Naas Botha with Freek Burger: The Red Card and Rules of Rugby

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ธ.ค. 2024

ความคิดเห็น • 42

  • @chrislouw9811
    @chrislouw9811 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Hey Naas, it's about bloody time that you started your own toob channel, congratulations, you have a new subscriber, I am quite sure that this can become one of the top rugby channels on this platform. I miss the good old days of Darren and Naas, sterkte ou yster!!

  • @IwasInThe60s
    @IwasInThe60s ปีที่แล้ว +11

    I have to finally get this off my chest: It was the time of sports isolation, and provincialism was the order of the day. I was a huge Western Province fan. I was in the Free State Stadium for the Currie Cup Final between WP and FS in 1976. The curtain raiser was an u.19 match between Northern Transvaal and Free State. There was this blonde flyhalf from NT who kicked penalties over from impossible positions. The next year, Northern Transvaal had a pre-season practice match against North-Eastern Cape (NOK) in Cradock. That was my part of the woods and me and my friends drove from Noupoort to Cradock for the match with my mum's Ford Cortina (even though neither of us were old enough to qualify for a driver's license yet - but that is a story for another day😆). There we were awed by Naas's other abilities: eye for the gap, breaking the line, perfect passing skills and so forth. Regrettably, I was one of the crowds of people that booed him at Newlands when he played against WP, to try to disrupt his game, aim and composure. Today I am relieved that it had no effect and probably motivated him even more! So this is my little tribute (and apology) to Naas... The greatest flyhalf ever.

    • @Palmstreet-u7x
      @Palmstreet-u7x ปีที่แล้ว +1

      believe me, there are thousands like you who did the same, many didn't like Naas, but he stayed a brilliant player

    • @Palmstreet-u7x
      @Palmstreet-u7x ปีที่แล้ว +1

      i was also that day at the stadium watching that game,

    • @IwasInThe60s
      @IwasInThe60s ปีที่แล้ว

      @@Palmstreet-u7x It is not that we did not like him... We FEARED him.😂 In that same era we meted out the same medicine to the late great Clive Rice in cricket, for the same reason. Thank you, I really appreciate the consolation.🙏 Fans, hey.🤦‍♂

    • @IwasInThe60s
      @IwasInThe60s ปีที่แล้ว

      @@Palmstreet-u7x My brother!❤ Morné du Plessis got injured during the week leading up to the final. Anyway, I was in the northern stand of the Free State Stadium and FS was kicking off to WP towards our vantage point. I remember clearly that there was what looked like a dust storm where the two packs clashed, and I thought to myself: Oh f..k, WP is screwed today.

    • @sakabula2357
      @sakabula2357 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      ​@eisbeinGermany lol..if he wasn't in your team you disliked him...but the talent was there to see

  • @seamus9750
    @seamus9750 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Yrrrrrrr!!!....Freek still looks fresh...a proper blast from the past 😮

  • @jacoduvenhage
    @jacoduvenhage ปีที่แล้ว +5

    I agree with Ex All Black Coach - He said TMO should only be used to confirm tries. That's it.

    • @kaalvoet
      @kaalvoet ปีที่แล้ว

      Foulplay?

    • @sakabula2357
      @sakabula2357 ปีที่แล้ว

      Yes of course an ex ab coach during the McCaw era would say that..No disrespect towards Richie..he is a great player..but wow..did he get away with those dark arts..

  • @megadiy8797
    @megadiy8797 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    For a team to score try's from rolling malls is beautiful. Those are always the most exciting try's to watch

  • @IanTolmayFastTrack
    @IanTolmayFastTrack 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Hello Naas. I really appreciate your videos. I hope you are going to make many more videos. There are many people who appreciate your honest and direct comments, especially pertaining to Rugby. Please keep making videos. Why not every day or at least once a week? I would love them short & to the point... Many rugby fans would love to hear stories of yesteryear. There are so many legendary stories that can be told. Will you tell us a story every week? All the best! Dankie!

  • @herman-phillipkleingeld2578
    @herman-phillipkleingeld2578 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    More people should subscribe to this man!

    • @hendo19742
      @hendo19742 10 หลายเดือนก่อน

      STILL EXTREMELY ANNOYED WITH THAT!😑😑😠😠😠🏉🏉🏉🇿🇦🇺🇲🇿🇦🇺🇲

  • @seanpinkey8798
    @seanpinkey8798 ปีที่แล้ว

    Freek Burger was one of the top referees in SA back in the 80s - a nice gentleman - saw him ref many Currie Cup gamrs

  • @chrislouw9811
    @chrislouw9811 ปีที่แล้ว

    I just love the way Naas says "raagby" LOL

  • @toscabrutus1781
    @toscabrutus1781 ปีที่แล้ว

    Naas uitstekende program en Freek Burger is baie goed! Groete uit LIma Peru!

    • @sakabula2357
      @sakabula2357 ปีที่แล้ว

      Joe van Niekerk...is dit jy???

  • @JackKinross
    @JackKinross ปีที่แล้ว

    Best discussion I've heard on these issues. Thanks.

  • @marcbrown729
    @marcbrown729 ปีที่แล้ว

    Good job gents. Thankyou.

  • @regislacomme5238
    @regislacomme5238 ปีที่แล้ว

    Thank you for that, please keep it going... so much that we, the "older purist of the game" wish that our beautiful game should benefit from... "cleaning up" all this unecessary clutter that seem to be designed for more and more unecessary control of the players,.... where in fact the players are more and more antagonized by this.... AND most of the spectators do no longer enjoy the spectacle of good rugby anymore!??.. ..well perhaps like most of us I miss the good old time of what I still call "old proper rugby".. a no non sense approach to a game of men ....gentlemen game played by hooligans( soccer/football_ against the so called hooligans game played by gentlemen, our pre professional rugby)... and the latest is what we showed the world with our Springboks in France winning it against all odds and all oppositions and it seems as well against a bit of spitfulness & sour grapes from certains overseas medias ? I rest my case, please keep your vlog going and growing!

  • @willene58
    @willene58 ปีที่แล้ว

    Thank you forsorting out the dissappointing finals.

  • @codepuncher
    @codepuncher ปีที่แล้ว

    Good discussion. Nice to see Mr Burger looking so well. Great ref in his days.
    This head contact thing is ruining the game. What`s stupidity is coming next - each player must wear a electronic Geiger counter to measure impact !! anything over a 4.2 is a red card...
    Ref`s mostly pick up on genuine foul play, I completely agree keep TMO for try line checks.
    Yes and these chongalolo lines behind rucks are ridiculous.
    Plus 20 % of todays tries Mr Burger would`ve rightly called back for a forward pass.

  • @mitakon21
    @mitakon21 ปีที่แล้ว

    100% forward motion of the ball before the bounce of the ball...it went forward from Telea's hands in the tackle from behind by PTSD....the forward motion of the ball before the bounce is obvious and explicit from a top camera view. It falls at least 50cm forward out his hands from the tackle into the intersecting corner of the 5m & 5m when Barret picked it up and went over.

  • @Mumbo_Jumbo_Kiwi.1
    @Mumbo_Jumbo_Kiwi.1 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    The problem with the rreed carrd is that it's too loosely arranged enabling player with ball in hand can milk a penalty stepping into a tackle. Owen Farrell exploited this to perfection against the Pumas in the 2019 WC crucial pool match

    • @stlouisix3
      @stlouisix3 ปีที่แล้ว

      Most Kiwis also pronounce red similar to 'reed', the difference is that Afrikaans-speaking people roll their rrrrrrrs.

  • @kaalvoet
    @kaalvoet ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Why no replay on that try since it was not clear not saying it was not a try just asking

  • @bhupendrasolanki663
    @bhupendrasolanki663 ปีที่แล้ว

    I'm surprised Freek Burger is still around!

    • @sakabula2357
      @sakabula2357 ปีที่แล้ว

      Looks like he can still ref..

  • @dirksamsungvalentin4936
    @dirksamsungvalentin4936 ปีที่แล้ว

    I was so upset with with the Red card that was shown to Marcell I wrote the following rules for a Yellow or Red Card offence:
    Increase squad to 24
    Union nominates 2 players for replacements for yellow and red card offenders per game.
    Yellow offenders: Position 4 - 15
    1. If a player is shown a yellow card:
    a. Player get replaced by one of the nominated replacements.
    b. Nominated player must wear a yellow armband.
    c. After 10min nominated player goes back to bench and offender returns.
    d. Player gets suspended for 1 game after match.
    e. Union get slammed with fine. (to be defined by World rugby)
    2. Second yellow card - follow point 1 with second nominated player.
    3. Same process for follow-up yellow cards if nominated player available.
    4. If first nominated player gets shown a yellow
    a. Second nominated player goes on field and first nominated player is benched for rest of game.
    5. No more Nominated players no replacements.
    Red offenders: Position 4 - 15
    1. If a player is shown a red card:
    a. Player get replaced by one of the nominated replacement.
    b. Nominated player must wear a red armband.
    c. Offender permanently benched for game.
    d. Nominated player stay on field
    e. Player gets suspended for 2 games after match.
    f. Union get slammed with fine. (to be defined by World rugby)
    2. Second red:
    a. If nominated player available same process as 1.
    3. No more Nominated players no replacements.
    Yellow offenders: Position 1 - 3
    1. Replacement props or hooker on field
    2. After 10min back to bench
    3. Suspension and fine same as yellow above.
    4. No bench on replacement
    Red offenders: Position 1 - 3
    1. Replacement props or hooker on field
    2. Replacement stay on field
    3. Suspension and fine same as red above.
    4. No bench on replacement
    Each union can deal with offenders financially as they deem fit.
    If no yellow or red cards shown during game - nominated players can sub players only in the last 10min.
    Have to get this off my chest!!!!!!!!

  • @philipkoekemoer4705
    @philipkoekemoer4705 ปีที่แล้ว

    Freek , die rooi was 'n rooi as jy enige ander wedstryde die jaar gekyk het.

  • @stlouisix3
    @stlouisix3 ปีที่แล้ว

    Sam Cane's red card wasn't a red card just as Beauden Barrett's 'try' was the result of a forwards flying pass and a knock on from Half-South Äfricän, half-Samoan All Black player Mark Telea.