2024 BMW X5 Vs 2023 Range Rover Sport: Which Luxury SUV Is Best?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 มิ.ย. 2024
- Today I compare a 2024 BMW X5 to a 2023 Land Rover Range Rover Sport!
Ask For Jordan: www.landroverlehi.com/
Ask For Brenden: www.bmwofpg.com/
Learn How To Save Time And Money The Next Time You Buy A Car: benjaminhardy.podia.com/learn...
Help Support The Channel: www.patreon.com/bePatron?u=52...
Second Channel: / @thebenhardyshow
Instagram: ben_hardypl
Facebook: @benhardycar - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
Bro, hatts off to you, you are the first reporer who brought this comparison,which i was waiting for almost year.
How interesting. I learned off road driving in California with the US Off Road team in a Range Rover back in the late 90's as an experience. What a great education it was and what a great experience it was. Land Rovers are impressive off road and for many years I wanted one. At that time they were the safest vehicles to own.
Love the review! Also, where are you filming?? The scenery is really cool with those mountains in the backdrop
Both Are Good.I Love The Exterior Design Of The RR But I Prefer The Interior Of The X5. I'll Take Either.
Own RR in Singapore. 60k miles. No complaints. Handles great. Looks great. Wouldn't change a thing.
Love your comparisons
great review
Here in Panama X5 all the way, non m sport x40i with none of the active tech is running around 100k, while the mid ranger RR is selling for 178k here
I've had both now - going back to RR Sport. Drive experience is like no other.
Drove both and went with an X5m50 over the RR. For under a 100k it’s Fuly loaded and performance on par with the RR svr that goes 140+. It’s a no brainer.
Current is 21 X5 great! RRS scheduled for Feb 2024 delivery, looking forward!
I have the x5 and love it. Range Rover is nice but I wouldn’t trade.
But have you drive both
good comparaison !
Ive had the range rover v6 supercharhed for 6 years and now wanna upgrade to the x5/x5m. i just wanna point out that range rover gets hate for no reason. people that never owned them, talk bad about the brand, never having lived with one. its atill gonna be my fav car. i had zero to none problems, it droves 90k miles perfectly- and it goes offroad like no other suv. Still cant decide between the SVR or X5M tho
X5 definitely
Just Bought my X5 Love
Hi Ben have you had the chance to try out the X5's new Highway Assistant? For long drives-- this feature may be very useful!
My dad is actually cross-shopping these 2 and the Cayenne so this video was very helpful! We already looked at the iX and might also give the EQS a look as we like the idea of an EV and the EQS seems to be a higher-quality vehicle compared to most of the other new Mercs. How do you personally feel about all these vehicles? I feel like the Range and the Merc are going to be the more luxurious ones while the Beemer and the Porsche are going to be the sportier ones. How would you compare the Cayenne and the Merc to these 2 vehicles?
The X5 is the better SUV. For a fully loaded 2024 X540i, which this is nowhere near, the price does not past $85,000. All X5s also come standard with air suspension on the rear axle, and if you get the X5M60i (V8) you get 4-wheel steering. When you have a top-of-the-line X5M60i, it includes 22" wheels, full 2-axle air-ride suspension, gesture control, soft-close doors, assisted-driving/hands-free highway driving, parking assistant with 360 views, heads-up display, 20-way power-adjustable seats, memory settings for the steering wheel, heads-up display (yes this is memory based), exterior mirrors, and driver and passenger seat, Swarovski glass controls, heated front and rear seats, heated steering wheel, heated arm-rests and center console, 4-zone climate control, ventilated and massaging front seats, full extended-merino leather, panoramic sky-lounge illuminated sunroof, illuminated kidney grille, bowers and Wilkins diamond surround sound system, leather dashboard, tow-package, I mean the list goes on. The V8 M60i also starts, yes, STARTS, at $89,300 and TOPS OUT at $109,280. You also get different driver profiles, remote start, remote parking, remote services with the myBMW app, digital key plus, AND 4-YEAR/50,000 MILES NEW VEHICLE WARRANTY AND 3-YEAR/36,000 MILE MAINTENCE INCLUDED. Honestly, I do not think Range-Rover or any other manufacturer compares to the performance and convenience features that BMWs are equipped with.
Now I can't unsee the halo elite energy swords
I bought a newish Range Rover sport to primarily take it off road. But I’m one of maybe half a dozen insane enough to do that.
Looked at both. Own the X5 and it’s the hands down winner. And if you spec a $100K X5 vs that $100K Range Rover the comparison really won’t be close.
I had an X5 MSport fully loaded and loved it. It was a rock solid SUV with great fuel economy. However, I did sell it as I got tired of trying to get inside and out. It needs to have the option of deployable steps and that would cure that problem which is the only problem with it in my opinion. I just drove a new Range Rover Sport and the drive is very serene and don't know when I have been in more comfortable seats. I found a Range Rover Sport Autobiography P440e that someone ordered almost a year ago and is not taking. I have put a deposit on it and looking forward to getting it. The quality of the materials RR uses is amazing as well.
There is no Autobiography P440e. It’s only on the P510e
I'm driving my 3rd X5. I have always been impressed with the styling of RR, but when reading all the owner reviews it is easy to discover that RR has serious dependability issues. This has never been an issue with BMW.
Its certainly been the case with BMW as well. Neither are good when it comes to dependability.
Me too - 4th x5 over 12 years and only a single fault. I do desire the new RR Sport but hear nothing good about reliability.
BMW X5 is a gem.
Where is the area you were testing this car?
I’d much rather have the RR! It’s my dream car! My husband owns a collision business so I should be fine just in case 😂
X5 is the better choice and cost less. Also, I've rented one out and was impressed.
RRS all day.
Status symbol/$ to 🔥/extra comfort/garage visits = RR---Driving precision/adrenaline/comfort/reliability = X5.
Had to play this at 0.75 speed as you talk so fast dude! Informative video though!
I Love em Both.
Currently have a 2021 X5 love it still enjoy driving it 2 yrs now.
But I'm a car guy and probably going to order sport specked out the way i want. Going to take a year to get though.
Waited 9.5 months for my 2023 first edition
Absolutely love it
Mine got built in 5 months.
I am 2 mo in, still in the build pool. No date yet
I am selling mine - Giola Green, Dynamic SE, black package, black roof and pretty much everything they had on LandRoverUSA. 100 miles on the vehicle, and sitting in the garage because I have decided to keep the fullsize.
@muayboran4life sounds like a nice one! You should have no problem getting your money out.
For me, the full size just seems too big for our 3 size family . Enjoy!
I live in Brazil and I'm considering both models. As the streets are horrible in Brazil, I think a lot about the comfort that cushioning can provide. Which of the two has better cushioning for bumpy streets?
Did you watch the video?
Ben, Your glasses look good on you!! Handsome 😊
why you lying bro, he is ugly
the bmw B58 engine beats everything
Next 2024 X6m vs 2023 gle 63 AMG
Engine & tranny response for driver feel. For sure X5, but if you dont care for that and want heavy with ultra luxury and being in the shop once a month then get the range
The X5 is ok ish but when you really want a car to depend on in bad weather then you have to go with the Range Rover Sport. And the design style of the range rover has just put it a leap ahead of the BMW. Oh and LR beat BMW in the recent JDPower appeal too
Just looked at both. Rover was at 20k over msrp. Went with X5 and ordered from scratch and had it in three weeks. BMW is the better choice with reliability and price….
not for me if I order the Sport it's cheaper than the X5
@@v12-s65 sport is what we wanted. They told us 18 month to get it. Had X5 in 2.5 weeks and love it. Will never go back to Land Rover. Good luck.
Much better
@@user-er7gx5sm6g I won't ever buy that ugly BMW brick. If I wanted an SUV I'd get a proper one like a Range Rover. Way more exclusive and nicer to the touch.
For me the new X5 is dead and I'm European, I grew up with several BMWs. Only valid BMWs are the 5 & 8 series. But everyone to their own preference
@@v12-s65 exactly 😊
That trim range rover should be up against the x5 M60i which would blow the doors of the rover.
Compared both when purchasing and ended up buying the X5 and pocketing nearly $20k. RR Sport just wasnt worth the extra money to me.
You’ll lose that 20k in deprecation though.
I think they are both good inside and out. But 3 things the X5 would win are reliability , residual value and safety.
I totally agreed. I had RRS, and I just couldn't wait to get rid of it because of so many issues. I will go with BMW
@@marypie5909 what model year is your RRS?
The bmw has one of the best reliability basically making it the most reliable German car
BMW reliability is no better. Non of the German manufacturers are, except for VW.
@thegamer4646 no VW is the most reliable of all the German ones. BMW, Mercedes, Audi, etc, ain’t that good at all.
X5 definitely has ventilation seats
I didnt see the window stickers
I would do the X5 over the range rover. One for quality and the second for performance. German cars are made to feel the road for safety. A lexus is driving in a tomb, not so with a German car - you are to feel and hear the road.
On looks style etc, Range Rover. And with the bmw engine it should be more reliable
X5 is my choice
So at which point does "minimalist" becomes "cheap and lack of features or design efforts"? Because, I counted quite a lot of "minimalist" when it comes to describing the Range Rover.
Went from a 2021 X5 to a 2023 RR Sport and I love both cars, but the Sport is a class above.
Must say that the BMW feels and it is faster and sharper, but the luxury and comfort of the Rover is way above everything in its class, even getting closer to the premium feel of Bentayga for a lot less money
I own a 23 RR in Eiger Gray, and have a 23 RRS in Giola Green on order. For someone who has owned several BMWs in the past (but never an X5) and let me tell you that the fullsize RR, and RRS are in a class of their own. I traded my 21 LX570 Sport on my 23 RR and the RR fit and finish is amazing and as good as Lexus. I6 in the RR is also quite potent and I have been averaging 22-23 mpg (actual) in my fullsize RR which is miles ahead of the LX.
Although I have had limited time in a RRS but looking at them side by side RR looks more cohesive in design and material choices. Also, not very common unlike the X5.
RR is like a bus
X5 it’s a real suv, you have everything what you need
@@eldismemushi X5 real suv hahaha.. can't even go off road like a range. Ska me range rover bmw jan vetura per fmija
Until some faults coming up 😂
Never skip leg day!! 😅
Gracious words are like a honeycomb, sweetness to the soul and health to the body.
X5 also has a 4.0 liter turbo v8 with over 450hp
I thought it came with 390hp?
2023 Lottery Win I Take the Land Rover Sport. I Can Dream, Can't I? (smile)
For the ones who keep repeating reliability, did y’all ever own one and was it new?
When the tail lights don't even line up on the RRS💀
BMW❤🎉
I’ve currently got both but the previous versions. I’ve driven both the new ones as loaner cars as I’m upgrading soon.
There isn’t a BMW on the planet that’s even in the same ball park as the RRS. One rides like a car and the other moves like a space ship - unless you tell it not to.
I have a previous gen RRS and came close to trading it in for a PHEV x5. In the end I just couldn’t pull the trigger - the RRS just felt more special inside, is more comfortable, looks nicer and has better steering and brake feel (surprisingly). As far as the price difference you mentioned, keep in mind that the current RRS comes standard with a bunch of the stuff that is optional on the x5 such as leather, upgraded sound system, adaptive cruise, surround cameras, air suspension, etc . If you add all that to the x5 it adds another 10k or so. Still cheaper than a RRS but the gap is narrower than it first appears
My biggest gripe with the new Range rovers are the seat controls. The main controls are on the door panel - which is kind of awkward but then you have to use the screen to adjust the lumbar! Crazy. Otoh, atleast they give you knobs for the climate controls whereas bmw now buries that in the screen
after having 2 X5s previously i jumped into the redesigned RR but ended up trading my RRS for X5 45e (too many issues) and never looked back (uk spec gets air suspension standard and a 50-mile electric range)
All the features that you mentioned as optional on the X5 were equipped in the test vehicle in this video (except real leather). In fact, the RRS lacked climate controls for the rear occupants, shocking on a 100K vehicle. Both cars are excellent. I went with X5 because of the type of driver I am (pretty much floor it at every light). I definitely agree that the RRS looks and feels more special. But the X5 feels so much better dynamically. Which is a must for me.
A better comparison (price-wise) would be the X5 M60i vs the RRS.
Don’t be afraid to choose next time 😅
X5
Good ❤
I would take the BMW X5 since I still have the one I purchased brand new in 2002 with 235,000 miles and it’s still running great with nothing but normal maintenance. When I am driving to work I see a shop with nothing but broken down Range Rovers, I would never buy one. They look good but the engine will not last.
Range Rover is much prettier but somehow I just feel like the X5 will give you an easier ownership
None on range rover trucks are being recommended because of extreme unpredictability
24 month waiting list 🤔
@@andrewg9236 There's a 2 year waiting list for the RRS ??
Don’t they have somewhat similar engines?
Land Rover please.
Im not an expert but shouldnt you compare range with x7?
I own a 2019 Range Rover Sport and recently built my 2024 Range Rover Sport which has a delivery date of April 2024. There is no comparison. The quality, feel and look of the Range Rover to the X5 is like comparing Chanel to Coach. Be for real. I had a BMW in college and have since graduated to the Range. Can’t see myself going back.
For me ist Range Rover the bigger SUV and more for driving in the Mountain, X5 is more sporty and for all street as well and not only for hunters in the mountain!
Man, I had a 2018 RR autobiography, the worse car I’ve ever purchased in terms of unpredictable unreliability. I’ll probably never purchase one again.
What specifically were the problems?
Ok we understand , bmw is fantastic, ans range Rover , in minimalist, thank you
Wait until 2024 when the Range Rover SV 606 comes out.
How you can compare cars with price 1.5+ times differ… why don’t you compare santa fe or cx90 with x5 too :))
Doesn't Range Rover source its engines from BMW? 🤔
YES
Only the SV.
The interior specifications of this Range Rover are among the worst they could have chosen: black piano & black leather.
Land Rover offers veneer options with brushed aluminum, wood, carbon fiber, and more than 10 finishes and colors of upholstery including tan, offwhite leather, alcantara and leather. But they optioned boring leather, I mean, black leather. 🤦🏻♂️
Why is the x5 always compared with the range rover sport, why not the x7?
Which is more similar in size, power and price........ Almost every TH-cam car reviewer does the x5 vs rrsport....
Sport is better
Regardsless of your preference, when you spend thousands of money to buy a luxury car, the least it should have is "reliability" - unfortunately that has been Rover's weakness for a long time, and BMW gives you that. I don't understand why Rover hasn't fixed it, so i would go for BMW.
If you like courtesy cars the Range Rover, if you want to drive the car you bought BMW
Suv luxurious
I would fork out the extra $17k, for the Range Rover, without a second thought, if I had money to burn. If I was in the market for a upscale SUV, I'd get a Cayenne.
🎯
x7
RR record for dependability is horrific. Cayenne is made by VW.
@@Davek111 Same old tired reliability comments?! Some data reference please. I own two, have a total of 5 others owned by friends, all love them and minimal to no issues.
@jimrothwell535 its easy to find.
Recently traded in my X5 for a Range Rover Sport . I absolutely love my Rover , both very nice cars but that X5 sat lower and drove too soft my likings .
Man all these luxury suns don't have ventilation seats I live in Hawaii don't need heated seats 😫👎
Range is beautiful but very big car. European customers make choose BMW, İ guess. İn North America and Middle East drivers like Land Rover🤔
X5 girl now
I like both very much. But I have 2024 X5 because of quality and price. Range Rover is very overpriced for quality they offer. Sorry... My view...
Range hands down
In terms of sheer beauty of design and aura of exclusivity, no BMW comes even close to the Range Rover.
If you want quality and no high maintenance bills you go for the BMW. RR is looking great but they have still quality issues unfortunately.
X5 is honestly a great product, just the range rover seems like its a half-tier above.
Let's get "BMW owners skip leg day" trending
😆
@@BenHardyCarswhich one is quietest to drive? If you are comparing luxury vehicles it would be a great idea to do a noise meter test at different speeds
I will take RR all day long!!!!
Agreed
Not really a apples to apples comparison. RR is fully primed and tested for off-road inc deep water ploughing. The suspension/engine are engineerged for off-road. The RR engine is also tuned differently. Not to mention in terms if interior space, RR is actually a "large size SUV" and not a mid size suv like X5. All the RR needs is all-terrain tires and ya can literally drive it thru anything. If u test drive any RR , ya won't go back to any BMW or Mercedes...
Source: Former X5 diesel owner and currently own '21 RR Sports with 25k miles and zero issues. Yes, maintenance is expensive but ya get real off-road capability in a premium luxury vehicle that's not just meant for soccer moms.
The RR sport is 4946mm long and 2209mm large and the X5 is 4935mm long and 2218mm large so how do they not compete in the same size category ?
sport is far superior
Should you not be comparing the X7 to the Range Rover?
I have narrowed my next SUV down to these 2 and will purchase in september, however, the 2024 RR Sport is out and should be compared to the 2024 X5, not last years model to this years model of different species. Ben if you could not get the 2024 RR Sport, you should have not done this video just for the sake of views. I stopped watching at 1:20...
Where have you seen the 2024 RRS? It's not due out before September, I think.
Range Rover is on a different leauge! I love the RR ❤. BMW vs Mercedes is a better comparison.
Sport and Luxury have had an entanglement then called it BMW
if you want to make friends in the mechanic, Range Rover is the option
Lease and get rid of it, no worries.
They have the same engine btw
@@donjalal no these ones don't
haha so original bro...not like the car just released
...because BMWs are renowned for their excellent reliability, right?