Doctor Who 10x13 SPECIAL REACTION!! "Twice Upon a Time"
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 ก.พ. 2020
- Eric Shane Calvin and Aaron react to and discuss season 10 episode 13 of Doctor Who - Christmas Special - Twice Upon a Time #DoctorWho
Vote in our polls and see certain Blind Wave videos early!! / blindwave
Blind Wave is Sponsored on Patreon by:
Keyboard Junkie
Website www.blindwave.net
Twitter : / blindwaveprod
FaceBook : / blindwaveproductions
Twitch: / blindwave
Discord: / discord
Snapchat: blind_wave
Subreddit: / blindwave
Send us Stuff at: P.O. Box 304 Marietta, OH 45750 - บันเทิง
Watch next week's Reaction to Doctor Who 11x1 "The Woman Who Fell to Earth" Early HERE: www.patreon.com/posts/33766232
Please also react to Honest Trailer for new who and classic who.
I think the reason the new doctor became a woman is cause most of the real strong characters are women, take the mars queen she wanted bill"s intake on what to do and not the doctors' and when clara did what she did to save her doctor. or when martha went around the world to help the doctor, or rose being rose and turning into the bad wolf to save the doctor. and yeah donna how she helped the doctor not become someone he would hate to be, and donna saving the doctor again.
Don't react to this sjw propaganda it sucks.
@@nikoskn1252 Brace yourselves we have the 9000 iq anti-sjws who think female lead is propaganda
Awesome thumbnail! :)
The Thirteenth Doctor's First-Words should have been: 'Still Not Ginger!'
Hey, if anyone's interested, I'm reviewing all the Doctor Who stories on my channel, with me just having uploaded my review of: 'Death To The Daleks (1974)!' No pressure, of-course; It just might be worth checking out! :)
"To be fair, they cut out all the jokes!" is the most underrated line in the whole episode!
I prefer his comment on the rug Bill had bought him 🤣
I was expecting the reaction for "I am younger!" lol
But also Bill's line: "long story short, i totally pulled"
@@JuanSam I don't remember that line, but that's probably because I don't understand what it means. So it didn't stick.
@@firefly24601 it's just slang that means "getting lucky" with someone
"Clara had a crazy last second of her life"
oh my god I never thought about that haha
I also like that this episode confirms that Clara did, in fact, eventually return to Trap Street to die seeing as she has a glass avatar at her current age.
But did she remember her adventures?
@@BlueSparxLPs was that a glass version of Clara? or did the glass Bill unlock the Doctor's memories leading to a vision of Clara? Doc even says he has his memories back.
@@donaldwatson7698 Maybe it's a bit ambiguous in the episode itself, but the episode as written is that Clara appears to the Doctor as a glass avatar. The more "dreamlike" feel to the scene occurs on-screen because Jenna Coleman couldn't appear on that set to film at the time and had to be green-screened in later.
Blue Sparx I always assume she went back because the universe hasn’t collapsed yet haha
TARDIS: “Ok, Doctor, you know the drill, time to redecorate, OUT”
Or redress, the TARDIS definitely doesn't like to be naked in front of the Doctor xD
Yep let me just grow some weird looking crystal thingys that bob up and down
Duolingo I love the crystal thingies. What are the crystal thingies?
No idea.
@@Jim_The_Fish Nah let's stick to the round things xD
@@avocadothecat what are the round things?
As soon as Bill said, "I'll prove to you how important memories are," I just lost it, I knew what was coming. I still cry every time I see it.
Me too
Same. It gets me everytime.
I was so happy that he remembered Clara in the end. I did not see that coming.
Although Matt Smith remains my favourite Doctor, I have nothing but love and respect for Peter Capaldi and what he achieved in this role. This was a beautiful send off to a wonderful character.
You have made it. You can finally watch the honest trailer.
Gonna be great!
Both of them preferably!
@@kellykat3554 You are bad
@@LordMooshroom no u
up
Farewell Twelve. Some criticized 'Twice Upon a Time' for being too indulgent, or “for having no plot”, but all it’s meant to be is a coda; a short reflection on change, death and the nature of memory, and as that, it works perfectly. Together with 'World Enough and Time/The Doctor Falls', these last three episodes were the best farewell for a Doctor yet, and a fitting one for a phenomenal Doctor. For me, Peter Capaldi's very flawed and insecure, yet kind and wise Twelfth Doctor was my ideal kind of Doctor and will always be my personal favourite. Capaldi got to live his lifelong dream of becoming the Doctor, and he delivered a portrayal that will forever be remembered for many years to come. I still miss him deeply, just like you would miss a very dear friend who will always be with you.
Too bad it doesn't work as a competent episode of television.
My family laughed when Capaldi regenerated. Only hardcore fans liked this episode.
@@LiveHedgehog Hardcore fans were pissed at the character assassination of the first Doctor. I was also pissed at how insanely drawn out Capaldi's regeneration was. I just didn't care when he did because I did all my mourning in the six months he took to regenerate. I do miss when the Doctor could just change without there being some big drawn out thing about it.
Anyone who doesn't appreciate this episode can get fucked. It's such a wonderful story.
@@cameroncaws8506 what character assassination do you speak of? I have seen all of Hartnell's episodes and I completely disagree with your assessment.
@@lostfremen lol no it isn't. It's awful.
The editing at the beginning of the Hartnell to David Bradley was done by the fan who did the most famous wholock fanvid
He also did the opening black hole sequence in "World Enough And Time" too. Amazing how they hired someone who created stuff for fun to end up working on the show. The production team did know about him for a while before from TH-cam and invited him to set, he likes to remain rather anonymous I believe in public.
@@fleason771 Adding onto this, Capaldi's title sequence was also a sort of remix of a fan title sequence. They brought the fan who created it on to make a version that kept the spirit of the fan version, but was more themed toward what they wanted for the Twelfth Doctor.
John Smith?
I will always remember when The Doctor was Peter Capaldi. He was my Doctor, he was my warrior, he was my hero, and I didn't want him to go.
Aaron's almost crying face absolutely destroys me
"She's gonna regenerate quick" lol Eric 😂😂😂
Shame she didn't tbh.
@@thedoctorgeneric5007 should have expected that comment really shouldn't I
@@thedoctorgeneric5007 that was my immediate reaction to when he said that 😂
@Doctor Tophat You have a terrible terrible taste if you think that... its the worse rated season in DW history. Just as bad as the last one. ZERO respect for Doctor Who, retconing and ignoring everything that been established before not to mention terrible, terrible writing that was dumbed down so much that no one is watching it anymore lol
I was a huge DW fan for years but now? They might as well cancel it at this point, I don't even care.
Doctor Tophat, there's only been one decent episode (Episode 5) and that's the only episode that feels like previous eras. The rest have been as bad as S11.
Another thing to keep in mind is that Peter himself grew up watching Doctor Who in the 60s and was a hardcore fan during those early years, so the fact that he goes back to the First Doctor's last story and has an extra adventure alongside him must be such an experience. Like Eric said, this is really good for classic fans who have stayed and cared for so long, but that also includes Capaldi and I can't imagine how awesome must that feel.
The weird old timey bigoted jokes they gave to the First Doctor were a big miss for me though.
Jokes are jokes.
Well, the jokes serve multiple functions. They serve to indicate how far removed One is from Twelve, to foreshadow the coming of Jodie Whittaker and give a different dynamic to the Doctor, as he’s at the same time in awe of him but also kind of embarassed. Isn’t that how we would act if we would be face to face with our kid selves? Maybe canonically there are some discrepancies, but damn it does make a good story. It shows how much the Doctor has changed, keeps changing, how change can be good. Doctor Who is a show that constantly changes after all. “We’re all different people throughout our lives” Matt Smith said in his final speech. For better and for worse.
I remember Peter saying in conventions (during series 8 and 9) that the villain he'd like his Doctor to face most were the original Cybermen. Moffat obliged. :)
Some of the bigoted First Doctor lines were not originally given to him by Moffatt; the Doctor actually said them in episodes in the 60s. I can clearly remember him threatening Susan with giving her a jolly good "smacked bottom." I can't remember which other lines Hartnell spoke, but many lines we now see as grumpy, cantankerous and tolerable because it's a black and white episode in the 60s, really do stand out when put in a contemporary setting. I do think there were too many of them in this episode, though.
@@michaeldeboer9940 My problem is not with the purpose they served, but with what the lines themselves were. They were jokes in bad taste. Given that is subjective, but I don't think threading that line should be a thing you go for to begin with. You didn't mind them? That's good, I'm glad for you. Other people did though.
Also I don't think reducing the First Doctor to "well grandpa always says sexist shit at dinner, please don't mind him" is in any way doing him justice. Kind of the opposite really.
@@michaeldeboer9940 I'm embarrassed at myself from 2 weeks ago, for ever saying 1984 was anything near a Good book.
Saying goodbye to Capaldi for the third time. First by myself, then with Merlon and now with the crew. It’s true, it doesn’t get easier. I’m crying again
Melron*
The First Doctor
Lethbridge-Stewart
Clara Oswald
Rusty The Dalek
Twelve's GOODBYE, and Thirteen's baptism by fire. BRILLIANT, indeed ❤
Shame it didn’t carry on in this vein, and between 13 and the new direction her “baptism” may as well have doubled as a funeral for the entire series
@MarvelDC girl 1255643 2354 No she is not. There is a lot wrong with the new season.
Parker Groseclose yeah but it’s not her that’s the problem it’s the writing
@@desmondpoppy4511 I'd argue its both, but I don't know. I don't really like how she plays the Doctor, but I don't know if its because of the writing or her acting. She may be awesome if she had a decent script as a foundation, but she doesn't so I have judge based off what we have. And what we have is disappointing.
Parker Groseclose just going by season 11, then yeah I’d agree. But she’s much better in season 12 imo
No more Murray Gold's music will leave a void in my heart
Twelve’s last speech always gets me
Ya, that's why it pissed me off they decided to skip it all in this reaction!
@@SGK1206 what about 'never be cruel, never be cowardly, hatred is always foolish and love is always wise?' THAT was what i was complaining about, the children thing is cute, but unnecessary, THAT was the bulk of this speech and it was omitted.
@@SGK1206 The children part was added in because of Peter specifically. In a q&a a young fan asked if Peter knew The Doctor's name, and he replied with almost the same thing.
This to me, is one of the most underrated Christmas specials of all time with so many people saying it didn't need to exist, but my gosh, that ending and the Doctor's speech. peter really sells his age in that one speech right before he goes back into the tardis.
The problem is that the Doctor Falls was the perfect ending. No fuss, no sappy speech, just the Doctor dying heroically without hope without witness without reward. Then we had to wait 6 months to watch them milk the regeneration so hard that I stopped caring. I did all my mourning six months before he changed.
@@lucasdolding6924 A Christmas Special didn't seem necessary at all considering that Chibnall instantly dropped the.
Matt Cybus Agreed. This is one of my favorite episodes actually.
22:20 it wasn't 700th episode, because the episode which was 709 episodes ago was hartnells last. You have to add up all the hartnell episodes, so plus 131.
Time of the Doctor is episode 800, so this will be 840, as Capaldi has 40 episodes. The show currently has 857 episodes, as of the most recent episode.
The 709 specifically refers to _The Tenth Planet_ part 1, which is the 131st episode overall. As the number fades it starts showing clips of parts 2 and 3, then reconstructed scenes from part 4, of which only the regeneration scene and a few other clips survive. _Twice Upon a Time_ is the 840th episode.
I went to the comments specifically hoping someone would address this so that I wouldn't have to. So thank you for that.
Can't believe we've already gotten to this point
All downhill from here 🤣
@@ChrisInScotland sigh. Yeah, season 11 is a bit of a hard watch. At least seaosn 12 has some stuff to like. Not a lot, but some.
@@ChrisInScotland Nah, Series 12 has been a big improvement so far.
Sooner or later, everything has to come to an end.
And here we are.
i cant believe this is the last Blindwave DrWho video ill be watching. Loved their reactions to the show.
We've seen a Time Lord refusing to regenerate and die. Remember when the Master refused to regenerate out of spite.
Wish 12 had refused to regenerate
@@morningcoffeecat2271 ok boomer
To the boomer, series 11 wasn't great.
But if you can't see the series 12 has improved, you can't see the forest for the trees. Or maybe a better analogy would be the river for the pond.
@@sayurimmiranda im younger than you🤔
@@hichaelmartline Honestly, I absolutely hated series 11, but 12 is a lot more interesting, to say the least. That new twist really does slaughter doctor who lore but, either way still loved it.
Goodbye to my favourite Doctor
709 episodes ago refers to the last Hartnell episode. Hartnell had appeared in well over 100 episodes prior to that episode. So the 700th episode of Doctor Who is actually Aliens of London with Christopher Eccleston. The series is now past 850 episodes
"If you call it the time war one." There were several time wars, it is call the last time war, so there were others.
To be more specific it's the "Last Great Time War", so in theory, there could be more time wars, just smaller scale time wars.
It’s actually called “The Third and Last Great Time War” in an episode.
The last episode of Doctor Who
When Clara appeared out of nowhere I actually just burst into tears. I was bawling and I hadn't expected it.
Rest now 12th, may the flight of not weeping angels look over you in paradise. You were truly Heaven Sent.
"Oh, there it is. Silly old universe. The more I save it the more it needs saving. It’s a treadmill. Yes, yes I know they’ll get it all wrong without me.
"Well, I suppose….one more lifetime won’t kill anyone. Well, except me.
"You wait a moment, Doctor. Let’s get it right. I’ve got a few things to say to you. Basic stuff first.
"Never be cruel, never be cowardly. And never ever eat pears! Remember - hate is always foolish…and love, is always wise.
"Always try, to be nice and never fail to be kind. Oh, and….and you mustn’t tell anyone your name. No-one would understand it anyway. Except….
"Except….children. Children can hear it. Sometimes - if their hearts are in the right place, and the stars are too. Children can hear your name. But nobody else. Nobody else. Ever.
"Laugh hard. Run fast. Be kind.
"Doctor - I let you go."
A bit drawn out, as final speeches go, but still decent.
Gets me every time
The master refused to regenerate after his “wife” shot him.
You'd think by now the Doctor would have gotten down "Land first, *then* regenerate..."
It’s really weird how excited I am to them seeing Jodie even though I didn’t find her first series particularly good. Although the new series with her is much better
aamj 00 I just hope I can keep up, since I’ve only watched one episode of her run so far, I gotta go.
I excited to see how much they hate it cause the quality of writing goes down so much that its hard to watch... I was a huge fan of DW but at this point I don't care anymore. They might as well cancel it and I would be fine with that...
@@Pir-o im excited to see them enjoy it personally, because they probably will.
@@Pir-o same man i'm done watching until chris chibnall is gone and the bbc change the way the show is going cause its absolute shit i dont watch doctor who just so i can know how shit the real world is i watch it because its fun and i dont think about the real world for a while i cant do that with series 11 and 12. The twelve doctor should have just chosen to die instead of this shit.
@@SuperGamingpepper I can't believe there are people who actually think that and they are not just trolling.
I grew up with Tom Baker as the quintessential Doctor, but Matt Smith became MY Doctor and was heartbroken with his departure. It took me a long time to warm up to Peter Capaldi, but he grew on me, and is truly a continuation of Matt Smith's Doctor and the greater Moffat arc. Capaldi is indeed a perfect Doctor. Salute!
How do you feel about Tennant. He is my doctor
The first time the crew saw Jodie would have been on Black Mirror. The episode where a chip records everything you see, she played the wife.
Milky Whitepee That was my first time seeing her as well.
David Bradley also appeared as an alien bird in the Sarah Jane Adventures where we get Jo Grant back too in the same episode
Missed that
My apologies, the announcement of your death was wrong. But i will rectify that. Immediately. Rest....in peace....doctor!!!
That actually wasn’t David Bradley but the actor sounded extremely like him. I questioned it too while watching and I had to Google it.
@Jimmy Fisherkeller he was credited at the end of the episodes so I will have to disagree with you there
Here we go! I've loved seeing them react to my favourite Doctor and favourite era.
Farewell 12!
and goodbye to in my opinion the best era of the show, the Moffat years!!
Liam Kershaw-Calvert Finally, someone with sense! The Moffat era was my favorite too, and SEVERELY under appreciated by several fans. Capaldi is my favorite Doctor, followed by Smith.
...ahh, 'twice upon a time' - one of my very favourite doctor episodes . my first doctor was mr william hartnell - 'the original you might say' - myself and millions of other kids thought the world of sir william. mr david bradley's ability to embody william's doctor is nothing short of remarkable - it's as if mr david was channeling the first doctor - just beautiful! the interplay between mr david and sir peter is amazing - these two terrific actors sparring and sparking off each other - what a great double-act! farewell sir peter, farewell sir steven of moffat, farewell sir murray of gold - y'all were fantastic!!
Let's hope Mr Hartnell _stays_ the original and none of this retroactive continuity of a cycle of women before him. Uurgh!
Adam Darren Lmao rewatch Fugitive of the Judoon. A lot of fans missed the obvious there. I know for a fact it’s either one of two things. One possibility is the Season 6B theory. Google it.
I don't need to Google it, I've known about the 6B fanfiction-fanwank for almost three decades. Never bought into it. Never bought into fanfiction in general.
What's the other possible theory?
@@mekonta the whole '6B' fandango doesn't make a lot of sense to me either. the current show-runners went to great lengths in the last series to construct 'stand alone' episodes - presumably to make the show more accessible to 'casual'/new viewers. it would seem counterproductive to all of that to suddenly start referencing 'deep fan' material in a big way. perhaps ruth is a regenerated susan paying the doctor back for leaving her stranded in a dreary, dalek-ridden london with a crummy boyfriend!!
@@mekonta Notice how you didn't say a cycle of *doctors*, or a cycle of *incarnations*, but a cycle of *women*. Why exactly is them being women worse?
You should watch Broadchurch (UK). It has Whitaker and also Tennant. Even Bradley is in it. :D
Three Doctors. Also, Aaron was reading Broadchurch off and mentioned Gracepoint as well. Gracepoint was an inferior retelling of Broadchurch set on the west coast of the USA. They got David Tennant to play the lead in it as well: basically a clone of his Broadchurch character but a different name.
Also arthur darvill who played rory
The Brigadier had a daughter named Kate who took over UNIT. Also, the Brigadier's name was Alistair Gordon Lethbridge-Stewart. He was a companion of the 2nd, 3rd, and 4th Doctors.
Nooooo my favorite doctor 😭😭😭
Aaron’s face when Clara appeared was totally my face when I watched it for the first time.
I saw these three episodes just yesterday. I can say Capaldi is MY Doctor. It`s been almost a year since I saw "Rose". Loved Ecclestone, Tennant and Smith, but Peter did the best Doctor, funny, awkward at times, wise, and those speeches!...
This probably my favorite Christmas special and favorite final goodbye to a Doctor.
i cried so hard with that episode...
They did the First Doctor so dirty in this
Honestly it makes me more uncomfortable the more times I see the way he’s written. It’s a shame as David Bradley portray’s the First Doctor with such perfection that the cheap jokes really bring the whole thing down.
@@SamR1995 Yeah its unfortunate
Moffat is horrible that way.
I know, they should have put those sort of things down to the time they were written, I don’t even remember the first doctor saying anything like that sort of stuff from what I’ve watched, but you have to get your political message that men are bad and all that I guess.
Also, it was only like two episodes ago the Doctor went on saying the Time Lords are so far beyond our petty concepts of gender or something and then they go write the doctor as a misogynist!
Not really. Its heavily exaggerated, but it was fairly in character.
Capaldi was my favourite doctor and Missy was my favourite master. I was so sad to see this era end. Also, the music in the episode! Man, the call backs!
I said this before and I will say it again if Doctor Who was to end as a show, then this episode would have been (Not Perfect) a satisfying or good way to do it. They can keep the war doctor but if they get rid of the 2nd David Tennant regeneration then that would have made Peters Doctor be the last Doctor of the cycle. The story of the last doctor convincing the first doctor to keep going all while knowing that this is his last life and also the fact that there isn't really an enemy for the story I think makes it better gives more time for the characters and the struggle they face in the story. Also having it be (roughly) taking place during in my opinion the biggest act of kindness and love the Christmas armistice, also Peters last monologue to Bill and Nardole really makes it act like this is the end of the entire thing. I could go on for ages explaining how this is a, again not perfect, but
a satisfyingly good end for the show, there are things I would change to make it a lot better but for what we got I'm happy with.
I really wish it was. Chibnall has killed The Doctor for me. He had no idea what he was doing writing that character, and now I don't even recognize the character.
@@epiccarrot88 same :(
@@epiccarrot88
Series 12 has been very good so far. So I have to disagree.
@@jeckjeck3119 Agree to disagree. It's still got all the main issues I had with Series 11. For me, the quality of the writing isn't what makes a show. The quality of the story isn't what makes a show. Sure, they both help, but they're not why I like stories. It's the heart, the soul, the passion for the story and the creativity. It's why the prequel Star Wars films are my favourite Star Wars Trilogy, despite the writing being pretty bad in some areas. Chibnall didn't have a story to tell, he had politics to discuss. He didn't take over Doctor Who because he had a grand vision of where he wanted to take the story, to build upon the work of the previous heads, and to create a piece of art. He did it because he wanted to make Doctor Who more woke; the show, in his eyes, needed more diversity, and more left-wing politics. He didn't care about the story. Mickey, Captain Jack and Martha are some of the most popular characters in New Who, despite them all coming in succession to one another and all being minorities. People didn't complain then because there was a clear story being told. Mickey being constantly insulted by the Doctor, realising he was just letting it happen, toughening up and becoming someone The Doctor ended up respecting. Captain Jack was a man from the future who conned people, only to end up trapped within his own life. Martha liked The Doctor, but eventually began seeing that nothing could ever happen between the two and that she deserved better than post-Rose Doctor was treating her. They all had a clear story to be told, and it was evident in their very first episodes.
The show ended here tho. Everything else is just a terrible fanfiction written by 14y old girl from tumblr for a group of mentally challenged 12y olds.
Its just better to pretend its not cannon
Awesome! I love the goodbye speech.
I hated how they made 1 act like an old sexist man from the 60s (yeah I get why) like a few episodes ago 12 told bill how timelords are the least sexist people in the universe. Plus 1 never even was a sexist in the og show.
Just a note regarding the mechanics of regeneration, The Master (as John Simm) also chose not to regenerate in ‘The Last of the Time Lords’ back in the third season
Farewell once more to my favorite doctor ♥️ you were legendary 12. Thank you
I never really got the idea of fans claiming a Doctor until I got to this one. I understood it but I never truly GOT it. But with 12 I was like yeah okay yeah this is totally my Doctor I love him and he's totally who I think of when I think of the Doctor. I love his character development so much. He started out questioning whether or not he was a good man and needing Clara to care about others on his behalf and not minding anyone's feelings when he said things. Now he cares so much even when he teases his companions and the thing he wants most for his next regeneration is for the next Doctor to be kind and never cruel and it speaks so much to his growth.
This wasn't just the end of Capaldi and Moffat's time on Doctor Who, but also the composer, Murray Gold. You can pick out his most recognisable themes throughout this episode from across the entire modern era. The 9th Doctor's theme (a.k.a. Bad Wolf theme) plays when 13 appears, and the 11th Doctor's theme "I Am The Doctor" starts right after the 1st Doctor says that exact phrase at 5:05
We were all sorry to see Murray go.
God I'm going to miss 12th so much.
As a german, this episode has a special place in my heart. I'm always getting goosebumps when they start to sing. Honestly as I watched it the first time I started crying, but in a good way.
@22:15
No it wasn't the 709th episode of Doctor Who. It was 709 episodes between the FIRST Doctor regenerating, and the Twelfth Doctor regenerating.
There are dozens of more episodes than that prior to that episode.
28 STORIES before tenth planet, of (an average) 4 to 6 episodes per story, plus the huge 10 part Dalek master plan, there's at least another 100 episodes before.
Gracepoint was the U.S. remake of Broadchurch. Chris Chibnall wrote a few DWs before this and was the main showrunner on the first two seasons of Torchwood. Alistair Gordon Lethbridge-Stewart was a Brigadier (often referred to as simply "the Brigadier"), not a Brigadier General; his modern equivalent is his daughter, Kate, and Archie is his Great Uncle.
Aaron sighs during the regeneration. "Here we go again." 🙃
Love this episode and so cool that Bradley got a chance to play the Doctor in the actual show after the the docu-drama. :) And aw goodbye 12th Doctor, but also hello 13th Doctor. :)
The Slitheen Two part story would've actually been the 700th episode.
So we know that now.
@@bigfatcarp93 No idea how that happened.
With so many things going on, he didn’t really focus on the fact that it was 709 episodes ago, but the number stayed in his head. He thinks Twice Upon a Time was episode 709. Easy mistake. But yeah.
Chris Chibnall has written Dr Who before, and he was a showrunner on Torchwood.
Goodbye 12 You will always be my favorite Doctor! And get ready because Season 11... Well it's gonna be a rough one.
This regeneration hit me the hardest T_T
Me too, we lost the Doctor.
Yep...
All downhill from here
Gracepoint is the American remake of Broadchurch which also starred Arthur Darvill (Rory) and Jodie Whitaker (the new doctor). I'd love to see your reaction to Broadchurch.
Also with the choosing to die instead of regenerating was shown in the season 3 finale when the John Simm master refused to regenerate in the doctors arms.
Callum Dyne Great show but I feel they should have left it as just one season, I enjoyed the second one as well but I feel the third was really unnecessary, leave on a high and all that!
"I suppose one more lifetime won't kill anyone."
Proceeds to viciously kill the canon with The Timeless Child. Thanks Chibnall!
Even though he says he feels the ending was truly great, I feel like Eric genuinely cannot get emotionally invested in Doctor Who any longer. The last 15 minutes of the episode either leave me sobbing like Calvin or introspectively moody like Shane... but I truly feel like Eric couldnt emotionally get into it just like Heaven Sent back in the days, sadly. :(
And no Eric, that wasnt episode 700... cause 709 episodes ago was the last episode of the First Doctor not the first episode of Doctor Who ever. :)
That's because at the moment, Chibnall has done nothing emotional at all. His story arcs haven't had any enormous heart-wrenching moments.
@@UKTheOmegaPyro The whole Ryan and Graham relationship arc in series 11 gets pretty emotional. I remember Melanie tearing up in their reaction of It Takes You Away when he finally calls him grandad.
Also, if Demons of the Punjab isn't emotional I don't know what is.
Cause the quality went down this season. But its still was 10000x better than the current season of DW. I rly feel they gonna hate the writing cause the quality of the show went sooooo down that its just sad to watch... truly a dumpster fire. For me they might as well just cancel the show cause WHOcares anymore?
@@DiegoE02 srsly? that was emotional for you? that terrible writing? Geeez. I've seen commercials that were more emotional
@@DiegoE02 Demons of the Punjab emotional... The only emotion I feel is cringe. That hack writer created one indian character just to make an episode in India but later forgot she even exited or that she was a cop lol... Thats why she barely speaks at all and has no character. Yeah... very emotional...
Also think about those Demons. So now everyone who dies not only gets scanned by the glass but also he has some demons looking at him? Getting a little bit clouded huh? Give the dead some space!
I scrolled a good ways down and didn't see one person say, "and this is where you should stop watching" or some other negative comment considering all the hate. Kinda proud of this comment section.
Let's wait for the next few weeks before giving ourselves too much credit
Unfortunately the shitty “fans” have arrived because they can’t just let people enjoy things. I didn’t appreciate Series 11 until my second viewing of it, and Series 12 has really blown all of that out of the water. I’m absolutely loving Jodie now. The style has changed in Doctor Who now, but once you get adjusted to it, it’s quite enjoyable. Series 12 is reminding me a lot of the Tennant era.
In what way do other people's criticisms impact on your enjoyment of the show? If you enjoy the show, all power to you but don't blame it on other people's criticisms if you're not enjoying it as much as you used to. That's the show's fault, no one else's.
OMG I'm not ready for this, very interested in what you think of next weeks episode.
If they think the next season is even watchable they will lose all credibility lol
@Oll why the truth triggers u so much my friend?
It's great seeing you guys react to this epic episode. It was definitely one of the most-emotional episodes. David Bradley was phenomenal. One thing I wanted to mention as you were listing his different appearances throughout Who. He did actually voice a character in the spin-off, "The Sarah Jane Adventures" (funnily enough in a character which featured both Matt Smith and one of the old companions too!). Mark Gatiss has also played various characters throughout the show, as well as writing episodes numerous episodes (he's also one of the creators and writers of "Sherlock" alongside Steven Moffat). Everything changes from this point on, like it did when Steven Moffat took over. Chris Chibnall takes over from this point on, so new Doctor, new composer, new look and new feel. Finally, Jodie Whittaker was one of the main characters in "Broadchurch" ("Gracepoint" was the American remake of "Broadchurch" but had a completely-different cast apart from David Tennant and wasn't well-received.) and has been in tons of stuff through the years, including the movie "Attack The Block" featuring John Boyega and Nick Frost.
It's gonna be interesting in a couple of months they'll be actually caught up to where Doctor Who currently is and they can do polls and QnA's and stuff
What I've always liked about this episode is how subtle it is in bringing back elements from past Capaldi storylines. Of course, all of his companions returning is kind of obvious. Additionally, though, the Testimony creating a sort of afterlife is similar to Missy's afterlife storyline from season 8 and the manner in which the Testimony operates by freezing people in time just before they die is evocative of Clara's fate at the end of season 9. Rusty making his return is not only a call back to Capaldi's second episode as The Doctor, but it also helps make Rusty a possibility for being the so-called "hybrid" mentioned throughout season 9 (since Rusty is a Dalek who had his mind temporarily linked with The Doctor and as a result inherited The Doctor's hatred of the Daleks, thus making him a hybrid of sorts of a Dalek and The Doctor). The Captain saluting The Doctor is a call back to the Cyberman who is presumed to be the Brigadier-General saluting The Doctor at the end of season 8.
I've meet david bradly in real life and been in a film with him (our parts were filmed seperatly), he is friend's with the godfather of a friend of mine from university, who also directed the film, so at the premier, I actually meet him. Such a nice and pleasent man.
Some of the things said in the discussion, and after doing the poll the other day, made me really hope for a Broadchurch reaction this year. There were a lot of shows on there I'd love but doubt will get enough votes, but for all the Doctor Who actors in that show it'd be so fun. Plus I'd love to see Eric and Calvin being detectives, and Shane and Aaron reacting to the family stuff as parents.
Also the thing you could've seen her in that's most likely is probably Attack the Block, which if you haven't seen would be fucking brilliant for a movie reaction.
Farewell to my favorite of all of the Doctors.
Ah yes! Been waiting! Can't wait for Melron's reaction to the new episode too :3
Doco56 Yeah, its the first time I’ve been excited to see their reaction to a Chibnall/Whitaker episode because up to now they have truly sucked!
@@keithwatson1384 Season 12 is really good so far.
@@keithwatson1384 Not true at all
Crazy4Comics What’s not true? Maybe you liked it but I wasn’t too keen.
@@keithwatson1384 Fair enough however you were stating that they were awful like it was factual not an opinion, so I'm disagreeing with that statement
The nostalgia from the first doctor’s tardis hits me every time I watch this episode. Literally. I only watched it the day before power of the doctor, because I was preparing for the regeneration, and it still got to me.
The brigader was the head of unit from the 2nd doctors era onwards and has meet the 2nd, 3rd (who worked for unit and the brig was technically his boss), 4th and 7th (at which point he had retired) doctors on screen.
Disappointing that Murray Gold's departure was not referenced by the guys. Love Capaldi he was a brilliant Doctor, arguably the best actor to ever play the character and such a lovely man in real life. Moffat's time was up but he had given so much to the show that I Am eternally grateful for. His final interviews with Cristel on Doctor Who The Fan show were very revealing into his experience as showrunner (Pt1 th-cam.com/video/iBwBlwGbVaA/w-d-xo.html Pt2 th-cam.com/video/ZOfIIqb8Uhg/w-d-xo.html Pt3 th-cam.com/video/bTRfKmVqdjo/w-d-xo.html
3:44
Even Naruto on the back, can't believe the first Doctor said that !
It'd be interesting if you reacted to the three-part Steven Moffat interview that the BBC uploaded on its channel after this episode was aired. It clarifies many aspects of his run, such as River Song, the 50th, Capaldi's choice, giving up the show after a long run... I think the gang would enjoy it and it'd also help y'all understand some important aspects of the last 6 seasons.
I don't think this was mentioned, but the whole thing about when you can hear the Doctor's name is something Peter Capaldi came up with on the spot at a convention, and then Steven Moffat incorporated it into the speech because it was just so good.
This is a good epilogue to Twelve’s era aswell as a nice ending for Capaldi and Moffat ‘s run on the show .
As someone mentioned below , it’s a nice reflection on change , death and memories wrapped in a fun romp . Capaldi and David Bradley have good chemistry together (even though I feel like they go a bit too far with the First Doctor’s sexist attitude).
Capaldi was not my favorite Doctor but I still thoroughly enjoyed him and his arc ..from someone who was unsure he was a good man to doing the right thing because it was kind ..Goodbye 12 , we let you go!!.
I’m interested to see your thoughts on the current era... I personally find it to be the weakest of the modern run so far but I’m still looking forward to going on the journey with you all!!.
It's been one hell of a journey folks, I can't believe we're almost caught up!
Almost there.
The end of an Era
It would be so cool if Classic Doctor Who eventually wins a poll. I really want them to watch Tenth Planet.
for season 13 they will need a bigger table. they should be caught up with melron by then so they need to shove up and make room for melanie lol.
michael jeacock I was thinking the same thing
12th will always be My Doctor.
Jodie Whittaker was a major character in the TV Show 'Broadchurch', was in the 'Black Mirror' episode called "The Entire History of You", was in the Great movie 'Attack the Block' with John Boyega & Franz Drameh (Jefferson Jackson (a.k.a. Firestorm) from Legends of Tomorrow) .
Another parallel between the regenerations is the ring falling off 13's hand. The same happened with the first doctor's ring after regenerating.
Absolutely loved Shane's thoughts and insightful comments...Oh wait 😂
😂
It's nice to come back and watch Moffat Who, before the dark times... Before the Timeless Child...
I’m gutted we didn’t get to see their reaction to the Rusty reveal. But that’s what Patreon is for.
That moment in that war for me is the greatest in human history. People, just regular people stopped fighting. Ignoring orders from "superiors" to not do what they were about to do. To unite for a moment. To have peace which is what they wanted, which is what everyone wanted. Only for the people with the power are the ones that want to fight. It was a middle finger to them people in power. And I love it! Don't let them divide us! Whatever race, creed, sex, sexual orientation, and age etc. Unite!
Mark Gatiss also wrote An Adventure in Space and Time
He was also Danny Boy from the Churchill episode and that chess player in the ‘shock chess’ or whatever it was! He’s written loads of Doctor Who episodes! And of course he co produced Sherlock with Moffat
@@keithwatson1384 Lazarus too 😀
The_Judge_ Yeah, but they mentioned that one in the reaction so I didn’t bother mentioning that one!
@@keithwatson1384 Ah, my bad !!
The_Judge_ No prob.
Broadchurch is a great show containing two Doctors and a companion.
And Olivia Colman (she made a guest appearance in The Eleventh Hour).
Rania Lian oh yes, I was trying to remember if she was on Doctor Who.
I love the smell of Nepotism in the morning.
"One? What do you mean One?"
Best scene from the trailers
Gracepoint was an American remake of Broadchurch. They brought Tenant to reprise the character with the rest of the cast replaced. It didn't take in the US, but Broadchurch went on to have several seasons.
SHEEEEEEE'S HEEEEEEERE!!!!!!! (I'm surprised Shane didn't say "I hate her!")
Give it time.
@@mekonta I was about to say the exact same things mate
Loved watching the Doctor Who reactions. It was an amazing way to re-experience the show. It also made me realize just how bad the show got after this, to a point where I actually find it depressing. So sadly I’m out from here. I can only hope the show will return to form when we get a new show runner, hopefully that will be sooner than later. Off to watch some more of your reactions!
Important to note that this wasn't the 709th episode, it was 709 episodes after Hartnell's last story.
Speaking of the armies. If I'm not mistaken, each side of that battle had to be swapped out. They refused to start fighting again after the peace. Because they realized how dumb it was and they were friends.