Why Do Game Names Change in Different Countries?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 ม.ค. 2023
- Today I wanted to talk about Game Name Changes.
Follow Me: / kirotalks
Credits
Footage
LongplayArchive - Pokemon Stadium, Zelda A Link to the Past, Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door, Zelda Link's Awakening / @longplayarchive
NintendoComplete - Earthbound, Final Fantasy 4 / @nintendocomplete
iwanttobelieve - Earthbound Samples Video / @iwanttobelieve1523
FCPlaythroughs - Final Fantasy / @fcplaythroughs
Ninbanyan - Paper Mario / @ninbanyan
iPlay Retro - Final Fantasy 5 / @iplayretro
Music
TrackTribe - Running Errands • TrackTribe - "Running ...
Images
u/TestZero - FF2 Promo Image / unused_promotional_art...
The Cutting Room Floor - Zelda A Link to the Past Censorship tcrf.net/The_Legend_of_Zelda:...
tcrf.net/The_Cutting_Room_Floor
creativecommons.org/licenses/...
Nintendo - Iwata Asks Zelda Link's Awakening Interview
archive.ph/20120629063241/htt...
#gaming - เกม
![[TH]FFWS SEA Spring 2024 Knockout Stage - Day 11](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Qr0L1ab9dLE/mqdefault.jpg)
![ตีสิบเดย์ [FULL] | แดนเซอร์ลำไย เด้งจน 1,000,000 แตก!!!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/MYsBsMIQeT8/mqdefault.jpg)
Phil Sandhop, the localizer for the first Mother game, confirmed that he randomly came up with the name Earthbound at the end to the translation period (assumingly August 1990)
Oh wow, well at least the name works lol
Ha ha fanboy
@@TeddyBelcher4kultrawide he probably just googled it
I always figured the Japanese name was meant to be “Mother Earth” given the logo, which lines up with “Earth Bound” nicely.
Earthbound is such a cool name though.
Yes
I wholeheartedly agree!
@TanookiMax Technically the Japanese version title sounded too generic for a video game franchise title.
Not as cool as Yo Mama 2
Yeah
Two of the strangest name changes are two of the Kirby remakes-Super Star was called “Kirby’s Fun Pak” in PAL regions, and Kirby’s Return to Dream Land was called “Kirby’s Adventure Wii” in PAL regions. However, their remakes use the American names in PAL regions, so I imagine some European players were very confused/annoyed (especially in the latter, since the PAL name is closer to the Japanese name, which is preserved in the remake, “Hoshi No Kabi Wii (Deluxe),” or “Kirby of the Stars Wii (Deluxe)”). So Kirby’s Fun Pak was remade as Super Star Ultra, and Kirby’s Adventure Wii became Return to Dream Land Deluxe.
Yeah that was really weird. Even Kirby Canvas Curse and Kirby Rainbow Curse had different names in PAL regions.
@@kirotalksyt Likely that it needs to adjust to British English & the other European languages.
Example:
US - Kirby's Squeak Attack
PAL - Kirby's Mouse Attack
For non-native English speaker o. non-speaker "Squeak" is way more difficult & confusing than "mouse".
Kirby squeak squad was called kirby’s mouse attack in europe because squad is apparantley a slur WHY IS EURPE LIKE THIS?!
@@autismandgaming4532 “Alright, Europe, which was more offensive, ‘squeak’ or ‘squad?’”
-Antdude
Let's be completely honest here, though, those European names are REALLY REALLY BORING.
*Fun Fact:* The name "EarthBound" comes from MOTHER 1's 1990 American Localizer Phil Sandhop as he was working in the unfortunately cancelled at the time US Localization of MOTHER 1. He knew Americans wouldn't buy a game with such a cheesy name of MOTHER so he randomly though up of the "EARTH BOUND" (the words spaced out.) After MOTHER 1's US Localization got cancelled last minute after it was already completed they reused the name of "EARTH BOUND" for MOTHER 2's US Localization.
A funny thing to note that I doubt was actually intentional is that the word "earthbound" obvious meaning bound to earth or restricted to earth also has a second meaning. That 2nd meaning "attached or limited to material existence as distinct from a spiritual thing." something that if you ever played MOTHER 1 reminds players much about the character known as Queen Mary which I won't spoil her full on backstory, but is a character (trying to be vague here) is whose entire existence in the game is restricted to a spiritual world of some sort, meaning that Queen Mary a character who the game's plot revolves around is the literal definition of the word "earthbound."
I always thought that the B being so big compared to the rest letters in earthbound was meant to be a visual pun with the German "ss" sound: ß
So you could read it as Earth's sound, which is fitting, because you collect melodies that come from the Earth
nt jewbani
That makes some sense. Though, very likely not the intent. What the intent was, I wouldn't know. It's not something the (probably) intended American audience would get.
Probably not the game never came out in Germany like 99.9% of jrpgs.
RPGs were popular in Deutschland but I don't know about JRPGs (still can't figured out what makes Japanese RPGs different to normal RPGs lol)
@@SoapheadPog the problem with jrpgs. is that before the PS1 they never came out outside of Japan and north America. even the most successful games.
0:14 for a couple frames it says "YO MAMA 2" lol
Link's Awakening Japanese name is not exactly a spoiler of the end, because the Owl talks about "waking the dreamer" since the beginning and we get to know the true nature of Koholinth's island and it's eventual fate at the Ancient Ruins.
And Zelda II is Link's Adventure even in Japan, so it wasn't an English thing.
Yeah, I could've worded that better. I wasn't trying to imply it was exclusively the English titles that mentions Link's name, just it was a recurring theme with the early English titles.
@@kirotalksyt I wish it STAYED that way. I'm tired of people calling Link "Zelda".
Also. In Europe, Luigi's Mansion Dark Moon was changed to Luigi's Mansion 2.
Isn't it "Luigi's mansion 2: Dark Moon"?
@@uh3610 looking it up it does seem to be the case that it's just "Luigi's Mansion 2"
(and the one of the JP title's is ルイージマンション2 which is basically "Luigi Mansion 2" written in hiragana and katakana so it is closer to that title)
interesting
@@aceae4210 just katakana. Though, a merger of the two names as believed to be the reality by Definitely Not British does make more sense to me.
i was thinking of sonic unleashed being sonic world adventure in japan
Sonic Unleashed was originally going to be a true sequel to Adventure 2 (hence the name "Sonic World Adventure" in Japan), but knowing Sonic Team's previous game in the franchise (Sonic '06), the game's concept was changed. I guess the name change outside of Japan was so that people wouldn't think of it as an "Adventure 3".
That's a good one. I actually like both titles.
One of the first things when I saw the title was the Yakuza/ Like a Dragon series. The numbers are all the same worldwide but the outside of Japan its known as Yakuza instead of Like a Dragon. And Like a Dragon 7 was known as Yakuza: Like a Dragon.
And the western release of the fourth and 5th game also lacked the subtitle, with the 6th game's subtitle being slightly different (poetry of life in Japan, song of life in the west)
Wipeout 2097 was renamed to Wipeout XL in the US as Sony were genuinely worried that Americans might wonder what happened to the previous 2095 sequels!
Larry Bundy comments like a mofo
…
"I'll save those for another time"
Now I guess we need to wait for the bonus video, right?
Stay tuned.... :)
@@kirotalksyt don't forget to correct yourself with the clusterfuck that is the zelda timelines
"Fire Emblem: Wind, Flower, Snow, Moon" title is derived from a Chinese poem and represents the change of scenery with the passage of time and the seasons that come and go with it, fitting the game's various time related mechanics and story.
The localized title is "Fire Emblem: Three Houses", which with the DLC there's now 4 Houses. Not on the fortunate side of title changes I'd say.
I particularly like when series try to reunite the different names in different regions... recent years seeing the release of both "Resident Evil 7: Biohazard" (released in Japan as "Biohazard 7: Resident Evil"), and also "Yakuza: Like a Dragon".
Interestingly, this stuck for one but not the other... subsequent games have kept the "Like a Dragon" name, dropping "Yakuza", but "Biohazard Village" still got renamed to "Resident Evil Village".
Also, whichever graphic designer managed to pull off the "hide a 7 in the logo" trick for both names of RE7 deserved to be paid way more than they probably were.
And usually because of trademark reasons if that name was already taken or too similar in the west. Dragon Quest was called Dragon Warrior in North America until renamed in the 8th game. Star Fox was called Starwing and Star Fox 64 was called Lylat Wars in Europe. Resident Evil was Biohazard.
Other mentions include the Castlevania games are various names of Demon King Dracula and World of Mana games are Seiken Densetsu (Legend of the Holy Sword) in Japan.
My favourite are the DS Layton games. Curious Village stays the same. But the next 3 change depending on Pal or the rest of the world.
You have Pandoras Box, Lost Future and Spectre's Call in Pal Regions, while theyre called Diobolical Box, Unwound Future and Last Spectre.
I personally prefer the Pal names but I grew up with them so I would.
*Fun Fact:* After Final Fantasy 6's success worldwide in both Japan & America. Square for a short period of time decided they wanted to go back and localize Final Fantasy 5 for the SNES as a spinoff in America and title it "Final Fantasy: Extreme" for the game's more "extreme" gameplay mechanics compared to other FF games at the time. "Final Fantasy: Extreme" didn't really go anywhere until after FF7's genre and history defining success everywhere where Square finally decided to give American fans FF5 through a Final Fantasy compilation game
The Capcom fighting game series "DarkStalkers" is actually called "Vampire" over in Japan, primarily because Demitri Maximoff was intended to be the main character in the series despite that role going to the likes of Morrigan Aensland, who is a succubus. If I'm gonna be honest, though, I definitely prefer the name change for series when it was released internationally, especially since all the other characters in the games are not vampires at all, which would make perfect sense if not everybody likes to play as Demitri and/or Morrigan.
PLEASE do more, ive always loved finding out what games have been called in different regions!!! scratches that itch of curiosity in my gamer brain :)
As always, wonderful video!
The series is called Mother because of the song by Jhon lennon, following the music theme of the series , and The name makes sense in the context of the story, with the whole María and Giegue relationship
In South Korea, Super Mario Galaxy is called "Super Mario Wii". I'm not exactly sure why they made this change.
Does anyone remember Super Mario Bros. 2? You know, that incredibly hard and troll-like sequel to the original? Or the fantastical game where the main four go to Subcon?
0:52 You called that because Piñatas como from the viceroyalty of New Mexico.
Really enjoyed the video! I think this topic is super interesting. I do wish you mentioned how some games like Pac-Man 2 changed their names for brand recognition, and to increase sales, but oh well. Maybe you could include it in a second part perhaps?
9:56
Glad you enjoyed it. Sure, I'll keep that idea in mind for a future video!
1:32
Funny you should say that, as that's literally the exact thing that happened with the original King's Field trilogy on PS1. In amusing twist, the reasoning for the first not being localized is similar to Final Fantasy II and III, being that King's Field II released in Japan not long before the PS1 released in North America, so it was localized instead of the first one
The Mysterious nut sounds like a game where Link goes on a quest to find who his father is.
Fire Emblem’s naming convention got weird for a bit when they first brought it to the states. Since it was the first game in the series in the west it was just called _Fire Emblem_ though in Japan it’s _Fire Emblem: The Blazing Blade_ and was the 7th game in the series. You’d think the first game in Japan was called Fire Emblem but nope! It’s _Fire Emblem: Shadow Dragon and the Blade of Light_ not to be confused for the remake, _Fire Emblem: Shadow Dragon_
Salamander; the spinoff to Gradius, had its name changed to Life Force for the North American NES release. Salamander for arcade actually received a re-release called Life Force; which goes further with the visuals representing the official backstory of you being inside a gigantic space organism.
Metroid Prime 2 Echoes is actually called Metroid Prime 2 Dark Echoes in Japan. Dark Echoes make sense considering Dark Samus and that there are objects that you can see in Light Aether but can only be interacted with in Dark Aether.
Due to legal kerfuffle in Europe; Star Fox was called Starwing and Star Fox 64 was called Lylat Wars.
Fire Emblem: The Goddess of Dawn became Radiant Dawn; which is fitting since the previous game was Path of Radiance (Path of the Blue Flame in Japan).
Story of Seasons is in fact the Harvest Moon series in Japan (called Farm Story there).
Due to licensing issues around 2010, Sega has to call the arcade re-release of Daytona USA as Sega Racing Classic (though the HD home console version was able to have the Daytona USA title).
Dark Cloud 2 is Dark Chronicle in Europe and Japan.
I'm surprised you brought up Mario without mentioning Super Mario Bros 2.
Japan: Sonic & Tails 2
USA: Sonic triple trouble
Same for Sonic & Tails 1, which is Sonic Chaos.
The best part is this double naming was so easily decided that leaked beta build have title screens that say "Sonic and Tails or Sonic Chaos"
Jeez Christ this channel video quality makes it seem like the channel made it past 1m subscribers a while ago.
European Mario & Luigi titles are like Protoman in the Ruby Spears Mega Man cartoon
In Japan, Resident Evil is called Biohazard and Resident Evil 7: Biohazard is titled Biohazard 7: Resident Evil in Japan
Biohazard makes a Lot more Sense as the title of the series but Resident Evil Just Sounds cool
I got to give it to Capcom when it comes to making fun of there localization names are there the top of the line.
Same how as far as I know the Dr. Light equivalent in the Battle Network series name are the Japanese words for Light and Right as a reference to how in the main series he is called Dr. Right in Japan and Dr. Light in the West.
I hoped you make another one of these videos. There's a lot to talk about. For example: Street Fighter Alpha's name in Japan is Street Fighter Zero and Resident Evil's is Bio Hazard. In both cases I think the original name is better. In Street Fighter because these games are a prequel to the first games, so they are the number zero and in the case of RE because the games are about a literally bio hazard.
Second cousin 2 would be a hit in the south.
Boy, are there quite a few examples of these out there, even including those already mentioned in the video. What an interesting topic, indeed!
Actually, with MOTHER 2 in particular, I tend to refer to it as its Japanese name rather than EarthBound because while the latter title is pretty cool, it does feel kinda weird to call the second entry in the MOTHER trilogy something else entirely. This is just how I feel though.
Fun fact: Pacman at the time of its original release in Japan was titled "Puckman", but when they released the game overseas, they changed it, due to worries of the title being defaced to make it look like "F***man"
"The mysterious nut"💀💀💀
Mentions name changes for the Mario RPG series, and yet no word on the who Super Mario Bros. 2/The Lost Levels/USA debacle...
Yes, they're two different games. Just find it funny that "Super Mario Bros. 2" refers to two completely different games depending on what country/region you live in.
The best part is the US version was released in Japan as Super Mario bros. 2 USA so Japan got 2 Super Mario bros. 2 games.
0:14 "YO MAMA 2 "👌💀
I would like to know the reason behind more obscure game title changes. Like, why was Dewprism changed to Threads of Fate? Why was Poison Pink changed to Eternal Poison? And why was Demento changed to Haunting Ground?
Yeah, whenever I do get around to making a Part 2 to this, I plan to tackle a bigger variety of stuff.
Its called mother because of the song mother by john lennon
i never got why a usa (an ntsc region) version of a game is named differently from the uk (a pal region) version when both of the countries speak the same language. it always bugged me.
Yeah, it is very odd, and a lot of the time, like with Dream Team Bros., it seems super random.
Basically everything involving ninjas used to be censored in PAL regions, leading to a lot of name changes, but I've got no clue about anything else.
I think a large part of the reason is that the UK is Governments by a General Europe centered branch of the company meaning all of the EU will often get the same thing.
So the UK get the EU's team's branding rather than the US ones.
Because 90s game localisers just loved changing things for no reason.
Sometimes copyright issues necessitated the name change. Examples were Rockman > Megaman, Biohazard > Resident Evil and Star Fox > Starwing/Star Fox 64 > Lylat Wars.
One of my favourite little name things, is Resident Evil 7. Which is Resident Evil 7 Biohazard, and in Japan it's Biohazard 7 Resident Evil.
BTW when Final Fantasy 2 3 and 5 got re-released they fix every names so JP FF3 is now FF3
I kinda like and despise name changes like that lol
I remember back in the day that I was getting into Final Fantasy, the first one I played was FFIII for the DS, when I tried to search for something about the game in the internet, FFVI always popped up like- "WHAT??"
Another one was Dark Chronicle and Dark Cloud 2.
I only had the demo version of Dark Chronicle for a long time and I wanted to confirm if the full game existed or not, but for some reason searching for "Dark Chronicle" never gave me enough information about it.
I ended up finding the full game by myself by pure accident, and years later that I found out that Dark Cloud and Dark Chronicle were part of the same series... I was really dumdum back then 😂
I suppose they could have called Final Fantasy 2/4 “Super Final Fantasy” in the west. Better or worse?
Better tbh, goes along well with other SNES titles
but then what would 6 be called?
could have run into the issue of calling it "Super Final Fantasy 2"
@@MasterLu551 super duper final fantasy
I remember Donkey Kong 64 was Donkey Kong: 6 and 4s
SpongeBob Creature from the Krusty Krab was simply called SpongeBob in Japan because apparently it's the first SpongeBob game to be released there.
Second Cousin 2 goes hard
I still don’t get why the Resident Evil games have different titles in Japan and America (especially considering they both used the other region’s title as the respective subtitle for each version of RE7)
Copyright issues lead to the name change.
@Tidepool Clipper is that what happened? I know that happened with Star Fox, but I never heard about that happening with RE
You can’t copyright real-world single-word titles in the U.S. So they changed had to change biohazard (one word) into resident evil(two words).
6:29 - How do you know they share a birthmother? It could be that they share just a father or neither and are adopted.
Yoshi's island implies they both share the same 2 parents.
@@pineapplepenguin1759 Which one of the YI's?
@@shocknawe SMW2: Yoshi's Island showed the stork deliver them to the same set of parents at the exact same time. Yoshi's New Island retconned it and showed that the stork brought them to the wrong parents, but the end of that game shows the stork bring them to the correct parents, and again, its just 2 people, and they are delivered at the same time
chronologically confused territory
Eternal arcadia was changed to skies of arcadia
If this ever gets a second video I love to see harvest moon in it
1:36 when did we get Mother 1?
Wii U Virtual Console
Ah yes my favorite game Yo Mama 2
Gravity Daze was changed to Gravity Rush outside of Japan & I can totally see why. I wouldn't buy the game if it was called Gravity Daze in my country, heck, I wouldn't be caught dead playing it.
Megaman is known as rockman in Japan. As in rock and roll. But that doesn’t necessarily come across
Why is "USA" written on top of the flag of Netherlands on the thumbnail?
What about Rockman, the Game changes too much things like the name of the caracters, and it's a little bit confusing, i really like the fact that You can call the two brothers in the series with the original names "rock and roll"
I know that protoman it's also the brother of megaman
BOI YOU MISSED CASTLEVANIA
Sometimes the Japanese names where silly and made up by people who didn't actually speak English. but a lot of times the changes where unnecessary. these days most stuff from japan becomes mainstream word wide. but in the 90s there was a huge filter that Americanised everything.
Even to this day a lot of stuff is still Americanised, and I mean outside of USA. There are people here in the comments saying "we have to use the titles used in USA to not confuse the Americans" ... a cause of Americanising the rest of the world. Even though USA could just learn from the rest of the world instead of the other way around.
@@Liggliluff Yea while it has become a lot better we have ben used to American stuff for a very long time now .if you count movies at least since ww2 maybe even ww1. and before that the uk was number one so same language .you need to go back to the days of Napoleon to find an era where English was not the number 1 language .
we should keep the same names to avoid confusion.
That remind me with Biohazard
Oh Sorry, I mean Resident Evil
Well, yeah
Japan: Xenoblade
Europe: Chronicles
Japan: Okay
The funniest thing is that it wasn't even going to be Xenoblade. Tetsuya Takahashi first called it Monado: Beginning of the World, likely to draw a line in the sand and move on from Xenosaga, which failed commercially, caused a big fallout at the company, and saw him removed as director from the second game onwards. Nintendo of Japan then requested the name be changed to Xenoblade to pay tribute and draw a clearer tie to Takahashi's previous work than was ever intended. And then Nintendo of Europe decided to change it *back* to something that was less of a clear tie to Gears and Saga, just like Takahashi wanted to begin with. Dude must be so confused.
@@barleybap9528 I'd say the name change made Takahashi make Xenoblade more in line with Gears and Saga. You can see it especially around the end of Xenoblade 2. 3 kinda ditches the heavy Xenosaga sci-fi but the callbacks and links are still there. N being pretty reminiscent of Grahf from Xenogears.
@@xenogen372 Yeah, definitely agree. The name was a last minute change of title with Xenoblade 1, but I think you see progressively more of that Xeno DNA slipping in as the series goes on. Saw so much of both Gears and Saga in XB3 when I played recently.
I hear the Oracle games were made by Dee in Japan
deez
More exmples...
Probotector - Contra
Star Wing - Starfox
Teenage Mutant Hero Turtles - T M Ninja Turtles
Mega Man - Rock Man
Wario Land: The Shake Dimension - Wario Land: Shake It
Probably many more examples. Probotector is the probably the biggest name change that I can think of. Says on Wikipedia that it's about a german law that they had to change the name from Contra to something else.
The thumb has US with the flag of Netherlands and Japan with the flag of China
genuinely confused why you dont get more views n have more subscribers
“Yo Mama 2”
HAHAHA THE TITLE SAID NÜT HAHAHA
I am honestly fascinated by the localisation decisions when localising between Japanese and English specifically. Also yeah, they definitely made the right call with the name of Earthbound in English.
Super Mario World is called Super Mario Bros. 4: Super Mario World in Japan.
what about the Mario and Luigi remakes
Wow! Those Legend of Zelda titles were definitely too long in Japan. I'm so glad they changed the titles over here
Everything is too long in Japan. Have you seen their movie titles? It's funny because on all other accounts they make things as small as possible, whereas America goes "the bigger the better", but for titles of any kind, they almost spell out the entire story, plottwists included.
@@PikaLink91 queue the jokes about light novel titles which can end up being a sentence or longer
one of the reasons is why the names got so long (sometimes) is that by having the title of the book or manga being a blurb can be a way to directly show whats unique about your thing from every other book
They're long for our standards and when translated, but not really that long when read in Japanese
But hey, they sure are used to long titles already
Yo mama 2 knocked me out hard
Personally i don't mind spoilers at all
Earthbound sounds better but mother feels like a better name
Japan hits you with the classic: The Legend of Zelda: It Was a Dream the Whole Time Spoilers
why does the SNES have a different shape in japan
Because so did the NES. Europe's SNES was the Japanese model though.
Because gaming companies in the 90s where just obsessed with changing things the worst one was the turbografx 16 the console flopped outside of Japan because of their decisions.
I would play Second Cousin 2.
we could simply have mother 2 and call it that here since the games started in japan. pokemon red and blue are red and green there.
Actually red and blue are blue there. Blue was like the yellow to red/green, an updated version and that was ported here as red and blue
5:00 super mario 64
The answer is simple: Because Bionic Commanda was originally called "Hitler's Resurrection: Top Secret".
I'm surprised you didn't mention this in the video, it was such a low hanging fruit lol.
Can you cntrl f "final fantasy" on your script of this video and give us the count because I'm dying to know.
30 Times!
I'm pretty sure FF5 was skipped because after FF4 got low sales in the USA, Square thought, "ok, maybe these games are too complicated for these dumb Americans" and they decided to make an entry-level RPG for the Western market, which was Final Fantasy: Mystic Quest instead of bringing over FF5.
When that also flopped, they went back to just releasing the main series, but by that time, FF6 was the newer, shinier, seeminly more appealing game.
(2:57) This claim about there being little known about the cancelled official FF2 NES US Localization is completely false. An prototype cartridge of Final Fantasy 2's NES Localization resurfaced to the public in the late 2000s and has to dumped on the internet for years now for anyone to play using an emulator (or reproduction cartridge on official NES hardware) to experience what could of been with the Final Fantasy series in America. There is also the website called the TCRF (The Cutting Room Floor) which dissects regional version differences as well as unused, planned, and cut content in video games which goes into the version difference between the Famicom version of FF2 and the cancelled NES version of FF2.
Who knows.
I like Earthbound as a name and don't think it's a bad choice, but I really don't think that Mother is as weird a title for English-speaking audiences as you suggest here, and heavily disagree that it's just gratuitous English for the sake of it.
I think it's very likely a reference to the English phrase Mother Earth (the title theme to the first game even has that title IIRC), which is a thoughtful and meaningful choice of title that fits with the themes of the series, even to a native English speaker's ear. In fact, I'd argue that it perhaps carries more meaning in the context of the series than "Earthbound" does. Again, don't think it's a bad change necessarily, and Earthbound has a nice ring to it, but I don't really agree that it was strictly necessary to change it.
It’s 100% a reference to the John Lennon song, do you even know how that is..?
@@fshoaps No it's not. Itoi has mentioned the Lennon song as being one of the many reasons he settled on the title, but it was more than just that. In a 1996 interview about Mother 3 he had this to say regarding the title:
今のゲームって非常に父性的なんですよ。父親の罠を息子が攻略していくみたいなね。だから母性的な匂いのするものを作りたかったんです。例えば、最初に円盤が出てくるけど、それはマザーシップだし、お母さんも出てくる。そんな母性（マザー）的な要素を入れたかった。それに僕たちって母親が作った人間なんです。父親が作った人間ってすごく少ないと思いますよ。
Here's a quick translation:
"There's a real fatherlike quality to modern games, you know. When a player plays them, they become like a son trying to solve the wily puzzles set to them by their father. So I wanted to make a game that instead had strong ties to motherhood. For example, the disc that appears at the start is called the Mother Ship, and your mother appears as a character in the game. I wanted to pack the game with elements like that that evoke motherhood. Plus, it's our mothers who make us who we are. I think there are very few people in the world who were made into the people they are by their fathers."
The John Lennon song is one factor in the choice of name, but it's absolutely not just a simple throwaway reference to a song title. If you're going to be rude to people, try to at least make sure you're correct.
He also didn't mention the Lennon song at all in his response in that interview, for what it's worth. So I think you're grossly overstating how much of an influence that was.
@@barleybap9528 Look at how much the game references the beatles, it’s not a stretch to say, that yeah maybe the name had a great deal to do, with lennons song.
@@fshoaps I mean it's certainly one thing Itoi has mentioned, and like you say, the game has a lot of western music references, with the Beatles a particular favourite. But you said that it was 100% a reference, and it's demonstrably not based on Itoi's own words.
Heck, I'd argue it probably wasn't even the main influence given that Itoi's quote that I cited above, the most commonly cited origin of the title among Japanese players, makes absolutely no mention of Lennon's song. But that's neither here nor there, and I'm not disputing that Lennon's song was one factor. I just take issue with you suggesting that the title is no more than a simple throwaway song reference, and implying rather rudely that I'm some kind of idiot for believing otherwise.
I'm from Europe. So are they brothers, or what?
Whats with your voice bro "japeean"
Comment for the algorithm
One case I recall that they drop out its localized title is Shin Megami Tensei. Originally, it was localized as "Revelations" in the first Persona and Last Bible games, but it isn't a title that really fits at all with the series. Shin Megami Tensei literally means "True Reincarnation of the Goddess", which is a really cool name and depicts the fact that the protagonists can summon mythological creatures. But for some reason, they kept the name in Japanese since Nocturne release... that at the same time is the localized name for Shin Megami Tensei III because the first two wasn't localized.
wrong usa flag bru 💀
8:47 I constantly see TH-camrs throwing these snarky quips around, and I genuinely fail to understand this logic. Just because the game came out 30 years ago, do you seriously expect everyone in the world to have already played it ? Because a game has been around for longer, does that take away its value in any way and our entitlement to enjoy its story fully blind ?
At least you put in a spoiler alert, but why even do that if you didn’t even care enough to give me a time stamp to skip towards to, so I ended up being spoiled anyways ? I mean yeah sure, it was about a cliche trope - but how would I know that ? Does that mean I cared less about not knowing it ? Congratulations, you just turned off a new viewer - which is a shame, because I genuinely enjoyed the rest of the video.
That's fair. Sorry you got spoiled. I'll be more careful with this sort of thing in the future.
I don't know whether to be baffled or genuinely impressed that you somehow haven't heard how the game ends. It's basically the "I am your father" of video game twists-you know it whether you've played the game or not. I've heard the game barely tries to keep the secret anyway, to the point where some refuse to even call it a twist.
I played the game but i never beat it maybe one day.