All agree the Sahrawi people are the indigenous population of the region. Why not holding a referendum among the Sahrawis and let them determine the status of their land?
Aaah okk... So a group who call them self arab are indigenous to. Part of the world where the Amazigh (Moroccans) are the indigenous people.... How stupid are you
This solution is impossible because people now who lives in refugees camp in Tindouf algeria are from differents countries not only sahraouis live there
We cannot give a country to a bunch of historic nomads whose numbers won't even fill up a small football stadium ...and if you claim the the saharawi nomads are indeed a nation and need to heve a country why then stop only at those in southern Morocco , why the saharawis in southern algeria lybia tunisia egypt etc....do not have also the right to self determination and the right to independent countries...
@@jarveyjaguar4395 a saharawi is an inhabitant of the Sahara which streches from southern Morocco to southern Egypt...the saharawis in southern algeria (Azawad and Touareg) also demand the right of self determination and the right to use their oil and gas riches which the state of algeria was stealing and is still stealing from their soil since 1962
@@jarveyjaguar4395 stop your nonsense , Algeria is an artificial state that was created by decree by colonial France in 1963 , it never existed all the southern part is Azawad and Touareg territory it was never part of the north or unified to it by any means ...also the north is partly Kabyle territory and other pieces of land that France stripped from Morocco and Tunisia and added to its French Algeria ...the only Algeria that the Ottomans handed to France in 1830s was Algiers and its surrounding , that's the only historic Algeria ....oil and gas were discovered by France on Azawad and Touareg territories and then annexed to French Algeria cause back then France considered Algeria a DOM TOM , aka a French Departement d'outre Mer and was never planning to give it up so it kept adding pieces of territories to it ....
educate urself before commenting on nonsense look at a moroccan map before colonization by france and spain , and yes if u want free sahara then free catalonia bavaria and lets divide ur own country after that
@@PaisGEO just write morocco old map u are clueless the sahara was moroccan during the reign of moroccan sultain moulay ismail ben chérif ..lol SALty algerian son of the ottomans and france 😂😂
@@Wizzy678 You are the real clueless, the Almoravides are Mauritanian, also don't talk to me without having a father bousbiri that in your country you sell your women for a few tacos
There has never been a country or a nation called western Sahara, The whole conflict is between Algeria which was backed by the east during the cold war time, and Morocco which is backed by the west, all that following the conflict of the two nations over the borders when France left the area. France grabbed lands from Morocco and Tunsia and giving it to Algeria which was its last colonial land which they thought they will stay in it forever after 130 years of occupying it.
Yes, both Spain and France gradually chipped away territories of Morocco in the 19th century and eventually combined their forces to finish off the rest of Moroccan territories in the 20th century. There were also annexations made indeed by the French and the Spanish since they thought those Moroccan territories would be theirs forever. Algeria is not willing to give those territories back. At least 1/6 of Algeria was Moroccan territory, but those 1/6 were indeed also added by the french to Algeria.
Yes and you speak for all Sahrawi? It baffles me how little peoples perspectives allow them to see. Also how little people care to free native peoples oppressed by Colonizers. FREE WESTERN SAHARA AND FREE THE UIGHURS
Do u live in the Saharwi Arab Democratic republic or the Moroccan part? Also the conflict is more of a debate between two sides than fighting from what I’ve heard
I feel great watching this video from the Moroccan Sahara and the phosphate train passes in front of me while I eat the fish of our beautiful desert 🤩🇲🇦🤩🇲🇦🤩🇲🇦🤩🇲🇦
@@jarveyjaguar4395 I'm an Idrissi, and my ancestor Moulay Idris rests in Fez. We're a kingdom since 789, 2nd oldest regime after the Japanese empire which is still relevant. Your colonizer has always said that you were never a nation. DeGaulle, Macron... Please don't compare our history with yours
There is no nation called western sahara, Morocco have a western Sahara and Egypt have also a Western Sahara which translates literally to western desert. The polisario militias and institutions are based in Algerian soil.
Much of the SADR controlled territory is desert with no water access or farmable land or an effective power grid. Would you want a base of operations in a place with no water access or farmable land?
🇪🇭🇪🇭 ❤ i would like to make it clear that all this Moroccans talking here don't talk for saharawi people both in refugee camp or in occupied territory , and as a sahrawi person i assure you'll that sahrawi people are suffering for freedom and will get it
the only question to ask: was the Sahara a terra nullius at the time of the arrival of the Spanish colonists? No, the inhabitants had always pledged allegiance to the Moroccan sultans. End of the discussion.
What are you talking about? Lol. Morocco once "pledged allegiance" to France so by that logic the French occupation of Morocco can return? All these arguments completely fall apart when looking at how no International legal body recognizes the Moroccan occupation and Morocco has refused to hold a referendum for the indigenous population to decide.
@@SuperMovieLvr933 what a bunch of lies, morocco refuses to hold a referendum ? There"s literally thousands and thousands of refugees from countries like mauritania / Niger / mali that have immigrated to algeria and were put by the algerian government into the Tindouf camps to artifficialy pump up the numbers of refugees, how do you know who's a real sahraoui or not ? plus algeria literally refuses to let the UN do it's work to estimate the real number of sahraoui people. And there's also sahraoui people living in the morrocan controled side of the sahara, what do we do with them ? we don't count them cause that doesn't match your political agenda ? and finally yes, the argument of the inhabitants pledgind there allegiances to the moroccan sultans is historically true, but I guess the west decided that we don't care according to the international rules that they invented lol
@@SuperMovieLvr933 oh really, Morocco pledged allegiance to France? You don't know nothing about the history of my country so please stay away from this. There's never been a census of the Tindouf refugee camps since 1974, and the algerians know why. And you know what? The moroccan flag is floating in our southern regions, come get it if you want, but you better be well prepared kid... There's never been a country called RASD and there'll never be.
@@SuperMovieLvr933 Do you even know why Morocco became a french protectorate? Answer this and I'll tell you if you can have an opinion about the history of my country.
@@hififreak8771 Seems like you have much contempt for democracy and indigenous liberation. Good thing you have no affect on any of this. Hopefully the Sahrawi people can be free from Morocco's illegal belligerent occupation.
If you can't even determine who wants what on a piece of land, isn't that already a sign in itself? Like seriously, claiming the Western Sahara, which if you look at it is a clear continuation of Moroccan territory geographically speaking, if it takes so much effort to deny Morocco's claim on that land and can't even be backed up by popular demand and requires a neighbor country's manipulations then it seems like we're trying too hard to prove this is not Moroccan territory instead of proving this is part of the Republic of Western Sahara. Compare this with Israel and Palestine. There's a clear and powerful demand for the Palestinian state. Such a contrast.
I'm confused. At the beginning, Spain left that area and Western Sahara was devided between Morocco and Mauritania. Then Mauritania decided to leave Western Sahara as it is not worth the hassle.Why did Morocco claim the other half?
yasmine hasnaoui is a mouthpiece for the Moroccan government who works as an academic. This is another example of the lack of autonomy of Moroccan universities that are controlled by a regime - something found in all Arab countries
@@alvaro701 Incorrect mate. People who live there (Moroccan western sahara) want to be part of Moroccan kingdom, hence the country's autonomy proposal. PoIisario on the other hand are keeping abducted people under miserable conditions in tindouf and refuse talks with Morocco. UN has reduced its aid to poIisario this week after finding out poIisario is selling cooking oil aid to Mauritania.
@@knockknockrepoman They have been fighting Morroco for decades mate. If they are so sure about it, make a referendum, win it, and question settled for ever.
Algeria using oil supply as blackmail, same tactic Russia has been using on European countries. Algeria says western Sahara is not its affair. Yet there they go making irrational decisions.
@@aissa9428 Spain is the former colon of Moroccan Sahara, hence its implication. Algerian military regime should have no implication whatsoever as it was admitted by Algerian president.
@@knockknockrepoman government of morroco gave bigger Concessions to Spain in exchange for this recognition, and I think this is not in the interest of the Moroccan people, but only in the interest of Spain،And the problem concerns Algeria as well because there are a lot of people who have sought asylum in Algeria from Western Sahara
Common sense easy solution = Non biased 3rd party hold a secure vote for the people of the region to decide if they want to be under Morocco or be entirely their own nation.
too late to do that, should've done that back then, now all people are fed 50uyears + years of propaganda and they won"t be able to give their own opinion.
@@mounir7910 yeah morroco is a colonizer just like any other european nation that's it, they want to retain its colonies just like the united states, spain, UK and france.
thats a great idea the thing is 99% of the people will vote in favor of morocco, the polisario is a small terrorist group living in the eastern sahara in algeria
It won't work because Morocco invaded and massacred a large number of the native people, mostly men resisting the annexation. The women and children fled to refugee camps in Algeria. Then Morocco brought in tons ofi mmigrants from the North attempting population replacement. They even banned the native Sahrawi Hasaniya Arabic dialect. Hundreds of thousands of Sahrawis have been in exile for 40 years. So the vote would most likely be biased. Plus Morocco's claim is based on pre European colonial borders of the Moroccan empire. So they don't care what the people think, its their land because they conquered it twice, historically and at present.
well, Algeria never existed till france has Put it there at 1963 but yeah even when the talk about the files of the UN, the File was Posed by Morocco, Morocco is ready to solve this thing peacefully or with War, We got both history and power .back us UP.
@@elhadi9886 Hello El Hadi, the problem with the algerians is their short access to the archives ? who said that morocco didnt try ? Morocco's History is not like none of the other African countries he had Three colonizers bcz of its geographical place and its Religion annexe ( Islam - Spian is christian ) Morocco had its land Splitted between Powers, it didnt take its full independence, bcz as u know they wanted to split morocco from the world, spain took the North and south france took the middle and the east, btw there were some Cities, that u better go check they were annexed to Western Sahara , and they took their independence even after the Green March 1975, We talking abt Sidi Ifni, and other small cities, SO, if u, by any Chance was Brought by France, to serve French interests in Africa by giving them Gaz For cheap, stay away From Us, we' are a nation, we were , and we staying, what we gave and giving to africa is mostly New to you.
Boumediene supported the claim of Morroco at first but then, he adopted a new strategy and invented a so called sahraoui cause. why he didn't include algerian sahraoui just show how stupid this claim is
@@mounir7910 OMG please shut up, if u'r not a moroccan then, dont u ever talk abt Boumedian Supporting morocco, how come a president who ordered the expulsion of 350,000 Moroccan nationals from Algeria on. 18 December 1975, the first day of Eid al-Adha,, how d u think he would support ? plus, back then, there was no algerian sahraouis France never Mentioned them in any of their archives and these sahraouis they were not included in the Autodetermination ( what the algerian calls idependence ... ) "" Check Document5 in the French Archive ""
This conflict is a result of french and spanish colonization. Moroccan territory was split like a cake among colonizers, they did whatever they wanted, and eventually left Morocco in pieces and fighting for whatever it could have back of its territories. It is not a question of colonaziation as the polizario propaganda suggest, it is a question of a Morocco that's trying to protect its territorial unity and its right to be liberated from the shadows of colonization that left not only Morocco but all African nations stuck in ruins of the past. All these conflicts only benefit global powers in keeping an upper hand on Africa and using its resources, by making it unstable and unable to be independent.
i Spain is carrying a politcal and historical shame on its shoulder until the people of Western Sahara get their rights they were strugling for decades.
So you want a "country" as big as 1/2 France ruled by maybe 40K people (Polisario), of majority land is sand? .. This is just a cocktail for a failed state, full of internal conflicts and wars (it is happening already between the clans in Tindouf), terrorisme. I mean just another South Sudan scenario. ..... And not to forget Algeria who will claim their return of investment in years of political, financial and military support?Algeria will be overruling the polisario to benefit access to Atlantic. Do you think Algeria is spending billion of dollars per year just for the sake of ideal idea's. Wake up .. the world has changed - no country (certainly US, EU, ...) will vote for another new failed states in such strategic and hot place in Africa. So keep dreaming!
gfu, you benefited from the drawing of the borders made by France when it colonized you and this drawing included the sahrawis of the eastern sahara and of kabylia which wishes its independence. But this contradiction does not bother you. The Sahara is and will remain Moroccan and it is not Algerians like you who will change anything
Don't lie to me. Before the Spanish occupation, the Sahara was not part of Morocco. When the Spaniards arrived in the Sahara in 1884, they spoke to the Saharan ruler and the Sultan of Mauritania. That is why, when Morocco and Mauritania, with the assistance of the United Nations in 1975, brought the Sahara case before the Hague court, it ruled that Western Sahara, because of its lack of sovereignty ties, with Morocco and Mauritania, could be subject to resolution 1514, which grants the Saharan people the right of self-determination that awaits them so long.
I have 2 questions : who was the king or president of the "western sahara republic" at that time ? and whats the difference between a sahraoui in morroco and another one in algeria or tunisia ? So if.sahraoui want a republic it have to be a a repubulic that includes all south territories of Morroco, algeria, tunisia and lybia
@@walid3397 The former Western Sahara Spanish Sahara, which is a non-autonomous territory in the process of decolinization, has very well delimited territories. A Sahrawi in other countries is the same as a French or Moroccan in others. Morocco only has to comply with the self-determination referendum agreed with the Sahrawis in 1991, under the auspices of the United Nations.
@@patxiaznar9656 you didnt answer my questions..... Sahara were morrocan before spanich colonzation, its still Morrocan in the present and it will stay Morrocan until the end of the days 😉
@@walid3397 I recommend you study history before you talk nonsense. Are you asking me about a king in Western Sahara? I really don't believe it, anyone who knows a little bit about history knows that the Sahrawi population was organized into tribes, so asking about a king doesn't make sense. If you know, I'll tell you again, when the Spaniards arrived in the Sahara, they talked to the Sultan of Adrar el-Tmar and the most respected Sahrawi leader in the area. Hence the Judgment of La Hague ruled that it was possible to implement United Nations Resolution 1514, which enables the right of self-determination of nations.
Vive la3das ou lahlib, heheh .... Ila Algeria rjal .. 3lach ma diw slah (les armes) li Palestine bhal li polisario .. wallah hata thayadkoum Israel in kharita ... Vive Maroc.
morocco is buying western support with western sahara resources (phosphate with half the price for the US and EU) + giving israel the wright to explor for oil and gas there i dont know much about international relationships but buying a land thats yours (or at least that what morocco thinks) seems realy weak and shamful morocco is already going down economically with debts almost 50% of its GDP , i think they will lose sovereignty trying to steal sahrawis land
algerian propaganda, phosphate comes from khouribga and ben guerir regions in central morocco, not from moroccan sahara. moroccan sahara has no oil or gas, moroccan sahara doesn't have natural resources except fish. morocco is not losing sovereignty anywhere except imagination of algerian junta, go back to sleep and dream about destroying morocco !!
"giving israel israel is bad" you are soo worst than western colonists. thank you for showing us the levels of ur obsession and delusions..it started funny kinda, but got wayy out of hand on your end of course..100,000 moroccans from poor amazigh villages no longer breathing. moroccans need to wake up.
وله الحق المغرب في ثرابه ابان عن جد وتحية للمغاربة الاشراف الاسود من طنجة إلى الكويرة وسبتة ومليلية والجزر الجعفرية والصحراء الشرقية 🦁🦁🦁🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🦁🦁🦁🦁🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦💪💪💪💪💪
well France is 125% gdp external debt, the us is over 90% its almost economic recession. second, the conflict is between Algeria and Morocco, third western Sahara belongs to Morocco, historically and actually under Moroccan control. You can't buy support, you can have good diplomacy. seriously polisario is a lost cause, only failed states support it.. so Algeria and its gang is only waisting time and money. If you are a real Saharan, Morocco will welcome you with open arms. you can work, live, and be happy. if you are algerian, you should better take care of your country.
It’s a southern region of Morocco, plus all the consulates opening there and even Spain accepting the Kings project on a self governing region under Moroccan control so it’s Moroccan end of the storu
@@gothicgolem2947because it goes against the interest of a certain neighboring country’s regime, which is fueling hate beyond words to the people in the region who associate with Morocco.
imagine bowing down to a king and kissing his hand while he spends your “country’s” money in gay clubs in Belgium 😔 being Moroccan must be so humiliating
The bias line of question by the journalist against Western Sahara representative to the UN is clear. VIVA POLISARIO and Long Live. Victory is certain.
The only solution is to let western Sahara people decide via a free referundum, as decided by united nations in the early sixties. Morroco can say whatever they want, it's not up to them, the reality says that Algerians and Saharouis are against morroco occupation, but one silent player who's also against the morrocan occupation, but he is quiet, but at the same time he accepts western Sahara as an independent country, I am talking about Mauritania. The funny thing, morroco sleeps for a century and whenever Algerians, muritanias or Saharouis free their lands from French and Spanish occupation, morroco claims that's it's his land!!!!!!! These three countries knows very well the history of occidental Sahara and they will never let morroco impose his occupation agenda, trust me never ever. We have the same problem which gulf countries were having with Saddam regim. Morrocans has to respect their neighbors borders or it will end up with a big war in the region, because we won't let them impose such unfairness. This is the history of western Sahara, and you can judge!! لماذا الصحراء ليست مروكية: * دخل الإحتلال الإسباني الصحراء سنة 1884 و كانت مملكة فاس و مراكش مستقلة، و لكنها لم تحرك ساكنا و لم ترسل جيشا ليوقف الغازي الإسباني. * ظل الإحتلال الإسباني جاثما على صدور الصحراويين طيلة قرن من الزمان، و لم نسمع بثورات أو حروب قادها سلاطين فاس و مراكش المتعاقبين لتحرير الصحراء الغربية من المحتل الإسباني. * كانت بعض القبائل الصحراوية الحدودية تقود عمليات ضد المحتل الإسباني و عندما إتصل الإسبان بسلطان فاس و مراكش، أكد لهم في إتفاقية وادي نون بأن الأراضي الواقعة تحت وادي نون ليست تابعة له. * إندلع الكفاح الصحراوي ضد المحتل الإسباني سنة 1973، بدعم من ليبيا و الجزائر، فيما بقي ملك المروك متفرجا يترقب ما ستؤول إليه الأمور و رفض دعم الصحراويين في كفاحهم. * تحت ضغط المقاومة الصحراوية إنسحبت إسبانيا من الصحراء سنة 1975، فتفاجأ الصحراويون بملك المروك يقتسم أرضهم مع ولد دادة، متناسيا حينها ما يسميه اليوم وحدته الخرافية!!! * ركز الصحراويون ضرباتهم أكثر على جيش ولد دادة، إلى أن قبلت موريتانيا بالإنسحاب من وادي الذهب سنة 1979، و لكن تفاجأ الصحراويون بملك المروك يسرقها منهم ثانية كما فعل مع الساقية الحمراء سنة 1979!!! العجيب في الأمر نسي وحدته الخرافية سنة 1975 و تذكرها فجأة سنة 1979!!! قمة الظلم و الإعتداء، كلما حرر الصحراويون أرضهم سرقها ملك المروك منهم!!!
This is all drama. It's all a question of keeping the balance established by third parties countres (very wealthy). The aim of this "balance" is to make sure that Africa stays poor.
that’s true but we need to take half of Algeria because it belongs to Morocco but we don’t need melilla and septa because it’s small we need half of Algeria the land that we took during the sand war 🇲🇦🤜🏻🇩🇿🇪🇭💩💩
@@mehdibb4186 we Moroccan hate Algeria. Algeria never had a history and they are weak just like the sand war they lost to Morocco and soon when the time is right we will take our stolen land from Algeria and if Algeria doesn’t want to give it back to us it’s ok we can take it by force Tough guy
No Hassania, the war with morocco will lead to something…horrible…but could be necessary to cleanup and free the oppressed and frustrated people…of course The Algerian will need also to focus on their issue, but as you failed to show with your understanding of politics, running a state is never only internal…but it’s ok, you’ve earned your blessing from your “god”.
Algeria didn't exist in the précolonial era, and france made it the largest territory identified as a single country in africa, polisario should grab their share from "algerian" sahara !
@@akdjksolnng7811 yes we are and we are being kept down by Spainyard who just 9 gen ago killed Amazigh wiped them out on Canary Islands 🇮🇨 & Algeria which has took our land and now trying to stall by draining our recourses time and 100k lives by going after WS.
@@donkeeefarms3795 you wear your name well... Much more is at stake than your simplistic vision. Morocco cannot accept having a vassal state of Algeria in the south. This would enclave it and cut off its access to the African market with which it does a lot of business. Morocco is playing its survival in this story.
this conflict has already been resolved. There are only a few mercenaries left in the pay of Algiers who are stupidly stubborn. These fools don't even realize that they are just the puppets of Algiers with views of the Moroccan Sahara
@@Ali-id4vu and what the minurso did right now in morroco ? and if western Sahara is morrocan why divided it with a wall and mines from the north to the south ! and
It's moroccan land from an historical perspective. All evidence is stored in historical documents stored also in France. Algeria is created by France in 1963 and exist from Moroccan ,Tunisian ,lybian land. Mauritania,Mali were also non existing countries before the French colony.
@@alfredomafiosoMorocco was a protectorate. It is normal that when the occupiers leave the land returns to the ruler of that nation. It's not la la land It's common sense and international law. The boundaries in Africa are not natural but drawn by the european colonisers in the sykes picot agreement.
Morocco is a creation of France ( Marechal Lyautey ) , which transformed Marrakech and Fes sultanat by a country which named Morocco . France is the the Father of mOROCCO
@@alfredomafioso bro I think you have mental problems Morocco was never part of France. Morocco was the moorish empire the only reason why Algeria existed because they come form France and Polisario Western Sahara come from Algeria. Spain and France team up together to defeat Morocco in ww2 because Morocco took hole territory of Spain during the year of empire Spain and Portugal wanted to take Morocco but they fail then in ww2 Spain told France let’s team up and take Morocco Spain took Morocco Western Sahara and France took Morocco and made them France protectorate
Where is the algerian guest 🤔 I think it's an obvious thing to have at least someone algerian Other things Algeria made it clear that they don't have any problems with the European union nor with the Spanish people it's only because of the actual gouvernement and their statement about western Sahara 🇪🇭
If Algeria supoort sefl determination they have to recognize Kabylia republic, ten millions of Kabyles people want their own country in the north east of algeria
@@joebidet2050 western Sahara is moroccan with or without the recognition of USA or other countries. The recognition of usa is just a plus, actually the sahara is controlled by morocco and there lives my brothers and it's ressources are exploited by us. Legally we don't care what UN says but we still will play ur game. About isreale we did some pretty good agreement.. like buying the drones from them.. the same we use to KILL those terroristes who tries to touch the sand of my sahara ;) There is no pity
Misogyny from little boy Algerians.. something I experience 24/7 as they invade Moroccan woman’s Spaces, even girl-only, to call us prostitutes (when it’s illegal in our country but legal in theirs..) a very troubled population.
Actually the blackmail over Spain came from Morocco by spying over the Spanish MP ( Pegasus scandal) and by lifting control over the border at Ceuta and Melilla which led to a flow of illegal migrant into Spanish Territory. Western Sahara territory is not an Algerian affairs simply because there is no territory claims over it. The two concerned by this territory dispute is Morocco and Polisario. Algeria stand with the choice of the Sahrawi peoples whether they wants independence or being part of Morocco.
not algrian affair?jajajaja sad with spain for recognizing sahar moroccan plan..all the time lying...Algeria send heroin to europe and migrant to europe too, flights from algeria last weeknd with 2000 kilos . moroco is NATO 25 foreign member and eeuu , uuss alied, algria NOO
so according to you: Algeria is spending billions of $$ per year, giving heavy political support and military.. even damaging own economical benefits (like now against Spain) etc, .. just for the sake of supporting 40K ppl to determine their "independence"? Do you really believe this bul**. As Boumedian said "I am going to create a stone in shoes of Moroccan for ever" - and that is Polisario. And you are telling Algeria is not involved and just providing some moral support? and for nothing - access to Atlantic? Keeping Morocco busy? cut-off Morocco from rest/ west Africa?
@@gregorytheblackkitten9422 Say wherever bullshit, but its just the truth. Morroco spied Pedro Sanchez, Macron, some ministers and many european Journalist. Also, they blackmail us using inmigrants and, of course, keep an ilegal occupation of Western Sahara. They can do that thanks to their daddies, which are the US, France, Gulf countries and now Israel, that let them do wherever they want.
This conflict was created by Algeria.Its the Moroccan flag which is waving there, the currency is the Moroccan Dirham, the citizen living there get the Moroccan passport and citizenship.For our ennemies claiming that its not Morocco can you give us the countries where we can find the ambassies of this so-called country? What is the name of the ruler there ? Can you show us the pic of an ID or of a passport of this country ?
What about IJC decreed. "despite these "certain" links, there was no Moroccan sovereignty over Western Sahara, but only a certain "authority" or "influence" over "some" Sahrawi nomads (ICJ, 1975, paragraph 128) and such links did not deserve consideration"
in 2023, there is no room for war and hatred, the world people become intelligent, work together, live together, live and let live, educate themselves on the Internet for free, make themselves intelligent, polite and friendly. take the example of the EU.
The Moroccan Sahara is a disputed territory located in the Western Sahara region of North Africa. It has been the subject of a long-standing conflict between Morocco and the Polisario Front, which seeks independence for the territory. Morocco claims sovereignty over the region and has established a government presence there, while the Polisario Front maintains control over some parts of the territory. The conflict has been ongoing since the 1970s and has involved military clashes, political negotiations, and international mediation efforts. Currently, the United Nations maintains a peacekeeping mission in the region known as MINURSO, which is tasked with monitoring a ceasefire that was agreed to in 1991. There have been some recent diplomatic efforts to resolve the conflict, but it remains unresolved.
In this 'indulgent' toxic 'conflict', No else Moroccan or Algerian people side would get benefited on this kind of things, but i see... it would benefits some else country 'military industrial complex' and would cheered up some 'Europe identitarianist' extremists movement there. Don't fall into a same pit like those Libya and Levantine countries lads my advice from Indonesia🇮🇩
Before france invade morocco there is no such thing called algeria, france took a big part of morocco and and tunisia and libya and kabayle to create algeria.
just to make it clear a lot of ppl think saharwis are native to western sahara thats not true at all saharawis are banu hassan tribes an arabian tribe that came from hijaz in saudi arabia in 17 century they drived the amazigh natives by a series of genocides to northern parts of north africa the natives of western sahara are the amazigh tekna tribes and sous amazighs who are moroccans and those ppl will never allow thier land to be taken from them again
nonsense there is no genocide of amazigh by Arabs in fact the majority of Moroccans are of amazigh decents they are just arabized meaning they adopted the culture and the arab language
@@YA-kr4fr you need to study more about north africa and saharawi tribes sahrawis are mostly from rguibat tribe wich is part banu hassan arabs who invaded maghreb sahara in the 17 century
It doesn't matter if there's never been a country called Western Sahara. People have a right to self-determination, countries don't exist to serve a ruling fmaily, elite, or ethnic majority. If Western Saharans want to form a country why wouldn't they?
I have only recently begun to learn about this conflict, añd wonder what the pepple living in Western Sahara wañt and have they been involved in the discussions aɓout possible solutions? Why can Western Sahara not ɓecome an independent democrstoic state responsible for it's own destiny with ever yone living invthe state having equal rights....is this anothervUN failure?
Morocco will never understand the Algerian position to stand by the Sahrawi people simply because Morocco never had a revolution to free its people from foreign occupation over the centuries. This lady falsely claiming that Algeria is "against the autonomy of the Western Sahara"!? That's not true. The position of Algeria is give full freedom for the Sahrawi people by the referendum to choose if they want to be part of Morocco or not. The referendum will include ONLY the Sahrawi people, but not Moroccan occupiers who moved and settled in WS. Let them choose by themselves for their future. Morocco can't even claim their own territories of Ceuta and Mellila, because they scared of Spain, but they go with the "weak" to claim all Western Sahara! It's not going to work...
So you think that Algeria will never ask anything in return for its a political, financial and military support of Polisario for 50 years (do the math how much billions $ it is)? dream on ya waldi! About what you said about Ceuta and Mellilia: those cities will return thru a peaceful process like Hong Kong etc. Morocco and Spain are civilised countries to solve issue by political talks .. And you know: if Algeria didn't keep Morocco busy with the sahara conflict for 50 years , and even in stead supported Morocco with C & M (as you said Algeria has high standard when in it comes to supporting liberation of occupied places) , then Morocco would have got C&M by now ... Morocco is not scared of Spain .. it is a matter of time and on going game of diplomacy! Only you - Algeria still think of time Che - taking arms and signing Cuban songs. The world has changed if you dind;t notice. Btw - isn't Algeria that supported Spain during a short conflict between Spain and Morocco about a small island Leila? traitors!!
@@jamdodo7500 The only traitors out there are the Moroccan Makhzen and its supporters. You're trying to "buy" other countries' supports with everything you can, including your dignity, if you have any left, just to put your friends and neighbors in the bad situation. Like I said, if Morocco wants Western Sahara, give the Sahrawi people the right to choose without any pressure. Let them decide by themselves for their future. Otherwise, it is just pure occupation and exploitation. Good day
@@ashraf_rpl4961 Clearly you don't care about democracy or the opinions of the indigenous Sahrawi people. Proving that the Moroccan occupation has always been about brute force and suppression. Moroccan occupation of Western Sahara is almost identical to Israeli occupation of Palestinian Territories and Russian occupation of Ukrainian lands. All of it is illegal under international law and completely immoral. Hopefully the Moroccan dictatorship collapses. Inshallah.
@asad africa You can't go to the Polisario controlled areas easily at all because they live behind a giant wall and are cut off from their native lands. Morocco invaded Wester Sahara just like Russia is invading Ukraine. The only difference though is that people don't seem to care about Western Sahara or the Sahrawis like they do Ukrainians.
Nothing like educating yourself about a situation you have absolutely no control over :).
😆
😂😂 Wlh
rather know than not know
I am from Indonesia support western sahara independence day
@MrGuest-qb5tiyou don’t own western Sahara , you have to understand that Marroquín
@@oscarpena7285we do own it.. Whatever you like it or not
@@MazinhoShenthen morocan intervention is an involuntary occupation
@@oscarpena7285tell us the name of one king or president of the "western sahara republic" before 1975 and we will leave this territory 😂
@@MazinhoShenthen you’re illegally occupying it the same way Zionists illegally occupy Palestine.
All agree the Sahrawi people are the indigenous population of the region.
Why not holding a referendum among the Sahrawis and let them determine the status of their land?
Aaah okk... So a group who call them self arab are indigenous to. Part of the world where the Amazigh (Moroccans) are the indigenous people....
How stupid are you
This solution is impossible because people now who lives in refugees camp in Tindouf algeria are from differents countries not only sahraouis live there
The U.S. tried in the early 2000s, morroco tried in the 90s
@@walid3397
Bai posiblea da eta errolda Suitzan gordeta dago
@@patxiaznar9656 permanecerá en Suiza hasta el fin del mundo.
tal vez incluso Cataluña, los Países Vascos y Córcega sigan adelante
We cannot give a country to a bunch of historic nomads whose numbers won't even fill up a small football stadium ...and if you claim the the saharawi nomads are indeed a nation and need to heve a country why then stop only at those in southern Morocco , why the saharawis in southern algeria lybia tunisia egypt etc....do not have also the right to self determination and the right to independent countries...
@@jarveyjaguar4395 a saharawi is an inhabitant of the Sahara which streches from southern Morocco to southern Egypt...the saharawis in southern algeria (Azawad and Touareg) also demand the right of self determination and the right to use their oil and gas riches which the state of algeria was stealing and is still stealing from their soil since 1962
@@jarveyjaguar4395 the sahara is not just in morocco dumbass
They don't want to bend , kiss hand and be slave like some other people
@@jarveyjaguar4395 stop your nonsense , Algeria is an artificial state that was created by decree by colonial France in 1963 , it never existed all the southern part is Azawad and Touareg territory it was never part of the north or unified to it by any means ...also the north is partly Kabyle territory and other pieces of land that France stripped from Morocco and Tunisia and added to its French Algeria ...the only Algeria that the Ottomans handed to France in 1830s was Algiers and its surrounding , that's the only historic Algeria ....oil and gas were discovered by France on Azawad and Touareg territories and then annexed to French Algeria cause back then France considered Algeria a DOM TOM , aka a French Departement d'outre Mer and was never planning to give it up so it kept adding pieces of territories to it ....
@@ez.sfdz.6342 that’s not what they say.. i have Touareg friends
Freeee Sahara 🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭
educate urself before commenting on nonsense look at a moroccan map before colonization by france and spain , and yes if u want free sahara then free catalonia bavaria and lets divide ur own country after that
@@Wizzy678The Sahara was never Moroccan, while the territories you mention were from their respective countries, study first before criticizing.
@@PaisGEO just write morocco old map u are clueless the sahara was moroccan during the reign of moroccan sultain moulay ismail ben chérif ..lol SALty algerian son of the ottomans and france 😂😂
@@PaisGEO lol algeria was literally france creation, 😅😅😅said de gaulles himself.
@@Wizzy678 You are the real clueless, the Almoravides are Mauritanian, also don't talk to me without having a father bousbiri that in your country you sell your women for a few tacos
There has never been a country or a nation called western Sahara, The whole conflict is between Algeria which was backed by the east during the cold war time, and Morocco which is backed by the west, all that following the conflict of the two nations over the borders when France left the area. France grabbed lands from Morocco and Tunsia and giving it to Algeria which was its last colonial land which they thought they will stay in it forever after 130 years of occupying it.
No😂😂
lol This is the biggest joke I've ever heard in my life 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@numidiachai2440 and the biggest one will be Morocco withdraw from its Sahara.
Africa is so mess up by Europe that they been fighting over small part of land
Yes, both Spain and France gradually chipped away territories of Morocco in the 19th century and eventually combined their forces to finish off the rest of Moroccan territories in the 20th century. There were also annexations made indeed by the French and the Spanish since they thought those Moroccan territories would be theirs forever. Algeria is not willing to give those territories back. At least 1/6 of Algeria was Moroccan territory, but those 1/6 were indeed also added by the french to Algeria.
I live in Western Sahara region and there's actually no conflict here. Moroccan flags are hoisted above buildings and people here are living in peace.
Yes and you speak for all Sahrawi? It baffles me how little peoples perspectives allow them to see. Also how little people care to free native peoples oppressed by Colonizers. FREE WESTERN SAHARA AND FREE THE UIGHURS
I love Morocco 🇲🇦
@@ibrahimab6896 well, he actually fuxking lives there and says it's peaceful what are u on lmao
@@ibrahimab6896 Morocco has always contained western shapes that
Do u live in the Saharwi Arab Democratic republic or the Moroccan part? Also the conflict is more of a debate between two sides than fighting from what I’ve heard
I feel great watching this video from the Moroccan Sahara and the phosphate train passes in front of me while I eat the fish of our beautiful desert 🤩🇲🇦🤩🇲🇦🤩🇲🇦🤩🇲🇦
It was the hungry Moroccans like you who made the Sahara Moroccan
بصحتك السمك👍
I love Morocco 🇲🇦
u mean ur king dragged u there like dogs in 1975
Western Sahara
Algeria is just being childish I've never seen a childish nation ever 🤣
Le Maroc et juste une pute d’Israël 🇲🇦🐕
it's not even a nation 🤣 it first existed by France, at 1962
@@hamzabmz8585 wish that France stayed there at least we won't have crazy senile acting like a 1 year old
@@hamzabmz8585 moorish go back to your poor prostitution country
@@jarveyjaguar4395 I'm an Idrissi, and my ancestor Moulay Idris rests in Fez. We're a kingdom since 789, 2nd oldest regime after the Japanese empire which is still relevant.
Your colonizer has always said that you were never a nation. DeGaulle, Macron...
Please don't compare our history with yours
It’s already solved. It’s Moroccan always has been and always will be.
No 🇪🇭🇪🇭
@@akdjksolnng7811 get a life 🙂
If someone committed horrible human rights abuses against you and your people, would you lie down and take it or would you fight back?
@@reanimationeas342 Fight back.. as Morocco did.
@@akdjksolnng7811 cry more 😂
There is no nation called western sahara, Morocco have a western Sahara and Egypt have also a Western Sahara which translates literally to western desert.
The polisario militias and institutions are based in Algerian soil.
Much of the SADR controlled territory is desert with no water access or farmable land or an effective power grid. Would you want a base of operations in a place with no water access or farmable land?
Oy vey
🇪🇭🇪🇭 ❤ i would like to make it clear that all this Moroccans talking here don't talk for saharawi people both in refugee camp or in occupied territory , and as a sahrawi person i assure you'll that sahrawi people are suffering for freedom and will get it
You will get it in Tindouf
the only question to ask: was the Sahara a terra nullius at the time of the arrival of the Spanish colonists?
No, the inhabitants had always pledged allegiance to the Moroccan sultans.
End of the discussion.
What are you talking about? Lol. Morocco once "pledged allegiance" to France so by that logic the French occupation of Morocco can return? All these arguments completely fall apart when looking at how no International legal body recognizes the Moroccan occupation and Morocco has refused to hold a referendum for the indigenous population to decide.
@@SuperMovieLvr933 what a bunch of lies, morocco refuses to hold a referendum ? There"s literally thousands and thousands of refugees from countries like mauritania / Niger / mali that have immigrated to algeria and were put by the algerian government into the Tindouf camps to artifficialy pump up the numbers of refugees, how do you know who's a real sahraoui or not ? plus algeria literally refuses to let the UN do it's work to estimate the real number of sahraoui people. And there's also sahraoui people living in the morrocan controled side of the sahara, what do we do with them ? we don't count them cause that doesn't match your political agenda ? and finally yes, the argument of the inhabitants pledgind there allegiances to the moroccan sultans is historically true, but I guess the west decided that we don't care according to the international rules that they invented lol
@@SuperMovieLvr933 oh really, Morocco pledged allegiance to France? You don't know nothing about the history of my country so please stay away from this. There's never been a census of the Tindouf refugee camps since 1974, and the algerians know why.
And you know what? The moroccan flag is floating in our southern regions, come get it if you want, but you better be well prepared kid... There's never been a country called RASD and there'll never be.
@@SuperMovieLvr933 Do you even know why Morocco became a french protectorate? Answer this and I'll tell you if you can have an opinion about the history of my country.
@@hififreak8771 Seems like you have much contempt for democracy and indigenous liberation. Good thing you have no affect on any of this. Hopefully the Sahrawi people can be free from Morocco's illegal belligerent occupation.
Ceuta and Melilla for Morocco.
Gibraltar for Spain.
I suppose you are going to get all those people to leave their homes or become citizens of new countries?
No deal
and Siberia for China
@@geoms6263 not all of it just Vladivostok and the territories near it and Mongolia
@@Th3Nigma Bingo.
The Spanish Would Leave Ceuta and Melilla and Go Back to Spain , and English Would Leave Gibraltar and Return to England.
If you can't even determine who wants what on a piece of land, isn't that already a sign in itself? Like seriously, claiming the Western Sahara, which if you look at it is a clear continuation of Moroccan territory geographically speaking, if it takes so much effort to deny Morocco's claim on that land and can't even be backed up by popular demand and requires a neighbor country's manipulations then it seems like we're trying too hard to prove this is not Moroccan territory instead of proving this is part of the Republic of Western Sahara.
Compare this with Israel and Palestine. There's a clear and powerful demand for the Palestinian state. Such a contrast.
I'm confused. At the beginning, Spain left that area and Western Sahara was devided between Morocco and Mauritania. Then Mauritania decided to leave Western Sahara as it is not worth the hassle.Why did Morocco claim the other half?
@@nounou7ydra226 Because imperialism. Spain didn't left the Sahara, Spain was thrown out. The natives of the land kept fighting Morroco afterwars.
@@alvaro701 Have some shame.
yasmine hasnaoui is a mouthpiece for the Moroccan government who works as an academic. This is another example of the lack of autonomy of Moroccan universities that are controlled by a regime - something found in all Arab countries
Exactly, she did not even try to hide that, I was surprised a reputable network like AJ invited someone like her.
Shes the moroccan representative, what would u expect??? Idiot
Sahara belongs to Morocco, this is the only solution that will be accepted.
Not only is it the right solution, it is also historically proven to be Moroccan Kingdom sovereign territory.
@@knockknockrepoman exactly
@@knockknockrepoman The people living there doesn't want to. It's territory conquered to Spain. Let them free is the only good solution.
@@alvaro701 Incorrect mate. People who live there (Moroccan western sahara) want to be part of Moroccan kingdom, hence the country's autonomy proposal. PoIisario on the other hand are keeping abducted people under miserable conditions in tindouf and refuse talks with Morocco. UN has reduced its aid to poIisario this week after finding out poIisario is selling cooking oil aid to Mauritania.
@@knockknockrepoman They have been fighting Morroco for decades mate. If they are so sure about it, make a referendum, win it, and question settled for ever.
Algeria using oil supply as blackmail, same tactic Russia has been using on European countries. Algeria says western Sahara is not its affair. Yet there they go making irrational decisions.
It not Spain's affair either right
So it should just pucker up to Spain and France? Real world does not work like that.
@@aissa9428 Spain is the former colon of Moroccan Sahara, hence its implication. Algerian military regime should have no implication whatsoever as it was admitted by Algerian president.
@@chadgaston8615 If it weren't for diplomacy's sakes, Morocco would have erased soviet empowered Algerian regime from the map.
@@knockknockrepoman government of morroco gave bigger Concessions to Spain in exchange for this recognition, and I think this is not in the interest of the Moroccan people, but only in the interest of Spain،And the problem concerns Algeria as well because there are a lot of people who have sought asylum in Algeria from Western Sahara
Common sense easy solution = Non biased 3rd party hold a secure vote for the people of the region to decide if they want to be under Morocco or be entirely their own nation.
yeah right, keep dreaming about that 🤣
too late to do that, should've done that back then, now all people are fed 50uyears + years of propaganda and they won"t be able to give their own opinion.
@@mounir7910 yeah morroco is a colonizer just like any other european nation that's it, they want to retain its colonies just like the united states, spain, UK and france.
thats a great idea the thing is 99% of the people will vote in favor of morocco, the polisario is a small terrorist group living in the eastern sahara in algeria
It won't work because Morocco invaded and massacred a large number of the native people, mostly men resisting the annexation. The women and children fled to refugee camps in Algeria. Then Morocco brought in tons ofi mmigrants from the North attempting population replacement. They even banned the native Sahrawi Hasaniya Arabic dialect. Hundreds of thousands of Sahrawis have been in exile for 40 years.
So the vote would most likely be biased.
Plus Morocco's claim is based on pre European colonial borders of the Moroccan empire. So they don't care what the people think, its their land because they conquered it twice, historically and at present.
What I don't understand is why Algeria didn't complain when the Sahara was colonised by spain
well, Algeria never existed till france has Put it there at 1963 but yeah even when the talk about the files of the UN, the File was Posed by Morocco, Morocco is ready to solve this thing peacefully or with War, We got both history and power .back us UP.
@@elhadi9886 Hello El Hadi, the problem with the algerians is their short access to the archives ? who said that morocco didnt try ? Morocco's History is not like none of the other African countries he had Three colonizers bcz of its geographical place and its Religion annexe ( Islam - Spian is christian ) Morocco had its land Splitted between Powers, it didnt take its full independence, bcz as u know they wanted to split morocco from the world, spain took the North and south france took the middle and the east, btw there were some Cities, that u better go check they were annexed to Western Sahara , and they took their independence even after the Green March 1975, We talking abt Sidi Ifni, and other small cities, SO, if u, by any Chance was Brought by France, to serve French interests in Africa by giving them Gaz For cheap, stay away From Us, we' are a nation, we were , and we staying, what we gave and giving to africa is mostly New to you.
Boumediene supported the claim of Morroco at first but then, he adopted a new strategy and invented a so called sahraoui cause. why he didn't include algerian sahraoui just show how stupid this claim is
@@mounir7910 OMG please shut up, if u'r not a moroccan then, dont u ever talk abt Boumedian Supporting morocco, how come a president who ordered the expulsion of 350,000 Moroccan nationals from Algeria on. 18 December 1975, the first day of Eid al-Adha,, how d u think he would support ? plus, back then, there was no algerian sahraouis France never Mentioned them in any of their archives and these sahraouis they were not included in the Autodetermination ( what the algerian calls idependence ... ) "" Check Document5 in the French Archive ""
they were busy fighting the French in their own territory
sahraaa magribia ❤❤
This conflict is a result of french and spanish colonization. Moroccan territory was split like a cake among colonizers, they did whatever they wanted, and eventually left Morocco in pieces and fighting for whatever it could have back of its territories. It is not a question of colonaziation as the polizario propaganda suggest, it is a question of a Morocco that's trying to protect its territorial unity and its right to be liberated from the shadows of colonization that left not only Morocco but all African nations stuck in ruins of the past. All these conflicts only benefit global powers in keeping an upper hand on Africa and using its resources, by making it unstable and unable to be independent.
If it not Algeria's affair
Then it not Spain's affair either is it
🎯
Sahara is Moroccan for ever ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ long live Morocco
Everyone talks about Palestine but forgets about Western Sahara 🇪🇭
All the world is shifting to Morocco after they were neutral, hopefully the biggest player, Alegria, will understand this.
The SAME world also supports Israel's occupation of West Bank and East Jerusalem.
Will Arab countries support that too?
Embarrassing
@@akdjksolnng7811 Algeria should gain some shame and class, but class is tied to culture and we all know Algerians have no culture
The chosen ones gave morroco their blessing hehe
@@incogb6696 don’t get it twisted with your poor third world country habibti ❤️❤️🇲🇦🇮🇱
i
Spain is carrying a politcal and historical shame on its shoulder until the people of Western Sahara get their rights they were strugling for decades.
So you want a "country" as big as 1/2 France ruled by maybe 40K people (Polisario), of majority land is sand? .. This is just a cocktail for a failed state, full of internal conflicts and wars (it is happening already between the clans in Tindouf), terrorisme. I mean just another South Sudan scenario. ..... And not to forget Algeria who will claim their return of investment in years of political, financial and military support?Algeria will be overruling the polisario to benefit access to Atlantic. Do you think Algeria is spending billion of dollars per year just for the sake of ideal idea's. Wake up .. the world has changed - no country (certainly US, EU, ...) will vote for another new failed states in such strategic and hot place in Africa. So keep dreaming!
gfu, you benefited from the drawing of the borders made by France when it colonized you and this drawing included the sahrawis of the eastern sahara and of kabylia which wishes its independence. But this contradiction does not bother you. The Sahara is and will remain Moroccan and it is not Algerians like you who will change anything
We will never forget your attempts and reverse lies, and neither will you
Don't lie to me. Before the Spanish occupation, the Sahara was not part of Morocco. When the Spaniards arrived in the Sahara in 1884, they spoke to the Saharan ruler and the Sultan of Mauritania. That is why, when Morocco and Mauritania, with the assistance of the United Nations in 1975, brought the Sahara case before the Hague court, it ruled that Western Sahara, because of its lack of sovereignty ties, with Morocco and Mauritania, could be subject to resolution 1514, which grants the Saharan people the right of self-determination that awaits them so long.
Well it's part of Morocco now end of discussion
I have 2 questions :
who was the king or president of the "western sahara republic" at that time ?
and whats the difference between a sahraoui in morroco and another one in algeria or tunisia ?
So if.sahraoui want a republic it have to be a a repubulic that includes all south territories of Morroco, algeria, tunisia and lybia
@@walid3397 The former Western Sahara Spanish Sahara, which is a non-autonomous territory in the process of decolinization, has very well delimited territories. A Sahrawi in other countries is the same as a French or Moroccan in others. Morocco only has to comply with the self-determination referendum agreed with the Sahrawis in 1991, under the auspices of the United Nations.
@@patxiaznar9656 you didnt answer my questions.....
Sahara were morrocan before spanich colonzation, its still Morrocan in the present and it will stay Morrocan until the end of the days 😉
@@walid3397 I recommend you study history before you talk nonsense. Are you asking me about a king in Western Sahara? I really don't believe it, anyone who knows a little bit about history knows that the Sahrawi population was organized into tribes, so asking about a king doesn't make sense. If you know, I'll tell you again, when the Spaniards arrived in the Sahara, they talked to the Sultan of Adrar el-Tmar and the most respected Sahrawi leader in the area. Hence the Judgment of La Hague ruled that it was possible to implement United Nations Resolution 1514, which enables the right of self-determination of nations.
Moroco should be kicked out of the United Nations and African Union. The era of colonialism is over.
Come and try it
Viva Algeria, Viva Palestine
Stone age era boy
Ch3b chyat
Vive la3das ou lahlib, heheh .... Ila Algeria rjal .. 3lach ma diw slah (les armes) li Palestine bhal li polisario .. wallah hata thayadkoum Israel in kharita ... Vive Maroc.
2 bad u are like Israel 🤡
SAHARA IS FROM MOROCCO🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦
🤮
Morocco in his sahara and algeria gain a bunch of terrorists 🤭
I am from Indonesia respect west sahara
morocco is buying western support with western sahara resources (phosphate with half the price for the US and EU) + giving israel the wright to explor for oil and gas there
i dont know much about international relationships but buying a land thats yours (or at least that what morocco thinks) seems realy weak and shamful
morocco is already going down economically with debts almost 50% of its GDP , i think they will lose sovereignty trying to steal sahrawis land
algerian propaganda, phosphate comes from khouribga and ben guerir regions in central morocco, not from moroccan sahara.
moroccan sahara has no oil or gas, moroccan sahara doesn't have natural resources except fish.
morocco is not losing sovereignty anywhere except imagination of algerian junta, go back to sleep and dream about destroying morocco !!
"giving israel israel is bad" you are soo worst than western colonists.
thank you for showing us the levels of ur obsession and delusions..it started funny kinda, but got wayy out of hand on your end of course..100,000 moroccans from poor amazigh villages no longer breathing. moroccans need to wake up.
وله الحق المغرب في ثرابه ابان عن جد وتحية للمغاربة الاشراف الاسود من طنجة إلى الكويرة وسبتة ومليلية والجزر الجعفرية والصحراء الشرقية 🦁🦁🦁🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🦁🦁🦁🦁🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦💪💪💪💪💪
well France is 125% gdp external debt, the us is over 90% its almost economic recession. second, the conflict is between Algeria and Morocco, third western Sahara belongs to Morocco, historically and actually under Moroccan control. You can't buy support, you can have good diplomacy. seriously polisario is a lost cause, only failed states support it.. so Algeria and its gang is only waisting time and money. If you are a real Saharan, Morocco will welcome you with open arms. you can work, live, and be happy. if you are algerian, you should better take care of your country.
It’s a southern region of Morocco, plus all the consulates opening there and even Spain accepting the Kings project on a self governing region under Moroccan control so it’s Moroccan end of the storu
How is it end of story there is much debate about it
@@gothicgolem2947because it goes against the interest of a certain neighboring country’s regime, which is fueling hate beyond words to the people in the region who associate with Morocco.
imagine bowing down to a king and kissing his hand while he spends your “country’s” money in gay clubs in Belgium 😔
being Moroccan must be so humiliating
The bias line of question by the journalist against Western Sahara representative to the UN is clear. VIVA POLISARIO and Long Live. Victory is certain.
Tindouf is burning why do you think so.
How old is that pick up truck with a howitzer on it!?
Probably 70's or 80's, Toyota War era.
Old enough to generate its own fossil energy?
It is not old model. It just looks dry.
🤣😁😄
I was born in December, 76. I saw it before my birth as well, just that it was a km away.
I Just farted, Algeria be like 'its morocco's fault'
@@jarveyjaguar4395 so obsessed instead of using european way of bonding (killing us, keeping us down, and trying to integrate) you can do better
The Moroccan Sahara has been solved. America signed and agreed that this region is Moroccan. Full stop. Period.
the white man is ur god
@@procrastinator8817 you mean the UN which polisario is bootlicking and straight up lying to?
The only solution is to let western Sahara people decide via a free referundum, as decided by united nations in the early sixties. Morroco can say whatever they want, it's not up to them, the reality says that Algerians and Saharouis are against morroco occupation, but one silent player who's also against the morrocan occupation, but he is quiet, but at the same time he accepts western Sahara as an independent country, I am talking about Mauritania.
The funny thing, morroco sleeps for a century and whenever Algerians, muritanias or Saharouis free their lands from French and Spanish occupation, morroco claims that's it's his land!!!!!!!
These three countries knows very well the history of occidental Sahara and they will never let morroco impose his occupation agenda, trust me never ever.
We have the same problem which gulf countries were having with Saddam regim. Morrocans has to respect their neighbors borders or it will end up with a big war in the region, because we won't let them impose such unfairness.
This is the history of western Sahara, and you can judge!!
لماذا الصحراء ليست مروكية:
* دخل الإحتلال الإسباني الصحراء سنة 1884 و كانت مملكة فاس و مراكش مستقلة، و لكنها لم تحرك ساكنا و لم ترسل جيشا ليوقف الغازي الإسباني.
* ظل الإحتلال الإسباني جاثما على صدور الصحراويين طيلة قرن من الزمان، و لم نسمع بثورات أو حروب قادها سلاطين فاس و مراكش المتعاقبين لتحرير الصحراء الغربية من المحتل الإسباني.
* كانت بعض القبائل الصحراوية الحدودية تقود عمليات ضد المحتل الإسباني و عندما إتصل الإسبان بسلطان فاس و مراكش، أكد لهم في إتفاقية وادي نون بأن الأراضي الواقعة تحت وادي نون ليست تابعة له.
* إندلع الكفاح الصحراوي ضد المحتل الإسباني سنة 1973، بدعم من ليبيا و الجزائر، فيما بقي ملك المروك متفرجا يترقب ما ستؤول إليه الأمور و رفض دعم الصحراويين في كفاحهم.
* تحت ضغط المقاومة الصحراوية إنسحبت إسبانيا من الصحراء سنة 1975، فتفاجأ الصحراويون بملك المروك يقتسم أرضهم مع ولد دادة، متناسيا حينها ما يسميه اليوم وحدته الخرافية!!!
* ركز الصحراويون ضرباتهم أكثر على جيش ولد دادة، إلى أن قبلت موريتانيا بالإنسحاب من وادي الذهب سنة 1979، و لكن تفاجأ الصحراويون بملك المروك يسرقها منهم ثانية كما فعل مع الساقية الحمراء سنة 1979!!! العجيب في الأمر نسي وحدته الخرافية سنة 1975 و تذكرها فجأة سنة 1979!!!
قمة الظلم و الإعتداء، كلما حرر الصحراويون أرضهم سرقها ملك المروك منهم!!!
This is all drama. It's all a question of keeping the balance established by third parties countres (very wealthy). The aim of this "balance" is to make sure that Africa stays poor.
It’s time now for Morocco 🇲🇦 get back the eastern Sahara from Algeria 🇩🇿 and Septa and Melilla towns from 🇪🇸
that’s true but we need to take half of Algeria because it belongs to Morocco but we don’t need melilla and septa because it’s small we need half of Algeria the land that we took during the sand war 🇲🇦🤜🏻🇩🇿🇪🇭💩💩
@@Shaw737 good luck come get it then tough guy
@@Shaw737 Kepp coping, Spain is still colonizing you hhhhhh
@@mehdibb4186 we Moroccan hate Algeria. Algeria never had a history and they are weak just like the sand war they lost to Morocco and soon when the time is right we will take our stolen land from Algeria and if Algeria doesn’t want to give it back to us it’s ok we can take it by force Tough guy
@@Shaw737 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Sahara is Morocco Forever🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🦁🦁🦁🦁🦁🦁🦁🦁🦁
No Hassania, the war with morocco will lead to something…horrible…but could be necessary to cleanup and free the oppressed and frustrated people…of course The Algerian will need also to focus on their issue, but as you failed to show with your understanding of politics, running a state is never only internal…but it’s ok, you’ve earned your blessing from your “god”.
Theres actually a war in the region
Algeria didn't exist in the précolonial era, and france made it the largest territory identified as a single country in africa, polisario should grab their share from "algerian" sahara !
Cry moorish
educate yourself, foolish
@@akdjksolnng7811 yes we are and we are being kept down by Spainyard who just 9 gen ago killed Amazigh wiped them out on Canary Islands 🇮🇨 & Algeria which has took our land and now trying to stall by draining our recourses time and 100k lives by going after WS.
Why Spain got involved? Stop interfering internal affairs
Much of this is their fault like the British in Palestine.
@@chechnya what makes you think Spain is civilized?
@Luis my common sense is “not interfere with other internal affairs unless it’s welcome”
@@tnt_pkk1311 spain interfered when they invaded morroco,. they had no choice than take their responsability to Morroco
@Luis Was Christopher Columbus civilized?
Fighting over literal desert. Brilliant.
@@milotura6828 yes and where is phosphates and uranium come from according to you?
@@kristofferlaw6991 Morocco doesn't need extra phosphate. He already owns 75% of the world's known phosphate reserves.
@asad africa obviously they care about it if they are fighting over it (a desert). Literally.
@@donkeeefarms3795 you wear your name well...
Much more is at stake than your simplistic vision. Morocco cannot accept having a vassal state of Algeria in the south. This would enclave it and cut off its access to the African market with which it does a lot of business. Morocco is playing its survival in this story.
@@mounir7910 I wish them no ill will
One of these days, Polisario movement will be treated as a terrorist organization....Wait and see!
why not the invader??? ha!
Yes. This conflit can be resolved by applying the rule of law.
this conflict has already been resolved. There are only a few mercenaries left in the pay of Algiers who are stupidly stubborn. These fools don't even realize that they are just the puppets of Algiers with views of the Moroccan Sahara
FREE WESTERN SAHARA 🇪🇭❤️🇪🇸
Free kabayl Republic
@@Ali-id4vu and free RIF 👍🇪🇸❤️♓
@@hamzabel5782 Rif and western Sahara are under Moroccan sovereignty. Free kabyle
@@Ali-id4vu and what the minurso did right now in morroco ? and if western Sahara is morrocan why divided it with a wall and mines from the north to the south ! and
bel minurso will prove the right of Moroccan kingdom as the last un resolution done.
It's moroccan land from an historical perspective. All evidence is stored in historical documents stored also in France. Algeria is created by France in 1963 and exist from Moroccan ,Tunisian ,lybian land.
Mauritania,Mali were also non existing countries before the French colony.
@@alfredomafiosoMorocco was a protectorate. It is normal that when the occupiers leave the land returns to the ruler of that nation. It's not la la land It's common sense and international law. The boundaries in Africa are not natural but drawn by the european colonisers in the sykes picot agreement.
تحية للمغاربة الاسود كافة من طنجة إلى الكويرة وسبتة ومليلية والجزر الجعفرية والصحراء الشرقية 🦁🦁🦁🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦💪💪💪💪💪
Morocco is a creation of France ( Marechal Lyautey ) , which transformed Marrakech and Fes sultanat by a country which named Morocco . France is the the Father of mOROCCO
@@alfredomafioso bro I think you have mental problems Morocco was never part of France. Morocco was the moorish empire the only reason why Algeria existed because they come form France and Polisario Western Sahara come from Algeria. Spain and France team up together to defeat Morocco in ww2 because Morocco took hole territory of Spain during the year of empire Spain and Portugal wanted to take Morocco but they fail then in ww2 Spain told France let’s team up and take Morocco Spain took Morocco Western Sahara and France took Morocco and made them France protectorate
@@alfredomafioso go search moorish empire and see what is Morocco then make sure to quit smoking weed because it makes you high 🥴
Where is the algerian guest 🤔 I think it's an obvious thing to have at least someone algerian
Other things Algeria made it clear that they don't have any problems with the European union nor with the Spanish people it's only because of the actual gouvernement and their statement about western Sahara 🇪🇭
it's western sahara not algerian sahara.
But algeria Pay millions, at least they have the right to be invited.
This Is Allarming 🚨
If Algeria supoort sefl determination they have to recognize Kabylia republic, ten millions of Kabyles people want their own country in the north east of algeria
I thought western sahara was given to Morocco by the USA in Morocco recognition of Israel
😆
😶
And where is the problem?
@@son-of-the-moorish-empire so why is there still a debate? I thought it was final
@@joebidet2050 western Sahara is moroccan with or without the recognition of USA or other countries.
The recognition of usa is just a plus, actually the sahara is controlled by morocco and there lives my brothers and it's ressources are exploited by us.
Legally we don't care what UN says but we still will play ur game.
About isreale we did some pretty good agreement.. like buying the drones from them.. the same we use to KILL those terroristes who tries to touch the sand of my sahara ;)
There is no pity
The Sahara is Moroccan and will remain Moroccan❤🇲🇦
We want our land 🇲🇦
Hands down the
Moroccan lady got stunned 😦 by the saharaoui guy statement ahahah colonisation will be over one day
It’s Algeria 😂😂😂😂 they’re sick
Morocco the best
The lady from Casablanca is irritating with her shrill voice and emotional reaction, unlike the other two participants. emotional reaction,
Misogyny from little boy Algerians.. something I experience 24/7 as they invade Moroccan woman’s Spaces, even girl-only, to call us prostitutes (when it’s illegal in our country but legal in theirs..) a very troubled population.
Actually the blackmail over Spain came from Morocco by spying over the Spanish MP ( Pegasus scandal) and by lifting control over the border at Ceuta and Melilla which led to a flow of illegal migrant into Spanish Territory. Western Sahara territory is not an Algerian affairs simply because there is no territory claims over it. The two concerned by this territory dispute is Morocco and Polisario. Algeria stand with the choice of the Sahrawi peoples whether they wants independence or being part of Morocco.
All the countries spy on each other...Spain is doing that on a daily basis (globally speaking)
not algrian affair?jajajaja sad with spain for recognizing sahar moroccan plan..all the time lying...Algeria send heroin to europe and migrant to europe too, flights from algeria last weeknd with 2000 kilos . moroco is NATO 25 foreign member and eeuu , uuss alied, algria NOO
This is the most bullshitt I have ever read and sometimes I read Algeria news to get some jokes 🤣🤣
so according to you: Algeria is spending billions of $$ per year, giving heavy political support and military.. even damaging own economical benefits (like now against Spain) etc, .. just for the sake of supporting 40K ppl to determine their "independence"? Do you really believe this bul**. As Boumedian said "I am going to create a stone in shoes of Moroccan for ever" - and that is Polisario. And you are telling Algeria is not involved and just providing some moral support? and for nothing - access to Atlantic? Keeping Morocco busy? cut-off Morocco from rest/ west Africa?
@@gregorytheblackkitten9422 Say wherever bullshit, but its just the truth. Morroco spied Pedro Sanchez, Macron, some ministers and many european Journalist. Also, they blackmail us using inmigrants and, of course, keep an ilegal occupation of Western Sahara. They can do that thanks to their daddies, which are the US, France, Gulf countries and now Israel, that let them do wherever they want.
This conflict was created by Algeria.Its the Moroccan flag which is waving there, the currency is the Moroccan Dirham, the citizen living there get the Moroccan passport and citizenship.For our ennemies claiming that its not Morocco can you give us the countries where we can find the ambassies of this so-called country? What is the name of the ruler there ? Can you show us the pic of an ID or of a passport of this country ?
so to speak morocco the transgressor killing innocent people & stealing their land is not to blame??? Speechless!
@@LInaD-rh1cr nobody is getiing killed
they have eveything u asked for but cant post photo here so
She talks about vulnerability of refugee .who made them refugees? Morocco!!
The borders have never been geographical, they are ideological.
If France is abolished maybe, give India the seat France had in the un.
What about IJC decreed. "despite these "certain" links, there was no Moroccan sovereignty over Western Sahara, but only a certain "authority" or "influence" over "some" Sahrawi nomads (ICJ, 1975, paragraph 128) and such links did not deserve consideration"
We don't care about icj, now it's ours because we say so... End of discussion
Oh I got a new information regarding 2002 July crisis thanks guest sir
in 2023, there is no room for war and hatred, the world people become intelligent, work together, live together, live and let live, educate themselves on the Internet for free, make themselves intelligent, polite and friendly. take the example of the EU.
The Sahara is Moroccan and who says otherwise can hit their head against the wall.
Just by calling it Western Sahara is a big win for Sahraouis
Half to Polisario, half to Morroco.
🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭
kifach
yeah, another peaceful day in Africa
Not if Russian Wagner has anything to say about it.
POLISARIO FRONT , pelastine , same struggle .
It's was Moroccan before Spain took it 😂
Lying rat, Morocco didn't even exist when Spain colonized the Sahara, liar.
The Moroccan Sahara is a disputed territory located in the Western Sahara region of North Africa. It has been the subject of a long-standing conflict between Morocco and the Polisario Front, which seeks independence for the territory.
Morocco claims sovereignty over the region and has established a government presence there, while the Polisario Front maintains control over some parts of the territory. The conflict has been ongoing since the 1970s and has involved military clashes, political negotiations, and international mediation efforts. Currently, the United Nations maintains a peacekeeping mission in the region known as MINURSO, which is tasked with monitoring a ceasefire that was agreed to in 1991. There have been some recent diplomatic efforts to resolve the conflict, but it remains unresolved.
Freedom to western Sahara from Morrocan occupation.
long live the freedom struggle for independence. Saharawi people shall be victorious.
STFU. I'm from Western Sahara and Morocco is our Homeland. You don't have the right to express your opinion if you aren't from the region
@asad africa Morrocco is occupying the land of the saharawi. Our people shall be free & victorious. Long live saharawi.
@@watchman1thewaycher169 Morocco is the rightfull owner of the land go back to where ever you came from and cry there
Pipe dreams 😴
@@watchman1thewaycher169 terrorism will never win. Algerian regime is already defeated.
In this 'indulgent' toxic 'conflict', No else Moroccan or Algerian people side would get benefited on this kind of things, but i see... it would benefits some else country 'military industrial complex' and would cheered up some 'Europe identitarianist' extremists movement there. Don't fall into a same pit like those Libya and Levantine countries lads my advice from Indonesia🇮🇩
Long Live Algeria 🇩🇿❤️
Long live to Morocco 🇲🇦👑
Land of long queue for 3das, hlib, etc .... ruled by 3000 generals of average age of 70+ years while 60% of population is under 30y!!
Nobody Cares 🇹🇲
fckkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk DZ algeria
The Moroccan Sahara..End of discussion.
Before france invade morocco there is no such thing called algeria, france took a big part of morocco and and tunisia and libya and kabayle to create algeria.
New name Morocco El Sahara . New flag magribi Al Sahara Arab
Sahara is Moroccan, before spanich colonisation the sahara was Moroccan
I love Morocco 🇲🇦
Sahara is Moroccan forever never give up on the Moroccan desert
just to make it clear a lot of ppl think saharwis are native to western sahara thats not true at all saharawis are banu hassan tribes an arabian tribe that came from hijaz in saudi arabia in 17 century they drived the amazigh natives by a series of genocides to northern parts of north africa the natives of western sahara are the amazigh tekna tribes and sous amazighs who are moroccans and those ppl will never allow thier land to be taken from them again
nonsense there is no genocide of amazigh by Arabs in fact the majority of Moroccans are of amazigh decents they are just arabized meaning they adopted the culture and the arab language
There are plenty of research about the genetic of North African population so please don't spread lies that are harmful and racist
@@YA-kr4fr you need to study more about north africa and saharawi tribes
sahrawis are mostly from rguibat tribe wich is part banu hassan arabs who invaded maghreb sahara in the 17 century
@@YA-kr4fr saying the truth is racist now ? smh
@@YA-kr4fr look up "char bouba war"
Dar el islam "!!!...our beloved monarchy is islam !...no ideology must exist...
It doesn't matter if there's never been a country called Western Sahara. People have a right to self-determination, countries don't exist to serve a ruling fmaily, elite, or ethnic majority. If Western Saharans want to form a country why wouldn't they?
Because we Moroccans don't want 2,its ours
That claim could be made for many regions of the world
Independence to sahara
800 years it was part of Morocco ? It was part of Morocco sinds saaidi dynasty what’s your problem
@@abdelelman197 mOROOCO DID NOT EXIST AT THAT TIME , IT WAS ONLY FES AND MARRAKECH ,
FRANCE CREATED MOROCO , mARECHAL LYAUTEY
🇺🇸❤🇲🇦❤🇪🇸❤🇮🇱
And 🇮🇱
@@YudielJared 🇺🇸❤🇲🇦❤🇪🇸❤🇮🇱
based
4 toilet papers
@@YudielJared toilet paper
I have only recently begun to learn about this conflict, añd wonder what the pepple living in Western Sahara wañt and have they been involved in the discussions aɓout possible solutions? Why can Western Sahara not ɓecome an independent democrstoic state responsible for it's own destiny with ever
yone living invthe state having equal rights....is this anothervUN failure?
Free western sahara
It's aready been resolved, Morocco exercises its sovereignty over the territory and it is only Algeria that is stubborn when it has lost
The UN supports Morocco anyways 😂
Moroccan desert
Morocco will never understand the Algerian position to stand by the Sahrawi people simply because Morocco never had a revolution to free its people from foreign occupation over the centuries. This lady falsely claiming that Algeria is "against the autonomy of the Western Sahara"!? That's not true. The position of Algeria is give full freedom for the Sahrawi people by the referendum to choose if they want to be part of Morocco or not. The referendum will include ONLY the Sahrawi people, but not Moroccan occupiers who moved and settled in WS. Let them choose by themselves for their future.
Morocco can't even claim their own territories of Ceuta and Mellila, because they scared of Spain, but they go with the "weak" to claim all Western Sahara! It's not going to work...
Free kabylia
Free Kabylia from its algerian tyrants
@@YA-kr4fr bla bla bla...I'm kabyle Algerian and proud.
So you think that Algeria will never ask anything in return for its a political, financial and military support of Polisario for 50 years (do the math how much billions $ it is)? dream on ya waldi! About what you said about Ceuta and Mellilia: those cities will return thru a peaceful process like Hong Kong etc. Morocco and Spain are civilised countries to solve issue by political talks .. And you know: if Algeria didn't keep Morocco busy with the sahara conflict for 50 years , and even in stead supported Morocco with C & M (as you said Algeria has high standard when in it comes to supporting liberation of occupied places) , then Morocco would have got C&M by now ... Morocco is not scared of Spain .. it is a matter of time and on going game of diplomacy! Only you - Algeria still think of time Che - taking arms and signing Cuban songs. The world has changed if you dind;t notice. Btw - isn't Algeria that supported Spain during a short conflict between Spain and Morocco about a small island Leila? traitors!!
@@jamdodo7500 The only traitors out there are the Moroccan Makhzen and its supporters. You're trying to "buy" other countries' supports with everything you can, including your dignity, if you have any left, just to put your friends and neighbors in the bad situation.
Like I said, if Morocco wants Western Sahara, give the Sahrawi people the right to choose without any pressure. Let them decide by themselves for their future. Otherwise, it is just pure occupation and exploitation. Good day
We moroccan are in our motherland Sahara
Western Sahara is Morocco 🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦
Western sahara 🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭
Referendum is only solution by people to join with any country.
Well Morocco didn't orchestrate a referendum when they illegally occupied the country in 1976.
@@SuperMovieLvr933 cuz it's Moroccan
@@ashraf_rpl4961 Clearly you don't care about democracy or the opinions of the indigenous Sahrawi people. Proving that the Moroccan occupation has always been about brute force and suppression. Moroccan occupation of Western Sahara is almost identical to Israeli occupation of Palestinian Territories and Russian occupation of Ukrainian lands. All of it is illegal under international law and completely immoral. Hopefully the Moroccan dictatorship collapses. Inshallah.
@@SuperMovieLvr933 keep dreaming you ignorant piece of khra
@asad africa You can't go to the Polisario controlled areas easily at all because they live behind a giant wall and are cut off from their native lands. Morocco invaded Wester Sahara just like Russia is invading Ukraine. The only difference though is that people don't seem to care about Western Sahara or the Sahrawis like they do Ukrainians.
this territories must be with God Allah ans our beloved prophet mohamed and no any others guerilleros ...of ideology
NO
This lady is out of touch