Rose Tyler is and will always be my favourite companion. Others may have had more interesting storylines but Rose was my first companion and I formed an emotional bond with her that could never be broken or bent. She's just the best!!
Rose for me is my favorite companion in modern who. She has everything that makes the perfect companion and I do like Billie Piper as the first modern who companion as well. What really won me over was the episode when she saved her dad and had to pay the consequences for it.
Like her or not,rose was the ONLY companion that not only reintroduced doctor who back into the world but also made new doctor who fans in the modern era
Say what you want about love and monsters, Elton's last line always cracks me up "big absorbing creature from outer space and you're having a go at me?"
Rose Tyler was a blessing and her character was wonderful, it was a shame to see her go off of Doctor who. I wish Rose's Tyler was still in Doctor who yet.
My favourite companion. I just love Rose sm and I can’t help but miss her when I get to S3 when I rewatch Doctor Who. There has only been one other ship that I’ve been as emotionally invested in a ship as much as the Doctor and Rose
For mine list, it’s gonna be Rose, Clara, Donna, Sarah Jane, Amy and Martha, Bill I understand some may find Clara being not a great companion but I just always remember the one phase, “Let me be brave”
Rose will always be that girl. So nostalgic, I love what she did for the DW brand and the revival of the show, so many great storylines and scenes also. My fave❤
all the way from their first appearance in Spearhead From Space, which was also Jon Pertwee's first appearance as The Doctor, and the first story made in colour.
@@SamuelBlack84 I’ve never actually seen pre-2005 Doctor Who as full episodes. Only in clips here and there. Understandable, given I was born just a few years earlier and had zero access to anything capable of showing them. Man, what I’d give to see Tom Baker in all his original glory.
I wished they would have included Rose's scene with the Dalek in "Dalek", basically. I think it was a really emotional one, one of Rose's best moments. I'm not convinced by all the scenes chosen for this video, tbh, but it paints a fair portrait of Rose, I daresay.
Recently met her at Awesomcon in D.C. Was a collaboration photo with her and the 9th Doctor!! Thing is, she was NOT blond and when we walked in I though she was a handler until I saw her face and she smiled, love her smile!! She totally geeked out over my Barf cosplay!!! Yeah it was a GOOD day!
No not Martha she was whiny cause she was friendzone due doctor pining rose was and her love was unrequited 1.rose Tyler not because of the feelings are the love for the doctor it was the fact that rose on that one fateful day came face to face with a monster and help him become a man again 2.Donna yes cause she was great for the doctor cause she was a mate no feelings she was the one that help move on from rose after he lost her and took away his loneliness.3.sarah Jane because she was great too but the doctor wronged her by leaving her behind with no explanation
I still prefer ninth and rose relationship anyway under the 11th doctor trope there is Official couple Ninth doctor (ROSE) tenth doctor and meta crisis doctor (ROSE) so technically tenth doctor was cheating in rose when he kiss Madame de Pompey in the girl in the fireplace
@@jsproductions8569 The lessons have become really heavy handed. Doctor Who has always had a message to it, but it's too much now. It seems to be in every episode and the dialogue is wooden. I watched "The End of the World" yesterday, the second episode with Rose in it where she sees the Earth die and they introduce The Face of Boe and Cassandra to the lore. It is so smartly written and Rose has this moment where she realizes she has no idea who The Doctor really is or what she is doing, how far from home she is. The current cast doesn't have those moments. There's very little development of characters and the dialogue is wooden. I wondered if I was just outgrowing Doctor Who, so I went back and watched episodes from early seasons and got sucked in right away. It was never about great special effects. It was about fun adventures and there's moments that are just so memorable. Even secondary characters who might only be in a single episode are memorable. Now, it's just really meh and it's lost me since Chibnall took over. I feel for Jodie since she is a great actress and she is a good Doctor, just at a time where the show isn't on the right track. It reminds me of Sylvester McCoy that way as he had the same issue. He was so good, but the show wasn't.
@@TheHockeyGuy Omg! You’re here! Love your stuff on both your channels. Totally agree on Chibnall and Jodie. Really wish she had had better material to work with. Love her energy/enthusiasm. Missing the Tennant/Capaldi runs. For me, those were the best. Capaldi didnt have the best material, but what an actor!
Rose, forever my favourite and my first companion I ever traveled with. Amy was a good one, and so was Clara, but you will always be my favourite one. 💜 Now that 10 is back temporarily, I can't imagine we'll get a Rose cameo too.
She was one of the best, Rose and Bill are my favourite companions. I really hope we get back to the stories of this era and not the awful preaching of the last few series.
Funny (or sad?) story, Billie Piper was at a comic con I was going to and I got in line to have her signature and I just froze and got emotional and left the lane hahaha. One of my greatest missed moment, I was so attached to Rose
That bit of The Satan Pit was literally the first bit of Doctor Who I saw. It's no wonder I got so attached to Rose and the Doctor/Rose ship (2nd strongest OTP for me).
Weelll, Billie Piper just said if the story and cirumstances were right she could see a possible return to DW happening. So theres a chance RTD will bring Rose back. At least i feel free to hope. ^^
He could have been in love with all of them... but we all know (we sense) that if he were given the choice to stay with one of them for life, it would undoubtedly be Rose Tyler. 🙂↕️🌷❤️
My favorite companion ever. Funny thing is that I only watched first watched Doctor Who because I thought Billie Piper was fine. I’m glad I stuck around even after though because it’s my favorite show 😂
Not saying this is legit a thing but something that raises eyebrows, same video comes out as Billie Piper says he's open for a possible return to the show
I think Billie Piper being a Doctor would actually be kinda cool and weird at the same time cause the Doctor had a thing for Rose and now he looks like her then lets say at some point they reunite that would be a very awkward situation lol.
Rose was the first true love interest for the doctor. I feel that river and the doctor wasn't really true love or not for the doctor at least. I hope rose comes back one more time.
I love rtd era and I freaking love Bad Wolf. I tried to watch moffat chibnall eras and I actually watched some episodes like the premiere of Jodie, Rosa and the ones with James Corden, somes with Clara but, I dunno, I prefer the way Russell's mind work ig lol I love Rose and Donna they both don't have the complexity of Amy and Clara and River pff she have a cool personality but creating her to kick Rose out Doctor's hearts? Lmao I'm so excited that RTD is coming back, the best news EVER
Rose wasn’t my favourite companion, and I still think it’s slightly absurd that the Doctor would fall for her so quickly in the scheme of his life… but she was absolutely what was needed, both for the show in a meta sense and for the Doctor’s character arc in having just come from the Time War. It just wouldn’t have been the show it was without Rose.
Maybe you all forgot the first song we ever listen at the first scene of Jodie as the Doctor: It was the Rose theme. Now, I understand there's a reason, we'll see again the Bad Wolf or Rose Tyler at the end of the 13th Doctor to say goodbye and meet the next Doctor that Russel T. Davis will write. I think it is not a coincidence cause BBC has called the showrunner has awake Doctor Who in 2005 to save the series or end it. Maybe Russel is interested to restore such elements of his old narrative style as Billy Piper, I hope she will not be the next Doctor... and back as companion and regular character.
I legit love how 10th Doctor doesn't even register that there are other passengers in the rocket when he thinks about destroying the planet. He's just only concerned for Rose! 😂
I feel stupid even considering this, but do we think that these daily updates are hints of things to come in Series 13? Cause this channel had never had consistent daily updates like this, so now I'm wondering...
"out of that whole pantheon, if i believe in one thing, i believe in her."
the delivery of that line leaves me breathless every time
25:46
❤
Rose Tyler is and will always be my favourite companion. Others may have had more interesting storylines but Rose was my first companion and I formed an emotional bond with her that could never be broken or bent. She's just the best!!
Mine too 🥲😞💜💜
Same
My favorite as well.
Same!
She's jarring as he'll after S1 for me
Wow this video comes out the same day Billie Piper says she's welcome to return to Doctor Who. What a coincidence.
Beat me to this by a second 😂
I thought the same omg
@@ospreyphil8995 Hehe, it's good to hear someone had the same thought as me.
@@TheConman761 Awesome, good to know there are people who think like me in this case.
@@foxymanaic5934 from that video that she put out today I think she’s 100% coming back.
Rose for me is my favorite companion in modern who. She has everything that makes the perfect companion and I do like Billie Piper as the first modern who companion as well. What really won me over was the episode when she saved her dad and had to pay the consequences for it.
“A rose by any other name would smell as sweet”
D'ya park the TARDIS on a meter?
@@theredstonebuilder1120 I don't know, but I hear it's awful at "parralel" parking.
@@theredstonebuilder1120 Did you just pitch up from Mars?
"I still ain’t bovvered!" Oh I love them 😄✨
Rose is always my #1 companion, Amy is a close second.
Like her or not,rose was the ONLY companion that not only reintroduced doctor who back into the world but also made new doctor who fans in the modern era
Russel T. Davies is announced to return, followed by iconic scenes from his initial run.
We see what you're doing, DW. 👀
Just finished watching bad wolf to remember Russel’s style, perfect timing, and a great reminder for an underrated companion
She’s not underrated, in my eyes shes the most iconic companion
@@peachy3135 agree
Regardless of if you liked or dislike rose and 10 or rose and 9, you have to admit Billie Piper is an excellent actress
Seeing her in other things like the Prince Andrew thing on Netflix, she’s brilliant.
How can she be so good after being a pop star?
The ninth doctor was the first doctor I watched, Rose was the first companion I loved straight away.
They’re missing some scenes lol, like Rose literally saving the Doctor’s life in the first ep
Say what you want about love and monsters, Elton's last line always cracks me up "big absorbing creature from outer space and you're having a go at me?"
The Rose theme by Murray Gold is a beautiful piece of piano. He has been missed and the series has suffered from the absence of his beautiful music.
Rose and Clara had the best themes IMHO
Best thing he did to doctor who was turning it from a cheesy sci fi british show, and turn it into a hollywood blockbuster.
I share your choices. Very sweet and tender.@@ACanOfBakedBeans
Rose Tyler was a blessing and her character was wonderful, it was a shame to see her go off of Doctor who. I wish Rose's Tyler was still in Doctor who yet.
Rose Tyler was my very first New Who Era companion. She is and always will be my favourite.
mmm Billie Piper said that she wants to comeback.'' What a coincidence'' hahaha. The signals.
Nice to meet you Rose, run for your life!
You have broken me. I Miss them every time I hear the sounds of the tardis regardless of the season
Rose with 9 was great. Rose with 10 was a love story to shatter universes. Piper and Tennant were fantastic and I'll never tire fo them.
Thanks for including the bit where Wilfred salutes Ten. Really, just the best.
I love Rose Tyler with my whole heart and not just bc she shares my name. She is so incredible I miss her
My favourite companion. I just love Rose sm and I can’t help but miss her when I get to S3 when I rewatch Doctor Who. There has only been one other ship that I’ve been as emotionally invested in a ship as much as the Doctor and Rose
I love Rose more than anything
For mine list, it’s gonna be Rose, Clara, Donna, Sarah Jane, Amy and Martha, Bill
I understand some may find Clara being not a great companion but I just always remember the one phase, “Let me be brave”
You haven't watched any Dr Who from before 2005 I assume.
@@Trev359 there isn't a viable way to watch the Classic Who
"Run you clever boy. And remember it."
For me it’s Rose, Ace, Zoe, the Brigadier; Sally Sparrow would be nr. 2 if she’d become a companion.
Personally I look at Amy and Rory as a package deal. Rory was just as much if not moreso a companion to the doctor as well
Rose will always be that girl. So nostalgic, I love what she did for the DW brand and the revival of the show, so many great storylines and scenes also. My fave❤
rose tyler was/is/will forever be THE moment 💕
I forgot how terrifying the autons were.
all the way from their first appearance in Spearhead From Space, which was also Jon Pertwee's first appearance as The Doctor, and the first story made in colour.
@@colinmoore7460 They were actually creepy in that story, not the modern versions
@@SamuelBlack84 I’ve never actually seen pre-2005 Doctor Who as full episodes. Only in clips here and there. Understandable, given I was born just a few years earlier and had zero access to anything capable of showing them.
Man, what I’d give to see Tom Baker in all his original glory.
@@TheOriginalEwan I was born in 84 and grew up watching the classic episodes. Sylvestor McCoy was my Doctor
They may be scary, but their ''leader'' is a big molten plastic head.
I remember watching the s2 with rose leaving when I was a kid and it being the first time I ugly cried
We've only got about 5 billion years until the shops close lol.
I wished they would have included Rose's scene with the Dalek in "Dalek", basically. I think it was a really emotional one, one of Rose's best moments. I'm not convinced by all the scenes chosen for this video, tbh, but it paints a fair portrait of Rose, I daresay.
I agree i think theres some good scenes missing from series 1 especially
Rose Tyler and Clara Oswald
The best companions from the new era...
Agreed. And Dan too, now we've met him, in my opinion.
They're both my favs, tying
I can't pick cuz Clara is so adorable and loveable and such good companion material
And rose is rose
Rose and Clara are my favorites as well, but I also loved Rory (Amy not so much)
@@ACanOfBakedBeans Why do you love Rory but not Amy? What's not to love about Amy?
Rose Tyler my favourite companion in doctor who
Recently met her at Awesomcon in D.C. Was a collaboration photo with her and the 9th Doctor!! Thing is, she was NOT blond and when we walked in I though she was a handler until I saw her face and she smiled, love her smile!! She totally geeked out over my Barf cosplay!!! Yeah it was a GOOD day!
Rose, Martha, Donna... the best
No not Martha she was whiny cause she was friendzone due doctor pining rose was and her love was unrequited 1.rose Tyler not because of the feelings are the love for the doctor it was the fact that rose on that one fateful day came face to face with a monster and help him become a man again 2.Donna yes cause she was great for the doctor cause she was a mate no feelings she was the one that help move on from rose after he lost her and took away his loneliness.3.sarah Jane because she was great too but the doctor wronged her by leaving her behind with no explanation
@@charlenerafferty3534 For a one-off companion, I loved Bernard Cribbins as Wilfred Mott. Only proves how great an actor Cribbins was. RIP
Rose will always be my favorite! She was an icon and I loved her relationship with The Doctor ❤🤗
I still prefer ninth and rose relationship anyway under the 11th doctor trope there is Official couple Ninth doctor (ROSE) tenth doctor and meta crisis doctor (ROSE) so technically tenth doctor was cheating in rose when he kiss Madame de Pompey in the girl in the fireplace
Rose Tyler: classic companion!
You upset my mum
Great big absorbing creature from outer space, and you're having a go at me?
@@IG7799-c4u No-one upsets my Mum.
Bring Rose back. Just do it. Bring back what made the show so great, good characters and grounded plots without a "lesson" for society.
I like the 'lessons'
@@jsproductions8569 The lessons have become really heavy handed. Doctor Who has always had a message to it, but it's too much now. It seems to be in every episode and the dialogue is wooden. I watched "The End of the World" yesterday, the second episode with Rose in it where she sees the Earth die and they introduce The Face of Boe and Cassandra to the lore. It is so smartly written and Rose has this moment where she realizes she has no idea who The Doctor really is or what she is doing, how far from home she is. The current cast doesn't have those moments. There's very little development of characters and the dialogue is wooden. I wondered if I was just outgrowing Doctor Who, so I went back and watched episodes from early seasons and got sucked in right away. It was never about great special effects. It was about fun adventures and there's moments that are just so memorable. Even secondary characters who might only be in a single episode are memorable. Now, it's just really meh and it's lost me since Chibnall took over.
I feel for Jodie since she is a great actress and she is a good Doctor, just at a time where the show isn't on the right track. It reminds me of Sylvester McCoy that way as he had the same issue. He was so good, but the show wasn't.
@@TheHockeyGuy oh ok. I get what you mean, and mostly agree
@@TheHockeyGuy Omg! You’re here! Love your stuff on both your channels.
Totally agree on Chibnall and Jodie. Really wish she had had better material to work with. Love her energy/enthusiasm. Missing the Tennant/Capaldi runs. For me, those were the best. Capaldi didnt have the best material, but what an actor!
Doctor who has always had lessons for society
Rose, forever my favourite and my first companion I ever traveled with. Amy was a good one, and so was Clara, but you will always be my favourite one. 💜
Now that 10 is back temporarily, I can't imagine we'll get a Rose cameo too.
She was one of the best, Rose and Bill are my favourite companions. I really hope we get back to the stories of this era and not the awful preaching of the last few series.
Well now that Russell T Davies is returning to be the next showrunner you'll get the wish.
Mines gotta be Rose, Donna, Amy, Rory and Sarah Jane.
I didn’t like rose, Sarah Jane was my favourite
Donna all the way for me :D
Clara because I have a huge crush on her🙃
I hope they’ll bring previous characters and Doctors back to the show. At least for a few episodes 🥺
Funny (or sad?) story, Billie Piper was at a comic con I was going to and I got in line to have her signature and I just froze and got emotional and left the lane hahaha. One of my greatest missed moment, I was so attached to Rose
My all time favorite companion. There is no one else other than Sarah Jane
RIP Elizabeth Sladen
Her name was spelled Elisabeth actually
Rose is still my favorite character she's my spirit animal I love her!!!!!! I need to get season 2 back at least!!!!!
Why does Rose have to be so cute?
She’s my favorite Companion and I have a few fanfictions of her being a Time Lady and the Doctor’s wife.
Those are my favourite types of fanfictions
That's a raver bit cringe, innit bruv
We're here for it 🙋🏻♀️🙏🏻
Jesus I cried again so many times.
That bit of The Satan Pit was literally the first bit of Doctor Who I saw. It's no wonder I got so attached to Rose and the Doctor/Rose ship (2nd strongest OTP for me).
BEST COMPANION ❤️
I hope series 2 of the ninth doctor adventures will feature rose from big finish
I love Rose Tyler
Rose Tyler>>>>>Any other companion in DW
Rose, Martha, Donna, and Clara. The best companions from new who. River as well but she was a part timer
Rory was pretty good too (Amy not so much)
What about Bill?
We need her back! 😍😍😍
RTD comes back and a rose video is uploaded🤔
Coincidence I THINK NOT
Probably a tribute to her as he's taking over again
Weelll, Billie Piper just said if the story and cirumstances were right she could see a possible return to DW happening. So theres a chance RTD will bring Rose back. At least i feel free to hope. ^^
@@anneb799 part of me hopes he doesn't. Cause if he did, it would have to be PERFECT or I would riot.
It must be 2005 again
She was the only one who is Doctor in love with.
What about River Song?
He was also in love with river ^^
River, Bad Ann Da Pop A Don, John Smith girlfriend, Susan's Grandmother, more
Grace, River, his wife on gallifrey, Madame de Pompadoure, Astrid Peth
He could have been in love with all of them... but we all know (we sense) that if he were given the choice to stay with one of them for life, it would undoubtedly be Rose Tyler. 🙂↕️🌷❤️
the fact the bad wolf speech isnt in here is a crime
"I have got a mole, I can feeling it between the shoulder blades there's a mole. That's alright love the mole go on then tell me what do you think?"
I love that clip. Too bad the channel didn't put it in the video.
Best companion with Clara
this was fantastic
First thing Russell T Davies needs to do once he takes over Doctor Who again is bring back the great Murray Gold. I love the music of Murray Gold.
You say bring back as if Gold was fired. He chose to leave to focus on his family
My favorite companion ever. Funny thing is that I only watched first watched Doctor Who because I thought Billie Piper was fine. I’m glad I stuck around even after though because it’s my favorite show 😂
Couldn't watch this if I tried. I would just drown in my tears or suffocate from the nostalgia
I cried too much. Not seen any of these clips since before season 11.
Miss her my favourite companion
She was more than a companion she was the doctors friend
I would show Rose my spaceship too.
I believe in Rose Tyler supremacy
What about her highlights? Jackie reckons her _"roots need doing"_ in the Rose Target novel, if that's at all relevant.
Rose
Tell the Doctor two words. Bad Wolf
Not saying this is legit a thing but something that raises eyebrows, same video comes out as Billie Piper says he's open for a possible return to the show
I love Rose Tyler i love i love i love my favorite.
How could they leave out bad wolf
She’s epic ❤
Honestly I could only watch doctor who with her as the companion
Imagine if Rose became the next doctor
omg now Im imagining a whole scene of 13 regenerating into Rose LOL
I think Billie Piper being a Doctor would actually be kinda cool and weird at the same time cause the Doctor had a thing for Rose and now he looks like her then lets say at some point they reunite that would be a very awkward situation lol.
In the Whoniverse, twists can be forever flexible and especially for regenerations as well as all know.
@Prince Phillip Mickey the idiot!
@@CometStar100 That is just stupid ! Rose is a companion, full stop
I bet they uploaded this because billie piper who played rose was hinting a possible return to the show…maybe?
Rose Tyler highlights: just plays the entirety of series 1&2
I've been in Philippines for 10 years, I've so missed Dr Who.
Sara Jane is my # 1 but Rose is a close close #2
Rose was the first true love interest for the doctor. I feel that river and the doctor wasn't really true love or not for the doctor at least. I hope rose comes back one more time.
"I guess it's my last chance to say it. Rose *Tyler--Elyler"*
You should make a video about the best moments from the rtd era
I love Billie.
I love rtd era and I freaking love Bad Wolf. I tried to watch moffat chibnall eras and I actually watched some episodes like the premiere of Jodie, Rosa and the ones with James Corden, somes with Clara but, I dunno, I prefer the way Russell's mind work ig lol I love Rose and Donna they both don't have the complexity of Amy and Clara and River pff she have a cool personality but creating her to kick Rose out Doctor's hearts? Lmao
I'm so excited that RTD is coming back, the best news EVER
So, how do you feel about this comment in 2024?
Rose wasn’t my favourite companion, and I still think it’s slightly absurd that the Doctor would fall for her so quickly in the scheme of his life… but she was absolutely what was needed, both for the show in a meta sense and for the Doctor’s character arc in having just come from the Time War.
It just wouldn’t have been the show it was without Rose.
Agreed with everything you said !!
It was more David Tennant's Doctor that fell for her.
Fantastica Billie Piper la migliore tra le compagne del Doctor
Maybe you all forgot the first song we ever listen at the first scene of Jodie as the Doctor: It was the Rose theme.
Now, I understand there's a reason, we'll see again the Bad Wolf or Rose Tyler at the end of the 13th Doctor to say goodbye and meet the next Doctor that Russel T. Davis will write.
I think it is not a coincidence cause BBC has called the showrunner has awake Doctor Who in 2005 to save the series or end it.
Maybe Russel is interested to restore such elements of his old narrative style as Billy Piper, I hope she will not be the next Doctor... and back as companion and regular character.
Actually, the was the 9th Doctor's Theme, not Rose's!!!
Let’s face it she’s coming back isn’t she 😏😘
Love rose , god times
And only shortly after RTD saying he was coming back…
And Billie herself saying that she would be interested in returning.
I love Rose Tyler so well all was be my favorite same for the 9th doctor and the 10th doctor
I legit love how 10th Doctor doesn't even register that there are other passengers in the rocket when he thinks about destroying the planet. He's just only concerned for Rose! 😂
My ranking of the NuWho companions
Jack
Rose
Donna
Martha
Mickey
Dan
Clara
Rory
Yaz
Graham
Bill
Nardole
Ryan
River
Amy
What a beautie!
The time Lord didn't deserve her and neither does mickey
4:45 Look, it's the Isle of Wight again! It's been a long road, getting from The Runaway Bride to The End of the World
they tryna trick us with these donna and rose rumours but really it’s nardole who’s returning in series 13
1:53
"You're becoming hysterical."
I feel stupid even considering this, but do we think that these daily updates are hints of things to come in Series 13? Cause this channel had never had consistent daily updates like this, so now I'm wondering...
I've been wondering too, buy maybe it's just because of Russel T. Davies coming back after season 13... Doctor who knows? haha ✨