I never considered being captivated by a 12 & 1/2 minute video on toilet paper. Butt you got me. Thanks for such a well none (no stupid fluff) informative video.
While I haven't watched the follow up on tank treatments, that is a big one! What happens (chemical action) in the black tank is very important. I spent my career in a pulp & paper mill. The machine runs on RV/Marine toilet paper are very short for a niche market. We would stop a toilet paper winder complex at the end of a production run, switch the wrapper section to an RV wrap, change the sheet count down on the winder for smaller rolls and start the machine back up... on the same paper! THE SAME PAPER WENT IN THE RV PACKAGE!
They're such a beautiful couple. I don't think I've ever seen such chemistry in a relationship on TH-cam. I know the comment is out of context, but I had to say it. Thanks for this wonderful review, as I really needed it. And I hope you both are doing well.😊
@Wandering Weekends so after using this brand for 4 years, is it still your favorite pick? 😄 We are so excited, we picknup our Grand Design XLS 22MLE in 2 weeks!
I am not even half way through and I am impressed by your efforts. Thank you for taking the time to do this challenge. It is something many RV'rs do wonder about. I appreciate it as a newbie.
This was something that has been on my mind for our new 5th wheel! I thank you guys so so much for taking your time and I only had to spend 12 minutes! Thank you very much great video! My wife and I were both glued to the screen lol
I just started staying in my friends 45 ft fifth wheel and I’m responsible for the care and the maintenance of it. You did a wonderful job on the video. thanks very much on the detailed breakdown.
Thanks so much. We are living in our camper and have issues constantly with Scotts and it actually got worse when we switched to Scotts because we where told it was recommended by the rv store. Thanks again for taking the time to do this. GOD BLESS!
Thanks for such an informative video. We currently use the Scott RV TP but will try the Great Value TP next trip to Walmart. As a side note, I dump about 1/4 cup of Simple Green down each sink and the shower drain and 1 cup into the toilet (after dumping and rinsing) before we break camp and have never had issues with the sensors. I started doing this primarily to break down any grease/oil residue in the grey tank but it also keeps the drains from giving off any odor. Just my .02 cents worth. Happy Camping!
This is a game changer for a lots of peoples 😜and saves a lots of Time for cleaning black tank🤓🤓🤓 Great video 👍 is not about what you present 🤪 but how you Do it👍 Great presentation and setup🤙
Me and my wife agree, this was most likely the most practical and useful rv video we've seen. So glad you took the time to do the research. We use the Scott also but may have to consider a change. Thanks again, K & M.
I RV Full time and empty both tanks at the same time. Black tank first then grey to clean out the hoses. The toilet paper I use is regular old tp from the dollar store. Its already the cheapest stuff for sale and it works really well in the RV. As far as the amount of breakdown...they all breakdown eventually. If you're like me and drain every week or so then you'll never have a problem. Every 6 months or so I stick the black tank spinning cleaner into the toilet and it cleans off the sensors. But I don't get bent out of shape if my sensors are out of whack. Its a simple clean up with the spinner and its done.
Wow, we full-time in our motorhome (having so much fun!!) and have been using the Scott's septic safe. Terribly thin, so we end up using twice as much. Ugh! Thanks so much for taking the time, money, and energy to put this test together. RV'ers around the world appreciate you!!!
Something I was taught yrs ago by my dad. If you're going to a park with full hook-ups, wait till you arrive to dump your tanks. The driving will agitate the stuff and help expedite the breaking down.
Roy Davis maybe if you’re going park to park but we’re just weekenders so we arrive/ leave empty. Black tank flush and clear elbow at the valve has been essential for us! Thank you for watching and commenting. Happy camping!
@@WanderingWeekends i bought a clear elbo to connect to my TT with a black tank flush. TT is 2 years old. There was stuff in the tank that was in there for a while. Great investment. Like the TP information
I am very, very greatful you made this video. We experienced a sewer slow drain and sensor not working properly. Black tank indicator says my tank is 1/3 full, and I just dumped so I know something is stuck to a sensor and I'm thinking is toilet paper from watching your video. Thanks a million for making this video, it saves lots of money. 👌💐
Great video! I use Camco because that's what was recommended when I purchased my first trailer. I can tell you now after watching this video, I'm gonna start using Great Value.
One of the most simple yet useful videos I’ve seen. Thank you for taking the time to test out the real deal. I constantly have my tank sensors gummed up by toilet paper.
Thanks so much! Truly appreciate that. Hopefully it helps with those sensors! We did a follow up test using holding tank treatments. May wanna check that one out too... we ended up changing treatments. Here is that vid th-cam.com/video/903XEB17kEM/w-d-xo.html
AWESOME video folks! We use the Scott's rapid dissolving just like you but now it looks like we will be changing as well. Very helpful information. Thanks for sharing.
Of all the videos on TH-cam I watched every second of this one.. LOL But then again I have always wondered about this.. Thanks for taking the time to share this video..
Thank you for all your research for this video. Probably 1 of the more informative videos I've seen. We have used both the CampaChem & the Thetford in the past & found both to be rather thin & scratchy. More recently, like you, we have used the Scott but after seeing this video, the Great Value TP is probably the way we're going to go (pun intended) Thanks again!
I have now switched and we are now fixing to have our 1st pump out with it. We have a 33FT Forest River that sits in a campground year round and it is more important to have a good breakdown of the TP for this reason.Thanks!
Man! I wish I would have ran across this video BEFORE I bought my 8 roll pack of Scott tp for rv's and boats. Thanks for the review. I will be buying the Great Value next time.
Ty for sharing your findings and taking the time to do the test on the paper products. Most Rv and boat heads do need the ez break down type. Ty again, and HUGS and blessings for ALL your family. 🌠🌌🏞👍😎. HUGS from NY State. New subscriber here
The key is too always make sure there is plenty of liquid in your black water tank. It should be allowed to get close to full before dumping it and your should add some water to it after that.
Brilliant. My husband and I are having this conversation atm. Re the expense also to consider the super thin tissues will for me require to have to use more then 4 tissues virus the thicker tissues.
Great review! We love watching your videos. We are in the north Ga mountains as well. Keep those campground reviews coming we use those to know where to go.
Adam Fowler we certainly will! Several more Georgia State Parks and some COE’s this year. So glad they’re helpful. Thank you for engaging with the channel!
This was surprisingly fun to watch. Good job! We are using the Scott RV paper and i was skeptical it was really the best. I think they just slapped RV on the package.
I buy Scott, and in my RV systems, and we have two different campers that we use, often, but we also use RidEX with our campers to keep the smells down, and to break down the waste and it works very well too. I like Scotts, and for us, it is the best. We don't like Charmin, or Cottonelle, just our Scotts. I use RidEX at home too, we have a septic system at our home, no public sewer. So it works well for us. Everyone has an opinion, and even if it is different than mine/yours, doesn't make it wrong, just different. We use what we do because it works for us.
thanks, it is important to use the right paper because emptying the tank is a pain and will always say half full even when you dump if you use the wrong paper. so people it is important to watch this video.
I use Cottenelle along with a tank treatment & have never had any problems. I have a 50 gallon black tank with a Camco Tornado black tank washer and use a Valterra Sewer Solution system. It uses a small hose (1" dia?) and the force of the water used to flush the waste to the dump station works great. IMHO it works better than the large diameter hoses because once the tank valves have been closed the fresh water rinses the entire system. Since it's just me in the RV a 50 gallon tank would take a l-o-n-g time to fill up but I try to flush it when it's about 1/3 - 1/2 full to reduce unneeded weight. The RV Geeks did pretty much the same test as you did & when I discovered the Cottenelle breaks down easily I started using it. Good informative video - thanks.
OMG, thank you for this!!! Never in a million years would I have thought that I would subscribe to someone's youtube after watching only one video and it being on doopah wipe!! You two are awesome!
@@WanderingWeekends Seriously,. this experiment of yours helped us even in our home. We live on a mountain and have to buy the RV type toilet paper due to the septic system. I hate it :-( This not only helps us with the van/camper we are currently working on to start traveling, but our home as well. Warmest Regards, Eileen and Bill
my friends owned a trailer and they keep a diaper jeany in the bathroom to deposit your toilet paper in, they said it don't smell and it saves on maitenace on the system
I've heard of several folks using similar methods. It must work! Thank you for engaging with the channel. Every tidbit of info helps the next viewer! Sincerely appreciated.
Greetings from Australia. We are getting our first caravan next year and this was something I'd never thought of. Now I'll do some research on the brands we have here in Australia to see which one is best for us. Thanks for the video, we've so much to learn!
We just bought a Travel Trailer and were wondering what kind of TP we needed to buy. Thank you for providing this video. Now I know I can buy Great Value! Thanks SO much!!
Another thought on this is if you have a black tank flush system this will also assist with the dissolving of any paper products along with your chemicals
Great video and comparison, thank you! I always wondered how much the RV versus regular paper mattered so this was great! I also appreciate the softness comparison!
Being a skeptic of online reviews I was very interested in the outcome but I tested the Walmart Great Value Everyday against our standard Thetford RV which we have never had a problem with but is expensive when you count the sheets. As shown here the WM Great Value Everyday septic safe truely out performed and will be our go to and less expensive TP from now on. Thanks for pointing us to this.
My wife and I have been camping with all kinds of RV's for many years. We have always used "septic safe" toilet paper and have never had any problems with our black water tank. Of course, as with most RV systems, proper use and maintenance are key.
Gale Brown a sincere thank you for commenting. These type of real world insights are invaluable for newbies out there who really have no clue where to start. So much conflicting info out there. Thanks again and happy camping!
@@WanderingWeekends yep, true. Its amazing how sometimes there are so many products out there that all do basically the same thing, some way too expensive and some very affordable and cheap. Even with gas, prices being enough different so as to plan our refueling a little bit. Our local gas stations are a ripoff compared to just an extra 10 or 20 minutes further. Buyer must always beware. God Bless
Great video, I also did similar TP test on over 20-25 brands and I narrowed it down to Angel Soft. I will do another test with the Walmart brand and Angel Soft. Thx
I liked your test . We were just trying to figure out what toilet paper was best to use in our RV, you saved us the time and effort, Thank you.. We will go with your recommendation.
Loved your tests as it reflex mostly real world , have looked at several others found some to be very bias on their choice and out come , With paper breaking down in just water add in chemicals and its golden no more or limited concern of waste plugs !!!!
Thanks for the tip. I am actually heading out to pick up some RV supplies. I usually just use the RV brands but I think I’ll give your suggestion a try. Safe travels and happy wiping.
Good video but I was surprised to see that you didn’t test Costco Kirkland brand which we use and I find it breaks down very well, it’s septic safe and many rv’ers use it! 👍🇨🇦
Guess i am going to Walmart ..., great review , we are heading out to Serpent river campground in northern Ontario on Friday , this will be in our camper .
We like to use the Scott brand when camping thinking the name is good, after trying the feel was good and we stuck with it. After seeing this review we may have to switch. Very good review, thank you for taking the time to share and safe travels👍
One of those subjects that has no tactful way around it, but you guys pulled it off and shared some very helpful information...I too am making some changes since I was using the Single Ply and apparently besides being a bad TP, it does not breakdown very well.
RV'n in North Carolina you’re not alone! We have 3-4 new packs of Scott in the trailer... thank you for the kind words and engaging with the channel!! It’s sincerely appreciated.
I really thought this would be a bogus test - but it really was helpful and moved along well. I too was a Scott user and I am definitely switching! I have a large yacht and our toilets - all new - have been clogging more than I think they should - but because they were new I was blaming it on the toilets as just clogging more than the old ones. However - this coincided with us going to the Scott Fast Dissolving brand by a few months. We are a family that does not make any mistakes putting anything into our toilets that is not "marine toilet" safe - so I was not really thinking it was the toilet paper in this case. However it is evident that if the stuff does not break down really fast - and in marine toilets it needs to dissolve nearly instantly. Soooo, we save money and I don't work on toilet problems - big win! A BIG thank you!!
We have used White Cloud TP in our trailer, and it breaks down almost within 45 seconds and its soft. But this was still a very informative video, and thanks for posting it.
Just an FYI, I did my own trial, in plain water, with the Big Lots brand that I had in hand. Same flip flop action as you, 30 minutes, etc. and it was probably 90% dissolved by the end. So not I have two choices, Great Value or Big Lots, depending on where the nearest store is.
Did a few tests myself and found "no name" Bathroom Tissue and Camco TST orange drop ins, both from wallyworld, to be the best combo for me. No bad smells, no strong cover up smell, no problems, easy tank release, will continue to use. And I live in my Outback since I retired. Lovin' it, can clean in half an hour and no grass to cut in the hot humid south lol!
@@WanderingWeekends NE Ohio.... everything on Walmart's website says that it is out of stock. There's a chance that they might be changing it because ours listed as a blue package and it says Ultra Soft. So either they're changing the toilet paper or just changing the packaging one of the other. At least here they are. Will keep on looking.
Follow up video using tank treatments can be found here... th-cam.com/video/903XEB17kEM/w-d-xo.html
Well done!
Is the winner at Walmart?
Yes... great value brand is Walmart’s brand
Since you only wander on weekends why don't you use the heads in the park? You could even clean them!
You showed cottonelle but didn't test it. 😏 Love that tp and wanted to know how it sized up.
I never considered being captivated by a 12 & 1/2 minute video on toilet paper. Butt you got me.
Thanks for such a well none (no stupid fluff) informative video.
George Moomaw haha! I consider this a great compliment. Thank you for watching and commenting!!!
I felt the same way!! Hahahaha!
Lol butt
He said Butt. Hen hen hen
George Moomaw 😂😂😂
While I haven't watched the follow up on tank treatments, that is a big one! What happens (chemical action) in the black tank is very important.
I spent my career in a pulp & paper mill. The machine runs on RV/Marine toilet paper are very short for a niche market. We would stop a toilet paper winder complex at the end of a production run, switch the wrapper section to an RV wrap, change the sheet count down on the winder for smaller rolls and start the machine back up... on the same paper! THE SAME PAPER WENT IN THE RV PACKAGE!
Would be neat if you could do an updated video since some are not available now.
I am so impressed that you would even consider doing a video on TP, and you did a great job. Thanks.
You're welcome!
They're such a beautiful couple. I don't think I've ever seen such chemistry in a relationship on TH-cam. I know the comment is out of context, but I had to say it. Thanks for this wonderful review, as I really needed it. And I hope you both are doing well.😊
Darn... haha 😄
You guys are getting very practical here! Thanks for the fun and actually very important review.
Cheers, Eric
Anytime!! Haha
@Wandering Weekends so after using this brand for 4 years, is it still your favorite pick? 😄 We are so excited, we picknup our Grand Design XLS 22MLE in 2 weeks!
Yes it is!
@@WanderingWeekends thank you!
I am not even half way through and I am impressed by your efforts. Thank you for taking the time to do this challenge. It is something many RV'rs do wonder about. I appreciate it as a newbie.
Geovanni InUSA you’re welcome! We appreciate you watching ☺️
All that extra fire starter lol great review! Thanks so much for your time on this!
Ha! Thanks for watching!
Who’da thunk that toilet paper break down could be so entertaining.
And informative. Have a great day.
This was something that has been on my mind for our new 5th wheel! I thank you guys so so much for taking your time and I only had to spend 12 minutes! Thank you very much great video! My wife and I were both glued to the screen lol
Dan Tolle happy to help! It’s not a glamorous issue but it’s a worthwhile subject for us RV’ers! Thank you for watching and commenting. Happy camping!
As Walmart no longer sells " everyday soft" is there comparable, Or any follow up videos?
I just started staying in my friends 45 ft fifth wheel and I’m responsible for the care and the maintenance of it. You did a wonderful job on the video. thanks very much on the detailed breakdown.
Robert Vitorre you’re welcome!! Thank you for watching and commenting!!
Thanks so much. We are living in our camper and have issues constantly with Scotts and it actually got worse when we switched to Scotts because we where told it was recommended by the rv store. Thanks again for taking the time to do this. GOD BLESS!
Thanks for such an informative video. We currently use the Scott RV TP but will try the Great Value TP next trip to Walmart. As a side note, I dump about 1/4 cup of Simple Green down each sink and the shower drain and 1 cup into the toilet (after dumping and rinsing) before we break camp and have never had issues with the sensors. I started doing this primarily to break down any grease/oil residue in the grey tank but it also keeps the drains from giving off any odor. Just my .02 cents worth. Happy Camping!
Good set up for your next trip because except for the toilet none of that is making past the sink P-traps .
This is a game changer for a lots of peoples 😜and saves a lots of Time for cleaning black tank🤓🤓🤓
Great video 👍 is not about what you present 🤪 but how you Do it👍
Great presentation and setup🤙
Another that breaks down well is the Kirkland brand from Costco. Decent softness as well.
Kirkland caused pyramid for me
@@mozberg2191 I’ve been using it fo about 7 years, and never had a problem. Might depend on what chemical is used.
Me and my wife agree, this was most likely the most practical and useful rv video we've seen. So glad you took the time to do the research. We use the Scott also but may have to consider a change. Thanks again, K & M.
Imagine Travels Thanks guys! We sincerely appreciate the support! Happy travels out there.
Good review; interesting to see the comparison. Thanks for sharing the results. Y'all Be Safe!
Thanks for doing this! I got lucky and was already using great value 2 ply. Will definitely stick with it!
Thank you all for sharing this information with the public! This is the information needed
You bet!
I RV Full time and empty both tanks at the same time. Black tank first then grey to clean out the hoses. The toilet paper I use is regular old tp from the dollar store. Its already the cheapest stuff for sale and it works really well in the RV. As far as the amount of breakdown...they all breakdown eventually. If you're like me and drain every week or so then you'll never have a problem. Every 6 months or so I stick the black tank spinning cleaner into the toilet and it cleans off the sensors. But I don't get bent out of shape if my sensors are out of whack. Its a simple clean up with the spinner and its done.
Wow, we full-time in our motorhome (having so much fun!!) and have been using the Scott's septic safe. Terribly thin, so we end up using twice as much. Ugh! Thanks so much for taking the time, money, and energy to put this test together. RV'ers around the world appreciate you!!!
You’re welcome!! We appreciate you guys watching!!!
Something I was taught yrs ago by my dad. If you're going to a park with full hook-ups, wait till you arrive to dump your tanks. The driving will agitate the stuff and help expedite the breaking down.
Roy Davis maybe if you’re going park to park but we’re just weekenders so we arrive/ leave empty. Black tank flush and clear elbow at the valve has been essential for us! Thank you for watching and commenting. Happy camping!
Wandering Weekends I
@@WanderingWeekends i bought a clear elbo to connect to my TT with a black tank flush. TT is 2 years old. There was stuff in the tank that was in there for a while. Great investment. Like the TP information
I am very, very greatful you made this video. We experienced a sewer slow drain and sensor not working properly. Black tank indicator says my tank is 1/3 full, and I just dumped so I know something is stuck to a sensor and I'm thinking is toilet paper from watching your video. Thanks a million for making this video, it saves lots of money. 👌💐
Great video! I use Camco because that's what was recommended when I purchased my first trailer. I can tell you now after watching this video, I'm gonna start using Great Value.
The Lost Texan same here!!
One of the most simple yet useful videos I’ve seen. Thank you for taking the time to test out the real deal. I constantly have my tank sensors gummed up by toilet paper.
Thanks so much! Truly appreciate that. Hopefully it helps with those sensors! We did a follow up test using holding tank treatments. May wanna check that one out too... we ended up changing treatments. Here is that vid th-cam.com/video/903XEB17kEM/w-d-xo.html
AWESOME video folks! We use the Scott's rapid dissolving just like you but now it looks like we will be changing as well. Very helpful information. Thanks for sharing.
Thanks! The Scots did a little better once chemicals were added but Great Value still outperformed. Happy camping and thanks for watching!
Of all the videos on TH-cam I watched every second of this one.. LOL But then again I have always wondered about this.. Thanks for taking the time to share this video..
Wonderful video. And the results really did speak for themselves!
Thank you for all your research for this video. Probably 1 of the more informative videos I've seen. We have used both the CampaChem & the Thetford in the past & found both to be rather thin & scratchy. More recently, like you, we have used the Scott but after seeing this video, the Great Value TP is probably the way we're going to go (pun intended) Thanks again!
Marcy Webb 😂😂💩 thank you for the engagement... everyone’s story adds to the video! Happy camping!
I have now switched and we are now fixing to have our 1st pump out with it. We have a 33FT Forest River that sits in a campground year round and it is more important to have a good breakdown of the TP for this reason.Thanks!
Man! I wish I would have ran across this video BEFORE I bought my 8 roll pack of Scott tp for rv's and boats. Thanks for the review. I will be buying the Great Value next time.
Same!
Ty for sharing your findings and taking the time to do the test on the paper products. Most Rv and boat heads do need the ez break down type. Ty again, and HUGS and blessings for ALL your family. 🌠🌌🏞👍😎. HUGS from NY State. New subscriber here
Welcome! So glad you're here. We love some hugs... right back at ya!
Happy Easter. Looking forward to seeing more videos soon. 🌞🦋💐. Happy Holidays for whatever holiday you celebrate .
Thank you for taking the time to do this!
Of course! I hope it was helpful!
The key is too always make sure there is plenty of liquid in your black water tank. It should be allowed to get close to full before dumping it and your should add some water to it after that.
Brilliant. My husband and I are having this conversation atm. Re the expense also to consider the super thin tissues will for me require to have to use more then 4 tissues virus the thicker tissues.
I was curious about RV tp and you have answered my curiousity. Thank you very much for your research and efforts!
American Patriot Happy to do it! Thank you for watching and commenting.
I have read several threads on TP for RV, but this video really puts it into perspective. Thanks for "going" the extra mile!
Haha! Happy camping!
Great review! We love watching your videos. We are in the north Ga mountains as well. Keep those campground reviews coming we use those to know where to go.
Adam Fowler we certainly will! Several more Georgia State Parks and some COE’s this year. So glad they’re helpful. Thank you for engaging with the channel!
This was surprisingly fun to watch. Good job! We are using the Scott RV paper and i was skeptical it was really the best. I think they just slapped RV on the package.
I buy Scott, and in my RV systems, and we have two different campers that we use, often, but we also use RidEX with our campers to keep the smells down, and to break down the waste and it works very well too.
I like Scotts, and for us, it is the best. We don't like Charmin, or Cottonelle, just our Scotts. I use RidEX at home too, we have a septic system at our home, no public sewer. So it works well for us.
Everyone has an opinion, and even if it is different than mine/yours, doesn't make it wrong, just different.
We use what we do because it works for us.
Very eye opening! We're still pretty new to the RV life and have been buying the Scott stuff. Think we may need to switch too!!
thanks, it is important to use the right paper because emptying the tank is a pain and will always say half full even when you dump if you use the wrong paper. so people it is important to watch this video.
I use Cottenelle along with a tank treatment & have never had any problems. I have a 50 gallon black tank with a Camco Tornado black tank washer and use a Valterra Sewer Solution system. It uses a small hose (1" dia?) and the force of the water used to flush the waste to the dump station works great. IMHO it works better than the large diameter hoses because once the tank valves have been closed the fresh water rinses the entire system. Since it's just me in the RV a 50 gallon tank would take a l-o-n-g time to fill up but I try to flush it when it's about 1/3 - 1/2 full to reduce unneeded weight.
The RV Geeks did pretty much the same test as you did & when I discovered the Cottenelle breaks down easily I started using it.
Good informative video - thanks.
Al Ewers great insight! Thank you for engaging the channel. Every comment helps the next viewer learn a little more. Happy camping out there!
Charmin Ultra Soft, very nice and breaks down well..
Robert Moore Charmin didn’t fare too well in our follow up test. Folks swear by it though so if it works for you then keep on wiping 😊.
Thank you so much for taking the time to test these. You've definitely saved me money!
we appreciate you watching!
John Wayne TP. It’s rough and tough and don’t take no crap from nobody!
OMG, thank you for this!!! Never in a million years would I have thought that I would subscribe to someone's youtube after watching only one video and it being on doopah wipe!! You two are awesome!
Awe! Thanks! We think its funny many of our subscribers have "met" us through this vid. If we end up being the TP couple we're good with it! Haha.
@@WanderingWeekends Seriously,. this experiment of yours helped us even in our home. We live on a mountain and have to buy the RV type toilet paper due to the septic system. I hate it :-( This not only helps us with the van/camper we are currently working on to start traveling, but our home as well. Warmest Regards, Eileen and Bill
One of the best videos on this subject I’ve seen yet. I’ll be trying Great Value for this year’s adventures.
Cummins Camping sincerely appreciate that! We’re switching too! Thanks for watching and commenting.
my friends owned a trailer and they keep a diaper jeany in the bathroom to deposit your toilet paper in, they said it don't smell and it saves on maitenace on the system
I've heard of several folks using similar methods. It must work! Thank you for engaging with the channel. Every tidbit of info helps the next viewer! Sincerely appreciated.
@fladave99 Mills Yeah, 4 squares and a wad is not going to do it for me....huum maybe a banna leaf! hahaha
That sounds absolutely disgusting
completely unnecessary. put any kind of tp in the holding tank. it all drains three a three inch pipe to the campground system. REDICULOUS.
@@STEVEID1946 lol. You CLEARLY have no idea what you're talking about 😂😂😂
Greetings from Australia. We are getting our first caravan next year and this was something I'd never thought of. Now I'll do some research on the brands we have here in Australia to see which one is best for us. Thanks for the video, we've so much to learn!
Greetings!! Let us know what you find!
Great video! Thank you. We are going to switch to Great Value! I love your faucet as well. See you on the road!
We're switching too!! Safe travels!
Here's the faucet... amzn.to/2Ts6Dfb We took a chance on a cheapo and after a year we've been happy!
We just bought a Travel Trailer and were wondering what kind of TP we needed to buy. Thank you for providing this video. Now I know I can buy Great Value! Thanks SO much!!
You are welcome!!
I like that you did this video. I think if you have a water saving toilet one ply is best. The thick stuff can sit on your sensors.
Awesome job, you two! This actually helped me a lot. I've always wondered about this for my rig.
Maria Welty so glad!! Thank you for watching and commenting!!
Another thought on this is if you have a black tank flush system this will also assist with the dissolving of any paper products along with your chemicals
It is surprising what the flush removes. I wouldn't have an RV without one after seeing it work.
5 times cheaper than the specialty stuff .. that's quite a savings over an entire camping season! Thanks for your video.
Great video and comparison, thank you! I always wondered how much the RV versus regular paper mattered so this was great! I also appreciate the softness comparison!
vitaminbp1 you’re welcome!!
I always thought RV toilet paper was a ripoff. Thanks for your video. Great timing.
Being a skeptic of online reviews I was very interested in the outcome but I tested the Walmart Great Value Everyday against our standard Thetford RV which we have never had a problem with but is expensive when you count the sheets. As shown here the WM Great Value Everyday septic safe truely out performed and will be our go to and less expensive TP from now on. Thanks for pointing us to this.
You’re welcome!!
My wife and I have been camping with all kinds of RV's for many years. We have always used "septic safe" toilet paper and have never had any problems with our black water tank. Of course, as with most RV systems, proper use and maintenance are key.
Gale Brown a sincere thank you for commenting. These type of real world insights are invaluable for newbies out there who really have no clue where to start. So much conflicting info out there. Thanks again and happy camping!
The wife and I use the best TP always We do use the garbage 🗑 though, it doesn’t go in the tank.
We got a kitty litter disposal similar to diaper Genie, but smaller. Holds any smells away, and very easy to maintain.
Yuck!
Nice, excellent video. Very thorough. Thanks folks. I think the most important thing is the paper being septic safe. Happy n safe RVing
Maybe... but keep in mind all of these papers were labeled "septic safe" and broke down differently. I dunno?!
@@WanderingWeekends yep, true. Its amazing how sometimes there are so many products out there that all do basically the same thing, some way too expensive and some very affordable and cheap. Even with gas, prices being enough different so as to plan our refueling a little bit. Our local gas stations are a ripoff compared to just an extra 10 or 20 minutes further. Buyer must always beware. God Bless
Blessings to you guys!
Great, scientific way to choose the right TP for an RV. Thanks!
Susan Carlson you’re very welcome! 😊
Very thoughtful to test all these brands... Thank you
You are welcome! Hope it was useful!
We use Angel Soft and have never had a problem in the three years we've been camping. Love the video!
Scott Michel Angle Soft did better than the Scott “rapid dissolving” we were tricked into using!! 😂😂
@@WanderingWeekends it's all in the name! Lol have a great night.
Great video, I also did similar TP test on over 20-25 brands and I narrowed it down to Angel Soft. I will do another test with the Walmart brand and Angel Soft. Thx
I liked your test . We were just trying to figure out what toilet paper was best to use in our RV, you saved us the time and effort, Thank you.. We will go with your recommendation.
Loved your tests as it reflex mostly real world , have looked at several others found some to be very bias on their choice and out come , With paper breaking down in just water add in chemicals and its golden no more or limited concern of waste plugs !!!!
We keep a cover waste bin so we don't worry about paper breaking down and as long as it's thrown away every other day there's no smell.
Thanks for the tip. I am actually heading out to pick up some RV supplies. I usually just use the RV brands but I think I’ll give your suggestion a try. Safe travels and happy wiping.
EOW weekend RVer appreciate you stopping by! Happy camping!
Good video but I was surprised to see that you didn’t test Costco Kirkland brand which we use and I find it breaks down very well, it’s septic safe and many rv’ers use it! 👍🇨🇦
Guess i am going to Walmart ..., great review , we are heading out to Serpent river campground in northern Ontario on Friday , this will be in our camper .
I bet the cashier at the Walmart gave you a funny look when you bought all that tp. Haha. Great video. Thank you.
Janet Perez haha!! I should have thrown a few buckets of ex-lax into the mix to really get a look. 😂😂
😂🤣
Great test information! We are new RVers, and need all the advice we can get.
The Great Value Everyday Soft says on the package it’s comparable to Angel Soft. That’s probably why they were both the softest.
Awesome! Great value from wallmart! cheap and a bit soft. Thank you
You bet!
We like to use the Scott brand when camping thinking the name is good, after trying the feel was good and we stuck with it. After seeing this review we may have to switch. Very good review, thank you for taking the time to share and safe travels👍
Angel Torres same here! We have 4 unopened packages of the Scott’s on the RV... I guess we will use it in the house now and get the Great Value!
Thanks for doing this. I hate paying for rv toilet paper. Picked up some great value for this spring.
Shirley Gray you’re welcome. Hopefully you saved a buck or two! Happy camping!
Great video. It will save us money going forward. Would love to see a comparison that included Kirkland brand.
Great Value it is. We use the same brand RV paper you use I think we will try the Great Value. Can’t beat the price. ❤️
where do you get it from?
Walmart brand
Been using regular Scott, no problems. Will put great value in the rotation.
This had me on the edge of my ((toilet)) seat the whole time for this very well thought out and well done video. +1 for you guys!!
Barry Dutton Sells Homes thanks Barry! Sincerely appreciate it.
Me too! But i wasn't on the throne that long!
One of those subjects that has no tactful way around it, but you guys pulled it off and shared some very helpful information...I too am making some changes since I was using the Single Ply and apparently besides being a bad TP, it does not breakdown very well.
RV'n in North Carolina you’re not alone! We have 3-4 new packs of Scott in the trailer... thank you for the kind words and engaging with the channel!! It’s sincerely appreciated.
Thanks for doing that. Always wondered and thought Scott 1000 was what I should have been using. Now I know....
I really thought this would be a bogus test - but it really was helpful and moved along well. I too was a Scott user and I am definitely switching! I have a large yacht and our toilets - all new - have been clogging more than I think they should - but because they were new I was blaming it on the toilets as just clogging more than the old ones. However - this coincided with us going to the Scott Fast Dissolving brand by a few months. We are a family that does not make any mistakes putting anything into our toilets that is not "marine toilet" safe - so I was not really thinking it was the toilet paper in this case. However it is evident that if the stuff does not break down really fast - and in marine toilets it needs to dissolve nearly instantly.
Soooo, we save money and I don't work on toilet problems - big win! A BIG thank you!!
Glad you enjoyed.
We are newbies to the camping world and loving yalls videos. Y’all are so much fun to watch!
Welcome!! Don't hesitate to say hi if you see us out!!
We have used White Cloud TP in our trailer, and it breaks down almost within 45 seconds and its soft. But this was still a very informative video, and thanks for posting it.
Oh Lawd…”Happy Wipen’”…lol, I about fell out of my chair!
😂🤣🤗🤓
I didn't need to know but I am glad I watched. Thank you. Very informative.
Great video on a touchy subject.
Thanks for your time to figure this out! Sure helped me.
So glad! Happy camping!
Just an FYI, I did my own trial, in plain water, with the Big Lots brand that I had in hand. Same flip flop action as you, 30 minutes, etc. and it was probably 90% dissolved by the end. So not I have two choices, Great Value or Big Lots, depending on where the nearest store is.
Great info! Thank you!
Great experiment! We’re often looking frantically for the rv tp but will definitely switch to your choice too! New subscriber here.
cocacolafiesta Welcome! So glad you’re here!😊
Thanks for doing this...I've always wondered this but never tested it!!
Thank you. I was actually about to buy Scott. Appreciate your video
Roxane McDaniel we are grateful you watched!!
Did a few tests myself and found "no name" Bathroom Tissue and Camco TST orange drop ins, both from wallyworld, to be the best combo for me. No bad smells, no strong cover up smell, no problems, easy tank release, will continue to use. And I live in my Outback since I retired. Lovin' it, can clean in half an hour and no grass to cut in the hot humid south lol!
Thanks for the video! I dont want to pay for camper tissue so I've been using the walmart off brand and very glad to see it breaks down so well! 😀👊
Glad it was helpful!
Very good video, I always wondered about RV/ marine TP.
Great job... Love the insight.... Finding that Great Value Everyday Soft is rare as hens teeth... We'll keep looking though..👍😁
Oh wow... where are you located? It's all over the place here in northern GA. Hope you have better luck finding some!
@@WanderingWeekends NE Ohio.... everything on Walmart's website says that it is out of stock. There's a chance that they might be changing it because ours listed as a blue package and it says Ultra Soft. So either they're changing the toilet paper or just changing the packaging one of the other. At least here they are. Will keep on looking.
Sam's club MembersMark breaks down very well also.