Ford Mustang Mach-E vs. Tesla Model Y -- Which One Should You Buy?

Is the Tesla Model Y The Best Electric SUV? Is the Ford Mustang Mach-E better than the Tesla Model Y? Is the Ford Mustang Mach-E The Best Electric SUV? Should I Buy a Tesla Model Y? Should I Buy a Ford Mustang Mach-e? Does the Tesla Model Y have Apple CarPlay? Does the Tesla Model Y have Android Auto? Does the Ford Mustang Mach-E have Apple CarPlay? Does the Ford Mustang Mach-E have Android Auto?
We will answer all these questions and more with my excellent comparison video!
To watch my full review of a 2024 Tesla Model Y Performance, please click here:
• 2024 Tesla Model Y Per...
To watch my full review of a 2023 Ford Mustang Mach-E Select, please click here:
• Ford Mustang Mach-E Se...

[@CarDietrich]

At 2:10 there is a factual error, in between the time I started working on the script for this video Ford announced a version of the Mach-E with slightly longer range than the longest range Model-Y. However I still would have given the point for “EV-ness” to the Tesla for its expansive Supercharger network.

[@fundme3215]

Model Y sales # speaks for itself.

[@sunlover5150]

Ford branded EV’s now have access to the Tesla Supercharger network.

[@CarDietrich]

If that is true then the Ford wins even harder

[@justinpro9733]

@@CarDietrich It is true

[@mosconi0359]

Classic example of padding the stats so that the wrong vehicle gets chosen. The points given to the Mach-E were for style and looks and let's say "ergonomics." What matters most to EV users is "performance, ease of charging, and comfort (ie: roominess). Model Y wins hands-down in these most important areas. It is easy to "say" you'd prefer the Mach-E over the Tesla, but I bet this guy didn't buy a Mach-E.

[@lemmuhj]

I've been burned by FORD quality over the past 3 decades and so I'd have to write off the Ford because of this..I swore to never give them another chance.

[@rcdizo]

nobody is buying the mach e's. thousands of inventory at dealers nationwide and they cant sell them. same as lightnings f150's

[@mechmany2k]

With the current depreciation on both models... neither...

[@galaxiedance3135]

Anyone who's given a choice between these two cars and choses the Ford. They deserve all the problems that they're going to get with it. This is absolutely a no brainer! Only people who are stuck in the 80's and always wanted a Mustang but never could would want this. This E.V. stuff is kind of a new technology, why wouldn't you pick the company who has the most knowledge of how to build one.

[@unlimitedhoops3784]

Model Y is much better from someone who has owned both

[@unlimitedhoops3784]

and it ain't close

[@6AM_YT]

What do you like better about it? I have a Mach E that I've come to the end of my time with and I'm considering the Y.

[@MrFoxfire510]

The small narrow wheels on the mach e alone should make it loose it’s 1 point in the looks department. The tesla model y has a nice set of shoes on it with some good wide rubber.

[@Sammy-sd8sb]

Everything in life fluctuates.
Love how the American brand doesn’t have a 3rd party to jack up the price for us Americans.

[@jjamespacbell]

Buy the Mustang:
If you dislike buying the most American-built car, Mach-E is assembled at Cuautitlán Assembly in Cuautitlán Izcalli, Mexico.
If you don't want the highest performance and efficiency
If you are happy with a car that fails the "Moose Test"
If you don't want your family in the safest car in the world
If you don't want a car built in an Elon Musk factory
if you don't want a vehicle capable of autonomous driving on city streets.

[@Sammy-sd8sb]

Tesla for the win
👇

[@eeroala5132]

This is not even a fair competition

[@humanbeing8855]

Agree

[@Igoriann]

Nothing to argue. All facts. I picked Mach e for those reasons

[@TheParsaver]

Which Ford dealershit are you working for ?

[@keithferguson6422]

Tesla model Y all day long....

[@tomm5480]

I’m in this very pickle trying to decide. I honestly don’t want a Tesla, EVERYONE has one…I’m in so-cal and they’re everywhere, a driving appliance. I don’t like being at a stoplight and seeing a half dozen cars just like mine (it’s bad enough with my current ride, a Macan S). I’m leasing, I’ll buy electric after that….so it’s not permanent. Money wise a 23 machE premium is quite a bit cheaper to lease. I also can’t imagine not having CarPlay and the machE wins in looks hands down. 99% of my charging will be at home….plus you can now use the Tesla network to charge at….it’s becoming easier as I write this…

[@CarDietrich]

If the Mach-E is cheaper to lease, its a no brainer.

[@RicardoLopez-zw1st]

Ford 😎

[@toronado455]

I prefer the Mach-E slightly over the Model Y. For me, the main problem with the Model Y is the ride quality. But the Mach-E isn't stellar in that area either, just less punishing than the Model Y.

[@CarDietrich]

Agreed.

[@Passportbros8]

The model Y does look like an 🥚 egg. I confirmed.

[@toronado455]

😂