Asus ROG Scar 17 Review - AMD did it again, 3D V-Cache in Laptops is a Game Changer, literally!

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ธ.ค. 2024

ความคิดเห็น •

  • @dalefrancis9414
    @dalefrancis9414 ปีที่แล้ว +43

    Yeah that thing where some manufacturers treat AMD like a second class citizen annoys me too. Think only Lenovo gives them the respect they deserve. Great review as always.

    • @NotebookcheckReviews
      @NotebookcheckReviews  ปีที่แล้ว +15

      But then again, they announced the Legion Pro 7s with Zen 4 CPUs months, and they are nowhere to be seen ...

    • @Vulcannyx
      @Vulcannyx ปีที่แล้ว +4

      Hopefully the framework 16 gets higher option amd gpus/cpus soon, i can't wait

  • @joelconolly5574
    @joelconolly5574 ปีที่แล้ว +14

    Review of the mobile X3D is finally here

  • @allstargaming2500
    @allstargaming2500 ปีที่แล้ว +15

    Asus should understand that given the premium price point, they gotta make some things to look premium. They gotta include a mechanical keyboard with no squished in numpads(17" and 18" still feature kitten sized keys). Biometrics and 3 USB A and 2 USB C is necessary. Camera quality gotta go upto 5MP with IR. And maybe a SD card with upto 150MB/s. This is why I think some people don't like Asus because they charge a premium price but not looking premium with such features. They gotta go back to the drawing board and redesign their keyboard like Alienware full sized keyboard and good RGB lighting already. It looks super dull and F1 to F12 icons are not lit up which is weird.

    • @NotebookcheckReviews
      @NotebookcheckReviews  ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Well, Asus showed that they CAN do it with their Zephyrus Line-Up. Even the Scar 16+18 are a big step forward from this one. I would love to see a ProArt Notebook, baut with the Scar 17s hardware config ... that would be something.

    • @allstargaming2500
      @allstargaming2500 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      @@NotebookcheckReviews Zephyrus is good, but I want them to do the same for Strix/Scar. I mean they both are in the 2 grand to 4 grand budget range so there's no excuse that these laptops don't have the features I said.

  • @Max_Mustermann
    @Max_Mustermann ปีที่แล้ว +11

    A good example of "gamer" aesthetic done right is IMO the Zephyrus range. The design manages to look futuristic and distinct, yet understated.

    • @NotebookcheckReviews
      @NotebookcheckReviews  ปีที่แล้ว +5

      True. The Lenovo Legions also strike an excellent middle ground, and I personally like Alienware's approach too.

  • @neerajkarunanidhi6804
    @neerajkarunanidhi6804 ปีที่แล้ว +12

    Handing the older chassis to an objectively better SoC is just….weird. The OG 7945HX model can be justified. This feels unfair. They have one last shot with the rumored 7900M chip based Strix AE model in the barn……if that goes out the winds, then it’s clear that Intel has resorted to hand-wringing to prevent an objectively better product from a competitor.

    • @NotebookcheckReviews
      @NotebookcheckReviews  ปีที่แล้ว +10

      I agree, who knows what is going on behind the curtain, and how far back any agreements date. But lets hope we will see a lot more, premium, AMD-equipped notebooks soon!

    • @MrRobaloAmigo
      @MrRobaloAmigo ปีที่แล้ว +2

      there is nothing weird - only this chasis from Asus has vapor chamber

  • @gaming_centric
    @gaming_centric ปีที่แล้ว +19

    Is it just me or is the pricing on these absolutely wow-inducing :)) its shocking

    • @josue85
      @josue85 ปีที่แล้ว +5

      The pricing for all rtx 4000 series laptops have been ridiculous. I normally upgrade every year, but the nvidia tax this year has been a real turn off

    • @NotebookcheckReviews
      @NotebookcheckReviews  ปีที่แล้ว +23

      Absolutely! The Scar is a great laptop, but at that price it should offer a better/higher quality chassis.

    • @IguanaFilmArts
      @IguanaFilmArts ปีที่แล้ว +2

      This is why I am very happy I got my Vivobook Pro 14X for 1300 euro's, because it has a lot of premium features such as 90hz 2.8k oled and 32gb ram alongside 5900hx that make it a production beast still. The rtx 3050ti 4gb is the weak spot but at least it has a high performance per watt and just uses 40watts max, leading to a small compact body and PSU. RTX 4070 Zenbook Pro f.e. has twice the gpu performance and more vram but also needs a much bigger laptop body and PSU. The Vivobook Pro 14X is 1.4kg but the Zenbook Pro 14 1.8kg with twice the PSU size.A 32gb 1tb rtx 4070 i9 13900 Zenbook Pro might have twice the performance but is 2.5x the price and much heavier and less compact to travel with. So there are trade offs. Finally, single core performance of the 5900hx is 70% of the i9 13900h, which for production apps is enough anyways. I am waiting for prices to drop or for me to find a last minute deal otherwise the RTX 4070 Zenbook is way too expensive.

    • @gaming_centric
      @gaming_centric ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@IguanaFilmArts sounds good! A lot of nice features for a relatively small sum. Nice find!

  • @TotallyNotEvil910
    @TotallyNotEvil910 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Your comments on the second class citizen treatment for AMD machines are very welcome, it feels like they've been sabotaged like that for years now. Dell didn't even touch AMD, not even when Ryzen 4000 and 5000 were crushing Intel 9th, 10th and 11th gen. This practice feels very scummy, and they are probably being paid for this.
    I usually hammer on this very key on almost every machine, too- saving pennies on machines that start at 2000 EUR is ridiculous and very off-putting.
    On the machine itself, it's looks shockingly similar to the G15 AE, which is both good and bad. The keyboard on it I find great, albeit lacking in a numpad, but the touchpad does look different, and I find the one in the G15 quite good as well.
    3D V-cache really changed the game, and I can't wait to see it trickle down further, especially for handhelds. Imagine Zen 5 3D v-cache chips with an RDNA4 iGPU, that is going to be straight up silly.
    One of the most appealing parts of 3D GPUs seem to be missing from this as AMD went the way of Intel, deciding to forget tuning the power curve to instead just deliver the highest possible Cinebench scores. To be fair, I get the reason why- big number means neuron activation and all that. For the top-most, mobile workstation chip, I don't mind too much.
    The best part is that I expect any 3D V-cache CPU to hang at the top spots in the gaming CPU hierarchy for a long while, because to this day there are games where the humble 5800X3D, a CPU that, effectively, is a mid-range chip from 2020, is still trading blows with a 250W latest-gen i9 that costs two or three times as much, and doing it while sipping power. It has been aging really, really well.
    It's crazy how some games are an absolute blowout in the favor of any CPU with the extra cache, regardless of it's "base power", and it feels like we are getting more of those as of late. I don't know if it's more detailed models, more complex physics, more background stuff that happens in ever more ambitious titles, but given Intel is also racing to implement their own low-level cache expansion technologies (Adamantine I think it's called?), I suspect this trend will continue for some time.

  • @JTorres30
    @JTorres30 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Thank you for the review, one question, what brand is your shirt? Thanks

  • @lenbata
    @lenbata ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Just placed an order of this today 10/03/2023 $3,699.99 plus California tax

    • @NotebookcheckReviews
      @NotebookcheckReviews  ปีที่แล้ว

      So it is finally available? Nice, have fun with your new machine!

  • @toungeenaamoo
    @toungeenaamoo 6 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Why is it that only one sku used this processor?

  • @drifter4training
    @drifter4training ปีที่แล้ว

    hmm according to the official asus site, the model also have power delivery / G-SYNC function on 1 usb c port and G-SYNC function on another c port

  • @highlanderc
    @highlanderc ปีที่แล้ว +1

    why can't they put the mouse pad on the damn center?

  • @vgvgvg234
    @vgvgvg234 ปีที่แล้ว

    It says 3D V-Chache on the video title. (typo for V-Cache)

  • @wolfgang6319
    @wolfgang6319 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Nice but how much cost 😢

    • @NotebookcheckReviews
      @NotebookcheckReviews  ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Unfortunately we do not know how much the X3D version is yet! :/

  • @zachariah380
    @zachariah380 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    All I want is the Unicorn of laptops, like if this had a 16x10 ProArt screen and it had a baby with a Dell XPS. Is that too much to ask? 😁

  • @RedTick2
    @RedTick2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Too bad you can't find them anywhere for sale. Links are always for versions other than the 7945HX3D.

  • @MatematicasyFisica
    @MatematicasyFisica ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I want a legion 7 with this processor

  • @kb8582
    @kb8582 ปีที่แล้ว

    How can it be that Asus claims that their Performance Mode does not excede 40 Db, and your testing says it is about 48 Db?

    • @NotebookcheckReviews
      @NotebookcheckReviews  ปีที่แล้ว

      You have to read the fine print about how they test. They might got their measurements at a different distance/angle/workload etc.

  • @nahhsa16584
    @nahhsa16584 8 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Is it the same screen as the scar 16? Mini led 1100 nitts?

  • @butanding1987
    @butanding1987 ปีที่แล้ว

    Why can't you use liquid metal?

  • @thomasanderson1416
    @thomasanderson1416 ปีที่แล้ว

    No optical drive any more?

    • @NotebookcheckReviews
      @NotebookcheckReviews  ปีที่แล้ว +4

      I think we have been past optical drives for a while now 😅

  • @marcin_karwinski
    @marcin_karwinski ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Chip - better than the non V-cache unit, as expected... though what would have been perhaps even better would be a mixed Bergamo chiplet and 3D V-cache one, as both are more energy efficiency oriented, one potentially giving 16 full-fledged cores with regular cache size per chiplet and one with more cache for those apps that benefit from it. That aside from a full-on 3D V-cache dual chiplets CPU would make it far better. Sure it would cost as much if not slightly more, but then it would make a better premium component than this is. Still, this chassis at this price point? Perhaps sometime soon Dell might start offering a refreshed internals Alienware units, then this CPU might be offered there in some Xnn line-up models. But currently and globally it seems that along the so called "premium" laptops only Asus has the global reach and distribution (it's one thing to state that something is offered, it's a different thing to deliver it to retailers/clients worldwide). And yet, they're putting the premium compute components into an old chassis coming from a refresh 2 or 3 years ago on an even older design, with only an okayish screen? Asus once had Zephyrus S17, why not base the chassis design on it, just improve the cooling more (who knows maybe they could even get the Frore systems on board to get a whole huge set of their AirJets spread over the surface of the vapor chamber/laptop space), use the raised keyboard for extra air intake and to keep hands cool all the time and to put a huge touchpad, maybe even one to rival those from the Macbooks, put a miniLED 17" screen with 8:5, or how it is now commercialised/named 16:10, AR as there are a few of those on the market to choose from at FHD+/QHD+/UHD+ resolutions, give more than 2xUSB4-C and 2xUSB3.2-A ports as well, upgrade to the WiFi7 cards, maybe consider adding a 10GbE ethernet port as a first in Windows laptop market, and as a must-have add better camera like what's being done on the "office-oriented" Zenbooks, plus complete the package with both IR for face detection and a fingerprint scanner, maybe even consider adding smart-card reader for trully all the boxes ticked in the security department. Finally, drop the awful RGB everywhere discoteque leaving only the useful parts, like keyboard lights and maybe, if you really want RGB on a chassis, add turnable hard to see ports monikers like Lenovo did on Legion 7. Heck maybe even consider checking the USB-C chargers to get some 240W+ PD GaN small-ish brick for the on-the-go occasions... That would make it a head turner for those in the know and a stealthy looking one for those that don't want to lug around room ambient lights along with the thick old-looking laptop. And that, priced at similar range as the current old chassis, would make far more sense to the consumers looking for a trully premium offering. Someone at Asus must have known that, and yet we got this?
    Btw. we're still missing RDNA3 GPUs higher than 7600M in laptop space... wouldn't it be great if AMD could combine their efficiency designs and release whole platform top of the range AMD? Maybe then people could forget the old chassis setup offered on a premium product... just maybe.

  • @vik1ng313
    @vik1ng313 ปีที่แล้ว

    Why can't it be liquid metal? Is it due to some technical problems with the chip or just ASUS not giving an option? That phase change pad is also pretty close to liquid metal in performance.
    Also, is the 7945HX3D single CCD or double like the desktop 7950X3D?

    • @devonoconnell2742
      @devonoconnell2742 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Because Liquid Metal would eat away at the chassis

    • @vik1ng313
      @vik1ng313 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@devonoconnell2742 Is the chassis fully aluminium? I might have missed it. Even so if liquid metal leaks, damaged chassis would be the least of their problems. Not like they don't place guards around the CPU to prevent leaks.

  • @notchipotle
    @notchipotle ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I have no idea that notebookcheck has a youtube channel lol

  • @KoiAquaponics
    @KoiAquaponics 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

    How noisy at full load?

    • @Joshimite
      @Joshimite 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      It's very quiet for a gaming laptop

  • @helloworld77771
    @helloworld77771 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I had the Acer Helios 18. It felt weird the 16:10 display. It is true you can have some extra lines of stuff in Premiere, After Effects, etc. BUT the whole "feeling" it has as a more "squared" vs the more "cinematic" feel of the 16:9 is a turn off - especially when watching videos. What's next in their marketing department? Selling a 4:3 as the new cool? No thanks. I stick to 16:9 like the Scar 17 has.

  • @DaClaymore
    @DaClaymore ปีที่แล้ว

    Is this available in Germany yet? I can’t seem to find the „G733PYV-LL053X“-Version, as you call it in your german review. But maybe I’m just stupid 🤓

    • @NotebookcheckReviews
      @NotebookcheckReviews  ปีที่แล้ว

      I also did not find it, but it was supposed to be available today! I will update the links as soon as we have news! There has also yet to be a word on pricing.

    • @_TrueDesire_
      @_TrueDesire_ ปีที่แล้ว

      Try with G733PYV only

    • @DaClaymore
      @DaClaymore ปีที่แล้ว

      Giving that there’s still no (official) word on pricing yet, I guess it’s safe to assume by now, that Asus forgot about their own launch? 😅

  • @Smart_boy2001
    @Smart_boy2001 ปีที่แล้ว

    I don't understand,what X3D is going to improve

  • @snakeplissken1754
    @snakeplissken1754 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

    While you have some good points i would add that the more powerful a laptop gets the worse it´s battery time will become. Hence it becomes more of a desktop replacement with the perk of being smaller, easier to move then a desktop pc.
    So stuff like keyboard flex, certain style choices, heck even the quality of the display do not matter as much anymore as they would in a laptop you actually use for "laptop" things.
    Sure for the pricetag they ask it´s arguable if "cutting corners" isn´t bit of a cheap shot, there are other brands that offer similar performance for less money while cheaping out on parts that probably a lot of consumers don´t even care about (or would even notice).
    If i would require a laptop for work, presentations etc i´d definitely not get one with a dedicated gpu and focus a lot more on efficiency. After all you do not really do high workload stuff on the go using battery.
    There are plenty of laptops around 400-500 bucks that are much better suited for doing anything on the go and you can add some more money to get the preferred build quality/display option etc.
    The one that shows up to a work meeting with a ryzen 9 7945hx3d laptop either doesn´t give a damn or wants to do some weird flex that most in the room won´t get.

  • @beeqool
    @beeqool ปีที่แล้ว

    how do you people deal with neck pain from laptop use? i love their portability but the sore neck i get seriously puts me off...

    • @NotebookcheckReviews
      @NotebookcheckReviews  ปีที่แล้ว +1

      A laptop stand would be an option. The elevation would be something to help here!

  • @JamesRocheUK
    @JamesRocheUK ปีที่แล้ว

    what s that curved monitor on your desk?

    • @NotebookcheckReviews
      @NotebookcheckReviews  ปีที่แล้ว

      That is the Acer Predator X45. The full review is coming on sunday!

  • @napalmarsch
    @napalmarsch 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    endlich mal notebooks mit genug vram

  • @VediziYT
    @VediziYT ปีที่แล้ว

    What is a "100%" reference in this graphs? In gaming perf Strix have 98%, and nothing have 100%.

    • @NotebookcheckReviews
      @NotebookcheckReviews  ปีที่แล้ว

      Its a synthetic reference, that no laptop was able to surpass yet.

  • @user-qh9qb2kt7f
    @user-qh9qb2kt7f ปีที่แล้ว

    Does it supports raid 0?

  • @TrungTheCelestial
    @TrungTheCelestial ปีที่แล้ว

    The numbers in this review and the numbers from other sources like Jarrod are very different.

  • @nileredsexperiment834
    @nileredsexperiment834 ปีที่แล้ว

    ooh!! was excited to see this beast!

  • @TheRealBigChungusOfficial
    @TheRealBigChungusOfficial ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Your reviews are amazing and super informative

    • @NotebookcheckReviews
      @NotebookcheckReviews  ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Thank you for the kind words. Unfortunately, we did not test the updated Aorus 7 yet. Check back at the website regularly so you don't miss it!

    • @TheRealBigChungusOfficial
      @TheRealBigChungusOfficial ปีที่แล้ว

      @@NotebookcheckReviews thanks for the heads up! Move love ❤️

  • @murtazahassan08
    @murtazahassan08 11 หลายเดือนก่อน

    its not available in middle east

    • @NotebookcheckReviews
      @NotebookcheckReviews  11 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      I think that is a global problem!

    • @murtazahassan08
      @murtazahassan08 11 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@NotebookcheckReviews if it is then why they launch it 🤐

    • @NotebookcheckReviews
      @NotebookcheckReviews  11 หลายเดือนก่อน

      🤷‍♂️

  • @eric131313
    @eric131313 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    i almost forgot that there was launch day today, great pr amd 😂

  • @rauhwelt2460
    @rauhwelt2460 ปีที่แล้ว

    I need this wallpaper

    • @NotebookcheckReviews
      @NotebookcheckReviews  ปีที่แล้ว

      I found it on unsplash.com
      Just look for "abstract wallpaper"

  • @arestavo
    @arestavo ปีที่แล้ว

    Mmmm that extra cache!

  • @drumtro11
    @drumtro11 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Should have had OLED

    • @NotebookcheckReviews
      @NotebookcheckReviews  ปีที่แล้ว

      I don’t think there are any 17“ QHD 240Hz display in production, unfortunately

    • @net200777
      @net200777 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@NotebookcheckReviews There are 17" OLEDs, maybe not 240. I would want 4k with a 4090 personally.

  • @denisdavidek
    @denisdavidek ปีที่แล้ว +5

    What an unused potential. Typical Asus are treating AMD as a second-class citizen. Hopefully, we will see X3D chips also on other notebooks like Lenovo Legion.

    • @NotebookcheckReviews
      @NotebookcheckReviews  ปีที่แล้ว

      My thoughts exactly!

    • @greebj
      @greebj ปีที่แล้ว

      Yep! But given we've already waited all year for a promised L7Pro 16ARX8H 7945HX model that's never come, I'm just not bothering to hope until something is actually released and in stock

  • @OleksanderKotek
    @OleksanderKotek ปีที่แล้ว

    Its better to buy dream machines for this cost

    • @NotebookcheckReviews
      @NotebookcheckReviews  ปีที่แล้ว +1

      It is a dream machine … at least in terms of
      Performance 😅

  • @anwartahernuman7675
    @anwartahernuman7675 ปีที่แล้ว

    Nvidia ripping people off due to monopoly

  • @rjpajaron
    @rjpajaron ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Asus strikes again: cheap laptop with high powered AMD CPU.

    • @NotebookcheckReviews
      @NotebookcheckReviews  ปีที่แล้ว

      It is such a shame. I used it as a daily driver, but it was closed and connected to an external screen with a mouse and keyboard. And it's so good ... I just wished they would put everything in a nicer chassis!

    • @silverpro8356
      @silverpro8356 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@NotebookcheckReviews Hi Notebook i am torn between the strix G17 and the strix G16 with i7 13650HX with 4060gpu. Do you think the G16 would still be ok for editing videos and multi tasking. I kinda like the 17inch but a lot of people are saying the cooling is not as good as the G16 and G18 computers. The G16 i was thinking of buying also has a 240hz QHD screen .

  • @Alex-df4lt
    @Alex-df4lt ปีที่แล้ว

    In a workstation V-Cache is not worth it due to not being compatible with liquid metal. That means a quite noisy laptop with worse multi-core CPU performance than 7945HX. For gaming it will bring a small performance benefit as CPU isn't running at max TDP while gaming. Overall it doesn't make much sense as you will get much better gaming experience from a desktop for much less.

  • @anarsosoroo2891
    @anarsosoroo2891 ปีที่แล้ว

    First 😅

  • @Frozoken
    @Frozoken ปีที่แล้ว

    Nice one amd, tack on an extra power hungry 8 cores that are useless for gaming and were already rejected on desktop. Don't take advantage of your chip thats even faster for gaming but with half the power consumption of normal zen 4 ON THE BATTERY POWERED FORM FACTOR. 🤦‍♂️Amd knew how power hungry even their chiplet links were so they had monolithic designs for mobile to get around that, now theyre adding both an io die link and cross ccd link needlessly so you have this chip literally losing to intel in video playback & web browsing battery life.