Humpty Dumpty Oh ok !! Thank you and by the way I am bbueno2009 is just TH-cam deleted ALLL my comments from before June 2020 D: that means years and years of commenting gone but thank you,!!
The sicknes of being moomoo: When you watch mamamoo immortal song performance, you will end up marathon all of 13 of mamamoo immortal song 😂😂😂 Despite u allready watch it million times...
For those new comer in our fandom. number one rule is Don't bring other girl groups down just to compliment Mamamoo. please, we want to maintain the PEACEFULNESS of the Radish field. thank you. with all the love-Moonbyul trash😘
Individually Solar, Hwasa and Wheein have such beautiful voices but when they sing together it just blows my mind. And Moonbyul's perfectly inserted rapping adds so much to the group dynamic. I am so glad I discovered Mamamoo.
The rest of the song is fantastic as it is, but Hwasa's breathy singing voice on those certain lines... it just gives me chills. Girl is absolutely unreal.
That was Solar and Hwasa at your timestamp. Did you mean Solar and Wheein after that? ...or was it all three of them at your timestamp. I wish they were showing the whole stage for that part. 😅
There's not enough like buttons! I need to like this at least a hundred times! 😭 (I've heard just about everything Mamamoo has done and the vocals in this song still slay me every time!)
Why does Hwasa's note at 3:13 make me so emotional 😢 I love the tone of her voice, it's so unique. but man, I always come back to this performance and it doesn't get old. Solar's high note, Wheein's beautiful voice, moonbyul's rap. they are all just so talented. 😢
I'll never get tired watching their immortal song performances. By far, this is my favorite. I'm Moonbyul-biased but Hwasa's soulful voice always gets me. I don't know why but it makes me emotional. I've just become a Moomoo a few weeks ago and I don't regret anything about it. They raise the standard of kpop groups...
I fell in love with them four days ago, no joking. I already learnt their names but I'm still trying to differentiate (I don't know if my spelling is right, lol) Solar and Wheein. I'm not even into K-pop 😅. I've just became a Blink and then discovered MAMAMOO, I'm falling with these Immortal Songs' perfomances.
There are two type of singers in this world: singing as an occupation and singing as a passion. Mamamoo really highlights the difference between the two.
@Layton T. Montgomery Of course we can't. But not every artist goes that extra mile to add different adlibs to *every single* performance of the same song, interact and sing *with* the audience, and hype up just about any audience, and have the time of their lives about every time they are on stage, not with the appearent ease MMM does it. It's not possible if one does not have great passion for what they are doing. By the way, I have no intention of offending anyone and if I've come across as such in any way, I apologise. Have a good time 😊
It's 2020 and this rule still applies, in this fandom if you want to compliment mamamoo you do not bring other girl groups into it, we are known as the most well mannered fandom and I would like to keep it that way, please and thank you
Yes.. and yes... mamamoo for the win.. there is no need to compare them.. they are incomparable. I suddenly was humming this song and came back to listen to it again.. and it felt so good.
Yeah, the downside is that ballads by K-pop groups don't tend to do as well commercially and being from a small company where they are currently the primary earner, it's important for them to generally have something that will sell and chart well, win music shows, and get music festivals psyched to book them. They do the occasional ballad, but mostly they are B sides of a single or deep cuts from their albums. Red Velvet is another girl group with some great ballads as that group sings harmonies well too, but SM couldn't get them to chart as well in the early years of the group and pretty much just goes with dance-pop now as that is what seems to chart and sell the best. Mamamoo is kind of in the same boat, but being at a much smaller company it is even more critical that they make good money on a single. SM can afford to break even on a single or take a small loss to prove an artistic point. RBW can't yet. Now if Oneus and Onewe do well and their next girl group that is getting close to debut, RBW might have a little more freedom to experiment musically with Mamamoo.
@@kentvesser9484 This is so sad but true 😥✊🏻. I wish people would look more into ballad songs as much as they do pop songs. So much of an idols' talent can be shown by singing a ballad song yet people only appreciate the pop songs 😥
@@kentvesser9484 but still there's a chance that mamamoo could be recognize globally through singing ballad.... many people in the world loves ballad music with emotinal feels... popular music doesnt have to be lively and party like..... just like Whitney Houston... My Queens need to have have many exposures internationally
+Miss Pluto I'm sure that Mamamoo is the group to stick with, and in the future they will deliver many more great performances. For me Mamamoo and EXID are the most genuine and fun groups out there, and they love their music and eachother. I'm speechless.
+Alexis C her voice is powerful and they both have a 3 octave range. It's just sometimes her projection is weird and it sounds like she's singing far away. Even though the Mic is right in front of her. I've never understood why hwasa's mic sounds different.
I can never imagine Mamamoo without each member. They're like a painting that is complete only because each member is there. Mamamoo in my opinion would be incomplete without Moonbyul, or Hwasa, or Solar or Wheein.....
True!! I believe they will since they have really good relationship with each other, with the company and with the fans. They are genuine and is not superficial. And hi there fellow Mamamoo Trash xD
So true. You guys probably know this, but I read somewhere that Solar once said that, without the rest of MAMAMOO, she as well as each of the members are just parts of the same body. They may be amazing soloists as well, but they themselves always see them as whole only when they are all together. Your comment reminded me of that🥺🥺❤️❤️❤️❤️ Our unnie's words get really poetic from time to time, I love it🥺🥺❤️❤️❤️❤️
Watching their performances in immortal songs made me realize that they always had the potential to be one of the amazing gg groups. They might be not that popular to internationals but they are very well known because of their vocal skills. I’m so proud to see them grow and what they have achieved this 2020. Each of them got to do their solo and get to make their own music. Will always be hoping to see more music from MAMAMOO.
Take note Mamamoo consider top vocal in korean industry they are 6times ( 2016-2020, even now ) notimate in MAMA as best vocal or best vocal group. When they are rookie, korean media called them as Super Rokie because a months debut won against senior korean industry. There vocal made them popular in korea. Now Mamamoo well known in Korean Industry as titled : Multi-Talented Girl Group, Girl-Crush group, Trending Performance, Never Dissapointed, Belive and Listen Mamamoo, Best of best copetition, And Musician Group or best singer group.
Mamamoo should perform this kind of performance at major award show like Korean Music Award to present a lifetime achievement award perhaps. Just like Lady Gaga pays tribute to Julie Andrews at Grammy Award. It will be amazing.
+o anii o They' re taking small steps in learning how to produce. I'm expecting Mamamoo as an artist rather than just Idols in the future. I mean, just like Brown Eyed Girls, they debuted as a "vocal idol" group but i doubt anyone regards them as idols now. (Srr, I'm such trash for Brown Eyed Girls and Mamamoo)
HT. Minh Thảo Yeah, I've noticed their involvement in their album tracks. xD I think I could have worded my comment a little better since I meant that other idols must idolize Mamamoo. |D
omg they're like a banana split sundae. Wheein is the vanilla ice cream, solar is the chocolate fudge that just blend everything, hwasa is the banana that gives it nice kick, moonbyul is the cherry on top.
My beautiful beautiful girls, I will stay with you, forever and ever. Moon's rap was incorporated so well into the song I am so happy. Their voices were... simply out of this worldm
I think Moonbyul is a very "special" rapper.Her rap fits in perfectly in any song and it doesn't sound awkward or like it is from another song like it does sometimes with other groups.Idk if she writes hher raps or not but she should go to SMTM...not Unpretty Rapstar.I think she has the skill to win over the guys :))
gabber230ful That's why I said "if" she writes her lyrics c: Maybe she can diss.We really don't know yet... P.S: Yezi was a idol rapper too but she slayed in Unpretty
Adina Psyche I felt the second and third rapping parts were a little out of place..who cares tho I just want to hear Moonbyul unnie do her thing. but why don't they let her sing when she has a beautiful voice???
I think she doesn't want to because she feels more comfortable rapping(?) I don't think RBW wouldn't LET her sing just because hse doesn't have "powerful" vocals like the other three dorks
I posted 5yrs ago on this video. And today I’m posting that I saw them live in Chicago. 🥹 My moomoo heart is filled with so many emotions and love. Thank you Mamamoo for making music 🎶 that makes me feel so confident and loved. Thank you for your artistry and passion. I’ll never forget it! 💚 Till we meet again. I’ll be back to listen to this cover over and over again.
lol I just have to comment this. hwasa's voice is so addictive, byul's rap is so on point I swear like its the best thing ever and both wheein and solar have a great voice. a perfect package
This performance sealed the deal for me being a moomoo. I was amazed by their You're the Best performance that I first saw before this but being as old as I am, songs like this speak more to me. Now, I feel like Mamamoo keeps me young because they are so vibrant. I wanna adopt them as my children, since I have none. Wheein especially.
Why do I feel like this could be in a Disney OST though it probably can't? 😂😂😂😂 MoonByul's rap is the best thing about this performance lol God blessed this group when it was being put together.
When you realize that Solar is the pillar of the harmony in MMM... Her voice is suprano but love how she does the lower register for the harmony then goes up again always balancing her voice for the perfect harmony, love it much... 😘😊✌🏻
But the fact is Wheein is mamamoo's vocal pillar, Kim Dohoon (RBW'S CEO) said that Wheein is a bridge between Solar and Hwasa, Wheein is always lowering her tone for perfect harmonization Even if you often hear mamamoo songs, Wheein always gets a pretty difficult part But we know that our leader Solar is a belter in Mamamoo
I wanna pop a question to those 103 people who dislike this performance. why the hell did u hate such beautiful rendition? it's not just Mamamoo, that woman who sing "AHEYA" was amazing too. everything was epic. come on!
The mix between Mamamoo's voice and the woman singing Aheyaa, brought tears to my eyes, everytime I listen this song. And Moonbyul, absolutely stunning!!!!!
listening back to the original version after watching the "remake" they did in the 8th anniv special video 🤧 time flies so fast, but this still remains a gem 💖
@3:45 . i teared alittle bit. i saw wendy's face. its not a face of sore or a fake smile. its a smile so sincere it makes me tear. it' s like she's in love. she is really crazy abt music and singing. i imagine she going through a sort of submission during this performance. i loved wendy. she is pretty, kind, lovely, humble, dorky and talented. i've never seen this face of wendy's, seems like only with intimacy could bring this out from her. its like i have now understand her alittle bit more. only true fans of wendy's will understand why i go my way out to point out something like this. as a proud and true fan of rv and also behalf of those who are just like me , i thank mamamoo for bringing this moment of wendy out.
Their vocals are so perfectly matched that when they all sing high notes, it's completely harmonic. Wheein's crystal clear high notes cut straight through to even out the lower more gutteral tones of Hwasa and Solar though Solar is a little higher in pitch in volume that it doesn't clash either. When Moonbyul joins in, it's to stabilise the high notes to keep it from being too chaotic by bringing in her moderating tone. It's beautiful and I don't know the correct terminology for this but this is how I view it.
No fancy costums, no fancy make-up... in fact when looking at their attire they look as if they walked in from the street. No big dance act or flashy visuals, just 4 ladies with a mike each with a live band singing in a language I don't understand. Nonetheless, they still hit me right in the 'feels' even when not reading the sub's (side note, props for the original rap, if you didn't know better you would think that it was part of the original)
Byul actually has a really beautiful lower register, they should really utilize her more as a vocalist, she may not be a belter, but they sleepin on her talents. But her rapping though, damn.. it's so hard to find female rappers with her sort of, vibe/flow I guess? she has so much talent, they all do, like wow, they lucked the hell out with this group, just.. wow. I never liked kpop before, but there's really just no way around liking them, from vocals and performance to personality and chemistry, they have mastered all trades. They really are just amazing, nothing more to it.🤷
currently binging mamamoo immortal songs performances in quarantine... this one is one of my favorites and watching it again brings back so many good memories.. i remember when they were still relatively small fame wise years ago.. watching youtube videos of their fan meetups outside in a courtyard where it was a quite small gathering and they would hand out sandwiches to the fans.. they’re just as humble, and soso talented. they deserve the popularity they have now and i’m glad they’re prospering !!
Man.. Mamamoo on immortal songs was what got me into their music and just korean music in general back in 2015-2016.... listening to this again after a while makes me fall in love with them all over again
![MAMAMOO - Delilah | 마마무 - 딜라일라 [Immortal Songs 2]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YJfC23ZZjNw/mqdefault.jpg)
![MAMAMOO - Delilah | 마마무 - 딜라일라 [Immortal Songs 2]](/img/tr.png)
![MAMAMOO - The way to Sampo | 마마무 - 삼포로 가는 길 [Immortal Songs 2]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/jAmVJ3YI4UM/mqdefault.jpg)
Never a group made me so emotional like Mamamoo did.
Sutrisna Adi same, but this song is too much for me :c
Me too, i get teary eyes whenever listening to this.
The lyrics, their voices, goosebumps.
Btob and mamamoo
YAAASS FINALLY I FOUND SOMEONE THAT STAN BOTH MAMAMOO AND BTOB!!!!!OMG IM SO HAPPY!!!!!!YASSSSSSS
Same, I get teary every time I watch this
That traditional singer line "Aheya" really add the flavour to this song!!
it really did
bbueno2009 idk korean or anything but i think it’s just a chant???
I really want to know that singer. Who is she?
Humpty Dumpty
Oh ok !! Thank you and by the way I am bbueno2009 is just TH-cam deleted ALLL my comments from before June 2020 D:
that means years and years of commenting gone but thank you,!!
@@nanlone7660 Samee
Their entertainment company seriously hit the jackpot!!!! It's rare to find a group who every single member can actually sing well... MAMAMOO FTW!
Not just that, their personalities individually are very positive and vibrant, together, they are a riot. That also attracted a lot of people to them.
Not just sing, all of them can rap and dance too 😍😍
Yuju got JAMS they can do all things lol😂
grant hale if you like groups where all the members can sing (extremely well) I suggest ladies code! absolutely amazing girls
I think its mutual.. I dont think mamamoo will become like this if they join JYP or SM. Mamamoo have raw talent, and RBW help polishing them.
The sicknes of being moomoo:
When you watch mamamoo immortal song performance, you will end up marathon all of 13 of mamamoo immortal song 😂😂😂
Despite u allready watch it million times...
this is true... :))
Bruhhh fr this is my thousands time
true.😭😂😂
Indeed🥰🥰
So true 😅
mamamoo was great, as always, but that lady’s “aheya!” literally gave me chills
moonsun Same here.
What she’s doing is called Gukgak (I think its a traditional singing technique for them) and It’s really hard to do so.
Saaaamee
Same same and after that followed by "stay with me" dude i'm in tears 😭
those rap parts are like the general narrator of the whole story the song contains. It's just so.. fucking perfect.
Hey fellow army
KookieBuds Beh spoken poetry. 😭
@@jileelab5696 indeed its just like spoken poetry
i couldnt agree more
If I am not mistaken, didn't Moonbyul write this rap(and the ones from their other IS performances as well)?
At 3:41 when Solar hits that High note and it blends with Hwasa's
Perfection.
+Alraune slayed me again for like the thousandth time lol, there's only so many times one video can slay me xD
The lead guitar's note also help
Wendy from rv would agree with you from her reaction lol
Agree, that part always gives me goosebumps whenever i hear it. Such perfection
and then followed by wheein's melody. beyond amazing 💕
For those new comer in our fandom. number one rule is Don't bring other girl groups down just to compliment Mamamoo. please, we want to maintain the PEACEFULNESS of the Radish field. thank you. with all the love-Moonbyul trash😘
Those kinds of comments are so rare I'm so proud To be a moomoo 😄 second rule could be "just enjoy"
Ima good radish
2018 and this rule still applies
I'm a good radish
The radish field is my safe space. I love it here.
Any MooMoo still doing an Immortal Song marathon in 2024? 🙋 ❤️
absolument
I go back to these over and over again. Mamamoo are just built different than other K-Pop GGs.
When I want to listen to one of them I just can't stop after and go over all of them again and again ❤
Neehhhhh... i miss them❤
You:"After all this time...?
All of us: "Always...!"
Individually Solar, Hwasa and Wheein have such beautiful voices but when they sing together it just blows my mind. And Moonbyul's perfectly inserted rapping adds so much to the group dynamic. I am so glad I discovered Mamamoo.
Wendy is a moomoo, she looks like she's in love with them haha :').
ikrrr 😭😂😂
mamavelvet 💕
Mamamoo and Red Velvet are best friends! they even said they have their on Gc
actually seulgi send BDGift to wheein too.
irene even said solar is one of her closest friends
"stay with me"
"don't go stay with me"
WHAT IS YOUR ADDRESS I WILL STAY WITH YOU AND STICK WITH U ALL LIKE A GLUE AND NEVER LEAVE.
LOOOOOOOOOL
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ME
Go go south Korea
Preach
I like the part when MoonByul raps while the other members hit their night notes.
Epic
sharon wu that was so intense it gives me goosebumps
I love the effect. I saw it in Delilah too and was epic. It’s a quite original effect that it’s a bit like their sign of disctintion
3:45 The way Wendy looks at them with those glowing eyes... appreciation and respect from one true vocalist to another.
That’s cause she isn’t an idol singer she is an actual singer like mmm
Member of the only group capable of being in the same league as MMM... I'm not talking anyone down... I like a lot of groups...
petition for Mamamoo to be in Immortal Songs again
A thousand times, "Yes!"
Let me make 6192014 alternate accounts real quick so I can petition with them all🤭
When Hwasa sings the last line,I wanna cry
same. its like she poured all of her emotions in that line :'
Same but then I saw her laugh at the end😂
@@beyarmzybeyarmy4777 maybe she wanted to stop the tears from falling out. i love her and all members. they are too perfect.
The rest of the song is fantastic as it is, but Hwasa's breathy singing voice on those certain lines... it just gives me chills. Girl is absolutely unreal.
Am I the only one that can't stop listening to this?😫
me too
me too 😂😂
me too
I can't stop listening to this one and Delilah 😍😍
I listen to this every day
3:42 can we just appreciate how smoothly both Solar and Wheein switched notes.
That was Solar and Hwasa at your timestamp. Did you mean Solar and Wheein after that? ...or was it all three of them at your timestamp. I wish they were showing the whole stage for that part. 😅
There's not enough like buttons! I need to like this at least a hundred times! 😭
(I've heard just about everything Mamamoo has done and the vocals in this song still slay me every time!)
Why does Hwasa's note at 3:13 make me so emotional 😢 I love the tone of her voice, it's so unique. but man, I always come back to this performance and it doesn't get old. Solar's high note, Wheein's beautiful voice, moonbyul's rap. they are all just so talented. 😢
***** It is just so captivating 😢
I'll never get tired watching their immortal song performances. By far, this is my favorite. I'm Moonbyul-biased but Hwasa's soulful voice always gets me. I don't know why but it makes me emotional. I've just become a Moomoo a few weeks ago and I don't regret anything about it. They raise the standard of kpop groups...
황주희 I'm Moonbyul unnie's fan too
I fell in love with them four days ago, no joking. I already learnt their names but I'm still trying to differentiate (I don't know if my spelling is right, lol) Solar and Wheein. I'm not even into K-pop 😅. I've just became a Blink and then discovered MAMAMOO, I'm falling with these Immortal Songs' perfomances.
I
Did you watch Delilah? Sounds perfect too!
Especially this performance
There are two type of singers in this world: singing as an occupation and singing as a passion. Mamamoo really highlights the difference between the two.
I agree completely. They sing as if their lives depended on it and that's passion.
@Layton T. Montgomery Of course we can't. But not every artist goes that extra mile to add different adlibs to *every single* performance of the same song, interact and sing *with* the audience, and hype up just about any audience, and have the time of their lives about every time they are on stage, not with the appearent ease MMM does it. It's not possible if one does not have great passion for what they are doing. By the way, I have no intention of offending anyone and if I've come across as such in any way, I apologise. Have a good time 😊
Oh, heck yeah!-
Korean Best Vocal Group ever exist
It's 2020 and this rule still applies, in this fandom if you want to compliment mamamoo you do not bring other girl groups into it, we are known as the most well mannered fandom and I would like to keep it that way, please and thank you
Yes.. and yes... mamamoo for the win.. there is no need to compare them.. they are incomparable. I suddenly was humming this song and came back to listen to it again.. and it felt so good.
i think mamamoo should do more ballad songs when they do comebacks cuz damn those vocals are so amazing
+Chi Mel I agree~ They should promote a follow-up song like some groups do.
Yeah, the downside is that ballads by K-pop groups don't tend to do as well commercially and being from a small company where they are currently the primary earner, it's important for them to generally have something that will sell and chart well, win music shows, and get music festivals psyched to book them. They do the occasional ballad, but mostly they are B sides of a single or deep cuts from their albums. Red Velvet is another girl group with some great ballads as that group sings harmonies well too, but SM couldn't get them to chart as well in the early years of the group and pretty much just goes with dance-pop now as that is what seems to chart and sell the best. Mamamoo is kind of in the same boat, but being at a much smaller company it is even more critical that they make good money on a single. SM can afford to break even on a single or take a small loss to prove an artistic point. RBW can't yet. Now if Oneus and Onewe do well and their next girl group that is getting close to debut, RBW might have a little more freedom to experiment musically with Mamamoo.
@@kentvesser9484 This is so sad but true 😥✊🏻. I wish people would look more into ballad songs as much as they do pop songs. So much of an idols' talent can be shown by singing a ballad song yet people only appreciate the pop songs 😥
@@kentvesser9484 but still there's a chance that mamamoo could be recognize globally through singing ballad.... many people in the world loves ballad music with emotinal feels... popular music doesnt have to be lively and party like..... just like Whitney Houston... My Queens need to have have many exposures internationally
The ting is that MAMAMOO's vocals are showcase in any type of songs.
only mamamoo can make me cry like this, i get so emotional with their voices. oh god. i'm blessed to be alive at the same time as these women
Preach. The struggle is real.
❤❤❤
*wipe tears
I'll stay with you forever, Mamamoo. Wherever you are
+Miss Pluto I'm sure that Mamamoo is the group to stick with, and in the future they will deliver many more great performances. For me Mamamoo and EXID are the most genuine and fun groups out there, and they love their music and eachother. I'm speechless.
Miss Pluto their music is their own blood
Not to be over dramatic but every time i watch 3:25 onwards I literally cry
Same .. everytime, like always, not joking, Everytime I heard this song I end up with tears
You are not alone...
You are not over-dramatic, that is completely understandable
Once you Wheein, you can't Wheeout 😊
I think Hwasa shone the most in this. It's like her voice was made for this performance.
+bee.syrup omg yasssss i love you for saying this
+bee.syrup ... well they all did. love these girls
+bee.syrup her voice is not very powerful like solar but it's full of emotions
+Phát Trần Her voice is powerful but it's not as high as solar's.
+Alexis C her voice is powerful and they both have a 3 octave range. It's just sometimes her projection is weird and it sounds like she's singing far away. Even though the Mic is right in front of her. I've never understood why hwasa's mic sounds different.
Damn. Moonbuyl's rap blends so well in the song.
I just can't stop the feels when watching their perf TT
I can never imagine Mamamoo without each member. They're like a painting that is complete only because each member is there. Mamamoo in my opinion would be incomplete without Moonbyul, or Hwasa, or Solar or Wheein.....
Mamamoo trash i agree 100%, they complement each other very well. It's hard to see them as per person not whole. Long last Mamamoo ❤
True!! I believe they will since they have really good relationship with each other, with the company and with the fans. They are genuine and is not superficial. And hi there fellow Mamamoo Trash xD
So true. You guys probably know this, but I read somewhere that Solar once said that, without the rest of MAMAMOO, she as well as each of the members are just parts of the same body. They may be amazing soloists as well, but they themselves always see them as whole only when they are all together. Your comment reminded me of that🥺🥺❤️❤️❤️❤️ Our unnie's words get really poetic from time to time, I love it🥺🥺❤️❤️❤️❤️
Ot4 forever... solar, moonbyul, wheein, whasa
Watching their performances in immortal songs made me realize that they always had the potential to be one of the amazing gg groups. They might be not that popular to internationals but they are very well known because of their vocal skills. I’m so proud to see them grow and what they have achieved this 2020. Each of them got to do their solo and get to make their own music. Will always be hoping to see more music from MAMAMOO.
Lets enjoy every moment they made for us....proud to be Moomoo...forever...
Take note Mamamoo consider top vocal in korean industry they are 6times ( 2016-2020, even now ) notimate in MAMA as best vocal or best vocal group. When they are rookie, korean media called them as Super Rokie because a months debut won against senior korean industry. There vocal made them popular in korea. Now Mamamoo well known in Korean Industry as titled : Multi-Talented Girl Group, Girl-Crush group, Trending Performance, Never Dissapointed, Belive and Listen Mamamoo, Best of best copetition, And Musician Group or best singer group.
Mamamoo should perform this kind of performance at major award show like Korean Music Award to present a lifetime achievement award perhaps. Just like Lady Gaga pays tribute to Julie Andrews at Grammy Award. It will be amazing.
Wendy was like... 'can i be in that group?' XD
i feel ya 😂😂
Christine Jillian Wendy totally mersmerized by the performance
That's it hahaha
What if she was tho ?? Can you imagine ? I loveeeee rv But I wish Wendy can spread her wings even more
she's too good for SM and Red Velvet. Even Seulgi
Idols among idols. Jesus, those vocals.
they are more like Artists than idols...they are amazing
+Hana Stiles they are more than divas, they are Goddesses. ;)
they are divas not idol 😂😂
+o anii o They' re taking small steps in learning how to produce. I'm expecting Mamamoo as an artist rather than just Idols in the future. I mean, just like Brown Eyed Girls, they debuted as a "vocal idol" group but i doubt anyone regards them as idols now. (Srr, I'm such trash for Brown Eyed Girls and Mamamoo)
HT. Minh Thảo Yeah, I've noticed their involvement in their album tracks. xD I think I could have worded my comment a little better since I meant that other idols must idolize Mamamoo. |D
omg they're like a banana split sundae. Wheein is the vanilla ice cream, solar is the chocolate fudge that just blend everything, hwasa is the banana that gives it nice kick, moonbyul is the cherry on top.
Haha my girl Wendy, she is all about music. She looked like she want to stormed to that stage and sing with them too.
im using these immortal songs to test my new earphones im so satisfied
My beautiful beautiful girls, I will stay with you, forever and ever. Moon's rap was incorporated so well into the song I am so happy. Their voices were... simply out of this worldm
+Ima Nzurum Moon's first rap part was sublime. It kind of reminded me of MC Sniper's rap feeling.
omg solar's voice never fails to make me fangirl all the time 😍
Me too! I feel she is often times under-recognized for her vocal abilities and her ability to convey sincere emotions.
I think Moonbyul is a very "special" rapper.Her rap fits in perfectly in any song and it doesn't sound awkward or like it is from another song like it does sometimes with other groups.Idk if she writes hher raps or not but she should go to SMTM...not Unpretty Rapstar.I think she has the skill to win over the guys :))
+Adina Psyche lol no she's a good rapper but still an idol rapper. I'm pretty sure she doesn't diss people lol i 'd prefer her not to.
gabber230ful That's why I said "if" she writes her lyrics c: Maybe she can diss.We really don't know yet...
P.S: Yezi was a idol rapper too but she slayed in Unpretty
+Adina Psyche She writes her lyrics.
Adina Psyche I felt the second and third rapping parts were a little out of place..who cares tho I just want to hear Moonbyul unnie do her thing. but why don't they let her sing when she has a beautiful voice???
I think she doesn't want to because she feels more comfortable rapping(?) I don't think RBW wouldn't LET her sing just because hse doesn't have "powerful" vocals like the other three dorks
I posted 5yrs ago on this video. And today I’m posting that I saw them live in Chicago. 🥹 My moomoo heart is filled with so many emotions and love. Thank you Mamamoo for making music 🎶 that makes me feel so confident and loved. Thank you for your artistry and passion. I’ll never forget it! 💚 Till we meet again. I’ll be back to listen to this cover over and over again.
My mother actually took me to see them in Nashville as a surprise. That was a major life memory right there. I have a great mom. ❤
I was summoned bc someone commented on my comment here 6 yrs ago 😂. Let the mamamoo immortal songs marathon begins😅
Lmao I relate
Shall I summon you again? Haha
Wendy and I have the same expression going on here. The sheer amount of talent from these girls... I love mamamoo so much!
4 diff girls, 4 diff voice, 4 diff stories, made the perfect song.
Honourable mention for the backing vocalist, she was fantastic.
I love comeback season because streaming brings me back to all the immortal songs gems
wendy expression is so precious
OMG mamamoo forever like slaying life.
I'm crying nowwwww
lol I just have to comment this. hwasa's voice is so addictive, byul's rap is so on point I swear like its the best thing ever and both wheein and solar have a great voice. a perfect package
true perfect package....
Rookie groups will never come like this again 🥲
I love Wendy's reaction. Vocal legend recognizes vocal legends
mamamoo's voices BELONG together. there is no better combination. it's like hearing church bells.
Thinking the same here
they all sound perfect but since no one mention it , that falsetto in 1:30 melted my heart.
It's been 6 years, this remains the most moving song I've heard.
My heart stopped when Wheein hit that note at 3:35!!
VOCAL CARD NEVER DECLINESSSSSS
I listen kpop songs, but I never interested in any girl groups until I started listening Mamamo. Love their vocals. Once I started, can’t stop at all
This performance sealed the deal for me being a moomoo. I was amazed by their You're the Best performance that I first saw before this but being as old as I am, songs like this speak more to me. Now, I feel like Mamamoo keeps me young because they are so vibrant. I wanna adopt them as my children, since I have none. Wheein especially.
aww that's so sweet of you :) Thank you for becoming a Moomoo
What a coincidence that Wheein actually came from a broken family :(
Why do I feel like this could be in a Disney OST though it probably can't? 😂😂😂😂 MoonByul's rap is the best thing about this performance lol God blessed this group when it was being put together.
i feel movie like pearl habour or titanic or frozen would perfect for this song sing by mamamoo
When you realize that Solar is the pillar of the harmony in MMM... Her voice is suprano but love how she does the lower register for the harmony then goes up again always balancing her voice for the perfect harmony, love it much... 😘😊✌🏻
But the fact is Wheein is mamamoo's vocal pillar, Kim Dohoon (RBW'S CEO) said that Wheein is a bridge between Solar and Hwasa, Wheein is always lowering her tone for perfect harmonization
Even if you often hear mamamoo songs, Wheein always gets a pretty difficult part
But we know that our leader Solar is a belter in Mamamoo
I think so too! I feel like Wheein’s voice is the perfect in between of Solar’s and Hwasa’s voices!
@@robiatulasifah1861
Moonbyul is the one who's in charge of low notes
@@ungegreier1802 she's in charge of rapping
Actually it's wheein who is mmm's vocal pillar
Wendy the face that she did was like 'omg so talented'
My girl of course has good ears 🥰
talent sees talent
dang. now i have to binge watch Immortal Songs again. I wish they comeback to Immortal Songs
I love all there voices but wheein is just....
I don't know but I just kept on repeating her part, I just love her voice so much.
I wanna pop a question to those 103 people who dislike this performance. why the hell did u hate such beautiful rendition? it's not just Mamamoo, that woman who sing "AHEYA" was amazing too. everything was epic. come on!
that's what haters do. they are blind and deaf when too much talent hits them.
The mix between Mamamoo's voice and the woman singing Aheyaa, brought tears to my eyes, everytime I listen this song. And Moonbyul, absolutely stunning!!!!!
i still wanna know who's that girl she was so perfect someone pls tell me omg
Yeah, I was like "they literally hired a person just to specially and specifically singing 'AHEYA-HEYA'"
I know, right?!!! This performance was so perfect!
their voice compliment each other, mamamoo literally change the game in kpop group. im so happy i stan them
wendys's reaction is so priceless🥰🥰🥰
listening back to the original version after watching the "remake" they did in the 8th anniv special video 🤧 time flies so fast, but this still remains a gem 💖
Me too
Sorry. Is there a link to the remake?
Just search Mamamoo 8th Anniversary.
No way to hate mamamoo they're perfect, I love you solar-hwasa-moonbyul-wheein.
@3:45 . i teared alittle bit. i saw wendy's face. its not a face of sore or a fake smile. its a smile so sincere it makes me tear. it' s like she's in love. she is really crazy abt music and singing. i imagine she going through a sort of submission during this performance. i loved wendy. she is pretty, kind, lovely, humble, dorky and talented. i've never seen this face of wendy's, seems like only with intimacy could bring this out from her. its like i have now understand her alittle bit more. only true fans of wendy's will understand why i go my way out to point out something like this. as a proud and true fan of rv and also behalf of those who are just like me , i thank mamamoo for bringing this moment of wendy out.
i feel you
AnymorAnime this is a beautiful moment and im happy you witnessed it :)
i don't have enough words to explain how amazing mamamoo is.
Mamamoo as rookies did THAT , your faves could never
Their vocals are so perfectly matched that when they all sing high notes, it's completely harmonic. Wheein's crystal clear high notes cut straight through to even out the lower more gutteral tones of Hwasa and Solar though Solar is a little higher in pitch in volume that it doesn't clash either. When Moonbyul joins in, it's to stabilise the high notes to keep it from being too chaotic by bringing in her moderating tone. It's beautiful and I don't know the correct terminology for this but this is how I view it.
I m back after Mamamoo's 8th anniversary
Me too
I was listening to this, while working, and suddenly I‘m crying. They are so beautifully intense.
Got the goosebumps again from watching this. Also the lyrics are so beautiful
These performances should receive 100M views
No fancy costums, no fancy make-up... in fact when looking at their attire they look as if they walked in from the street.
No big dance act or flashy visuals, just 4 ladies with a mike each with a live band singing in a language I don't understand.
Nonetheless, they still hit me right in the 'feels' even when not reading the sub's
(side note, props for the original rap, if you didn't know better you would think that it was part of the original)
3:30 That girl is me watching every performance of Mamamoo on Immortal Songs
her name is solar shes the goofy leader and is on we got married with eric nam
+тαєнуυиgѕ #1 нσє that isn't Solar lol that's just a girl in the audience
No V No Life
well shit ok then
U must be really lucky to hear their live performance ahhh I'm getting jealousy :P
+Ngọc Linh I don't think she meant it literally
Byul actually has a really beautiful lower register, they should really utilize her more as a vocalist, she may not be a belter, but they sleepin on her talents. But her rapping though, damn.. it's so hard to find female rappers with her sort of, vibe/flow I guess? she has so much talent, they all do, like wow, they lucked the hell out with this group, just.. wow. I never liked kpop before, but there's really just no way around liking them, from vocals and performance to personality and chemistry, they have mastered all trades. They really are just amazing, nothing more to it.🤷
currently binging mamamoo immortal songs performances in quarantine... this one is one of my favorites and watching it again brings back so many good memories.. i remember when they were still relatively small fame wise years ago.. watching youtube videos of their fan meetups outside in a courtyard where it was a quite small gathering and they would hand out sandwiches to the fans.. they’re just as humble, and soso talented. they deserve the popularity they have now and i’m glad they’re prospering !!
I literally cry with this ??????
Ugh the traditional singer never fails to give me chills
Man.. Mamamoo on immortal songs was what got me into their music and just korean music in general back in 2015-2016.... listening to this again after a while makes me fall in love with them all over again
y'all need to stop sleeping on Mamamoo. They're easily one of if not the most talented new girl group❤❤
The lyrics are so simple yet the message they deliver is so moving that I'm crying right now T_T
VOCAL PRINCESS REACTING TO VOCAL QUEENS WOW IT’S INCREDIBLE TO SEE
"I'll live with you and plant something" will go in my wedding vow.
Mamamoo is so underrated! They should have more attention coz their so talented!
Who is watching this video while waiting for their comeback ???MAMAMOO is the BEST 👍👍👍👍 I still hear this song even though it's been 2 years now...
me
i got chills, i sweated, i was left with my jaw dropped, i cried. mamamoo is on another level
Mode on for mamamoo immortal songs marathon.
I literally watch this every day. This is my daily ritual
3:33 goosebumps. even more, 2nd year artists did this. wholesome moment!!! their lives are arts.
Aheyaa~
Mamamoo always gives justice to every songs they sang
Watch all mamamoo immortal song during the quarantine is the best thing ever.
Came from Aya and this performance STILL makes me cry. That's the power of Mamamoo.
mamamoo really made me emotional huh, and that "aheya" made this song more emotional and perfect