Israelis: What is your solution for Palestinian refugees?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 เม.ย. 2024
- HOW TO HELP
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
The Ask Project is made possible by donations from viewers like you.
To donate to the project:
* www.paypal.me/coreygilshuster
* / askproject
WHAT IS THE ASK PROJECT?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
Do you want to know what Israelis and Palestinians really think about the conflict? Ask a question and I will get answers. All answers are from random people and all answers are included and unedited. The questions come from you, the viewers.
WHY DO I DO THIS?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
See the following videos where I explain the background and goal of the project • The Ask Project interv...
I enjoy your videos. Keep up the great work.
Watching from Toronto, Canada.
Fck chuslam 😢
Thank you for the interview ! Very interesting! The weather always looks so nice and bright 🌼
The humility of the first respondent was admirable
Amazing video! Thank you! So thoughtful and deep, surprising to see people want peace
Israelis want peace without justice so it’s not gonna happen
You doing incredible work
Why does no one in the Arab world talk about Jewish refugees from Libya, Syria, Egypt, Iran, Iraq, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Yemen, Algeria, Lebanon, Morocco, Iran???
Do you know how many things any given person isn’t talking about right now? Why aren’t you talking about the Uyghurs? Is it because you have a nefarious endgame?
jewish refugees? from where? tell us more!
@@nws9517after 1948 they were all kicked out of the neighboring Arab countries (listed above) thousands of jews forcibly displaced simply for the crime of being Jewish. The ones that survived settled and in Israel, that's why 60% of Jewish isrealis are from Arab heritage
@@OdorGod what he said is relevant to the conflict. There were many Jewish refugees. Thing is, they settled down once again for the 100th time. Palestinians didn't do it once.
Baghdad was a quarter Jewish. Tripoli was a quarter Jewish. Alexandria, Aleppo, Damascus, Beirut, the list goes on and on...are all Judenrein (German for Jew free) now. Most had their properties, bank accounts, farms, schools, businesses and their possessions stolen
6:42 interesting that he brings up Germany as we are in a similar situation with Poland, Russia, Lithuania and Czechia. 20 million ethnic Germans of the east were displaced or killed during and after the war and my family's home in eastern Prussia is to this day under Russian protectorate.
I guess in our case the cold war helped as we were forced apart for half a century so the question of returning never went anywhere without total nuclear annihilation and after the collapse of the soviet union people had already assimilated into their new homes.
Hence we regard ourselves as "Vertriebene" - displaced people, not refugees (my grandparents were refugees at a point in their life, my parents and me are not)
@hmvolbanane1259 see below
It needs to be stated clearly and explicitly , they are not refugees. They are the *descendants* of refugees. There is not a single other group in the world where the descendants are considered refugees. For example, what happened to the “boat people “ of Vietnam? Were the Hmong people who left Vietnam at the end of the war and settled in the US and elsewhere allowed back into Vietnam?was there such a demand even?
Maybe because it’s a unique situation?
@@asynchronicity what makes it unique?
@@polinageller3489 The formation of Israel and the sudden mass displacement it caused. Never seen anything comparable ever….Have you?
Like it or not, they are refugees.
Simply because of the fact that they are not citizens of the place they are living in, because they are not from those places.
The place they are from was taken from them and they were made to flee, that is a refugee of war.
However it needs to be stated clearly and explicitly that contemporary Jews from anywhere around the world are not Israelite's(of ancient history) in fact there is no such thing that can even prove that they are descendants from them either.
They are just a religious group that came to colonize parts of Palestine in accordance with Zionist ideology.
There is not a single other group in the world that can go around claiming land where other people are currently living as being their's on the basis of thousands of years ago i believe this and that was the case so i am here to ''reclaim'' my ''home'' and get away with it.
For example when Germany tried to ''reclaim'' Europe as being the homeland of Germania and expelling and murdering anyone who stood in their way during the process, what happened?
Were the Germans who violently and forcefully took control over European territories allowed to get away with it?
Was there even a thought of letting them get away with it?
@@aliragh Like it or not, they are *not* refugess. You saying that they are does not make them so.
It is true that certain Arab countries have denied them citizenship (at least in part in order to maintain the pressure on Israel), but that is against the convention on refugees... Either way, I am not denying that there is a problem, but the solution is not that they will "go home". That will simply lead to others being dispossessed. Others, mind, who have done nothing to deserve this (e.g. Jewish refugees from elsewhere, including the Arab world, or people who were born in Israel).
The idea that the Jews are just "a religious group" is laughably. Six million people, Jews, were killed because they were Jewish, and many of them were not only not religious but often only the descendants of Jews, and did not even know they were Jewish. For two thousand years Jews have prayed "Next Year in Jerusalem" and indeed, there were always Jews in the land (in fact, there was a sizable community in Gaza itself until 1904 when the Arab community threatened to lynch them and they had to be evacuated overnight). The League of Nations recognised the Jewish aspirations in 1922 and assigned the mandate of Palestine to Britain amongst other things, specifically to allow the Jews to make it their homeland. You cannot turn history around and deny people rights just because you don't like them.
Next, the Jews did not "steal Palestine". The communities that migrated into Palestine from the late 1800s on bought every inch of land they settled in and there have been many offers to reach an agreed settlement with the Arabs who lived there, including Brit Shalom (look it up) who offered to live under Arab Suzerainty. It was the Arabs who rejected all the proposals ("Palestinians" in the modern sense did not exist until 1964, they were simply Arabs who were living in that tract of land).
There were two proposals for partition. One in the 193s (1936?) and one, adopted by the UN in 1947 which the Jews accepted but the Arabs didn't. Had they accepted it, there would have been a Palestine and no refugees. Instead, Arab countries ganged up on the new Jewish state and intended not only to prevent the creation of the state but to kill every last Jew in it (same offer Hamas makes today). Do you think that is an acceptable solution?
Some Palestinians within what is now Israel left "for their safety" as advised by their leaders and some were expelled by Israel either because they were engaged in fighting or for other reasons (which was certainly NOT OK). There were negotiations with Egypt in the 1950s for a possible solution, but unfortunately came to naught and since then all Israel had was the threat of annihilation time and time again.
Ask yourself again, if you were Israeli, would you just say "OK, I'll die then"?
Gaza, I'll remind you, was under Egyptian occupation from 1948 until 1967. It was not annexed nor made an independent state but instead was ran under military regime. Why? The West Bank was annexed by Jordan (which was not recognised by any other country, but we'll leave that to one side) and the Palestinians in it had Jordanian citizenship until the first intifada (1987 if memory serves me right), at which point King Husein despaired of the chances for a satisfactory solution from his point of view and retrospectively revoked the West Bank Palestinians' citizenship. So, are they refugees?
There are two million Arabs living today in Israel, and they are living well, thank you very much. Very few of them, even those who complain vociferously of the quashing of their Palestinian aspirations say that they would be happy to live in a Palestinian state if one came to exist. They are very aware of what Palestinian society is and how Palestinian politics are run, so claims aside, Israel is a good place to be and would be a better place if both sides learned to live in peace. There is a lot more to be said on the matter, but "decolonisation" is not the answer. In fact, it is not an option at all. "Justtice" is a solution that allows everyone to live with the national identity they prefer. Everything should be on the table, but not murder and annihilation or removal.
The German removed you from your home and Palestinians took Israel people in and you remove them from their own country and say now you need to take refuge somewhere else , is it fair?
Ah yes took the Israelis in also known as start 2 wars and commit a whole lot of hate crimes which warranted the existence of Israeli militias.
They accepted them with open arms like when they pressured the British to close the border for all Jewish people who want to come to the mandate
The Arabs in the British mandate didn’t take Israel people in. The British did.
Writing from South Africa, I am someone that would call myself “pro Palestinian” but it’s great to be able to hear the voices of ordinary everyday Israelis and see them as “normal” as on TV we often only get to hear the radial right wing. Thank you for these videos they are very informative
Same, we may disagree with them, but these seem to be people that are prepared to at least have a conversation. But how does one create the space for that? I have seen Middle Ground episodes, and the Palestinians (at that time) were also open to a conversation.
Its unfortunate that the "normal" israelis you encounter randomly at the street are willing to negotiate and have peace, but they have no trust for the palestinians.
In contrast, when you encounter a random palestinian at the street he would be with radical views and justify murdering of children and women, with a very narrow mind about an Israeli state to even exist.
The problem is you only hear the radical left wing. Israel is not like South Africa. It is not a typical "colonial" country. The bulk of the Israeli Jews are descendants of refugees of 100 different countries, western and Arab. Christian and Muslim.
And history has taught them they cannot count on others for protection and safety. And neither have they a place to run back to (like the white South Africans)
Israelis will fight to the death for their country. Therefore as long as the Palestinians (and many others) want to destroy Israel, then Israel has no other choice than to fight Palestinian organisations like Hamas or Islamic Jihad.
I don't know if I have watched the same video that I watched or not
But still the dirty ppl of this shit called israeel having the same terorrrr Mentality
Lmao this is a propaganda channel. This is edited, the foreign ministry office isn’t going to finance a channel that makes jews look bad. They even invite you to israel at the end of every video. It’s quite obvious. If you want to see what jews really think of palestinians, watch Abby Martin.
Israel has the right to defend itself from 3 former UK serviceman delivering aid
iranian bot
UK never delivered aid when Arabs blockaded Jerusalem
@@JeanBod1111 u a f00l
@@JeanBod1111hasbarabot
@JeanBod1111 hardly, israel were fully informed that this vehicle would be passing that route at that time, and still decided to be trigger happy. It's a valid comment.
Weird question. Somebody asked Palestinians/Syrians/Jordanians/Iraqians and all others - what is their solution for Jewish refugees?
The Middle East is a 20th century invention Through the Sykes-Picot Agreement and the mandate system Britain and France helped to establish the foundations of the nation-states in the region that continue to remain today. The imperial powers also created the term 'Middle East'. 1916 Sykes-Picot agreement and .Paris Peace Conference of 1919. This turn of events shaped much of the current Middle East, and led to the establishment of the modern nation-states that exist today in the region. The political boundaries and geographical identities are all 100 years old. Prior to this that whole area consisted of Bedouin tribes stateless nomadic herders.
Zionism and anti Zionism neither of these are what National Conservatives should support. We should take a position of Europa First we look out for Europa First our loyalty is to the West is to Western Civilization is to Europa and not to Zionism or Islamism or any Middle Eastern derived Ideology. That whole region is doomed. Few people realize that, in addition to creating the map of the modern Middle East, postwar European imperialists actually created the concept. The region we recognize as the Middle East today, a roughly defined but distinct swath of territory stretching from Turkey to Egypt to Iran, only came into being with the end of the Ottoman Empire .
@@davidroter5580Zionism was born in the Pogroms of Europe due to religious intolerance and racism.
It's mostly the West that's to blame for it.
@@glennlgg6871THEY ARE ALL RECREATIONS false signs and lying wonders the world is a stage Satans grand deception All Theatre folks A Zionist project to decieve the world
Bahrain
Iran
Iraq
Israel and Occupied Palestinian Territories
Jordan
Kuwait
Lebanon
Oman
Qatar
Saudi Arabia
Syria
United Arab Emirates
Yemen
A widely quoted Bedouin apothegm is "I am against my brother, my brother and I are against my cousin, my cousin and I are against the stranger"[
@@glennlgg6871That whole region is doomed. Few people realize that, in addition to creating the map of the modern Middle East, postwar European imperialists actually created the concept. The region we recognize as the Middle East today, a roughly defined but distinct swath of territory stretching from Turkey to Egypt to Iran, only came into being with the end of the Ottoman Empire . Psalms 83:3-8 Dont get suckered in people
THEY ARE ALL RECREATIONS false signs and lying wonders the world is a stage Satans grand deception All Theatre folks A Zionist project to decieve the world
Bahrain
Iran
Iraq
Israel and Occupied Palestinian Territories
Jordan
Kuwait
Lebanon
Oman
Qatar
Saudi Arabia
Syria
United Arab Emirates
Yemen
A widely quoted Bedouin apothegm is "I am against my brother, my brother and I are against my cousin, my cousin and I are against the stranger"[
@@glennlgg6871
Psalm 83:3-8
They have conspired together with one mind; Against You they make a covenant:
That whole region of the modern Middle East The political boundaries and geographical identities the establishment of the modern nation-states that exist today in the region. (The entire concept)
They are all part of the Zionist project to rebuild the ruins of the ancient world for the end of days great deception
Malachi 1:4
Edom may say, “Though we have been crushed, we will rebuild the ruins.” But this is what the LORD Almighty says: “They may build, but I will demolish. They will be called the Wicked Land, a people always under the wrath of the LORD.
I’m originally from Palestine from a village used to call Falugeh which now a Jewish settlement not quite sure what’s called inside Israel borders now! I’m welling to back and live in peace with Jew under Jews rules as long they were fair and treat me and ma family with respect with no separation and hate .. I believe we all wants to build a great democratic place where you can be whatever you want and keep your culture a live with NO HATE and killings That even the thought of Palestinian state we aren’t fan of bc we lived under Arabs rules for many years and we treated like 💩 that’s why we want to back to the land we might have more freedom and respect there - I don’t like how some Israeli immediately assumes Palestinian will create problems once they get to Israeli as I said I work with Jew and isrealis and they treat me way better than Arabs to be honest if I have the chance to live with them won’t be a problem for me I will be happy! As I said as long there’s no hate .. too bad it can’t happen
Have you applied for residency or citizenship?
@@tartarus1322 where!
As an Israeli i would be happy to see a person like you come back here and live with us. We have a lot of Arab Palestinians in Israel that are free and happy here, and most of us are happy to have them live with us. I have heard multiple Palestinians say that they feel they are treated better by Israel then by other Arab countries...
The reason some Israelis assume Palestinians will create problems though, is because Palestinians like you, from what we have seen, are unfortunately not the majority. And even if you were, because there are millions of Palestinian refugees, statistically many of them will not want to live in peace, but will instead want to take the land back for the Palestinians to rule, and will kick out the Jews if they can. That is why we are afraid and don't know which Palestinians we can trust to live in peace with us, and which we can't...
I truly hope that one day a solution can be found that allows you and people like you to come back...
@@AndreyKrichevsky thanks for your words hope things get better soon ❤️🩹
@@AndreyKrichevsky Go back to Ukraine where you came from. Get off of my land.
I love Mizrahi man in brown pattern sweater answer. He has a lot of wisdom.
he's telling lies. jews in tunisian didn't get expelled. they travelled to israel cause you know, israel : german reparation money, american money, european money, cheap lands, cheap houses, opportunities, well payed jobs, a jewish supermacy... the jews lived under the muslims in andalus and made their golden age, and when the muslims were expelled, the jews followed them to live another 500 years in peace, i don't understand what's the reason, suddenly the muslims expell them in 1948.
and also, when the german colonized france, so they colonized tunisia (french colony), you can read about wht the tunisian did to hide the jews.
tunisia is a small country, and until today 7000 tunisian jew still live there, they can join israel any time, but they choosed to stay. and every year 30.000 jew come to celebrate pelgrimage AL GHARIBA in djerba, even israelis.
he said western culture and middle east culture are different, but his grandparents came from tunisia. i don't get it.
it's so alarming when israelis don't see that they live in a radical society, with radical education, radical government.
@@nws9517 nop, majority were pushed out
@@toti550 sources?
@@nws9517 when he speaks of eastern culture he means tribalism and barbarism, when he speaks of western culture he means democracy and capitalism. in essence Israelis and Arabs are not very different in demeaner
@@nws9517 1.Academic journals such as "Jewish Social Studies" and "The Journal of North African Studies" which may feature articles on the history and experiences of Tunisian Jews.
2.Books on the history of Tunisia and North Africa, including those that discuss the Jewish communities within the region.
3.Historical documents and records from periods of French colonial rule, Tunisian independence, and other significant events in Tunisian history.
4.Websites of reputable organizations focused on Jewish history and culture in the Middle East and North Africa, which may provide insights and resources related to Tunisian Jews.
When I see such a comment all I hear is "There are no sources cause I never bothered to look for them"
😂
Wish I had 1000 upvotes to give this.
Hmm. Why's the dog mad, I wonder. Something must've provoked it.
And fascist wirathu’s country is burning by communist rebellion
Yeah and Israel is a deranged dog. I like the way they call Palestinians terrorists when Israel is a terrorist state.
Coery is a star here on youtube and ive directed people to this channel.
If I was a Palestinian Muslim living in Jordan with Jordanian citizenship, where mostly everyone had the same language (and dialect) and religion as me, where they dance Dabke at weddings and they share a common history as me, where my King is the official custodian of Al Aqsa, where i have rights in a developed and stable country. Where the flag is basically identical, why would I want to leave? Visit maybe. But leave? Why?
The thing is that those Palestinians living in Jordan can't even visit the lands of 48 or the West Bank or Gaza. And why would they want to leave? Perhaps because they would like to live where their grandparents lived?
מסכים, אתה גם מבחינת האו ם לא פליט אם נולדת בירדן, אתה ירדני.
@rajm2626 the country is a jewish country now. Its all built up with jewish homes and cities.
Because it’s not your home
It is a grave injustice that so many who have never wronged a soul cannot even be buried in the land they were born in. The connection with the land is deeper than you can imagine.
My parents families were all refugees from Sirya, Lebanon and Iran, what is the solution for them? Do I have the right to claim all their properties in Beirut, Mashad, Halab?
Many Israelis are now living in properties and land looted from Palestinians in 1948 so give me a break and cry me a river. I've spoken to Palestinians who family came from Jaffa and Haifa not only did Jewish "refguees" ended up stealing their families' properties these same people are banned from returning because they aren't Jews.
70% of Gaza descend from the expulsion of what is now "Israel". And the descendants of the those who looted them in the first Nakba are doing it again and quite proudly. I've seen videos from your so-called "moral army" laughing as they burn houses, bulldoze schools and make fun of the destruction they have caused. Even looting items from houses.
So this why I call bullshit when Israelis try to act dumb after putting Gaza under blockade for 20 years and literally living in the homes and land they took from those who fled or were expelled to Gaza in 1948 trying to act like they aren't hated for reason. No sane person wouldn't hate Israel in Gaza.
After seeing what is being done in Gaza and amount of children slaughtered I honestly could not care less about your so-called "refugee" family. Go back and take your grievances and make your claims with those countries. The Palestinians owe you and Israelis NOTHING.
@@interestingyoutubechannel1im Libyan we muslim protected you from mussolini
Yes you do lol
@@streety2308read a history book before italian colonization no problem but they divide Libyan jew and jew from livorno granas and after with zionism the mess between comunities began. But fascist italian forced jew to work on saturday they revolt and after deported to nazi camp.
@@emnajelloul5590 I'm telling you, Jews were massacred in Tripoli, from Arabs that came from around Libya. This was additional to the deportation to nazi camps from fascist Italy. My family lived it, don't deny it.
You mention Jews from Livorno, you must have never learned that they were also originally Libyan Jews before they arrived in Livorno, they were from Tripoli and Benghazi.
Wow that last interview
Can you ask what the Israelis think about “Haaretz” and if they read their articles?
As an Israeli, literally almost nobody read "Haaretz" in Israel, only the very far left. Haaretz audience is mostly in the US.
AS AN ISRAELI, THE PEOPLE WHO WRITE IN HAARETZ ARE DELUSIONAL LEFTIES AND I PERSONALLY DONT LIKE THEM
You can goo gle the readership or circulation.... i think its less then 3%.
I personally call it the "Hate-retz" so there's that.
As said before, Haaretz is considered a radical left-wing newspaper. In light of the many lies it published, it has become completely untrustworthy in Israel. Those who read it are mainly extreme leftists, and many Muslims in fact, who find in this newspaper a justification for their hatred of Israel. Because this newspaper is fuel for Israel haters.
I think amazing the patience you have talking to some of those more intolerant people, knowing that you're family lost their own home in Jaffa ( I think you said Jaffa in another video correct me if I'm wrong).
Coming from the north of Ireland where we still live with the experience of post colonial settler mentality. Fascinating to watch your videos and to realise that the same stories are being played out around the world.
But seriously it's clear you're very patient and empathetic. Good luck in the future. Beir Bua
There are parallels but the Six Counties is not the same as the Israel/Palestine conflicts, which is far more brutal. Whilst Irish unification will come about in the next 10+ years, there is no solution as things stand between the Israelis and Palestinians, the Oslo Accords were the latter's best chance.
Don't compare incomparable. Nothing here is as in Ireland
Uhh which intolerant people in this video?
So according to some you're not allowed to compare comparable things now.
Like a donkey stuck in the mud they are.
The vast majority in these videos.
I really enjoy your videos. I only hope there can be peace some day. We are all humans and all have the same goals to house, feed, clothe and educate our families.
Thanks!
The answer to Camila Roman is resolution 194 issued by UN in 1949
The United Nations adopts resolution 194 (III), resolving that “refugees wishing to return to their homes and live at peace with their neighbours should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date, and that compensation should be paid for the property of those choosing not to return
Even the interviewer didnt know it
Ben gurion disputed this and said that the return of the Palestinian refugees will create havoc in israel and it will destrupt the peace there. UN resolutions are also non binding
The problem is in "to leave in peace". Who will measure the wish to leave in peace? We observe the opposite wishes.
@@sh25098off course he disagreed. He was a zionist and a killer
@sh25098 Ben Gurion ideology is at the heart of the problem. If he had accepted it, we all might have been in a better place, and none of the wars and killings might have happened.
However, we are where we are today. In my opinion, what has gone in Gaza over the last 6 months made the problem 10 times harder to resolve, not forgetting the illegal settlements in the West Bank. A lot of civilians got killed, and I can't see how justice can be served without bringing punishment, adding more disputes.
@PeterGeo2 Yea, especially if you look at the settlers in West Bank and the IDF behaviour in West Bank and Gaza. Very scary if you are a Palestinian to live in West Bank. A lot of Israelis don't realise it.
So in 1967, 1948 and 82 Intifada, and on every occasion, the Arabs started a war around and inside and lost. I don't think I would return any land either. You just tried to destroy them. This is the price of war.
And the refugees for 75 years had to acclimatize within the countries they are in, just like the Jewish refugees who were dispossessed of all their lands, their homes and property in Arab countries, and arrived in Israel as refugees, dispossessed of all their possessions, and they worked hard and acclimatized within Israel,
And like all the refugees in Europe after World War II, after 15 years they all acclimatized and rebuilt their lives in whatever country they chose to live in in Europe or the USA.
So if it's a war stop whining if they attack you
@@theoutsider078 I'm not whining, it's all Hamas supporters whining that the IDF responded to the massacre, - and if it's a war, then as many will die between Hamas and Hamas supporters, and you have nothing to cry about, because it's a war, as you said. OK, we'll continue to live like this until it comes The Messiah. Very soon with God's help
@@gadishaked9938 You really think God is on your side
It's a very important question, and none of them give a good answer, and this is the problem with Jews Israelis.
The refuges have the right to return.
The 2nd speaker absolutely nailed it on the head. The assymetry in this conflict is a massive driver of the problem. You can see this in how Israel responds and reacts to other actors in the region with larger and more capable militaries when compared to how it treats the Palestinians. This only further hardens Palestinians resolve not to want to negotiate with Israel because from their perspective Israel will just later find a reason to renege on prior agreements using pretexts manufactured by either the settlers or the state or the settlers herding the state into an unavoidable confrontation with the Palestinians.
I’ve spoken _extensively_ with people from the Kahane Chai movement and in some respects (collectively speaking) they are worse than some other extreme groups on the Palestinian side. There are some individuals among them who could be considered easier to approach than others on this subject but there are some very valid reasons why they were let nowhere near the reins of power. Now you have the likes of Ben Gvir as your minister of Insecurity. No wonder why the region is in such terrible trouble.
Well said
After october 7th, this is one heck of a piece of victim blaming.
@@dogbert52 Are you aware that Israel killed 100's of Palestinians in the West Bank BEFORE the 7th Oct???
That included 34 Palestinian children.. What started on the 7th Oct?? I do condemn the murder of civilians that day but this INSANITY has been going on for years and Israel continue to drive out and illegally settle more and more of Palestinian land.
@@thomasjosullivan9179are you aware that it all started when your loved ones tried and failed to genocide the jooose just 3 years after the holocaust?
@@dogbert52 you don’t want to get me started with blaming the victim. I can confirm repeated examples that the Palestinians have been suffering for decades dating back to 1948 when Lehi was conducting all of their dirty work.
“As devastating and as traumatic as October 7th was, it doesn't give Israel license to commit atrocity after atrocity. Israel experienced one October 7th - since then the Palestinians have experienced 156 October 7ths,”
at least the first guy admits he doesn’t have a solution instead of saying something horrible
we like your channel ❤❤❤
@corey can you suggest how I can meet israeli arabs and get to know their view on the region
What is the solution for Jewish refugees originally from Yemen, Iran, Irak, Syria, Lybia, Egypt, etc ?
They were welcomed and encouraged to make their home in Israel.
@@bobbygabriel9574 They were killed and expelled from these countries, where they lived for 2000 years, being the indigenous population, more ancient than the Muslims of these countries. About 800 thousand Arabs fled from Israel and at the same time about 900 thousand Jews fled from Muslim countries. For some reason, the descendants of Arabs who fled Israel are also considered refugees. No one is even talking about considering the descendants of Jews who fled from Muslim countries as refugees.
@@bobbygabriel9574why arent the 22 arnab state encourage and accept the arnabz from israel? Dont arnabz love each other?
Not refugees they left in secret and promised more in a new homeland and had their kids stolen to richer Jewish European couples and the parents were told the baby died at birth.
@@sandman5088ok, so the arnabs should leave for their 22 giant countries habibi
Let's take a look at the historical precedent. 12M Germans were expelled from Czechoslovakia and Poland in 1945-50. 14M Hindu/Muslims were driven out of Pakistan/India in 1947. Up to 2M people were moved between Poland and Ukraine in 1944-46. 350K Italians were forced out of Yugoslavia. 5M Koreans were made refugees during the Korean civil war. 800K Mizrahi Jews were driven out of the Arab states in 1940-60s. Thousands of Cham Albanians were expelled from Greece. 1.5M civilians were expelled during the Azeri-Armenian wars in 1992-2000.
None of them got the right of return, or even compensation, and especially not their grandchildren and great-grandchildren.
Hence we repeat the same cycle?
@@asweetieaccount6983 The best İsraelis can do is withdrawing from West Bank and Gaza, then refugeés to come to this lands and establish a new country there.
Those Germans and Italians were expelled because they were seen as the collaborators of nazis and fascists. So many of them were not but Germany and Italy as the states were. Not the same situation.
so your justification for doing it is that other nations do it? lmao
You are comparing population exchange agreements (like India/Pakistan) with forceful displacement (Israel/Palestine). You’re slow
Some of these follow ups are a little leading. It makes people draw a conclusion on a supposed opinion
Yoav Askelov was great i agree with hid views. Smart man.
Those guys at the end, they are *tuned in* they know the facts. I want to give them all a big hug and I'm not much of a hugger. Brothers!!
The guys at the end are the worst type who keeps the war going and their info is one sided and full of zionist fabricated history, very superior race attitudes which the rest of the democratic world doesn't accept. The argument they put forward is the same as the white apartheid South Africans used when they were in power.
Only one solution, one state, one man one vote irrespective of race colour or even religion
Like every democratic country in the world
Back in 1949 The United Nations adopts resolution 194 (III), resolving that “refugees wishing to return to their homes and live at peace with their neighbours should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date, and that compensation should be paid for the property of those choosing not to return
most of the answers here were rather peaceful and sensitive to the human condition but comment section reveals how much hatred and misconception is out there towards Jews and Israelis. seems that people prefer to hate rather than accept the fact that the reality is very complicated but still hear that most answers here speak of co existence
There is nothing complicated about it, Israel is a settler colony that predicated its settlement on ethnic cleansing
someone who wants to the right to return to their homeland doesn't necessarily means he hates jews.
Please give me an example of hateful misconception towards Jews from this comments section.
@@dongkhamet1351 i mean ... Just scroll down - i see people asking for DNA tests, people saying imaginary land of the Jews, i see some one said "the Austrian painter ...", not accounting for a sizable amount of Jews that are of Middle eastern \ North African descent and considering European Jews as non Jews. just read brother\sister its all there
This wouldn't be fbe reaction of the world hadn't researched and learned the truth on how much of these are just lies. Especially since the p-lístans have given so many solution of THIER LAND to have two state solution with them getting lesser of the two. And yet they keep rejecting caus ethey just can't be satisfied with not having more land. They don't just want p-listans but neighbouring too. The world isn't like oct last year anymore....
The arrogance of those last people is suffocating
I think what they're trying to say is that by Palestinian logic anyone could make the claim they do
An Arab claims the land was taken from them isn't so different to what was taken from Jews in the war and in fact from many from other wars
For example a Scots man could claim a peace of land was taken from them in the last war and they want it back because a relative was forced of the land meaning their relative was a refugee making them also one
I so agree with the second speaker 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Im praying for all the Palestinians that are suffering rn 🙏🏻🙏🏻 also stan newjeans ❤❤
The Claim that jews did well under islamic countries is false . Literally every jew had to flee from those countries which now are stricken with war , oppression of women and poverty. Should refugees go back? Depends if the conditions are able to support peace and prosperity. We see refugees world wide due to what?? Mainly islamic fundamentalism. But people want to focus on easy points without really understanding its ideology and teachings that need to change...should jews go back to Iraq? Egypt , Tunisia yemen amd demand property back ? Probably not the best idea or logical. People need to think with truth rather than fantasy
Les Juifs vivaient beaucoup mieux sous la domination musulmane que sous la domination chrétienne, même si le niveau de vie dans ces pays n'était pas parfait. Ils étaient littéralement protégés des nazis au Maroc, en Algérie, en Libye, en Iran, en Irak, au Yémen et en Syrie. Vous pouvez blâmer les musulmans pour tous les malheurs du monde, mais vous ne pouvez pas falsifier l'histoire et inventer des persécutions. Aujourd'hui, la situation est différente parce que la majorité des Juifs adhèrent au mouvement sioniste dont le but est de nuire aux pays arabes et à leur stabilité, en plus de coloniser les terres appartenant aux Palestiniens et de manquer constamment de respect aux lieux de culte musulmans à Jérusalem. Le but du sionisme est de judaiser la terre sainte et de ne plus permettre aux chrétiens et aux musulmans d'être respectés.
Which countries that the Jews fled are now stricken with war?
1967 agreement has the land set. All the current settlements are illegal.
The Yoav guy was very well spoken and articulate.
To those who say it cannot be solved, I daresay the opposite is the case. Not only can it be solved. For the sake of your children, theirs and anyone else affected by this conflict, I say it must be solved. The hardliners on both sides need to be made to understand that this conflict doesn’t end with anyone leaving the land. No party will get everything they want at first but that can later be used to progressively improve and increase security guardrails on both sides. I feel embarrassed that I should have to explain that in the 21st century but here we are.
Singapore is a really good example of a country that came from very little and created a successful country by solving their toughest challenges first.
The Middle East is living on its own terms. This whole European philosophy of tolerance is absolutely inapplicable to the Middle East.
Nice!
Gaza could’ve been Singapore..
Got paid more then Singapore, had lots of resources..
But you see how that turned out..
You can thanks Islam later
It was made successful by the UK
@@timesup6302 replace the word UK with Lee Kwan Yew and maybe I can listen to you with a straight face. Typical colonial racism bs on full display.
The last guys at the table were so funny but it’s so true what they said !! 😂
As soon as he stroked his beard I knew he was gonna have something funny to say and also wise
Corey Gil-Shuster - What is your solution?
The question of the 700,000 Palestinians is no longer Israel's problem since we've found a solution for the 850,000 Jews expelled and robbed of their property in Arab and Muslim countries. We solved ours (without the UN's tens of billions), they must solve theirs. This is called population exchange, as between India and Pakistan, for example.
What was Palestinian language before Arabic?
aramaic i think
Aramaic, Greek and Latin! No Arabic at all!
@@amouri0307 and Hebrew
palestinians are not an ethnic group of people, it's a regional name, so all JEWS, Drews, Arabs, and Turks were Palestinian before 1948 and everybody spoke their own language, but mostly Arabic.
@@chris123sim So, what unifies them to want to have a state?
Amazing comments here.
Guy talking from 5:13 presents the most logic and valid reasons. No minority can leave in peace and equal rights unter muslim reign, muslims becoming a majority in a country will always create problems. As much as I have understanding for the Palestinian people seeing the place as their home, Israelis have just as much right to claim the place their home. And as long as fanatic muslims do not accept and learn to live in pluralistic societies, they will never be happy or prosperous anywhere in the world.
Corey, I truly enjoyed this video! All the people you asked are so smart and truthful. Also on point, especially Yoav from Ashkelon and the 3 guys!!! I just loved their answers!!! Am Yisrael Chai!!! 😊
Not smart as they have no idea of their dark history in Palestine.
22 arnab states. 56 is lumic states.
So what they are still Palestinians !!!
Imagine invading Serbia , replace the Serbian with others and then saying "Well you can move out , there are 13 Slavic countries and 80 Christian countries"
Or invading the Québec and saying to Canadian , well there are 30 Francophone countries and 80 Christian countries"
That's a bullshit !!!
It’s a shame that you see so many peaceful wanting a solution and no fighting Israelis and Palestinians in these videos, but the media/govs/influencers push the voices of the extremist of both sides to the front to make it seem like there is no other way to deal with it but fight until one is left standing because they are both fighting “evil”.
This is an old video, ask people today, and answers will be completely different
I suggest that turkey, iran, iraq, Norway, yemen, syria, Jordan, Ireland, Spain and others each take 100k refugees. that way they are safe and far away from the Jews.. LOL
5:00 The solution ist Not in Israel.
The question is incomplete, first it should be elaborated what is meant by "Palestinian refugees"? All arabs all over the world who identify as Palestinians, e.g. those living in Jordan and having a Jordanese citizenship, or only the Palestinians who live in Gaza and West-Bank?
Depending what is meant by "Palestinian refugees", that tells a lot about the motive behind the question, e.g. is it to suggest that all arabs (all over the world) who identify as Palestinians, should have a right of return to Israel (not only Gaza and West-Bank), in essence abolishing the nation of Israel.
all of them r refuges ALL PALESTINIANS!
Palestinian refugees exist all over the world, not just the West Bank and Gaza. The right of return is supposed to be returning to the village or the city that they were kicked out from. It will mostly be inside the 48 borders. However, some will return to villages inside the west bank as they were kicked out from there.
The definition of jews with right to return is quite broad.
The right of return is for any one how kicked out from his house
@@walktip That would mean that palestinians that were born after 1948, should have no right of return to the state of Israel. No one ever kicked them out of their house. Yasser Arafat, for example, was born in Cairo, Egypt.
Masses of Karelians fled from Finnish Karelia to Finland in 1940, away from the attacking Soviet Union. No one today is claiming there are "Karelian refugees" (including their offspring) that should have a right of return to that part of Russia, nor are they shooting rockets to Russian cities today because of that. Should they?
Also, Israel has no obligation to take back arabs who collaborated and supported the attacking arab states in 1948. They are enemies of Israel, period. The arabs who didn't collaborate with the attacking arab states, stayed in Israel and are today Israeli arabs.
2000 years ago is only the age of the Roman conquest of colonized Egypt (not incl Nubia) which also coincides with the "kingdom of Israel"......
Dude at 09:24 has a kind heart
I have a question , they took you in and you want to remove them from their own country and tell them to take refuge in other countries
Who is haj amin al husseini?
What is a dhimmi?
What is taqqyia?
Where’s the question? Also they didn’t allow us to come in. They tried to stop it. The British and ottomans let us in because they controlled the territory.
@@dogbert52 Who were the Irgun?
What is Jews exclusive right to self determination?
What are goyim?
Gaza and West Bank should become a nation, and the refugees in Syria, Lebanon, and Jordan can either stay in those countries or move to Gaza and West Bank.
The Palestinians were offered that option multiple times in the past and flatly rejected it, opting instead to continue the conflict
@@rishone7392 lies'
who are you decide that ? we want to go back to our grandparents homes
@@HhB-ob Your grandparents were part of a war that they lost. So too bad, it's not happening. I am sure the Jews didn't want their grandparents to be kicked out of their homes either but shit happens and it's time for you to move on.
@@ProudAmericanValdez we will see 💁♀️
They should move to other arab countries they have a collaborated way of thinking that got me
Really?
So Ukrainians should move to other European countries because they have a collaborated way of thinking?
See, when you apply such logic, you have to be consistent with it and apply it in all situations.
This logic seems to sound ok, but it really just means i don't like you because you don't agree with my points of view.
A bunch of white settlers talking about natives.
Israel has the right to defend themselves against civilians delivering food to starving children
The guys at the table around 15:00-16:00 or so are amazing 👏👏
for thinking refugees deserve to be refugees? your comment is so idiotic it makes me cringe
They appeared to be Hillbilly settlers of European/ASHKENAZI origin and not of the Levant. The Pole should return to Poland. The Palestinians can then return to their homeland.
@@earthlingkat2124 all Jews are from the Levant, you’re just a racist.
I have another question “are members of the Hilltop Youth allowed to enlist in the IDF, and if they are, do you think that’s a good idea?” Great channel, thank you for all the hard work.
By law all citizens in Israel are required to enlist. In practice they don’t enlist everybody- the army sometimes chooses not to enlist certain individuals (medical reasons, security reasons etc.) . Note that those enlisting mostly aren’t combatants - there are many other rear roles in the army.
@@nolmol9934 thank you for the answer, much appreciated. So do you think it’s a good idea to let the Hilltop Youth in the IDF?
I personally don't see a problem.
You have been brainwashed a bit by the media about them. I know them. Ideological, simple and good patriotic guys.
@@hanna319 thank you for the response, much appreciated
@@hanna319 sorry, can I ask a follow up question. Why do you think that the media has brainwashed me about them? And what do you think their motives may have been? Thank you again, have a wonderful and safe day
Palestinians didn't allow the jrws to enter the british mandate of palestine even though it was never their land
What do you mean it was not their land? Palestinians lived there for centuries and they didn't want zionists people with them
Even a roman historyn 2000 years ago call them Palestinians in his book
Palestinians welcomed the Jews in the 1920s.
The British Mandate stipulated that only a certain number of Jews be allowed into Palestine to keep the balance between the population with the Palestinians.
However the Jews did not like that so in 1946 they bombed the King David Hotel where British were staying, killing 91 people including some Jews.
As a result the Mandate was overturned when the British immediately withdrew from Palestine!
Ha ha ha "welcomed" propoganda brainwashed. Read what Hagana is - against arab riots! @@Stephanie-zd5im
this is blatant lies lol. Hussaini was working with A.H on the final solution. The british did accept Jews and arabs to come in the country. Jerusalem for example, was a city of 14k people (10% jewish, 30% christian, 60% muslim) by the british mandate, Jerusalem had grown to be a city of 500k+ people with most of the population growing from Arab migration into the land to seek better opportunities. Those same Muslims opposed the idea of Jews entering "their" country even though they immigrated to it aswell. King David Hotel bombing is a completley different thing, it is part of the independence war and the hotel wasnt only hosting "British" it was a british inteligence and army base@@Stephanie-zd5im
Two State Solution. What about the Druze in the Golan? Where is our coutry damm it!!
The golan is part of israel
Golan is Syrian
@@sh25098
Lie it was annexed and stolen.
@@user-ql2jg5fm1manother bit you lost after declaring war in 1967. Stay salty habibi
@@dogbert52
Declared war? This Israel?
the lovely mizrachi lefty spoke for the heart of the jewish people. we wished for peace. but how can it happen? we are tired. and we need our kids to be safe. what can we do? its an impossible situation.
2nd guy is ver y clever and gives me hope
What "Refugees" do you mean ? Araber born in arabic countries and living there for 50 or even 70 years?? As far as i know, Jordan gives them Jordan Passports after some years, so why not Lebanon?
Here in Europe, this process takes around 10 years!😉
Israel sees all jewish outside israel as diaspora
Even if they have a jordanian citizenship 🙂 they wants to come back to their homes that were expailed frim
@@HanaHana-bt7fwand what if Jews want to come back to the homes they had before WWII? Or Pakistanis ?
@@Irin31 first german governments are still paying to the isralies what they did to them, and why wouldn’t pakistanies wants to gain back what they lost ? Who even draw the borders it was england as always
@@HanaHana-bt7fwbut not you not anyone else demands anyone else to go back or call them refugees, correct?
the government in Lebanon, Jordan and other countries that started a war with israel back in 1948 should absorb these refuges as their equal citizens because it's their war that led to those people to leave their home in the first place
I am ( genuinely ) curious about your understanding of this part of history. Wasn't Plan Dalet - a zionist plan to conquer already populated land to prepare for the establishment of Israel and then the declaration of statehood what prompted the war. The UN partition was nothing but an evacuation order for palestinians followed by military conquests before the war even errupted.
No before they attacked 250-400000 palestinians were already displaced
@@fatimasaksoukit’s a result of the UN partition that led to both jews and arabs left where they used to live
@@jojotang8339 no it's a result of zionist gangs violence
They had Gaza, then October 7th happened. I don’t know what’s next.
but if there are people who want to live on their land, who are expropriated... Are you also asking about that? The refugees don't come from nowhere. Saying: They should stay in the refugee countries is not enough. Kind regards to your project.
6:25 well I mean they already live in those countries?
But they are Palestinians not Jews
Corey, I discovered your channel within the past few days and I have not left it since. What you are doing and what we are seeing might be some of the most important documented footage in the history of the world. You are boldly standing in the frontlines of a war; yet there are no tanks or troops present. Because the true war isn't a physical war over physical land. The true war is a spiritual war over souls. Souls of good and souls of evil. Your videos make it evident that both types of souls can inhabit any human body in any region of land and in any religion as well. Thank you so much for what you do and may God bless you abundantly in Jesus name, shalom
This is a lovely comment.
at approx. 16:00, bearded man is referring to Mark Twain who wrote the book Innocents Abroad where he wrote that the region of Palestine was largely uninhabited in the 1860s.
Get the men at 1:40 and 6:40 f2f for a discussion, that would be interesting af.
May be start a new forrnat like that, may be for patreons only.
PS: For the business idea I will take just 1% of the profits, I aint greedy. 😇
Why do Muslim/Arab nations dont take other Arab refugees
Why don't Eurpean countries don't take isrealis as refugees?
Why 100+ countries kicked the isrealis out ? Why palastinians have to leave their homes and their land to the illegal settlements ?
Why don't Semites take their Semite cousins back into the fold?
why don't germany-poland-US take israelis?
Because their tribes with flags. I had a Libyan roommate who had a Egyptian mother who couldn't get Libyan citizenship despite living more hlaf her life in the country.
For the guys around the table, when you returned for Diaspora, they had created a country for you.
They created one for palestinians too, it's called Jordan.
They also created Jordan 🤷🏼♀️
No they didn't, this land was a sh*thole when we came back.
But don't trust me, trust the English and European travelers who visited this area at the time and wrote about how its impossible to live here, how Jews are being persecuted and how violent the Arab tribes were.
Jordan shot 25.000 in 11 days...
Then maybe Palestinians will behave better there.
Neka narod Izraela i narod Palestine napokon zajedno dožive i uđu u eru Mira🕊️❤. Svako dobro želim tim narodima.
Too bad the audio is so horrible.
I have a question for you to ask, and for others to educate me on; ‘is it antisemitic to think that the bible shouldn’t be taken literally’. Please help me.
It so happens that archeology is proving the Bible being right more and more
@@HR-op2cqyes I have seen that, it is truly fascinating. But as you say, we don’t yet know that a lot of it is true, so do you think it’s antisemitic for me to hold this view? Thank you for answering me btw, much appreciated.
If you're an anti-s, only you would know. Look in deep in your heart..
The proof of j-s being indigenous to Israel is pretty definitive if you look objectively.
Now anti-sism, is really pervasive in most societies East and West north and South.. so it may be that it's not even your fault. You just absorbed it from the environment..
It's not trivial that so many archeological findings indicate the events of the Bible are pure truth.
You can also look at history if you don't believe in religion - the Arch of Titus shows you the events from a Roman perspective.
The Romans destroyed the same temple that the Muslims are denying ever existed because they occupied the compound.
Thanks g-d that ancient empires documented the historical truth before Islam decided to deny history for political-imperialist goals@@OhDearOhDear69
Why would it be?
A Blessed Shabbat Shalom To All Am Yisroel And Friends Of Zion.......
Special Prayers And Tehillim For Our Brave Soldiers And Hostage.
Freedom for PALESTINE 💔🇵🇸
Brave soldiers? You mean terrorists
@@AbdulelahAhmed-nu6zz
Jordan 🇯🇴 is Palestine 🇵🇸.......Palestine 🇵🇸 is Jordan 🇯🇴
@@Linda43
Israel is Jordan, Israel is Palestine, Palestine is Israel
"Most Zionists don't believe that God exists but they do believe he promised them PALESTINE"
- Ilan Pappe
@mws9517 Then I guess it’s ok to say that the 2 million Palestinians in Israel need to be “withdrawn” as you put it and leave since you obviously don’t want any Jews living near you.
09:42 - there is no sea in mitzpe ramon
The solution for the Palestinians is in their hands. Some tips:
1. Stop using refugee status as a tool of war.
2. Stop feeding victimhood and take responsibility for their part in their situation.
3. Understand that refugee status is not inherited.
4. Recognize the existence of the State of Israel.
5. Educate for construction and development instead of hatred and destruction.
5. Concentrate on the future and not the past.
6. Move forward The war ended in 1948.
And peace will come upon us and upon all Israel!
👌👏
After taking their homes and land, its bold to say that. You are completely blind
@@en1msayy An understandable reaction from a brainwashed inundated with myths and lies.
@@mikitoledano6530 Myths and lies filmed live by the camera. There are even amateur videos by locals where we see the settlers entering their homes. Take a Joker, this excuse doesn't work anymore
@@en1msayy Smoke and mirrors, there are many good movies in Hollywood too. Your gooker is more like a clown
The UN should pressure other countries to give citizenship to the Palestinian refugees from 48 and 67. Every other refugee group has been granted citizenship pathways.
So europe takes all palestinian refugees because they sent jewish refugees to palestine
The problem with this refugees is they don't want to be asitizen in israel they want to kick off all the Israeli
05:04 - the only guy who makes sense
Imagine actually believing that hahaha.
I'm surprise more Israeli's don't say "they now belong to whatever country they are in; they aren't 'refugees' from Israel anymore." The national comunity should force countries where they currently reside to deal with their citizenship; it isnt Israel's problem now.
Neat!
It’s not Israel’s problem anymore. They need to take responsibility and sort themselves out. The idea that Israel must protect and look after its enemies is an absurd notion.
So your point is that Israel shouldn't care because half of the population in Gaza is "born guilty", right? There are laws of war, and thank god there are. You also don't understand how people work on the most basic level. If you're a 15-year old boy born in Gaza and you see your occupiers having killed and arrested your people and are now watching entire families eradicated, what do YOU think will happen to that 15-year old boy? What do you think his life goals will be? THIS... is how you make terrorists.
Yet at soon as possible, Syrian refugees in Europe should return to Syria, right?
Spot on!!! 😊
The fact that you view an entire group of people collectively as enemies is the problem
Israel is the one who kicked them..
"Mowing the lawn"
- Prof Norman Finkelstein
Finkelstein is worst then Hamas leaders.He is a shame for Israel culture
Fecalstain
"Gooning leads to fascism"
-Prof Norman Twinklestein
@@alonso1244 Mr. Borelli! Mr. Morelli! Mr. Moralli!!
@@shainazion4073Mr Borealis! Mr Murrell! Mr Bomurelli! Mr Muborenelli!!
Host them here... Bro you literally kicked them out of THEIR OWN houses with the claim that you were there THOUSANDS OF YEARS AGO. Oh my God, the delusion.
I will answer to the 5th person at 5:05. You say why would u host them right ? You claim all the Jews who migrated to isreal since 1948 their ancestors lived here so now they’re returning to their “homeland” (though they’re Jewish converts , very few can track their lineage to the actual migrates). So if they can return, why can’t all these Palestinians return to their homeland since their ancestors had been living in this land for thousands of years. Some Jews who don’t any relations of this land as they mostly had converted to Judaism, have more right on this land than the Palestinians ( or Arabs) who have been living in this land for centuries.
What kind of a logic is this ?
Corey Gil-Schuster, what is your opinion on the hundreds of Hasabara Bot accounts commenting on your videos?
You have an overactive imagination.
it's more likely to be overzealous boomers with nothing to do than bots replying.
He is an israeli so I guess he likes the jews and israel🇮🇱❤️
Somewhere, somebody is noticing.
@@Shie67 or else society will label you a traitor and antisemite, what a democracy!
Both peoples have a claim to the land. Israel has governed and fought many other nations ,and peoples for the land for thousands of years of losing and gaining back the land before the Arabs invaded around the 5th century and once again the Jews were exiled . So, while the Arabs only occupy the land, and did not govern or cultivate the land in any way to be prosperous. Therefor the only logical thing is for the " Palestinian" Arab peoples to "bend the knee" and peace and prosperity for all will prosper.
Bro quit yappping and look for the word refugee in a dictionary
the palestinians residing in palestine now have canaanite dna. they aren’t just foreign invaders, the arabs arrived in palestine and converted much of the native population to islam, but their blood didn’t change. they remained canaan, just like the jews.
the jews weren’t exiled by the arabs though, they were exiled by the romans and were later even forbidden to enter their holy city when christians took control. when the muslims under caliph omar took jerusalem around 7th century, they allowed the jews to return back. that’s why jews view omar in high regard for that. but conversion happened, the natives adopted arab religion and began to speak arabic. i’d say arabization became inevitable in that area, but it doesn’t mean that they are arabs. they are still natives to the land. many are jews who converted long ago.
"did not govern or cultivate the land"..any idea how crappy most of Europe looked like in 1948?
@@harutorurubyjane5294no, they are mostly migrants from Jordan and Egypt
The concluding group serves as a poignant illustration of the challenges inherent in achieving peace: they react to any challenge to their beliefs with an emotional reaction, a fundamentally flawed approach as it inhibits their understanding and growth. Such emotional responses, I believe, hinder the development of empathy and rule out acceptance of any other narrative than their own. That said, it was heartening to hear the woman who was interviewed in Ashkelon.
Keep the great videos coming!
for all Israeli lovers & haters, the Palestinian refugees question is a difficult one for all of us.
In 1948 the new Israeli government promised that all living in Israel would be citizens with full rights. So why did the refugees leave Israel? They left in order to make war against Israel therefore they should not be allowed back. They should be permanently settled where they are living.
Are you kidding? They were forced to leave . They were killed , raped and expelled from their lands
@@laurita28061 I am not kidding. You have been told a lie. Read the proclamation of the Statehood of Israel; all living in the land were invited to be citizens. Immediately after, Israel was invaded by all the surrounding countries. Their leaders told them it would only take 48 hours to push the Jews into the sea, to leave their homes; they'd be back. But that was not the case. Israel won, but they lost the Old City where they were expelled.
No, it's the Jews that have been expelled from the surrounding countries, killed and raped.
In what source did you get this information? Check out it better please
@@laurita28061 no they weren't, at most 100 people died in the worst massacre as opposed to the palestinians who would kill literally everyone given the chance, the ones who didnt leave are still there to this day.
@@Winn345 "THE STATE OF ISRAEL will be open for Jewish immigration and for the Ingathering of the Exiles; it will foster the development of the country for the benefit of all its inhabitants; it will be based on freedom, justice and peace as envisaged by the prophets of Israel; it will ensure complete equality of social and political rights to all its inhabitants irrespective of religion, race or sex; it will guarantee freedom of religion, conscience, language, education and culture; it will safeguard the Holy Places of all religions; and it will be faithful to the principles of the Charter of the United Nations."
www.gov.il/en/departments/general/declaration-of-establishment-state-of-israel
Ask them to get the DNA test to see whether they are indigenous people or not
Ask the Palestinians...
@@zehavitmimran7414 They are indigenous. I saw their DNA results. I am asking about the DNA of Israelis
@@hibazedan123 you saw their DNA test like I saw an alien 👽... this land is jewish can you argue with all the archeology evidence founded through the centuries? No you can't...
In general, Jews and Palestinians share more DNA with each other than with any other ethnic group in the world. There were people living in Israel during the Islamic conquests, they were Jews, Samaritans, and Christians, who the Palestinians are descendants of.
Indigeneity is not an argument for legitimacy of a governing body. Israel was created by the Jews and Arab Muslim and Christians who fought against the "Palestinians" (didn't call themselves that at the time) and other Arab/Muslim nations. Israel respects the individual rights of its citizens, thus it is a legitimate governing body (i.e. a Nation State). Not because the people are indigenous, but because the governing body respects the G-d given rights of the people it governs. The Palestinians have not formed a legitimate governing body, and they have been given the chance to do so. When they waged war against Israel, and lost that war, they lost any claim to territory they hold, that's a risk of waging any war, just or not.
If you are honest with yourself, you know the Palestinians would not form a legitimate governing body if given another chance. By legitimate, I mean, one that respects the individual rights of those it governs, as such, they have no right to form such a government, as such, they are going to have to give up on Jihad and accept Israeli residency. If they refuse this, they can move to Yemen or South Africa, or make peace with Allah who they will meet soon enough.
@@hibazedan123
@@toddfulton2280 No they are not
Those 4 guys on the table are just the worst, the Algerian guy with his friends I guess
Thanks for sharing 🙏🙏