And even if there was a miscarriage, and Batman caused it, he was merely defending himself from a threat. If anyone's negligent and to blame, it would be Harley putting herself in danger, attacking Batman when she knew she was pregnant. Either Batman wouldn't have known she was pregnant at all, or he knew she was, but having to defend himself from her when she attacked him. It would have been a sad situation, but that wouldn't make Batman a horrible person, given the context.
I could see Ivy slowly dying from the effects of Titan like Joker did. While both had an immunity or resistance to toxins, Titan did a number on Joker.
@@ccghidorah1 I would assume that similar to some fungi, Ivy would possess the ability to adapt to said toxins and either push them out, or absorb them to alter and improve her own immune system. But you may be right. 🤔
@@-Ughly-true and I have noticed in my opinion she seems to age more in this game compare the previous Arkham games so it kinda makes sense about her slowly dying from the titan implant
@@darlingxluxii7977 She's definitely aging faster than normal. Which yeah, is probably a result of the Titan. Hmmm, I'm thinking y'all may be right hah
a personal theory of mine (if this has been done to death I’m sorry, I’ve only been into the games for about a year now), is that the Scarecrow in Arkham Knight was Anarky doing a little identity theft as a treat. They make a big point out of nobody knowing what happened to him, and the ensuing chaos of the Cloudburst and tearing down Batman seems within his wheelhouse. Maybe instead of getting eaten by Croc, he was just severely injured, and those Scarecrow messages in Arkham City could’ve been from him after he picked up where Crane left off. Maybe the Scarecrow mask we find lying around was discarded by Anarky because it didn’t match what he wanted to be well enough. not sure but that’s my idea
I personally don't think Jervis was scouting Vicki, I think he was defo scouting Batman seeing as in Knight he wants Batman to be his Alice in the jail cell
@@BestManGamer But again, going off the tapes, it could imply he was setting her to be his Alice. She was probably trying to interview both of them (Quincy and Hugo) before the events of Asylum, and after.
@@zock5766 It should be out either Tuesday or Wednesday! I also plan on making a compilation video of all the Arkham Theory videos I've done. So that way it makes it easier for everyone by being able to watch that one video, rather than all four individual videos hah 🤍
I seriously love your videos dude! ❤ they are so awesome ❤ keep up. I think next theory you could do the scene where we thought Barbara died in the gas room but fans speculated that the actual body is a militia soldier and Batman was hallucinating seeing Barbara dying thus crane trying to fool Batman in that scene. ❤❤
@@darlingxluxii7977 Thank you so much 🤍 I really appreciate that! And ohhh, yeah, I'll definitely use that one, and I'll shout you out for the suggestion! I plan on making a compilation of all the Arkham Theory videos I've done so far. That way, its easier for everyone to just watch that one video, rather than all four hah 🤍
@@-Ughly-welcome!! ❤omg thank you so much! 🥹💜🫶🏽 it means a lot man! Yeah that’s awesome idea you should do that! 😭 also another theory is that people said crane’s voice is different from asylum and knight because of croc attack. That is a theory too because he seems so different in knight compare to asylum. I know it’s the croc 🐊 attack but just his voice is insanely different.
My theory on ivy is that she was not dying, but perhaps because of how long its been since the titan incident, she might have been having her powers start to fade. Its possible that since her powers came from a chemical spill, and that everyone seems to need refreshing in asylum and city, ivy just simply was reverting from a plant monster to the scientist she was back before the accident. Then her sacrificing herself to save gotham would mean so much more, since its the town that caused her to become a monster to begin with. A big theme of arkham knight is moving on and accepting mistakes, so having ivy move on from both evil and her plant powers as well feels right.
I don't think that Batman causing Harley's miscarriage (if that's even how it happened and not the alternate possibility others have pointed out that the brand of pregnancy test Harley used in the earlier game had a tendency to give false positives) would make him a bad person. Even with Detective Mode, you can't tell if Harley's pregnant and she attacked him (as well as coming equipped with a long, LOOOOONG history of trying to kill Batman), so I don't see anything wrong with Batman defending himself, especially since he always seems to go easier on Harley than the regular goons. If anything, going into battle with a guy who's regularly beaten her with ease would make Harley worse than she already is if she knew or suspected she was pregnant at the beginning of Arkham City. Knowing how much she loves Joker, however, I'm guessing she didn't start taking any pregnancy tests until later and never would have gone into battle if she even had an inkling that she was carrying a Joker-baby. Given she has no baby-bump, however, I'm guessing the baby was too small to have been hurt by that throw (the baby would be the size of a cell or so, which seems hard to hit with only slight concussive force)...I don't know how this kind of thing works, though, so I could be wrong and even a microscopic baby can be hurt with a fistfight.
1) ivy wasn’t dying, scarecrow had her locked up and formed tests on her, which is how he knew his toxin could kill her 2) in season of infamy, we know that surgical tools did cut through croc’s skin, so it’s reasonable to assume that before this, scarecrow was able to inject fear toxin. It also explains how scarecrow was so fucked up (cuts on his body) 3) the pregnancy test tells us it can show fake results, so Harley wasn’t actually pregnant. Plus she never mentions of a potential baby in city dlc and knight
@@Yourfat247 A needle is completely different than high tech surgical tools. Meaning; For his needles to be able to inject him, he would've had to designed them with the intention of putting Croc under the toxin. Which is something I can't see Scarecrow doing. Especially on such short notice.
3:13 Harley would have been the cause of the miscarriage, if she knew she was pregnant she was an imbecile for trying what always fails against Batman. She never was too bright.
The original writer wanted her to be pregnant for the dlc and knight, but he was let go near the end of city and the new writers retconned that idea, as well as Hush’s bigger role in knight.
Maybe Ivy was sick with the TITAN Joker gave her in Asylum! This is a fantastic video man, thanks for making it!
@@BeeSquared I appreciate you! Thank you so much 🤍
For Theory 4, I always assumed that the original pregnancy test was a false positive and that there was never a baby to miscarry.
@@nicholasfarrell5981 You could very well be right 🤔
Yeah and plus we would’ve seen Harley in pain if the miscarriage happened
@@darlingxluxii7977 Thats a REALLY good point! 🤍
And even if there was a miscarriage, and Batman caused it, he was merely defending himself from a threat. If anyone's negligent and to blame, it would be Harley putting herself in danger, attacking Batman when she knew she was pregnant.
Either Batman wouldn't have known she was pregnant at all, or he knew she was, but having to defend himself from her when she attacked him. It would have been a sad situation, but that wouldn't make Batman a horrible person, given the context.
Most likely, I Harley is the type to hold grudges and absolutely would have brought it up.
I could see Ivy slowly dying from the effects of Titan like Joker did. While both had an immunity or resistance to toxins, Titan did a number on Joker.
@@ccghidorah1 I would assume that similar to some fungi, Ivy would possess the ability to adapt to said toxins and either push them out, or absorb them to alter and improve her own immune system. But you may be right. 🤔
@@-Ughly-true and I have noticed in my opinion she seems to age more in this game compare the previous Arkham games so it kinda makes sense about her slowly dying from the titan implant
@@darlingxluxii7977 She's definitely aging faster than normal. Which yeah, is probably a result of the Titan. Hmmm, I'm thinking y'all may be right hah
“What do you Y’all think? Do you y’all think [X]?”
Big Dora-Talking-to-the-Camera energy (very fun video, great job)
a personal theory of mine (if this has been done to death I’m sorry, I’ve only been into the games for about a year now), is that the Scarecrow in Arkham Knight was Anarky doing a little identity theft as a treat. They make a big point out of nobody knowing what happened to him, and the ensuing chaos of the Cloudburst and tearing down Batman seems within his wheelhouse. Maybe instead of getting eaten by Croc, he was just severely injured, and those Scarecrow messages in Arkham City could’ve been from him after he picked up where Crane left off. Maybe the Scarecrow mask we find lying around was discarded by Anarky because it didn’t match what he wanted to be well enough. not sure but that’s my idea
@@nunyabizness4584 Thats a good one 😲 I like that!
Yeah but we see scarecrow and red hood next to each other T the end of the game
@@Flareguy oh shoot really? I forgot, when was it?
@@nunyabizness4584 at the very end of the game when he shoots free Batman for him to stop scarecrow
I personally don't think Jervis was scouting Vicki, I think he was defo scouting Batman seeing as in Knight he wants Batman to be his Alice in the jail cell
@@BestManGamer You got a point, but I still love the thought of Hugo setting her up as Hatter's Alice, in order to get rid of her.
@@-Ughly- It actually wasn't Hugo setting up Vale cause it was Joker who called her and told her where Batman was
@@BestManGamer But again, going off the tapes, it could imply he was setting her to be his Alice. She was probably trying to interview both of them (Quincy and Hugo) before the events of Asylum, and after.
@@-Ughly- she could have been yeah but if so why not just throw her into Arkham City like they did Jack Ryder?
@@BestManGamer Maybe she was smarter than Ryder, and didn't get caught hah
Can‘t wait for the next video!
@@zock5766 It should be out either Tuesday or Wednesday! I also plan on making a compilation video of all the Arkham Theory videos I've done. So that way it makes it easier for everyone by being able to watch that one video, rather than all four individual videos hah 🤍
I seriously love your videos dude! ❤ they are so awesome ❤ keep up. I think next theory you could do the scene where we thought Barbara died in the gas room but fans speculated that the actual body is a militia soldier and Batman was hallucinating seeing Barbara dying thus crane trying to fool Batman in that scene. ❤❤
@@darlingxluxii7977 Thank you so much 🤍 I really appreciate that! And ohhh, yeah, I'll definitely use that one, and I'll shout you out for the suggestion! I plan on making a compilation of all the Arkham Theory videos I've done so far. That way, its easier for everyone to just watch that one video, rather than all four hah 🤍
@@-Ughly-welcome!! ❤omg thank you so much! 🥹💜🫶🏽 it means a lot man! Yeah that’s awesome idea you should do that! 😭 also another theory is that people said crane’s voice is different from asylum and knight because of croc attack. That is a theory too because he seems so different in knight compare to asylum. I know it’s the croc 🐊 attack but just his voice is insanely different.
As in his voice is permanently damaged too. Not just his face. Poor crane 🥺 ❤❤❤💕
@@darlingxluxii7977 You're right!! Dang, Crane really went through it, didn't he? Haha
My theory on ivy is that she was not dying, but perhaps because of how long its been since the titan incident, she might have been having her powers start to fade. Its possible that since her powers came from a chemical spill, and that everyone seems to need refreshing in asylum and city, ivy just simply was reverting from a plant monster to the scientist she was back before the accident. Then her sacrificing herself to save gotham would mean so much more, since its the town that caused her to become a monster to begin with. A big theme of arkham knight is moving on and accepting mistakes, so having ivy move on from both evil and her plant powers as well feels right.
@@JoshPhantom Woah 😮 I REALLY like that theory!
What’s worse is that you can’t put on detective mode during the beginning of the church scene
Great video keep up
I don't think that Batman causing Harley's miscarriage (if that's even how it happened and not the alternate possibility others have pointed out that the brand of pregnancy test Harley used in the earlier game had a tendency to give false positives) would make him a bad person. Even with Detective Mode, you can't tell if Harley's pregnant and she attacked him (as well as coming equipped with a long, LOOOOONG history of trying to kill Batman), so I don't see anything wrong with Batman defending himself, especially since he always seems to go easier on Harley than the regular goons.
If anything, going into battle with a guy who's regularly beaten her with ease would make Harley worse than she already is if she knew or suspected she was pregnant at the beginning of Arkham City. Knowing how much she loves Joker, however, I'm guessing she didn't start taking any pregnancy tests until later and never would have gone into battle if she even had an inkling that she was carrying a Joker-baby. Given she has no baby-bump, however, I'm guessing the baby was too small to have been hurt by that throw (the baby would be the size of a cell or so, which seems hard to hit with only slight concussive force)...I don't know how this kind of thing works, though, so I could be wrong and even a microscopic baby can be hurt with a fistfight.
1) ivy wasn’t dying, scarecrow had her locked up and formed tests on her, which is how he knew his toxin could kill her
2) in season of infamy, we know that surgical tools did cut through croc’s skin, so it’s reasonable to assume that before this, scarecrow was able to inject fear toxin. It also explains how scarecrow was so fucked up (cuts on his body)
3) the pregnancy test tells us it can show fake results, so Harley wasn’t actually pregnant. Plus she never mentions of a potential baby in city dlc and knight
@@Yourfat247 A needle is completely different than high tech surgical tools. Meaning; For his needles to be able to inject him, he would've had to designed them with the intention of putting Croc under the toxin. Which is something I can't see Scarecrow doing. Especially on such short notice.
3:13 Harley would have been the cause of the miscarriage, if she knew she was pregnant she was an imbecile for trying what always fails against Batman. She never was too bright.
The original writer wanted her to be pregnant for the dlc and knight, but he was let go near the end of city and the new writers retconned that idea, as well as Hush’s bigger role in knight.
@Luffy.9757 I didn't know that 🤔
Great video. But i think the repetition of scenes it's a little annoying 😉
Hi bro, sorry for not joining your the last of us live, but I don't like that game.
@@IlPinguonauta It's not a problem. 🤍