Funny thing is, Java is practically unkillable. Most if not all bad features can be modded out, authentication servers can be circumvented and replaced, and there's a lot more community history and attachment than Bedrock.
@@numizumi5131 If that happens the game will probably slowly fade into obscurity. Content creators pretty much only play java edition and if they axe it, then Microsoft's free marketing disappears.
@@numizumi5131 It be hard for them to make a case against the servers due to how they function in that it is held on the owner’s computer / server and not Microsoft meaning they are not on Microsoft area. Also though our accounts merged into the Microsoft account the previous contract players had is still valid meaning there is certain limits Microsoft can do. It is similar to a contract change when buying a house even if banks get merged your contract and loan remains untouched just under another company name. If they due push to do this and false ban somebody this would heavily breach several contracts with the player and server owners which could lead to a large lawsuit.
One motivation they have for keeping pocket edition as the main version is the fact that they can monetize it so why wouldn't they want to kill a version that is a one time purchase and make the overly monetized version that preys on children's money the main version instead
I think that's the reason. Literally every smartphone game (except for very few ones, these not including MCPE) preys on the user's money. And Minecraft Bugrock was originally a smartphone game.
Makes sense, and It also makes sense that they would literally remove the label (Bedrock Edition) from the main title.. The moment you join into your new account on Bedrock Edition or Pocket Editon you are BOMBARBED WITH ADS SCREAMING AT YOU TO BUY TEXTUREPACKS, BUY SKINPACKS, BUY THIS, BUY THAT.. and not Hey thanks for purchasing our game, I hope you enjoy!.. The advertising just completely reveals Microsoft's hand and It's fucking disgusting.. I wouldn't be surprised If someone from high management in MICROSOFT PAID Pewdiepie to make a lets play about their game to increase popularity and of course the return PROFITS WILL BE MASSIVE..
my biggest problem with microsoft is that they always wait for a big update and yet they still fail. They should focus on listening their community and make these updates regularly, so that people can adjust to them better
It's a mega corporation, we can't do anything about that sadly. Most megacorps don't even listen to the community and only want those $$$, but we still have hope for java edition to be THE version of minecraft.
There is one major thing you forgot about: They merged "Minecraft" and Minecraft Java into one purchase. And to play the Bedrock version, you must get the launcher from Microsoft Store. They also made the old launcher say that there is a better version of the launcher - which is bullcrap since there is virtually no difference between the two launchers besides the Minecraft Bedrock - making people download the Microsoft Store version, which, at least for me, hadn't worked properly when I first started using it (I switched to the OG one after two days or so) I've been playing Minecraft for eight years, and the recent 4-5 years have been a colossal disappointment. My will to play this game is starting to fade away.
there have been a lot of problems with compatibility of both lounchers. I am not sure how it is at the moment but if you download the new one you should have deleted the old louncher. Now its probably less buggy.
If the last 4-5 years have been a colossal disappointment, then I don't know anything that could satisfy your ungodly high expectations. Despite some annoying changes, the overall content updates Minecraft have received are nothing short of spectacular. Minecraft, content wise, is the best it has ever been. This video zooms in on all the miniscule, age-old negatives while ignoring all the relatively recent positive changes that Mojang, under Microsoft have accomplished. If your will to play Minecraft is fading away, then that is the fault of your receding nostalgia, not the game itself.
What did you expect for them to add? Turn it onto a Wow-like mmo or what? It's either a low quality bait or you failed to understand what minecraft is in the first place
I loved minecraft because it could be controlled by the player, you could make farms for every resource in the game and make huge structures to be proud of. But to me it seems like microsoft is making minecraft into less of a fun sandbox game and more of an adventure type game where the objective is to explore all the different crazy biomes and mobs and live alongside them. I liked it better when the player objective was to control the environment around them and make up their own worlds lore letting the imagination overflow. Building huge structures that overlook a simple sandbox world that you have redesigned to fit your preferences, That's what I loved about minecraft.
and they haven't even done it well either. There are tons of mods available, any one of which do a better job of making Minecraft an adventure game than Mojang has.
I think i would disagree with that, think of it this way, they’re adding more toys players can mess around with, therefore increasing the sandbox potential. Adding more biomes and mobs shouldn’t in any way or form disrupt your type of gameplay, you can stay on a single biome and not explore any others as much as you want. New content was really needed, there’s a reason why adding mods is so popular after all besides, if it really really bothers you that much, you can simply jump to the older versions lol. Edit: Oh and also, minecraft to this day has no clear objective or goal lmao, I honestly have no idea what you’re talking about now. Last time i played vanilla minecraft was about a year ago with a friend, the only thing we did was build our own little village, we visited other biomes only to acquire more blocks and killed the ender dragon so that we can get elytras.
How can you not do that anymore ? You can create your own world and control it. And if you feel you've been gated to some resources, you have creative. For me it's the opposite. Like, when you have some elytras and a few other blocks, you have NO in-game reason to go back to the end except for farm optimization and duping if you're into that. For an "end-game" location it feels so empty and useless. So I can see the argument that "oh, there's no point anymore story-wise or adventure-wise to keep playing", but if you want to have a sandbox game with no real objective, even the survival version is pretty good at that.
I agree wholeheartedly. It really hasn’t felt the same and I don’t think that’s nostalgia because even just a few years back it wasn’t so much. That being said nether, caves, and cliffs needed updating I don’t think they did any of the changes in a bad way, just really doesn’t fit how I grew up playing. I’ve owned the game since Alpha and I still play a lot but it’s so much different that it barely resembles some old versions I remember.
I hope minecraft survives and isn't ruined by chat reporting, I think one of the reasons Microsoft might want to remove java edition is because java edition players will always have mods that could to some extent undo their changes
Basically the encryption means, client messager and recipient must have the same encryption/decryption key, and to anyone else reading the message, it appears as complete ASCII gibberish. Even if you could report that message, what gets sent to microsoft is complete gibberish and nonsensical.
Since Farmes and Redstone are the things in Minecraft that I care about the most, and that those in particular are "broken" in Bedrock, means that I don't like it very much.
they are not broken. They work differently (smoothly, better) we java users are just to "lazy" to understand the smoother bedrock mechanics. I hope you know that you can move chests with pistons in bedrock :) i dont play bedrock but i hope java gets some things from bedrock actually
@@tommyIT im not sure how you can call it better when in bedrock edition something can literally work a different way the second time as it did the first time, and the fact that 2 different actions with a 1 tick apart difference can vary in which one goes first is just comical.
I myself hope they leave it alone and leave it to the modders to make updates and tweaks. All the past updates by Microsoft have been dogshit and not even related to minecraft a core aesthetic and philosophy
I've only been playing for a year or so but am too invested in Java edition. I tried the MS version and it felt too much like the "Free to play, pay to win" games you see being advertised on TH-cam all the time. I am not used to bedrock mechanics and ways of doing things that are different than Java or in java but not Bedrock. I doubt I'd make the migration over to MS should they ever shut down the Java edition. In fact, it might make me go outside and get a real life.
Same ,i started playing last year in august(33 years of age) when i went to visit my little brothers(10 and 15) ,the got me into it and we still play in the first world we started.If they fuck it i will just quit!
@@leadharsh0616 that was probably not the right word for it. But it was the pop-ups for points I earned and where to spend them in a market place. It cheapened the game for me. I don't need a market place, coins, reward points, etc. I am just happy to play MC and be left alone while doing it. As I think about it. Knowing Microsoft there will be a point where you'll need x coins or points to get access to features, blocks, the nether, or the end. And a monthly subscription to prevent pop-up ads, bigger worlds, just all the things that can go wrong will in the hands of MS.
@@TheFeralBachelor you don't even earn any points? And I've never seen a pop up. There's just one button saying marketplace and it apparently sings that someday Microsoft will do this and that. God some people of so scared of stuff that never happened and never will. I can't imagine making impossible scenarios in my head to denounce someone and make the whole community scared. "Knowing Microsoft" Lmao. If they wanted it would have already happened since so many years!
@@CrossUnity No one cares what you think. Your technicalities are out of the window for players who will do whatever the heck they want no matter what Microsoft dictates. Companies thinking they now own something just because they bought the legal rights to it from another will always be laughable. Gaming communities will always far outlive these "owners". The power of passion goes way further than hunger for money. Companies know this now, that's why they try so hard to take control of communities. Keywords there: "try". They will never succeed.
I think MC isnt dying , this new snapshot is giving a very good hope that MC is gonna make itself better than ever. Some guys those who like to live in nostalgia cant ever overcome the fact that everything needs to get changed over Time . we cant live in nostalgia whole life . (*These Are My Opinions*)
Some people simply play the same version for years without the doom snd gloom. 😂. Others complain because people don’t like it exactly the way they like it. I jumped from 1.7.10 to 1.16.5 two years ago, after investing 6 years in my two worlds, and, it’s true some awesome mods are missing, but I’m not about to go back for them. It’s not a contest, it’s a game, just enjoy it, that’s my approach.
exactly, these people are all kinda delusional. Unable to enjoy any game after playing shitty grindy games for thousand of hours... alone. It's just not for them
It makes perfect sense that they’d want to phase out Java Edition. Most of the customisation that you pay money to do on the Bedrock Edition is free in the Java version, ie skins. They’ll be trying to extract as much profit as possible, that’s Microsoft at its finest 😂
@@leadharsh0616 It nots just skins tho. Bedrock you need to pay for so many maps or pay for a realm, java world downloads are free and you can just make your own server.
At least now it seems that they care more about user response and feature requests and officially they don't want to discontinue either Bugrock or Java... Which doesn't mean that this video has no reason, quite the opposite, this video is important to remind us to keep the original Minecraft alive! I think that if Micro$oft decides to drop Minecraft Java I'll help to keep it up as a community project, just like many Linux distros are mainly or fully a community project.
Every feature added since 1.12.2 is fucking horrible. So listening to user response isn't always good. Esp when you have ppl from ages like 4 all the way to 100. So whoever you listen to, you fuck over everyone else not in that age range. And of course the younger ppl are more out spoken, so they always get their way. "Modern" Minecraft AND GTA Online are 2 good reasons why you don't listen to children!!!
My biggest problem is that the game has VERY BIG potential looking into all the mods the community had created yet they can not add something cool and use this potential. I feel like every mob they added lately is basically useless. Like Glow Squids, now the Sniffer is coming which will probably be useless as well, Polar Bears, not adding skylights, frogs. I sometimes look at the curse forge page and wonder: Why they don't want to work with any of those mod creators and include some of them into the original game? I do not say that every mod that is good fits the vanilla minecraft but they are definietely some that fits it perfectly
@@vladgrecu7816 not quite, it can smell the seeds of ancient extinct plants, and they’ve added horses from an ex mod dev, the end was from an ex mod dev, pistons were from a mod too. I will admit that things are setup a bit odd and scarily right now, but with what’s happening with ancient cities and ruins and the like, I think it’ll be fine.
@@leadharsh0616 true. I believe the actual problem lies in whoever is managing the game design team at Mojang. I believe the management team is forcing polictics on the game, such as climate change, animal cruelty, gender identity, etc. This, paired with the short deadlines, causes the resulting update to seem watered down or unfinished. CASE STUDY: The reason the nether update was so good was because of the fact that the 1.15 update was extremely small, giving them time to make 1.16 better. Another reason for the success of 1.16 is how the Mojang dev team was able to have full freedom with the nether as their canvas. They did not have to worry about climate change politics or "realism", since they were working with a fully fantasy dimension.
@@thetruetrident pretty sure the devs said that they were actually over exerted and pressured to add so much to 1.16 and that there never could be another similar update if they don't work like machines. Idk where the politics come into this, people here have very weird takes
I hope minecraft will never die. Because it is a Legendary game, I couldn't imagine having one day without knowing minecraft is playable. Worst comes to worst, if it does, then I'm gonna enjoy every moment of my time with minecraft and use the time I have with it well. 🙂
0:55 yes, absolutely. more money=more problems. I don't even want to ever get paid for my own uploaded content and if offered by any corporate entity or advertiser I will refuse and you can hold me to it.
Started on Bedrock due to having a Windows 10 computer. Purchased Java edition a few years ago and never went back to Bedrock. If Microsoft kills all Java updates, I won't go back to Bedrock. I have a feeling this will end in a class action lawsuit if Microsoft prevents the Java edition to work on the launcher or no longer supports getting older versions of the Java game.
honestly since they implemented that chat moderation, I've quit playing Multiplayer all together. knowing my rotten luck I'd be the target of some A..hole who'd want to get me banned for another immature reason. so I don't play Multiplayer, better safe than sorry.
Most large servers send your messages when you type. For example, on hypixel when you send a message it gets edited by the server (to add prefixes, remove words from their profanity filter and replace them with ****) so people simply cannot chat report your messages as the game thinks they are all sent by the server. They can still go through hypixel’s report feature, but that has been a thing since forever. You can always check this by hovering your mouse over the little line on the left before each message. It will tell you if the server sent it or not. Server messages cannot be reported
There are many reasons I prefer Java to Bugrock but the main one is mods. Not custom worlds and skins like on bugrock but real mods that add new functionality and impressive code manipulations. Carpet mod would never exist if it wasn’t on Java.
I love Java version because it has the original logic of Minecraft, Bedrock version introduce a lot of strange things that trasform Minecraft into an other game
"Embrace, extend, and extinguish" (EEE), also known as "embrace, extend, and exterminate", is a phrase that the U.S. Department of Justice found that was used internally by Microsoft to describe its strategy for entering product categories... ~Wikipedia
almost every parity change made to bedrock edition is to make it closer to the java edition, even if it means taking something the bedrock edition players like, for example the shattered savanna grass color. i doubt theyre killing the java edition and most of the developers still sees java as the main version
Don't worry guys there will always be unlimited amount of people keeping the game updated with whatever microsoft could add to bedrock edition by modding it in to the original Minecraft.
I hate how it feels that Mojang cared less and less about community opinions the longer Mojang was owned by Microsoft it now feels that the only thing we have a say in is the mob vote but with that said as long java edition is making good profits I think Mojang would be foolish to kill it
The only way they can truly kill it is by removing the ability to go back to previous updates. Some of the new features from the recent snapshots I really don't like, so I might just stick to 1.18, since I do enjoy the caves! I've been playing since 1.6 BTW, so I WAS around before Microsoft. I'm fine with the 1.9 PVP.
As a bedrock player the only thing they do on bedrock is monetization they don't care about community they remove bugs that we thought were features and then they say it was a bug but on Java edition we have crawling buildings above nether roof tnt duping and stuff that were bugs but community liked them so they kept it at this point Microsoft is killing Minecraft in general not just Java edition
I agree that Java is going to be going away in the not too distant future. It's sad, and if that happens, then I will probably stop playing. I just don't like bedrock, and this is my personal preference.
If it's due to Java being a mainly single core engine, I can understand why is seems like it's on its way out, but before that can happen, there needs to be more parity between both for the transition to be seamless. No falling through the world, no random deaths, Java's 0 and 1 tick pulses, movable tile entities, more optimization than to only match previous versions, LoD render distances beyond what's currently loaded, and the ability to play previous updates of each version, probably dependant on platform, are what come to mind for me.
I think like many other games, it will loose popularity but because it’s so iconic and resonates with so many people, it will always be relevant to a lot of people. With this in mind I think it’s near to impossible that it will die. However, I do agree that this game needs an extra set of helping hands and also to take their time with updates and to think about the most important communities, such as the technical and the explorers.
Concerning the 1.9 update: I think it's a good update. And servers can disable these 1.9 pvp things with just 2 (additional) lines of code or something in a plugin.
Is it possible that Micro$oft want to kill off Java Edition because of the modding community i.e. something they can't control the way they have introduced the other "features"?
Mods keep the game going. They won't shoot them selves in the foot. That's Nintendo's job. You want to see someone who actually hate their gaming community? It's Nintendo. They delete all fan variants and discourage modding as much as possible.
Honestly I don't understand a lot of people's complaints. People complain that there are hardly any updates but whenever there is one they just get mad. Even great updates like 1.19 (the warden is amazing). And people are complaining when 1.20 looks like it's going to be great. Also everyone wants Minecraft to change how it is but then they say how they miss the simple days and how it's worse now. Be happy that the game is still here and getting good updates.
I don't think anybody was complaining about the features we've actually got in 1.19. They were complaining about the false advertising, the poor dev communication and the report system. As for 1.20, I've only seen positive comments about it. I have no clue what universe are you from
I didn't say people are complaining about 1.20. I said people are still complaining about the game in general while 1.20 is coming out which as you said only got positive responses. And I agree about the report system.
@Shulkercraft bro, i think that the updates after 1.9 aren't bad, like, in the past, minecraft worlds and servers used to have a short life, like, the game didn't have a lot of content to make the players have 5 years old worlds, but today, the game has a lot of updates that the comunity wanted before, like the cave update and a wold generation update, and the combat update isn't that bad, in 2009-2015, the combat used to be "just click as fast you can", now the combat with mobs is totally diferent, well... the combat with players is kinda broken, like end crystals and others things, but the mid-game combat, like iron armor and iron sword, is a very good, it have more content. Conclusion: i think that the updates aren't bad, now the game has cool features, a lot of content and cool things to do, obviously things like the mob update and the account migration are bad, also the game price, because i'm brazilian, the real(R$) is less valued, like, 1 dollar is 5,19 R$, it makes the original game very expansive. So, the updates are good, but other things are bad. Note:the text got so big probably because i have attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD)
Not only this stuff happening but also the servers of Minecraft went down multiple times ever since Microsoft bought Mojang, before they bought it, Minecraft servers never went down once, and now in my country Minecraft servers have been down for the last 30 days and they still didn't fix the servers and I can't play multiplayer at all
Boys and girls it's time for us to stop blaming each other as for java or bedrock is better it's time to stay up together for your friends or foes to be able to rise up the once and great for all game Minecraft java edition from Microsofts bloody hands it's upto us to stand up and talk aloud for what is once out childhood memory and a real piece of jewellery in our heart so please I say please sue microsoft and what's joy if java disappears and bedrock exists all of those funny controversies surrounding the theories are gonna be alike so hope you all good and healthy and straight up get microsoft friked up
"Theres nothing the servers can do" FORTUNATELY, most server plugins (like paper) should provide an anti-chat reporting feature, and there are client side mods to disable it entirely.
Minecraft java edition will never die because us as a community wont let it.minecraft isnt just a game its much more ,its freedom an escape its a place where we can be anything we want or anyone we want without anyone stopping us and we'd never ever let it die because imagining a world without minecraft that almost brings tears to my eyes
If Microsoft eventually discontinues Minecraft Java, players will simply make updates for the game thanks to mods. No sane Java player would ever switch to Badrock.
I think that to achieve "complete parity" they will remove features from java instead of adding to bedrock. I personally think java is getting replaced with bedrock within 5 years because of missing features and general other things such as the store/marketplace
Microsoft probably does this because they need their 2.5 billion dollars back, and in bedrock they made an in game store so they can earn their money back if all the java players go on to bedrock and possibly buy minecoins
the video doesn't say anything really. The real reason is that you're growing up and growing accustomed to the old game. You're not a 12 year old forever
Java is one of the worst languages to code a g ame in. It's impressive that they got so far with it and it's still relatively good playable. I can sense the pain of the devs extending the game while trying to keep it performant. If they could kill Java tomorrow without a giant sh**storm, I bet they would do it.
i already knew things where going in the wrong direction when we required internet to play our solo worlds,all i will say they stop java then i stop minecrafting,i had this game for 11+ years and its sad to see wat its becomming
Honestly though.. the fact that bedrock is so easily accessible, has cross-platform, can be played on PC, is almost identical (almost) to Java, there’s no reason to play Java unless you want mods. I suppose the marketplace is the big thing this all goes back to. Otherwise, bedrock seems to be a clear winner. I could be wrong; if so, please let me know.
As a Java player on Mac, I don’t think they will kill it off for now, because if they kill it Mac users won’t be able to play Minecraft. So until they can properly port Mac users over to bedrock, Java will still be here, if not they will lose a whole player base. 😅 And since I’m aware that the game rules on both platforms are different, I’m not too excited about it. I like what I play currently.
yeah chat modderation as someone who grew up playing minecraft.Halo,Cod, and borderlands games i heard plenty of profanity and its just part of me. You cant ask me to censor myself because theres kids playing the game. alot of us were kids playing the game growing up and it was never a problem then.
@@Lassef3k a small company like mojang won't be able to offer free upgrades but Microsoft can so without Microsoft minecraft would be abandoned long time ago
although Minecraft is a classic game that has survived everything, all great things must come to an end.eevn if we aren't willing to admit it, there's nothing in history that hasn't died due to the company or the player base, or even just because it became bad in general.
I don't remember Pewdiepie's MC series being all that culturally impactful until late summer 2019. I'd give much more of MC's resurgence to SMPLive, especially with its many varied content creators and Pewdiepie's waning views. Hell, SMPLive is the starting point of many other popular SMPs later down the line like Dream's.
Stopped playing the newer versions about 4 years ago, but the old versions and all their mods are more than enough honestly. Been playing for almost 12 years, probably around 15000 hours total, and still one of my favorite games.
Bedrock is okay, but the drastic differences in game mechanics (redstone, anyone?) between the two has always prevented me from fully embracing it. If there was more parity between the two, I think it would only help them both.
Microsoft made C# programming language, specifically to compete with java programming language, since bedrock edition is made entirely in C#, it's clear they don't like to have a game written in java when they're trying to compete with it, i believe that unfortunately Microsoft will soon or late kill the java version
I miss all the old days after school when I would actually be happy playing Minecraft. All I feel now is dissapointment for the direction the game i following.
I dont really agree, because if you think of it, its not Microsoft that is deciding what to change its the developers, including Jeb. Do you really think Bill Gates has enough time to literally go through the updates of Minecraft. As a matter of fact Minecraft is getting better and better.
If java gets deleted, They're pretty much deleting minecraft itself. The reason why minecraft is still so beloved is because of mods, Servers and creative freedom.
I see and agree with some of the point in this video, but i have few problems 1. Pewdiepie being the sole reviver of minecraft is just wrong. Yes he was a part of it, but not the only one. 1.13 was one of the biggest updates ever. Overhauling the oceans and swimming, fixing big bugs (and giving new ones). Grian also joined hermitcraft s6, which ended up making the s6 the longest running season to this date. 2. Was the migration a bad thing? i doubt, it really didnt affect my gameplay at all 3. There were people asking for some sort of reporting tool. Could Mojang have implemented it better? Yes, there were problems with it. Is minecraft dead after Mojang introduced it? No, Minecraft is still very popular game. And if you play on a whitelisted server, you shouldnt need to worry about getting banned, because most likely you are all friends. And if you end up getting reported, reporter has to add some messages to proof that you should be banned.
With latest Snapshot which I think is nice we can't lose our track and forget about that how unfair and humiliating it is to have chat monitored like a Chinese city
i just need them to literally not shelve the second wave of the combat update that they were testing all those years ago, because some of the features in it were really cool like hoes actually being usable in combat like a fast switch weapon.
Microsoft is an information company, like Tesla Microsoft is collecting data from your computer, and now through Minecraft: What you've got, usage, what sites you visit on the web And other personal data Have you read the Microsoft EULA ? 🧐 I’m happy to play Minecraft off-line, ty
Personally, I was really angry abt the chat reporting but since other people were smart enough to realize how bad it was, no server has it enabled. Why do we need it when like every server has a reporting system??
I really disagree. Most people already have microsoft accounts so the migration isn't that big of a deal, and everything on the marketplace is optional. MCPE and Windows 10 edition still allow you to upload skins. Mods still exitst on bedrock edition too! Most of the complaints people have about microsoft are really dumb. Plus, Microsoft has been cleaning up the unfinished parts of minecrafts. Oceans are dark and bland? Update aquatic! Villages are ugly-looking, helpless, and not very useful? Village and pillage! Nether isn't that rewarding for how dangerous it is? Introduce many awesome biomes, a place to hunt for endermen, the best material in the game, and piglins! Mining is boring, get's repetitive, and materials became scarce near spawn once you mine too much there? Add many cave biomes and give worlds extra underground layers! People miss the beta days when lighting was crap and minecraft looked like a horror game in dark areas, there wheren't any beds to skip the night, and they where helpless from huge swarms of mobs so they had to hide from them? Add the deep dark, a city made out of dark materials like deepslate to replicate the dim feel of beta minecraft, and a terifying mob that guards the loot and attacks you for doing as little as making a sound! Disagree with the minecraft marketplace as much as you like, but it's all optional. And 4J studios left a bunch of minecraft content in Mojang's hands that they couldn't let get lost to history, and it's a buisness they gotta make money off of it somehow.
- Discontinue Java version and only focus on Bedrock. - Merge both teams and hire more. - Fix Bedrock and make it on par with Java. - Have the option for Java worlds to be converted to Bedrock without issues. - Release yearly updates with actual mod level content and charge money for it. (1.21 - End update €10,-). - $profit$?
Microsoft wants to drop java edition. I know for certain they won’t port bedrock to GNU+linux meaning they would drop support for it. This isn’t too concerning for me as I only play older versions of Minecraft but GNU+Linux users who like to keep up to date on minecraft may have issues
Microsoft's eternal attempt to destroy GNU Linux is reason enough for a software export embargo against USA, it is a far cry from fair play, fair trade and understanding that the need for technology surpasses the need for their profit. Microsoft and Apple should honestly just be expropriated and all assets forced open source to stop this destruction. Minecraft is likely going to be the legacy of video games as an art form, like the primary example of a video game, from the gaze of future minds. If they ruin this, they will literally be killing an important aspect of 21st century cultural/art history, however insane or silly that sounds. The Sillicon Valley trust fund babies already killed, reanimated, disfigured and desecrated the other contender, Dwarf Fortress.. Maybe world cultural heritage should apply to more than just buildings and paintings huh?
anyone else believe in java edition superiority compared to bedrock edition, especially considering how it's less influenced by microsoft and just has more options for the player over a group
Yes bedrock has gotten a LOT more love from mojang now. But as a bedrock player i still think Java is superior de biggest advantages from bedrock are bridging better cauldrons and for some people the combat system meanwhile Java a lot other exclusive features has
Claim your Starter Pack of 70k food and the EPIC Purpureus Dragon! Download Dragon City by clicking here: dragoncity.onelink.me/DDHl/shulkercraftJ #ad
Ofc
2nd babeh
Sorry, but I won’t download Dragon City
i subed
Inside of the game, how do we claim this pack
Funny thing is, Java is practically unkillable. Most if not all bad features can be modded out, authentication servers can be circumvented and replaced, and there's a lot more community history and attachment than Bedrock.
Agree
never say never
Once Microsoft kills Java and they sue anyone using Java mods for using the likeness of mine craft...
@@numizumi5131 If that happens the game will probably slowly fade into obscurity. Content creators pretty much only play java edition and if they axe it, then Microsoft's free marketing disappears.
@@numizumi5131 It be hard for them to make a case against the servers due to how they function in that it is held on the owner’s computer / server and not Microsoft meaning they are not on Microsoft area. Also though our accounts merged into the Microsoft account the previous contract players had is still valid meaning there is certain limits Microsoft can do. It is similar to a contract change when buying a house even if banks get merged your contract and loan remains untouched just under another company name. If they due push to do this and false ban somebody this would heavily breach several contracts with the player and server owners which could lead to a large lawsuit.
i will always prefer java edition because of the modding, its not as monitized, and i like the Redstone mechanics more than bedrock
Bedrock edition works good if you have no strong pc
@lyka sky 👍
Minecraft has been through a lot of crisis and it hasn't died. I'm sure it will survive this and much more
So true
Straight on facts
It died in like 2015 and it was revived by pewdiepie
@@iso-ossi thats the point. if it weren't for pewdiepie, the game would have most likely died
@@iso-ossi I don't think minecraft ever died. There were always people playing it
Java is unreplaceable. We must protect it at all cost! 😅
We will. Don't worry.
One motivation they have for keeping pocket edition as the main version is the fact that they can monetize it so why wouldn't they want to kill a version that is a one time purchase and make the overly monetized version that preys on children's money the main version instead
I think that's the reason. Literally every smartphone game (except for very few ones, these not including MCPE) preys on the user's money. And Minecraft Bugrock was originally a smartphone game.
Man i want the old bedrock edition back
That sound very bad. This is why I am a Java fan instead of a Bedrock or Pocket Edition fan.
@@shdz5984 this has nothing to do with java vs bedrock..
Makes sense, and It also makes sense that they would literally remove the label (Bedrock Edition) from the main title.. The moment you join into your new account on Bedrock Edition or Pocket Editon you are BOMBARBED WITH ADS SCREAMING AT YOU TO BUY TEXTUREPACKS, BUY SKINPACKS, BUY THIS, BUY THAT.. and not Hey thanks for purchasing our game, I hope you enjoy!.. The advertising just completely reveals Microsoft's hand and It's fucking disgusting.. I wouldn't be surprised If someone from high management in MICROSOFT PAID Pewdiepie to make a lets play about their game to increase popularity and of course the return PROFITS WILL BE MASSIVE..
my biggest problem with microsoft is that they always wait for a big update and yet they still fail. They should focus on listening their community and make these updates regularly, so that people can adjust to them better
Yea, they make big updates and then rush to push tiny updates that screw with stuff
They aren't caring about community. they are trying to make minecraft for everybody to play
@@waterfrogman yeah exactly
@@Ashmit6501 yes but everyone already likes this game. They should just focus on the gameplay and not some account migration thing
It's a mega corporation, we can't do anything about that sadly. Most megacorps don't even listen to the community and only want those $$$, but we still have hope for java edition to be THE version of minecraft.
Don't worry, I am sure even if mojang removed java edition, those Minecraft modders would add everything from new updates to version 1.12
@Анамє that's still 1.12, nevermind...
There is one major thing you forgot about:
They merged "Minecraft" and Minecraft Java into one purchase. And to play the Bedrock version, you must get the launcher from Microsoft Store. They also made the old launcher say that there is a better version of the launcher - which is bullcrap since there is virtually no difference between the two launchers besides the Minecraft Bedrock - making people download the Microsoft Store version, which, at least for me, hadn't worked properly when I first started using it (I switched to the OG one after two days or so)
I've been playing Minecraft for eight years, and the recent 4-5 years have been a colossal disappointment. My will to play this game is starting to fade away.
there have been a lot of problems with compatibility of both lounchers. I am not sure how it is at the moment but if you download the new one you should have deleted the old louncher. Now its probably less buggy.
If the last 4-5 years have been a colossal disappointment, then I don't know anything that could satisfy your ungodly high expectations. Despite some annoying changes, the overall content updates Minecraft have received are nothing short of spectacular. Minecraft, content wise, is the best it has ever been. This video zooms in on all the miniscule, age-old negatives while ignoring all the relatively recent positive changes that Mojang, under Microsoft have accomplished.
If your will to play Minecraft is fading away, then that is the fault of your receding nostalgia, not the game itself.
What did you expect for them to add? Turn it onto a Wow-like mmo or what? It's either a low quality bait or you failed to understand what minecraft is in the first place
I'm not talking about the new versions and features but rather the change of direction they're heading with the game
@@taruros what direction? Explain it properly please.
i really loved how Shulker finally got out of his 'child favorite persona' and talked about the elephant in the room it really hits hard
I loved minecraft because it could be controlled by the player, you could make farms for every resource in the game and make huge structures to be proud of. But to me it seems like microsoft is making minecraft into less of a fun sandbox game and more of an adventure type game where the objective is to explore all the different crazy biomes and mobs and live alongside them. I liked it better when the player objective was to control the environment around them and make up their own worlds lore letting the imagination overflow. Building huge structures that overlook a simple sandbox world that you have redesigned to fit your preferences, That's what I loved about minecraft.
and they haven't even done it well either. There are tons of mods available, any one of which do a better job of making Minecraft an adventure game than Mojang has.
I think i would disagree with that, think of it this way, they’re adding more toys players can mess around with, therefore increasing the sandbox potential. Adding more biomes and mobs shouldn’t in any way or form disrupt your type of gameplay, you can stay on a single biome and not explore any others as much as you want. New content was really needed, there’s a reason why adding mods is so popular after all besides, if it really really bothers you that much, you can simply jump to the older versions lol.
Edit:
Oh and also, minecraft to this day has no clear objective or goal lmao, I honestly have no idea what you’re talking about now.
Last time i played vanilla minecraft was about a year ago with a friend, the only thing we did was build our own little village, we visited other biomes only to acquire more blocks and killed the ender dragon so that we can get elytras.
And I kinda hate that everything is instant and easy to do. You building types want everything instantly when that's what creative mode is for
How can you not do that anymore ? You can create your own world and control it. And if you feel you've been gated to some resources, you have creative.
For me it's the opposite. Like, when you have some elytras and a few other blocks, you have NO in-game reason to go back to the end except for farm optimization and duping if you're into that. For an "end-game" location it feels so empty and useless.
So I can see the argument that "oh, there's no point anymore story-wise or adventure-wise to keep playing", but if you want to have a sandbox game with no real objective, even the survival version is pretty good at that.
I agree wholeheartedly. It really hasn’t felt the same and I don’t think that’s nostalgia because even just a few years back it wasn’t so much.
That being said nether, caves, and cliffs needed updating I don’t think they did any of the changes in a bad way, just really doesn’t fit how I grew up playing. I’ve owned the game since Alpha and I still play a lot but it’s so much different that it barely resembles some old versions I remember.
I hope minecraft survives and isn't ruined by chat reporting, I think one of the reasons Microsoft might want to remove java edition is because java edition players will always have mods that could to some extent undo their changes
Oh yeah facts
i have a mod installed that encrypts all server chat messages and wipes the client signatures. it is a fabric mod which i think has become popular now
It is literally called 'No Chat Reports'
Basically the encryption means, client messager and recipient must have the same encryption/decryption key, and to anyone else reading the message, it appears as complete ASCII gibberish. Even if you could report that message, what gets sent to microsoft is complete gibberish and nonsensical.
@@nithrakfiranahk3342 yea your right
Since Farmes and Redstone are the things in Minecraft that I care about the most, and that those in particular are "broken" in Bedrock, means that I don't like it very much.
they are not broken. They work differently (smoothly, better) we java users are just to "lazy" to understand the smoother bedrock mechanics. I hope you know that you can move chests with pistons in bedrock :)
i dont play bedrock but i hope java gets some things from bedrock actually
@@tommyIT brocken maybe the wrong word, but those strange things are the most interesting for me 😁
@@tommyIT im not sure how you can call it better when in bedrock edition something can literally work a different way the second time as it did the first time, and the fact that 2 different actions with a 1 tick apart difference can vary in which one goes first is just comical.
@@CH-su5vj that is or was a bug
can you send me a video of the current version where that happens?
@@tommyITbedrock doesn't have quazo connectivity so no its not better
If they ever even DARE to Abandon the Java Edition, i'm done with the game.
I myself hope they leave it alone and leave it to the modders to make updates and tweaks. All the past updates by Microsoft have been dogshit and not even related to minecraft a core aesthetic and philosophy
@@Masamune-JGb215 It would be nice returning to the 1.7.10 days where all my mods are on the same version
What a flawless sponsor transition
I smiled for once instead of skipping immediately, well done
Came here to say this. Love a well done ad intro. Funny enough to make me not click off
@@danielndibongo5048 me too
I've only been playing for a year or so but am too invested in Java edition. I tried the MS version and it felt too much like the "Free to play, pay to win" games you see being advertised on TH-cam all the time. I am not used to bedrock mechanics and ways of doing things that are different than Java or in java but not Bedrock. I doubt I'd make the migration over to MS should they ever shut down the Java edition. In fact, it might make me go outside and get a real life.
Same ,i started playing last year in august(33 years of age) when i went to visit my little brothers(10 and 15) ,the got me into it and we still play in the first world we started.If they fuck it i will just quit!
idk what is there for pay to win, because the base game is still the same price?
@@leadharsh0616 that was probably not the right word for it. But it was the pop-ups for points I earned and where to spend them in a market place. It cheapened the game for me. I don't need a market place, coins, reward points, etc. I am just happy to play MC and be left alone while doing it. As I think about it. Knowing Microsoft there will be a point where you'll need x coins or points to get access to features, blocks, the nether, or the end. And a monthly subscription to prevent pop-up ads, bigger worlds, just all the things that can go wrong will in the hands of MS.
@@TheFeralBachelor 100% right
@@TheFeralBachelor you don't even earn any points? And I've never seen a pop up. There's just one button saying marketplace and it apparently sings that someday Microsoft will do this and that. God some people of so scared of stuff that never happened and never will. I can't imagine making impossible scenarios in my head to denounce someone and make the whole community scared. "Knowing Microsoft" Lmao. If they wanted it would have already happened since so many years!
Even if Microsoft tries to take down Java, They can't terminate a community who has stood strong for years. They quite literally cannot kill us off.
They never will. Microsoft is nothing. We own the real Minecraft.
@@Bene_Singularis Technically speaking you're just wrong.
@@CrossUnity No one cares what you think. Your technicalities are out of the window for players who will do whatever the heck they want no matter what Microsoft dictates. Companies thinking they now own something just because they bought the legal rights to it from another will always be laughable. Gaming communities will always far outlive these "owners". The power of passion goes way further than hunger for money. Companies know this now, that's why they try so hard to take control of communities. Keywords there: "try". They will never succeed.
Even then there are something called cracked launchers
I think MC isnt dying , this new snapshot is giving a very good hope that MC is gonna make itself better than ever. Some guys those who like to live in nostalgia cant ever overcome the fact that everything needs to get changed over Time . we cant live in nostalgia whole life . (*These Are My Opinions*)
Agree 100% I like 90% of the new changes since Microsoft bought it.
Or you could just permanently play in older versions of the game if you're on Java
Update 1.20 will bring forth armor trimming and various other new features.
Some people simply play the same version for years without the doom snd gloom. 😂. Others complain because people don’t like it exactly the way they like it. I jumped from 1.7.10 to 1.16.5 two years ago, after investing 6 years in my two worlds, and, it’s true some awesome mods are missing, but I’m not about to go back for them. It’s not a contest, it’s a game, just enjoy it, that’s my approach.
exactly, these people are all kinda delusional. Unable to enjoy any game after playing shitty grindy games for thousand of hours... alone. It's just not for them
It makes perfect sense that they’d want to phase out Java Edition.
Most of the customisation that you pay money to do on the Bedrock Edition is free in the Java version, ie skins.
They’ll be trying to extract as much profit as possible, that’s Microsoft at its finest 😂
they already make millions and probably billions of people just buying the game
bro theres literally a whole skin curtomization section on bedrock minecraft which is completely free wtf are you about!?
@@leadharsh0616 It nots just skins tho. Bedrock you need to pay for so many maps or pay for a realm, java world downloads are free and you can just make your own server.
@@DrKnife-dy7xw you can make your own becrock server too and there are also free maps? Yk where? The same place as java!
at this point i would not be surprised if Microsoft secretly sold the Minecraft francize to EA
At least now it seems that they care more about user response and feature requests and officially they don't want to discontinue either Bugrock or Java...
Which doesn't mean that this video has no reason, quite the opposite, this video is important to remind us to keep the original Minecraft alive! I think that if Micro$oft decides to drop Minecraft Java I'll help to keep it up as a community project, just like many Linux distros are mainly or fully a community project.
What's Bugroch?
@@vinsplayer2634
I meant Bugrock, corrected it now.
@@Lampe2020 Oh, the one with the bugs. Yeah, thanks for clearing up the misunderstanding.
@@vinsplayer2634 Fact: Java has more bugs than Bedrock
Every feature added since 1.12.2 is fucking horrible. So listening to user response isn't always good. Esp when you have ppl from ages like 4 all the way to 100. So whoever you listen to, you fuck over everyone else not in that age range. And of course the younger ppl are more out spoken, so they always get their way.
"Modern" Minecraft AND GTA Online are 2 good reasons why you don't listen to children!!!
My biggest problem is that the game has VERY BIG potential looking into all the mods the community had created yet they can not add something cool and use this potential. I feel like every mob they added lately is basically useless. Like Glow Squids, now the Sniffer is coming which will probably be useless as well, Polar Bears, not adding skylights, frogs. I sometimes look at the curse forge page and wonder: Why they don't want to work with any of those mod creators and include some of them into the original game? I do not say that every mod that is good fits the vanilla minecraft but they are definietely some that fits it perfectly
Bro the snifer would be op if they add it. They told us that it will be able to sniff for an ancient city and then dig down to it
pretty sure literally half of mojang developers are ex mod creators like the person who made the aether mod is on there
@@vladgrecu7816 not quite, it can smell the seeds of ancient extinct plants, and they’ve added horses from an ex mod dev, the end was from an ex mod dev, pistons were from a mod too. I will admit that things are setup a bit odd and scarily right now, but with what’s happening with ancient cities and ruins and the like, I think it’ll be fine.
@@leadharsh0616 true. I believe the actual problem lies in whoever is managing the game design team at Mojang. I believe the management team is forcing polictics on the game, such as climate change, animal cruelty, gender identity, etc.
This, paired with the short deadlines, causes the resulting update to seem watered down or unfinished.
CASE STUDY:
The reason the nether update was so good was because of the fact that the 1.15 update was extremely small, giving them time to make 1.16 better.
Another reason for the success of 1.16 is how the Mojang dev team was able to have full freedom with the nether as their canvas. They did not have to worry about
climate change politics or "realism", since they were working with a fully fantasy dimension.
@@thetruetrident pretty sure the devs said that they were actually over exerted and pressured to add so much to 1.16 and that there never could be another similar update if they don't work like machines. Idk where the politics come into this, people here have very weird takes
I'm still waiting for the "Super Duper Graffics Pack" update.
Maybe Microsoft can fix this
I feel so bad for the new players that start playing on Bedrock and accept that version as the definitive version of Minecraft.
I hope minecraft will never die. Because it is a Legendary game, I couldn't imagine having one day without knowing minecraft is playable. Worst comes to worst, if it does, then I'm gonna enjoy every moment of my time with minecraft and use the time I have with it well. 🙂
0:55 yes, absolutely. more money=more problems. I don't even want to ever get paid for my own uploaded content and if offered by any corporate entity or advertiser I will refuse and you can hold me to it.
I‘m shocked how good the editing in these videos is. Great content.
Started on Bedrock due to having a Windows 10 computer. Purchased Java edition a few years ago and never went back to Bedrock. If Microsoft kills all Java updates, I won't go back to Bedrock. I have a feeling this will end in a class action lawsuit if Microsoft prevents the Java edition to work on the launcher or no longer supports getting older versions of the Java game.
I think that if Java edition is removed then from that point of time Minecraft will slowly but surely die.
Unfortunately, yes.
honestly since they implemented that chat moderation, I've quit playing Multiplayer all together.
knowing my rotten luck I'd be the target of some A..hole who'd want to get me banned for another immature reason.
so I don't play Multiplayer, better safe than sorry.
Most large servers send your messages when you type. For example, on hypixel when you send a message it gets edited by the server (to add prefixes, remove words from their profanity filter and replace them with ****) so people simply cannot chat report your messages as the game thinks they are all sent by the server. They can still go through hypixel’s report feature, but that has been a thing since forever.
You can always check this by hovering your mouse over the little line on the left before each message. It will tell you if the server sent it or not. Server messages cannot be reported
for someone who plays minecraft their whole life it was beautiful seeing milions of players playing in 2019 and 2020
There are many reasons I prefer Java to Bugrock but the main one is mods. Not custom worlds and skins like on bugrock but real mods that add new functionality and impressive code manipulations. Carpet mod would never exist if it wasn’t on Java.
I love Java version because it has the original logic of Minecraft, Bedrock version introduce a lot of strange things that trasform Minecraft into an other game
@Jordan Banks ye
"Embrace, extend, and extinguish" (EEE), also known as "embrace, extend, and exterminate", is a phrase that the U.S. Department of Justice found that was used internally by Microsoft to describe its strategy for entering product categories...
~Wikipedia
almost every parity change made to bedrock edition is to make it closer to the java edition, even if it means taking something the bedrock edition players like, for example the shattered savanna grass color. i doubt theyre killing the java edition and most of the developers still sees java as the main version
Don't worry guys there will always be unlimited amount of people keeping the game updated with whatever microsoft could add to bedrock edition by modding it in to the original Minecraft.
Reporting system can be bypassed by plugins or just not updating the server to newest versions. I hope they won't do anything about it.
It’s pretty much inevitable
I hate how it feels that Mojang cared less and less about community opinions the longer Mojang was owned by Microsoft it now feels that the only thing we have a say in is the mob vote but with that said as long java edition is making good profits I think Mojang would be foolish to kill it
The only way they can truly kill it is by removing the ability to go back to previous updates. Some of the new features from the recent snapshots I really don't like, so I might just stick to 1.18, since I do enjoy the caves!
I've been playing since 1.6 BTW, so I WAS around before Microsoft. I'm fine with the 1.9 PVP.
As a bedrock player the only thing they do on bedrock is monetization they don't care about community they remove bugs that we thought were features and then they say it was a bug but on Java edition we have crawling buildings above nether roof tnt duping and stuff that were bugs but community liked them so they kept it at this point Microsoft is killing Minecraft in general not just Java edition
I agree that Java is going to be going away in the not too distant future. It's sad, and if that happens, then I will probably stop playing. I just don't like bedrock, and this is my personal preference.
If it's due to Java being a mainly single core engine, I can understand why is seems like it's on its way out, but before that can happen, there needs to be more parity between both for the transition to be seamless. No falling through the world, no random deaths, Java's 0 and 1 tick pulses, movable tile entities, more optimization than to only match previous versions, LoD render distances beyond what's currently loaded, and the ability to play previous updates of each version, probably dependant on platform, are what come to mind for me.
I think like many other games, it will loose popularity but because it’s so iconic and resonates with so many people, it will always be relevant to a lot of people. With this in mind I think it’s near to impossible that it will die. However, I do agree that this game needs an extra set of helping hands and also to take their time with updates and to think about the most important communities, such as the technical and the explorers.
Concerning the 1.9 update: I think it's a good update. And servers can disable these 1.9 pvp things with just 2 (additional) lines of code or something in a plugin.
Is it possible that Micro$oft want to kill off Java Edition because of the modding community i.e. something they can't control the way they have introduced the other "features"?
Mojang wouldnt make the code so open. They have also encouraged people on making mods, custom textures and maps for many years now
Mods keep the game going. They won't shoot them selves in the foot. That's Nintendo's job. You want to see someone who actually hate their gaming community? It's Nintendo. They delete all fan variants and discourage modding as much as possible.
Dragon City should give you a Shulkercraft dragon!
Honestly I don't understand a lot of people's complaints. People complain that there are hardly any updates but whenever there is one they just get mad. Even great updates like 1.19 (the warden is amazing). And people are complaining when 1.20 looks like it's going to be great.
Also everyone wants Minecraft to change how it is but then they say how they miss the simple days and how it's worse now.
Be happy that the game is still here and getting good updates.
I don't think anybody was complaining about the features we've actually got in 1.19. They were complaining about the false advertising, the poor dev communication and the report system. As for 1.20, I've only seen positive comments about it. I have no clue what universe are you from
And free updates not paid DLC or a battlepass
People are so entitled it's not even funny...
I didn't say people are complaining about 1.20. I said people are still complaining about the game in general while 1.20 is coming out which as you said only got positive responses.
And I agree about the report system.
@Shulkercraft bro, i think that the updates after 1.9 aren't bad, like, in the past, minecraft worlds and servers used to have a short life, like, the game didn't have a lot of content to make the players have 5 years old worlds, but today, the game has a lot of updates that the comunity wanted before, like the cave update and a wold generation update, and the combat update isn't that bad, in 2009-2015, the combat used to be "just click as fast you can", now the combat with mobs is totally diferent, well... the combat with players is kinda broken, like end crystals and others things, but the mid-game combat, like iron armor and iron sword, is a very good, it have more content.
Conclusion: i think that the updates aren't bad, now the game has cool features, a lot of content and cool things to do, obviously things like the mob update and the account migration are bad, also the game price, because i'm brazilian, the real(R$) is less valued, like, 1 dollar is 5,19 R$, it makes the original game very expansive. So, the updates are good, but other things are bad.
Note:the text got so big probably because i have attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD)
Thank you for making this video, it's very important that all minecraft youtubers visit this topic atleast once
Not only this stuff happening but also the servers of Minecraft went down multiple times ever since Microsoft bought Mojang, before they bought it, Minecraft servers never went down once, and now in my country Minecraft servers have been down for the last 30 days and they still didn't fix the servers and I can't play multiplayer at all
Boys and girls it's time for us to stop blaming each other as for java or bedrock is better it's time to stay up together for your friends or foes to be able to rise up the once and great for all game Minecraft java edition from Microsofts bloody hands it's upto us to stand up and talk aloud for what is once out childhood memory and a real piece of jewellery in our heart so please I say please sue microsoft and what's joy if java disappears and bedrock exists all of those funny controversies surrounding the theories are gonna be alike so hope you all good and healthy and straight up get microsoft friked up
"Theres nothing the servers can do" FORTUNATELY, most server plugins (like paper) should provide an anti-chat reporting feature, and there are client side mods to disable it entirely.
Minecraft java edition will never die because us as a community wont let it.minecraft isnt just a game its much more ,its freedom an escape its a place where we can be anything we want or anyone we want without anyone stopping us and we'd never ever let it die because imagining a world without minecraft that almost brings tears to my eyes
If Microsoft eventually discontinues Minecraft Java, players will simply make updates for the game thanks to mods. No sane Java player would ever switch to Badrock.
You should definitely do more documentaries like this. I was genuinely disconnected from the real world when watching
Bro what 😂
@@BundaFiend i mean i was paying no attention to the real world seeing how good the editing was
Undo the chat report. Make cross play between bedrock and Java a thing so that you just download the hosts mods and whatever and ur in!
I think that to achieve "complete parity" they will remove features from java instead of adding to bedrock. I personally think java is getting replaced with bedrock within 5 years because of missing features and general other things such as the store/marketplace
Microsoft probably does this because they need their 2.5 billion dollars back, and in bedrock they made an in game store so they can earn their money back if all the java players go on to bedrock and possibly buy minecoins
2023- minecraft is dead..no one plays Minecraft
2026-minecraft is back again
happened once before
@@jeffthedog_2619 Hi josh
@@killianobrien2007 man what that’s crazy u found me !!
This really feels like it clarifies why I feel like Minecraft is feeling so different
the video doesn't say anything really. The real reason is that you're growing up and growing accustomed to the old game. You're not a 12 year old forever
100% totally killed it!!! Game sucks now. I cant even login properly due to Microsoft being weird.
@Abird Pilguy ok new gen cringe player who spends 10 hours a day on bedwars ruining everyone else's fun
Tell me you suck without telling me you suck
Yea
lets be fr that transition from talking ab minecrafts deal with microsoft to the dragon city sponsor bit was so clean
Mods litrrally make the game so much better. I do like vanilla hardcore though.
Java is one of the worst languages to code a g ame in. It's impressive that they got so far with it and it's still relatively good playable. I can sense the pain of the devs extending the game while trying to keep it performant. If they could kill Java tomorrow without a giant sh**storm, I bet they would do it.
i already knew things where going in the wrong direction when we required internet to play our solo worlds,all i will say they stop java then i stop minecrafting,i had this game for 11+ years and its sad to see wat its becomming
I dont agree but great video
Honestly though.. the fact that bedrock is so easily accessible, has cross-platform, can be played on PC, is almost identical (almost) to Java, there’s no reason to play Java unless you want mods. I suppose the marketplace is the big thing this all goes back to. Otherwise, bedrock seems to be a clear winner. I could be wrong; if so, please let me know.
I agree 100%.
Mojang would absolutely remove the chat reporting feature after seeing community's reaction, but they didn't. Guess why.
As a Java player on Mac, I don’t think they will kill it off for now, because if they kill it Mac users won’t be able to play Minecraft. So until they can properly port Mac users over to bedrock, Java will still be here, if not they will lose a whole player base. 😅 And since I’m aware that the game rules on both platforms are different, I’m not too excited about it. I like what I play currently.
The Thumbnail doesn’t show if this video is about Java or Bedrock! Nice detail!
yeah chat modderation as someone who grew up playing minecraft.Halo,Cod, and borderlands games i heard plenty of profanity and its just part of me. You cant ask me to censor myself because theres kids playing the game. alot of us were kids playing the game growing up and it was never a problem then.
Without Microsoft minecraft won't be funded by now
What are you talking about? Minecraft was founded by Notch, so Microsoft had nothing to do with that.
@@Lassef3k a small company like mojang won't be able to offer free upgrades but Microsoft can so without Microsoft minecraft would be abandoned long time ago
@@mustafamasri6438 saying it would be abandoned is kinda rediculous given thats its minecraft but it likely would see far less updates
although Minecraft is a classic game that has survived everything, all great things must come to an end.eevn if we aren't willing to admit it, there's nothing in history that hasn't died due to the company or the player base, or even just because it became bad in general.
Minecraft is unique man😂
I don't remember Pewdiepie's MC series being all that culturally impactful until late summer 2019. I'd give much more of MC's resurgence to SMPLive, especially with its many varied content creators and Pewdiepie's waning views. Hell, SMPLive is the starting point of many other popular SMPs later down the line like Dream's.
Stopped playing the newer versions about 4 years ago, but the old versions and all their mods are more than enough honestly. Been playing for almost 12 years, probably around 15000 hours total, and still one of my favorite games.
A much needed video and a good video from you guys.
The destroying began in 2018 when 1.13 came out
They aren't killing it, they're executing it.
Bedrock is okay, but the drastic differences in game mechanics (redstone, anyone?) between the two has always prevented me from fully embracing it. If there was more parity between the two, I think it would only help them both.
1
Your first! I confirmed it
yep ur first
Microsoft made C# programming language, specifically to compete with java programming language, since bedrock edition is made entirely in C#, it's clear they don't like to have a game written in java when they're trying to compete with it, i believe that unfortunately Microsoft will soon or late kill the java version
If 1.20 is a combat update, Minecraft would feel better
fr just give us the damn combat 2.0 update already.
You can play the Combat Test snapshots.
if java and bedrock merge i will never come back to minecraft even after having played it for 10 years now
Minecraft was good when Mojang produced the contents with love
I miss all the old days after school when I would actually be happy playing Minecraft. All I feel now is dissapointment for the direction the game i following.
Even though I’m a bedrock player, I hope Java edition doesn’t get destroyed.
I dont really agree, because if you think of it, its not Microsoft that is deciding what to change its the developers, including Jeb. Do you really think Bill Gates has enough time to literally go through the updates of Minecraft. As a matter of fact Minecraft is getting better and better.
If java gets deleted, They're pretty much deleting minecraft itself. The reason why minecraft is still so beloved is because of mods, Servers and creative freedom.
@@hectic1830 yes, defiantly.
The way larid introduces the sponsor is so good😂
I see and agree with some of the point in this video, but i have few problems
1. Pewdiepie being the sole reviver of minecraft is just wrong. Yes he was a part of it, but not the only one. 1.13 was one of the biggest updates ever. Overhauling the oceans and swimming, fixing big bugs (and giving new ones). Grian also joined hermitcraft s6, which ended up making the s6 the longest running season to this date.
2. Was the migration a bad thing? i doubt, it really didnt affect my gameplay at all
3. There were people asking for some sort of reporting tool. Could Mojang have implemented it better? Yes, there were problems with it. Is minecraft dead after Mojang introduced it? No, Minecraft is still very popular game. And if you play on a whitelisted server, you shouldnt need to worry about getting banned, because most likely you are all friends. And if you end up getting reported, reporter has to add some messages to proof that you should be banned.
With latest Snapshot which I think is nice we can't lose our track and forget about that how unfair and humiliating it is to have chat monitored like a Chinese city
i just need them to literally not shelve the second wave of the combat update that they were testing all those years ago, because some of the features in it were really cool like hoes actually being usable in combat like a fast switch weapon.
"Embrace Extend Extinguish"... let us remember how Microsoft operates.
Microsoft is an information company, like Tesla
Microsoft is collecting data from your computer, and now through Minecraft:
What you've got, usage, what sites you visit on the web
And other personal data
Have you read the Microsoft EULA ? 🧐
I’m happy to play Minecraft off-line, ty
Personally, I was really angry abt the chat reporting but since other people were smart enough to realize how bad it was, no server has it enabled. Why do we need it when like every server has a reporting system??
I really disagree. Most people already have microsoft accounts so the migration isn't that big of a deal, and everything on the marketplace is optional. MCPE and Windows 10 edition still allow you to upload skins. Mods still exitst on bedrock edition too! Most of the complaints people have about microsoft are really dumb. Plus, Microsoft has been cleaning up the unfinished parts of minecrafts. Oceans are dark and bland? Update aquatic! Villages are ugly-looking, helpless, and not very useful? Village and pillage! Nether isn't that rewarding for how dangerous it is? Introduce many awesome biomes, a place to hunt for endermen, the best material in the game, and piglins! Mining is boring, get's repetitive, and materials became scarce near spawn once you mine too much there? Add many cave biomes and give worlds extra underground layers! People miss the beta days when lighting was crap and minecraft looked like a horror game in dark areas, there wheren't any beds to skip the night, and they where helpless from huge swarms of mobs so they had to hide from them? Add the deep dark, a city made out of dark materials like deepslate to replicate the dim feel of beta minecraft, and a terifying mob that guards the loot and attacks you for doing as little as making a sound! Disagree with the minecraft marketplace as much as you like, but it's all optional. And 4J studios left a bunch of minecraft content in Mojang's hands that they couldn't let get lost to history, and it's a buisness they gotta make money off of it somehow.
- Discontinue Java version and only focus on Bedrock.
- Merge both teams and hire more.
- Fix Bedrock and make it on par with Java.
- Have the option for Java worlds to be converted to Bedrock without issues.
- Release yearly updates with actual mod level content and charge money for it. (1.21 - End update €10,-).
- $profit$?
Still waiting for the red dragon
And all these updates were already in que in his mind
Microsoft wants to drop java edition. I know for certain they won’t port bedrock to GNU+linux meaning they would drop support for it. This isn’t too concerning for me as I only play older versions of Minecraft but GNU+Linux users who like to keep up to date on minecraft may have issues
Microsoft's eternal attempt to destroy GNU Linux is reason enough for a software export embargo against USA, it is a far cry from fair play, fair trade and understanding that the need for technology surpasses the need for their profit.
Microsoft and Apple should honestly just be expropriated and all assets forced open source to stop this destruction. Minecraft is likely going to be the legacy of video games as an art form, like the primary example of a video game, from the gaze of future minds. If they ruin this, they will literally be killing an important aspect of 21st century cultural/art history, however insane or silly that sounds.
The Sillicon Valley trust fund babies already killed, reanimated, disfigured and desecrated the other contender, Dwarf Fortress.. Maybe world cultural heritage should apply to more than just buildings and paintings huh?
honestly i'm survived minecraft survived so well under microsoft noting they have the capacity to entirely destroy beloved developers.
*cough* rare
anyone else believe in java edition superiority compared to bedrock edition, especially considering how it's less influenced by microsoft and just has more options for the player over a group
Yes bedrock has gotten a LOT more love from mojang now. But as a bedrock player i still think Java is superior de biggest advantages from bedrock are bridging better cauldrons and for some people the combat system meanwhile Java a lot other exclusive features has