May all never be separated from the sacred happiness which is sorrowless; And may all live in equanimity, without too much attachment and too much aversion, And live believing in the equality of all that lives. --Traditional Buddhist Prayer
Your slave government is lying to you, it's not like that, it's about money, free dollars got cut off, they want to make money on poor afghans, these people wont forget how they were treated by so called Muslim country.
Pakistan and Afghans have always been one
This nationalism in the new generations has turned Afghans into Indians
Since when Pakistan and Afghanistan were one , it is only told by Pakistani military establishment . If you look at the history , Afghans only looted and killed ordinary Punjabi , Kashmiri people for centuries.
LoL your Ummah 😂😂😂😂
@@freeman4899 Totally agree
Afghans into WHAT?😂😂😂 INDIANS? seriously 😂😂😂 I mean can u please elaborate further,,,,,.
You son of angreez go to your court you well find out you are becoming second isreal to us
Pakistan has done great job for the people of Afghanistan. Now, Afghanistan is being normalize after wars and a government is functioning. No country of the world like Pakistan has accommodated Afghan people specifically after 1979 Soviet war. People of Afghanistan rush to Pakistan without documents and settled and most of them having Pakistani nationality permanently and i am the eye witness of many families in may area. Now Pakistan will welcome Afghan people those will visit Pakistan on passport like other countries and it is need of time and to counter terrorism and to stable Pakistan.
Strong woman from Pakistan, why international community didn't stop it in the first place.
Their country is still free, they can go now, these people have been living here for 50 years without visa or passport.I am in the force myself, many Afghani men and women are involved in Explosions Many are also caught who work for the RAW agency
Ohhh really the country who itself is rogue and their leaders who premeated and fostered terrorism and harbour terrorists organisation like taliban are blaming others good joke 😂😂😂
I am a Pakistani ex-pat who visited the country recently for several month. I had a chance to look at the reality on the ground. In all honesty, 99% of all security issues in the country are caused by the very people who call themselves Pakistanis, who otherwise swear to love and protect the country. The self-proclaimed patriotic elite creates the circumstances that that create lawlessness, corruption, and much social, political and economic turmoil in the country. The police and other government officials see their positions as venues to forcibly take bribes, harass innocent people, and create rule of the jungle. The powerful shamelessly use government resources for personal gains. All this in the name of the country. The Afghans, on the other hand, were mostly peaceful, most hard working people in the country.
They're worrying for those who are living freely in Pakistan with all their rights and how sad is that they're not worrying for the massacre which is being carried out by the Israel
Did others also notice how the host showed complete dissent and turned a blind eye as soon as the panelist from Pakistan, who throughout condemned illegal expulsions, tried to put up Pakistan’s view point and explain how the international community is to blame?
They still believe they should call the shots when the hostilities among many afghans against the general population of Pakistan (not the military per se) is on the rise.
Not only they deported Afghani refugee but also kept all their assets , money and allowed to keep 170$ to take with them. It's cruelty
They also force every Afghan refuge to pay $830 per person exit fee. Btw, It's Afghan. Afghani is local currency, like Dollar, etc.
@@yasminea7149 sorry My bad
Pakistan is a British establishment 1947 in occupied Southern Khorason Afghan land. Pakistanis in reality are all illegal Indian settlers who were led by the British to illegally and immorally invade Afghan territory and they successfully occupied. Then Pakistan expanded just like Israel 1948 ! Pakistan has been ruled by western Zionist leaders since 75 years !
Pakistan long made profits off Afghan blood ! Pakistan and USA created Taliban to destabilize Afghanistan and assist western military industrial complex war profits !
Pakistan is a British establishment 1947 in occupied Southern Khorason Afghan land. Pakistanis in reality are all illegal Indian settlers who were led by the British to illegally and immorally invade Afghan territory and they successfully occupied. Then Pakistan expanded just like Israel 1948 ! Pakistan has been ruled by western Zionist leaders since 75 years !
Maybe the US needs to take the ones who are at risk for working with the US during their occupation
Iran is also expelling afghan refugees. The thing is people expect countries with poor economy to host refugees in large numbers.
Why don't They have a legitimate government I don't see that 🤔❤️
The same reason why UK / USA deporting illegal immigrants. If UK / USA cannot afford these illegal immigrants, how come country like Pakistan can ? Pakistan hosted them for decades and I am talking about the lagrest refuges ever hosted by any country. This is extreamly poor coverage I have ever seen.
Ethnic cleansing 😢😢
Ehat kind of cleansing😂😂😂 you fool do you know what cleansing mean
I am a Pakistani...and I beleive this decision is taken soley by pak army...These measures are absolutely against himan rights...The world should take notice of this human rights violation...Also Afghanistans are same as we are..we are brothers...they should and must not be treated this way...
Laanti pathan
This is the only correct decision that the military elite made. Afghans must go back, especially because they hate pakistanis from core and they are taking over businesses and resources.
Take them to your home then
Shame on Pakistan
Shame
Lets pray the 800,000 have the intelligence to communicate the need for improvement and change in society for better living, yet still being true to faith in afganistan afganistan.
the Qatari have a huge hand in Taliban fighters coming to power in Afghanistan stop blaming Pakistan next they will sanction Pakistan
İts life is heartbreaking not like in Gaza
Y won’t Afghanistan citizens go to NATO peacekeepers UN Security Council Resolution zone
Why does any country expel illegal migrants. There are rules in place for residence visa. Just abide by the law.
Pakistan is doing right thing in karachi there are millions of afghani lives and doing unstable situations in daily life. now Afghanistan got freedom they should return to their own country they have afghanistani id card themselves not a single Afghani person who not visited Afghanistan once a year.
Such a shame on Pakistan .. 🗣🇵🇰🤮
No protest? People are suffering.
I am sorry, but this lady is clueless and talking bs.
Pakistan long made profits off Afghan blood ! Pakistan and USA created Taliban to destabilize Afghanistan and assist western military industrial complex war profits !
Pakistan is a British establishment 1947 in occupied Southern Khorason Afghan land. Pakistanis in reality are all illegal Indian settlers who were led by the British to illegally and immorally invade Afghan territory and they successfully occupied. Then Pakistan expanded just like Israel 1948 ! Pakistan has been ruled by western Zionist leaders since 75 years !
The Afghans have a right to stay in kpk and upper Baluchistan, because it’s a part of Afghanistan,We on either side of the now redundant Durand line. I may live on the so called Pakistani side of Afghans but I never want to force my brethren afghans to cross over to the other side. I want Afghanistan to take back the parts that was annexed by Britain in 1809, as the agreement no longer apply. My heart break when I see my own afghans in this situation
Old people and women’s should not force to leave , we should help them we should not treat them this due to taliban
This Pakistani lady is straight up stupid. Punjabi people follow establishment line? We had afghans live in our neighbourhoods for years. She is being racist against punjabi people who have always love and respected their pashtun brothers and sisters.