Can ovaries make new eggs? There's an old story scientists tell about human ovaries: that they are ticking clocks that only lose eggs, never gain them. Now that story might be changing, opening the door to new treatments for infertility and menopause. Listen to more on Unexplainable, Vox's podcast that explores big mysteries, unanswered questions, and all the things we learn by diving into the unknown: link.chtbl.com/unexp817
Seriously, while not knowing every single detail about fertilization, in my mind it was always a 50/50 job. At least our third world biology books got that much across.
as a russian i have been given The Children Encyclopedia when I learned to read on my own, where was this information, and also a bit about all the things in the world...
@@subifyouhatetiktokandreddit234 as someone who studied science in India I am particularly baffled how the United States find so many spaces to squeeze political agenda . Bruh
English is typically ordered left --> right, as are time-lines and cartesian graphs. It is possible that in some right --> left written languages like Arabic or Chinese the choosen tube may be different (also, the diagrams may not be ordered as a progression from bottom (entrance of the vaginal cannal) to top, but instead right --> left.)
Bruh i had like 3 years of health class in my american school system where they went over human reproduction a solid 4 times over multiple years. The school districts have a huge budget though bc of property taxes though so thats probably why
This video is actually short on the science sources (the 2014 paper being the single referenced source that revisits Emily Martin’s 1991 paper) besides the two individuals interviewed. All you’ve done is interviewed one pair of paper authors. Did you talk to more than the paper authors or authors of the critiqued texts? Approach problems with the textbooks rather than just citing the one or just approach it with an 8-minute subjective snippet? Viewers would have been better informed without the intro. Perhaps it should have actually been shorter there. Context to your point seemed lopsided. This video seems... off. Give it the academic rigor such a claim deserves.
@@americanbookdragon I'm sorry to read that. The good thing is that we have a whole life to keep learning new things 😊 By the way, i subscribed to your channel. It looks pretty interesting.
@@diezgp I've had problems getting back to normal on the uploads. My new laptop kept bluescreening and geek squad just now gave it back. Thanks for subscribing. 😊
@@tamaspacso9899 Though it seems you mean to compare US to a underdeveloped country here, you used the term 3rd world country. Well 3rd world country doesn't mean less or underdeveloped countries it simply mean countries that chose to remain neutral during cold war era i.e. nor they aligned with US neither USSR. Countries of 3rd world also called member countries of Non Align Movement.
@@commentsanitizer7929 Yes, Switzerland is third world country. Going by historical records it can be said as"Switzerland unlike many other countries is neutral by law. That means that it is was not allied with the NATO/US (first world) or with the Warsaw Pact (second world) during the Cold War, making it a third world country.".Some other European 3rd world countries are Finland, Sweden, Ireland.
Lol, I love how all people outside the US just assume Americans don’t know this. As an American college student I can assure you everyone I’ve encountered has known this since middle school. But education varies by state so it’s possible religious states didn’t do their due diligence, but that’s not the majority of the US
@@dawae2162 But the camera being racist is a real issue with sensors capturing light. Yeah the cameras are not "racist" but they have an issue. This is different
@@RodrigoroRex the problem is. you know we as a human still have a limit with our technology and stuff. One of them is with that sensor. And let me ask you, should we bring a racial problem on that kind of topic. I agree darker people have a problem but Like, should we bring how camera is design by white people. and other stuff that connected to white privilage and stuff. And they didnt include why blue eyed people was affected by this back then and actually japanese company that mostly promote white people as a model of the camera.
@Andree De haan, and ya I'm confused about the other reproduction methods too. I just thought I am not aware of those method, since I'm not much aware of this field.
Very surprised this video completely ignored the primordial follicle pool and follicle selection in which primitive eggs are induced to grow and then begin to actively produce hormones to try and inhibit each other until only one survives to ovulation. Seems like one of the most active and selective parts of fertilisation.
In Australia, you’ll learn the menstrual cycle in a lot of detail and a little less about the mechanism of fertilisation, but it’s definitely not skewed.
i think the reason biology textbooks don’t go into this much detail is because the way it’s explained in textbooks is easier to understand for people just learning about the subject. everything dosent need to have an agenda
This didn't go into any detail at all haha. They just picked what to say to make their point. Most of it is undoubtedly correct tho, the issue is there's a bunch of stuff they didn't go into that would have somewhat dampened their message
THIS is the comment I've been looking for! I'm currently in medical school and I found it confusing on what this video was actually for. The video was good on clarifying missing info on the aspects of fertilization but that's usually understandable since you're not supposed to force complex information on lower grade education. I don't think there was anything wrong to be honest, even the whole disclaimer thing felt forced
@@LavenderHV I’d like to think that the scientific details were left out because to a 10th grader they aren’t going to be useful. Misogyny isn’t the reason. The man basically does 1% of the work required for creating a child anyways, so don’t think that by shortening the story of how the egg is fertilized is misogynistic.
I'm a 10th grade indian, and my parents have never ever tried to have the "Talk" to me. My friends, are the ones who told me. I never knew that a parent is supposed to have a talk.
@Acer72 I love how its at a stage where you're comparing US education to third world education XD thats embarrasing for the 'greatest country on earth' as many yanks like to claim it is.
@@James-rc6qq the us has the second best education system globally. Does it really matter if your comparing it? The people who compare us to third world countries have often never been to a third world country. Don’t get me wrong, the us education system has its fault but no where near third world level. You comparing us to a third world doenst make the us any worse or better
It's all they care about. Not his knowledge and intelligence, nor his accomplishments, just his skin. Less than a decade ago she would be openly and rightfully declared racist and ignored. But not in the racist world of today.
funny, but it's sadly true.... they held the most power for the longest and collectively systematically subjugate oppress and abuse every other group. It's about dismantling it, and not ignoring the group responsible - not hating white men. But yes, more can be done to make clear that hate mongering against white men isn't the goal or solution.
Disclaimer: I usually really enjoy Vox videos (although I very much prefer Johnny Harris' now that he went solo) That being said, this video is ridiculous and at certain points I thought it was bordering satire.
I think they had no idea what to do and just grabbed a random topic and Made up a problem. Even thought vox is backed up from important international Banks and their perspective is fixed to favor them they usually do good news. I'm worried this is the first step in a lower Quality medium
I'm from South America, most of this is taught in elementary school (maybe those sonar waves are missing). It's probably the same in the US. Am i missing something?
Little sad that this video treats the public like they don’t know anything/much but I learned this in 5th grade lol. It’s all about how much a person wants to retain.
Or.. if you went to a private school that doesn’t care about anything other than academics and never teaches you anything about anything and calls it: The Parents Job
This video is ridiculous, everyone knows the process of an egg being fertilised IF THEY PAID ATTENTION IN CLASS. Ridiculous that were digging holes into this.
i payed a lot attention in class as science as a whole is something i am interested in (except for chemistry) and i didn't get to learn about this. and i am canadian.
The real question I would be asking is, “why is there two Fallopian tubes when you can just have one? Why have two testicals when you can just have one big ball?”
I'm not sure if this is why but I know Hitler only had one ball. I think he was born like that. I'm probably making a wild guess but it might have to do with the fact that if you lose one, you still have a backup one
This is almost exactly how I was taught about fertilization and beginning of human embryo in my school. I guess here in Europe we have higher standards than in the USA.
Ah yes, another European taking their unique experience, mistaking it for a general European experience and then comparing it to a misinterpretation of a general American experience.
Me too. European here. Also… the disclamer felt unnecessary, unless this is oriented to children, since I assume people would understand the type of reproduction it’s talking about.
I was taught this in middle school as an American, the writers either didn't pay attention in school or have just forgotten the information. Most schools don't even use textbooks anymore.
haha... spot on! It's a ridiculous parody of what someone who wants to accuse the left of being psychos would claim channels like Vox put out, and a leftie would probably deny vehemently that anything like this exists.. but then they'll see the video and find a way to start convincing themselves that Biology textbooks are problematic.. They'll probably request to go and read their kids' books and then post to social media to complain about the sheer sexism of biology books written by 'white men'.
Why shouldn't women be upset about being erased from a story they play such a vital role in? And who are you to tell women what they should and shouldn't feel? You have no business dictating what others are upset by
Vox, are you OK? Because if you want to spin off a science channel, you can just do that. Though I can't promise you'll be able to compete with channels like Scishow.
Who are you to police women having feelings about being erased from biology textbooks? There's a million actually useful, creative things you could be doing with your life instead, try doing one of them for a change
@@vacafuega There's a million other ACTUAL problems women have to face in today's society, try bringing those issues into the limelight instead of making up problems.
Unless your going to study this in further info and use it for a job. The basic story tells you what you need to know and no more. Making a feminist issue out of the reproduction story seems a little petty to me.
Why are you so mad, why should people not learn how the reality of the fertilization process? You can cry about feminism all you want, but why would you want schools to only teach half a story and not even tell it correctly??
Why is it bad that the egg plays a relatively passive role? This doesn't have to be a damsel in distress situation. If the egg wants to chill, LET IT CHILL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
FYI, minus the calcium boost at the very end, I was aware of all of this. I am American Midwest. Edit: I ran into this comment of mine again and while I can say I definitely did know these things I am definitely not so sure I had all this info at the time I should have had it
And I'm not actively researching this info. I learned biology in HS and College, gen eds. Like, yes, there is dramatically oversimplified language and I can agree with that, but I feel the thesis of this video is too black and white.
Same for me on all accounts. It seems like this is not an education problem, but a problem with whether these people cared enough when they learned in order to retain the information.
@@kamel30001 but the way of insemination is different and that's what we are talking about here? I don't know if you're too dense to understand the topic of the video but alright
No I don't. And it wasn't. And they missed alot that I actually got from a Seeker video because Seeker was focused on teaching rather than trying to find any way possible to say white man bad.
I'm a doctor and I'm MIND BLOWN BY THIS. Technically I knew all this information but still its so true that the books all portray it in a certain way! Love this video!
I had been thinking of unsubscribing because the container is just not very interesting to me anymore. This video made it easy to me to make my decision . Thanks for, it was nice while it lasted.
Question. Can we somehow prove that this was done at a time when all that information was available? Or is it possible that at that point parts of the fertilization explanation were a byproduct of educated guesses?
Equally surprised and proud of how many people in these comments are mocking this poorly executed video. Vox is going the way the History channel went when it started airing all those aliens shows 😂🤦🏻♂️
Can ovaries make new eggs? There's an old story scientists tell about human ovaries: that they are ticking clocks that only lose eggs, never gain them. Now that story might be changing, opening the door to new treatments for infertility and menopause.
Listen to more on Unexplainable, Vox's podcast that explores big mysteries, unanswered questions, and all the things we learn by diving into the unknown: link.chtbl.com/unexp817
Seriously, while not knowing every single detail about fertilization, in my mind it was always a 50/50 job.
At least our third world biology books got that much across.
It's better than being taught things that just aren't really correct idk
Exactly. This video was just splitting hairs.
what are you talking about?
True it's just easier to make jokes about seems not being fast enough.
Yup! We were taught the right way in my third world country
RIP my homies that went down the wrong Fallopian tube
😢
😂😂😂
😂🥺🙄
F
Hey, at least you're the healthiest one Corey👍👍👏
Anyone else just never had "The Talk?" Hope it's not just me.
I haven’t either lol
Same
My mom is a nurse so it was inevitable.
Traditional norms
Ok
As a European, I never even had "the talk" since I was just taught this in school.
my parents just gave me a book about it bruh
as a russian i have been given The Children Encyclopedia when I learned to read on my own, where was this information, and also a bit about all the things in the world...
I learnt all of this from the internet
@@okkasannan in Soviet Russia, baby makes you!
Same
"you've never heard of the egg" bro I'm past middle school.
Middle school to high school textbooks are what they referenced. Beyond Junior High.
Lol they just prove that the us school system has failed miserably
uhhh, no one said that? like, that's not a sentence in the video and you've grossly misunderstood what this video is about...
Before watching the video: the title feels like The Onion headline or something
fr
It's becoming hard to see the difference
This is what happens when you hire feminists
@@subifyouhatetiktokandreddit234 true
@@subifyouhatetiktokandreddit234 as someone who studied science in India I am particularly baffled how the United States find so many spaces to squeeze political agenda . Bruh
This is the most Vox video ever
truly
The disclaimer was def the most Vox moment.
As a whole though i still think the «cameras Are racist because they need light» video was more Vox
Disagree, their videos are usually well informed and objective.
@@SueMyChin I agree, but even must admit that the "there are many ways to make babies" thing was kind of ridiculous. Really, there are?
@@AaronLitz In vitro fertilization
also different question:
why when showing fertilization illustrations, why is they always focus on the left side fallopian tube and not the right one?
Really is it always the left one? That's interesting. Maybe because we start reading and writing from the left?
English is typically ordered left --> right, as are time-lines and cartesian graphs. It is possible that in some right --> left written languages like Arabic or Chinese the choosen tube may be different (also, the diagrams may not be ordered as a progression from bottom (entrance of the vaginal cannal) to top, but instead right --> left.)
Another video topic
Because textbooks aren't that big
@@mufasaiam7794 no not just in textbooks. in other illustrations too. have you not looked at other illustrations of this?
Ok wow, in Europe we have the “talk” in biology in elementary school
Depends where tho
Bruh i had like 3 years of health class in my american school system where they went over human reproduction a solid 4 times over multiple years. The school districts have a huge budget though bc of property taxes though so thats probably why
I'm in the UK/Wales. And we knew this since year 7.
(Grade 6)
I knew about it well before anyone talked it to me. Those 80s and 90s films of the reproduction system really helped me at 5 years of age.
Everyone should praise Albert Barillé
This video is actually short on the science sources (the 2014 paper being the single referenced source that revisits Emily Martin’s 1991 paper) besides the two individuals interviewed. All you’ve done is interviewed one pair of paper authors. Did you talk to more than the paper authors or authors of the critiqued texts? Approach problems with the textbooks rather than just citing the one or just approach it with an 8-minute subjective snippet?
Viewers would have been better informed without the intro. Perhaps it should have actually been shorter there. Context to your point seemed lopsided. This video seems... off. Give it the academic rigor such a claim deserves.
I am with you on this one.
The video has good scientific facts, but its main message (denoted by the title) seems rooted on a premise that it goes very little into depth on.
The american school system* I thought it was common knowledge, that's how it's taught to us in Europe
I haven't learned it that way either, and I'm not from the US, but the majority of text books are written over there.
Sadly not everywhere even in Europe
I learned it the right way in europe some 20 years ago, then again the accusations they make are kind of... vague?
TF are you talking about? This is literally common talk in biology class
I learnt it this way in India too
I usually don’t comment but this seems like raising an issue that wasn’t an issue to begin with
I think it's a pretty handy explanation. I never went through the education system and wasn't taught any of this.
@@americanbookdragon were you homeschooled?
@@diezgp No. My parents didn't teach me anything. I was educationally neglected. Didn't know math beyond addition until I was 18.
@@americanbookdragon I'm sorry to read that. The good thing is that we have a whole life to keep learning new things 😊
By the way, i subscribed to your channel. It looks pretty interesting.
@@diezgp I've had problems getting back to normal on the uploads. My new laptop kept bluescreening and geek squad just now gave it back. Thanks for subscribing. 😊
Everybody knows it takes two to tango.
most neutral ever
You guys haven’t found out how to asexually reproduce yet?
The doctor would feel sad if you said to them, especially when many of them help with Artificial Insemination.
EulaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaAAAAaAAAaaAAAaAAAA
You can Tango with a mirror but it's a bit boring :P
This channel is a meme nowadays
Lol right!
Because people don't watch the whole video, just the title
I learnt not even a single new thing.... Even the fact that American education is f
The us is starting to show that it's really a third world country. There is really not many social systems working properly (or at all) over there.
@@tamaspacso9899 Though it seems you mean to compare US to a underdeveloped country here, you used the term 3rd world country. Well 3rd world country doesn't mean less or underdeveloped countries it simply mean countries that chose to remain neutral during cold war era i.e. nor they aligned with US neither USSR. Countries of 3rd world also called member countries of Non Align Movement.
@@ramijr Switzerland is a developed third world country then?
@@commentsanitizer7929 Yes, Switzerland is third world country. Going by historical records it can be said as"Switzerland unlike many other countries is neutral by law. That means that it is was not allied with the NATO/US (first world) or with the Warsaw Pact (second world) during the Cold War, making it a third world country.".Some other European 3rd world countries are Finland, Sweden, Ireland.
Lol, I love how all people outside the US just assume Americans don’t know this. As an American college student I can assure you everyone I’ve encountered has known this since middle school. But education varies by state so it’s possible religious states didn’t do their due diligence, but that’s not the majority of the US
This is An American problem
As third world as Nigeria is , we know the real process of fertilisation
Really
@@biafra13743 yeah we follow British curriculum so the narrative is way different
@@aladeplays7884 yes I am Nigerian, I don't see why we should still be using the British curriculum
Ikr, I'm Zambian and the first time I learnt about reproduction was in grade 4 then again in grade 8 and finally in grade 12.
@@biafra13743 tbh its for the best , British curriculum is used by almost all English speaking Countries
Because they were colonised by them
Vox turned into Buzzfeed the second Borders and Earworm stopped 😔
They already did it when they made a video about how camera being racist.
@@dawae2162 at least you could strech that into saying that there'sracist photographers who can save this????
@@dawae2162 But the camera being racist is a real issue with sensors capturing light. Yeah the cameras are not "racist" but they have an issue. This is different
@@RodrigoroRex yes they arent racist, and who say that they are racist because of a technical issue??
Vox
@@RodrigoroRex the problem is. you know we as a human still have a limit with our technology and stuff. One of them is with that sensor.
And let me ask you, should we bring a racial problem on that kind of topic. I agree darker people have a problem but Like, should we bring how camera is design by white people. and other stuff that connected to white privilage and stuff.
And they didnt include why blue eyed people was affected by this back then and actually japanese company that mostly promote white people as a model of the camera.
Actually I learnt about most of the egg's role too.
we all did, someone has an agenda and created a dragon to slay
@@tomservo5007 I’m gonna nab that that’s sounds clever as f
FeMinISM
@@tomservo5007 I don’t trust men who use phrases like “had an agenda” unironically.
@@LangkeeLongkee I just don’t trust people in general. At least this way, I don’t hurt anyone else.
I personally (at least consciously) never saw eggs or females in a bad light, just because I thought the egg just stays there.
Yeah same
@Andree De haan, and ya I'm confused about the other reproduction methods too. I just thought I am not aware of those method, since I'm not much aware of this field.
@@Sivah_Akash In vitro fertilization.
Fr, I always felt like the women did everything! The title felt a bit of a mini attack on guys but oh well😂🤣
@@idonthaveaname8164 ivf is still reproduction between man and woman at the end of the day
Watching this made me thank my parents for sending me to a good school, can't believe that this isn't a common knowledge.
What are the different ways of making babies for "Other people" May I ask ???
IVF, IUI and many other forms of Artificial Insemination
Asking for donation😂 no offense
@@supreetmahurkar183 here?
@@madhusree1472 are we teaching those to children in schools?
@@SueMyChin I learnt it in my 8th grade and then again in 10th grade and 12th grade Biology but idk about every education system
Very surprised this video completely ignored the primordial follicle pool and follicle selection in which primitive eggs are induced to grow and then begin to actively produce hormones to try and inhibit each other until only one survives to ovulation. Seems like one of the most active and selective parts of fertilisation.
In Australia, you’ll learn the menstrual cycle in a lot of detail and a little less about the mechanism of fertilisation, but it’s definitely not skewed.
The need to add a disclaimer is nuts
Rock
i think the reason biology textbooks don’t go into this much detail is because the way it’s explained in textbooks is easier to understand for people just learning about the subject. everything dosent need to have an agenda
This didn't go into any detail at all haha. They just picked what to say to make their point. Most of it is undoubtedly correct tho, the issue is there's a bunch of stuff they didn't go into that would have somewhat dampened their message
Yeah I couldn't care less about the specifics of how it happens. Seems like they just wanna attack white men lol
@@JeffDvrx yeah, they picked the narrative that fitted their agenda
THIS is the comment I've been looking for! I'm currently in medical school and I found it confusing on what this video was actually for. The video was good on clarifying missing info on the aspects of fertilization but that's usually understandable since you're not supposed to force complex information on lower grade education. I don't think there was anything wrong to be honest, even the whole disclaimer thing felt forced
@@clydecledera2793 exactly!
Alternative title: how to waste money in useless research
The man in charge is definitely overdoing it.
Next up: Is math racist?
yes, yes it is you patriarch
The focus shouldn't be on the right answer! (modern leftism)
is genderphobic cause is binary xD
I'm pretty sure they already made that video. Actually I might be thinking of the one where they said sleep was racist.
Our number system was at least partly imported from India, via the Middle East.
🤷
"How to make an unproblomatic thing extremely problematic in 8 minutes or less"
the point is an airplane, it went over your head.
We are evolving just backwards
Everybody just want to work and have money. They dont care.
How is that? They telling scientific facts that are ignored because of misogyny
@@LavenderHV I’d like to think that the scientific details were left out because to a 10th grader they aren’t going to be useful. Misogyny isn’t the reason. The man basically does 1% of the work required for creating a child anyways, so don’t think that by shortening the story of how the egg is fertilized is misogynistic.
Might be time to stop watching Vox for a while o.o
Or just don't watch it ever
We've had the internet on a serious scale since 06, if you haven't googled this type of stuff you're using it wrong.
@Makise Kurisu How old are you?
@Makise Kurisu I'm 27 kid, we're not the same.
06 ewwww
@Makise Kurisu congratulation keep it up high schooler 🎇🎆
Cause you google any random thing ever?
Hey don't be so harsh it's the only race I won
💀
You didnt won the race you where chosen by the egg cell
You did awesome my dude congratulations
@Mavrick Schofield We all are.
@@ludwigjosh9619 that's how a lot of races are won
Make a video on why periods are misogynistic
Next video why MENstruation starts with men 😡😡
Loooooooooooooooolllll
I'm a 10th grade indian, and my parents have never ever tried to have the "Talk" to me. My friends, are the ones who told me. I never knew that a parent is supposed to have a talk.
That's the life of an average Indian teenager bro 🤣
Lol, same. Indian here, and I got majority of my 'the talk' from internet and some of it from friends
@@the1stmetalhead its same in Pakistan too haramipan me subcontinent badha aage hai
I am Indian and this is true
they only care about your academics 😅
How poop got the credit for fertilizing soil.
How farmers got credit for planting corn.
vox crying cuz nature is sexist 💀💀
This is when you realize that sometimes third-world science education is better than U.S. education -_-
It's always better
I've been in a US system school, my dad, in a third world system. The US system is worse.
@Acer72 I love how its at a stage where you're comparing US education to third world education XD thats embarrasing for the 'greatest country on earth' as many yanks like to claim it is.
@@James-rc6qq the us has the second best education system globally. Does it really matter if your comparing it? The people who compare us to third world countries have often never been to a third world country. Don’t get me wrong, the us education system has its fault but no where near third world level. You comparing us to a third world doenst make the us any worse or better
@@apdifpapdjaapickgspjakf5937 according to what source? because most sources i found had the US outside of top 10, some out of top 20
This is satire, right? They can't be for real
this sounds like feminism
It is. This is so ridiculous I laughed through the whole video.
@@clockworkorange7064 it’s sadly not, vox is very left wing
@@josephortega6080 can you elaborate pl?
@@piggynatorcool668 what's wrong with feminism?
Feel free to jump to 7:00 for the answer to the question in the title.
The answer is "the white man" in case you're curious.
They're not wrong, when you really unpack everything, but this feels like a cheap virtue signal for the liberals
It's all they care about.
Not his knowledge and intelligence, nor his accomplishments, just his skin. Less than a decade ago she would be openly and rightfully declared racist and ignored. But not in the racist world of today.
Thanks.
funny, but it's sadly true.... they held the most power for the longest and collectively systematically subjugate oppress and abuse every other group. It's about dismantling it, and not ignoring the group responsible - not hating white men. But yes, more can be done to make clear that hate mongering against white men isn't the goal or solution.
“If you’re not first, your last” - Talladega nights and egg fertilization
Disclaimer: I usually really enjoy Vox videos (although I very much prefer Johnny Harris' now that he went solo)
That being said, this video is ridiculous and at certain points I thought it was bordering satire.
I think they had no idea what to do and just grabbed a random topic and Made up a problem. Even thought vox is backed up from important international Banks and their perspective is fixed to favor them they usually do good news. I'm worried this is the first step in a lower Quality medium
The sad part is that he didn't "go solo", Vox let him go when travel got banned because of covid, he didn't really want to go solo
@@jgzales1 they've been low quality since their first video. You're just now catching on to what vox haters have been seeing the entire time.
0:23 "For someone who just gestated and delivered a human baby"
Aah yes, we all be dropping kangaroo babies every weekend aren't we.
Maybe you haven't noticed, other animals give birth to "babies" to.
@@Joshua-dc4un Aah yes i too have personally seen a kangaroo deliver a HUMAN baby
@@princess_consuela lol
I love it how she had to mention that it was WHITE males who first discovered this. Is the color of there skin relevant somehow?
Yes, because white skin is racist and sexist…
Well it's just a fact. And your racial status does affect how you think and see the world, especially back in the day.
Everything is now racist
Remember this channel once made a video about how camera was racist
@@dawae2162 Oh yeah I almost forgot about that one!
They blew half the budget on those biology books
I'm from South America, most of this is taught in elementary school (maybe those sonar waves are missing). It's probably the same in the US.
Am i missing something?
I think it was just an informative video with some extra social issues thrown in
(they were chemical signals btw, not sonar)
@@8ball708 no social issues. Just a bunch of attention seeking feminists
Well based on the study it seems most American biology text books don't describe the fertilization process as it really is
@@1eV you are weak though. Always make excuses.
“Only. passive. language.” OHHHH GODDDD THE HORRORRRR
🤣🤣🤣
Like how Vox doesn't want to get cancelled with that "disclaimer"
"There are different ways of making babes for different kinds of people"
Wait what??!!
I think I need a part 2
I assume they mean In Vitro fertilization.
prolly in-vitro
@@4knewt505 I think the people talking in this video need a part 2.. and be less politically charged
@@Giacumein can we just talk about science? People will breathe and y’all are like “STOP BEING POLITICAL”
Little sad that this video treats the public like they don’t know anything/much but I learned this in 5th grade lol. It’s all about how much a person wants to retain.
Or.. if you went to a private school that doesn’t care about anything other than academics and never teaches you anything about anything and calls it: The Parents Job
*how badly educated the person wants to be
The egg yoke just got WOKE....chirp-chirp-chirp, tweet-tweet-tweet
This video is ridiculous, everyone knows the process of an egg being fertilised IF THEY PAID ATTENTION IN CLASS.
Ridiculous that were digging holes into this.
i payed a lot attention in class as science as a whole is something i am interested in (except for chemistry) and i didn't get to learn about this. and i am canadian.
@@erei5659 how old are u?
@@erei5659 I'm Canadian and I was taught this in the 5th grade. What part of Canada are you from?
@@erei5659 homie I was in 5th grade when I learned this but that might be an Ontario thing ngl
Sometimes school is wrong
The real question I would be asking is, “why is there two Fallopian tubes when you can just have one? Why have two testicals when you can just have one big ball?”
Question of the century
@@unrulyrhyme7139 question of the eon
I'm not sure if this is why but I know Hitler only had one ball. I think he was born like that. I'm probably making a wild guess but it might have to do with the fact that if you lose one, you still have a backup one
@@Ricky911_ you can’t live life without risks 💀 one nut, take it or leave it.
well we also have two kidneys and two lungs and two halves of the brain and stuff... I don’t totally know the answer to any of these lol
this dude really just called fertilization an awesome two player adventure im dead
This is almost exactly how I was taught about fertilization and beginning of human embryo in my school. I guess here in Europe we have higher standards than in the USA.
Some schools
yeah europeans are so smart thats why you losers cry when you dont get approved for a green card to study/live in the U.S.
@@kkuo13 its not 1999 anymore boy, Europe is far better place to live now than USA.
Ah yes, another European taking their unique experience, mistaking it for a general European experience and then comparing it to a misinterpretation of a general American experience.
@@sypialnia_studio Was it worse in 1999?
America really do be living in the Middle Ages when it comes to education
It’s sexist so I guess not too far off
and yet somehow we still winning 😁
Ok im weirded out. Is this an american thing or something?. Cuz everything he said is exactly how i learned reproduction at school.
YES
Me too. European here. Also… the disclamer felt unnecessary, unless this is oriented to children, since I assume people would understand the type of reproduction it’s talking about.
theres something wrong with my brain when i click on that title
i grew up in the us and I literally learned everything explained in this video,
I didnt
@@silentj624 now you do. congratulations
@@silentj624 Congrats I learned the same thing in Africa. And before I knew that I already had the common sense that it takes 2 two tango
Good for you, no one asked
what has this channel become
I was taught this in middle school as an American, the writers either didn't pay attention in school or have just forgotten the information. Most schools don't even use textbooks anymore.
6:10 OH COME ON I WAS TRYING SO HARD TO GIVE THIS VIDEO THE BENEFIT OF THE DOUBT BUT THATS RIDICULOUS
50% interesting educational content
50% unnecesary feminest layer on top of it
This channel is the left equivalent of prager university
haha... spot on!
It's a ridiculous parody of what someone who wants to accuse the left of being psychos would claim channels like Vox put out, and a leftie would probably deny vehemently that anything like this exists.. but then they'll see the video and find a way to start convincing themselves that Biology textbooks are problematic..
They'll probably request to go and read their kids' books and then post to social media to complain about the sheer sexism of biology books written by 'white men'.
Man, of the things to be upset by, this probably isn't a priority
Why shouldn't women be upset about being erased from a story they play such a vital role in? And who are you to tell women what they should and shouldn't feel? You have no business dictating what others are upset by
@@vacafuega We're literally born from women, who's exactly being erased?
@@vacafuega You need some serious help
People should know basic biology
@@vacafuega my dude they grow the baby in their body what's more vital than that
This guy gives off “where my hug at?” Vibes
Vox, are you OK?
Because if you want to spin off a science channel, you can just do that.
Though I can't promise you'll be able to compete with channels like Scishow.
Vox, just start up Vox Borders again.
seriously
nah won't be the same without Johnny Harris
Vox Borders was one the best things on TH-cam. Now you get this..
We need Borders
They need to find a border that is sexist, racist and transphobic.
Don't worry though... they will.
This is the most Vox title I’ve ever seen.
Really strange combination of interesting information and eye-rolling over-sensitivity
Who are you to police women having feelings about being erased from biology textbooks? There's a million actually useful, creative things you could be doing with your life instead, try doing one of them for a change
@@vacafuega There's a million other ACTUAL problems women have to face in today's society, try bringing those issues into the limelight instead of making up problems.
1:25 my dude just throwing around $1000 worth of books.
Tbf you didnt offer much of a different story you just talked about the specifics.
Patriarchy. Saved you a click.
@Tardis_Kia yes it does :)
@Tardis_Kia kinda funny how you think that, Patriachy still has its effect on us tho just saying
@@DanielJohnNicholson explain to me how women go to college way more than men
@@DanielJohnNicholson the "patriarchy"has made western women the most privileged group in world history
Hosea Jackson Yet men still get paid more. I’d consider that a privilege.
Unless your going to study this in further info and use it for a job. The basic story tells you what you need to know and no more. Making a feminist issue out of the reproduction story seems a little petty to me.
Why are you so mad, why should people not learn how the reality of the fertilization process? You can cry about feminism all you want, but why would you want schools to only teach half a story and not even tell it correctly??
@@xxxfairycorpsexxx7592 You are like that kid that found your school is not perfect and now thinks the world is out there to oppress you.
@@scientia.veritas bruh i just don't want schools to lie to students and teach them wrong information lol
3:06 the fact that this even has to be mentioned is a bit outrageous
No one:
The route my parents said they took to get to school:
That's creative
Why is it bad that the egg plays a relatively passive role? This doesn't have to be a damsel in distress situation.
If the egg wants to chill, LET IT CHILL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Because it doesn't actually play a passive role? So saying that it does is a lie by omission. Someone didn't watch the video properly :)
Definitely didn’t learn a lot of this stuff
Because it's the only independently moving part making it feel like it has its own life, while eggs feel more like an organ like a liver
Makes sense
Oh no it's much more complex dude! The eggs also goes through a great deal
@jay frost The ones that believe it to be unnecessary are boys/men.
@@SpringLeafWolf if men are 99% of the population then yes.
@@SpringLeafWolf sexism much. How can you assume that
Notice how neither of them are actual scientists
LOL
FYI, minus the calcium boost at the very end, I was aware of all of this. I am American Midwest.
Edit: I ran into this comment of mine again and while I can say I definitely did know these things I am definitely not so sure I had all this info at the time I should have had it
And I'm not actively researching this info. I learned biology in HS and College, gen eds.
Like, yes, there is dramatically oversimplified language and I can agree with that, but I feel the thesis of this video is too black and white.
Congratulations a lot of people dont
Same for me on all accounts. It seems like this is not an education problem, but a problem with whether these people cared enough when they learned in order to retain the information.
What is the other way of making babies vox? Is it storks, fairies or hallucinations?
Artificial Insemination like IUI, IVF?
@@madhusree1472 still a man and a woman 😁
@@kamel30001 but the way of insemination is different and that's what we are talking about here? I don't know if you're too dense to understand the topic of the video but alright
@@kamel30001 sounds pretty insensitive man
@@kamel30001 still you being uneducated
People can think whatever about vox (i like them) but you have to admit this was very informative and i actually learned A LOT.
True, in my country they just explain it like is the one that arrives first lol
No I don't. And it wasn't. And they missed alot that I actually got from a Seeker video because Seeker was focused on teaching rather than trying to find any way possible to say white man bad.
I'm a doctor and I'm MIND BLOWN BY THIS. Technically I knew all this information but still its so true that the books all portray it in a certain way! Love this video!
I had been thinking of unsubscribing because the container is just not very interesting to me anymore. This video made it easy to me to make my decision . Thanks for, it was nice while it lasted.
good choice dude. Hope more people run away from Vox
seriously? people get offended with medical text? grow up karen
At this point, Vox is just a joke
True, although anything not related to politics is still great though
@@pombenenge But with vox, everything that isn't politics is "systemic oppression and" "white supremecy"
*Hit or Miss*
*This was a miss, Vox*
This is called looking for problems where there aren't any.
Their was time when we were kids and our elders told us "an angel came and drops the baby"
Storks are more fun
Question. Can we somehow prove that this was done at a time when all that information was available? Or is it possible that at that point parts of the fertilization explanation were a byproduct of educated guesses?
Remember when you guys accidentally doxxed John McAfee and got him arrested and murdered? lol
7:25 Normal human beings know that fertilization is a two-way dance. This lady is imagining things to be outraged by.
I honestly think that vox might be reading into things a bit much here.
You didn't even need that disclaimer!
So glad you're tackling such important social issues, Vox!
I can't tell if this is sarcastic or not
Hahahahahahah Vox is slowly turning into BuzzFeed
Equally surprised and proud of how many people in these comments are mocking this poorly executed video. Vox is going the way the History channel went when it started airing all those aliens shows 😂🤦🏻♂️
I guess women would seem like aliens to you, since you've obviously never met one up close... At least, I hope not for her sake!
@@vacafuega Cope harder fem1nist
Because this is a subtle agenda
Ancient aliens.
A man was walking weirdly, was he an extraterrestrial creature?🦀
Why is this a video? Seriously, who was the blue haired brain that asked?
So many Einstein's were wasted on a piece of toilet paper.
"Everybody I talked to all told me different stories that had a lot of holes"