Laphonza Butler Presses Mark Zuckerberg About Face Filters That Cause 'Self-Hate' In Young Women
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 30 ม.ค. 2024
- At today's Senate Judiciary Committee hearing, Sen. Laphonza Butler (D-CA) grilled Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg.
Fuel your success with Forbes. Gain unlimited access to premium journalism, including breaking news, groundbreaking in-depth reported stories, daily digests and more. Plus, members get a front-row seat at members-only events with leading thinkers and doers, access to premium video that can help you get ahead, an ad-light experience, early access to select products including NFT drops and more:
account.forbes.com/membership...
Stay Connected
Forbes on Facebook: forbes
Forbes Video on Twitter: / forbes
Forbes Video on Instagram: / forbes
More From Forbes: forbes.com
![[TH] VCT Masters Shanghai Playoffs DAY 4 // 100T vs GEN | G2 vs TH](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/UkTGSxdCUQw/mqdefault.jpg)
Why do these parents roll over and give their children smartphones? When I was growing up, I knew families that didn't even have TV's. No smartphones until you're 21. What's wrong with that? The parents are the ones who buy the smartphones and pay the bills. They are responsible too.
Laziness
Exactly don't buy your kid a smartphone
I agree with you parent need to stop giving all the responsabilty of their kids to governement
Lol. The whole pandemic is conspiracy that has led to this further
21? You can vote and die serving your country in the military yet they shouldn’t have a smart phone?
Honestly, the best thing I ever did was turn off the notification badges from social media apps. It made it so easy to get off of them.
The best thing I did was delete all my social media 10 years ago.
I stopped using all social media a while ago and life is so much better without it! It’s a negative drain of your energy and produces nothing of any value!
Yes!
Social media had responsibilities, but I think we as parents should be more aware of what our children doing.
There really is no but…. Parents need to monitor what kids are doing. Period. Large tech companies need to be regulated so we can protect children. Period. There’s no but.
Face Filters are the most disgusting thing in recent times, Snapchat is so awful with this.
Where do you live? I want to go there. People driving drunk and destroying families, chld trafiking, drug overdose, poverty, open borders, weaponized legislation, chld Jenny Tell mutilation, two tier justice, inflation, and government coercive lies must not exist there If filters are the worst thing. Not to mention slightly undercooked pizza, forgetting your sunglasses, dropping mustard on your shirt, ads, a pebble in your shoe, getting a hair in your mouth, low battery, and hearing opinions like the ones held by the woman in the video are all far worse.
I'm thinking it's a very good time to remind them all that they are under oath
Under oath to what?
Like that means anything to them
Yea that doesn't matter to people without souls. It's shocking they even show up just to fill a chair with empty answers
They're ALL non-dualists.The only lives that matter are their own.
@@michaelzalecki5596
These people do NOT care whether they are or are not under oath. They are without morals, guided only by their perverse lust for numerous things, MONEY being high on that list
No one is talking about the addiction These apps cause for both children and adults
That’s all screens, not just apps.
The DEVICES don’t require parental controls for phones setup for certain ages and the next matter is parents don’t use them or set an age when setting up, that should be the law.
so dont go on it...the world is not that dificult
Well I think there may be other addictions that are killing people a little more vigorously. I'm not seeing people breaking into cars for Google play cards, standing on corners for data, or rotting and nodding when they have low battery.
Been off for 4 years, just my YT account.
I agree with ya
Bless you Laphonza Butler for bringing up the harm of the filters.
Amen. Teenagers loved having acne before snapchat came out. No girl had ever compared themselves to magazines, movies, pop icons, or models before Instagram. Life was perfect when they couldn't watch tiktok to see how makeup was applied to achieve the look they like.
No lie or cheat in the heart of Mark Zuckerberg but having the beauty and the truth in his heart. And no blood on the hands of Mark Zuckerberg but having the light on his hands. Really, he is a light for our planet that inherited by the nature. people of the world should create a global legal system for our planet with the contribution of capitalism and science. The time has come for the people of the world to get rid of the outdated American laws, Chinese laws, Russian laws, European laws, Asian and African laws that are creating crises in the earth.
I am so sad for the parents who lost their children .
its incredible how efficient congress can be when they're all on the same page. Lets go solve other problems together now.
right!
Except they arent. One party has been allowing a free flow of cartel members (and the substances they bring with them) into our country for more than 3 years now. As much as I despise most social media, they aren't directly responsible for any overdose deaths. Ms Butler's party is responsible for allowing this to happen for political gain imo, and that's beyond cynical and borderline treasonous.
Where's the efficiency? Blaming Snapchat for fentanyl because the feds have failed closing the border or stopping foreign cartels?? It's nice to see the CEOs squirm but it's not as if the government is in any position to criticize them on issues that they have much more power and resources to control, but have failed spectacularly.
@@hiddenhansexactly, X and Meta are scapegoats at this point, but there's plenty of blame to go around.
I heard them talking about it, maybe not this clip but in the hearing as a whole they sure did
EVERYTHING CAN BE USE IN A NEGATIVE WAY BUT ITS THE PERSON WHO'S CONTROLLING IT, THAT CHOOSES GOOD OR EVIL
Body dismorphia effects adults as well.
I’m 21 with BDD. Because of social media.
I have to say that social media needs to be regulated, but I also have to say parents are the largest problem, I did not allow my kids to have a cell phone until they went to college, no drama, no influence, no brainwashing, I also did not allow my kids to have a computer in their rooms, or a tv not a chance, it was downstairs in the living room where we could all see what they were doing, schools are a large problem with this one. I would like to tell parents if they want healthy kids to do these things, no matter what bs the kids come up with, their mental health is so much more important to you, to them, and to everyone. 98% of kids would not have to be on meds to help them cope, they would be kids, and they would go out and do things, not sit online. please parents wake up. If you enact these simple measures at a young age, their lives will be so much better all the way around.
No lie or cheat in the heart of Mark Zuckerberg but having the beauty and the truth in his heart. And no blood on the hands of Mark Zuckerberg but having the light on his hands. Really, he is a light for our planet that inherited by the nature. people of the world should create a global legal system for our planet with the contribution of capitalism and science. The time has come for the people of the world to get rid of the outdated American laws, Chinese laws, Russian laws, European laws, Asian and African laws that are creating crises in the earth.
Blaming Snapchat for fentanyl is a bit unfair when the Congress is letting 10,000 people pour into the country every day by refusing to solve the border. Snapchat is not in charge of the border or busting Mexican and Chinese drug cartels. The feds are. Child safety is important and it's good to see Zuckerberg be called out, but these Senators are way too smug given what they themselves have accomplished on the same issue.
Congress isn't letting 10,000 people pour into the country every day. That's nonsense. President Biden is letting them in.
They're grandstanding politicians in dereliction of their duty to keep the United States secure from threats foreign and domestic. All they care about is 5 minutes of footage in the spotlight finger wagging at whichever unfortunate soul has been called to testify before them. Great content for re-election campaign ads and not much else.
@firsthide2295 EXTREMELY Well stated and positively on point❣️
Agreed in terms of port of entry for said cargo though distribution and access is relevant. If they have no access they are less likely to use it.
THIS!!
Why won't parent assume responsibility for their kids instead of relying on tech companies and the government to keep your kids safe?
Personal accountability is dead and people love to grandstand and scold the “other guy.” These hearings are set up for senators to testify and increase their popularity amongst those who are easily impressed and devoid of independent thought. Additionally, they seek to use this negative sentiment they’re manufacturing to obtain more control over these companies, as well as the citizenry, through creepy legislation. Bunch of morons fall for it.
because they cannot demand that the we submit gov iD to use the internet otherwise... which is exactly where all this is going... it's so obvious.
gov gives zero fs about children or citizens overall.
Look another creep who has an issue with regulations that protect children.
Parents need to STEP UP.
Absolutely, they should be talking to their kids. Unfortunately, young children's can't see last their nose. These platforms need to be dismantled and shut down.
Y’all can’t be that slow. You need someone to blame but you don’t want to blame these dumbass parents! These parents need to take accountability and regulate and be in their kids lives. I’m sorry they lost their kids to what happened but they gotta take accountability for not knowing or being in their kids life 🤦🏽♂️🤡💯
parents are too busy on social media, that's why we need to ban all social media platforms
@@JohnRangel-if2qm I agree somewhat. Respectably
Yeah , instead of handing their kid an ipad .
Let children be children!
For that they need parents to actually parent!
You don't have to be a child psychologist to know what beauty filters would do to teenage girls and young women.
Then keep your kids off social media. These parents are to blame for their kids misfortune. We should not amend section 230 we will unleash the flood gates of Karen lawsuit's I can already see religious parents sueing social media companies for their kids see a gay character or video
I cannot blame social media for catering to social fads. Its not their fault teens/parents make terrible life changing choices without considerable thought.
10 year old are at Sephora buying RETINOL !! thats for spot treatment of pimples, made famous into face cream & serums by these beauty influencers. A kid at 10 will have good skin already. At the most they need some lip balm & good face cream& sunscreen. Apparently some dolphin or whale facial (sorry forgot the name) routine they are obsessing over.
Only girls???
That's true. But it's unethical and immoral for them to target kids.@@JusticeAlitodacuck
This Is Extremely EVIL!!!!WOW American People Deserve Accountability Immediately!!!
No what is evil is parents blaming social media for their own ineptitude
what are you even talking about?
@@JusticeAlitodacuck Agreed, but you can't watch over your child 24/7 , if he or she wants to get something off SM they will get it
when you as a parent aren't watching so I still think SM has to answer for
a lot of things !
Parents ,convince the youth that these applications , Facebook , instagram are not required for normal youth and life
Thank you to all the senators and the committee for doing this, not all parents are responsible and kids are kids . these companies know what they're doing and corrupt.
Learn to write and try not to be so easily impressed by the self-righteous grandstanding of the most incompetent, purely self-interested worms among us.
The senators are shaming Americans. Policies that allows drugs to be sold and then blaming social media companies. blaming others for your own failure. Wow americans
I'm confused, what are you thanking them for? Did they pass any laws about this? Did they change anything about it whatsoever?
No lie or cheat in the heart of Mark Zuckerberg but having the beauty and the truth in his heart. And no blood on the hands of Mark Zuckerberg but having the light on his hands. Really, he is a light for our planet that inherited by the nature. people of the world should create a global legal system for our planet with the contribution of capitalism and science. The time has come for the people of the world to get rid of the outdated American laws, Chinese laws, Russian laws, European laws, Asian and African laws that are creating crises in the earth.
Close all social media companies now.😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂
How about you leave TH-cam before you start telling everyone else it needs to be shut down.
Destroy Social Media... now
go of it simple
I converse with people the old fashion way. Email and phone calls. People would be surprised how liberating it is. But yes, I do watch TH-cam. 🩵
@Stephen_A. I totally understand. Humans obviously can't handle the amount of connections that are possible. Families no longer try anymore. Ol' Aunt Susan has to do is web stalk her family across the country and get her fulfillment. No longer has to call, write letters or travel to go see the niece and nephew.
@@technicaldifficulties2522 💖
This isn't a hard fix, but these social media outlets are making too much money, just like in the 1960s how big tobacco had a lot of strength.
as if you can get cancer from Facebook; I keep saying it, my children didn't come online before they were sixteen without me checking what they were doing and there was a child lock on it, I also checked their history every month, and they were allowed in the living room so I could see what they were doing 1 hour online per day, usually for school, etc. +My children did not like that, I was not the nice mom....but I was their mother who taught them how to deal with Social Media
This women ROCKS!!!!!
Singular= woman
Plural (more than 1) = women
You are welcome.
This woman smokes rocks*
She rocks like kidney stones*
@@hardkore360Except you understood the point. The function of language is literally just to relay information from one person to the next. Being a prescriptivist nit-picker may make you feel superior, but it just looks absurd to those who actually study linguistics.
Why is not TH-cam didn’t showup?
I think the legal age should be raised to 18 for social media usage. If you wouldn’t allow your child to drink, get a tattoo, have sex, gamble until they are 18, why allow them to use social media? It is a predators paradise 🤮 PARENTS TAKE BACK YOUR POWER NOW.
minors shouldn't have access to the internet period unless it is for school
Agree but the way they're going to want to regulate that is through having everyone submit gov ID to use the internet... which is the ultimate goal of all this theater...
The problem is that a lot of adolescents are doing those things way before 18(probably not the gambling and tattoos)
A lot here means most when it comes to having sex especially according to data on adolescents' behaviors.
Monitor your child.
Dont buy your 10 year old a phone
How many drugs are sold to children on different city transit services, or in city parks?
public schools... pride parades...
Man, it’s amazing what public servants politicians can be…..when they are not worried about running for office. You would never get from this clip that Ms. Butler is a stand-in lame duck Senator. She is not running for the full 6 year term in her California Senate seat. Somewhat a shame upon reflection.
And this california senator who allows metric tons of drugs to be carried across her border while blaming FB for drug problems flooding teen lives.
Easily impressed I see…
@@mcbeavis6380 your opinion of my impression matters not one bit 😊
@@bernardwylie9760 cute 😘
The parents are as much to blame as the social media outlets BUT they won't take any responsibility for parenting.
? It is not necessarily about parenting but about the policies that allow predators to take advantage of the systems tech companies built on platforms including instagram, Facebook, Snapchat etc. they are essentially allowing for the exploitation and abuse of children and as a parent the dangers never end so to put the blame on the parents is pointless considering children still go behind their parents backs anyways and when that happens these companies are not only helping these predators but giving them tools to make it easier to commit these crimes. He (Mark) is being negligent on a very grand scale especially because he controls a huge majority of these social platforms and by not correcting his policies (his mistakes) he continues to hurt and further hurt the future which are our American youth.
But you do understand that the social media companies have no liability.
I guarantee you that if they would definitely change the way the operate. The only other companies that get away with it is pharmaceutical
Yep. So pathetic. They need to blame themselves for bad parenting.
You're correct to a point. Yes as parents we need to be vigilant and parent our children, BUT social media companies are granted unprecedented latitude without hardly any oversight, if any at all. This incentivises them to NOT have to worry about being sued or held accountable. They can essentially do anything they want. That is the point of this hearing. Yes parents have a responsibility, but that doesn't change the fact that these companies need to have guard rails and some of their legislative protections removed so they can be held accountable.
Parents should be most to blame for not educating their children about social media and for overlooking these risks when they decide to give their children a computer or smartphone that connects to social media apps. Parents refuse to take responsibility for their negligence and always look to point the finger and blame others that have nothing to do with a parent's decision of buying their children a smartphone plus helping them get social media accounts.
Let s open a Nuremberg trial for these people !
Smart Women! Thank you for asking the right questions and done so with very little wavering.
I only saw one woman
Is their full coverage on this wow I guess I am lucky TH-cam even showed me this.
Shit, these filters cause self hate in grown ass women. Stop letting your kids on these platforms.
Only the ones that have good reason
Sure. Every single one of the owners of each platform should own up to some responsibility, but why are we neglecting to such a high degree the responsibility of the parents? I mean, all of the stories are tragic, for sure, but then what's the solution? Do we just erase every social media site on the internet? It's my understanding that these companies could be doing a better job preventing such damaging material from being shared, but as we all know, wherever there is human touch, there will always be a way of villainizing anything, and the best way to prevent kids from being in contact with such an evil reality is to either NOT EXPOSE THEM to it or provide some supervision. How many of the parents will take 10 min to try and understand how they could be supervising their children using the disposed tools?
Do we just go back in time and disconnect from the virtual world? Be my guest! But to act like most of these tragic events couldn't be prevented by some sort of parental supervision is just ludicrous.
The kid's parents need to take a big part of the responsibility for this as well. It's not all FB fault.
And this california senator who allows metric tons of drugs to be carried across her border while blaming FB for drug problems flooding teen lives.
Facts
💯‼️🎯
They don't have the right to legislate what these companies offer unless it overtly illegal. It's not governments place to be everyone's parents.
She they keep saying they just want yes or no answers and then she repeats the same exact question to each person😂😂
This seems to be the only issue uniting both sides of the aisle. Save the Children.
yet this california senator who allows metric tons of drugs to be carried across her border while blaming social media for drug problems flooding teen lives. the irony is strong.
Privacy Power Grab
thank you for bringing up the harm filtering has done on young people in society
Hat off to the women senator!
Great job, SENATOR!!! HOLD THEM ACCOUNTABLE!!!!
No social media for minors. Thats the solution.
So this is how it looks like when a group 40YOs get called to the principals office
Dude she's terrific
Uhhhh, what did she accomplish?
@@lemonstealinghorsdoeuvreShe’s doing a far better job than you are. Sat under literally EVERY comment under this video. So weird. Some weird bot in favour of capitalist tech companies.
Funny...all these people blaming companies for what would seem to be a parent's responsibility...Do you know what your own kids are doing with their time?
both are fault, but companies carry higher responsibilities cus they effect whole humanity.
sure I'm not at their own seat, working my ass off to make best app safe for everyone. but I will take way more responsible for myself if I know my app will kill the humanity, spread a woke virus, etc.
I think lots of ppl in holllywood should have used a plastic surgery filter to guess in advance how they’d turn out messed up 😂
I am getting nauseous! These business people are 100% rotten in what they do
We need to sue music industry too.
Handle this man😂😂😂
Blame everyone except for themselves. The parents are the ones to be blamed. Might as well shut down the internet if thats what these people are nit picking at
The number of hours kids spend active at home is less than they spend in school.
Most of them see these things during school hours. The parents are only in control when they're home.
@@Choca3786 facebook has been around before these kids were born. You cant expect it to be shut down. Its up to parents to teach their kids right from wrong and to ignore and not invest so much into social media. Not every kid is weak minded.
Why dont we stop making everything so kids wont get hurt. Cars movies games carpets sharp corners of a wall. Lets live in a bubble.
Ya the world doesnt cater to kids.
@@JDMEXforme well no one is asking for Facebook to shut down, just for them to take down sites that endanger children promptly.
Comprehension you know.
If you have ever reported a site to Facebook, you'll understand why people are angry. Unless you want to tell me you run one of those sites.
@@Choca3786 i dont use facebook.
I agree that for the explicit content that needs to be removed. I think they have Ai that finds and removes that stuff.
THE DAMAGE IS LONG DONE!
Phones also have filters for pictures
They sit down with thier rich friends and ask.. not regular folks.
Ms. Butler you are a hero! Push and push hard!
Truth is coming out! 🐍
Oh come on!! We need government doing government stuff, not babysitting people's feelings, It's not their place to legislate face filters.
Finally we address the filters
*sharp
PARENTS it is your job to parent.
YOUR JOB to provide your kids with the mental tools for the world.
Parents it is YOUR RESPONSIBILITY to hold yourself accountable.
You are waiting for the government to raise your children.
Lots of emotionalism but nothing of substance. Protect kids how exactly?
We Shall Overcome!!
Woow.....Thank you Universe for this HUGHE step toward BETTER WORLD
Not all filters are bad but yes i do agree that any beauty related ones shouldnt be a thing
I knew this day would come smh 🤦♂️
No one above the law.
Capatalism at its finest, throw the rick of success then hide your hand.
Although I am no fan of social media and the companies that run them I think parents need to take a degree of responsibility for allowing their under-18-year-olds to use these dreadful platforms.
As any parent would know you can monitor the access of social media on phones and tablets etc. but it is a full time job because it is constantly changing scenario. And as much as you can monitor your own children, you cannot monitor their friends, or what goes on at school. And as the children grow, they spend more time with their friends and school mates than they do their parents.
What is she doing to stop the drugs coming in from the Mexican border???
Justice for All not Some. That's a Bigger problem in Washington.
What about accountability of the parents who let their kids have social media accounts and monitoring it also it can’t be a one sided blame at the end of the day every one’s to blame
Why are they speaking to each other about questions before the hearing?
Blaming others is the GOP's solution. The senate and congress, however, do nothing about gun control and murders caused by guns. If a parent does nothing about one's mental health, how can the government's funds and bills help?
🎯‼️💯
No one’s talking about the music first. Obscene languange in media. I was more concerned about opening a public music app where an album cover depicted sex with a snake. CHRIST PPL. SEX WITH SNAKES!! Kids can’t unsee that.
100% a bipartisan issue. Hope both sides will keep fighting
Sen. Butler is from the same state as Zuckerberg, California. Nice!
Fu… snap chat. They have no morals…
“I asked you this very question” the look she gave him 😂
Hazmat beet are never. Always a one incurr as a beets. Red Beets.
Social media can indeed be very toxic and cause many insecurities and false narratives and bias. Of course, these developers should ensure that these products create a positive environment NOT just for children but for everyone. They make A LOT of money from users, they should do everything in their power to ensure the influence of these products on users is positive and safe.
the responsability is on the parents. if I was Mark...I would shutdown facebook and dont give not even a cent to to this theater.
I wish this was criminal court lol
Can't you just give your kids a dumb phone if they need to have a phone to reach you?
He lies
AT THE END SHE ADMITS TO DOING NO STUDIES BUT MADE IT SEEM LIKE SHE DID
"Imma buy my kid a phone the companies will take care of him.I'll see about my day....."
How about holding vehicles accountable and talking to each dealer
Thank you to these women for standing up for ALL of our children
I really can’t believe the rampant corporatism ingrained in their speech patterns. Going before a senate hearing with non-answers as though it’s an earnings call or something. “Yes or no, is the sky blue?” “well you see senator we have delegated this very possibility to our solutions team who have implemented several causalities that detect and determine whether or not the infrared spectra are appropriate for what one could subjectively describe as blue. In order to determine what blue means we have also consulted several focus groups and asked them what they feel is blue in order to cross reference against our own algorithmically derived model for likelihood of a blue sky occurrence.”
Insufferable.
It’s like gambling your rewarded just enough for using the app that you want to keep using it for the hit. Best to never play, know what I mean ?
Here's a trivial idea try keeping your children off social media by being a responsible parent.
Oh please 🙄
This lady is a boss
There company needs to be closeed down cell phones should be only used by 18 and up
so well spoken lady
honestly this is rough. I agree they could have done more, but trying to put most of the responsability for everything that happened or happens is social media on the Ceos is wrong. Parents and the way they raise their kids are huge part of it. Schooling is huge part of it. when i was a kid lots of things were on, new and exciting, but my parents made rules in terms on when and how long i could use those tools.
I'm 32 years old, I don't have any social media, I just have WhatsApp and I seeing childs and teenagers with social media is just parent's fault. This is RIDICULOUS
Respects to Laphonza. Very well spoken.
Let children be children...why exactly are you buying them smartphones?
Way to go Laphonza!