What’s behind the South China Sea dispute? | Start Here
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 พ.ค. 2024
- China and its neighbours all want a piece of the South China Sea.
Rights to fish, territory, oil and gas.
This fight has it all, including the potential for war.
So why is ASEAN struggling to manage the problem? And why won’t China share?
- Subscribe to our channel: aje.io/AJSubscribe
- Follow us on Twitter: / ajenglish
- Find us on Facebook: / aljazeera
- Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
#South_China_Sea
#ASEAN_Al_Jazeera_ENglish
#Al_Jazeera_English
![🔴 [TRỰC TIẾP] Tứ Xuyên (Trung Quốc) VS BCTT Trường Tươi Bình Phước | Cúp VTV9-Bình Điền | JET STUDIO](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5nF-PCh_Ojw/mqdefault.jpg)
As Indonesian, ASEAN need to be strong!
We can't win in technology but we can win in tactics
- Heneral Luna 👊👊
We should just call the sea "south east asian sea"
@@epiciguessa3463 SEA sea.
@What gun does a military chef use? A-Salt-Rifleonly Malaysia and Philippines I think? But the rest its not
@@epiciguessa3463 Yes!
The Philippines fought for its rights and won but the UN has to assert that not the Philippines alone.
Its the UN that is doing nothing.
Agree
You are right because un is with China.
America killed millions of fillipinos and inslaved millions during the spanish American war. America has blood on its hands.
The UN is not but the EU is
That's why PH leave UN, UN doing nothing afraid to china or being silence because of money
Recently they actually showed hostility to Filipino fishermen who were STILL in the Philippine Economic Zone, just trying to make a living, showing up in their vessels with missiles and following the fishermen.
The Chinese have power to claim the moral high ground. They never fire the first bullet. Just crash their boat, and detain these fisher-man from water.
And its response/avenge to the killed Chinese fisher-man.
Yeah you see there is history. these incident is from early incident escalation.
To block the fisher-man from main-land China is a waste of money. to save the face to claim/control the water under her power and safeguard trading ships is the purpose.
Philipines need Ask help to other countries
""WE NEED TO GO NUCLEAR ALSO""
LET US STOP THOSE " DAK DAK,,
NGAK NGAK,, SAT SAT,, OBLADI
OBLADA TAPOS NGA NGA!!!
@@riverchas1844 Could you provide some evidence for that claim? These fishermans got nothing compared to the chinese that you claim got killed. Furthermore, even other fisherman that came from the other neighboring countries can fish in there before then.
@@riverchas1844 China has no defense. It is violating national waters of a half dozen countries.
It's high time to put the CCP navy at the bottom of the sea.
China: that sea is ours based on history
Mongols: Ayo that wall looking pretty sturdy lemme test it
You made my day
😂 lmao
Why did i read this in KSI's voice?
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 i need to sub this PondTurtle now!!!
Philippines is older than China, we discovered the Chinese long before they started building boats. We are one of the most ancient civilizations... The world has been hiding Ophir...
Bruh if we go to war. We will join with Philippines. From Myanmar 🇲🇲
How?! The country is heading to a state of civil war.
Thank you! We also support the Myanmar people to get back their country's democracy. Much love from the PH!
India ..is with you...we should all unite against china .
No one's going to war. Even China isn't thinking about that (for now). Also, it's the nuclear age! Even if other Asean countries join together, we don't have enough technology to fight a giant like China who has nukes in their arsenal. The solution I'm seeing is putting trade sanctions on China so they won't have resources to fuel their forces.
@@emmanueljugno5810 bruh every countries hate china and most counties has nuke
ASEAN should have one voice, one goal and one direction. Respect, Freedom and prosperity to all South East Asian Nations.
it's not very political...need a new organization
they will never have that BECAUSE USA is controlling them, they are USA PUPPETS...if they made a pact with CHINA , they would all become very RICH and USA would loose TRILLIONS..thats one of the most important routes and YOU are giving it for free to USA...
@@onlyfacts3178 I agree.
Before, ASEAN and East Asian Nations were living together in harmony and in prosperity until the West came.
@@msoanvb6225 Under the fist of China. :)
Unfortunately Chinese doesn’t understand the meaning of that words
Ipag laban ang ating inang bayan. Mabuhay 🇵🇭 ❤️ 🙏🏾
@@kankuro2978 kayung mga tagalog eh puro lang kayu sindak matapang lang mga bunganga nyu pero pag nasa labanan na naduduwag mabilis lumambot🤣
Hindi ko maintindahan bakit naging kapital ng pilipinas ang manila na mga mahihinang nilalang nmn nkatira jan.. mga ninunu nyu kasi jan mga pok pok kaya nagustuhan ng mga kastila at americano tumira jan🤣🤣
@@kankuro2978 NABUANG NKA HAHA
@@kankuro2978 AJW PAHALATA WAKAY GRADO BAI HAHAHA
@@kankuro2978 IMONG CHINATAN MURAG BUGING HALATA NGA MUBO RAKAG UTOK HAHAHA
Nakabahag buntot ng taga mindanao😅😂🤣
Iwasan magtampo ang china daw. Malaki daw baril nila at baka sumugod.
Bumili nlng kayo galunggong sa china😅😂🤣
Thanks for the insight.
Western nations certainly aren't without their faults, but I do have my concerns about China's global ambitions. I naively wonder why they simply can't be 'happy' with their already strong standing in the world community.
They want to conquer the world, even the whole milky way galaxy if given a chance
There is something called humiliation
Thank you
@@s2dream817 those who look to the past to create war in the future will forever create death and destruction.
Greedy ipabarang nlng namen 😂😂
Philippines can't no longer breath nowadays because of so many Chinese guards in our West Philippine Sea we will die little by little so we decide to make a last move in order to breath. Help us God and be with us in our actions. Alleluia!
I fear there will be a time when China's ideology will encompass the east, where faith will be denied and the holy books will be burned, replaced by a little red bible glorifying arrogance.
“In our West Philippine Sea”? Hello Helen! Nobody owns the South China Sea/West Philippine Sea. It’s a disputed sea. We do not have sovereignty in that area. It is not our territory.
that is because we have a useless president...makes you wonder if duterte has been bought already by the CCP!
@@jasonflores4250 How do you evaluate if a president is useless?
@@jasonflores4250 what more the president before.. 😂😂
Luckily we have DUTERTE now, willing to fight for our rights.
she has a million dollar voice
if she could be my wife I want to have a morning argument with her every breakfast
👌
She has a million dollar everything hot hot hot
I prefer Abby Martin's voice.And she is prettier than this one
Also face 😊😍
Wherever there is oil ;
USA : this region is now our hegemony
South China Sea Islands needs some freedom and democracy
@@aAverageFansame to ur mom, leave her alone
shabi
I hope our nation have a big heart and strong determination to save our country now....I love Philippines.....
We're practically being bullied out here, however in reality how long can they keep pushing their luck until their house of cards suddenly collapses in on itself.
Exactly. China is literally bullying all its neighboring countries. If USA and China goes to war Taiwan, Malaysia, Vietnam, Indonesia will not be their ally. Maybe Philippines will since the President is a puppet of CCP
@@alarconick i didnt know the filipino president is a puppet of the ccp
@@xthax9718 he always helping chinese when the chinese make a move near ph. Our president will help china occupy PH because he's a puppet
@@dexterbarroa6053 The only reason he backed down is that we're not really much of an ally with US (We are but only for them to protect PH from sudden attacks like in marawi), if were in war were out of advantage, instead they planned to attack china if they steal oils and we already know why. And if US join you know what they're up for. THE OIL
@@dexterbarroa6053 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Man, I miss the simpler times when Southeast Asian kingdoms and tribes used to traverse along the West Philippine Sea to raid the coastal towns of mainland East Asia CENTURIES BEFORE any Chinese state had a proper navy.
(Even before the reign of the Ming dynasty).
The waters of Southeast Asia BELONG to the SOUTHEAST ASIAN COUNTRIES.
Not just south asean seas, but also the west philippine sea want china to claim as their sea. The island shown in this video with military base of china is thousand miles away from china and that island is part of west philippine sea which just hundred miles away.
But keep in mind that the major bosses of the raiders were also Chinese
u miis the times? u were alive at that time?
@@jameslong4801 who told you that ? are you sure???
@@maximocristobalvaldespino5408 Pretty famous. You can also find some Chinese novels about them, one of them being female
❌ South China Sea
✅ ASEAN Sea
Thanks myanmar from Philippines 🇵🇭❤️😁
Its funny how they selectively use UNCLOS, they say it doesn't apply to the West Philippines Sea but invoke it against Japan.
Right?! The CCP has some of the biggest hypocrites there are!
If Philippines and Japan and China is in one room, if Philippines or Japan feel to be as*hole it going to be fun
Yes it dosnt apply because china had already own them prior to unclos and hv ratify unclos with reservation to.protect them.
@@John-us9rm Already own them? Lol The Hague says otherwise
@@currently.crying4265 Yes. China owns them since the 40s claim in the UN. Unclos has no juridicsion to deny chinas territory.
I love her voice, so clear and soothing
Yeah, not like the news one. Im asian sorry if im wrong
@@StrikerTheSlacker I agree
I love u too
@@lingling114 lol
Soothing and moaning
technically if you plot the EEZ 200 nautical miles of every country's coastline on the map, some boundaries really overlaps. In the case of China and Vietnam they are entitled to have another 200 miles (400 in total) because of their continental shelf and the overlapping increases. Now if you build an island in the middle of the sea, your EEZ will again be extended. There are really gray areas in that UNCLOS and this really translate to disputes.
Artificial islands are awarded neither territorial sea nor EEZ. There is no gray area on this.
@@garymartin9777 Thank you, Gary. Clicked the comment to say just this.
@@garymartin9777 eez is not territorial waters. Now unclos territorial waters is only 12 miles. China had made reservation to unclos 2006 to protect their exsisting territorial soveriegn before unclos. That means the 11 dash sea is exempted
While philipine had not made reservation. This means their original territorial sea limit stipulated in the treaty of paris, 118° meridian is no more when they ratifed unclos. Now is only 12 miles from philipines borders.
You are blubbing mate.
@@John-us9rm nonsense
Maybe we can stop calling it south china sea and just call it WEST PHILIPPINE SEA
West philippine sea.
Whatever..
I think that's what all Philippines want.
It was known as the Champa Sea before the arrival of Portuguese.....
i am a malaysian and i would rather have this than the "south china sea".
@@Flazerie I agree, if China colonizes Philippines, there's a possibility that Indonesia and Malaysia wilm get affected.
this place is called:
"THE WEST PHILIPPINE SEAS."
Thanks! I was about to comment this. 😕🙂
Most populous nations should be favored over this maritime rights like Phillipines. Honestly honest have a lot of land huge tracts to feed its people
Im a Filipino and I disagree with you. This is called SOUTH CHINA SEA and know by the world by that name. We Filipinos do not own the South China Sea so why name it like that. maybe as filipinos we refer to that name as WPS but if with another countries and the world SOUTH CHINA SEA is the real name. DI natin pagaari yan wag kang selfish
@@elprincep582 It should be Asean sea or South East Asian sea.
@@elprincep582 who called that the South China Sea anyway? it's as arbitrary as pete's claim. it should have been called the Southeast Asian Sea as it is more fitting considering the tracts of lands/countries around it-- not to mention the SOUTH of China extends only up to its coastal borders.
She has explained this understandably clear because I already always loved and liked to learn what is behind the South China Sea.
Philippines: *Actually reclaims the sea*
China: *Cries*
Philippines: "Wag ka iiyak"
Roasted
Well, it's a fact that islands are first come first take policy.China found them first And documented. It's better for involved countries to work out acollaboration deal,Than to change the law. Also sea is open for anyone to sail through as long as not very close to islands.
There is a time for everything, history knows what happens to bullies.
Malaysia, Indonesia, Vietnam, Taiwan and Philippines should ally to keep the bully in check. Hopefully USA will back us up also
What happened to the bullies? They thrived, just look what happened to the US, Thats how the world works.
@@alarconick All of those you mentioned all have claims over the disputed sea. Taiwan has the same claims as the China. If the Philippines can win a war against China, then Philippines will also have to fight against Taiwan
Biggest gangster in the world is USA
Boxer war 2 electric boogaloo
"If one day China should change her color and turn into a superpower, if she too should play the tyrant in the world, and everywhere subject others to her bullying, aggression and exploitation, the people of the world should identify her as social-imperialism, expose it, oppose it and work together with the Chinese people to overthrow it.” Deng Xiaoping speech at the United Nations, April 10, 1974
I agree fully with Deng Xiaoping. China is doing exactly the same thing that the US, Israel and European allies have been doing for so many years now. Invading and illegally colonizing other nations land. Stealing precious resources based on false flags like WMD and 911 . Intimidation through economic sanctions and unjustified military actions. Bullying of smaller nations ......So what is wrong? China just follow the pace! at least China is not manufacturing false flags to attack any other country. China NEVER invaded any country like the US. WTF US is doing in Lybia, Syria, Iraq, Afganistan ...??????? Is the US still looking for Weapons Of Mass Destruction or Ussamah Bin Laden?????
remember a communist is a liar they didn't mean things they say
@@issmgun69 So should Vietnam also start invading Chinese territory. If china can do it should Vietnam also have the right to invade china?
Guess that time has come , let's get ready bois
@@issmgun69 has gone full retart here. China NEVER invaded any other country? Really? How about Tibet? How about India in 1962? Vietnam in 1979?
"China has been around for thousands of years"
Yeah right, we South East Asian people never existed until recently. Awesome.
Does chinese for being around for thousand of years justifies and proves your claim to south china sea?
Human evolution
Chinese existing for thousand of years ...so we just what....were we cane from... Ungas din tong host na to di nag iisip. Maka chinese
thousand years ago you guys still live in tribe, you guys are not capable to set sail to the ocen
@@igzqui7817thousand years ago you guys still live in tribe, you guys are not capable to set sail to the ocen
Excellent reporting. Love these episodes. Truly remarkable journalism
The reporter voice it's so calming,love it.
Millon thanks usa
You were easily seduced then.
@@JohnCharville bruh what..
@@JohnCharville OP said calming, not seductive.
She gets paid. That's why.
The real definition of 9 dash line : Greediness and stupidity at its peak.
On which countries you.pointed at? China? Or any SE Asia country?
@@ardi08 The one who made 9 dash line and the one who still insists its validity is.
@@ardi08 china of course
Fun facts, 9 dash line was drawn by a former Taiwan leader, who was also former Chinese leader before this position. And he was supported by the U.S
@@mantin5371 who cares who draws it, the international law will tell you otherwise, your country is greedy
3rd Hour on Start Here ... Always a lifesaver, when it comes to IR deadlines. Amazing job on Int issues
I'm scared that the South China Sea dispute is just a taste for what's to come on resource scarcity on a global scale. For hundreds of years the competition for resources have always been a trigger for war. Who's to say that the depleting resources in the world (e.g., due to overconsumerism and global development) won't lead to even more conflict in the future?
As the fossil fuels becoming out of favour due to climate changes, l think the chances for war is remote.
China has been using SCS to trade with ASEAN and even Arabic nations more than a thousand years, and using those islets for typhoon shelter etc. They have the right to proclaim in 1929. The Pacific Ocean is carved up by western powers and Sulu Sea joining Malaysia is solo to Philippine only! Why?
Lol fish near China? They are literally in South America and East Africa overfishing!
ANOTHER IDIOT.
@@kwanhonkong6527 Yes, you. He's right. China overexploint everything and trashes their environment. Wonder why Beijing needs a screen to show people the sun?
They were doing illegal fishing since ancient time... during the voyage of Admiral Zheng He
Actually according to UN reports the worst poachers were vietnamese fishermen.
@@MRTY323 do Vietnamese go fishing illegaly as Fleet like china?
I really need another one of this where they focus on the artificial islands China made inside ASEAN countries EEZ and how it will impact China and its neighbors and seemingly the world, in the process.
What ever happened we all pilipinos are ready to anything . We stand us one we fight us one . Laban pilipinas puso
Keyboard
Ready ka saan😂
Ready Saan Boi Laban O Titi?
yeah...laban pinas!pusong pinoy!para sa bayan...para sa mamamayan!para sa kapwa asyano...ituwid ang kabuktutan ng CHINA!wag DUWAG!ipaglaban ANG ATIN!!!
ready for die... how cute
I can see far in the future, China will also claim the moon, the mars based on shenlong lives there
🤣🤣🤣
😂😂😂😂
Your comment
well, who puts a flag there first?
Don’t mind me I’m just here to watch Sandra.
me too but that guy at 8:20 has a major lisp
👌
What’s so special about her? Here in my neighborhood there are plenty of her look-alike. Even better lol
Me too, I use to care for China sea but now i Dont!
@@montana6768 😂
Since when Al Jazeera got a super hot presenter?
she's been presenting this show for months..
Here in my neighborhood there are plenty of her look alike. Even better lol
@@donovan8747 Could you name the neighbourhood's name ??
when they started to pay big salaries, tax free.
I should have used an exclamation mark to indicate this is a rhetorical question.
hi from Mexico. Thanks for that great explanation about the importance of the S. china sea and the tensions in the area. We make vids. here in Mexico
thank you for this video.a must watch by all Filipinos :)
Chinese claimed all South China sea because they said they are the owner, and Chinese Claimed some border of India because they said they are the owner as well, the latest Chinese claimed the Origin of KIMCHI because they said they are the 1st who invented of that food, MEANWHILE THEY NEVER CLAIMED the origin of the COVID-19?
Nice comment. All we need to do is "Unity" to fight with China.
Well..at least they only focus on kimchi. Without Kim Jong Un they might claim Korea as one of its provinces....hahaha.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@Sean Yee 40000 chinese vs 1000 filipino. What happen .korean war.vattle of yultong
Nice!
Gosh this editorial was well put together. It also bears the element of suspense. I was totally drawn in.
so who the heck drew that Nine Dash Line?
Well Explained Sandra and Al Jazeera Always No.1 in delivering simply..
2:00 I've heard that China makes promise it has no intention of keeping. Regarding one island claimed by both China and the Philippines both agreed to leave the island until deals matured. Philippines left. China never did. At least that's how the TH-cam channel portrayed it
that might be true, they did the same think in India
They did it in Scarborough shoal
Never trust China. They lied always!
the truth they(Chinese) didnt left the islands since then, and also built military base to it,
our(PH) aquatic resources hike it price, like GOLD. for real,
You meant china should leave her territory?????
The waters are big enough for everyone to use and share but the hearts of men are filled with greed
stfu bout stuff you dont understand
@@c-valueenigma4977 why the disrespect????
@@c-valueenigma4977 i think bro you are right such bastards should not be allowed to comment in public
Greed is driven by capitalism. It doesn't come out of nowhere.
It's funny how people can't even reason without trying to disrespect each other just show how shallow some minds are...
2:20 the main reason for this conflict is because of the cartographer that drew the nine dash line
The Nine Dash Line 'map' is essentially propaganda. You think China would simply mind its own business without it?
In 1947, the government of the Republic of China drew a nine-dash line and drew up a map of the locations of the islands in the South China Sea. It set our southernmost territory at 4 degrees north latitude and included the Zengmu Shoal within the territorial line. At that time, this U-shaped line or nine-dash line was to indicate the scope of our jurisdiction to the international community and list a territorial line. I think the nine-dash line should be an island ownership line. China should finalize the legal status of the nine-dash line as soon as possible, otherwise there will be endless consequences. Because Vietnam has announced its law of the sea, this is very detrimental to us, because the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea only stipulates a 200-nautical-mile exclusive economic zone, but it does not specify how the 200-nautical-mile exclusive economic zone should be drawn. This requires relevant countries to formulate their own basic maritime laws to solve the problem.
Half Chinese half Filipino people rn:
👁️👄👁️
👉👈
Regardless of ethnicity, they should know that China is in the wrong here.
Remarkable study... Enjoyed every minute.
One word: Superb
Beyond excellence in reporting. Over time, I have come to respect and depend on Aljazeera news, especially when it comes to the Palestinian Occupied Territories. You have become the BBC of the Middle East. Congratulations! Don in the USA.
The alarming militarization rate of China and their growing aggressive stance in the South China Sea and neighboring ASEAN countries despite their rhetoric of non-aggression is appaling.
US have hastily withdrawn troops in Afganistan, sent 2 nuclear submarines to SCS for the first time and the formation of QUAD and strengthening ties with ASEAN.
Do you think US will let China easily takeover its supremacy? I dont think so.
If you want peace, prepare for war.
如果美国准备好在南海跟中国和俄罗斯开战，先把11艘航母都开过太平洋
How is China being aggressive if their security depends on able to access beyond the first island chain. If you country's survival and long term prosperity depend on securing this thing, you will be extremely stupid not to try to fight for it. But fighting for it does not have to be violent and while China lay stakes to some islands in SCS, the most we have seen is unfortunate skirmishes being blown out of proportion (deliberately mostly by western media). Seem like we like to talk about everyone's security concerns and not about China's. If you only look at your own needs and ignore everyone else, you are always going to sleepwalk into a war like what America does every time.
If you want peace, learn to look at things from each other's perspectives and negotiate in good faith. Or else, you are just guaranteeing you are going to war. This kind of one-sided and arrogant perspective is the bread and butter of western countries, and should not be adopted by SE Asia.
7:00 **southeast..... okay SOUTHEAST!
Nice video. It’d be great if it included analysts from East Asian or Chinese institutes as well.
unbelievable accurate and balanced report
Are people forgetting war means death of the ones you love whether you know it now or not... nuclear war with no hold barred is a real possibility. If the battle doesn't kill you, the radiation will
Ask the Palestinians about UN conventions or the USA when UN conventions apply to the Palestinians.
@Chocolate boy Actually it can't because it doesn't have any authority over Kashmir no matter how much Pakistanis rant about it.
UN didn't even make a move about the issue of uyghur in china
Whataboutism.
@@dyxasofficial cringe
From the Philippines
- thanks Aljazera for RIGHT INFORMATIONS.
1) informative
2) attractive to listen to.
3) brief for the topic
Great video. Thank you for the information
hello miss, can i rq u to share a pdf about dispute of SCS for my assgmnt.
The greed will destroy them. That's what I often her from my grandma. You may want them but you shouldn't obsessed with them.
I live in one of those Southeast Asian countries, And I have been waiting for Start Here to cover it. :) Thank you al Jazeera.
Strange though it is, I believe that al Jazeera is my best source of international news.
@@theccpisaparasite8813 Try NTD, epoch times and skynews Australia. They're better.
This presenter is absolute fire on all fronts 🔥
Informative one 👌🏻
British cartographer drew a map
China: ok those are ours now
Funny thing is PH also presented a map
PH map was from Spain which was from the 16th century
You guys clearly stated that in many cases, China's claim to the 'South China Sea' was dismissed or rejected, but why do you still refer it as that? Wouldnt i dont know, like West Phillipine Sea or the actual internationally acknowledged name to it better to use as reffering to it?
as the first ever major contry to be notice back in the colonial age china said it is the sea of china as so the west writen it as SCS but they never truely explore the vast ocean and back then is a diffrent situation now
today is called the china sea because of back then
@@N0_F1le how can china claim back then when china was never a country then but slaves to foreign forces such as the Qing of the manchu and mongolian yuan
@@tengteng4076 because china
@@N0_F1le because china what?
I prefer ASEAN sea tho since it's within the interior of all South East Asia
thanks.po.
Love and support China 🇨🇳🤚💕💚❤️😘🇮🇶
Those nine dash line and "military base" also NOT acceptable for all of us, asean countries!!!
ask Vietnam and flippines to remove their military bases first lah
@@niuchajianfa6222 why you said that... And please correct your grammar
@@RedTitan5 why, only Vietnam and Philippines are allowed to build military bases in South China Sea?
@@niuchajianfa6222 all claimants has bases.. Are you really comprehending????
you have raised a good point. The ASEAN must stand up to any sort of foreign aggression, whether it be Chinese or American.
Love this!! More!
The narrator is fantastic. Calm and clear
China building military bases on Islands in its own backyard (where Chinese have been using for centuries before anyone else were there) it's "unacceptable for the United States." While US has built 400 military bases with nukes aiming at China, encircling China.
Love your videos..
So informational, short and sweet..
Keep up the good work.. ;-)
HOW IGNORANT PEOPLE ARE..AMAZING..
watching from cebu city
Watching from Metro Manila,Philippines
Watching from Cebu City too
That's some bit of gear! Love you x
0.56 They had Zheng He fleet, it was huge.
I have the impression this is somewhat similar to the situation what Russia had with Constanipole in the 19th century, taking the city wouldnt have solved the issue, as Russia could be easily blocked at Gibraltar and Suez -> so at least the access to the S-C-Sea can be easily blocked by chokepoints like the Malacca Strait, or by other affected island nations in the Pacific ... and we all know what happend back then -> Russia's impatient ambitions (coupled with that of those of Imperial Germany) was 1 of the main catalyst for WW1, which actually screwed up the whole 20th century ... that shouldnt be allowed to happen again ...
It’s the West Philippine Sea, by the way
thats right
It’s just a name not for China. China is greedy, liar, can’t be trusted, land grabber you name it. God will punish them. They can’t go unpunished.
come and take it with you 「navy」，please I can not wait😂
ASEAN Sea
Just call it "Everyone's sea" to be fair!
Sandra Gathmann... photogenic, beautifully spoken, easy to listen to, wicked smahht... let's see more of HER! Nice job, young lady...
Thailand, Philippines, Malaysia, Vietnam, Myanmar, Indonesia, Not weak bro if China want war I think "RIP CHINA" ASEAN💪💪💪👊👊👊 As an Indonesian that what I think👍
You answered the question the first 10 seconds of the video. Anywhere there’s oil and gas and minerals there’s ALWAYS disputes
Nice info. 👍
By the way, Stay optimistic in these pandemic days of Covid19. 🙏🏼 Praying and hoping for the best for the world future. 🙏🏼 Amen. ❤️
Some mistakes or missing informations here:
- Taiwan is not a country
- The ROC aka Taiwan has long had an 11-dash line
- Not only China had disputes with its neighbours. The other ones have them too (especially Vietnam and the PH)
- Where is the proof, that the constructions on the islands are used for military purposes?
I find your insights on this issue as objective enough a useful material in analyzing the SCS problem. Thank you.
In this video it should be noted that the countries in the ASEAN group that didn´t want to irritate Chine are not the ones with any interest in the South China Sea but the ones who are downriver of China along the river Mekong, namely Thailand, Laos & Cambodia. The exception being Vietnam who is a major player in the S.C.S. & also part of the Mekong group.
As the saying goes BE CONTENDED OF WHAT YOU HAVE....
I like the Bahamas. At one point less than 70 miles off the coast of Florida. I think the US should take it. Likely some native people who migrated from Florida thousands of years ago owned it, and now we own Florida, so it makes sense. While we are at it, I like Vancouver Island too.
The fight is because Aussie Iron Ore Spot Price (Any Origin) is at a current level of 169.63, up from 155.43 last month and up from 95.76 one year ago. This is a change of 9.14% from last month and 77.14% from one year ago. Cheers🍻
I'd just like to point out that most of the smaller Asian countries who are competing with China for the South China Sea have American naval bases. No world power would want USA warships in their backyard. Rather than the issue being that China just wants to hog resources and bully other people, there is also another perspective that China wants to take countermeasures against USA basically having naval bases all over Asia. How would USA feel if China had several hundred naval bases in the Caribbean islands? China should really do a better job being friends with its neighbors but when there are potential threats outside your yard, you would at least want to put a safety boundary/zone for yourself in case they decided to storm you.
Excellent journalism, fantastic journalist.
5:22 how confident should we be in America's friendship and help?
I love how Vietnam fight for their seas. Some people in my country fight for it too but their influence and backing were not much as the one who has more which is pretty sad. If China succeeded, then it’s neighboring countries won’t be able to regain their rights on their seas anymore. UNCLOS should’ve stand their ground and do what they have to do.
i come from Vietnam and i remembered in 2015 we fought against China on Facebook, Twitter so serious that at that time i was in grade 8 but i changed my facebook's avatar to contribute to our fight, too!
thank you so much
@@jihoonpark7398 越南也是社会主义也是共产党也是改革开放😂不明白的是为何心却外走
Biendong Sea not south china sea. Use correct word 👌
@@llovetheworld9101Việt Nam và Trung Quốc cùng thể chế chính trị không đồng nghĩa với việc Việt Nam đồng ý yêu sách của Trung Quốc đâu 😂
@@sonh99tên quốc tế là “South China Sea” bạn ơi. Giống như Indian Ocean ấy, tên là Indian nhưng có phải của Ấn đâu
Angelic voice in my ear..
Let peace prevail.
No SCS tension long before UNCLOS. So is UNCLOS relevant?
WoW right time to heard about South China Sea issue.
Nice job team StartHERE
Thank you Sandra, I am always watching your amazing presentation. I suggested last week to make a clip on a hot topic, you read my comments and did it. Thank you
Great respect and love!!
🎯 Key Takeaways for quick navigation:
00:00 🌊 The South China Sea dispute involves competition for oil, gas, fish, and vital shipping lanes, with China aiming to control it, while other countries claim rights.
00:55 🚢 China's desire to control the South China Sea is driven by its need for trade routes, resources, and economic growth, leading to competition with neighboring countries and the US.
02:06 🗺️ China's historical "nine dash line" and expansionist appetite explain its territorial claims in the South China Sea, which are motivated by significant trade and energy interests.
03:21 🏴☠️ China employs military strategies and territorial control, including building outposts and reclaiming land, to secure access to the South China Sea, raising tensions with the US.
06:26 ⚖️ Legal disputes have arisen, with an international tribunal invalidating China's territorial claims in the South China Sea, while ASEAN seeks a Code of Conduct to manage tensions.
08:31 🌏 The South China Sea dispute remains a high-stakes issue with potential for military confrontation, and it's a complex challenge involving multiple parties and interests.
Made with HARPA AI
peace among everyone, i wish all borders is fixed.
Come on UN ASEAN must unite! UNCLOS must prevail! It must be followed! By all countries! China must support it!