Artificial Intelligence | FULL DEBATE | Doha Debates
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 ก.ค. 2024
- Advocates for AI defend it as manageable and say the risks are marginal, and the rewards life-improving, by empowering more people with instant information. But critics warn about transparency gaps and power disparities, including a slippery slope into a digital apocalypse where superintelligent machines surpass humans’ ability to control them. Watch as four experts weigh in on the future of AI.
►► Subscribe & join the conversation: bit.ly/38fuJjZ
►► Subscribe to Course Correction: megaphone.link/QF2056074382
Don’t Settle for a Divided World. Think. Debate. Act. Let’s find solutions to the world's most pressing problems.
00:00 - Artificial Intelligence
00:53 - Opening Remarks
05:25 - Speaker Intros
06:31 - Muthoni Wanyoike
14:37 - Dex Torricke-Barton
24:35 - Nick Bostrom
33:22 - Joy Buolamwini
47:11 - Govina Clayton (Connector)
52:46 - Majlis
1:10:21 - Voting Results
1:11:05 - Audience Questions
Doha Debates examines the world's most pressing challenges through live debates, digital videos, a TV series, blogs and podcasts. This innovative approach includes Majlis-style conversations designed to bridge differences, build consensus and identify solutions to urgent global issues.
►► Follow us on Facebook: / dohadebates
►► Follow us on Twitter: / dohadebates - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
![รวมเพลงลูกทุ่ง 6 หนุ่มไทบ้าน ฮิตติดกระแส ชุดที่ 1 l มนต์แคน ไมค์ ไผ่ เสถียร ไหมไทย พี [Longplay]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/GD2v1OjMw5I/mqdefault.jpg)
Timeliness and suitable debate on AI, thanks for whole team who involved in this awesome task.
23:00 Zuckerberg said he wasn't comfortable sharing it with the room but it was implied that his company when it has such information about others would share it with advertisement companies and others who have paid him for it! That others also do not wish him to share their personal information with AI data filtering algorithms. Regardless of the permission to do so being given under agreement via terms and condition.
You didn't read the terms of service huh? Thats how that make their revenue, if you don't like it delete your account. I have, and I have survived.
Interesting times
could you please tell me how can I participate in Doha debates
Unfortunately, they didn't talk much about A.I but more on other un-related topics, those aren't really experts.
T_D is leaking. Why is this comment section so toxic? Debate seems insightful.
The government are not the philosophers who are not the programmers. The government orders for engineering and development in this sector is a few decades old now. The development teams are not about to hire philosophers to debate restrictions on their code slowing development. Slow development is bad for business against the bottom line, profit. It removes a company from the race for growth. So the ethics of AI is out of the loop of development.
That is precisely the problem. They should build the laws for AI advancements, ethically as a framework with/alongside the technology as a framework for the protection of society and its citizens. But the "race for growth" priority in AI technical advancement is not simply for the betterment of humanity... it is and has always been, the priority to win the "race for the money and power" OF the system advancements IN ORDER TO control/take advantage of the citizens (which has to be without their knowledge) - otherwise it would not work. Frog in the pot of slowly boiling water scenario 👍🏼
I am African and a student of Computer Science. I appreciate the points brought up in this debate but I do not feel that it tackled the technical issues of machine learning or any of AI safety and morality research which I hoped to hear. It was more of a political debate which is just as important but in a sense dissatisfying for the audience. As for the problem of bias in AI systems, I think we blacks especially need to stop complaining and start building technologies that reflect our demographic and values. You cannot have a person build a technology based on his/her culture and expect it to reflect yours. We need to come together; the smart and industrious young minds of Africa and build technologies that suit our values and stop depending on the western world for innovation and then complain when these technologies are biased. It is true that there are some socio-political and economic obstacles in our way as well as international control/ subjugation and the aftermath of exploitations that setback our continent; but I believe we can get past that and build our continent if we as Africans are ready to cooperate in the sciences, tech and business rather than politics and activism. This goes for black America as well.
@@DohaDebates Okay I will thanks.
I totally agree with you. She pointed out saying that the resume automation ranked resume of women down. I am sure that she is stating facts with bias. An ML algorithm would definitely not completely fit to that criteria. If the stats say that men (with certain other parameters) are better than women (with certain parameters), then it’s not the algorithm to be blamed. It might be the hard truth.
Second point, with respect to black face tracking. It’s high time they categorise it into racial discrimination. ML algorithms are in initial stages and if the data had more white faces, then you can’t blame! I am brown BTW and that’s my view.
Is wtf these so called ppl are trying to tell us without causing to much alarm, is they've already lost control, & the A.I. is running shit, & has been
The Asian gentleman at 21:03 is an actor. He is told to nod his head at an inopportunistic times to further invoke the ideas he has, thus making them believable. This causes you to want to agree with him so that you have no doubt. It's a assurance; reaffirmation.
using too much technology can make us forget every thing just like zuker he even forgot the hotel he stayed right before the day he gotinfront of senet
Is it me...or did everyone looked afraid of the guys in white
I feel dissapointed with the speakers, or is AI in charge already? I feel confused!🤔
why be confused we need to live in a simple manner. We will have tornadoes, floods, earthquakes.
@@audreydunham4600 they are innocent, I mean they barely know a thing.
When the stage is bigger than you. The speakers are innocent, I mean they know not a thing. When you google to do your assignment defined in practical terms.
Answer is 'D'
I am G-11 computer science student from PAKISTAN and want to continue my career in AI and I am quite inspired by making computers take decisions and predictions i agree with every thing these 2 people said but now I want to tell you guys who are in my comment Tell me what ll gonna happen if robots get any issue or may be some 1 spreads virus or program them in the was that the robots go for destruction in all around the world just think about it we are using AI in the future for almost every think related to basic human needs i mean in every field but we should think about it that if we use AI in every field we may face issues related to unemployment and stuffs so I think we should use the AI and ROBOTS to make humans life easy but I think making robots in large number and trying to think that once AI will completely launched it will be good for every thing but I think we are doing a big mistake if we use AI in every field it can get big crises to us so thanks for those if u have read my comment and i would like if some 1 wants to have a conversation with me about AI and ROBOTICS
WITH thanks SHERYAR KARIM
I know your comment is from 9 months ago, but i agree, if we insert AI into every aspect of human life, then if something goes wrong with it, we wont be able to simply turn it off without catastrophic consequences to ourselves.
@ kevin thats so true
Not insight full rebate .it is advertising artificial intelligence
Book of Revelation brought me here
The time has come my brother
What about the book of revelations? We're not in the end of days. Until all people walk as Christ did in love, and until all people believe and rely on Christ alone, Jesus will not return. Jesus is not going to return until all people believe. The Bible even says this.
12:00 clip
but its not 2015 anymore
We shouldn't complain or blame A.I. if it did not give the expected outcome that you we are looking for and conclude that using A.I. will just amplify bias or increase risks of danger to society.
When you work on a project you should already know what your goals are and what you expect from the project to fulfill these goals. You define which results are acceptable, which are not, and which part we can make a compromise and so on.
It's the decision makers who answer this questions are the people we need to be in check and not blame these gaps to using A.I.
I strongly believe that government should work with tech experts to define policies that will make sure A.I. will be used as tool to help/assist humans instead of it being a risk.
If you're wanting to hear anything about AI the effects and benefits don't watch this.
You said it. It was a hash of adoration for AI or virtue signallying pseudo-intellectuals preening for the audience. The only one who made any sense was Nick Bostrum of Sweden. AI is a mixed bag. There is no way to stop but it can be regulated and must be regulated in order to prevent a digital dictatorship.
Got any suggestions then? Most A.I. discussions I find on YT tend to be by low intelligence people who don't seem to know what A.I. is outside movies and TV. Even from so called Experts and Professionals.
What a waste of time. AI is advancing, human intelligence is going the other way
This is why I am hopeful for AI, i'd rather choose one of them as a leader than humans at this point.
So Truistic :')
so this co called connecter.. what is his role..he adds nothing to the debate.. what is the the point of him?
To laugh during his introduction, throughout every installment of this series 🤦♀️
Pointless having him on this project!
What "Doha" means?
It's a place ig
What will AI do about jobs? I get how they'll replace jobs but surely the government won't let unemployment skyrocket?
Short-term vs Long-term context...LoL...focus on self-contained vs interconnected and networked settings for the AI's usage...and their codes should be publicly scrutinized and reviewed in full scrubdown of their coding if ever they will be put into a real-time networked environment that have access to the people and public welfare.
Technology has a great potential to reform our world in many ways but human being need to learn how to use it
Well…we’ve seen how that goes.
Doha debates higly resembles World Economic Forum.
A lot of blowhards.
It's crazy that the world is ok with selling their souls to evil
I will put my point through like this , let say humans are AI created by God to do good and take care of earth but look at us , what we have become but we should also note that their are good people still out here doing good and trying to make the world a better place , I think AI will be the same it will be used for good but evil will always come through from any tools, all in all AI is here to stay so will can move forward as a race but effort should be made to always make it safe or reduce the negative effects AI will always bring.
HAHAHAHAHA... WHAT? WHAAAAAAAAAAAT?!?! This is what the debate has evolved to? I was thinking this was something from 2010... this makes me feel we literally knew more about A.I 10 years ago but I shouldnt judge the field from one debate but god this is embarrasing... this is laughable...
I rather watch a debate between two goldfish
Just a simple question...ask an AI whose life is more important between Person A or B or give it a list of 5 sample humans and ask it to sacrifice/kill person A or B or 2 of the 5 and justify why it chose those. - BTW...robots (tools) don't kill...the mind, will and body behind it's building and usage IS the one that actually kills.
Both these women are like........ don't need to be here cause there like not even representing a diversity correctly
Ai is a tool that can be used for good or evil but my dission is everyone who is in it must Fear God
yea no, the Ms. Boulamwini was on a political train
Ted talk is Dead 😂😂😂, Doha debate is new deal 🤝.... Interesting
I doubt
Sales people😂😂
Honestly the dangers and concerns of AI expand so much farther than sexism and racial bias. I think first we should concern ourselves with whether AI is destined to become extremely prejudiced against all of human kind.
AI doesn't exist yet, and like the TRUE GOD, no one can agree.
Joy's point is too basic, they could have brought in better guest
Like you could do better than her
Huh? But nobody is black... They're brown, but just different shades of brown. And "white" people are also different shades of color. I've never seen a black or a white person in my entire life. 🤷♀️
Mohammed
Dude! I think Nick Bostrom is the most knowledgeable and credible person here, other people are just talking about AI without defining specifically what kind AI they're talking about, of course we cant expect everyone to be experts, as AI is only at its infant stage (even experts can be clueless about their future predictions, look at the Internet in 1990s). I think it is almost impossible to predict the "long term" context because we wont know or even conceive of AIs potential (watch Sam Harris ted talk about it), because at a certain point I think AI can replicate thousands years of human evolution in a milisecond with enough computing power. I think Nick wont even know too, he answered : "We should work together", a very basic answer, merely a replacement for IDK. So I think its best to focus on short term first.
Is there any peer reviewed objective research statics to prove, AI systems inherently biased compared to human counterparts? Will the AI in a black African country discriminate against the darker skin person to a lighter skin person or is it happen in the other way round? Should people balme AI as bias when their Politically Correct views negated by it?
AI isn't biased. It conforms to objective reality. An objective reality that most humans refuse to come to grips with. There are obvious differences in cognitive ability and violent tendencies in population groups. AI always figures this out quickly, humans pull the plug or literally code bias into the AI logic to "equalize" it.
@@GrandmasterofWin You proved my hunch that I always had, thanks for someone who stand up and says it openly. I wonder Why the big boss corporation like Google, Facebook, IBMs Microsoft like, maintain total silent on this issue. Their Political Correctness rather trying to appease those dystopian AI lobby really harms the objective progress of the future AI.
@@ValerianTexeira Honestly when someone spends over a decade building a career portfolio and 8 years getting a doctorate the last thing they want to do is slip up and speak the truth. If they'll burn James Watson at the stake then they'll burn anyone. Think of the young engineer working for Google who proposed that there are biological differences between men and women (an established scientific fact). He lost everything.
The liberal world order is a religion complete with prophets, original sin, promise of salvation and threat of excommunication and damnation.
Hopefully we hit a tipping point. They can fire an individual but they can't fire everyone.
@@GrandmasterofWin Totally agree.
@@GrandmasterofWin Hi, I'm pretty sure you're wrong - or maybe I misunderstood. how do you know that 'AI conforms to objective reality'? is there a proof? In my experience, most AIs are based on machine learning which itself is based on data which definitely can be biased - leading to biased models and bad AI.
that socialist guy in the back, 21:17
As long as feminism or other corruptions aren't allowed to stunt Africa's growth, she will thrive.
Look how manic and crazy the thinking of the feminist in red, avoid that being a powerful influence in your countries.
When did you test all of us genius?🤔
@Evidentialist maybe you should take a psychology one, and realize how easily the psychometric are misinterpreted over interpreted, and in IQ case, over essentialized is, and how much it goes within one generation with one simple thing, Opportunities.
🤦♀️💩🧠
Just started. How long until the black women talk about AI being racist I wonder..?
Edit, oh my lord that Joy is irritating. See ya.
Only Nick Bostrom is a big name. The rest are effectively unknown and are probably invited for "diversity purposes"...
@Evidentialist Yet the evidence is really strong - all these news from Wakanda's Academy of Science. Watch the movie and see for yourself.
Book of Revelation brought me here
I wonder why? It has no relation to A.I whatsoever.
Mohammed