ไม่สามารถเล่นวิดีโอนี้
ขออภัยในความไม่สะดวก
WHICH TO BUY IN 2023? GoPro Hero 11 vs DJI Osmo Action 3
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 14 ส.ค. 2024
- Go to Squarespace.co... to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain using code "DAVIDMANNING"
GoPro Hero 11: geni.us/DMGoPro11
DJI Action 3: geni.us/DMAction3
DJI Wireless Mic: geni.us/DMDJImic
Quick Release Action Gear: geni.us/DMF22
THE BEST GOPRO ACCESSORY: geni.us/DMSnap...
Best Thumbscrews: geni.us/DMThum...
MY CAMERA GEAR:
Main Camera: Sony a7SIII - geni.us/DMA7Siii
Photo Camera: Sony a7IV - geni.us/DMSony...
Best Travel Tripod: geni.us/DMUlan...
Vlog Tripod: PolarPro Apex Base - geni.us/DMApex...
Vlog Tripod Head - Joby Ballhead - geni.us/DMJoby...
F38 Quick Release Plate: geni.us/DMF38
Support the channel and BUY SOME MERCH: shopdavidmanni...
🎵DOWNLOAD THE COPYRIGHT FREE MUSIC I USE: bit.ly/epidemic...
INSTA - / david_manning
TWITTER - / david_manning
MY CURRENT VIDEO GEAR:
My Video Camera: Sony a7SIII - geni.us/DMA7Siii
Main lens: 16-35mm - geni.us/DM16-35
Favorite Lens: 24-70mm - geni.us/DM24-70
Best Travel Tripod: geni.us/DMUlan...
💰 USE CODE "DAVID" TO SAVE 20%
Pocket camera: Sony ZV-1 II -
My Quick Release System: geni.us/DMF38
Mini Quick Release System: geni.us/DMF22
Backpack Clip: bit.ly/3jQvqri
MY CURRENT PHOTO GEAR:
My Photo Camera: Sony a7IV - geni.us/DMSony...
Favorite Lens: 24-70mm - geni.us/DM24-70
Long lens: 70-200mm - geni.us/DM70-200
35mm - geni.us/DM35mm
50mm - geni.us/DM50mm
85mm - geni.us/DM85mm
90mm - geni.us/DM90mm
The leather camera strap: cleversupply.c...
----Use Code "MANNING" for 10% DISCOUNT
ACTION CAMERA GEAR:
Insta360 ONE X3 - geni.us/DMVX3
GoPro Hero 11 - geni.us/DMGoPro11
Quick Release Action Gear: geni.us/DMF22
THE BEST GOPRO ACCESSORY: geni.us/DMSnap...
📫 I LIKE MAIL:
David Manning Vlog
PO Box 2622
Valley Center, CA 92082
Chapters:
00:00 - Intro
01:13 - Side by Side Comparison: GoPro vs DJI
03:06 - The Categories I Compare
03:40 - Image Quality
05:03 - Audio Quality
07:09 - Stabilization
07:42 - Bugginess
09:22 - Sponsor Slot - Squarespace
10:59 - Battery Life
14:40 - A Few More Things
*Most links in the description are affiliate links meaning I earn a small commission when you purchase.
#goprohero11 #djiosmoaction3 #actioncamera
I realize it sounds like I'm saying DGI instead of DJI, but I promise it feels like I'm saying DJI... What do you guys think? Is the Action 3 the new King of Action Cameras in 2023?
Dji
I went with the GoPro 11 although I was torn between the dji because of its ability to not overheat. All things considered I am extremely happy with my choice to go GoPro.
What about the focus issue on DJI
I'm not buying anything until they get it right. Both cameras are good but still not what I wanted yet. Most things are great but I'm looking for bokeh. I know asking for bokeh is too much for action camera. I'm also looking for much better Bluetooth microphone feature. As of now, it's not existed.
If I was going on pure battery life, I'd switch to the DJI, I've never had an issue with a GoPro. Guess I'm just lucky.
Loved the image from the GoPro 11 but I dont miss it at all after getting the DJI Action 3. No freezes, no over heating, longer battery, it just works better!
@@Seminoles11 I haven't had any. Not sure if it was fixed in a patch or something, I bought mine very recently.
@@Seminoles11 dji action 3 is just incredible and I got go pro hero 8 from relative. I spent around 80 dollars on accessories like mic adaptor etc. Will wait and watch what go pro hero 12 and dji would offer and accordingly will upgrade.
Dji has lots of benefits like price, bundle etc
Hey i do have the Action 3 for like 2 Weeks now and never had any focus issues, is this a common thing or just before the new updates came out?
I have a lot of Gopro accessories, will they work on the action 3?
@@Youno954 most of them will. The action 3 comes with the finger mount the go pros use. Just things very specific to GoPro like their Media Mod, and special lenses won't be compatible.
I have the DJI Action 3 and have used it for work, most recently in HOT Bali and the DJI performed flawlessly, My son has the GoPro 11 and has experienced the shut downs and battery issues... So 100% agree DJI Action 3 at this stage (especially when you NEED it to perform) is the best option. - Great informational video too 👍
Bali Indonesia
@@Andwave the one and same 👍
Did you happen to use it for any water activities, scuba diving?
@@robertfox374 I have not yet used it for Scuba. I have however, used it in shallow water and it worked great. The colour and image were (I think) better than the GoPro 11's underwater image.
@@DaveDiggle Thanks
I bought the DJI Action 3 around a week ago for a trip and this review really put my mind at ease, thank you.
Camera B. Hands down. Clarity & color alone. Watching on a 85” tv and I can see how much more of a difference it is. The GoPro is way clearer and colorful. Since it’s first priority and what it actually is a “camera” that’s what it should do best. Both companies have work to do. Great video David. Thanks!! So do I want a longer battery with poorer videos? Or superior video with less battery? Hmmm
In real life action filming you only film your action. 3-4 mins top per clip. If you film long clips get a camera 🎥
@Nor-Cal Refrigeration & H.V.A.C I put GoPros on my daughter's helmet, and she can run around for over an hour before the batteries die (the white batteries@2.7k:60)
@@MotoFamMayhem that’s awesome
@@NorCal-refrigerationnot at all a realistic approach 😂😂
Everybody watches videos on a 85” tv, really, totally ridiculous evaluation and the differences are marginal at best. There also both designed as Action cameras, picture quality is not their priority, ease of use and reliability are, there the Action wins hands down. Want picture quality use a heavy pro camera such as an SLR.
Outstanding review. I had the Hero 3 Black and never had a problem. The I finally bought the Hero 9 and right away experience the dreaded freeze up. I also did a 1 hour+, indoor, 4k recording test and no had problems but still felt it might be unreliable. I have the original dji Action and am considering getting the Action 3. Not willing to buy any more GoPro cameras. Its amazing how dji entered this action camera game only recently (May 2019) and is now kicking GoPro's butt.
I found your channel about 6 months ago when I first thought about getting an Action Camera. I had never heard of DJI Action Cameras at that time. But your first comparison vlog had me leaning towards DJI. I of course watched other vloggers comparing the same cameras. In the end, I finally decided to pull the trigger last week. For me this video is about 5 days to late, my camera will be here next Tuesday. I went for the DJI Osmo Action 3. Now I feel like I made the right decission!! The external microphones and the price where to 2 big factors for me. Thanks so much for your insightful videos. Moving on to deciding which accessory bundle to purchase and reviewing your video from last. Thanks again for your tutorials.
I was happy to see that blind test on the images and on the audio. That was I wasn’t swayed ahead of time. I did like the 11’s image a bit better but the battery and overheating that everyone talks about definitely has me leaning to the Action 3 I think. Thanks for the great video! 👊
I had the gopro hero 5, 7, 8 and 10 over the years and I had issues with all of them. I sold those other cameras and decided to try the A3 and I have not had a single issue with that camera. Not only that, I am a mobile editor and I use luma fusion on my m2 ipad pro to edit my videos. When plugging the A3 into my ipad, the files app recognizes it as a drive and it makes transfering files that much easier. With the hero 10 I had to either go thru the gopro app or I had to do it thru the photos app and that was always an extra step I had to take which I didn't like. I also have the dji mic system and that has been flawless as well. I am very happy with my action 3 but I am curious with what the hero 12 will be like. Its a shame we are coming up to 12 generations of the heros and yet those cameras still have issues while DJI is 3 gens in and they have pretty much made the A3 near perfect (at least for what I use mines for).
I’ll get. OA3 for sure. I prefer the warmer more vibrant colours in GoPro but the fact that I can change that in post and also not seeing them side by side means I’ll never know any different. Also the Adventure and platinum pack are so much better value in AUS.
I had the GO system forever. I didn’t have the 11 but had 2 GP 10 and all the stuff. I use mine professionally and the over heating crashing and having to dismantle it from the mod to pull battery and reset was hard on production. I picked up the DJI 3 and after a month or two using it extensively I put all of my GP gear on CL. I took a bath on it, but better than it growing old in a drawer. For me the GP isn’t even close for me extreme needs.😎🤙
This is an AWESOME NON-BIASED comparison! Excellent job!
I've been looking at action cameras as I transition my TH-cam channel into more outdoors videos. I was pretty much sold on a GoPro. Names been around forever. I've heard whispers of unreliability but nothing major. Just happened to stumble on this video and glad I did. After watching, I've spent the last 4 hours digging and found SO MANY GOPRO RELIABILITY complaints! Thank you for pointing that out! I struggle with Tech sometimes. If I had gotten a GOPRO and it failed, I would have thought it was my fault. And beat myself up for not knowing how to fix it.
I honestly can't thank you enough for making this video. You earned a lifelong subscriber here. And I'm definitely using your links to get a DJI
P.S. Your sound, video quality, and edits are smooth and seamless. GREAT JOB!
This is exactly what I was looking for. Was considering these two cameras 📷 Battery life is important to me. Over heating may be a bigger problem on hot days. I want a reliable camera that I know will work. 👍
Stoked you found it! If those two mean the most to you, then I think you know which way to go👍
@@DavidManningvlog Yup. Good to see them compared in such detail.
I switched to DJI after GoPro Hero 7 . My drones, action and pocket cameras are all DJI. I don't think I'll ever go back, although I just added an Insta360 X3 and a Feiyu Pocket 3 to my stable. Thanks for backing up what I have experienced. Also the ease of lens cover replacement and , for me, the ease of file movement to my laptop are a couple of more great reasons I prefer the Action 3
Hi David,
Some more thoughts to consider when buying either brand:
- Accessories. Most people have GP as it’s been around for awhile so starting new means, they can be reused especially for GP9/10/11 like Media Mod, Cage, etc. Can’t do that with A1/2/3 so we need to factor this into the total cost to be fully objective than just entry price; and
- Batteries. Stress test is nice but when I want continuous long form shooting both don’t cut it unless you use Volta or Ulanzi power banks + tripod legs and I don’t want to lug around extra batteries I will probably use so depends on your workflow; and
- Image Quality. The devil is in the details and hands down, GP11 is better for me.
Aside from this, we left the Elephant out of the room. What did DJI do for those who had the close focus quality issues? Like Gopro, nothing. Didn’t confirm or deny, just fixed it and kept quite to avoid lawsuits. So if you’re in that lot, I’m sure you will not be happy as well as the freezing issues over at Gopro. Both get thumbs down for this again trying to be fully objective for new buyers to know and now buy early models of A3.
The other thing is that for vlogging, DJI exposes the subject and blows out the background when switching between say in the forrest and back to sunlight, while GP seem to balance between subject and background. Check for yourself so depends on your use cases.
The other things not mentioned is photo quality, GPS, 8:7 to reframe portrait or landscape or re-crop, 360deg horizon lock in most shooting modes while DJI is limited to 2.7K. If these don’t matter in your workflow than DJI is the way to go;
- TCO. Total cost of ownership, where accessories is one but the big one is between new models, there’s no backward or forward compatibility not consistent drive price.
Meaning if you bought A1, it was good value for money and affordable. Then A2 was crazy high, completely different design, had overheating issues and got left behind after A3 was released, same chip and inside but repackaged but yet A3 got the 10bit upgrade, wtf DJI! And it cost way more than A3. So be like Sony and punish your loyal customers who spent more. Then you get the A3 which is more affordable but different design again. So if this trend stands and you upgrade, then expect A4 to cost more and a new design
I myself couldn’t decide and got the A3 (and previous pissed off A2 buyer) in Jan’23 to avoid the quality close focus issues only because Gopro ecommerce couldn’t let me buy the GP11 working overseas for some reason so their loss.
I’m a fan of tech so will load up where I can and both have major flaws and should go back to releasing every 2-3yrs so we get finished products instead of half baked ones and be guinea pigs and buy early and then get happy when they release firmware updates 3-6-9mos later when it should be there Day One.
I’m waiting more eagerly on both ZV-E1 to arrive and the P3 to release as I don’t do extreme or underwater sports as much these days.
Anyhow, good content as always and you covered most of the bases for new buyers to consider.
I agree with the rest, however image quality is very subjective. Because the sharpness and quality is top notch on both. But unless you plan on uploading your footage straight after recording it. The DJI’s more neutral color tones makes it easier to edit and correct post production. GoPro is better without editing, DJI is definitely better with editing.
Nice timing especially when I bought GoPro 11 few weeks earlier based on your previous review when you said GoPro was better :)
Hahhaa! Gahhhhh! An update just a little late! Like I say at the end of the video, the GoPro Hero 11 is still an incredible camera and super impressive in every area. You might just need to pickup a few extra batteries👍
This was SO enlightening! I was thinking of buying the Hero11, but I will now investigate lot into the Acton3. Thanks once again for a great video. Cheers from Lisbon!
12:47 Wait a second... it DIDN"T overheat? I am so confused. The Hero 11 I had never made it past 15 or so minutes at 4k 30fps.
Reason to buy the GoPro: higher resolution sensor. You can print photos larger or zoom in while editing video. Also 5.3K can give you a high resolution screen grab. Single door latch. One less point of failure. I read of several dji action 3 leaks while snorkeling. Even if the GoPro has a lower depth water resistance rating, the door seems to be better designed. The GoPro can be found for much less with frequent sales and with the subscription.
The dji has the advantages you mentioned, but it seems you ignored the GoPro qualities over the Action.
Resolution means nothing when the gopro constantly dies from overheating. Gopro resolution is zero.
@@kayakexcursions5570 never dies on me. Maybe you have a lemon or you live in the desert of Saudi Arabia. GoPro works for me great, for the size. Customer service has been very good when accidental damage happened. The Enduro battery works definitely better than the standard.
I have good resolution images of a sand tiger shark i came face to face with that i can print, as i was shooting 5.3K
With a lower res camera the stills would not be so good.
@@stefpix It literally died in his video. Gopros are garbage, they cant keep up other action cameras.
The dji looked good in the sunlight but completely fell apart when you went underwater and into the shadows. However, a lot of that can be fixed in post. The mic quality is trash tho. Not much you can do to fix that other than buying a seperate microphone
Dropped GoPros a long time ago for DJI, too many issues with software and over heating. Have the original Action, the original Pocket and the Action 3. I don’t use the Action underwater. The DJI mic is so good too, especially for vlogging and moto vlogging.
PS. The battery life is in a different league and there’s fast charging…
Gahhh! Totally forgot to mention Fast Charging! That's a huge plus!
I have been using GoPro for about 10 years now and I have gotten really familiar and used to it, I also have collected meany mounts and accessories for my GoPros over the years and I think I will stick with and continue to use GoPro because that is just what I am used to and have spent a lot of money and time on GoPro but I defiantly wanna try out other action cameras like the dji osmo action
After using the Osmo Action 1 for yrs it was a no brainer for me to get the action 3. I just waited for 8 months for DJI to get some bugs out of it via firm ware updates. The Action 3 will go give GoPro a run for their money in the coming three yrs if they do the same with Action 3 as they did with the Action 1. Keep on improving via firmware upgrades instead of releasing a new GoPro every 12 to 18 months
Is there a head strap for it? I'm considering getting a OS3.
Thanks David, I have been weighing up updating from my Hero 7 Black and this tips it over. I think I'll buy the DJI Action 3 and the DJI wireless microphone as a pair as it seems a worthwhile and faultless investment.
Great video. 👍
I use a GoPro 7 Black and have a 7 White as a back up. My camera has only bugged out on me once and only overheated once. Haven't had major issues at all. However, I am slightly unsatisfied with the Stabilization. Nothing serious. I also do very little editing and it took me a long time to find the camera setings I like, but I do use an auto color and brightness feature on my editing software.
What about the focus issues on the DJI that plagued the initial launch? I was all set to buy one on release, but then the reviews all complained about the focus being out of alignment!
All sorted now but it was over hyped…
I actually traded all my GoPro stuff out (except the Daytripper backpack) in favour of DJI Action 3 and Insta360 X2. Both are such amazing cameras and love the no wire mic (although I wished it mounted a bit better…looks kinda funky but hey…no wires).
B was better in many aspects but a few went to A. However I hate the delay when shooting with Go Pro. When diving I need instant on, marine life doesnt hold still and wait
I just found your channel after recently buying a gopro 11 and trying to get it up there with my cinema cameras color wise lol. Ive been using a wireless Lav kit like the DJI version and with GoPros media mod it's been flawless. the one thing that actually has helped immensely is the kit im using from Comica, the audio receiver is like almost half the size of the DJI one, so saves size and weight on the gopro 11. Keep creating dude! By buddy Josh told me he met you at NAB and are an awesome dude.
That's a killer setup you've got going brother! The Hero 11 is still a super impressive camera! Hoping that both companies keep up the competition and push each other to keep making better and better cameras for us!
So I don't own an action camera. If I were to buy one, I pick the Action 3. My fishing buddy uses a Gopro 9 (I think) that he mounts at the back of his flats boat and solo fish from the front of the boat. He turns on the recording on his GoPro with a remote control. I don't think the Action 3 has a remote control to turn on the Action 3 correct? Can you start recording using the external DJI mic you mention in your video? As always great comparison video David.
Time to redo this one already - Action 4. Can you please look at two additional scenarios? Scenario 1 - can both work externally powered without the batteries inside them? Scenario 2 - You'll need 4 cameras for this one; but can you pair two up (2 x DJI and 2 x GoPro) and control them with a remote control so that they start and stop video recording somewhat together? This is a multiple view of the same scene scenario where you want to start and stop the cameras together to capture the same scene. Scenario 3 - bonus scenario - do both have loop recording ability with said remotes, and here's the key, at what resolutions/frame rates (ideally all of them but I know GoPro doesn't work at all of them).
Can we get the Insta 360 vs DGI Action 3 video?
Thanks for a rigorous and convincing evidence-based comparison! I have been using GoPros for several years now, mainly for underwater filming (including several frustrations with GoPros freezing up while underwater), so I had already figured from published specifications and reviews that the DJI Osmo Action 3 will be my next camera (or perhaps an updated version if it comes out in the meantime). I also have a small DJI drone, which is excellent and totally reliable. So you have now reinforced my decision!
The focus issue of the Osmo Action 3 destroyed the camera.
Yeah too bad, I was about to buy the camera shortly after it come out but luckily some independent reviews pointed out the issue.
As I understand it fixed months ago…anything built in 2023 is fine. Still, an annoying start.
@@gordon3988 Just the fact that I need to check the production date of a product that cost hundreds of € for me it's a no go.
Both camera have advantages & disadvantage, OA3 are the best battery life time, ang not overheating, and have the best EIS rocksteady.. and the only issue are auto focus only but it's easy to fix on firmware update, while GoPro, has 5k resolution... But the issue is overheating, poor battery lifetime
So both action cam, are great...
@@JSF_1183 if a camera is out of focus you cannot fix it with a firmware update as proven but lots of independent reviews. More sharpening does not magically make a clip in focus.
When you press record, does it record? If so, the dji wins. It probably needs a very specific phone like every other product they make.
OA3 user here, bought it last december,amazing camera.friendly user, no lagging,extraordinary magnetic mount, the battery life and price factor, definitely it will be the new king of action cameras😊
GoPro provides best image quality and best features. This sounds like an add for dji.
And what about the elephant in the room….. focus
In your comparison and others, I definitely like GoPro video better (but, yes, it's not a huge difference). I recently upgraded to the Hero 11 from a 10, however if 1. I had not gotten the GoPro, with an extra battery, for $300 and 2. I didn't already have a bunch of GoPro accessories (including the dome, which wasn't cheap) and most important 3. I have not experienced the bugginess/overheating that so many other people have (don't know if it's just dumb luck or what I use it for, hopefully I haven't now jinxed myself for saying it), I would have went with the DJI, the connection system is so much more convenient, battery is way better, no bugginess, just better overall except for slightly lower video, and I have a DJI drone, which I love. Next upgrade I will probably switch to DJI, it just sucks when you have so much money invested in a brand that can't be used with another one. Oh well, the grandkids will be thrilled when they get a free GoPro 😁
I LOVE the GoPro 11 picture quality and I own 3, - one regular and two minis. I've had to return & exchange 2 different minis in less than 6 months due to battery issues. And even tho I'm a member and GoPro says that includes "No-questions-asked camera replacement," I was asked questions for a half hour or more each time! I deal with shut downs from over-heating regularly and often retrieve the camera and find that the last 20 minutes of awesome footage I believed I got does not exist because it shut down for one reason or another. When David said "BUGGINESS" I was like, "YES! EXACTLY!" I love these cameras even with their faults but I will be purchasing DJI from now on and use these GoPros if I specifically need the image quality the GoPros excel at (more contrast, saturation, and 5.3K).
Also, David, it does sound like you are saying DGI instead of DJI but it literally sounds like that in every TH-cam video that anyone does for some reason, so don't sweat it.
My man David coming through again! I need a helmet cam for biking and wasn't sure which cam is better for my use. Got the DJI on the way!
Widest field of view in the game right now!
I have two GoPros, and it seems that even in the 11th generation, the issue of having to remove the battery from time to time when using QuickCapture has not been resolved. If you can't trust your camera to do its job properly, the image quality becomes futile
Thanks for a great comprehensive comparison between these two cameras! I'm SO GLAD you addressed the Overheating issue finally at 12:57! THIS is why I'm here, to see of the Osmo has any overheating issues...and you cleared it up for me, thank you!!!
About 07:42 - Bugginess - I'm really surprised that I I didn't hear you say in THIS chapter about overheating (this is where I was first looking for your comments on overheating), because my GoPro 10 overheats EVERY SINGLE USE after 5-20 min at 4k60fps AND 30fps (NOT 120! I don't even bother with 120 since 30-60 is so bad!). To me, that is by FAR the BIGGEST bug of any GoPro in this range! And other TH-camr's videos show this as an issue with ALL gopros in this number range.
BUT, that's why I'm looking to switch to the Osmo, because nobody says it ever overheats...right?
I chose the GoPro hero 11, after watching many videos. It’s not perfect but in my opinion it was the better of the 2.
Love hearing that Steve! Like I mention, it's very subjective in which of the two you like best. I will say that when not viewing them side by side, it would be difficult to say which is which. But the side by side makes it pretty evident
@@DavidManningvlog I already have a GoPro hero seven black which has 12 megapixels so it’s somewhat similar to having the Osmo action 3. I also like the hero 11’s, Horizon Lock and menu better. I just ordered two more batteries so now I have six lol. btw it does sound like you are saying DGI oh well
Looking forward to getting an Action 3. But not until my Action1 gets lost or stolen. The way it's going I will have to wait years before it wears out. DJI makes great stuff.
Have used both to live stream softball games, RTPM does not work on the DJI. Had numerous conversations with their tech support, their solution was that the camera I had was bad. Exchanged it for a new one, same issue. Did this twice. I now use the GoPro for live stream and the DJI for everything else.
"the video quality is almost identical" cracked me up. Just take ONE look at the surface textures on the dji and you'll see there's almost no detail compared to the Gopro.
See, that's where preference comes into play. The GoPro for sure has a more crispy and textured look, but many people see that as over-sharpened and digital. If you appreciate that look though, for sure the GoPro is the way to go👍
@@DavidManningvlog sharpness and details are 2 different things. The GoPro video is objectively more detailed. The oversharpening can easily be corrected in the settings, after all there's 3 steps available but even without the sharpening there's still more detail and also way better exposure. The dji still tends to blow out highlights, one thing that's super obvious on my dji pocket 2, and it's still present on the action 3. The gopro footage is way more balanced.
About bugginess, it's actually very stable as long as it doesn't overheat which it still does in 5.3k60. I can use the hero 3h+ hooked up to my powerbank and record my bike ride without any issues, but after 30-35 minutes in 5k it overheats.
I've not had any stability issues besides the overheating which still is a bummer for sure and the strong point for the action. But most people won't use it like that.
For my bike rides the Gopro was definitely the better choice, I want to see the road texture, which the action simply doesn't show
@@TheNitpicker I was hoping someone would point this out in the comments. I can understand if someone prefers a more cinematic look compared to a super-sharp digital image. However, sharpness is an entirely difference issue compared to detail. All the way through his comparison shots, the Camera B video had FAR more detail and texture everywhere. I recorded a bunch of screen shots just to confirm this to myself. In the closer shots, on Camera B, you can see all the beard stubble on David's face. On Camera A, there is none at all. It's just smooth, blurry skin. In all the shots on cement or gravel with brick walls in the background, Camera B shows tons of detail. You see all the gravel and the texture of the cement and the detail in the walls and in the bushes and trees and even in his clothing. The Camera A footage of those same shots has no detail at all. Stop the video at the point when David is with one of his daughters on the slide, and you can see tons and tons of detail in the Camera B footage. His beard stubble and skin texture is so clear. And his daughter's hair looks great. But the Camera A footage has no detail at all. His skin is just smooth white space. The same for all the background gravel and cement and foliage. And the Camera A footage was almost always slightly out of focus and blurry.
I had no idea which camera was A and which was B when I watched the comparison, but the B footage was SO much better. Like you, I was astonished when David started his discussion by saying that the image quality from the two was identical. I have no idea how he could come to that conclusion. There was such a large difference. And it has nothing to do with sharpness or any kind of "over sharpened" GoPro look. It was all about simple detail and texture and focus and a balanced exposure. It's not like Camera B recorded sharpened beard stubble and gravel and Camera A recorded more cinematic, unsharpened beard stubble and gravel. In the Camera A footage, there simply was no beard stubble or gravel. It just recorded smooth surfaces with little to no detail at all.
There are still lots of reasons for someone to buy the Action 3 over the Hero 11. David listed a bunch of those: cheaper price; less buggy; the quick switch button; the ability to see the video on the smartphone app while you are recording; better battery life; the magnetic mounting system; etc. And perhaps all of that is enough for some people to outweigh the issue of video quality. I can understand that. But to say that the sample video clips in this Camera A vs Camera B comparison are identical is really quite strange. They weren't even close to identical. I'm not sure how David can't see that. He's usually pretty reliable in his video reviews and comparisons.
David's conclusion was that it all comes down to preference in terms of which look you prefer and that some people like the "over sharpened" GoPro look. But that seems like an inaccurate conclusion. I didn't see a difference in sharpness. I just saw lots of detail in the Camera B footage while the Camera A footage had smooth surfaces with very little detail.
@@PlanetDoug Yes IQ wins out for me every time.
In my opinion GoPro 11 footage looks way better but stabilisation seems better on the Action 3. Overall DJI wins but I hope they improve the image quality for version 4.
the only problem of my DJI A3 is highlight. Always blown out 😆😆 but never regret choosing the A3
I’ve been using my Gopro hero 9 for two years and I am so happy with it. I barely had any issues with it. I know the Action 3 looks better but I still prefer to get a Gopro. Will see what changes with gopro hero 12
well I would still go for the gopro as I saw the huge difference under water.
Battery isnt a deal at all for most people, I carry my reserve battery around the whole vacation and never need it. price of the gopro is the real disadvantage
I've been using an Action 3 for all my cycling videos. It is a joy to use compared with my old GoPro 10. It has terrific stabilization. I've never had any overheating issues - ever - and the battery lasts much longer.
A
B - Fair review. Nicely done and your process is the same as I would have done. Thanks for sharing
In those first side-by-side comparison videos, which color setting did you use for the Gopro? I find the "vibrant" setting gives more of that "Gopro look" and looks more like the Action 3, while the "natural" setting looks overall crisper.
Also - a big tell which camera is which in the side-by-side's, is the distans to the object, the Gopro is much more "close-up" than the Action 3!
I love how every GoPro owner knows exactly what you mean the second you say "the GoPro Freeze".
So glad I watched this before buying the gopro. I'm moving to the Philippines later this year to start vlogging and you convinced me to get a better option for less money!
Welcome to the Philippines. 😊
Just need to adjust the color a little when shooting underwater footage I guess if I get the DJI.
I could tell the difference and absolutely like Cam B. The Action3 is still out of focus and it shows. Glad I went GoPro. However if you not quite as critical or perhaps no way to compare then it may not matter to many.
Hero 11 looks a little better color wise but I can make the DJI look more like the hero in post, but without them being side by side I wouldn’t be able to tell. I love love love the DJI working with the DJI wireless…….I really want an insta360 X3, or a good action camera to the mix. Maybe one day lol 😂 Great video as always!!
I’m buying an action camera for my daughter and really appreciated your comparison review. Not knowing anything about action cameras it was very helpful
I have the GoPro 11 and use the DJI wireless mikes. Love the combo. But I've had a few bugs with the GoPro. Maybe I'll go all DJI on the next setup.
Yes, the DJI Mic is easier to use with the DJI Mic, BUTTTT with the Media Mod, it can be used on the GoPro too.
I got a lot of family trips planned this summer. Thanks for making my decision easier!
David thanks for the video. Timely in my case. I have the DJI Osmo Action and I love it but I’m thinking I need to upgrade to the 3. First, I use it while cycling and I bought 3 1300mAh batteries to help extend battery life. I’m on the bike sometimes for 2-3 hours and the batteries just don’t last. DJI says that’s about as good as it gets for the Osmo Action. Second, I have a front and rear mount on my bike and it’s helpful to glance at my phone (also on a mount) to see what the camera sees, especially when using the rear mount. It’s very helpful to see traffics coming up from behind. The bugaboo is the battery and SD card indicator font is so small I can’t see it while riding. I asked DJI if font could be increased and they said no. No way I can do it on my iPhone 13 either. Don’t know if this would be any better with the Action 3 but thought I’d check with you to get your thoughts.
I use a GoPro 10 to record all of my sons’ baseball games. Recording at 4k/120 with out overheating would be incredible! I think I need to pick up a DJI set up. It would be awesome if DJI would talk to the Travel ball community, it’s a huge market.
I actually like the colors in camera B; now back to the video
I use a rode wireless with my GoPro hero 9. With snap mounts. It all works well together. But it seems like DJI has came along ways.
I bought the Hero 11 back in December and I havent had to pull the gopro reset once, I used to have a hero 4 silver which needed that a lot. I also havent had any overheating or freezing problems, its been at -30 C all the way up to 50 C here in Dubai. I personally havent had any experience with the action 3 but people tend to hate on the gopro for no reason.
for no reason? my gopro11 broken 2 times and can't find any after-sales service
I would've loved to see the Insta360 One RS to be included in this line-up, as I am currently debating getting either the DJI or the One RS.
Perhaps a video in the future?
I was so wishing that the Action 3 had the better video quality in your comparison. I'm so disappointed in GoPro bringing out a new model each year that doesn't address the performance and reliability issues of the prior year model. If the Action 3 had the better video quality then it would be my next action camera.
Pretty much preferred camera A, though both were fine and very close.. B looked a little too dark at times on your face, but I preferred it’s FOV. Didn’t see either freeze up so maybe neither was really the GoPro? 😊. Now I get to see. As for audio, if you want good audio in wind you have going to have to mic up. Looking forward to the results!
Going on a family vacation to Florida next week. Thx for helping me make my final decision!
The GoPro. From the first second to the last. One reason! It was actually in focus! I guess if you want a blurry camera with better battery life and nicer touch screens go with the Action 3. If you want in-focus footage, GoPro.
Before even watching the video, thanks for your follow up game, its greatly appreciated as someone who rarely buys when something first comes out but is always looking for the device to get better over time.
I can’t wait to get rid of my GoPro. I carry one for my landscape photography channel - so I am often out in cold climates. The GoPro just can’t handle it well. Once it gets to around 20F or so, battery life is non-existent, cameras shuts off - none of the other cameras had that issue in the same trip.
On another trip to RMNP a friend loaned me the 1st gen DJI and I took my GoPro Hero 10 as well. The GoPro was terrible once again, no battery life at all, shutdowns, unusable. The DJI ran the whole time - no issues.
The next time I’m in the market for an action cam, I’ll be going DJI.
A. You sold me on it. I guessed and got them right. Aside from underwater, all the punchiness of B is easy to get in editing. B's sound is better, but I'd not be using the camera's sound. Thanks for the effort on the review 😀
Totally agree Christopher, now that they're both on 10-Bit, there's quite a bit more adjusting that you can do in post with them. And in listening back, it does sound like the GoPro's audio is better right out of the box, but man does that wireless mic make life easy with the Action 3🙌
Does the GoPro lock up issue still happen when using a scandisk extreme pro micro SD card?
I like the GoPro look & recording quality more but it did look like it cropped the image in more.
I like the idea of only recording once in the 8:7 & then having the option to edit in post.
Having extra batteries is not a big issue for me as you could get the Volta also if required.
Hopefully the version 12 will be more stable, better battery life, less over heating, a front touch screen, bigger rear screen, quick switch button & the option of using usb c mics directly without the media mod.
I’m thinking of waiting until the GoPro 12 comes in September/October time
Was looking for an updated video. Been eyeing the Action 3. Excellent video thanks fir addressing the lesser discussed like bugginess, etc.
I have a GOPRO Hero 10, used it for about a year, no issue, then one day at the beach, got water inside, got a replacement had to pay the 100 bucks, get the new one, after a dip at the beach, water inside.. Not Diving, just at the surface. I have a DJI action one, and has NEVER had an issue. I like the colors better on the Gopro, actually loved it. But I'm done with GOPRO, I'm getting an Action 3... Also, DJI has AMAZING customer care, Gopro is a mission to get a replacement, took me almost a month had to send them pictures, etc.. DJI just sends the replacement right away, then you ship the old one.
David, can you make a tutorial, how you color correct Go pro footage!?Please, it is sometimes pretty difficult to get natural colors
yes I have heard the battery and heating problem with gopro for a long time wIt it out and watch this review. It seem it doesn't go away. so sad. I like color from gopro but for reliability definitely has to go with Dji A3 for sure.😊
You can use the DJI microphone on the GoPro just as you can on any camera so that’s not a one up
Can you do a video addressing the Action 3 focus issue, what manufactured dates affected, etc. I think it would also get good views!
DJI still the best for me...until now i still use the DJI action cam one and I dont experience any late recording, press record and it records right away, battery still last longer than the go pro. DJI is still the KING since day 1 they released the first action cam 🙂
Camera B seems a bit sharper in dark.
I'm surprised that the DJI's footage is wider. How about the performance in slightly darker conditions? Which has less noise and can stabilise better?
Camera B hands down had better clarity, better near and far focus/sharpness, better colors, better dynamic range, more contrast, and the underwater color looked waaaaay more natural with her skin tone than A. The wind sucked on both but on B it didn't sound like a blown out speaker where... A did! I'm crossing my fingers B is the GoPro because that's what I have but even still my GoPro doesn't look like Camera A did in these shots so there's that! Hahahaha Woooohoo it was the GoPro!!! Next point of fairness, YOU CAN PUT THE RODE WIRELESS GO II ON THE GoPro so don't be trying to act like DJI has a leg up with audio there! In the final aspect of this, I would 100% buy the Hero 11 again and again! I'll take less battery life and shorter stress testing in lieu of significantly better image quality and performance! Knock on wood, I have yet to experience any buggy issues with my Hero 11 but I'm also not using it as any form of an A cam so it doesn't get pushed as a main cam would nor should it.
All solid points Mike and stoked that you picked out the GoPro correctly! The Rode Wireless GO II works great on the GoPro, but in comparison to the DJI Wireless mic setup, the ease of use goes to DJI. With my GoPro, I need the MediaMod, then the Wireless GO with a cable running into the media mod. It's a great solution and sounds awesome, but the DJI Wireless mic plugs straight into the camera and overall I like the DJI Wireless mic system over the Rode Wireless. The thing is, this comparison is like comparing a camera that's 94% fantastic to one that's 98% fantastic. You really can't go wrong either way in my opinion!
@DavidManningvlog You can see the video being recorded on the GoPro app as long as the quility being filmed is 1080p / 30fps or lower I think
No need to remove the battery to reset a GoPro. You hold the power button pressed for 10 or 15 seconds and press again. Camera reboots. no need to remove the battery, so you can do it during a dive. The Hero 11 only froze once in 6 months for me. No issues.
I've had two action 3 cameras. Both of them drop a few frames every time it splits the videos into multiple files. Easy to spot when using it to record music. Very discouraging.
Awesome as always David,. Love your work. 😊
The wireless mic is nice and all but I would love to know if there is a different mic solution like the one from the DJI (DGI) Action 1, nothing will beat that that slim design adaptor. The ability to have pass through power while driving is a nice thing to have if battery life is a concern.
I just bought the Action 3 and waiting on it to be delivered. Can’t wait! Thanks for all the great info.
I love my GP 11 and I stress the hell out of it. I have broken several GoPro in the past and I gotta say, their “insurance” program is way better than DJI and that is the selling point for me. I don’t have to worry about breaking my camera while scuba diving, which is my main activity with it. I’ve had replaced 3 cameras with 0 fee. I’m based in Costa Rica and covering the shipping it has never been a problem for GoPro. While DJI, has always giving me headaches in regards to their warranty and insurance programs since I am not in the USA. Both cameras are amazing, it all comes to personal preference and what matters the most for you.
Its a win win for us, two great action cams. Competition is good. Either way one can't go wrong. I own the GoPro but would have been satisfied with the Osmo.
i have bad experience with gopro battery.. i bought original gopro 9 battery before, had 6 of them.. within 6 months, without any extensive use, 5 of them easily bulged and swelled.. their battery are not cheap though.. thats the only reason i decided stop using a gopro and change to other.. if battery is not the issue, they are fantastic..
get the enduro batts, they're wayyyy better and i film anything from -20 to +30 deg weather
I had the exact same experience. I've spent a fortune on batteries for my GoPro Hero 9. In a very short time, all of the batteries swelled up and I had to throw them away and buy new ones. I've lost count of how many batteries I've gone through. I could have bought an entire camera for the price of those batteries. Now, I've replaced them all with the new white Enduro batteries. I'm hoping that they won't swell up like the old ones did.
Not hard to tell as far as video quality goes, picked out the DJI right away, there was no 'tie' in the video quality... The shadows are still just mushy and muddled for the DJI. For me video wins over all, I never run my camera long enough for the over heating to be a problem. But I can totally see how someone that does vlogging prefer the DJI as they may have clips that running longer.
Just got a Hero 11 in Whistler. It’s awesome.
Thanks for the vid, I checked them out last fall but didn't hear much since.. As a pilot who uses cams on the outside of the plane I would much rather have the DJI, my gopro's stop working and never last in cold weather. Plus the no remote with preview really bad, I'd like to see on my phone if my shot is still good. Not like I can get out of the plane midflight to check it out.. LOL
Yeah, for use cases like that, the Action 3 is 100% the way to go👍
@@DavidManningvlogCan you confirm that if you buy a osmo action 3 now it will not have the focus issue.. Thanks.. Keep seeing people very confused on this issue, I thought it was fixed 6 months ago.
The RockSteady +plus is another update which is better then GoPro omp
A couple of things I'd like to add from my own experiences of using both cameras. Battery life is definitely one area where the Action 3 excels. However, you can get a significant boost to battery life with the the GoPro by turning off the wireless function when you don't need it. I was told recently by one GoPro athlete that it can be as much as 30% more, and certainly, I've noticed a huge difference by doing this.
Overheating: I often use action cameras to film my kayak freestyle practice so I can judge what I'm doing wrong and make corrections. When I was doing this in the swimming pool over winter, I've often left my GoPro running with Hypersmooth turned off and it's never overheated. Amazingly, it was the Action 3 that shut down from overheating! I wasn't expecting that.
One other thing that you can add to the Action 3 benefits is the ultra-wide lens that doesn't need a dynamic stretch mode like Hyperview. Overall I still prefer my Hero11 day-to-day as I prefer the image quality, and I don't like that I can't adjust the sharpness setting on the Action 3. But, damn, the ultra-wide on the Action 3 is to die for and is incredible for POV shots. I really hope that GoPro has something similar up its sleeve for the HERO12.
There is one last thing you could have included on the list. And that's a consideration in choice if you are a true power user, for example the highly customisable Labs firmware for the GoPro.
But yeah, it's a very tough call, and it's undeniable that the Action 3 is a very serious rival to the GoPro and offers amazing value for the money as well. But, it's all good in my eyes because it spurs GoPro on to make the next camera even better, followed by DJI etc, and so the cycle continues. We all benefit. As for being mad at your decision? Nah, that was a really good, considered video, dude.
I don't care how many different setting you choose to use, the GoPro should simply work and it simply does not. GoPro SUX!
I had the go pro once never again I bought the dji action again after my original had water damage (my fault) dji is amazing