फार सुंदर व विस्तृतपणे विवेचन केले आहे.शिवाजी महाराज यांचे युध्दकौशल्य यातून समजते.किल्ल्याच्या वेढ्यातून सुटणे व त्यासाठी महाराजांच्या साठी जीवावर उदार होणारे लोक कसे असतील, त्यांचं शिवाजी महाराजावर किती अतोनात प्रेम असेल हे स्पष्ट होते.
मला एक प्रश्न आहे ....आता जो सिनेमा आला त्यात आसं दाखवला आहे की रायाजी बांदल खिंडीत धरातीर्ती पडले ....पण सर जे बोलले की रायाजी ना बाजी प्रभू देशपांडे नी महाराजांना सोबत पाठवले नक्की खरं काय आहे????
@@prasadwaghmare5491 director digpal lanjekar ne बोलले आहे की इतिहास चा आधार घेऊन banawala आहे पिक्चर. त्या साठी books, references खूप वाचले आहेत त्यांनी
इंद्रजित sir.... खूप छान mahiti मिळाली.... Thank u 😊 Sir सरसेनापती नेताजी पालकर आणि महाराज यांच्यातील पन्हाळा वर खरंच वाद झाला होता की तो गनिमी कावा होता... याबाबत mahiti हवी होती....
Mala ek preashnna aahe, bareech divas Jatipatiche kahitari pachaka ki. Abhyas kay bhari aahe. Amhi engineering karat hoto na, mhanun kay mahit nahi. Lay bhari tumhi
Your research and presentation is truly appreciable. Request to present a good research on the foll. 1. Understand that shudras and Marathas were non vegetarian. Therefore they could have easily accepted Muslims as their rulers. But how the Brahmins , who were totally vegetarians, having great purity ,were even not allowing shudras come near them, worked under the Muslim who were Beef eaters. 2. Why did the brahmin slaves under muslim sardars Afzal Khan ,not revolt (or leave his contingent) when he was desecrating by cutting cow in front of the Godess Tulzapur Bhawani etc . E.g. his lawyer Bhaskar Kulkarni. Why did he attack Chatrapati Shivaji Maharaj during the fight With afzal Khan. 3. What role did Ramdas Swami play , when the Brahmins of maharastra denied carrying the coronation of Chatrapati Maharaj , calling him a shudra. 4. Complete details (vidhi) of coronation ceremony by Gaga Bhatt. 5. Sanatan dharma had put ban on sea travel, creating hurdles on Shivaji Maharaj ambition of naval warfare. 6. Understand that Shivaji Maharaj fought relentless wars day and night. Did he take any purohit advise to check the day(teethi) whether the condition is favourable or unfavorable before going for the attack or defending an attack . 7. Do today's politicians refer any purohit to find an auspicious day (teethi) for pulling down a govt or forming govt. Eg swearing- in- ceremony at7.30 am .
You have raised many issues by curiosity and it is very important points to be studied, but you said that Brahmins were vegetarian with great purity.I don't agree with you to the word great purity because their predecessor Brahmins were eating it in large amount .Today also you can notice this.But the points raised by you are of paramount importance.
Hello sawant ji Can you please make a video on relation between samarth ramdaas and ahivaji maharaaj Wanted to know about parmaarth which was did by mahraaj with samarth ramdaas
Sir, according to you if Shivaji Maharaj took 8-10 hrs to arrive at Pandharpaanee, then how much did Siddhi Massod take time to arrive at Pandharpaanee? Must same time not 3-4 hrs. Additional Shiva Kashid episode consumed more time. If Marathe's were tried then condition of Masood's army would have been worse than Maratha army. Am I correct?
@@ramraonirgude5125 sir, Mr. Indrajeet Sawant Sir has said the way from Panhalgad to Vishalgad is so circutous and difficult that traveling by horse that also in raining or in rainy season is difficult. I had been to that treck. So I feel by Shree Bajee Prabhu Deshpande had given fight at foots of Visalgad.
@@Raj-lw3zq I am quoting what ninad bedekar ji said. He said pawankhind battle didn't happened as it was portrayed. But after reaching vishalgad shivaji maharaj sent बाजीप्रभू and then the battle happened
@@omkargawas2025 thats what i m saying.ninad bedekars version is wrong.pawankhind battle is proven and its one of the greatest last stands in world history
@@Raj-lw3zq he's not a small historian. He's a shivbhushan awardee. And to make such claim is not a small thing. What's ur counter argument? Any references to prove ninad bedekar wrong?
th-cam.com/users/shortsYUynKF3l0Ng?feature=share Ninad bedekar बोलले की पावनखिंड चा युद्ध झालाच nahi. Please reply which is the correct version of history
अनेक बारकाव्यांसह यथोचित मांडणी.
इंद्रजीत सावंत साहेब आभारी आहे 👍
इंद्रजीत सर आपले खूप खूप आभार आपण माझ्या मनातला शिवाजी काशीद बद्दल असलेलं गूढ दूर केलं🙏🙏🙏🚩🚩
बांदल घराण्याचे उपकार न विसरण्यासारखे आहेत.
इंद्रजीत सरांच खूप खूप आभार
खरचं विषेलशन करून पूराव्यासहीत माहिती देतात
तुमच्या मुळे खरा इतिहास माहीत होत आहे
पुन्हा एकदा खूप खूप आभार
फार सुंदर व विस्तृतपणे विवेचन केले आहे.शिवाजी महाराज यांचे युध्दकौशल्य यातून समजते.किल्ल्याच्या वेढ्यातून सुटणे व त्यासाठी महाराजांच्या साठी जीवावर उदार होणारे लोक कसे असतील, त्यांचं शिवाजी महाराजावर किती अतोनात प्रेम असेल हे स्पष्ट होते.
पावनखिंड लढाई खरंच झाली का निनाद बेडेकर सर तर म्हणतात बाजीप्रभू ना विशाळगडाच्या पायथ्याशी युध्दात वीरगती प्राप्त झाली
जय गुरूदेव जय जिजाऊ जय शिवराय माझा राजा विश्व राजा सदा सर्व मावळे सदा मावळ सम्राट आहेतच
फारच सुंदर एकदा सरांच्या बरोबर पन्हाळा पावनखिंड विशालगड हा प्रवास करण्याची संधी मिळाली...
खूप उत्तम आणि विस्तृत विवेचन .खूप नवीन गोष्टींचा उलगडा झाला .धन्यवाद
मला एक प्रश्न आहे ....आता जो सिनेमा आला त्यात आसं दाखवला आहे की रायाजी बांदल खिंडीत धरातीर्ती पडले ....पण सर जे बोलले की रायाजी ना बाजी प्रभू देशपांडे नी महाराजांना सोबत पाठवले नक्की खरं काय आहे????
Cinema mhanje itihas nahi... Cinema madhe thodefar badal kele jatat story manoranjak banwnya sathi...
Don't Take Cinema And Serial Seriously
They add Flavors make Changes to make it more entertainment
@@prasadwaghmare5491 director digpal lanjekar ne बोलले आहे की इतिहास चा आधार घेऊन banawala आहे पिक्चर. त्या साठी books, references खूप वाचले आहेत त्यांनी
@@prasadwaghmare5491 ninad bedekar cha मत बघा काय आहे ते पावनखिंड वर
इंद्रजित sir.... खूप छान mahiti मिळाली.... Thank u 😊
Sir सरसेनापती नेताजी पालकर आणि महाराज यांच्यातील पन्हाळा वर खरंच वाद झाला होता की तो गनिमी कावा होता... याबाबत mahiti हवी होती....
Sir एक विनंती आहे की
महाराजांचं गुप्तहेर खाते या विषयी आपण अशीच माहिती द्यावी असं खूप मनापासून वाटतंय
Panhala wedaytil atishay sukshm mahiti milali sir abhari ahot.
त्या ठिकाणी खिड खरोखरच आहे का...कारण आपण जातो आणी खिंड म्हणतो तो पाण्याचा ओढा आहे...
Sir aawaj eco hot ahe.
मुलाखतकार म्हणून आपण प्रास्ताविकात खूप पाल्हाळ लावत आहात... ती कमी असावी. बाकी तुम्ही छान मुलाखत घेतली
सर खूप मौल्यवान व सखोल माहिती 👍
जय शिवराय
सर इतिहास संशोधक निनाद बेडेकर आणि त्यांचे चेले म्हणतात पावनखिंड ची लढाई झालीच नाही हा व्हिडिओ त्यांनी जरूर पहावा आणि धन्यवाद सर खूप सुंदर माहिती
खुप छान पस्टिकरण आहे 🙏🙏
खूप छान विश्लेषण इंद्रजित सर🙏🙏👌👌👍👍
खूप छान मांडणी आणी .स्वतः च्या भाषेमध्ये.
खूप छान आणि अप्रतिम आहे माहिती.
जगदंब!
आग्रा वरून सुटका यासाठी असा एखादा भाग झाला पाहिजे
खुप छान माहिती
महाराजांनी "वज्रवलय" ही लढाई ची पद्धत वापरली विशाळगडाचा वेढा फोडताना त्या विषयी माहिती सांगा ना काही ..
Detailed information 👌👌
छान माहीती दिलीत ...शिवा काशिद यांची समाधी कुणी शोधली...शोध कसा लागला..याची माहिती सांगावी
Mala ek preashnna aahe, bareech divas Jatipatiche kahitari pachaka ki. Abhyas kay bhari aahe. Amhi engineering karat hoto na, mhanun kay mahit nahi. Lay bhari tumhi
Excellent information
Sir, please note, book written by Mr. Babasaheb Purandare - Rajashivchhatrapati, mentions coruoge of Bandals.
फार सुंर माहीती
सिंदखेडराजा चे जाधव घराण्याची माहिती मिळेल का ?
🙏🙏🚩🚩
खूप छान माहिती.
Your research and presentation is truly appreciable.
Request to present a good research on the foll.
1. Understand that shudras and Marathas were non vegetarian. Therefore they could have easily accepted Muslims as their rulers. But how the Brahmins , who were totally vegetarians, having great purity ,were even not allowing shudras come near them, worked under the Muslim who were Beef eaters.
2. Why did the brahmin slaves under muslim sardars Afzal Khan ,not revolt (or leave his contingent) when he was desecrating by cutting cow in front of the Godess Tulzapur Bhawani etc . E.g. his lawyer Bhaskar Kulkarni. Why did he attack Chatrapati Shivaji Maharaj during the fight
With afzal Khan.
3. What role did Ramdas Swami play , when the Brahmins of maharastra denied carrying the coronation of Chatrapati Maharaj , calling him a shudra.
4. Complete details (vidhi) of coronation ceremony by Gaga Bhatt.
5. Sanatan dharma had put ban on sea travel, creating hurdles on Shivaji Maharaj ambition of naval warfare.
6. Understand that Shivaji Maharaj fought relentless wars day and night. Did he take any purohit advise to check the day(teethi) whether the condition is favourable or unfavorable before going for the attack or defending an attack .
7. Do today's politicians refer any purohit to find an auspicious day (teethi) for pulling down a govt or forming govt. Eg swearing- in- ceremony at7.30 am .
You have raised many issues by curiosity and it is very important points to be studied, but you said that Brahmins were vegetarian with great purity.I don't agree with you to the word great purity because their predecessor Brahmins were eating it in large amount .Today also you can notice this.But the points raised by you are of paramount importance.
सर तो मार्ग स्पष्ट सागा कृपया पन्हा एक दा
खूप छान
Drbarat talvarichya panache Man mhanje kay asayche
खूपच छान माहिती
Jedhe shakavli Karina book Available aahe ka kuthe milel
Talvaricha pahila man mhanje kai
Sir maze kahi prashn aahet contact kasa karu
Hello sawant ji
Can you please make a video on relation between samarth ramdaas and ahivaji maharaaj
Wanted to know about parmaarth which was did by mahraaj with samarth ramdaas
th-cam.com/video/rpm_MwnJZqo/w-d-xo.html
Shivaji maharaj and ramdas never meet
5000% घोडे नव्हते ...तुम्हीच बोलतय चिखल होता घोडे कसे असणार
I don't think Raje have gone to Vishal gad and break the siedge vedha... that is too risky and when it has only entrance
Why you are doubtful,it means you are not ready to give credit to shivaji Maharaj
Sir please make such detailed episode on Agra episode.
Sir, according to you if Shivaji Maharaj took 8-10 hrs to arrive at Pandharpaanee, then how much did Siddhi Massod take time to arrive at Pandharpaanee? Must same time not 3-4 hrs. Additional Shiva Kashid episode consumed more time. If Marathe's were tried then condition of Masood's army would have been worse than Maratha army. Am I correct?
३ हजार घोडदळ जोराने अंतर कापले होते... बाकी पायी आलं होतं
@@ramraonirgude5125 sir, Mr. Indrajeet Sawant Sir has said the way from Panhalgad to Vishalgad is so circutous and difficult that traveling by horse that also in raining or in rainy season is difficult. I had been to that treck. So I feel by Shree Bajee Prabhu Deshpande had given fight at foots of Visalgad.
@@ramraonirgude5125 तर आपण या या दोन प्रकारच्या योजना अंमलात
तर्क काढून इतिहास सांगता सर तुम्ही. असेल. असणार, असू शकत.जय शिवराय
तुम्ही करा मग लेखन
MVA sarkar padala, ata band kara jativar bolane, ata kahi upyog nahi
चावरे तु अनाजीची औलाद दिसतो
Ninad bedekar बोलले की पावनखिंड चा संग्राम झालाच नाही. महाराज vishalgad la पोचल्यावर बाजी प्रभू खाली येऊन ladhle
कोणता version बरोबर आहे? निनाद बेडेकर चा की तुमचं
Pawankhind battle did happen.many contemporary historical accounts mention the same
@@Raj-lw3zq I am quoting what ninad bedekar ji said. He said pawankhind battle didn't happened as it was portrayed. But after reaching vishalgad shivaji maharaj sent बाजीप्रभू and then the battle happened
@@omkargawas2025 thats what i m saying.ninad bedekars version is wrong.pawankhind battle is proven and its one of the greatest last stands in world history
@@Raj-lw3zq he's not a small historian. He's a shivbhushan awardee. And to make such claim is not a small thing.
What's ur counter argument? Any references to prove ninad bedekar wrong?
Sir 500 Mahar varses 28000 peshwa asa video yeto tyache Kai Satya aahe
Its bullshit
th-cam.com/users/shortsYUynKF3l0Ng?feature=share
Ninad bedekar बोलले की पावनखिंड चा युद्ध झालाच nahi. Please reply which is the correct version of history