Hearing that Parvati got a call is both comforting that they're still willing to cast old school players, but discouraging that they might go back to the same old well instead of giving other terrific people a second shot.
Agree with this. Some of the players, while very good and entertaining, have returned so many times that I think they need to stop 😂 I personally am not a Parvati fan to begin with so I’d be disappointed to see her take a spot, but I know she’s a fan favorite.
I really hope they bring back some pre-40 players for Season 50. I would love to see Christian, Dom, and Devens get another shot especially. And old school players like Shane Powers would be a lot of fun. I'm guessing it is more likely to be along the lines of Second Chances 2 because I think there needs to be new era players that play twice before there is something like a Legends season.
Shane won't be asked back on a seaosn with 50% POC casting as he's spoken against it on social media. A lot of the White players pre season 41 wouldn't survive on the current format and Shane is one of them. It would take all of two seconds for him to piss off his majority POC tribe to be unceremoniously dumped as an early pre merge vote off. Not to mention the newer cast would have pre gammed and have closer relationships.
I’m not trying to argue that the new era is harder than 39 days or anything, but don’t forget about the fact that they basically give them no food now. Even though it’s 26 days it must be HARD to not eat…
Your old school picks are really great choices. Lots of entertaining players who have the potential to play a much better game with small tweaks and having learned from their seasons.
We need a ‘Survivor: Season of Chaos’ where it’s just all of the most chaotic players who ever played. Half the cast of Gabon, Angelina, Coach, Carolyn, Coach, Shamboe, Shane, Emily, etc.
@tgraham1961 doing something like survivor will surely make you realize things about yourself. And that’s just the course it took for Emily, learning about herself. I’m not sure what you mean by “survivor is survivor” because Emily’s journey is EXACTLY what survivor is to me
I know this sounds like an Edge twist but after Winners at War, I feel that all All-Star seasons, players who gets voted out (or evacuated) should be on the jury.
@@WenNRomeI think it’d be the other way around cause cody is actually a good player but his edit got overshadowed by all the jessie dicksucking the editors did
I’ll add that Devon Pinto definitely deserves a Second Chance! His game was excellent and impressive and he had to deal with unfavorable and unexpected circumstances.
They really need a good mix of players from pre 41 to come back, some of these players have waited a long time for a second shot and we need to see them come back I mean Dom Christian Devens and Chrissy should just be solid locks to bring back at this point as well as T-Bird Nat and Sean and if she ever would play again Taj they would just make for such a great season
My two biggest concerns for a new school v old school season is 1: The age differences. Most of the pre HvV players are getting up there in age (45-60 years old) while new school, for the most part would be considerably younger. Don’t think it would necessarily be as lopsided as season 21 but it’s definitely a concern. And 2: We’ve already seen a bit of a glimpse of what a new school v old school season would look like with WaW. Old school got smoked. And now the game is even faster and more chaotic. It would be nice to see a bunch of old school players but it would suck to see them get annihilated as soon as they step on the island. I think a 2nd Second Chance, including only one time players since the last second Chance season would be the most fun and realistic season 50 we could ask for
@@Sixersszn0 I wanted to make the greatest trainwreck the show has ever seen with the tools at our disposal. I think it's semi-realistic, too, though, Coach may be a stretch.
Shan's been a villain after show, yeah. Post-Survivor she actually did a bunch of con artist stuff by scamming people out of their money through some religious pretense, and told people "you'll get your reward in heaven". Going and callously telling people "I'll pay you back once you're dead", is all kinds of...ooof.
I think you should make a part 2 to this video eventually for just new era players as I see it that survivor won’t bring back any players before season 41
Old school players: -Michelle (Fiji) -Natalie (Micronesia) -Teresa (Africa) -Tijuana (Pearl Islands) -Sierra (Tocantins) -Greg (Borneo) -Sean (Marquesas) -Rafe (Guatemala) -Shane (Exile Island) -Erik (Samoa) I know I included most pre survivor 21 players but these are the first names that come to mind.
I am sorry but Caroline, Shane, Courtney and Angelina on the same beach would be INSANE the mess that would that be 😭😭😭 Angelina would be like “Shane can I please have your coke” 😂😂😂😂😂😂
From the old schoolers I would've picked Earl. Firstly, all stars season imo needs a former winner (even if it would've left a major target on his back). Secondly, he was asked back so many times, but only had to refuse, so maybe now he could've appeared
Taj is always my first pic for a returnee player. It's probably because she's been so vocal about how she never plans on returning despite many offers to do so. I think we might have to settle for the various SWV miniseries
It's a travesty that Shane hasn't been back on the show. He was one of the best characters from old school era. Also, this list is great. Great combination of great and messy players. Many of them were my pics for wanting to win also.
I think there needs to be a survivor new era all stars so that all the new era players get their own time to mix with each other. I feel like if we have players from seasons 1-40 compete with the new era players it will just clash
It will be a repeat of Winners at War. The newer winners banned together to vote off the older winners. It's not mistake the majority of the winners at the end came from the later seasons (28-39). I know ppl want to see players post game changers, and before that but the majority of the season 50 cast will be from seasons 41-49. The older players will just be dumped off early and have their reputation tarnished. The truth is season 40 should have been All Stars/Second chance 2 for everyone from seasons 24-39. An all winners seasons would of made more sense season 50 as we'd have more POC winners for representation.
I am thinking we have all post 20 players as follows: Ricard Foye - Season 41 Omar Zaheer - Season 42 Josh Canfield - Season 29 Malcom Freberg - Season 25, 26, 34 Matt Blankinship - Season 44 Austin Li Coon - Season 45 Spencer Bledsoe - Season 28, 31 Troyzan - Season 24, 34 Tai Trang - Season 32, 34 Q - Season 46 Carolyn Rivera - Season 30 Michaela Bradshaw - Season 33, 34 Lauren Beck - Season 39 Naonka - Season 21 Edna Ma - Season 23 Abi Maria - Season 25, 31 Shan Smith - Season 41 Frannie Marin - Season 44 Jem Hussein - Adams - Season 46 One player from 47, 48, or 49
If s47 is allstars, id like this to be the cast: Males: 1. Rick Devens 2. Domenick 3. Dean Kowalski 4. S42 Jonathan 5. Jesse 6. Cody 7. Carson 8. Bruce 9. Austin 10. Hunter Females 1. S35 Crissy 2. Angelina 3. Victoria 4. Janet 5. Noura 6. Shantel 7. Karla 8. Carolyn 9. Emily 10. Venus
Definitely Christian he was sooo fun to watch one of the reasons why David vs Goliath was so good, I will never forget that immunity win and he definitely makes that season one of my all time favourites bring him back pleasee
I agree with a lot of your choices! As soon as I saw the title I said this list HAS to include Carolyn Wiger, Rick Devens, and Christian Hubicki. Christy Smith and Kaleb Gebrewold are players I also agree on. I'd also like to see Noelle Lambert, Brian Corridan, Bobby Mason, Sabrina Thompson, Laurel Johnson (kidding!), Matty Whitmore, Trisha Hegarty, Michael Yerger, Hannah Shapiro, Roark Luskin, Omar Zaheer, Reem Daly, Zane Knight, Devon Pinto, and Elaine Stott. Also, this one may seem odd but Billy Garcia!
Probably any player from 30-41 might be brought back but I don’t think anyone before heroes vs villains at the earliest because that might not be possible for any reason but who knows
Always happy to see some Kenny representation on these sorts of list. From the budget era, I'd also be ok with Emily (if she's willing), MGM, Karla, Jonathan, Lindsey, Omar, and Ricard on there as well.
Jonathan (42) is a literal cheat code in Survivor! Heather (41) deserves a second chance. Shane Powers (Exile Island) just for the sake of seeing how crazy he goes without cigarettes again. Alecia (Koah Rong) was wronged by producers for being assigned the Brawn tribe instead of Beauty tribe. She started the fire for her tribe and went idol hunting while being constantly harassed by the two most immature men of the season. Give her the second chance she deserves! Brett (Samoa) almost won the whole thing. And was severely under-edited in the show. Billy (Cook Islands) just for sheer entertainment. Twila (Vanuatu) because she’s overdue for a second chance. Ian (Palau) would be a gem to see play again. RC (Philippines) would be awesome. Cydney (Kaoh Rong) would have won if she beat Aubry in the fire making challenge. Bring her back too!
Your list is golden! I hope Probst is watching. The only thing is I’d swap out Karishma for Ricard and Rafe for Emily. And you have to consider Davie, Carl “the godfather” Boudreaux, and Natalie “the-no-jacket-giving Cole all from S37
Other than Shan and Carolyn, our new school wishlists are pretty much the exact same (I only say pretty much because Dom wasn't originally on my list, but you convinced me that he should be)
You replace Natalie with Dawn in Fans vs Favorites 2, I think the favorites come out looking pretty good with Cochran, Andrea, Malcolm, and Erik as favorites, Phillip, Brenda, Natalie, Corrine, and Brandon as favorites of production, with Francesca as the outlier
New School - Austin, Jake, Dom, Carolyn, Ricard, Rick Devens, Xander, Mike, Chrissy Old School - Yul, Earl, Natalie Bolton, Courtney Yates, Kenny, Natalie White, Taj, Erik, Yau-Man
Here is my 20 for an all stars style season. Meaning people who have played only once but have legend potential: Women: Lauren (38) Victoria (38) Lauren (39) Sabrina (24) Cydney (32) Shan (41) Angelina (37) Dee (45) Erika (41) Emily (45) Men: Devens (38) Devon (35) Christian (37) Omar (42) Jesse (43) Q (46) Kaleb (45) Davie (37) Chris U (38) Tommy (39)
My little wish list: Kaleb Noelle Chris Underwood Gabler- yes Gabler. I apologize. Alec M Reem Christian Hubecki Jonathan Carolyn Q Everyone else Meh Addendum: may I add DAVIE
This is a perfect cast. Was it 20 people? I was hoping the end would show every pick of yours. & tbh I don’t care much for Christian to come back. I would choose Q.
My (realistic) dream cast would be to follow the second chance theme and allow viewers to vote on who they want to see back. I would choose two people from each of the new era seasons (so 18 people) and then the other 14 from any season before 40. LET THE PEOPLE VOTE!
Q is the most entertaining, charismatic, strong willed villain player in the last 20 seasons. Q needs to come back, he has the potential to be one of the greatest players ever
I love T Bird but why is she the only one mentioned from Africa - I want the Samburu young four - Kim Powers, Lindsey, Silas and Brandon. Damn I hate how that season turned out. Also, I want Tijuana, Darrah and Lill from Pearl Islands. I wish one of them won
Previous Winners that should return - Richard Hatch, Vecepia, Todd, Sandra, Tony.... also Greg from season 1, Elizabeth season 2 (even though shes was a talk show host). I hope they bring more old school players back from the original seasons.
This would be my personal second chance cast, I know that not all of these choices are realistic and some of them might not even want to play but this would be my dream cast: Guys: Omar (42) Reed (San Juan Del Sur) Kaleb (45) Christian (David Vs Goliath) Domenick(Ghost Island) Judd (Guatemala) Jessie (43) Sean (Marquesas) Ricard (41) Ken (Gabon) Girls: Karla (43) Julie (Vanuatu) Desi (Heroes vs Healers Vs Hustlers) Cydney (Kaoh Rong) Lindsey (42) Teresa/T-Bird (Africa) Michelle (Fiji) Victoria (Edge of Extinction) Carolyn (44) Kelle (Island of the Idols)
Deep down we know they would separate it from 41 but this is a dream scenario that we all wish for
Parvati confirmed she got a call, from what I read on the Survivor reddit.
Bro how did you comment 12 DAYS AGO
@@lukelehman3probably a premiere
@@denzel8827 Patreon
01:52
I love how he calls it the “budget era” instead of the “new era”
He's not wrong
@@iankinnell5643 True. We would have needed a new name for it anyway after it became outdated
Yeah that's a great term.
Hearing that Parvati got a call is both comforting that they're still willing to cast old school players, but discouraging that they might go back to the same old well instead of giving other terrific people a second shot.
Agree with this. Some of the players, while very good and entertaining, have returned so many times that I think they need to stop 😂 I personally am not a Parvati fan to begin with so I’d be disappointed to see her take a spot, but I know she’s a fan favorite.
When’s she say she got a call
“Budget era” - love this terminology, much more accurate
I really hope they bring back some pre-40 players for Season 50. I would love to see Christian, Dom, and Devens get another shot especially. And old school players like Shane Powers would be a lot of fun. I'm guessing it is more likely to be along the lines of Second Chances 2 because I think there needs to be new era players that play twice before there is something like a Legends season.
Great choices
Shane won't be asked back on a seaosn with 50% POC casting as he's spoken against it on social media. A lot of the White players pre season 41 wouldn't survive on the current format and Shane is one of them. It would take all of two seconds for him to piss off his majority POC tribe to be unceremoniously dumped as an early pre merge vote off. Not to mention the newer cast would have pre gammed and have closer relationships.
devens was robbed in edge of extinction
I hope season 50 has 39 days cause I wanna see how the new era folks handle it
Agreed
I’m not trying to argue that the new era is harder than 39 days or anything, but don’t forget about the fact that they basically give them no food now. Even though it’s 26 days it must be HARD to not eat…
Your old school picks are really great choices. Lots of entertaining players who have the potential to play a much better game with small tweaks and having learned from their seasons.
What a coincidence that Jeff announces that 50 is returning players yesterday.
It worked out beautifully.
I remain confident that Angelina has not achieved any self-awareness.
(I heard that she got rice for the team once, and never spoke of it again).
she was so shallow...she should sell kiddie pools
33- Jay
35- Devon, Chrissy
36- Dom
37- Christian, Angelina
38- Devins
41- Shan, Ricard, Xander
42- Jonathan, Omar, Tori
43- Cody, Jesse, Karla
44- Carolyn
45- Kaleb, Drew, Emily, Kellie, Sabiyah
46- Q, Tevin, Jelinsky
I feel like Noelle could be a contender as well. Just my opinion
It would be cruel to bring back some of the 46 players, like jelinsky jess or bhanu.
jelinsky??
No more of that Jelegendary poser lol
TEVIN?! Lmao please. Venus, Charlie, Hunter >>>
We need a ‘Survivor: Season of Chaos’ where it’s just all of the most chaotic players who ever played.
Half the cast of Gabon, Angelina, Coach, Carolyn, Coach, Shamboe, Shane, Emily, etc.
That’s the only place I would want to see Emily back. Survivor is survivor, not “learn not to be a sociopath”
Also need Abi Maria in there. That would make a great season.
gotta have chaos kass back in there too
@tgraham1961 doing something like survivor will surely make you realize things about yourself. And that’s just the course it took for Emily, learning about herself. I’m not sure what you mean by “survivor is survivor” because Emily’s journey is EXACTLY what survivor is to me
I agrée!
AMAZON CHRISTY MENTIONED LET'S GOOO
I know this sounds like an Edge twist but after Winners at War, I feel that all All-Star seasons, players who gets voted out (or evacuated) should be on the jury.
Love almost all of your picks. Jesse can’t be back without Cody, the guy who needs the second chance the most after that brutal betrayal.
And that was quite brutal......I actually liked Cody
It actually would be best if he came back w/o CODY
@@WenNRomeI’d much rather see Cody back. So lovable
@@Ryan_Tiziano yeah either one
@@WenNRomeI think it’d be the other way around cause cody is actually a good player but his edit got overshadowed by all the jessie dicksucking the editors did
I saw Natalie Bolton and clicked so fast 😭
You’re not the only one haha
If not Survivor she is PERFECT for The Traitors.
she's fake asf
So real
^
So glad you listed Tai from Tocantins, i love her! Also totally need Devon, Christian and Shan!
Bring back Omar from season 42
No, thank you
No
yes
6:16 HELLO SORRY WHAT?!?!?! Gabon is WILD even all these years later 🤣
PLEASEEEEE
I’ll add that Devon Pinto definitely deserves a Second Chance! His game was excellent and impressive and he had to deal with unfavorable and unexpected circumstances.
He mentioned that he would only return on a blood vs water season with his mom
the applebees moment got topped🤣
I love your list, particularly the Krishna and Angelina picks.
I would love an old era vs new era 20 players 2 tribes and 39 days.
They really need a good mix of players from pre 41 to come back, some of these players have waited a long time for a second shot and we need to see them come back I mean Dom Christian Devens and Chrissy should just be solid locks to bring back at this point as well as T-Bird Nat and Sean and if she ever would play again Taj they would just make for such a great season
My two biggest concerns for a new school v old school season is 1: The age differences. Most of the pre HvV players are getting up there in age (45-60 years old) while new school, for the most part would be considerably younger. Don’t think it would necessarily be as lopsided as season 21 but it’s definitely a concern. And 2: We’ve already seen a bit of a glimpse of what a new school v old school season would look like with WaW. Old school got smoked. And now the game is even faster and more chaotic. It would be nice to see a bunch of old school players but it would suck to see them get annihilated as soon as they step on the island. I think a 2nd Second Chance, including only one time players since the last second Chance season would be the most fun and realistic season 50 we could ask for
Why not have it be formatted like HvV where there's old school and new schoo team
Purple tribe:
- Q
- Angelina
- Venus
- Coach
- Carolyn
- Jake
Green tribe:
- Christian
- Mike Turner
- Cody
- Janet
- Noelle
- Emily
Orange Tribe:
- Davie
- Dominic
- Kaleb
- Elaine
- Cydney
- Natalie (16)
That Purple tribe is filled with entertainment 💀
Swap out two of the green or orange tribe girls with Shamboe and and Sugar you got a chaos season
Cydney unfortunately will probably never play again, she’s a world champion bodybuilder, she has her career to think about and focus on.
@@Sixersszn0 I wanted to make the greatest trainwreck the show has ever seen with the tools at our disposal. I think it's semi-realistic, too, though, Coach may be a stretch.
@@TransparentEclipse That's too bad! She was a great player who I think could dominate a future season.
Shan's been a villain after show, yeah. Post-Survivor she actually did a bunch of con artist stuff by scamming people out of their money through some religious pretense, and told people "you'll get your reward in heaven". Going and callously telling people "I'll pay you back once you're dead", is all kinds of...ooof.
I think you should make a part 2 to this video eventually for just new era players as I see it that survivor won’t bring back any players before season 41
Parvati confirmed she got a call.
@@OnceUponAnIslandA call for what? I’m just curious
@@societyman7526 I'm assuming a call to return lol
@@OnceUponAnIsland OH SNAP!!!!👀
A call to run for President of the United States.
Old school players:
-Michelle (Fiji)
-Natalie (Micronesia)
-Teresa (Africa)
-Tijuana (Pearl Islands)
-Sierra (Tocantins)
-Greg (Borneo)
-Sean (Marquesas)
-Rafe (Guatemala)
-Shane (Exile Island)
-Erik (Samoa)
I know I included most pre survivor 21 players but these are the first names that come to mind.
I am sorry but Caroline, Shane, Courtney and Angelina on the same beach would be INSANE the mess that would that be 😭😭😭 Angelina would be like “Shane can I please have your coke” 😂😂😂😂😂😂
From the old schoolers I would've picked Earl.
Firstly, all stars season imo needs a former winner (even if it would've left a major target on his back).
Secondly, he was asked back so many times, but only had to refuse, so maybe now he could've appeared
Man, I’d love to see Earl back
If Christian from season 37 (David vs Goliath) isn't on season 50 I don't wanna see it.
Oh, hooey! You're gonna watch.
@alkholos lol you say that as if you work on the survivor team
I want Christian back now! I would def take Angelina, Natalie and Davie as well
Good then don't watch
@@mjphoto45 ☹️
Taj is always my first pic for a returnee player. It's probably because she's been so vocal about how she never plans on returning despite many offers to do so. I think we might have to settle for the various SWV miniseries
this is a super solid list
It's a travesty that Shane hasn't been back on the show. He was one of the best characters from old school era. Also, this list is great. Great combination of great and messy players. Many of them were my pics for wanting to win also.
Christy Smith and Rob in Amazon are the players that made me fall in love with Survivor. I would love to see Christy again
Old era vs new era would go so hard
I, personally, would love for it to be New Era All Stars, but I wouldn’t mind older players back
An odd pick, but to see Richard Hatch come back one last time to just have fun and be a nuisance would be a fun time lol
No player in the history of the show deserves to come back more than Dom!
Saw Karishma and liked the video❤
I think there needs to be a survivor new era all stars so that all the new era players get their own time to mix with each other. I feel like if we have players from seasons 1-40 compete with the new era players it will just clash
It will be a repeat of Winners at War. The newer winners banned together to vote off the older winners. It's not mistake the majority of the winners at the end came from the later seasons (28-39). I know ppl want to see players post game changers, and before that but the majority of the season 50 cast will be from seasons 41-49. The older players will just be dumped off early and have their reputation tarnished. The truth is season 40 should have been All Stars/Second chance 2 for everyone from seasons 24-39. An all winners seasons would of made more sense season 50 as we'd have more POC winners for representation.
I am thinking we have all post 20 players as follows:
Ricard Foye - Season 41
Omar Zaheer - Season 42
Josh Canfield - Season 29
Malcom Freberg - Season 25, 26, 34
Matt Blankinship - Season 44
Austin Li Coon - Season 45
Spencer Bledsoe - Season 28, 31
Troyzan - Season 24, 34
Tai Trang - Season 32, 34
Q - Season 46
Carolyn Rivera - Season 30
Michaela Bradshaw - Season 33, 34
Lauren Beck - Season 39
Naonka - Season 21
Edna Ma - Season 23
Abi Maria - Season 25, 31
Shan Smith - Season 41
Frannie Marin - Season 44
Jem Hussein - Adams - Season 46
One player from 47, 48, or 49
So many players I would love to see back! Christian, Chrissy, Devin’s, Caroline, Richard, Jesse, T-bird, Taj, Kaleb and Carson
If s47 is allstars, id like this to be the cast:
Males:
1. Rick Devens
2. Domenick
3. Dean Kowalski
4. S42 Jonathan
5. Jesse
6. Cody
7. Carson
8. Bruce
9. Austin
10. Hunter
Females
1. S35 Crissy
2. Angelina
3. Victoria
4. Janet
5. Noura
6. Shantel
7. Karla
8. Carolyn
9. Emily
10. Venus
Survivor 50 is the next returnee season, Jeff confirmed this a couple days ago.
Definitely Christian he was sooo fun to watch one of the reasons why David vs Goliath was so good, I will never forget that immunity win and he definitely makes that season one of my all time favourites bring him back pleasee
I agree with a lot of your choices! As soon as I saw the title I said this list HAS to include Carolyn Wiger, Rick Devens, and Christian Hubicki. Christy Smith and Kaleb Gebrewold are players I also agree on. I'd also like to see Noelle Lambert, Brian Corridan, Bobby Mason, Sabrina Thompson, Laurel Johnson (kidding!), Matty Whitmore, Trisha Hegarty, Michael Yerger, Hannah Shapiro, Roark Luskin, Omar Zaheer, Reem Daly, Zane Knight, Devon Pinto, and Elaine Stott. Also, this one may seem odd but Billy Garcia!
devens had some of the most satisfying moments on survivor,he remains to be my fave. If he won survivor 38 would be my best season
I would love to see Jay from Mill vs GenX and and Lauren O'Connell from season 38 Edge of Extinction
I wanna see a season of underrated and forgotten players and characters
The Natalie/Ringo comparison is perfect.
Probably any player from 30-41 might be brought back but I don’t think anyone before heroes vs villains at the earliest because that might not be possible for any reason but who knows
My wishlist
Sean R - Jesse
Tevin - Mike H
Cody - Maryanne
Q - Coach
Rob C. - Dee
Dreamz - Dominic
Omar - yam yam
Emily - Shane
Kaleb - Devens
Maria
Always happy to see some Kenny representation on these sorts of list. From the budget era, I'd also be ok with Emily (if she's willing), MGM, Karla, Jonathan, Lindsey, Omar, and Ricard on there as well.
I wanna see Jess from millenials v gen x back, she deserved better than to be taken out by bullshit rock draw
This is such a good list
An overlooked player is Kyle Jason from Kaoh Rong, absolutely shocked he never comes up when talking about the big personalities of the 30s
Didn’t mention Q in your season 50 player wishlist??? BIG MISTAKE.
Seriously though Q is a 100% lock
He tried to quit idk man
@@eastonburnor4018 jeff has defended it to no end saying it wasn’t an attempted quit. If that doesn’t tell you jeff loves the guy idk what will
Is it confirmed returning season?
Yes, Jeff and Survivor made an official post the other day on their socials.
Jonathan (42) is a literal cheat code in Survivor!
Heather (41) deserves a second chance.
Shane Powers (Exile Island) just for the sake of seeing how crazy he goes without cigarettes again.
Alecia (Koah Rong) was wronged by producers for being assigned the Brawn tribe instead of Beauty tribe. She started the fire for her tribe and went idol hunting while being constantly harassed by the two most immature men of the season. Give her the second chance she deserves!
Brett (Samoa) almost won the whole thing. And was severely under-edited in the show.
Billy (Cook Islands) just for sheer entertainment.
Twila (Vanuatu) because she’s overdue for a second chance.
Ian (Palau) would be a gem to see play again.
RC (Philippines) would be awesome.
Cydney (Kaoh Rong) would have won if she beat Aubry in the fire making challenge. Bring her back too!
Your list is golden! I hope Probst is watching. The only thing is I’d swap out Karishma for Ricard and Rafe for Emily. And you have to consider Davie, Carl “the godfather” Boudreaux, and Natalie “the-no-jacket-giving Cole all from S37
Other than Shan and Carolyn, our new school wishlists are pretty much the exact same (I only say pretty much because Dom wasn't originally on my list, but you convinced me that he should be)
Q, very entertaining player. Big Mistake leaving him off of this list!
I made this before that iconic episode. Q needs to be brought back now!
@@OnceUponAnIsland 💯
I'm more of a hunter fan from this season
@@Ryno12345able Yes Hunter, no Q
We need Emily from 45 back
Emily has to want to come back first 😢
@@kingjayded4752yeahhh. super sad she said wouldn't come back, but i will still remain hopeful.
@@kennys-kennysthey always say that but they’re capping
I put it into Brantsteele and these were the results:
20th: Natalie (5-4)🧡
19th: Carolyn (7-2)💜
Tribe Switch
18th: T-Bird (6-2)🧡💜
17th: Rick Devens (5-2)💜💜
16th: Jesse (4-3)💜💜
Another Tribe Switch
15th: Chrissy (3*-2)💜🧡💚
14th: Sean (3-2)🧡🧡💚
Merge
13th: Angelina (7*-6*) (4-2-2-2-1-1-1)💜💜🧡🖤
12th: Domenick (5-4-3)💜🧡🧡🖤
11th: Karishma (6*-2-2) (6-2)💜💜💚🖤
10th: Rafe (4-1)🧡💜💜🖤
9th: Christian (3-2)💜💜💜🖤
8th: Christy (4-4) (4-2)🧡🧡🧡🖤
7th: Courtney (4-3)🧡💜🧡🖤
6th: Kenny (2-2-2-1) (3-0-0)🧡🧡🧡🖤
5th: Taj (Medevaced)🧡🧡💚🖤
4th: Rory (Lost Fire-Making)🧡🧡💜🖤
3rd: Dreamz (1 Vote to Win)🧡💜💜🖤
Runner-Up: Shan (4 Votes to Win)💜🧡💜🖤
Winner: Kaleb (5 Votes to Win)💜🧡💚🖤
I personally loved Xander from 41 I hope he comes back
Jonathan from season 42! A MUST!
If mariah from this season does not make I will be disappointed. She was truly legendary
We need old school vs. new school
Theme ideas:
Cops vs Criminals (Tony and Sarah vs everybody else)
Legends Vs Losers (Jelenski, Boston Rob, Sandra, OZZY, etc vs Reat of Yanu and Lulu)
We NEED ozzy
This… is certainly a list.
I think they should bring back the legend himself, Jablinsky
Also tho, I loved this list, Christian and Devens are by far some of my favorite players
What is this list? I don't know about this.
Q: What is this list?
A: The Survivor Players Who Need To Be On Survivor 50
You replace Natalie with Dawn in Fans vs Favorites 2, I think the favorites come out looking pretty good with Cochran, Andrea, Malcolm, and Erik as favorites, Phillip, Brenda, Natalie, Corrine, and Brandon as favorites of production, with Francesca as the outlier
Honestly, I would love to see either Kellee, Jamal, Karishma, Elaine, or Janet or all five from Island of the idols to return
yes!! Christy and Tbird would slay
I would LOVE to see Crissy come back for a second all stars season. Hell, she was the one I REALLY wanted to win her season.
New School - Austin, Jake, Dom, Carolyn, Ricard, Rick Devens, Xander, Mike, Chrissy
Old School - Yul, Earl, Natalie Bolton, Courtney Yates, Kenny, Natalie White, Taj, Erik, Yau-Man
Here is my 20 for an all stars style season. Meaning people who have played only once but have legend potential:
Women:
Lauren (38)
Victoria (38)
Lauren (39)
Sabrina (24)
Cydney (32)
Shan (41)
Angelina (37)
Dee (45)
Erika (41)
Emily (45)
Men:
Devens (38)
Devon (35)
Christian (37)
Omar (42)
Jesse (43)
Q (46)
Kaleb (45)
Davie (37)
Chris U (38)
Tommy (39)
My little wish list:
Kaleb
Noelle
Chris Underwood
Gabler- yes Gabler. I apologize.
Alec M
Reem
Christian Hubecki
Jonathan
Carolyn
Q
Everyone else
Meh
Addendum: may I add DAVIE
Honestly really want to see Victoria back, one of the most behind the scenes strategists ever
Yess Caleb and Caroline. I’d love seeing Venus and Drew also
q, venus, kenzie & charlie for season 50 tho
Why were seasons 21-33 ignored for this list?
Because there were 7 returnee seasons between 21 and 34.
@@OnceUponAnIsland Ah, got it
This is a perfect cast. Was it 20 people? I was hoping the end would show every pick of yours. & tbh I don’t care much for Christian to come back. I would choose Q.
My (realistic) dream cast would be to follow the second chance theme and allow viewers to vote on who they want to see back. I would choose two people from each of the new era seasons (so 18 people) and then the other 14 from any season before 40. LET THE PEOPLE VOTE!
Q is the most entertaining, charismatic, strong willed villain player in the last 20 seasons. Q needs to come back, he has the potential to be one of the greatest players ever
After going on The Challenge and seeing his performance there, I think Jay from Melenials V.S. Gen X needs to return
We’ve still got to see the rest of 46 and see what kind of players 47, 48 and 49 bring
I love T Bird but why is she the only one mentioned from Africa - I want the Samburu young four - Kim Powers, Lindsey, Silas and Brandon. Damn I hate how that season turned out. Also, I want Tijuana, Darrah and Lill from Pearl Islands. I wish one of them won
Yes should be second chances 2. Anyone post Cambodia eligible + Shane Powers and Dreamz. Top 3 other must haves: Dom, Kaleb, Q.
Heroes Villains 2!
Heroes: Christian (37), Devens (38), Kellee (39), Maryanne (42), Erika (41), Cydney (32), Austin (45), Vecepia (4), Sean Rector (4), Kaleb (45)
Villains: Jesse (43), Rob C (6 and 8), Dom (36), Kenzie (46), Shan (41), Dee (45), Victoria (38), Hatch (1 and 8), Q (46), Ricard (41)
Alternates: Mari--Hero (33), Shane (12) Villain, Natalie B (16) Villain, Omar (42) Hero
Karishma?!? Kenny?!?! Dreamz?!? Are you kidding me?
Nope, feel free to make your own list.
@@OnceUponAnIsland Absolutely fair. That was just my first reaction to those picks.
Previous Winners that should return - Richard Hatch, Vecepia, Todd, Sandra, Tony.... also Greg from season 1, Elizabeth season 2 (even though shes was a talk show host). I hope they bring more old school players back from the original seasons.
Man, I loved Christy. She was a sweetheart but also a badass.
I saw you told someone Russell wouldn’t be on Season 50 because it’s only 1 time players. But I also saw that you said Parvati got a call?
I said my list is only 1 time players.
"COME ON IN GUYS!"
BIG MISTAKE!
This would be my personal second chance cast, I know that not all of these choices are realistic and some of them might not even want to play but this would be my dream cast:
Guys:
Omar (42)
Reed (San Juan Del Sur)
Kaleb (45)
Christian (David Vs Goliath)
Domenick(Ghost Island)
Judd (Guatemala)
Jessie (43)
Sean (Marquesas)
Ricard (41)
Ken (Gabon)
Girls:
Karla (43)
Julie (Vanuatu)
Desi (Heroes vs Healers Vs Hustlers)
Cydney (Kaoh Rong)
Lindsey (42)
Teresa/T-Bird (Africa)
Michelle (Fiji)
Victoria (Edge of Extinction)
Carolyn (44)
Kelle (Island of the Idols)
I would LOVE Christian back!! He’s one of my favorite castaways ever!
Two players should definitely be on Season 50: Sean Rector and Teresa Cooper.
Am I the only one who would like to see Greg Buis back after all these years?