Dude literally just said “no” and people are acting like he insulted Theory. He simply responded to a question and answered it truthfully as well. Everyone knows actors do not fw AI using their image which is completely understandable. Mark could have responded completely differently but he kept it simple and to the point.
It’s sad ppl can no longer tell apart an insult from a answer they’re just ignorant and idiotic people probably don’t have any lives at all at this point but just to be on social media and time again we’ll all know he haven’t actually asked him yet
No one is acting like Theory was insulted. In fact, people are against Theory for not asking permission. Mark Hamill gave his permission to Disney, not to Theory. Theory needs to stop being a fucking egotistical POS and start doing these things through the correct means
What’s worse are the people dick riding Theory, like I get Theory’s great n all but everyone acting like Mark has turned to the dark side and is trying to tear apart their childhoods lol
Mark didn't say anything demeaning he just answered truthfully that he had nothing to do with that project. It would have been different if he said something really negative against the project.
@MrRobertGillan yeah that just seems to be the norm now, ignorant angry people. I hate and feel sorry that people have to make these explanation videos, people need to lighten up and stop this cancel BS.
@@cab0316 ain’t even rlly about the video or the title; least to me, it’s the ppl in the comments who’re acting like they’re lives been ruined by Mark saying ‘no’ lol
This says absolutely nothing about whether he likes you, or not. He was asked a yes or no question, and gave an objectively true answer. He wasn't asked for permission to use his likeness, so he said as much. That's it.
@@s.l.thecoffeeaddict1657Mark never said it was yet Theory still decided to put words in his mouth and frame the conversation as if he was attacking him
no Hamill didn’t need to reply to an incendiary tweet by trolls who hate theory for political reasons. Nobody ever needed to ask for permission for fan fiction that isn’t making any money this is ridiculous
Mark isn't really saying that he doesn't like you, he's just saying that you didn't ask him for his likeness. Either way, wouldn't Disney destroy both of you with their lawyers?
@@ResidentRecon89 This is incorrect, the actors' and writers' strike served to establish that unauthorized AI deepfakes of actors are in fact illegal and can be pursued by law. It's no longer fair use to make deepfakes. That was one of the major pillars of the strike and one of the biggest wins from it. Disney could sue his ass into the ground, and so could Mark, over this, and I believe they should to make an example.
I mean mark hamil is an actor if he’s asked if he’s involved with something, answering clearly and truthfully is very important for a ton of reasons. He just answered as he should. If he came after you it would be a different story.
Read the fucking title.. Watch the fucking video.. Then delete your comment because it's a fucking asinine question because it's fucking answered in the title and the video..
I agree with you, it seems that Star Wars Theory is using this whole situation to add a clickbait title and make this video more redundant as publicity than anything.
I don’t think that was the point of the title. It seemed sarcastic to me. I feel theory was trying be like the repliers that were saying that mark didn’t like him
Theory is not the overseer of George Lucas. He thinks he knows, but he doesn’t. Shoot, George doesn’t know. He wrote a treatment and that was it. We don’t know whether he would have followed it. And for theory to say he’s going to follow what George would have wanted, if false. He’s never met him, never spoken to him and more than likely never will. So he’s not the gatekeeper to Star Wars is. He’s no different than Pablo hildago. And it was crowd funded. He self admitted that all super chats go towards his films. So it is crowd funded lol
No he doesn't hate/dislike you. I've been following Mark's twitter for a long time and he likes to answer a lot of questions with a simple "yes" or "no". Especially if the question is something like "Hey Mark did you do (x) ?" Like this one. Not only it is straight to the point and easy to understand, but it's time effective as well, since he's VERY interactive with the fans so he gets tons of these questions everyday.
Theory, these are difficult times when it comes to acting and AI especially. Love your content, but I think it would at least be the decent thing to do to give word to Hamill what this was about and that it wasn’t meant to be dishonest or disrespectful.
if anything youtubers are the disrespectful and dishonest people acting like they understand the entertainment industry and the effect of A.I and how its gonna hurt the employees and the art itself, do you think its a coincidence pretty much all talented writers, painters, actors, musicians, etc, think A.I is a bad idea? specially in its current form and how its barely intelligent and just copy pastes shit from internet, A.I will definitely get better but until then its mostly downsides until its smarter and regulated to not damage the working class
@@Ar1AnX1xare you saying AI would be a better idea if it were better? Just comes across that way a bit. Sure they can be disrespectful towards the entertainment industry but overall I see passion for what they like in these franchises. Putting that aside all he could really do is deepfake or cast someone as Luke. I don’t have any issue with this. I already dislike the idea of deepfakes but it in its current form, fan made content is a better place for imo. I’d prefer if AI and deepfakes were entirely avoided but I doubt that’s possible at this point.
@@Ar1AnX1xTH-camr's using deepfake/AI for non profit fan projects has no actual effect on the movie industry. Your beef should be with the movie industry itself.
@@Ar1AnX1x really? Why you all people so salty about using A.I. in situations where it isn't really possible to get live footage/voice/etc? It's basically the same shit that studious were doing with actors and all that since the moment computer graphic opportunities got shown to them. Damn, not so long ago, after death of Carrie Fisher, creators of last shitty movies were using materials that were captured before her death with heavy adding of graphic to mimic her appearing like "alive" in films. I didn't her people shitting on this, while it's basically the same as using A.I. But noooo, goddamn youtubes are the real problem, yes.
@@daniilbelov8652because the studios payed the family of said dead actor to use as a.i. generated cgi... In this case somebody would be stealing your face, your own face without permission, to do something good or bad, and you get nothing out of it... How is that ok? That's the problem here.
Bro, I've always appreciated you and your transparency. You are probably the only SW TH-camr/fan who has perfectly expressed my feelings on SW. I have a similar view of SW's (and DB's) importance to me, from childhood to adulthood. Which is why it saddens me so much that people who don't care about it, are making it into something that the fans and the creator don't even recognize. Keep up the great work brother! I will always support, pray for, and stick by you!
Single word responses leaves theory to handle a PR firestorm. Wouldve be kind if Mark Hamil added that he was okay with it or not or just not respond to tweets like that when theres a ton others that do the same thing.
EXACTLY I left when he said he'd happily pad his subscriber stats, _himself,_ if he could! What a douche.... what a douche... (waits for the delete or YT to censor me 🙄...ugh George Orwell would be having a fit... I'm so done with this planet and newer generations) Have fun KevyNova!
To be fair all he responded was ''no'' if he had your side of the story and all the details about it on how its purely for entertainment and not profit, im sure he would sign off on it.
@@lolmetswhathappeneduhhh2029He already has an agreement with Disney/LucasFilm. They don’t care as long as he’s not profiting off of it financially. It’s why he has to fund it all on his own and can’t monetize in any way.
To be fair, this is what many actors were striking against; using their AI likeness without permission and without being paid. Sure, it's different in terms of a fan film, but it can still be a gray area. Maybe the safest bet would be to contact him and ask for permission, he may even respect that. That way none of these haters can complain that you didn't at least try.
Just ask for permission. Thats all I ask for when it comes to fan films that use a person’s likeness. Whether its for good or bad just ask for consent.
@@TheUnpredictable2020the issue stems from any profit and/or potential profits. Like sure, SWT could say he's not making any money from the fan film, but if Disney catches wind of any profit being made off of their IP they will come down hard.
you’re exactly right. i like star wars and respect art as much as the next guy but you’re profiting off of someone else’s likeness without their permission and they get no compensation for it. i don’t like this project at all and i won’t support it.
He's super woke and narcissistic in his attitude to work as are most "actors" right now... its a deal thay made that didn't include residual payment... for example... the art of acting is being killed off by self inserts and so on... I'm not sure anyone with a brain gives a dam what an old man who only stands to help himself thinks. Remember Mark loves woke political attacks on fiction all up until it hits his charicter in star wars... he only cears about himself.
@@notmyrealhandleYou're not serious, are you? If you are serious. Of fucking course Mark Hamill owns the rights to his own face and voice, SWT could have easily messaged Hamill to ask if he could use his likeness for this deep fake, but he decided to be lazy and do it without permission instead.
Wait i think your misinterpreted this. Op basically asked mark hamil if he was given permission to use him and mark hamil just said no as in he wasn't aware he was being used for this project. Mark never said anything about hating you, he just said no when being asked the said question. Edit: just watched the video and i may have misunderstood the sarcasm on the title
@@slimmdusty8809 if someone were to use ur face in a project would u want them to ask ur permission? Cause It’s just kinda rude personally, regardless of money; not like Mark or Theory need any more lol
Long time subscriber (March '17). Always happy to see your posts. TH-cam doesn't recommend your content often anymore for whatever reason but I look up your channel every so often to get updates. Keep it up.
I would bet money the purpose was to stir up drama and Mark probably can’t give his blessing for the project if he wants to since the character is owned by Disney
Bro really made a whole interpretation off of the word “no”. Feels like my English classes where the teacher analyzes one word and makes a whole story about what it can mean 😂
Well the whole actors strike was about such matters so fresh in actors minds atm. One aspect about was about who gets paid if others are using a known actors image for their own monetary gain. I’m not sure if Hamill knew whether it was monetised or not.
Ive been lucky enough to meet mark hamill briefly at a con, I was a kid and didnt have a ticket to see anyone at the autograph booths area. I was dressed up like luke skywalker and mark saw me from afar and smiled and waved at me and did a funny face. Its now 15+ years later and ill still never forget that moment. I dont think Mark would ever intentionally try to hurt your feelings here, especially with how passionate about starwars you clearly are. I think he was just quickly responding to the question and hes entitled to say no. I dont think he meant to offend
Honestly when it comes to deep fakes, you have to be careful. The strikes over it literally just ended, it's a very sensitive topic for actors because it can set a precedent where anyone can use their likeness without compensation or approval. As a person, that has to be a really weird thing to see and be used like that. I believe getting permission on these things from the actor is important for this. I believe you should have tried to do that, and I don't believe this means Mark hates you. I get this really sucks, but just try to be careful going forward
It's irrelevant what Mark thinks on this topic anyway because he doesn't own the rights to his likeness when referenced as Luke Skywalker. He signed that away a long time ago. SWT has an agreement with LucasFilm who do own the likeness rights. The stuff with the actors strike also isn't relevant because SWT isn't part of the industry, nor is he in any of the relevant unions. Those agreements aren't legally binding to the wider population because it isn't a piece of US legislation, just a contract between private entities.
It wasn’t a deepfake strike. It was an overall AI strike. Deepfake still works best on the OG actor it’s trying to deepfake, and deepfake are still best used to make someone younger.
@@HenryCurrie-q2e It doesn't matter if he owns Luke Skywalker or not, it is still him, Mark Hamill. He still has a basic right to his personal face and public image because it is literally him. SWT doesn't have any rights of use for Luke Skywalker either, which is why this is a big deal and one of the reasons the actors strike happened, because of unfair usage of their public image in AI
They say it's better to ask for forgiveness than permission. In Theory's case, he should have simply asked Mark for permission to use his likeness and make the best content around his character. That way, you don't have to apologize. It's my two cents.
@@theprussianviking it is true he said "No problem", but why would he imply in the first place that mark is against the idea when he just answered the question?
This is a Community? I thought it was an endless cycle of bickering about what’s good and what’s not and attacking people for liking things other people don’t like like the New Shows, Dave Filoni, the Animated Shows, and Ahsoka. 😏
Thank you for making and continuing this channel. I was born in 83 so just had the originals to watch on TV so grew up on them. I was always frightened of my father as he had a very cruel and selfish personality. So I instantly identified with Luke and Darth Vader. In the late 90s 2000s I was in high school when the prequels came out. They got a lot of flack and everyone's option was influenced that they were terrible films. So when you said it wasn't cool to be a Star Wars fan at school, that really spoke to me. As unfortunately I had to act like I wasn't into it, one kid admitted he liked Star Wars and Star Trek and he was labelled the biggest Nerd in school, and it wasn't a cool thing to claim to be then. But now everyone knows I love Star Wars and I connect with all of it including the sequels such as Kylo Ren. Thank you for continuing this channel MLFBWY
You like the sequels? This isn't the channel for you brother. Believe me I used to like this guy too but there are way better channels than this clown. I'd recomend the Gold Man
I feel u ...I had to do the same in HS and before and I remember years ago after stop giving a shit and embracing anything I love I had a boxing trainer that was really in the streets and for codename purposes.."wit the sh" dude was strapped at all times and man he was a great fighter and I'm bigger and had more reach. Had surgery on both ears because of his brutal methods(human punching bag).. anyways he always was fascinated with the lore of star wars and loved the prequels. He definitely looked like the last person on earth who would bust out talking about like Skywalker and I admired he didn't give a shit with any crowd or whoever. Prolly because he was so damn good with his hands. He loved star wars so much he believed fake trailers were real...that's next level lol..(sarcasm). Anyways I don't know where I'm going with this
Growing up, I watched ANH every other Saturday for a year, to the point my family hated it. When Heir to the Empire came out, I read it in '92 and fell in love all over again. I began pestering my parents for the books or at least checking them out from the library. Guess who I had to talk to about my favorite franchise of all time? Spoiler alert : No one. I was teased at school for my constant reading. I never fit in with anyone, nor could I share my love for it. I'm glad Theory has this channel/outlet with people that enjoy what Lucas created. I'm happy to listen to a fellow fan.
@@StarWarsThrowbacks Well that only applies when there's money involved to begin with. Theory isn't making money off of this. He is only losing his own money on it because he loves Star Wars. His agreement with Disney is pretty clear. Nothing commercial allowed.
@@RadioactiveGooseNo, it has NOTHING to do with money. Its about respecting the actors wishes of having the ability to consent to where their face is used. Mark allowed Disney, he did not okay it for this, therefore he does not have the right to do so without his permission wheather or not money is involved
To be fair, we as actors just had a whole strike about AI, using our likeness without our consent, among other things. And it would be a horrific legal nightmare for you both if he did say “yes”. Don’t take it personally, my dude!
But that is about earning money. It doesn’t apply to this because you can’t make money off Star Wars fan films. So the actor isn’t being ripped off for the use of their likeness since there is no money to be made
Maybe Hollywood should try making some good stuff for a change instead of insulting their fans for rejecting their poorly written garbage? Actors and writers are rich, the strike was the most out of touch thing I've ever seen, yet I'm expected to feel sorry for Hollywood elites all of a sudden.
@@Maximilian_Ingrosso WTF are you talking about this isn't about money? Even if the fan film isn't monetized, it grows the Star Wars Theory brands. He makes money from TH-cam views and from merch. He makes money from it regardless, just not directly.
It’s seems like you’re more interested in making click bait than anything productive. They asked if Mark gave permission…. Mark answered honestly and said: “no.” He didn’t hate on you, he didn’t say anything negative. I noticed Disney Star Wars and the media are trying very hard to paint Mark Hamill in a bad light and to demonize him. He has been spot on about how badly Disney ruined his character. So we should be showing love to him and not hate. He didn’t do or say anything wrong to you, he just said “no they didn’t ask me…”
Theory come on bro, this is a clickbait. Mark didn't say anything negative about you or anything that could be interpreted as he doesn't like you. He just answered a question on whether he gave approval for his likeness to be used. I don't quite understand why you care what woke Twitter thinks. Just put them on ignore like all of society has done.
@@oldylad Uh at what point did I say that it wasn't a word people used? I love how you imagined something I didn't even say, then went on to say that *I* deny reality... That irony 👌
Guys don’t put blinders on. Mark didn’t _have_ to say anything. The fact he singled out this question and chose to reply makes it extremely clear he’s not happy about it. And read the thread, it’s full of people openly crapping on Theory. That’s not a coincidence.
What a load of nonsense. The strike that ended just a few weeks ago dealt with big issues surrounding AI. He did the right thing by responding and that’s all it was.
Of course the people hating in the thread is a coincidence. They all posted after Mark’s reply. It isn’t and cannot be evidence for Mark’s intentions. Anything regarding the context of why he replied in the first place might be considered “evidence”, but it’s still mostly guesswork.
@@LegitScott you’re drawing a false comparison between the two and slapping “AI bad” as a label on both. Part of the strike was to _regulate_ AI, to protect actors from being scanned once and then cut out of residuals while studios use their likeness indefinitely. SWT is an independent fan using deepfakes for a personal project _that makes no money_ . Those two things are not the same.
@@chaossalad3243 it’s not guesswork that Mark chose to bluntly answer a sensitive question about a hot subject, and that it elicited a negative response. It doesn’t take a rocket scientist to understand the subtext, or that people are jumping on the opportunity to accuse Theory of clickbait.
I think Mark Hamill doesn’t understand who you are and why you do what you do. He doesn’t watch your channel so he must of thought it was just “some TH-camr making funny videos with his face”
Mark has every right to denounce this. Actors and writers just went on strike and one of the major reasons was the risk of being replaced by AI. What SWT is doing is scummy.
I'm pretty sure Hamill understands better than anybody how companies are gonna use A.I to be even more abusive towards their employees and make even more money and how terrible A.I is gonna be, if anything its the audience of this channel and people online who want unregulated A.I who are the ones who don't understand how that works, he's been in the industry for a long time, I donno how anybody here thinks they know better than him
As a big fan of your channel for five years, I do think there are a lot of unethical aspects about using AI deep fake and voices. I feel like using an actor who sounds like Mark Hamill and either using (real) art or animation would go a long way.
@@RunNGunPhoto based on your channel, it looks like you take some amazing photos and video footage - what if someone fed that footage to an Ai generator and used the resulting content for free instead of hiring you?
@@ViewfromtheVoid no it isn’t just me go read the comments and how am I hating when his title literally says “mark hamill doesn’t like me?” After mark hamill only saying “no” to A question😂yea buddy that’s a very far reach. Theory just wanted clicks and if you can’t see that you’re lost!!
Love how your the only comment he hearted. Your exactly what he wants, a submissive, gullible child who believes every word he says and nothing else. Enjoy your heart
If you really listen to the situation, he never said this. He said no when asked a likeness question, no disrespect occured and never said he doesnt like him
Ive been watching you for the past 5 years everytime i get in to my star wars phase and your content has always been really entertaining and informative.💪
so its ok with ignore FAIR USE. yes it still applies whether they f*ing like it or not. doing this is saying " we hate fans" so if they want to kill off their REVENUE STREAM, by all means BE MY GUEST.@@WereSquatch
"I wanna make the best Star Wars content that I wanna see..." Something Mark can't even say.... Something I wish I could say. May the Force be with you.
No people, he's not only saying "no" just cause he didn't participate. Man is an actor/voice actor, he does not want anything to do with AI and obviously disapproves of his likeness being manufactured by numbers.
@@StevenRogers-hw9djHe gets casted, he plays a character on screen, he gets paid. Saying you have braincells is more of an overstatement than a millionaire who made his money ACTING being told hes not an ACTOR.
@@StevenRogers-hw9djLol then who tf qualifies as an actor in your book? JFC the audacity to think your opinion actually matters is the real overstatement here.
Really didn’t like the implication at 3.5 minutes in that girls who just became fans aren’t worthy to be called fans. Dude you can’t keep claiming Star Wars fans “aren’t sexist” and then use so many gendered attacks. As an “OG” fan by your definition (got my dog-eared copy of Heir to the Empire signed by Timothy Zahn himself) I want to say sorry to the people being bullied today for liking Star Wars like I was bullied as a kid. If you’re a woman who likes new Star Wars, I’m so sorry for people like this guy. You’re as much a fan as any of us.
To be clear: please keep creating fan content. My sister and I are long time viewers; I just mean that it’s time to live up to what you keep saying about being “apolitical.” At the end I like your point about this being a question of respect for what Mark Hamill has achieved as an artist. I know many actors are uncomfortable with their bodies being puppeteered on screen without consent. Just because someone disagrees with this use of AI doesn’t mean they are a fake fan or fall somewhere on the political spectrum. A lot of “fake fans” probably agree with you, and frankly love a lot of what you’ve created. Attacking the character of people criticizing you isn’t helping make your point, it’s just making it harder for people to enter this space who aren’t what you call “O.G. fans.”
Agree that people in this community need to stop with the sexism, even if it's just implied. I feel like you've kind of missed the point of the video, I think he was saying that using Mark Hamill's image like this is less problematic because he's only making fan works. Fanfictions have infringed on copyright for years, and they're usually treated as harmless. The world would be a lot worse if we didn't have this kind of content out there. (Please don't be sexist). @@jeffreylin2980
Only Sith deal in absolutes. He didn't imply that all girls are not worthy to be called fans. He specifically singled out these e-girls. jumping on the bandwagon because it's now cool to be considered a nerd and react to content and consume next product. So often, words get twisted or someone's comment gets summed up badly to the degree of distortion....really tiring and not fun anymore
it’s not about making money or hating star wars it’s about using ai to control someone’s likeness for something they didn’t agree too- 😭😭just cast someone to play him and all of this would go away
@@bastianwright3402 and? He still can't use other peoples faces without consent, you only don't care because it isn't yours, plus it does give him profit and fame through this empost mortem excuse of a channel. You Yes-Man are so brainless, think for yourself for a moment instead of kneeling to everything this cancer survivor says
I honestly think you put too much mind into what people think, say, do or do not(couldn't help myself). Just keep doing you, your project and your channel is amazing. Been following since forever
It's hard not to when major corporations take what idiots on social media say, and use it to make themselves look good, even if it destroys someone's life. Like what Pablo did when TLJ was released. As the PR guy, he should've been fired for what he did.
The politicalisation of Star Wars was such a strange thing to come back to after I’d bowed out of the fandom years ago. I grew up on the EU, but suddenly if you liked Mara, people are making assumptions about you, especially if you didn’t care for Rey’s character. Absolutely bizarre.
Ironic that you all say this when theory constantly makes it political. Dude literally got so triggered by Mark saying one word that he brought up politics for absolutely no reason in this video.
As a fellow OG fan of Star-wars and also your channel I can totally agree with your talking points people like us just don’t mix well with this toxic modern day culture we live in keep up the great work. May the force be with you my freind😊
I just think it has to be weird seeing people you don't know deep faking you. Which idk, think about if you drew an animation of him or had someone dress up to look like him, it's the same logic but because it's been around AND you know it's not you it's not as weird. This could be a huge case for whether artists can use deepfakes like that.
You're smoking. He's an actor. It's luke Skywalker. His face has been used and "deepfaked" more than most. Not that deep. There's a difference between a likeness and a person. There's a reason Mark Hamill isn't mad lol.
I have been saying this over and over again on my channel!! Star Wars is SO BIG. it's it's perfectly fine to like some bits more than others. and not liking or liking a piece of the content is NOT the same as political expression or views. Thanks for all your work! LOVE your content!!! Happy to know you're not going anywhere!
>the project you're creating >another guy is creating it >wants it to be clear he's not writing any lines, just ripping lines from legends Bro im not even a minute in and this is a bigger train wreck than I thought lmao
Dude, Mark didn't say anything against you or the amazing project that you are working on. I would caution against accusing the GOAT of the original episodes of not liking you. I think your frustration should be with the haters in the comments. I'm not sure why you are even paying attention to them. You do you bro. I would advise that you alter this video title before you spread any more confusion. Because if nothing actually phases you, then you wouldn't be making this more then it was: an honest answer. May the Force be with you.
To be fair he only said you didn’t ask him to use his likeness. Not that you can’t use it or he’s mad about it. However I think when Mark sees or hears about the project and he knows that you understand and respect his character he will probably enjoy it even if he’s not allowed to say. Why don’t you start your own Sci-fi adventure as well as Starwars projects. You seem to be good at story telling and you’d be able to monetise and fund more fan films. Head up dude you’re smashing it 🤘
tbf, you are getting heated while he gets subs every month while getting a LOT of views and THEEEN gets a LOT of attention, you are giving him as to what he wants
![SAFEPLANET - ดาวเคราะห์ [ THE PLANET ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4X1XL3I_k3c/mqdefault.jpg)
Dude literally just said “no” and people are acting like he insulted Theory. He simply responded to a question and answered it truthfully as well. Everyone knows actors do not fw AI using their image which is completely understandable. Mark could have responded completely differently but he kept it simple and to the point.
It’s sad ppl can no longer tell apart an insult from a answer they’re just ignorant and idiotic people probably don’t have any lives at all at this point but just to be on social media and time again we’ll all know he haven’t actually asked him yet
SWT fans are like that.
You really only just now learned that clickbait is a thing huh
No one is acting like Theory was insulted. In fact, people are against Theory for not asking permission. Mark Hamill gave his permission to Disney, not to Theory. Theory needs to stop being a fucking egotistical POS and start doing these things through the correct means
Especially since there’s been a recent writers and actors strike against AI too
To be fair. Mark only said "no" you didn't ask him. This doesn't imply anything else.
Clickbait brings in $$$
Yeah I agree, he was just answering the question
Yea but this is what everyone moron on twitter is saying
@@jackingtonfrost310He's probably already forgotten about it.
What’s worse are the people dick riding Theory, like I get Theory’s great n all but everyone acting like Mark has turned to the dark side and is trying to tear apart their childhoods lol
Mark didn't say anything demeaning he just answered truthfully that he had nothing to do with that project. It would have been different if he said something really negative against the project.
Exactly. It’s honestly ridiculous that people are even taking sides on this. All he said was no.
@MrRobertGillan yeah that just seems to be the norm now, ignorant angry people. I hate and feel sorry that people have to make these explanation videos, people need to lighten up and stop this cancel BS.
Watch the video and not just the title ffs
@@cab0316 ain’t even rlly about the video or the title; least to me, it’s the ppl in the comments who’re acting like they’re lives been ruined by Mark saying ‘no’ lol
Mark Hamill is looking at taking legal action.
I ran into Mark Hamill at a hotel once, I asked him if the cup of coffee on the table next to him was his. He said No. I feel your pain.
💀💀💀
😭
😢
SWT IS A SUCH A MANCHILD 😂😂😂
LMAOOOO
This says absolutely nothing about whether he likes you, or not. He was asked a yes or no question, and gave an objectively true answer. He wasn't asked for permission to use his likeness, so he said as much. That's it.
I took the title as hyperbole, regardless though X comments make it seem like Mark was attacking theory.
@jeremyalgood7230 No it absolutely doesn't. Jeez.
Watch the video 🤡
Well, we do know that Theory is a drama queen who craves validation and will use any title and means to cling onto his numbers
@@JustJoeeee It's not even drama, clearly a response to overreacting comments. A lot of you are just mentally challenged
He just answered the question in a straightforward manner. Don't think there was any intended malice in it.
Probably like how stealing Mark Hamill's likeness wasn't malicious either 😋
@@s.l.thecoffeeaddict1657Mark never said it was yet Theory still decided to put words in his mouth and frame the conversation as if he was attacking him
@@WereSquatch stealing is generally wrong.
@@s.l.thecoffeeaddict1657stealing😂
no Hamill didn’t need to reply to an incendiary tweet by trolls who hate theory for political reasons. Nobody ever needed to ask for permission for fan fiction that isn’t making any money this is ridiculous
For literally almost everyone here, He's probably making this video, Not because Mark said No, But because other people were attacking him for it.
Yeah thats what I'm getting from this
Mark: *says "no"*
the internet: 🤯
Mark isn't really saying that he doesn't like you, he's just saying that you didn't ask him for his likeness. Either way, wouldn't Disney destroy both of you with their lawyers?
Disney goes after you, even in death so yeah 💀
As long as Theory doesn’t monetize it, then there is no laws being broken here. It called fair use.
@@ResidentRecon89 This is incorrect, the actors' and writers' strike served to establish that unauthorized AI deepfakes of actors are in fact illegal and can be pursued by law. It's no longer fair use to make deepfakes. That was one of the major pillars of the strike and one of the biggest wins from it. Disney could sue his ass into the ground, and so could Mark, over this, and I believe they should to make an example.
@@driumissimoCease and Desist, sure but not sue man nah, thats cruel.
@@driumissimo LOL, it's not Hollywood. It's fan-fiction, non-profit project. Fkin weirdo.
All mark said was “no” to someone asking him if y’all asked for his permission. He wasn’t asked if he thought it was cool or anything like that….
I mean mark hamil is an actor if he’s asked if he’s involved with something, answering clearly and truthfully is very important for a ton of reasons. He just answered as he should. If he came after you it would be a different story.
My bro forgot how human interactions work
how do people turn a "no" to him disliking or even hating you? Lmao
Yes. You need to make click bait video titles to get quick views. It's a cynical thing to do but many TH-camrs do it.
@@raygorf735well this was bad way to do it lol
Jealousy is Evil.
Its what sjw liberals do for awhile now
Professional grifter and victim
How does Mark saying no to a question about if you asked for his likeness mean he doesn't like you?
Read the fucking title.. Watch the fucking video.. Then delete your comment because it's a fucking asinine question because it's fucking answered in the title and the video..
He is drama queen.
Drama and ragebait brings in views
Clickbait.
I agree with you, it seems that Star Wars Theory is using this whole situation to add a clickbait title and make this video more redundant as publicity than anything.
Theory, I have to agree that I don’t believe mark doesn’t like you, he was just answering the question
I don’t think that was the point of the title. It seemed sarcastic to me. I feel theory was trying be like the repliers that were saying that mark didn’t like him
@@oskiposki9026 hard to tell with theory nowadays. I mean why make a video at all? This screams "OMG LOOK AT ME PITY ME LOOK AT ME!!" it's pathetic.
Theory is not the overseer of George Lucas. He thinks he knows, but he doesn’t. Shoot, George doesn’t know. He wrote a treatment and that was it. We don’t know whether he would have followed it. And for theory to say he’s going to follow what George would have wanted, if false. He’s never met him, never spoken to him and more than likely never will. So he’s not the gatekeeper to Star Wars is. He’s no different than Pablo hildago. And it was crowd funded. He self admitted that all super chats go towards his films. So it is crowd funded lol
@@TheRibottoStudiosyou only think it's pathetic because you don't understand him. It's not a pity post at all.
@djstevenson888 and you do understand him? He isn't your friend dude. You're not in his personal circle.
No he doesn't hate/dislike you. I've been following Mark's twitter for a long time and he likes to answer a lot of questions with a simple "yes" or "no".
Especially if the question is something like "Hey Mark did you do (x) ?" Like this one. Not only it is straight to the point and easy to understand, but it's time effective as well, since he's VERY interactive with the fans so he gets tons of these questions everyday.
He only said "no", he wasn't asked. Doesn't mean he dislikes anything.
Wouldn't him saying "yes" have been a legal nightmare for both of you because of how Disney contracts its actors?
Good point but that wouldn’t be a good juicy youtube video for likes and views
@@StarWarsThrowbacksthat doesn’t make any sense if it’s do with legal issues.
He could’ve literally chose to not even respond
Could’ve just not said anything
Yeah and all he did was respond to the question, he didn't say he didn't like him
Theory, these are difficult times when it comes to acting and AI especially. Love your content, but I think it would at least be the decent thing to do to give word to Hamill what this was about and that it wasn’t meant to be dishonest or disrespectful.
if anything youtubers are the disrespectful and dishonest people acting like they understand the entertainment industry and the effect of A.I and how its gonna hurt the employees and the art itself, do you think its a coincidence pretty much all talented writers, painters, actors, musicians, etc, think A.I is a bad idea? specially in its current form and how its barely intelligent and just copy pastes shit from internet, A.I will definitely get better but until then its mostly downsides until its smarter and regulated to not damage the working class
@@Ar1AnX1xare you saying AI would be a better idea if it were better? Just comes across that way a bit.
Sure they can be disrespectful towards the entertainment industry but overall I see passion for what they like in these franchises. Putting that aside all he could really do is deepfake or cast someone as Luke. I don’t have any issue with this. I already dislike the idea of deepfakes but it in its current form, fan made content is a better place for imo.
I’d prefer if AI and deepfakes were entirely avoided but I doubt that’s possible at this point.
@@Ar1AnX1xTH-camr's using deepfake/AI for non profit fan projects has no actual effect on the movie industry. Your beef should be with the movie industry itself.
@@Ar1AnX1x really? Why you all people so salty about using A.I. in situations where it isn't really possible to get live footage/voice/etc? It's basically the same shit that studious were doing with actors and all that since the moment computer graphic opportunities got shown to them. Damn, not so long ago, after death of Carrie Fisher, creators of last shitty movies were using materials that were captured before her death with heavy adding of graphic to mimic her appearing like "alive" in films. I didn't her people shitting on this, while it's basically the same as using A.I. But noooo, goddamn youtubes are the real problem, yes.
@@daniilbelov8652because the studios payed the family of said dead actor to use as a.i. generated cgi... In this case somebody would be stealing your face, your own face without permission, to do something good or bad, and you get nothing out of it... How is that ok? That's the problem here.
Bro, I've always appreciated you and your transparency. You are probably the only SW TH-camr/fan who has perfectly expressed my feelings on SW.
I have a similar view of SW's (and DB's) importance to me, from childhood to adulthood. Which is why it saddens me so much that people who don't care about it, are making it into something that the fans and the creator don't even recognize.
Keep up the great work brother! I will always support, pray for, and stick by you!
Bro it hasn’t changed at all your bitchin for nothin.
I don't think he hates you. He just answered the question? Who cares? Do your thing theory💗
I hope so. So many actors from Star Wars have been disappointing me. The phrase "Never meet your heroes" just gets more and more true each day.
Theory doesn't give af. He's just using a misleading title to make money. Sad it's gotten to this but yeha
@@Gino_5550 You don't stay on TH-cam for eight years without learning the art of clickbaiting. Every good TH-camr clickbaits.
Single word responses leaves theory to handle a PR firestorm. Wouldve be kind if Mark Hamil added that he was okay with it or not or just not respond to tweets like that when theres a ton others that do the same thing.
@@BeTeLGeuZeXwhy would he be ok with it
Mark Hamill: “The sky is blue.”
The Ocean: “OMG mArK hAmiLL hAtEs mE!!!!”
EXACTLY
I left when he said he'd happily pad his subscriber stats, _himself,_ if he could! What a douche.... what a douche... (waits for the delete or YT to censor me 🙄...ugh George Orwell would be having a fit... I'm so done with this planet and newer generations)
Have fun KevyNova!
Damn, are yall even subscribed to this dude, seems like every video has somebody saying he’s being extra or something
@@OldManPaxusYT what are you even trying to say? lmao
@@OldManPaxusYT Who wouildn't pad their own stats if they could lol
To be fair all he responded was ''no'' if he had your side of the story and all the details about it on how its purely for entertainment and not profit, im sure he would sign off on it.
or they cld of ask MH if it was cool to do so
Exactly. Theory just needed to ask Mark for permission. Thats it.
Disney won't though.
@@lolmetswhathappeneduhhh2029He already has an agreement with Disney/LucasFilm. They don’t care as long as he’s not profiting off of it financially. It’s why he has to fund it all on his own and can’t monetize in any way.
The actor.....is not the character.
yeah but you have to use the actors face for the character
To be fair, this is what many actors were striking against; using their AI likeness without permission and without being paid. Sure, it's different in terms of a fan film, but it can still be a gray area. Maybe the safest bet would be to contact him and ask for permission, he may even respect that. That way none of these haters can complain that you didn't at least try.
Just ask for permission. Thats all I ask for when it comes to fan films that use a person’s likeness. Whether its for good or bad just ask for consent.
@@TheUnpredictable2020the issue stems from any profit and/or potential profits. Like sure, SWT could say he's not making any money from the fan film, but if Disney catches wind of any profit being made off of their IP they will come down hard.
you’re exactly right. i like star wars and respect art as much as the next guy but you’re profiting off of someone else’s likeness without their permission and they get no compensation for it. i don’t like this project at all and i won’t support it.
Can you name 5 movies that were using AI created celebrities?
He's super woke and narcissistic in his attitude to work as are most "actors" right now... its a deal thay made that didn't include residual payment... for example... the art of acting is being killed off by self inserts and so on... I'm not sure anyone with a brain gives a dam what an old man who only stands to help himself thinks. Remember Mark loves woke political attacks on fiction all up until it hits his charicter in star wars... he only cears about himself.
1) He doesnt hate you, he answered truthfully. 2) You should've asked him regardless just to get his blessing if nothing else
@@notmyrealhandleYou're not serious, are you? If you are serious. Of fucking course Mark Hamill owns the rights to his own face and voice, SWT could have easily messaged Hamill to ask if he could use his likeness for this deep fake, but he decided to be lazy and do it without permission instead.
@@notmyrealhandle Of course he does.
He has no reason to ask him, people can freely make recreations of other people. The only issue is when you claim its the real person.
Watch the video 🤡
I wouldn’t last Mark he’s insulted SW fans in the pass
Wait i think your misinterpreted this. Op basically asked mark hamil if he was given permission to use him and mark hamil just said no as in he wasn't aware he was being used for this project. Mark never said anything about hating you, he just said no when being asked the said question.
Edit: just watched the video and i may have misunderstood the sarcasm on the title
Clickbait=$$
But the thing is does he even actually have to ask mark for his permission? He’s not making any money off of this.
Sure, but it's telling that he even bothered responding to the question in the first place... especially in such a dismissive manner
@@slimmdusty8809 if someone were to use ur face in a project would u want them to ask ur permission? Cause It’s just kinda rude personally, regardless of money; not like Mark or Theory need any more lol
@@slimmdusty8809ABSOLUTELY HE DOES!!! Would you like it if someone used your likeness without consent and without you knowing? I doubt you would.
Long time subscriber (March '17). Always happy to see your posts. TH-cam doesn't recommend your content often anymore for whatever reason but I look up your channel every so often to get updates. Keep it up.
I think this had more to do with legal likeness rights than anything personal.
commenter: was your permission given for the use of your likeness?
Mark: no (the simplest answer to touch a screen)
Theory: mArK hAmIl DOeSnT lIKe mE
Not how it went busta but go off
Its clickbait bro. A lot of youtubers do it
That is literally what happened@@vangelisgru7271
@@vangelisgru7271brother that's exactly how it went
@@vangelisgru7271That’s almost word for word what happened
I would bet money the purpose was to stir up drama and Mark probably can’t give his blessing for the project if he wants to since the character is owned by Disney
That's what the Internet is all about, stirring up drama to get likes and popularity.
Blind loyalty isn't a virtue, all he said was no, that's like a girl telling you to get a job and you accuse her of cheating
Im confused? He just said he never gave permission. Doesn't sound like he doesn't like you
It is just click bait
His ego is just so big that he thinks MH saying "no" is a personal attack.
Fr no idea how he managed to make a 12 minute video on this
@@adamjensen8702not really his ego, people are coming at theory because of MH so he is addressing those people here
@@ZerotheeHeroit's total click bait. Stop lying
Bro really made a whole interpretation off of the word “no”. Feels like my English classes where the teacher analyzes one word and makes a whole story about what it can mean 😂
bro fr lol
Theory is a huge drama queen now. Dude loves to play victim and clickbait
@@danielvera2836tbh ye
@@danielvera2836 dude he was referring to the tweeter not Theory, if you hate him so much then why are you even here?
Broski your comprehension levels clearly aren't all there mate.
Well the whole actors strike was about such matters so fresh in actors minds atm.
One aspect about was about who gets paid if others are using a known actors image for their own monetary gain. I’m not sure if Hamill knew whether it was monetised or not.
Ive been lucky enough to meet mark hamill briefly at a con, I was a kid and didnt have a ticket to see anyone at the autograph booths area. I was dressed up like luke skywalker and mark saw me from afar and smiled and waved at me and did a funny face. Its now 15+ years later and ill still never forget that moment. I dont think Mark would ever intentionally try to hurt your feelings here, especially with how passionate about starwars you clearly are. I think he was just quickly responding to the question and hes entitled to say no. I dont think he meant to offend
Wait until Mark finds out you don't like bricks!!! 😂
He just said "no" dont overthink it
All he said was no when asked if you had asked him permission to use his likeness with AI deepfakes. This is a bit of a leap in logic.
You are brilliant man. The work you did with episode 1 was brilliant and the passion for Star Wars shows. The countless hours… it shows. 🎉
Mark simply replies “no”
Star Wars Theory: HE HATES ME
Honestly when it comes to deep fakes, you have to be careful. The strikes over it literally just ended, it's a very sensitive topic for actors because it can set a precedent where anyone can use their likeness without compensation or approval. As a person, that has to be a really weird thing to see and be used like that. I believe getting permission on these things from the actor is important for this. I believe you should have tried to do that, and I don't believe this means Mark hates you. I get this really sucks, but just try to be careful going forward
It's irrelevant what Mark thinks on this topic anyway because he doesn't own the rights to his likeness when referenced as Luke Skywalker. He signed that away a long time ago. SWT has an agreement with LucasFilm who do own the likeness rights.
The stuff with the actors strike also isn't relevant because SWT isn't part of the industry, nor is he in any of the relevant unions. Those agreements aren't legally binding to the wider population because it isn't a piece of US legislation, just a contract between private entities.
It wasn’t a deepfake strike. It was an overall AI strike.
Deepfake still works best on the OG actor it’s trying to deepfake, and deepfake are still best used to make someone younger.
@@dylanzrim3635 Deepfake is AI and was specifically addressed not to be exploited in the new contract, among other things like AI voicework
@@HenryCurrie-q2e It doesn't matter if he owns Luke Skywalker or not, it is still him, Mark Hamill. He still has a basic right to his personal face and public image because it is literally him. SWT doesn't have any rights of use for Luke Skywalker either, which is why this is a big deal and one of the reasons the actors strike happened, because of unfair usage of their public image in AI
Did Elvis give permission for people to pretend to be him and make money at events?
All mark said was “no” he didn’t bash you my guy lmao
SWT: “Disney has made Star Wars political.”
OT, PT: “are we a joke to you??!”
They say it's better to ask for forgiveness than permission. In Theory's case, he should have simply asked Mark for permission to use his likeness and make the best content around his character. That way, you don't have to apologize.
It's my two cents.
my guy gaslighting the entire star wars community even when mark hamill just literally answered "no".
Didn’t watch, huh? You must be a Twitter weirdo lol
@@kyuubifox339:43 why is he implying that mark hamill is against the idea?
@@frankieiero6859He literally said "No problem." Not sure what drugs you're on.
@@theprussianviking it is true he said "No problem", but why would he imply in the first place that mark is against the idea when he just answered the question?
This is a Community? I thought it was an endless cycle of bickering about what’s good and what’s not and attacking people for liking things other people don’t like like the New Shows, Dave Filoni, the Animated Shows, and Ahsoka. 😏
He just answered a question, which had nothing to do with whether he “likes” you.
If you actually watch the video, he’s being sarcastic smh
They make a mountain out of a mole hill. All he did was say no. I'm sure he will watch it when all things are done
Mark loves seeing peoples fan made work. I don’t think he is mad at all, just answering the question.
Keep being creative, my friend ❤😊. I know me and many others appreciate your hard work to make the Star Wars we want.
Yeah. You really need a new title for this video. Mark literally answered a question to the best of his knowledge. No ill intent at all.
He doesn't need a new title, he purposely did it for the clicks. Come on, man. This is the internet game.
@@thejanusproject32 so what if it’s internet? Current title makes him look like a whiny bitch lol
Dividing by 0 makes more sense than haters. Seriously, what's wrong with these people? Main reason why I stay away from social media.
Not a fan of the click bait brother, but I'm a fan of the content. Keep doing your thing, I'm grateful for the fan fictions!
Who cares u big baby
Content 👍🏻 Titles 👎
The content is just him crying at a camera for 10+ minutes
Clickbait is to trigger his haters who all happen to be Disney shills
@@Do_not_at_me_bro a shill is in on the grift and gets a share of the takings. I think you mean Disney fans
To be fair, isnt this the kinda thing the whole strike was about??
Thank you for making and continuing this channel. I was born in 83 so just had the originals to watch on TV so grew up on them. I was always frightened of my father as he had a very cruel and selfish personality. So I instantly identified with Luke and Darth Vader.
In the late 90s 2000s I was in high school when the prequels came out. They got a lot of flack and everyone's option was influenced that they were terrible films. So when you said it wasn't cool to be a Star Wars fan at school, that really spoke to me. As unfortunately I had to act like I wasn't into it, one kid admitted he liked Star Wars and Star Trek and he was labelled the biggest Nerd in school, and it wasn't a cool thing to claim to be then.
But now everyone knows I love Star Wars and I connect with all of it including the sequels such as Kylo Ren. Thank you for continuing this channel
MLFBWY
You like the sequels? This isn't the channel for you brother. Believe me I used to like this guy too but there are way better channels than this clown. I'd recomend the Gold Man
I feel u ...I had to do the same in HS and before and I remember years ago after stop giving a shit and embracing anything I love I had a boxing trainer that was really in the streets and for codename purposes.."wit the sh" dude was strapped at all times and man he was a great fighter and I'm bigger and had more reach. Had surgery on both ears because of his brutal methods(human punching bag).. anyways he always was fascinated with the lore of star wars and loved the prequels. He definitely looked like the last person on earth who would bust out talking about like Skywalker and I admired he didn't give a shit with any crowd or whoever. Prolly because he was so damn good with his hands. He loved star wars so much he believed fake trailers were real...that's next level lol..(sarcasm). Anyways I don't know where I'm going with this
Growing up, I watched ANH every other Saturday for a year, to the point my family hated it. When Heir to the Empire came out, I read it in '92 and fell in love all over again. I began pestering my parents for the books or at least checking them out from the library. Guess who I had to talk to about my favorite franchise of all time?
Spoiler alert : No one. I was teased at school for my constant reading. I never fit in with anyone, nor could I share my love for it. I'm glad Theory has this channel/outlet with people that enjoy what Lucas created. I'm happy to listen to a fellow fan.
He didn't say he didn't like you he just said No about you asking to use his face
Exactly lol actors just had s strike over AI and pay…. This wasn’t about Mark “hating” him.
@@StarWarsThrowbacks Well that only applies when there's money involved to begin with. Theory isn't making money off of this. He is only losing his own money on it because he loves Star Wars. His agreement with Disney is pretty clear. Nothing commercial allowed.
@@RadioactiveGooseNo, it has NOTHING to do with money. Its about respecting the actors wishes of having the ability to consent to where their face is used. Mark allowed Disney, he did not okay it for this, therefore he does not have the right to do so without his permission wheather or not money is involved
I wouldn't either
@@WereSquatch Unfortunately.. that is not up to Mark Hamill. Something you all need to understand.
To be fair, we as actors just had a whole strike about AI, using our likeness without our consent, among other things.
And it would be a horrific legal nightmare for you both if he did say “yes”.
Don’t take it personally, my dude!
But that is about earning money. It doesn’t apply to this because you can’t make money off Star Wars fan films. So the actor isn’t being ripped off for the use of their likeness since there is no money to be made
Maybe Hollywood should try making some good stuff for a change instead of insulting their fans for rejecting their poorly written garbage? Actors and writers are rich, the strike was the most out of touch thing I've ever seen, yet I'm expected to feel sorry for Hollywood elites all of a sudden.
What do you mean "we" shut up
@@Maximilian_Ingrossohe’d still be making money from ad revenue, especially if the fan film attracts new people to the channel
@@Maximilian_Ingrosso WTF are you talking about this isn't about money? Even if the fan film isn't monetized, it grows the Star Wars Theory brands. He makes money from TH-cam views and from merch. He makes money from it regardless, just not directly.
It’s seems like you’re more interested in making click bait than anything productive. They asked if Mark gave permission…. Mark answered honestly and said: “no.” He didn’t hate on you, he didn’t say anything negative. I noticed Disney Star Wars and the media are trying very hard to paint Mark Hamill in a bad light and to demonize him. He has been spot on about how badly Disney ruined his character. So we should be showing love to him and not hate. He didn’t do or say anything wrong to you, he just said “no they didn’t ask me…”
Mark Hamill: no
Star Wars Theory: 11:57 video
Look at the tweets dude, he’s responding and calling out those idiots who are interpreting it as mark hating him
I still can’t believe he made a simple ‘no’ to a question all about himself, this channel is really in the mud 💀
This is lame I've unsubbed lol.
Honestly I used to love theory's videos, but they've really gone downhill, it's just not for me anymore
Yup, this is the last time I'm dealing with his b.s as well, been a fan for a VERY long time. Not anymore.
He's a classic narcissist. People are saying, "Mark doesn't hate you, etc." But Mark Hamill DEFINITELY hates people like Theory.
he was just poking fun of the replies
"Did they ask permission?"
"No"
"OmG, hE dOeSnT lIKe Me"
I can’t wait to see your take on Luke. He’s always been my favourite character and you’re my favourite Star Wars TH-camr so, best of both worlds!
Theory come on bro, this is a clickbait. Mark didn't say anything negative about you or anything that could be interpreted as he doesn't like you. He just answered a question on whether he gave approval for his likeness to be used. I don't quite understand why you care what woke Twitter thinks. Just put them on ignore like all of society has done.
I agree with most of what you said, but your comment kinda lost credibility when you used the word "WoKe" unironically.
That’s the title because that’s what people were saying dude
@@dmaxwell910901the fact that people say woke unironically makes it a real word people use, it’s cringe to deny reality
@@oldylad Uh at what point did I say that it wasn't a word people used?
I love how you imagined something I didn't even say, then went on to say that *I* deny reality... That irony 👌
And you’re still subscribed to this guy😂😂😂. Everyone here is clowning on this douche!! 😂
Guys don’t put blinders on. Mark didn’t _have_ to say anything. The fact he singled out this question and chose to reply makes it extremely clear he’s not happy about it. And read the thread, it’s full of people openly crapping on Theory. That’s not a coincidence.
What a load of nonsense. The strike that ended just a few weeks ago dealt with big issues surrounding AI. He did the right thing by responding and that’s all it was.
Of course the people hating in the thread is a coincidence. They all posted after Mark’s reply. It isn’t and cannot be evidence for Mark’s intentions. Anything regarding the context of why he replied in the first place might be considered “evidence”, but it’s still mostly guesswork.
@@LegitScott you’re drawing a false comparison between the two and slapping “AI bad” as a label on both. Part of the strike was to _regulate_ AI, to protect actors from being scanned once and then cut out of residuals while studios use their likeness indefinitely. SWT is an independent fan using deepfakes for a personal project _that makes no money_ . Those two things are not the same.
@@chaossalad3243 it’s not guesswork that Mark chose to bluntly answer a sensitive question about a hot subject, and that it elicited a negative response. It doesn’t take a rocket scientist to understand the subtext, or that people are jumping on the opportunity to accuse Theory of clickbait.
I think Mark Hamill doesn’t understand who you are and why you do what you do. He doesn’t watch your channel so he must of thought it was just “some TH-camr making funny videos with his face”
This 100%. Idk why everyone is taking it so personally on his behalf.
Mark has every right to denounce this. Actors and writers just went on strike and one of the major reasons was the risk of being replaced by AI. What SWT is doing is scummy.
I'm pretty sure Hamill understands better than anybody how companies are gonna use A.I to be even more abusive towards their employees and make even more money and how terrible A.I is gonna be, if anything its the audience of this channel and people online who want unregulated A.I who are the ones who don't understand how that works, he's been in the industry for a long time, I donno how anybody here thinks they know better than him
@@StarWarsThrowbackstheory haters with pronouns in the bio are trying to take him down and jump on every little thing
Then why would Mark respond like that? For someone who claims to want to offend some people online? He’s just another Zack Snyder.
Continue doing what you love man. I love your content been watching it for years
Cool back story on your love of Star Wars. I think it’s awesome. Keep up the great work!
As a big fan of your channel for five years, I do think there are a lot of unethical aspects about using AI deep fake and voices. I feel like using an actor who sounds like Mark Hamill and either using (real) art or animation would go a long way.
If a.i. wasn't a thing, trust me, the puritan would be having a fit over the use of an vocal impressionist and CG.
@@ytsmI'll believe it when I see it; show me the people that got mad at Rouge One.
What's the difference? At the end of the day, it's what's on screen that matters. He IS using an animator.
@@RunNGunPhoto based on your channel, it looks like you take some amazing photos and video footage - what if someone fed that footage to an Ai generator and used the resulting content for free instead of hiring you?
It's not unethical if the content is free. The man is losing money to create content for Star Wars fans, because Disney isn't doing it.
Star Wars Garrison never hesitates to take shots and posts about Theory lol
He didn't say that he don't like you, it was all about the permission
After this vid mark probably don’t like him I wouldn’t either after this clickbait
@@mrgoingup626 no that's just you projecting as the silly little haters you all are got baited into watching this video.
@@ViewfromtheVoid no it isn’t just me go read the comments and how am I hating when his title literally says “mark hamill doesn’t like me?” After mark hamill only saying “no” to A question😂yea buddy that’s a very far reach. Theory just wanted clicks and if you can’t see that you’re lost!!
Imagine what a world this would be if our communities thrived off of positivity instead of negativity. Thank you Theory for being a force of light.
WHAT HOW COULD THIS BE MARK DOESNT LIKE STRENGTH THEORY!!!
Love how your the only comment he hearted. Your exactly what he wants, a submissive, gullible child who believes every word he says and nothing else. Enjoy your heart
If you really listen to the situation, he never said this. He said no when asked a likeness question, no disrespect occured and never said he doesnt like him
"Real nerds" is such a gate keeping term.
Gate keeping is good.
Oh for the love of god shut up
He also rips on egirls for making money off nerdy things and calls them opportunists. Is he not aware of what his own job is?
@@Chobaro115 No it isn't
@@jamesarnold7253 The double standard is strong with this one from him
You are one of The main reasons my love for Star Wars still exists , because as a SW fan, I am exhausted
Ive been watching you for the past 5 years everytime i get in to my star wars phase and your content has always been really entertaining and informative.💪
It's crazy how people still come for Theroy's neck for literally everything he does.
Mans likes to complain about bricks and tries to gatekeep the fans....it's deserved.
This is a situation that DOES deserve criticism. Actors just fought for the write to have control over their AI likeness and did not okay this
so its ok with ignore FAIR USE. yes it still applies whether they f*ing like it or not. doing this is saying " we hate fans" so if they want to kill off their REVENUE STREAM, by all means BE MY GUEST.@@WereSquatch
Bro is actually so petty because Mark said
“No”
💀💀💀💀
"I wanna make the best Star Wars content that I wanna see..."
Something Mark can't even say....
Something I wish I could say.
May the Force be with you.
That’s so annoying I’m so sorry dude :/ !! I’m sure he isn’t mad or anything like they haven’t done that to a bunch of celebs and stuff
No people, he's not only saying "no" just cause he didn't participate. Man is an actor/voice actor, he does not want anything to do with AI and obviously disapproves of his likeness being manufactured by numbers.
Calling Hamill an actor is a colossal overstatement.
@@StevenRogers-hw9djHe gets casted, he plays a character on screen, he gets paid. Saying you have braincells is more of an overstatement than a millionaire who made his money ACTING being told hes not an ACTOR.
@@StevenRogers-hw9djLol then who tf qualifies as an actor in your book? JFC the audacity to think your opinion actually matters is the real overstatement here.
@@simonkatz3779 Aw, did I hurt your feelings, little guy? Tough, your opinion is hilariously irrelevant to anyone possessing an IQ over 60.
@@WereSquatch Your demonstration of the fact that his fans are illiterate creeps is fantastic!
Really didn’t like the implication at 3.5 minutes in that girls who just became fans aren’t worthy to be called fans. Dude you can’t keep claiming Star Wars fans “aren’t sexist” and then use so many gendered attacks.
As an “OG” fan by your definition (got my dog-eared copy of Heir to the Empire signed by Timothy Zahn himself) I want to say sorry to the people being bullied today for liking Star Wars like I was bullied as a kid. If you’re a woman who likes new Star Wars, I’m so sorry for people like this guy. You’re as much a fan as any of us.
To be clear: please keep creating fan content. My sister and I are long time viewers; I just mean that it’s time to live up to what you keep saying about being “apolitical.”
At the end I like your point about this being a question of respect for what Mark Hamill has achieved as an artist. I know many actors are uncomfortable with their bodies being puppeteered on screen without consent. Just because someone disagrees with this use of AI doesn’t mean they are a fake fan or fall somewhere on the political spectrum. A lot of “fake fans” probably agree with you, and frankly love a lot of what you’ve created. Attacking the character of people criticizing you isn’t helping make your point, it’s just making it harder for people to enter this space who aren’t what you call “O.G. fans.”
Agree that people in this community need to stop with the sexism, even if it's just implied. I feel like you've kind of missed the point of the video, I think he was saying that using Mark Hamill's image like this is less problematic because he's only making fan works. Fanfictions have infringed on copyright for years, and they're usually treated as harmless. The world would be a lot worse if we didn't have this kind of content out there. (Please don't be sexist). @@jeffreylin2980
Bro I was wondering when someone would point this out. Not cool Theory.
P.S. 3:15 is when it starts
this
stop gatekeeping!
Only Sith deal in absolutes. He didn't imply that all girls are not worthy to be called fans. He specifically singled out these e-girls. jumping on the bandwagon because it's now cool to be considered a nerd and react to content and consume next product. So often, words get twisted or someone's comment gets summed up badly to the degree of distortion....really tiring and not fun anymore
It's not an understanding problem, it's a desire to make it into something else...
support you all the way you really have the vision of what star wars is supposed to be
it’s not about making money or hating star wars it’s about using ai to control someone’s likeness for something they didn’t agree too- 😭😭just cast someone to play him and all of this would go away
The title to your video is very misleading.
Egirls"im such a nerd and geek etc"
SWT:"no, your an opportunist"
Bro that is my favorite thing you have ever said.
Opportunist? thats STW in a nutshell kid, he litterally used others person's likeness without consent lol
@@Noobkiller653 stop crying.
@@gregrobinette8620 stop projecting🤣
@@Noobkiller653 to bring more great SW to fans centered around Luke? What a monster .. you know he doesn't profit from his fanfilms, right?
@@bastianwright3402 and? He still can't use other peoples faces without consent, you only don't care because it isn't yours, plus it does give him profit and fame through this empost mortem excuse of a channel.
You Yes-Man are so brainless, think for yourself for a moment instead of kneeling to everything this cancer survivor says
The theory hate is so forced man, I think this looks really cool.
Agreed
Nah looks like shitty AI work that spits in the face of the actors and writers' strike.
Haters are gonna hate.
Looks like a ps2 cutscene
Now say it again without crying @Gino_5550
I honestly think you put too much mind into what people think, say, do or do not(couldn't help myself). Just keep doing you, your project and your channel is amazing. Been following since forever
It's hard not to when major corporations take what idiots on social media say, and use it to make themselves look good, even if it destroys someone's life. Like what Pablo did when TLJ was released. As the PR guy, he should've been fired for what he did.
@@rebuiltHK47 that one? For sure, I am with you on that one 🤝
The politicalisation of Star Wars was such a strange thing to come back to after I’d bowed out of the fandom years ago. I grew up on the EU, but suddenly if you liked Mara, people are making assumptions about you, especially if you didn’t care for Rey’s character. Absolutely bizarre.
I know right? There are now so many political factions in the Star Wars fandom.
Ironic that you all say this when theory constantly makes it political. Dude literally got so triggered by Mark saying one word that he brought up politics for absolutely no reason in this video.
@@grandmasteryado8478 this.
All he did was say no to that guy. That doesn't mean he doesn't like your fan stuff
As a fellow OG fan of Star-wars and also your channel I can totally agree with your talking points people like us just don’t mix well with this toxic modern day culture we live in keep up the great work.
May the force be with you my freind😊
Agree
I just think it has to be weird seeing people you don't know deep faking you. Which idk, think about if you drew an animation of him or had someone dress up to look like him, it's the same logic but because it's been around AND you know it's not you it's not as weird. This could be a huge case for whether artists can use deepfakes like that.
You're smoking. He's an actor. It's luke Skywalker. His face has been used and "deepfaked" more than most. Not that deep. There's a difference between a likeness and a person. There's a reason Mark Hamill isn't mad lol.
Good grief master skywalker needs a chill pill
He just said no...
@@StoolGoodmanstill
I have been saying this over and over again on my channel!! Star Wars is SO BIG. it's it's perfectly fine to like some bits more than others. and not liking or liking a piece of the content is NOT the same as political expression or views.
Thanks for all your work! LOVE your content!!! Happy to know you're not going anywhere!
>the project you're creating
>another guy is creating it
>wants it to be clear he's not writing any lines, just ripping lines from legends
Bro im not even a minute in and this is a bigger train wreck than I thought lmao
Gotta say I love you saying "I could make the content I make, but I'd rather make cool stuff" which certainly implies how cool your content is.
how many drugs did you take before writing this?
@@shocktnc??????
Click bait asf he just said no lol
Dude, Mark didn't say anything against you or the amazing project that you are working on.
I would caution against accusing the GOAT of the original episodes of not liking you.
I think your frustration should be with the haters in the comments.
I'm not sure why you are even paying attention to them. You do you bro.
I would advise that you alter this video title before you spread any more confusion. Because if nothing actually phases you, then you wouldn't be making this more then it was: an honest answer.
May the Force be with you.
The most toxic thing is the people reacting on X to Mark saying, "No", and mocking Theory.
To be fair he only said you didn’t ask him to use his likeness. Not that you can’t use it or he’s mad about it.
However I think when Mark sees or hears about the project and he knows that you understand and respect his character he will probably enjoy it even if he’s not allowed to say.
Why don’t you start your own Sci-fi adventure as well as Starwars projects. You seem to be good at story telling and you’d be able to monetise and fund more fan films.
Head up dude you’re smashing it 🤘
tbf, you are getting heated while he gets subs every month while getting a LOT of views and THEEEN gets a LOT of attention, you are giving him as to what he wants
@@JordanWheeler1999 I don’t understand what you mean by that??
@@maccsamillion3158 then sorry to break it to you if you don't understand
@@JordanWheeler1999 break what to me?? 😅
@@maccsamillion3158 😉