Black Hunter VS Samick Sage

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 ต.ค. 2024

ความคิดเห็น • 75

  • @tomvawter4531
    @tomvawter4531 3 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Helpful video. I agree with your recommendations. I have had a Black Hunter for almost two years with longbow limbs. It is a fine bow! But I am now looking for a more versatile riser with attachment points for a quiver, stabilizer, etc.
    There are traditionalists, those who like the latest compound bows and gadgets, and crossbows. It is all a form of archery. I enjoy it all. Many new Trad archers are hesitant to mount accessories on their bows to avoid criticism. Just do what works for you! I know plenty of hard core Trad hunters that shoot indigenous style bows but run cameras and constant surveillance on deer. Nothing traditional about that, but it works! There are far more archers than purists. Just enjoy archery, it is awesome. For us hunters, it is nice to have easily adaptable accessories.

  • @wataboutya9310
    @wataboutya9310 3 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    The black hunter looks like a great choice for people with small hands like myself. I say that because I have a number of recurves from the 60’s and 70’s like for instance, the Browning Cobra 2. It’s a beautiful bow but hard to shoot for me because the riser grip feels like the thick end of a baseball bat. Also, for a beginner archer I think it is better to just learn how to shoot well first and forget all the accessories . The biggest mistake beginners make is buying a bow to where the poundage is too much for them to learn proper form and creates bad habits right out the gate. Leave your egos at the door and start with a 35lb @28” bow. 55” long is a good length to start with as shorter bows like the Bear super mag are harder to learn with. Arrows can be a make or break also. If the arrow isn’t spined properly for your bow, you will have a hard time also. So many archers give up early because of all these things and never learn how to become the arrow which gives immense satisfaction when conquered.

    • @seanjorgenson8064
      @seanjorgenson8064 ปีที่แล้ว

      Even us experienced guys get tune lazy sometimes. Good thing there's off season.

  • @kerryschultz8503
    @kerryschultz8503 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Great info something I always wondered about. Keep them coming I'm watching. You got a new sub.

  • @UTxTheArchangel
    @UTxTheArchangel 3 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    Your general point is which is better for a beginner. My first bow was a Samick Sage, out the box I was hitting center shots. Its a very easy to pick up and use bow and out the box you don't really feel like you need to do anything to it. It has a big sight window, so it's easy to see and it's shelf just allows arrows to fly with little issue. To quote a great archer, Arrows go where you point. The Black Hunter is the sexier bow. It has less options, its shelf doesn't allow for arrows to just fly with minimal issue. Smaller window. But it's the sexier bow.
    Its easy to sell it as the best between the too. Its smaller, sleeker, has a nice pistol grip, has a nice name. While the Sage is bulky, heavier, doesn't have a name like Black Hunter. Black Hunter sounds like a comic book character. Samick Sage....it should've been call The Sage.
    Sage is for the gritty archer than wants the bulk and weight. Hunters that want clean hits.
    Black Hunter if you're in your backyard and you wanna show your non archer friends a nice looking bow.
    The thing that sets the Sage from the Hunter to me is growth. You can grow with the Sage. It's not just a beginner bow, it's an intermediate bow, its an experienced bow. Its a bow you'll likely keep using from first bow til it can't shoot no more. Where as the Black Hunter? It's a bow you'll end up hanging up on your wall. An advanced archer, experienced archer...would just get a better bow meant for the experienced and give the Hunter to their kid...or again mount it.

  • @xfactoroutdoors165
    @xfactoroutdoors165 3 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    I love the BH's but agree. The sage has more options and has more mass weight as well as a bigger sight window. Its a better bow to learn on.

  • @labtrainer09
    @labtrainer09 3 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Thanks for this; it's an unusual and helpful comparison. FYI, the riser on the Mandarin Black Hunter is 15" long. There seems to be disagreement about the length of the Samick Sage riser, but 21" is more commonly quoted than other lengths.

    • @frank-hd6ts
      @frank-hd6ts 6 หลายเดือนก่อน

      closer to 19 inches

  • @mrdyvig
    @mrdyvig 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Thank you so much for this video! I have been researching take-down recurve bows and these were the two I was considering. For exactly the purposes you referred to. I eventually get into bow hunting, but want to get good first so, as you mentioned, it's a clean kill. I have spent half my life camping, hiking, mountain biking ect. so I know the outdoors, but a bow would really make it a lot funner. thanks!!

    • @BrianHuynhPersonal
      @BrianHuynhPersonal 2 ปีที่แล้ว

      :0 did you ever get a bow? How are you liking it?

  • @tomgodzik1344
    @tomgodzik1344 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Great video. I'm going with the Black Hunter longbow 30# for 3D archery and shooting at a target. I will tune the arrows to the bow. I was looking for a very lightweight longbow. Thanks for sharing.

    • @BigRigOutdoors
      @BigRigOutdoors  3 ปีที่แล้ว

      If you want a really light weight longbow then check out the Old Mountain Mesa or the Mesa ll longbow.
      They are both high performance and extremely light longbows that are absolutely great bows for there price

  • @dwightemery5694
    @dwightemery5694 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    You can always drill a rise if you have the equipment to do it for mounting stuff... easy to do. LOL! As long as you do not mess up the strength of the rise or crack it... not sure about laminate for this... might buy a riser for my Black Hunter by itself and drill it out and see how that works later... any way... currently I prefer my Mongolian Horse Bow for traditional archery. It is the best... LOL! Beautiful comparison on these... thanks for your review and point of view.

  • @shankspony9369
    @shankspony9369 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    G'day Mr Rig. I think you are mistaken about the Black hunterriser not being cut past centre. Measure with string from the centre of limb bolt to limb bolt, will prove the riser is cut past centre. What they havent done is square out the shelf to the riser which would make it a true 'past centre' riser. Its a simple process to sneak a bit of wood out and square it up without compromising the structure of the riser. The vertical window side of the riser can do with a bit of a rasp to flatten the area where a rest can be glued to shoot plastic vanes. I did this for my kids as they are hard on arrows and the plastic vanes are cheaper. They are only shooting a 25lb BH longbow so the structural integrity isnt really the issue it may have been with limbs over 45lb. In your video, you say the BH isnt as good as the Sage for new archers, and harder to setup isn't really correct. A little bit of work with a wood rasp and sandpaper and the BH is a true 'past centre' bow. I haven't seen anyone do the 'modification' in a review, so perhaps you are interested? I know you shoot off the shelf, but squaring the shelf of the riser would also aid in that. PS, you do a great job with your videos. All the best and merry xmas.

  • @buckshot21000
    @buckshot21000 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I’ve actually been looking a the southwest archery spyder but I like the look of the black hunter. Thinking about getting into traditional archery. Been shooting compound from the beginning.

    • @BigRigOutdoors
      @BigRigOutdoors  ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Go with what ever fits your fancy, but start with low poundage first.
      If your a person that likes to use gadgets then a bow like the sage or any of its copies will be great for you.
      If you prefer a more traditional looking bow then the black hunter style would be great.
      Both bows are takedown so order a set of limbs in 45-50 pounds to hunt with when your ready and have a set of 30-35 limbs to practice with.
      Keep in mind though you will need different spine arrows for each set of limbs.
      For your hunting arrows I would recommend bump up one spin weight and add a weighted insert or use heavy points for higher FOC (front of center).
      That will help with penetration on game, also to DO NOT SHOOT really light weight arrows they could cause damage to your bow.
      Hope this helps have fun and shoot straight

    • @buckshot21000
      @buckshot21000 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@BigRigOutdoors thanks for the help.

  • @jimbrunett5025
    @jimbrunett5025 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    For me I don’t want a accessories. I think the riser on the sammick to be too big and clunky. Also I think the Allen wrench to tighten the limbs is a more secure system rather than just thumb screw. As far as shooting, I don’t see a lot of difference.

  • @sigmanarchery54
    @sigmanarchery54 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Yes sir that’s true. But I really like my black hunter, and mine to is cut past center. I will say I have the Ragim matrix and it’s a great bow also with all The taps in the riser it to would make a great starter bow 😁 I think it’s much nicer then the samick just my opinion though. Thank again take care my friend and God bless.

    • @BigRigOutdoors
      @BigRigOutdoors  3 ปีที่แล้ว

      I've got the ragim ordered should be here around Christmas

    • @aurelienbourzat9204
      @aurelienbourzat9204 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      BH is cut past center

    • @sigmanarchery54
      @sigmanarchery54 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@aurelienbourzat9204. Thank you sir.

  • @JohnPlissken
    @JohnPlissken 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I got the Black Hunter and I'm not a beginner. I'm just too poor for a hand made custom bow, and I don't want any accessories.

  • @clee5653
    @clee5653 ปีที่แล้ว

    Regarding noise, both the Black Hunter Longbow and Sage recurve are pretty loud. I have a Black Hunter longbow, and compared to your setup, I have to use larger puff balls and place them closer to the nocking point to reduce the noise, but it still feels loud afterward. My brace height at 7'' might be the cause. I don't live in a huntable area, and I've always wondered how quiet a bow should be to avoid spooking game. Anyway, thanks for comparing the two. I plan to own both before getting into custom bows.

    • @BigRigOutdoors
      @BigRigOutdoors  ปีที่แล้ว

      Most Black hunters like a higher brace height 7.5"-8" for most. Adjust your brace height a little at a time and shoot a few arrows after each adjustment to see if it gets quiter and use heavy arrows to help reduce noise as well.

  • @Bowfella
    @Bowfella 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I don't understand why most trad hunters keep all their arrows on a bow-mounted quiver. It just seems like a really easy way to lose or damage arrows. When I hunted with a mounted quiver on a crossbow I lost and broke many bolts, which are much much stiffer and shorter than my 31" trad arrows. Granted I hunt super thick bush which you have to hunt for a clearing harder than you do a deer.

  • @xxzoddxx6096
    @xxzoddxx6096 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Hi great video, i was thinking of buying my wife a Sage bow. What length and draw weight is your wife's bow and does she find it comfortable to shot?
    Thanks

  • @ji2898
    @ji2898 ปีที่แล้ว

    I agree with you 1000%.Black hunter is form and not function. Beautiful to look at but that's about it. Samick has longevity-dependability & functionality. if someone only cares about the looks go for the black hunter. otherwise go for the samick Better yet spend the money right away and get the high quality Bear grizzly made in the USA!!

  • @alchemicalanarchist
    @alchemicalanarchist 10 หลายเดือนก่อน

    The Black Hunter is faster than the Samick Sage. Depending on the arrow setup and poundage the BH is 20-30 fps faster. Speed of your arrow is a very important consideration when choosing a bow. Both the BH longbow and Recurve are faster.

  • @stevengoff5291
    @stevengoff5291 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I have killed deer with both thay are good in my book I have lots of bows

  • @ethanamldon5657
    @ethanamldon5657 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Check out the lighting archery ghost for a first timer black hunter price but has the inserts of the samic

    • @BigRigOutdoors
      @BigRigOutdoors  ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Sorry just seeing your comment, the lighting archery ghost is the exact same bow as the samick sage.
      The limbs will interchange.
      These bows are sold by many different companies under different names.

  • @jesseashmore8426
    @jesseashmore8426 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I would disagree for the very reasons your stating. Beginners should learn the bow without all the bells and whistles. The Black Hunter is $70 cheaper, so if it turns out to be something you not into, you've got less money it. If people get to the point where they want quivers, sights, and fishing reels on their bow, well they are no longer beginners and would probably want a nicer bow at that point anyway. Spend $110 on the Black Hunter at 35 lbs and then step up in weight and gadgets if you decide it's something you want to invest more money in.

  • @bobbyb7127
    @bobbyb7127 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Where to buy the mandarin duck longbow? They are not on amazon.

  • @aurelienbourzat9204
    @aurelienbourzat9204 3 ปีที่แล้ว

    For a beginner, you are right.
    Black hunter is more for advenced archer Who s on a budget

  • @dennishein2812
    @dennishein2812 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I’m looking to get a longbow with about a 40-45 draw weight. My draw length is 25”. I’m in a wheelchair an due to neck and spine problems I am losing strength in my arms to the point I can no longer even string my longbow or my recurve let alone pull to full draw. I’m worried I might even have to drop to 35lbs. I can’t afford a whole lot but I don’t really trust ordering from amazon or some of these other companies. Don’t know what ones you can trust. I have heard some good things about the black hunter though.

    • @BigRigOutdoors
      @BigRigOutdoors  3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      You might be better off getting a youth bow at 25# draw first to help strengthen your muscles and work up to your desired draw weight

    • @dennishein2812
      @dennishein2812 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@BigRigOutdoors I’ve got a bow exerciser that uses 4 different bands for exercise. So far I can only pull the first band. Pretty weak

    • @louisbailey4900
      @louisbailey4900 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Try an ILF riser from Lancaster archery. ILF risers accepts tons of limbs from scads of makers. So its a great way to chank your bow and weight for cheap

    • @dennishein2812
      @dennishein2812 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@louisbailey4900 thanks for the advice.

    • @billbarry2984
      @billbarry2984 ปีที่แล้ว

      I wouldn't go past 35# if having to shoot from sitting position, if you do you may find that you're over bowed! I'm just a beginner and I'm a little over 200 lbs and find that my 50lb limbs a bit to much for me, can't be accurate when shaking like a leaf from the pressure so I recently purchased 30lb limbs to build up my strength and form.

  • @DrawingTechnical
    @DrawingTechnical 3 ปีที่แล้ว

    991st Subscriber :)
    Thanks for the indepth video, I was lost between which one to get from these 2, I might just go for the Samick Sage.

    • @BigRigOutdoors
      @BigRigOutdoors  3 ปีที่แล้ว

      If you get a chance please check out the old mountain mesa or the mesa ll from 3rivers archery.com I can't recommend them enough.

  • @jimdaugherty5804
    @jimdaugherty5804 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    For backyard shooting? Black hunter gets my vote.

  • @RedmanOutdoors366
    @RedmanOutdoors366 11 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Very cool 😎👍

  • @dienovandale4299
    @dienovandale4299 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    What if you just wanna fling arrows man , I don't wanna kill nothing ! I don't wanna fish with anything but my rod , hey can you fling arrows with a fishing pole ?

  • @garyv3588
    @garyv3588 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I really do make a conscious effort to try to support American made products and to my surprise the majority of these wooden bows being sold on Landcaster Archery or Amazon are all bows made in Asia. The only true reputable American brand I know is made by Fred Bear and generally a wooden Recurve bow from them starts around $400 price point. Makes me wonder if there’s a genuine craftsmanship and quality difference from the cheap Amazon $200 Asian bows to something like a Fred Bear Traditional wooden recurve bow ? This is all stuff I need to do research on. What’s your thoughts on the subject is there a difference in quality and craftsmanship ??

    • @BigRigOutdoors
      @BigRigOutdoors  3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      It's more quality control, Ive bought a few bows over the year that have been as much as ten pounds off of what is marked on the bow there will always be a little swing poundage wise when buying mass produced bow usually 2-3#.
      FYI a lot of the bear compound bows are made over seas just food for thought.

    • @garyv3588
      @garyv3588 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@BigRigOutdoors That’s crazy didn’t even realize that these American companies outsource their stuff. What to believe even PSE traditional bows are made overseas WTF

    • @BigRigOutdoors
      @BigRigOutdoors  3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@garyv3588 the PSE recurves are a copy of the samic sage or the sage is a copy of the PSE haha.
      You can take the limbs from the PSE bullseye and another model I can't remember right now but you can slap them right on a sage riser and most other copies.
      Most economy class bows are made over seas even some big names.
      Heck even a lot of the high end scopes are made in China but assembled in the US cough cough Leupold! 🤣 Vortex and Nightforce.

  • @noelportillo8633
    @noelportillo8633 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I want the black hunter but I have super long arms even though I'm 5'10

  • @nenolaura2199
    @nenolaura2199 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Thanks a lot for making this video and the last one. I'm new and looking to purchase my first bow. Between these two bows which one is more quiet? I don't plan on hunting but I don't want to disturb my neighbors. Thanks again subbed.
    Also, I was wondering about the longevity of the two bows, which one is more likely to snap?

    • @BigRigOutdoors
      @BigRigOutdoors  3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Traditional Bows in general are very quiet, most of the time the arrow hitting the target is louder then shooting the bow.
      For example I often shoot off my back deck only a few feet from my kitchen window while my wife is making dinner and she never hears the bow shoot.
      Not to mention there are a number of ways to make a bow quieter with string dampeners and limb dampeners, heavy arrows and so forth. But the sage is a little quieter.

    • @nenolaura2199
      @nenolaura2199 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@BigRigOutdoors Thanks. I plan on doing target practice/shooting a tree in my yard, do you have arrow recommendations to go with a 35 pound sage. Carbon, Aluminum, specifics etc. I will call my archery store but it would be helpful to have your input as well.

    • @BigRigOutdoors
      @BigRigOutdoors  3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@nenolaura2199 if all your going to be doing is target shooting I would use aluminum or carbon.
      If you decide to hunt then the aluminum would fit for that purpose very easy.
      There is a sale on 3rivers archery web site for Easton aluminum arrows right now.
      Be sure you get the right spine arrow for your draw length and weight.

    • @waynejohnson6889
      @waynejohnson6889 3 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@BigRigOutdoors never buy aluminium - once bent they can never be straightened - wood and carbon arrows shoot great out of a recurve. You forgot to mention that with the same arrow weight and same bow draw weight - the Black Hunter is considerably faster that than the Samick - at least mine is.

    • @BigRigOutdoors
      @BigRigOutdoors  3 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@waynejohnson6889
      My samick sage shoots faster then my black hunter but that's because my black hunter is a longbow lol.
      Recurves usually run a little fast then most longbows of similar length and material make up.
      Aluminum arrows are great for beginners because of cost and if not bent badly they can be straightened if bent badly the you got a great bunny buster arrow or glue some fluflu feathers on and use them to shoot Ariel targets lots of fun.

  • @E-BikingAdventures
    @E-BikingAdventures 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    It's not so bad if you just wound the animal and it gets away because a sasquatch will get it.

    • @SteveSmith-ik3tw
      @SteveSmith-ik3tw 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Sam-sqanch doesn't tolerate waste. 😁

  • @miguelbinha
    @miguelbinha 3 ปีที่แล้ว

    Very good video!!!

  • @Chance-ry1hq
    @Chance-ry1hq ปีที่แล้ว

    Just out of curiosity, how many times have you been bow hunting with a -15 degree wind chill. 😂GMAFB.

    • @BigRigOutdoors
      @BigRigOutdoors  ปีที่แล้ว

      Well I lived in north central Indiana for seven years so I would say I've hunted in -15 wind chill more than a few times

  • @Иванпонимаете-г4ш
    @Иванпонимаете-г4ш ปีที่แล้ว

    Which is more durable ?

    • @BigRigOutdoors
      @BigRigOutdoors  ปีที่แล้ว

      They are both durable if you take care of then and don't use light weight arrows.
      Using arrows that are to light puts excess strain and vibration in the limbs and that counts for a large number of bow/limb failures

  • @dkoriss1
    @dkoriss1 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I think that is mostly because of the huge Samick's handle that makes this bow look so ugly, though both black hunter longbow and recurve are pieces of art. Not to mention how fast, acurate and flexible they are specially into the dense forests.

  • @alexyatsyuk70
    @alexyatsyuk70 3 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Well, samik has a longer heavier riser more steady, less torque.then limbs of samik are cnc made, whereas mandarind duck chinese b hunter are not, bhunter uses cheap fiberglass, samick uses veneers.and bhunter riser is very very cheap and soft, limbs stacking.not recommend

  • @fishingkayakssa7956
    @fishingkayakssa7956 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Side by side, and comparing them, the BH does not come close to the SS.

  • @marcuspetford1098
    @marcuspetford1098 ปีที่แล้ว

    Nobody likes a bulky strap-on. Especially in cold weather!

  • @FloridaCaptains
    @FloridaCaptains 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Said beginner at least 23 times

  • @noahsmith8988
    @noahsmith8988 10 หลายเดือนก่อน

    A little too much talking and not enough showing same old thing over and over and a beginner does not need them options

  • @ddeboy002
    @ddeboy002 3 ปีที่แล้ว

    Just stop hunting. Don't have to worry about a bad shot.