I do almost feel bad for Ari. She's so talented. But comparing anyone to Mariahs Daydream era is rough. It was her best vocal era. Her voice was still super strong (before the nodes started getting in the way) and her technique had improved greatly by then! Her technique was impeccable in those years!
@unyun rangz That "I may never be as good as this legend, but I want to be atleast worthy of being compared..." I hope hit her hard someday in the near future. You know, seeing her clips in her young theatrical days where she hit a long belt with a freakin awesome resonance gives me hope she still can.
@@divaxvx yes I've been obsessed with her sweetener tour performances her vibrato is so strong ,her breath control is amazing ,and her her high notes are so much more supported .
CHANBAEK Enthusiast 🗣️ Whitney was absurdly talented as well. I’d say she’s very close second to Mariah. Mariahs technique is so good that even with nodules she’s still on the same level as Whitney. Her range is also way larger
Phoenix She did sing live but they dubbed it for the DVD release. Both versions sound similar but the dubbed version gave a more crystal clear sound. (The artist goes back to the studio and re-records certain parts to enhance their performance.) I personally love the undubbed versions more, the rawness of her vocals during certain parts sounds pretty pleasant.
@@ajayyy6060yeah but you can listen to her other concerts from that Tour (Rotterdam, London etc) and she sounded even better there, without any dubbing
even if an ariana fan made the video, mariah carey would win the same way because in 1996, at Ariana's age, Mariah's voice was very good and very agile and had no bad shows, just a few tired shows
Without being a hater, anybody who knows anything about singing knows that Mariah in her prime was almost peerless with her technique (and just about anything else to do with vocals!) and by far the greater singer when compared to Ariana and practically everybody else in the modern era. Love this ladies commentary and down to earth style 👍
Line Bach wow we have a delusional and deaf fan right here. I love ariana soo much but we have to put our feelings away when we’re talking about technique. MARIAH IS BETTER AND YOU CAN PREFER WHATEVER YOU WANT WITHOUT BEING DELUSIONAL 😘
@@reesewithoutaspoon ariana is a decent singer yes but shes nothing compared to really awsome vocalist even now. Jessie j and kelly clarkson are much much better vocalist
Ariana is a is better than that Mariah Carey who doesn't seem to know any other singers because she is too stuck up and rude she just probably tries to erase them from her memory because she knows their way better than her so no hate towards Mariah but all hate toward all the crazy/ delusional ppl that think that Mariah is better
Mariah Carey has always been a better vocal technician and musician than Ariana or most current pop artists, especially in her prime years (1990-2005). Ariana is a good singer, but comparing her to Mariah in her prime years almost a crime. People tend to forget Mariah's first vocal coach is her mother, an classically trained singer as well as a vocal coach. Mariah's only weaknesses are her vocal nodules and her stage fright.
@@dv96_dk i beg to differ... Emancipation of Mimi contains some of the best vocals in her career m the song Circles contain some of the most resonant sounds ever produced 😘
100% agreed. And it's true that people unsee the fact that Mariah has nodules and most importantly stage fright, which hinders her from being relaxed on stage and believe in her abilities, especially these days!
@@dv96_dk I meant the prime of her career and musical creativity, sure in 2001-2004 she basically written off by the American music industry, but she continued to flourish in other parts of the world such as Asia, Charmbracelet was an anthem in the Philippines.
For me MC is a way better melodic singer/vocalist with a much richer tone than Ariana. Ariana is also a good singer but no matter where Mariah is now, there will never be another Mariah. Great reaction btw x
Ricardo Augusto I agree she is very rich in tone and she has a very deep in her characteristics in her music. Ariana Grande will never give you that she always sings in a high pitch it’s never in different tones. One thing people need to realize the era of when these performers came out the industry was totally different.
I think it should simply even be an HONOR to be compared to Mariah Carey. The fact that you have that level of talent to be measured up against Mariah is astounding as well. To be compared to daydream era Mariah is brutal in all honesty. She was simply so mesmerizing with her agility and flexibility in the way she used her voice.
Well said! She can rest easy knowing she’s near the top of her game and maybe the best vocalist of HER generation, although certainly no GOAT like Mariah.
To all those angry arianators out there: I am also an Arianator, WAAAY before I also became a Lamb. I checked Mariah out because at the beginning of Ari's career, everybody's comparing her to Mariah. I was intrigued, and BOOM! Mariah's mah kween. You can't complain that, "ooh, those clips are just bad" or, "Ari's better" because she's not. I've watched most of their performances, and I can tell, Mariah's the Queen.
Mariah's voice sounds flexible even on higher belts that's why she sounds better than Ariana. Ariana sounds she's struggling on higher belts, barely do rifts & vibrato just plain high notes.
Yeah. Making excuses just takes away from how AMAZING Mariah was in her prime. But we also can’t forget that both singers have fantastic careers, songs, music videos, tours, everything. They’re both SUPER talented!
I'll draw, since some do not understand (or just dont want to understand). Mariah, doesnt apply tension when she's hiting the high notes, she has good enunciation, she has no problems with pitch and no signs of nasality. PS: The lady also recognizes that Ariana is a great singer (even tho y'all are saying those arent her best vocals), but the fact is Mariah Carey sings circles around Ari's poor techinique.
This isn't me trying to be a stan or whatever but back in the day the only times that Mariah would ever lip was on overseas TV shows where they literally tell the artist to do so. Plus she's absolutely terrible at lip syncing so it's pretty easy to tell when shes doing it. All Mariah clips in this video were live.
@@lashondahaddock5232 None of the home videos are dubbed. All filmed performances are sung 2-3 times back to back. One is chosen for the video. There are multiple performances of the same song from the same night. All vocals are done live that night.
Mariah is truly the greatest voice of our generation. Her technical expertise and her ability to wrap emotion on a lyric is unsurpassed. Few have come close (whitney, celine) but hands down Mariah's vocal ability is unique her buttery tone is prolific.
Of our(my) generation she isnt. Mariah got the better technique and now she even comes back with whistles and new songs but now its time for Ariana Grande.
xIDarkNeo Ariana is not even compared to Mariah even this to date since Mariah is still supporting higher than Ariana & even lower but just not as consistent.
Kirya Whitney? The singer who strains her low and high notes, and can’t do melismas properly like Mariah? Please dahling, don’t be stupid 😂😂. Mariah’s resonance and better technique ends Whitney any day.
*Why are people acting so surprised & pressed; Mariah is undoubtedly a superior vocalist.* 👑 Much more support, resonance, agility, diction, dynamics, breath control etc. *Ariana* is a great singer but there are levels to this... Plus anyone who knows anything about this vocal coach knows that she's quite objective & genuine with her critique ✨
@DANI S - Ariana also didn't make music in a time where power ballads were the moneymakers. She made songs that she wanted to, catchy, fun, cool. Whereas Mariah made songs to show off powerful vocals. I don't know whether you can judge who is objectively better - music is an art meaning it's subjective. Technique wise, they were sorta similar but yet again different. Both artists are / were going for different things when they wrote songs and performed. When Ariana was trying to sound like Mariah, her version of Emotions was amazing. They're both incredible and will be remembered for a long time.
Mariah Carey was also cute during her Tokyo dome all I want for Christmas is you preformance. Also because her company made her wear clothes from top to bottom in the 90s
@Bader it want unfair, the poin twas to compare them at the same age, ariana just cant really compare to mariah at the same age, its pretty fair to me, its unfair to compare someone in their 20s and someone who is 50 years old, they had to use clips so that they had the same age, and thats fair, ariana just cant compare
Yeah. Mariah was better than Whitney, who struggled with high notes. That’s saying a lot though because Whitney is certainly second runner up as far as timbre, versatility and tone.
i must say that in the beggining i was chary with your reaction videos but you know...sometimes the honesty is little difficult to accept it... :) especially when you have sooo many react videos with soooo many people who are trying to please every child or generally many ears so they will have more views or viewers...but i will say this...you are DEFINITELY THE MOST HONEST VOCAL COACH that exists right now on youtube!cause when you say your opinion is 100% YOUR OBJECTIVE OPINION!!!and thank you for that our beautiful vocal coach!!!!!!!!! :)
The Honest Vocal Coach The New Foundry Studios I subbed after this video, because I respect how you took the risk being honest about Ariana, unlike Tristan Paredes for example, who tries to please stans of teen idols at all costs (because I doubt that he lacks the knowledge to hear the truth).
Mariah my fave of all the singers... Technical, depth, rising voice, head tone, shes the queen... With her other queen celine and whitney. The vocal trinity. My top 3 best.
The reason why these comparisons exist is because they (a combination of media/fans) started saying Ari is the next Mariah. Also, Ari used similar breathy vocals in her first album and covered Mariah's Emotions (in the studio) which amplified the comparisons. Ari is a great singer, she is one of the bestin today's music, but if you are familiar with MC accomplishments n vocal technique, you would know she had no match in her prime.
those are the games of the psucho music intustry people...they tried to do the same thing with the GREAT WHITNEY with Jennifer Hundson...jennifer is a very good singer but never EVER will be like Whitney....
@@linusolsson1343 Sorry for the late response, yes I have. It took a while to appreciate the beauty of the song. Yes, it is quite pleasant, I heard her live whistles too and it was pretty good 👏 but still girl, a 25 year old Mariah was singing around in circles belting and whistling so effortlessly. Watch Tokyo Dome Mariah concert.... That's around Ari's age. I just find the comparisons silly. Mariah is Mariah and Ariana is Ariana.
@@drunk_taylora smettetela. Ma vi rendete conto del tono angelico di Mariah? Della sua capacità di comporre, scrivere e inventare melodie? E della sua tecnica eccellente?
Ariana is not a bad singer at all, but u cannot compare her with Mariah specially during her prime, cuz Mariah is just one of the best voices ever, and plays in a higher league than Ariana
There's so much about Mariah which made her advantegous among all others. One is the range, then the diction. The technique and enunciation. During Daydream, she was just in her element.
@@marcusedwards1471 y'all gotta understand people who were alive back then are used to R&B not Pop where mumbles are everywhere and weird accents are prominent.
Even if you take Mariah's wost clips when she had a cold, and Ariana's best showcase, Mariah has more resonance in her chesty notes, better pronunciation, ease of transition from chest to head to whistle, and thicker colorful voice. That doesn't mean Ari is a bad singer or is worst, she's the current rising star of this generation, but technically and vocally speaking Mariah in her prime beat everybody. Search up "Vanishing" Snl rehearsal, that was even younger, Mariah was only 20 years old, you see what I mean.
Giuliana CR Mariah isn’t the only one in her lane lol. There were several others who compared to her, and some who could top her. She’s amazing for what she did period.
Mariah is better, she makes it sound so easy... we all know that. Both singers are just different and Ariana sound a bit nasally. Ariana is just mainstream now. I love them both though
Ariana has a beautiful voice but I can't understand a word she says. My vocal teacher would make me sing a song over and over until she could understand each word.
I saw a lot of Ariana fans saying "Ari have better videos" blah blah blah. No matter what video you put in there, Mariah is better 100%. No doubt. In power, resonance, tone, consistency, whistle, diction, enunciation, pronunciation, low notes, middle notes, high notes, chest voice, head voice, falsetto, volume, agility, accuracy, etc.
About time a TH-cam "vocal coach" proves their authenticity! Thank you so much for the honesty here, you were objective and logical the entire time and I love that. Keep doing what you're doing, and don't ever change your ways or your honest reactions for the sake of pleasing these children who dislike your videos because they're too sensitive to accept the facts.
- Both of them can definitely sing? of course - Both of them have their own audience? lambily and arianators aren't there for no reason - Both are successful? ofc.. but sorry, at the same age of 26, mariah had achieved way lot of things and maybe more than any singers to ever stepped on earth.. she already had multiple platinum albums, #1 singles, and etc. No offense but ariana is not a comparable material to mariah Also note for anyone who say mariah is irrelevant, hello ? she's being headline every year, sitting at the top of the charts every frickin year, recently her AIWFCIY was #1 at itunes worldwide also being the most streamed song in a single day on spotify, and she's #2 at global singers on spotify (ariana is #1) irrelevant? even after more than 25 years? lol
not to mention that she writes and produces her own song with just few co-writers not like modern singers that write with along 6-8 other writers, some of them can't even write a song at all.. and people scream at them "LEGEND" or "QUEEN" omfg
@@Kenziebaby16 hmmm after 5 to 10 years ariana song is unknown while mariah have legacy and solid great living legend. Don't compare some break up and controversy driven #1 by ari. She can sing great but don't drag her accolade. She still need to establish some legacy.
I agree 1000000% with this video! Mariah is SO MUCH better technically wise than Ariana, they’re not even in the same league! Mariah has dynamic, awesome agility, 3 octaves supported range and even more!
Snatchedness Prevails yasss unlike those coaches who are not really vocal coaches at all like Tris___ who likes to kiss them 12 y/o as*es for the views and likes 😅💀
Mariah can take the note to the last word in a chorus and turn it into it's own melody line! In fact she can add a whole new melody line any where in a song and not lose the original melody line which happens a lot in jazz music! You can be listening to a song they go off in these rifs and get lost and be like what song am I listening to and it's not till they bring it home and you're like Oh yeah now i remember! lol
@@migifn I know they were dubbed. Dubbed it's different with lypsinc. They dubbed to get better quality for documentation. My point is All of these clips are live
So she has been lipping for 21 years now. More than three times as long as she has sung live. And still people born years after Mariah started lipping are going around praising her into high heaven. Sad comment on the "general public" .
So listen dude. Ariana May be the artists of this decade I get it. However Mariah has always been a better vocalist especially back in her prime. If Mariah was the same age as Ariana, Mariah will destroy her completely.
Preach Regis. I definitely agree, It is a FOOLS BET to ever bet against Mariah in regards to Vocal Ability against Ariana. On a SIDE NOTE, Ariana sounds more like she is a “MUMBLE RAPPER” as opposed to an ARTICULATE POP-STAR. Is it a Millennial Thing? This whole mumbled lazy speech? I definitely hear a lot from people, famous and not, who are within 5 years plus or minus of Grandes Age. Sorry for the tangent, just an observation I have noticed a lot in the past 9 to 10 years..... CHEERS ALL!!!!!
It sucks that a person like britney who has a natural lower register soulful voice is told by her company that her natural wont sell so they keep forcing the baby voice on her if she would have made a album with her natural voice it would be a hit and so many artist are popular using high r&b notes and singing why don’t they think britney can do it its exactly what the fans have wanted they just hide her talent
Andy Carey Mariah never lipped during the first seven years of her career unless on the *very rare* occasion she was told to lip on some international television show which I don't even know if you could find on TH-cam.
Mariah is a legendary vocalist.. She might not at her best today.. Shes 50 now.. But she already set the bar so hight when she was at her best.. LAGENDARY vocal, lagendary chart history, lagendary record sales.
No one can compare!!! That was one of my favourite recorded concerts of all time though and I've watched it 1000 times. I agree, can't understand what Ariana is saying at all!
Mariah's mom was an opera singer who studied at the best performance school in the world. M's mom also was a vocal coach. Mariah has a God given talent that was also cultivated into perfection by a strong musical education.
1990-1996 Mariah never lip synced, however they did dubbed the performance, but even if u watch the undubbed version, it’s still the same, even better in my opinion bc it’s more raw and resonant, Mariah in daydream era is just superior to everyone, luv the vid btw❤️
I think that mariah started to lip sync just during the Charmbracalet era and maybe some performances during the Rainbow era when she sang in Europe in some Shows
I'm a fan of both singers. But I should give the award to Mariah. She's untouchable in her prime time. What a true singer indeed. But Ari has improve so much now with her annunciations and pronunciations.
I kind of feel bad for Ari. She's so talented. But Mariah's Daydream era was one of the best tours vocally ever. It had everything-solid low notes, supported mid and upper belts, gorgeous head voice/falsetto, airy/pleasant whistle notes, and incredible agility, fluidity, and musicality.
definitely low and mid. as a matter of fact, whitney's mid and low are unbeatable in her prime. the thing that sets mariah from her is her extra octave and the ease and flexibility she has in her upper registry.
It's about time vocal coaches call Ariana out for all these poor techniques, diction etc. Everyone wants to count Mariah out after all the excellent vocal performances she gave us all throughout her career.
It's so effortless for Mariah. Ariana has to use everything she's got to hit those same notes. In Arianas defense, she does move and dance a lot more. So her energy may be more divided. But Mariah just gives me chills, good chills everytime she sang and Ariana it's like, ya ok that was nice
![Mariah Carey’s "Butterfly" [LIVE on Letterman 1997] - SINGER REACTS](/img/n.gif)
I do almost feel bad for Ari. She's so talented. But comparing anyone to Mariahs Daydream era is rough. It was her best vocal era. Her voice was still super strong (before the nodes started getting in the way) and her technique had improved greatly by then! Her technique was impeccable in those years!
Ariana is out of breath in all the clips
JoanRudith ikr
@unyun rangz That "I may never be as good as this legend, but I want to be atleast worthy of being compared..." I hope hit her hard someday in the near future. You know, seeing her clips in her young theatrical days where she hit a long belt with a freakin awesome resonance gives me hope she still can.
@god's magic acorn you should listen to her live vocals from her sweetener tour, she really has improved a lot !
@@divaxvx yes I've been obsessed with her sweetener tour performances her vibrato is so strong ,her breath control is amazing ,and her her high notes are so much more supported .
Gurl the whole Daydream Tour was 100% live.
But Tokyo Dome was dubbed
Krystian Kozłowski It's still 100% live tho
@@krystiankozowski6309 but she's singing live there.. and for me the undubbed version is better that the dubbed one.
Krystian Kozłowski lmao the undubbed one is definitely still far better than Ariana . The fact that Mariah dubbed performance is bad
Krystian Kozłowski And btw the 5:02 one is already destroyed Ariana Grande career . And it’s an Undubbed performance
this is mariah in her prime no one could beat her
seven rings yasss! We love a WOKE arianator 😍🥰
Whitney Houston said Hello
@@robynthebank919 that crackhead. Even Ariana beats her
Whitney never had Mariahs talent...sorry...Mariah is Mariah
CHANBAEK Enthusiast 🗣️ Whitney was absurdly talented as well. I’d say she’s very close second to Mariah. Mariahs technique is so good that even with nodules she’s still on the same level as Whitney. Her range is also way larger
Why even compare the two? Mariah in her prime was a beast!!! No comparison
Nooo jaja marian is the best
Mariah sung like that whole Tokyo dome tour. The hell
Phoenix She did sing live but they dubbed it for the DVD release. Both versions sound similar but the dubbed version gave a more crystal clear sound. (The artist goes back to the studio and re-records certain parts to enhance their performance.)
I personally love the undubbed versions more, the rawness of her vocals during certain parts sounds pretty pleasant.
@@ajayyy6060yeah but you can listen to her other concerts from that Tour (Rotterdam, London etc) and she sounded even better there, without any dubbing
Prime Mariah is very hard to beat in both vocal technique and ability. She was amazing in the 90's, still is now, but back then she was untouchable.
even if an ariana fan made the video, mariah carey would win the same way because in 1996, at Ariana's age, Mariah's voice was very good and very agile and had no bad shows, just a few tired shows
And no lip
THANK U NEXT
Without being a hater, anybody who knows anything about singing knows that Mariah in her prime was almost peerless with her technique (and just about anything else to do with vocals!) and by far the greater singer when compared to Ariana and practically everybody else in the modern era. Love this ladies commentary and down to earth style 👍
Line Bach wow we have a delusional and deaf fan right here. I love ariana soo much but we have to put our feelings away when we’re talking about technique. MARIAH IS BETTER AND YOU CAN PREFER WHATEVER YOU WANT WITHOUT BEING DELUSIONAL 😘
@@reesewithoutaspoon go check your ears and brain to
@@reesewithoutaspoon ariana is a decent singer yes but shes nothing compared to really awsome vocalist even now. Jessie j and kelly clarkson are much much better vocalist
@@reesewithoutaspoon she's almost 50. We're comparing them at the same age
Ariana is a is better than that Mariah Carey who doesn't seem to know any other singers because she is too stuck up and rude she just probably tries to erase them from her memory because she knows their way better than her so no hate towards Mariah but all hate toward all the crazy/ delusional ppl that think that Mariah is better
Mariah's G5 at 8:47 blew my extensions off all the way to Mars
Ariana Stacey this comment had me gagged. 😂
oh my godddd 1st time i see extensions 😂😂😂
I pee My pants with this comment 💦💦💦😭🤣🤣😂😂😂😂
@@christianhernandez4614 I'm not at 8:47 now but I know that you mean hero.
Ariana Stacey 😂😂😂
MARIAH HAS THE CLEANEST AND ANGELIC VIOCE DURING HER TIME
Mariah Carey has always been a better vocal technician and musician than Ariana or most current pop artists, especially in her prime years (1990-2005). Ariana is a good singer, but comparing her to Mariah in her prime years almost a crime. People tend to forget Mariah's first vocal coach is her mother, an classically trained singer as well as a vocal coach. Mariah's only weaknesses are her vocal nodules and her stage fright.
Kaname Mariahs prime was 1990-1996)
@@dv96_dk i beg to differ... Emancipation of Mimi contains some of the best vocals in her career m the song Circles contain some of the most resonant sounds ever produced 😘
100% agreed. And it's true that people unsee the fact that Mariah has nodules and most importantly stage fright, which hinders her from being relaxed on stage and believe in her abilities, especially these days!
@@giulianacr2638 Studio produced sound. You might as well declare a computer a great singer.
@@dv96_dk I meant the prime of her career and musical creativity, sure in 2001-2004 she basically written off by the American music industry, but she continued to flourish in other parts of the world such as Asia, Charmbracelet was an anthem in the Philippines.
For me MC is a way better melodic singer/vocalist with a much richer tone than Ariana. Ariana is also a good singer but no matter where Mariah is now, there will never be another Mariah.
Great reaction btw x
Ricardo Augusto I agree she is very rich in tone and she has a very deep in her characteristics in her music. Ariana Grande will never give you that she always sings in a high pitch it’s never in different tones. One thing people need to realize the era of when these performers came out the industry was totally different.
I think, Monroe can be the next Mariah! 😍😘😘💋
Ariana is Ariana, not the next Mariah
@@madjust21319 agreed but she was influenced by MC way to much.. even in her latest song "Imagined", I thought some parts were sung by MC lol....
@@meikotaichix4116 same😂
I think it should simply even be an HONOR to be compared to Mariah Carey. The fact that you have that level of talent to be measured up against Mariah is astounding as well. To be compared to daydream era Mariah is brutal in all honesty. She was simply so mesmerizing with her agility and flexibility in the way she used her voice.
Literally like the fact that she’s even being compare meaning she is close to her level amaze me thats why I will always stan her
Well said! She can rest easy knowing she’s near the top of her game and maybe the best vocalist of HER generation, although certainly no GOAT like Mariah.
To all those angry arianators out there: I am also an Arianator, WAAAY before I also became a Lamb. I checked Mariah out because at the beginning of Ari's career, everybody's comparing her to Mariah. I was intrigued, and BOOM! Mariah's mah kween. You can't complain that, "ooh, those clips are just bad" or, "Ari's better" because she's not. I've watched most of their performances, and I can tell, Mariah's the Queen.
Samee dahling! Mariah is the 👑
Mariah's voice sounds flexible even on higher belts that's why she sounds better than Ariana. Ariana sounds she's struggling on higher belts, barely do rifts & vibrato just plain high notes.
Yeah. Making excuses just takes away from how AMAZING Mariah was in her prime. But we also can’t forget that both singers have fantastic careers, songs, music videos, tours, everything. They’re both SUPER talented!
@Hei Dinglepop If they used good clips Ariana wouldn't win anyways, Mariah simply superior to her
Hei Dinglepop She still does not compare to Mariah. Get over it
A queen could never be compared. Mariah is a legend, she was hands down the best singer of the 90s.
Of 90s not the 20s
@@hello.3471 She got old, and had nodules her whole life, If Ariana can't beat Mariah during her orime then she simply has nothing on her
Whitney* then Mariah
@@stanbily9416 hell no whitney in the 80s but 90s was mariah then celine and then whitney
@@stanbily9416 no dude. MARIAH IS THE BEST
I'll draw, since some do not understand (or just dont want to understand). Mariah, doesnt apply tension when she's hiting the high notes, she has good enunciation, she has no problems with pitch and no signs of nasality.
PS: The lady also recognizes that Ariana is a great singer (even tho y'all are saying those arent her best vocals), but the fact is Mariah Carey sings circles around Ari's poor techinique.
Saulo Menezes finally someone says it !!!! Nasally ! Im not even hating it just annoys me. 😂
Saulo Menezes Exactly
Wond3rLOL YASSSSSSS, oh my god, words literally right out of my mouth.
This isn't me trying to be a stan or whatever but back in the day the only times that Mariah would ever lip was on overseas TV shows where they literally tell the artist to do so. Plus she's absolutely terrible at lip syncing so it's pretty easy to tell when shes doing it. All Mariah clips in this video were live.
You remember the Fantasy lipsyncing? I laughed there.
Exactly! Some of them were dubbed tho but the live versions of the dubbed clips were even better anyways
I think that was the dubbed version of forever for her Madison Square Garden DVD..
@@july3348 of course! One of the greatest singers out there.
@@lashondahaddock5232 None of the home videos are dubbed. All filmed performances are sung 2-3 times back to back. One is chosen for the video. There are multiple performances of the same song from the same night. All vocals are done live that night.
POOR ARI. I luv her VERY MUCH, but this is DAYDREAMRIAH. IN HER VOCAL PRIME!
Yeah. The best vocalist in Pop music (along with Whitney) at her best vocal era. This is a massacre.
I am so proud of being a Mariah fan. She is the best!
Comparing someone to daydream Mariah is crazy , cause the daydream Mariah is a definition of a vocal perfection 🤷🏽♂️😊
Mariah Carey is the winner, vocally nobody will ever compare to 25 year old MC. Vocal Legend.
charla clay Oh no dahling Daydreamriah is a legendary vocal goddess 🌝
even I'm a fan of ari. Mariah won just honest mariah is the legend
Queen Ari you stupid stupid bitch
And u had a lunox pfp
Jacob Wisch What's your problem wtf?
Lunox main yah
Jacob Wisch are u ok buddy
All I know Is that Mariah was and still superior than Ariana no shade 😌BTW all of Mariah clips are live
"WHAT ARE THE WORDS LOVE?!!"
SIS I-
HAHAHAHA WE STAN
Mariah is truly the greatest voice of our generation. Her technical expertise and her ability to wrap emotion on a lyric is unsurpassed. Few have come close (whitney, celine) but hands down Mariah's vocal ability is unique her buttery tone is prolific.
Of our(my) generation she isnt. Mariah got the better technique and now she even comes back with whistles and new songs but now its time for Ariana Grande.
xIDarkNeo There are so many better artists than ariana tho like pink, gaga, and so hyang
xIDarkNeo Not even, Mariah’s Supported Range this decade is *C3-E5/F5-F#5-D6/Eb6*
xIDarkNeo Ariana is not even compared to Mariah even this to date since Mariah is still supporting higher than Ariana & even lower but just not as consistent.
Kirya Whitney? The singer who strains her low and high notes, and can’t do melismas properly like Mariah? Please dahling, don’t be stupid 😂😂. Mariah’s resonance and better technique ends Whitney any day.
I am an arianator, and I know Mariah is better singer
Bitupon Ray not a very good aianator
Bitupon Ray she was
@@luukd9554 Just because he didn't lie? We're talking about technique, range, vocal ability here, that's not a favorite competition.
@@valeriadelmoral4008 She's still. Mariah's A4-E5 is so far better than Ariana's High Larynx notes.
@@luukd9554 why she is not a good arianator?you are a good arianator only you close your ears in anything else beside ariana?
*Why are people acting so surprised & pressed; Mariah is undoubtedly a superior vocalist.* 👑
Much more support, resonance, agility, diction, dynamics, breath control etc.
*Ariana* is a great singer but there are levels to this...
Plus anyone who knows anything about this vocal coach knows that she's quite objective & genuine with her critique ✨
Mariah is indeed better bruh but ariana's agility is better
Gabriel Muzaffar lol hell no 😂😂😂
@@gibraeel1034 ???? Do you even know what agility is?
Gabriel Muzaffar honey no
@DANI S - Ariana also didn't make music in a time where power ballads were the moneymakers. She made songs that she wanted to, catchy, fun, cool. Whereas Mariah made songs to show off powerful vocals.
I don't know whether you can judge who is objectively better - music is an art meaning it's subjective. Technique wise, they were sorta similar but yet again different.
Both artists are / were going for different things when they wrote songs and performed. When Ariana was trying to sound like Mariah, her version of Emotions was amazing.
They're both incredible and will be remembered for a long time.
Ariana Grande is cute. Mariah Carey is Mariah Carey.
Ariana Grande isn't Ariana Grande? 😳👽
Mariah Carey was also cute during her Tokyo dome all I want for Christmas is you preformance. Also because her company made her wear clothes from top to bottom in the 90s
all the dislikes coming from arianator. lol
Yeah obviously hahahhaha
@Bader i really dont see your argument, because the point of the video was to see their voces at the same age. at the same point of time.
@Bader it’s hard to find bad performances of Mariah in the day dream era lol
@Bader it want unfair, the poin twas to compare them at the same age, ariana just cant really compare to mariah at the same age, its pretty fair to me, its unfair to compare someone in their 20s and someone who is 50 years old, they had to use clips so that they had the same age, and thats fair, ariana just cant compare
@@jonathan_8100 she has many other performance in 2018 but they choose only one. Y’all didn’t understand the argument of the Arianators 2 years ago.
even if she were to compare WHITNEY HOUSTON to Mariah in this era, she would’ve still won every round
Glad someone knows that
Yeah. Mariah was better than Whitney, who struggled with high notes. That’s saying a lot though because Whitney is certainly second runner up as far as timbre, versatility and tone.
i must say that in the beggining i was chary with your reaction videos but you know...sometimes the honesty is little difficult to accept it... :) especially when you have sooo many react videos with soooo many people who are trying to please every child or generally many ears so they will have more views or viewers...but i will say this...you are DEFINITELY THE MOST HONEST VOCAL COACH that exists right now on youtube!cause when you say your opinion is 100% YOUR OBJECTIVE OPINION!!!and thank you for that our beautiful vocal coach!!!!!!!!! :)
The Honest Vocal Coach The New Foundry Studios I subbed after this video, because I respect how you took the risk being honest about Ariana, unlike Tristan Paredes for example, who tries to please stans of teen idols at all costs (because I doubt that he lacks the knowledge to hear the truth).
Mariah the Legend. The Songbird Supreme. Member of Vocal Trinity.
I love vocal Trinity 😘
Yesssssssssssss!!!!!! No one can compete with the vocal trinity, PERIOD!!!
Mariah my fave of all the singers... Technical, depth, rising voice, head tone, shes the queen... With her other queen celine and whitney. The vocal trinity. My top 3 best.
@Terra Realm All respect to the sexy queen Toni Braxton but she ain't the vocal master that Celine, Mariah and Whitney are.
@DANI S I'm glad somebody said it.
The reason why these comparisons exist is because they (a combination of media/fans) started saying Ari is the next Mariah. Also, Ari used similar breathy vocals in her first album and covered Mariah's Emotions (in the studio) which amplified the comparisons. Ari is a great singer, she is one of the bestin today's music, but if you are familiar with MC accomplishments n vocal technique, you would know she had no match in her prime.
The E7 in her Emotions cover are full on Autotune Lol. Seriously the people thinks that she is the new Mariah?
those are the games of the psucho music intustry people...they tried to do the same thing with the GREAT WHITNEY with Jennifer Hundson...jennifer is a very good singer but never EVER will be like Whitney....
Have u heard Imagine?
@@linusolsson1343 Sorry for the late response, yes I have. It took a while to appreciate the beauty of the song. Yes, it is quite pleasant, I heard her live whistles too and it was pretty good 👏 but still girl, a 25 year old Mariah was singing around in circles belting and whistling so effortlessly. Watch Tokyo Dome Mariah concert.... That's around Ari's age. I just find the comparisons silly. Mariah is Mariah and Ariana is Ariana.
Mariah is INCOMPARABLE. No competition. 😂
There is competition she’s not immortal y’all need to...
What about Dimash?
@@iatepipe lmfao
Be fr. She's great not God. Ari beats her in high belts and falsetto while she has better chest voice and full belt and both are good at whistle note.
@@drunk_taylora smettetela. Ma vi rendete conto del tono angelico di Mariah? Della sua capacità di comporre, scrivere e inventare melodie? E della sua tecnica eccellente?
No whistle for MC (in these performances , YET she still manage to score 10-0 😊 over Ari.... RESPECT THE QUEEN
sorry but ari and hers whitles notes baby..... shes the queen of our generation
@@gigimonst5865 ewwww 🤮
I’m hollering at 10-0 sksksks
I'm so glad you reacted to this. I agree Ariana is great but Mariah is unmatched for me personally (especially in her prime years).
Ariana is not a bad singer at all, but u cannot compare her with Mariah specially during her prime, cuz Mariah is just one of the best voices ever, and plays in a higher league than Ariana
sixto corrales castle so when will Ariana’s prime be? 😂
Melvin Bokingkito As well as Ariana is already age 25 ?
Its a same age comparison
Melvin Bokingkito believe it was during her Honeymoon Tour/DW Tour... and that isn’t saying much at all ☕️😂💀
Melvin Bokingkito I’m guessing when Ariana was young? Where she used to support more notes other than today.
Mariah, Whitney and Celine are the best singers. No one can compare with them
Agree
How about some none American singers? Dimash kudaibergen? I'd say he belongs in that top.
Magdalena Nuszczyk Selena Gomez does
@@axelamarillas2402 queen of vocals!
Axel Amarillas sry no she can’t really hit notes 😂😂😂
794 people dislike because the truth hurts.
Exactly
Mariah "THE UNMATCHED SONGBIRD SUPREME PURE PLATINUM VOCALS GODDESS OF THE VOCAL TRINITY" Carey
marquise Washington 😍🤩🤟🏻
you mean DIAMOND VOCALS
10-0 !!!!!!!!!!
This is very very objective!!!!!!!!!
Mariah's technique is miles better than Ariana
Mariah invented most of this technics, Ariana is using technics she listened before.
well the simple answer answer is its daydream mariah... i meann crystal clear voice, perfect pitch and technique. definitely the peak of her career.
No one could vocally beat Mariah in her prime😂.
Vickie Winans, LaShun Pace and Karen Clark Sheard what destroys Mariah
@@spiralplex8813
They're amazing, but never ever.
There's so much about Mariah which made her advantegous among all others. One is the range, then the diction. The technique and enunciation. During Daydream, she was just in her element.
@@spiralplex8813
Mariah writes her own songs and composes them. Your favourite could NEVER.
@@spiralplex8813hell no
"I find that really annoying" 😂😂😂
Honey Is Natural 😕
I didn't think that ari was annoying
@@marcusedwards1471 y'all gotta understand people who were alive back then are used to R&B not Pop where mumbles are everywhere and weird accents are prominent.
Yeah arianas sounds off note cause of her pronouncing
But she’s a good singer too! Probably one of the best of this century so far!
Daydream era Mariah was untouchable! She’s still amazing, but back then nobody could compare & that still holds true today!
Even if you take Mariah's wost clips when she had a cold, and Ariana's best showcase, Mariah has more resonance in her chesty notes, better pronunciation, ease of transition from chest to head to whistle, and thicker colorful voice. That doesn't mean Ari is a bad singer or is worst, she's the current rising star of this generation, but technically and vocally speaking Mariah in her prime beat everybody. Search up "Vanishing" Snl rehearsal, that was even younger, Mariah was only 20 years old, you see what I mean.
Giuliana CR Mariah isn’t the only one in her lane lol. There were several others who compared to her, and some who could top her. She’s amazing for what she did period.
Marco Murillo in her prime nobody can top her 🙂 bye
Marco Murillo Mariah is in her own lane and it's quite obvious lol
That's a fact there's is a video where Mariah is singing anytime you need a friend with Bronchitis and sound way better than Ariana.
Mariah is better, she makes it sound so easy... we all know that. Both singers are just different and Ariana sound a bit nasally. Ariana is just mainstream now. I love them both though
Ariana sound like a nasally micky mouse. Very annoying, actually.
10 (Mariah) to 0 (Ariana) is very accurate.
How can you compare the two, ari is good but can't be compared to the Queen mariah
Ariana has a beautiful voice but I can't understand a word she says. My vocal teacher would make me sing a song over and over until she could understand each word.
I saw a lot of Ariana fans saying "Ari have better videos" blah blah blah. No matter what video you put in there, Mariah is better 100%. No doubt. In power, resonance, tone, consistency, whistle, diction, enunciation, pronunciation, low notes, middle notes, high notes, chest voice, head voice, falsetto, volume, agility, accuracy, etc.
The only singer that could keep up with Mariah was Whitney Houston. Two Queens. ❤❤
Denniel Escoto haha . Really they add another reason why Mariah is better. Her videos were unclear but that didn’t stop her from singing better
Mostly if it’s against Daydream Mariah. Ain’t no way Ariana would win.
Ariana is better especially for her age
@@jaanfredericks they are in the same age here....
In the same age , Mariah is untouchable!!!!!! 10 first years of MC are insane ! Like an Angel , perfect vocalist 🤟🏻
About time a TH-cam "vocal coach" proves their authenticity! Thank you so much for the honesty here, you were objective and logical the entire time and I love that. Keep doing what you're doing, and don't ever change your ways or your honest reactions for the sake of pleasing these children who dislike your videos because they're too sensitive to accept the facts.
shes biased towards demi
Ariana rapes her and So Hyang definitely on belt battles
but she alway makes demi win with no real point
Lool
Amén
All the clips of mariah was from daydream, and all the lambs know that daydream Era is Perfection
We know you are a lamb haha!
Mariah is Queen and will always be Queen! 😍
No questions. Mariah is who she is for a reason. Unmatched. Thank you
Next
We all know Mariah is a better vocalist. 🙌
- Both of them can definitely sing? of course
- Both of them have their own audience? lambily and arianators aren't there for no reason
- Both are successful? ofc.. but sorry, at the same age of 26, mariah had achieved way lot of things and maybe more than any singers to ever stepped on earth.. she already had multiple platinum albums, #1 singles, and etc. No offense but ariana is not a comparable material to mariah
Also note for anyone who say mariah is irrelevant, hello ? she's being headline every year, sitting at the top of the charts every frickin year, recently her AIWFCIY was #1 at itunes worldwide also being the most streamed song in a single day on spotify, and she's #2 at global singers on spotify (ariana is #1)
irrelevant? even after more than 25 years? lol
not to mention that she writes and produces her own song with just few co-writers not like modern singers that write with along 6-8 other writers, some of them can't even write a song at all.. and people scream at them "LEGEND" or "QUEEN" omfg
Ari just broke a record for the only single artist to knock her own single off the chart and have three at the same time 😭😭
@@Kenziebaby16 hmmm after 5 to 10 years ariana song is unknown while mariah have legacy and solid great living legend. Don't compare some break up and controversy driven #1 by ari. She can sing great but don't drag her accolade. She still need to establish some legacy.
@@baddest12345 how can u say..like are u from the fukin future?
DayDream Era
No match for even the best of the best vocalists
She was simply the ultimate goddess that time
PS: love your reaction expressions btw
Mariah is a better vocalist. So many dislikes from people mad about the truth
Mezmerized4Life Jay tea
In 2019 Ariana is a better vocalist, and that’s a fact
@@ButeraVids 🤣
ButeraVids JAJAJAJA ARÉ YOU KIDDING ME?
ButeraVids ....Ariana compare to Mariah is nothing
anyways stream Caution by Mariah ⚠️💖⚠️
I agree 1000000% with this video! Mariah is SO MUCH better technically wise than Ariana, they’re not even in the same league! Mariah has dynamic, awesome agility, 3 octaves supported range and even more!
4 or 5 octaves
the drew identity supported is diff than overall range
Mariah Carey's Daydream era is U N T O U C H A B L E 👌
I had mariah's tape in the early 90s. with 'emotions' on it. ain't gonna get better than this.
10-0 that's what you get when compared to the prime Mariah
10 to 0 . Pretty accurate
'really' and 'honestly' accurate not just 'pretty'. lol
Not accurate at all
@@chipmunkaraoke true hahaha
GeneralFredz 7 how so? From a technical standpoint Mariah slayed ariana it’s really not a contest lol
GeneralFredz 7 in your dreams! LOL
I’m also a really big arianator, and NO ONE can tell me Ariana hasn’t got a good voice but she’s not really close to beating Mariah in her prime..
Erik Ariana has a good voice but no technique, she could be way better is she had one
Mariah's not in her prime and will sting Ariana under the table.
we stan an *HONEST* vocal coach!
Snatchedness Prevails yasss unlike those coaches who are not really vocal coaches at all like Tris___ who likes to kiss them 12 y/o as*es for the views and likes 😅💀
She is on maria's.
Rhon Tibayan hahahahahahaha that attack I can't-
thats why i subscribed even tho i dont watch most of her vids. she deserves
Mariah can take the note to the last word in a chorus and turn it into it's own melody line! In fact she can add a whole new melody line any where in a song and not lose the original melody line which happens a lot in jazz music! You can be listening to a song they go off in these rifs and get lost and be like what song am I listening to and it's not till they bring it home and you're like Oh yeah now i remember! lol
All Mariah’s performances on that Video was Live. All of it Live
Mariah 😊😊😊 girly voice but resonant dan powerfull
Girly??? Ariana has girly. Mariah's voice is womanly.
Compared to Whitney it is girlish, but compared to Ariana her vocals are powerful.
@@Perseus99 u definitely didn't watch the vid.
@@Perseus99 Girlish can be very powerful. In the case of Mariah, it almost always is.
@@Perseus99 womanly 😂 but yeah I like Ariana Grande's voice tho
I think everyone here really loves your honesty
Mariah never lip at first 6 years her career. She start lip in 1997. She was 25 here (1995) so 0 Mariah's clip lypsinc here.
Actually her first lipped performance is Without You in 1993
Dicky Martin I’m a hardcore lamb yet I have to mention that lots of her Daydream footage is dubbed.
@@migifn I know they were dubbed. Dubbed it's different with lypsinc. They dubbed to get better quality for documentation. My point is All of these clips are live
Lizzie McGuire
lipped isn’t the same as dubbed
So she has been lipping for 21 years now. More than three times as long as she has sung live. And still people born years after Mariah started lipping are going around praising her into high heaven. Sad comment on the "general public" .
ohhh mariah's daydream vocal. no one cam top that perfect bright tone like a clue sky.
Im personally Ariana's fan,she’s so talented ❤️ but no one can compare to Mariah ❤️
I need all this arianators calling this video unfair to make a video comparison themselves if they truly believe Ariana will win. I’ll wait 😉
No she won't
even I'm a a fan of her I respect mariah. mariah is a legend. mariah definitely win
So listen dude. Ariana May be the artists of this decade I get it. However Mariah has always been a better vocalist especially back in her prime. If Mariah was the same age as Ariana, Mariah will destroy her completely.
Preach Regis. I definitely agree, It is a FOOLS BET to ever bet against Mariah in regards to Vocal Ability against Ariana. On a SIDE NOTE, Ariana sounds more like she is a “MUMBLE RAPPER” as opposed to an ARTICULATE POP-STAR. Is it a Millennial Thing? This whole mumbled lazy speech? I definitely hear a lot from people, famous and not, who are within 5 years plus or minus of Grandes Age. Sorry for the tangent, just an observation I have noticed a lot in the past 9 to 10 years..... CHEERS ALL!!!!!
wow, we love a rude moment.
This just shows the huge difference between the two. I cant believe this is even the same age . Mariah just soars over Ariana
Ariana is okay . She’s not versatile , lacks soul, kind of corny . She can sing but she’s no Mariah
Yup, its true.
Her soul is only cute lol
@@Xdianaandini lol.. hahahahhahaha
Facts
It sucks that a person like britney who has a natural lower register soulful voice is told by her company that her natural wont sell so they keep forcing the baby voice on her if she would have made a album with her natural voice it would be a hit and so many artist are popular using high r&b notes and singing why don’t they think britney can do it its exactly what the fans have wanted they just hide her talent
Mariah Carey Queen of vocals ❤️🦋
I'm a vocal coach and I'm 100% agreeance with you.
Mariah stared her career with debute No1 vision of love and get it annually along 90,s here's successful not like debute almost 6 years to get No1
Shade!!!!
Flukey Perry misogyny here
Wowwww the shade of it all but heard no lies hehe
plus ariana also released two studio albums in just one year haha she's really desperate to get a number 1.
MARIAH IS A BETTER SINGER. PERIODT
Preach
.PERIODT.
Vocalist*
Ariana is the singer.
There´s no more to it I agree.
Where Mariah goes, Norielle goes. 😂😂
I'm also being honest, sometimes I don't know what Ariana is singing😆
U don't gotta listen..
Marcus Edwards ??? What does that mean?
@@yourlocalkaren1797 Who cares, she can mumble it we all know the lyrics so we can singalong.😊
She is really amazing.
@@marcusedwards1471 yeah, you gotta read the auto generated subtitles
@@DEA983 well for a new listener it is really odd
Mariah looks so effortless when she belts out her notes!
This channel deserves more subscriber.....
About the singing live you said early on the A4 note, Mariah is singing live in that whole year and era... I don't know about Ariana tho
Actually I think Mariah lipped in 1995. It was fantasy but it was outside the us so it's understandable
Andy Carey Mariah never lipped during the first seven years of her career unless on the *very rare* occasion she was told to lip on some international television show which I don't even know if you could find on TH-cam.
Andy Carey ALL Vocalist Lips from time to time. Example Social Media called out John Legend. Give it a REST.
Andy Carey there are shows like TOTP that make you lipsynch
Mariah all the way but you was harshly honest about Ariana! 🙈🙈🙈
No one can fault you for being honest! Great video!
Mariah is a legendary vocalist.. She might not at her best today.. Shes 50 now.. But she already set the bar so hight when she was at her best.. LAGENDARY vocal, lagendary chart history, lagendary record sales.
No one can compare!!! That was one of my favourite recorded concerts of all time though and I've watched it 1000 times. I agree, can't understand what Ariana is saying at all!
Mariah is simply a LEGEND and that says everything 👑
I think we ALL agree with you.
@@ramonpadilha9987 yeah, it is what it is 🤷🏻♂️
Lucas Guiness World of Record Holder she is, Songbird Supreme reigns forevermore 👑😍🥰
Mariah's mom was an opera singer who studied at the best performance school in the world. M's mom also was a vocal coach. Mariah has a God given talent that was also cultivated into perfection by a strong musical education.
1990-1996 Mariah never lip synced, however they did dubbed the performance, but even if u watch the undubbed version, it’s still the same, even better in my opinion bc it’s more raw and resonant, Mariah in daydream era is just superior to everyone, luv the vid btw❤️
I think that mariah started to lip sync just during the Charmbracalet era and maybe some performances during the Rainbow era when she sang in Europe in some Shows
@@flaviocappelli7506 no in 1997 too
I'm a fan of both singers. But I should give the award to Mariah. She's untouchable in her prime time. What a true singer indeed. But Ari has improve so much now with her annunciations and pronunciations.
I kind of feel bad for Ari. She's so talented. But Mariah's Daydream era was one of the best tours vocally ever. It had everything-solid low notes, supported mid and upper belts, gorgeous head voice/falsetto, airy/pleasant whistle notes, and incredible agility, fluidity, and musicality.
omg, only Whitney could match Mariah on daydream era lol her 1995 undubbed show is like a world treasure!
Not even Withney
She could match her int the middle register. Not the highs and the lows.
Mateo Fernández López Oh yes Mariah Carey at this point of her career is the only one who could match with Whitney !
definitely low and mid. as a matter of fact, whitney's mid and low are unbeatable in her prime. the thing that sets mariah from her is her extra octave and the ease and flexibility she has in her upper registry.
Chris it’s because Whitney is a mezzo soprano while Mariah is a coloratura soprano (that’s why Mariah can go in the high Cs)
It's about time vocal coaches call Ariana out for all these poor techniques, diction etc. Everyone wants to count Mariah out after all the excellent vocal performances she gave us all throughout her career.
It is because they want views from Arianas fans so some vocal reactions and stuff will say something is right even when it isnt
Grant Morgan *cough cough* Tristan Scamedes
Grant Morgan HA HA HA DITTO
Gently Fading Into Muse he is the most biased of all these coaches and he keeps saying that technique doesn't matter if people are successful 😂
@@ocandro he even used autotune in his cover LMAO VOCAL COACH
Hahahahah 10 -0 thats pretty much what every real vocal coach will say . Ariana cannot be compared to Mariah..
It's so effortless for Mariah. Ariana has to use everything she's got to hit those same notes. In Arianas defense, she does move and dance a lot more. So her energy may be more divided. But Mariah just gives me chills, good chills everytime she sang and Ariana it's like, ya ok that was nice
nothing compares to mariah... hahaha no matter what technique you used,whatever it is 😂(ariana 😂😂😂)idk 😅