I don't know [edit:as in I have no idea] if it's the best, but it's the one closest to what I hear inside my mind. I almost want to unlike the video just so I can like it again
Epoustouflant !!! Une telle maîtrise de l'instrument, mêlant tout à la fois virtuosité, légèreté, profondeur, force, délicatesse, harmonie, beauté, sentimentalité... est vraiment quelque chose d'exceptionnel, surtout concernant une œuvre si difficile à interpréter au violon.
Il est clair que ce morceau a originalement été écrit pour le violon et retranscrit pour l'orgue. Il n'est pas sûr qu'il ait été composé par Bach et il a nettement un style du Sud de l'Allemagne, voire même de l'Italie. Une fois au violon on entend plus de lien avec Buxtehude. Le mystère de son origine en fait quelque chose de précieux. Bravo pour cette magnifique interprétation, largement supérieure à tout ce qu'on peut entendre d'autre.
This is an amazing performance. In my opinion - much better than Vengerov's or Krylov's (both using the arrangement by Bruce Fox-Lefriche). The technique is impeccable, without putting too much "violinist ego" into the interpretation, keeping the performance clean, clear, letting the music speak for itself. Bravo !
There are those who say that this piece was not written by Bach, but by one of his students, and that it was written as a violin exercise. In any event, the Dm fugue is my favorite piece of music and she makes it look so easy that it nearly brought tears to my eyes.
@@Narragorth Yes, I am familiar with that theory. Actually, it goes farther than that and posits that the piece was written by one of Bach's students as a practice exercise for violin.
@@fearlessfosdick160 yea, but I can definitely hear "Bach" when it's played on violin. And there is a big difference between "vibe" (not just style) of Bach and his sons, for example, I can hear it. Similar here, I can hear some passages that are similar to other Bach's violin works. So I don't think that it could be written by Bach's student or son's. But, it's only my experience. Btw organ version is definitely written by Bach's student or son's and I can hear it too
@@Narragorth I am not saying that it is not written in Bach's style, of course it is. The truth is that I am not even sure that I buy into the theory. I am just stating what I read about it.
I bet she said 'wheew thank God' in her mind when she finished performing this piece. No mistakes, screeches. Everything was clear, great intonation, great timing. Bravo 👏 👏 👏
Quelle intelligence de jeu..!! Conduite limpide, lumineuse : merveilleux...! Souvenurs émus : entendu cette magnifique violoniste lorsqu'enfant elle étudiait dans le conservatoire ou moi-même enseignait le violon. Le talent de M.-A. Hulot n'avait échappé à personne... Félicitations aux professeurs qui auront permis le plein épanouissement de cette artiste. Merci pour le partage.!
He pulls the strings in my heart ❤️ brings feelings forth into the Light. When addressing the harpsichord on a couple of CD's I have...he can tune me right up. Yep...Good Medicine!
Cette interprétation me touche au plus profond de l'âme. C'est extraordinaire, ce jeu, cette délicatesse... Une sonorité d'instrument au service d'une interprète de talent.
Это бесподобно и восхитительно! Всегда эталоном игры на скрипке для меня был Ицхак Перлман. Но после этого будоражащего сознание исполнения, остаётся громко и в стиле maestoso вскрикнуть Браво!!!
Bien sûr je like cette impressionnante prestation transcription. Un bémol de ma part jouant cette toccata et fugue moi-même sur orgue .Il me semble qu'il faille respecter la tonalité de ré mineur Hors il ya dans cette prestation quelques audaces en Majeur qui à mon avis n'ont pas leur place .Toute l'œuvre doit en principe rester en mode mineur . Sinon un grand bravo tout de même et forcément like. Jean-Robert Dray Autodidacte Auteur Compositeur Interprète youtube.com/@JRDRAY007
I agree with Patrice Avazeri. This transcription is just ...beyond. I have not heard it before. It could be one of the "partitas" and in many ways it is - but just 2 movements. The execution is flawless. I am speechless! The number of instruments for which this piece has been transcribed is remarkable!
Been collecting as many versions of this on as many different instruments as possible. This goes towards the head of the line. Outstanding performance.
Fantástica... brillante... increíble... magistral... magnífica... los mejores calificativos al fin para esta sublime interpretación. Infinitas gracias por compartirla. ¡FELICITACIONES!🌝⚘
I love how dark and hauntingly beautiful this song is no matter the instrument it sounds like an introduction for a vampire on an organ and like a intro for a killer or a boss fight on a violin
This piece was probably initially written for the violin and then adapted to the organ so that explains why it fits perfectly with the violin ! Lovely interpretation 😍
idk i think the piano sounds great due to it allowing more notes WITHOUT the heavy overlay that organs give. as long as the piece has a call and response feel i love most interpretations. but sadly its frequently butched (to my ears) when the musicians just run through the notes. its a piece that has an acquired taste due to so many movements that overlap. (i am by no means a musical elitist but the call and response sounds so awesome that ANY OTHER Iteration just is horrendous, even worse so when the organ has no natural fall off (like the paino does) so that the notes just sound raucous. again that me speaking ill of both the composer and the player.. such a taboo i know. but thats my take. so yeah i love/ hate this piece depending on who and how its played. and she truly did this piece justice. trust me cuz i can play this song 7 times in a row just to compare and contrast different instuments and arrangements (solo, duo, small group full symphony, piano, violin, harp, horn quartet, and so on) at this rate I will listen to this piece just to compare its nuance. (all 8-ish minutes for 4-5 iterations, not including repeats, lol) again im not a music professional just a music lover.
Quelle matrîse de l'instrument ! J''écoute votre performance quotidiennement et je ne m'en lasse jamais Vous êtes un modèle de son pour moi ! Merci 1000 fois !
mi è piaciuta questa esibizione. L'artista ha reso tutto così facile, chiaro e meraviglioso, come si addice a Bach. Rimasi incantato, tanta sensibilità, tecnica così perfetta, come se l'avesse suonata Dio in persona😘
Je n'ai pas de mot pour une telle interprétation... Bach renaît de ses cendres à travers ces notes ... merci Madame, quelle émotion m'avez vous transmis !!
This goes straight to the top of my favorite violin performances. I discovered this video about 2 weeks ago and must have listened to it at least 30 times so far. Bravo, Maestra!
By the way, I have a minor shoulder injury this week and can’t play, so today I asked my violin teacher to spend my weekly lesson by watching your video twice and analyze everything and anything I can learn from your amazing technique. So thank you also for making such an excellent pedagogical video that shows the details your playing so well for fellow violin students.
Meravigliosa Marie-astrid,bellissima interpretazione,note pulite,Grazie di avercela suonata,io sono al quinto anno di violino e un giorno piacerebbe eseguirla👏🌹🌠
Wow , impeccable finesse and mature , sweet mellow tone . Eddie Van Halen would be proud of what he called the “ brown sound “ . A refreshing sound as compared to other contemporary’s of our time in the likes of Hilary Hahn or Anne -Sophie Mutter . Forgive my excitement , but may I ask the weight of your bow ? It’s moves so lightly yet sounds much like a viola bow . Thank you for sharing. This is impressive 😊
Truly amazing clean beautiful full of soul. Bach would turn in his grave for joy I sense. The dynamic is super balanced bringing out these amazing delicious pghraseologies that are the face of the genius of JSB
Très belle interprétation, tout à la fois subtile et animale avec une parfaite maîtrise technique notamment la main droite . Je suis prêt à traverser la France pour aller vous écouter !
Marie-Astrid what a gift and mastery to give us this rendition. Strenght and Beauty cultivated with time and passion. Bach is honored. Thanks. Happy new year.
Только не "беспроблемная" техника, а безупречная. Исполнение действительно очень не плохое, но Коган в своё время играл это "круче". Девочка ещё молодая, весь потенциал в ней откроется с возростом, при наличии усердия.
@@АлександрИванов-з5м2л "девочке" уже 25 лет стукнуло (это Мари-Астрид Юло, она родилась в Париже в 1997 г). Для скрипачки в профессиональном плане это уже, можно сказать, зрелый возраст.
WOW!!! Amazing! Of course I love the organ performances, but this performance is out of this world. The video perspective is fantastic too. I love watching her transitions back and forth on the runs up and down the scales in this classic piece… thank you for sharing this amazing performance.
Unbelievable. Been playing it on the organ all my life, but this exceptional performance convinces me that the solo violin was the original medium of BWV 565. Compared to the great preludes and fugues of Bach's Leipzig years, 565 isn't much of an organ fugue, but as a violin fugue, it's as good as they get. This is a stunning display of total command of the violin to bring us something we have never really heard before, a new and powerful insight on a beloved and important work that still holds mysteries from us. Brava (and bravo to the arranger!)!!!
best rendition ever performed by a violin player
Agreed!
I don't know [edit:as in I have no idea] if it's the best, but it's the one closest to what I hear inside my mind. I almost want to unlike the video just so I can like it again
Je suis violoniste, et je reste bouche bée par un tel talent ! 😮
Moi aussi violoniste et beaucoup d'admiration
Epoustouflant !!! Une telle maîtrise de l'instrument, mêlant tout à la fois virtuosité, légèreté, profondeur, force, délicatesse, harmonie, beauté, sentimentalité... est vraiment quelque chose d'exceptionnel, surtout concernant une œuvre si difficile à interpréter au violon.
Il est clair que ce morceau a originalement été écrit pour le violon et retranscrit pour l'orgue. Il n'est pas sûr qu'il ait été composé par Bach et il a nettement un style du Sud de l'Allemagne, voire même de l'Italie. Une fois au violon on entend plus de lien avec Buxtehude. Le mystère de son origine en fait quelque chose de précieux. Bravo pour cette magnifique interprétation, largement supérieure à tout ce qu'on peut entendre d'autre.
She plays this just so exceptionally well!
This is an amazing performance. In my opinion - much better than Vengerov's or Krylov's (both using the arrangement by Bruce Fox-Lefriche). The technique is impeccable, without putting too much "violinist ego" into the interpretation, keeping the performance clean, clear, letting the music speak for itself. Bravo !
Great comment, thanks! 🎻
讓音樂自己說話，多麼了不起的一個評論！巴哈的音樂在單純的基礎上進行多樣的變化，使得他的作品的內容豐富而燦爛！我也想試著拉拉看這首曲子。
I've heard Krylov whis Tokkata d- moll at really!
krylov's is the best, ego or not, his is very emotive
Pp😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
Wonderful... No words to describe Bach's Master-Piece... and... the Violinist Performance!!!
She plays this piece so effortlessly and beautifully, that it sounds like it was originally written for violon.
There are those who say that this piece was not written by Bach, but by one of his students, and that it was written as a violin exercise. In any event, the Dm fugue is my favorite piece of music and she makes it look so easy that it nearly brought tears to my eyes.
@@Narragorth Yes, I am familiar with that theory. Actually, it goes farther than that and posits that the piece was written by one of Bach's students as a practice exercise for violin.
@@fearlessfosdick160 yea, but I can definitely hear "Bach" when it's played on violin. And there is a big difference between "vibe" (not just style) of Bach and his sons, for example, I can hear it. Similar here, I can hear some passages that are similar to other Bach's violin works. So I don't think that it could be written by Bach's student or son's. But, it's only my experience.
Btw organ version is definitely written by Bach's student or son's and I can hear it too
@@Narragorth I am not saying that it is not written in Bach's style, of course it is. The truth is that I am not even sure that I buy into the theory. I am just stating what I read about it.
@@fearlessfosdick160If it was really the case I would love to know that genuis student name who literally wrote one of the best piece ever
I bet she said 'wheew thank God' in her mind when she finished performing this piece. No mistakes, screeches. Everything was clear, great intonation, great timing. Bravo 👏 👏 👏
Thanks for herself: *she* played!
@@domsau2 whatever
She plays at just the right pace. No showy acrobatics. Just a virtuoso performance.
Quelle intelligence de jeu..!!
Conduite limpide, lumineuse : merveilleux...!
Souvenurs émus : entendu cette magnifique violoniste lorsqu'enfant elle étudiait dans le conservatoire ou moi-même enseignait le violon.
Le talent de M.-A. Hulot n'avait échappé à personne...
Félicitations aux professeurs qui auront permis le plein épanouissement de cette artiste.
Merci pour le partage.!
why, every time I listen to toccata, played by any instrument, tears come to my eyes?💗💗💗
🎼💙🎵☯️🎶💙
That is what Bach is all about.
Oh tears
Oh joy!
Oh tears
of joy!
He pulls the strings in my heart ❤️ brings feelings forth into the Light. When addressing the harpsichord on a couple of CD's I have...he can tune me right up. Yep...Good Medicine!
It is obvious... Because you, too, know great music when you hear it.
Very impressive execution and arrangement of the piece! The dynamics during the fugue section were some of the BEST I've heard!
Beautiful, there is no other word. Perfect to my ears with over 60 years of playing and listening.
I am so obsessed with this performance. I come back here all the time. It's just perfect in every aspect.
So clean, such round sound and perfect speech!! Great job Maestra!
Yes exactly what I think: So beautiful tone and clean intonation!
Cette interprétation me touche au plus profond de l'âme. C'est extraordinaire, ce jeu, cette délicatesse... Une sonorité d'instrument au service d'une interprète de talent.
In blissful awe at this. She seems comfortably "in the zone" all the way through. Masterful and beautiful!
Absolutely brilliant. Would love to hear this live.
Great performance 👏 what great violinist .you deserve million subscribers
Ça me donne des frissons tellement c'est... Comme une puissance tranquille, une certaine violence dans la délicatesse... Tout et son contraire ❤
Absolutely wonderful
Quelle maîtrise de l’instrument 😨!! Interprétation magistrale . 😳🤗 bravo 🎵🎶
Это бесподобно и восхитительно! Всегда эталоном игры на скрипке для меня был Ицхак Перлман. Но после этого будоражащего сознание исполнения, остаётся громко и в стиле maestoso вскрикнуть Браво!!!
Bien sûr je like cette impressionnante prestation transcription.
Un bémol de ma part jouant cette toccata et fugue moi-même sur orgue .Il me semble qu'il faille respecter la tonalité de ré mineur Hors il ya dans cette prestation quelques audaces en Majeur qui à mon avis n'ont pas leur place .Toute l'œuvre doit en principe rester en mode mineur .
Sinon un grand bravo tout de même et forcément like.
Jean-Robert Dray Autodidacte Auteur Compositeur Interprète
youtube.com/@JRDRAY007
Gold for the ears, beautiful, excellent, wonderful !!!
Bravo ! Excellent ! Au violon ce n'est pas évident !
Grandios. Klar strukturiert und wunderbar artikuliert! Eine wahre Freude zuzuhören. Herzlichen Dank!!
Your hard work has really paid off young lady this is perfection to my ears! Bravo!! Love the dress too!🙏🙏🙏
Bravo!!! **standing ovation as tears roll down my cheeks** ♥♥♥
I agree with Patrice Avazeri. This transcription is just ...beyond. I have not heard it before. It could be one of the "partitas" and in many ways it is - but just 2 movements. The execution is flawless. I am speechless! The number of instruments for which this piece has been transcribed is remarkable!
I didn't thought it was even possible, what an acuracy, beautiful
Been collecting as many versions of this on as many different instruments as possible. This goes towards the head of the line. Outstanding performance.
What unusual instruments are there recordings of?
@@M_SC the melodica
Glass Duo does a fabulous interpretation of this song! Check them out if you haven't already.
@@M_SC Accordion(Sergei Teleshev). Guitar trio(California Guitar Trio). Harp(Amy Turk). Flute(Tim Macri). Brass quintet( Canadian Brass).
The depth of my impression listening to her wonderful performance Ìs immeasurable, and beyond description.
My soul Ìs purified
Fantástica... brillante... increíble... magistral... magnífica... los mejores calificativos al fin para esta sublime interpretación. Infinitas gracias por compartirla. ¡FELICITACIONES!🌝⚘
What an amazing transcription. Pure beauty.
Superb violin playing! Please upload the entire violin repertoire, when you have a chance... Subscribed.
Дуже гарно. Дякую! Зворушливий концерт.
I love how dark and hauntingly beautiful this song is no matter the instrument it sounds like an introduction for a vampire on an organ and like a intro for a killer or a boss fight on a violin
Extraordinary interpretation. Very good technique. Bach would have liked it very much. Thanks a lot. You are number one.
Superiority...
Excellence.
Thank you....gentile expression.
Браво это душа болит как каждая струна на скрипке а смычек не выдержвает браво !!!!!!
Maestro BRAVO so beautiful 🥲 tears to my eyes ❤️ 🫵 🙏 🎻 !!!!!
Your intonation is soooooo good.
OmG ! That’s amazing !! Wow! You can hear different voices as if they were different instruments. Those right hand techniques blow my mind. ❤️
This piece was probably initially written for the violin and then adapted to the organ so that explains why it fits perfectly with the violin ! Lovely interpretation 😍
idk i think the piano sounds great due to it allowing more notes WITHOUT the heavy overlay that organs give.
as long as the piece has a call and response feel i love most interpretations. but sadly its frequently butched (to my ears) when the musicians just run through the notes.
its a piece that has an acquired taste due to so many movements that overlap. (i am by no means a musical elitist but the call and response sounds so awesome that ANY OTHER Iteration just is horrendous, even worse so when the organ has no natural fall off (like the paino does) so that the notes just sound raucous. again that me speaking ill of both the composer and the player.. such a taboo i know. but thats my take.
so yeah i love/ hate this piece depending on who and how its played. and she truly did this piece justice. trust me cuz i can play this song 7 times in a row just to compare and contrast different instuments and arrangements (solo, duo, small group full symphony, piano, violin, harp, horn quartet, and so on) at this rate I will listen to this piece just to compare its nuance. (all 8-ish minutes for 4-5 iterations, not including repeats, lol) again im not a music professional just a music lover.
Quelle matrîse de l'instrument !
J''écoute votre performance quotidiennement et je ne m'en lasse jamais
Vous êtes un modèle de son pour moi !
Merci 1000 fois !
mi è piaciuta questa esibizione. L'artista ha reso tutto così facile, chiaro e meraviglioso, come si addice a Bach. Rimasi incantato, tanta sensibilità, tecnica così perfetta, come se l'avesse suonata Dio in persona😘
Divine❤️ lovely❤️ beautiful❤️ amazing❤️ uh…. I need more words to describe this…
So beautiful. Rich, round tones. Flawless. I want to here more of your playing!
Very fine transcription and great playing. I would really love to collaborate on a Video.
Awesome bowing. So enjoyable watching too. Wow!
You can feel the emotions weaving around, truly a magnificent performance!
Very nice Rendition. Very nice playing. Wish we could have the score
Thank you for blessing my day with this
Great versión! wonderful performance 👏 👏!
Extraordinaire ❤ beaucoup d'admiration 😊😊
Really fine performance!
Magnificent rendition! 👏👏👏
Such a joy listening to this - rich and ‘honeyed’ sound, perfect balance, exquisite taste and (as so many others have commented) zero ego!
Ogni volta che ti ascolto è sempre più bello ed emozionante. Veramente molto brava!!!!
I love the rich sound and the pacing. Wonderful performance!
Wow, that was amazing! Beautiful tone, wonderful technique, and the violin sounds great too! 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏❤❤
Je n'ai pas de mot pour une telle interprétation... Bach renaît de ses cendres à travers ces notes ... merci Madame, quelle émotion m'avez vous transmis !!
bach ne peut pas renaitre de ces cendres ! car il et toujours vivant !
Vraiment remarquable cette transcription pour une violoniste absolument étonnante 🎉❤
Very beautiful and so deep. I enjoyed so much. Performance is awesome.... Thanks for share. Please more videos... From Iran...
Adore violin music. ❤
The best music never dies...
This goes straight to the top of my favorite violin performances. I discovered this video about 2 weeks ago and must have listened to it at least 30 times so far. Bravo, Maestra!
By the way, I have a minor shoulder injury this week and can’t play, so today I asked my violin teacher to spend my weekly lesson by watching your video twice and analyze everything and anything I can learn from your amazing technique. So thank you also for making such an excellent pedagogical video that shows the details your playing so well for fellow violin students.
Wow! Very impressive how you could achieve the effect of multiple voices with the violin! Beautiful!
Wow
So Beautiful 😍
Thank you for sharing 🎉
❤❤❤ QUALCOSA DI STUPENDO,, musica da sogno, esecuzione SUBLIME ❤❤
Meravigliosa Marie-astrid,bellissima interpretazione,note pulite,Grazie di avercela suonata,io sono al quinto anno di violino e un giorno piacerebbe eseguirla👏🌹🌠
God bless the performer. Such a beautiful presentation.Great is the composer of this master piece J.S. Bach.
Beautiful rendition, Im amazed at her incredible bow technique!
Well done Marie! Amazing interpretation...c'est la perfection!
I've listened to this so many times and I'm still awed by your performance. ❤❤❤ When are you going to give us some more solo Bach???
Wow , impeccable finesse and mature , sweet mellow tone . Eddie Van Halen would be proud of what he called the “ brown sound “ .
A refreshing sound as compared to other contemporary’s of our time in the likes of Hilary Hahn or Anne -Sophie Mutter .
Forgive my excitement , but may I ask the weight of your bow ? It’s moves so lightly yet sounds much like a viola bow .
Thank you for sharing. This is impressive 😊
amazing feeling and interpretation, perfect performance, great maestro.
Himmlische Violin ! echte Talent , Frauen Kreativität .
Merci -💘💥💫
Wow, So beautiful ..
A master at work.
Bravo une magnifique exécution , c'est beau on se perd, on suit, on vacille. Merci !
WOW! How very beautiful
Beautiful...... Just beautiful.....
parabens srta muito bacana es ex expetacular diferenciadamente bom
Impresionantemente hermosa versión! Fraseo y clima musical perfectos! Infinitas gracias por tanto arte!!!👏👏👏👏👏👏
perfect in all possible ways i could think about
Bravissima. Mi hai toccato il cuore. Un collega che ti stima molto... Grazie.....
Truly amazing clean beautiful full of soul. Bach would turn in his grave for joy I sense. The dynamic is super balanced bringing out these amazing delicious pghraseologies that are the face of the genius of JSB
Interprétation de toute beauté ! ! ! Bravo à Marie-Astrid ❤ ❤ ❤
Très belle interprétation, tout à la fois subtile et animale avec une parfaite maîtrise technique notamment la main droite .
Je suis prêt à traverser la France pour aller vous écouter !
This is perfection.
Fantastic performance for J. S. Bach’s master piece. Wonderful!
Marie-Astrid what a gift and mastery to give us this rendition. Strenght and Beauty cultivated with time and passion. Bach is honored. Thanks.
Happy new year.
By far the best violin version in my opinion!
Глубокое чувство стиля , безукоризненный вкус , беспроблемная техника , филигранная интонация , привлекательная манера исполнения , лишенная признаков " нахрапа " , характерного для "лауреатов " ! Браво !
Только не "беспроблемная" техника, а безупречная. Исполнение действительно очень не плохое, но Коган в своё время играл это "круче". Девочка ещё молодая, весь потенциал в ней откроется с возростом, при наличии усердия.
@@АлександрИванов-з5м2л "девочке" уже 25 лет стукнуло (это Мари-Астрид Юло, она родилась в Париже в 1997 г). Для скрипачки в профессиональном плане это уже, можно сказать, зрелый возраст.
Que som magnífico 😢❤
WOW!!! Amazing! Of course I love the organ performances, but this performance is out of this world. The video perspective is fantastic too. I love watching her transitions back and forth on the runs up and down the scales in this classic piece… thank you for sharing this amazing performance.
Waauuu... Not a moment too soon, I needed this - right now. Thank you!
Sometimes you just wonder how things are possible. Gorgeous tone to the violin and so cleanly played.
So beautiful
Unbelievable. Been playing it on the organ all my life, but this exceptional performance convinces me that the solo violin was the original medium of BWV 565. Compared to the great preludes and fugues of Bach's Leipzig years, 565 isn't much of an organ fugue, but as a violin fugue, it's as good as they get. This is a stunning display of total command of the violin to bring us something we have never really heard before, a new and powerful insight on a beloved and important work that still holds mysteries from us. Brava (and bravo to the arranger!)!!!