The Brainwashing Cult of Joe Dispenza
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- In 1985 a scientist in France named René Peoc'h very nearly proved that love can alter the quantum state of matter with an ingenious experiment involving newly hatched chickens and a robot. If you think that sounds unbelievable, then just you wait until you find out what the chiropractor to the stars Joe Dispenza did with the results.
#quantum #healing #joedispenza
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @sgcarney
Get Exclusive Updates on Patreon:
/ sgcarney
Substack
sgcarney.subst...
Scott Carney Investigates Podcast
www.scottcarne...
TH-cam / @sgcarney
Books:
The Wedge
www.scottcarne...
What Doesn't Kill Us
www.scottcarne...
The Enlightenment Trap
www.scottcarne...
The Vortex
www.scottcarne...
The Red Market
www.scottcarne...
Listen to the Scott Carney Investigates Podcast on:
TH-cam
• Scott Carney Investigates
Apple:
podcasts.apple...
Spotify:
open.spotify.c...
Anchor:
spotifyanchor-...
Social Media:
Instagram / sgcarney
Facebook / scottcarneyauthor
Twitter / sgcarney
Bluesky staging.bsky.a...
"The brainwashing Cult of Joe Dispenza"
©PokeyBear LLC (2023)
Get Early Access on Patreon: www.patreon.com/user?u=82207370
Newsletter on Substack: sgcarney.substack.com/
EXCELLENT report. Agree 99%. Now show us some great journalism by revealing the true scientific breakthroughs in medical treatments of many conditions which fake "Dr" Joe claims to help. Then please show us scientific data that says: 1. consciousness is limited to the brain 2. quantum effects are not there at the neural level 3. "observer" effect does not exist in quantum physics 4. human brains have no capacity to collapse the probability wave function at the local level. 5. consciousness has emerged from matter-energy and has a causal one-way relationship only. Thank you!... P.S. No, I won't pay $2,500K for Dispenza's workshop, but the best doctors in the US have no treatment plan for my condition and no pharma studies are in the pipeline. All cognitive treatments failed too. So, please guide us to the scientific method of dealing with such conditions and chronic pain. I am sure you will get 1M+ hits.
I discovered Dr. Joe before he got really well known and attended an event. It was a small venue compared to what he does now. I found his meditations really helpful. They helped me shift the way I think and let go of negative thoughts and beliefs which helped me make needed changes in my life. In his event I did experience healing in the chronic pain I had on the right side of my back. I had relief for around 3 months. I really like Dr. Joe but never got obsessed or anything with him or his work. I think the issue is that you have a lot of people out there avoiding proper psychotherapy and mental health care and think meditation is going to fix those issues. If it's not Dr. Joe, it's someone else they become obsessed with.
I have to disagree with your statement that doctors are the best we have. If I had settled for the medical advice from a doctor that told me I would have to learn to manage debilitating pain that lead to vertigo and migraines, I'd be a mess right now. Instead I did my own research and found a naturopath that was successfully treating the type of pain I had and through her treatment, my body healed most of it and I no longer had chronic migraines and vertigo. There are many paths to healing.
That's awesome , so glad you were open minded to ALL healing modalities, ty for sharing & possibly helping others realize this
Naturopaths are not a thing. It’s fake.
@@TenaciousFe lol
spot on
Anecdotal. I think it's a numbers game. You're always going to find some people who had good luck with alternative methods, but for the vast majority: go to the doctor!
I am so grateful for Dr. Joe Dispenza. His work changed my life. I overcame PTSD thru his teachings. I didn't become obsessed with him and I haven't kept up with his work. I basically changed/healed my mind and then went on my merry way. Super grateful for what I gained thru his books and excersizes. No church, no other guru or any psychologists were able to help me and I searched high and low for over a decade. The healing and freedom I gained was life changing, almost miraculous. I have to say I dont believe he had any power, he just helped me changed the way I think. I believe that "belief" itself is powerful.
As long as you know it’s a belief and not science I have no issue.
@sgcarney You seem to have a lot of issues with a lot of people. The mind is powerful. Placebo effect, mind over matter, believing something into existence, manifestation, self fulfilling prophecy... just to name a few. Pretty sure they are all referring to the same phenomena. I know I'd much rather see it from an optimistic, positively tuned perspective, than from a pessimistic, negative one. The world and the people in it will respond to you based on you and how you show up. Choose carefully.
@@AimeeLizI have atudy Dr john E. Sarno's work! He was a real doctor and stress and childhood trauma can cause disease. He helped lots of people get well. I think with Scott is trying to prove is Dispenza makes all these claims that Science is aboard and there is no proof they are. Science does not support mindbody work. Dispenza makes such outrageous claims about what science supports.
Then you should read my books "The Wedge" and "What Doesn't Kill Us." Lots of optimism there.
When I was in a Psychotherapy cult I truly believed it changed my life and healed me in many ways... Oh boy I was wrong... I got everything back after waking up from the fog and magical thinking I was trained into. Belief is indeed a powerful thing, especially when one is indoctrinated with one.
Me screaming at the screen that the chickens just got in the damn way of the robot.
Turns out he just faked it.
Dude faked the study / results ??????
You could've said spoiler alert 😂
"Chicken love is not even being used to redirect missiles away from mass destruction targets" is such a hilarious sentence🤣
It is ridiculous. Isn't it?
@@Freja_Solstheim ,
The book, "The Intention Experiment" by Lynne McTaggart has a very interesting experiment explained in the first or second chapter that involved a doctor and his office plants__I can't recommend this enough to those who are sceptical about the power of thought, intention, and energy frequencies__MIND BLOWING! 💖🙌😺
The power of positive thinking seems self evident to most people. Fifty years ago, that idea was regarded as nonsense by most. The power of thinking has been known by a minority of people in the last century or so.
Positive thought does work, I agree.
@@peterobrien1499 No there were people like Neville Goddard and Alan Watts any many more who preached positive thinking to large audiences and they had a large following too.
@@peterobrien1499 oh there's a guy named Napoleon Hill who did similar teachings that were less Hindu/Buddhist and just more about positive mindset, that was about 70 years ago.
The power of thinking is highly overrated. Action is what produces results, not thoughts.
Positive thinking helps people recover, but it ain't gonna kill a virus or cure stage 4 cancer.
I like Joe but my issue with him is if there's so much proof of people healing themselves at his events, how is not a single healing event been filmed? Think about it. If it has happened half as many times as he claimed, then there would be some proof.
I'll still listen to Joe occasionally because he does have some bits of wisdom and his message is well-meaning. I just don't buy his products, go to his seminars or spend any money on him.
I can't tell if he is a scam artist or truly believes what he's pushing.
He can both believe what he’s pushing and be a scam artist at the same time.
I cut myself recently while working in my woodshop. I needed six stitches. My cut healed -- no need for positive thinking or thoughts of healing myself. Our bodies HEAL without any supernatural mind-body connection or any other quantum field mumbo jumbo!
@@sgcarneyAnd he can be a paid Shill who can not turn down $$, fame, & guru-worship.
It’s all about multi level marketing
@@mic3766 When the mark is gullible, the confidence man appears.
Here are just some of the inaccuracies of the video (in particular order):
7:16 True but he does have a degree in neuroscience more importantly he has actual medical doctors and scientists (Physicists, cancer biologists, neuroscientists) that work for/with him at his lab in La Jolla.
8:18 No Dispenza does not believe all you need is love and meditation. That is a flagrant misrepresentation. He quite often says "Change your personality, change your life". This deals with the effect our emotions (not just love) has on gene expressions. A large 40 year study (De Val, Zwir et al 2024) that came out this year in which AI analyzed all the data collected confirms what he has been saying for over a decade.
8:23 Joe has never said he understands the universe. He quite frequently says the opposite "Just when I think I understand, an experiment or experience shows I got it all wrong". He says this numerous times in different videos. Amazing you missed that.
13:18 To say none of his is surprising is misleading. Arresting 70% of the mitochondria function of cancer cells ie lights are turned, they no longer have energy to multiply or function is a big deal.
13:33 I will need to verify this myself as I'm a big advocate of science.
15:30 Again misleading, the degree and detailsb of the change is what is being glossed over.
16:27 Joe has never said "meditation can cure anything" in any of his videos.
17:38 Scott Carney continues to misunderstand what's going on. It is not just love. All emotions effect the field and as studies by Poppin et al, Lipton et al etc show our DNA. The winding and unwinding, expression and suppression of genes. A 40 year study done on thousands of people bolstered by AI confirms this as well.
19:22 A blatant misrepresentation to put it mildly. Dispenza has never put himself as " the only person who can show you the door to healing " nor does he distrust conventional medicine . In fact Dispenza said on video conventional medicine is good for acute conditions but not with chronic conditions. He encourages sick attendees to continue seeing their doctors while doing the work as studies show meditation enhances the effect of conventional treatment when compared to placebo. There are many more misrepresentation in the video ie all you need is love and meditation... Complete misunderstanding of whats going on.
20:26 This is half the truth. Many people who found success, including myself never went to any of his workshops or paid thousands of dollars. Simply bought one of his books.
20:41 To my knowledge watching his videos during my research of Joe, he has never said he talked to aliens. He said he has seen them but never has he said he talked to them.
21:41. Joe has never said you need aliens or anything outside of you for healing. He has never made aliens the focal point of his workshops. In fact he makes fun (in a light hearted way) of people who use crystals by repeatedly saying it's not needed. You don't need external frequencies, ayahuasca, channeling of anything etc. Amazing Scott Carney didn't find videos of Joe saying this despite there being numerous.
Everything I wrote can be backed by video of Joe over the years. Amazing Scott Carney either ignored them or just didn't do enough research.
There are more but I will stop here.
I will be back to check and see if this gets taken down like my other comment
Wow
So much pseudo science by you, mr "Kelechi Opara's Fitness Science Explained"
@@sgcarney Dude all your video did was just sling mud as another commenter said. He went time stamp by time stamp rebutting u . Where is the pseudo science? Your video show very little science just a bunch of wild accusations.
@@sgcarneyWhere is the pseudo science? Everything I said can be backed up by studies or in the case where you outright l!ed, video proof of what Dispenza actually said. I mentioned study authors in my response.
The way you look and make fun of the ppl you try to debunk tells more about you than them.
@@zizlog_sound underrated comment
yeah WH gave him a huge step up in his career and he has completely thrown Wim under the bus. Scott comes across as a very bitter man that panders for views on his channel
@@mkprocter882 I was thinking the same thing!! And I’ve only watched a few of his videos.
The way he..looks? 😂
You are clearly seriously butthurt by this video. Try to relax.
Is that supposed to be a wicked burn?
i found him interessting but selling love with courses being hunderts and thousands of euro worth is not love- its capitalism. he should at least publish a kind of etat of his foundation.
Hello, he does publish a lot of free material on youtube.
He has MULTITUDES of You Tube videos which are very helpful to those who want to learn to improve the quality of their lives; but who can't make the financial investment that "deep diving" involves for the super serious.
One thing that people don't understand is that Ultimately people HAVE TO help THEMSELVES out of their dilemmas and problems. People like Dr Joe are guides and helpers.
And this IS a capitalistic society. So, there is nothing wrong with his operating within that system.
@@aeaaea2789 yes. I,m with you!!!
@@earthangel2522 you right!!!
Is that a job , so... You want that without paying? We pay for a book, we pay for school, we pay for a film, we pay every thing because the other make a job from a passion , and that is ok. We pay a documentary because there are people who puts energy, time and money to make that documentary. So... What's your problem?
Hello, I am from Iran. In Asia, there were many people who recommended this path with even more complexities. If you have doubts about Dr. Joe, I suggest you study the teachings of Zoroaster, Buddha, Rumi, and Shams Tabrizi, as well as modern gurus like Sadhguru. In terms of quantum physics, you can conduct the double-slit experiment or study the works of Heisenberg, Bohr, Werner, Wolfgang Pauli, Einstein, and others. It seems to me that it is very difficult for your soul to be completely immersed in materialistic body and mind. Best wishes for awakening.
Sadhguru is a long-time WEF member and believes in many of their ideologies, especially in regard to reducing the overall global population
@@MA-nm2tv
At first, I apologize for my weak English.
I believe that all humans who have reached awareness have fully realized the importance of the Earth and that due to ignorance, lack of balance in upbringing, and a lack of control over their animal instincts, humans are leading the precious Earth to destruction. Either the Earth's population must decrease or the Earth itself, as it has done many times before, will face extinction.
To meet the needs of this population for food, animals, plants, etc., are disappearing. Greenhouse gases are being produced. Pollution is being generated to move humans around. I think the harms caused by humans are infinite.
I ask you to read the following text carefully:
Some scientists have suggested that Earth is currently in the midst of the sixth mass extinction event, known as the Holocene extinction, which began around ten thousand years ago. There is no consensus on whether this extinction is distinct from the Quaternary extinction event or part of it.
Some researchers believe that half of the current species on Earth will be extinct by the year 2100. The International Union for Conservation of Nature stated in its 2011 report that 25% of Earth's mammals are on the brink of extinction. According to findings published in the journal Science, more than 320 terrestrial vertebrates have gone extinct from AD 1500 to 2014. Furthermore, the total population of remaining species has seen an average decline of 25%. 25% of common vertebrate species and 45% of invertebrates have declined. Between 11,000 and 58,000 species go extinct annually. Humans are responsible for this situation, as the five previous mass extinctions were caused by phenomena such as asteroid impacts or intense volcanic activity, which do not play a role in the current extinction. It is clear that the current trend is due to human activity, making it the first time in Earth's history that a species is the cause of mass extinction of other organisms. This trend is actually due to human consumption patterns.
Considering these explanations and findings, it would be better if both you and I were members of the WEF 😅
@@MA-nm2tv reduction is not "ideology" but a matter of necessity in a world of scarce resources, it should be a nobrainer. The issue is HOW to get to a reduction. Public healthcare and pensions are a good way to stop people getting hyperprolific just to ensure help when elderly..
Be careful Sadhguru is a WEF plant, also is against the farmers !!
ویک سوال که همیشه برام مطرح بود ، اگر جو یا اکهارت یا هرکدام ازینها له راز دسترسی پیدا کردن، پس چرا زندگیشون از طریق فروش ایده و فکر وخیال میگذره؟
اگر به رازها دست یافتن خب راه بهتر ومفیدتری درجهت خدمت به جهان بطور قابل رویت بایستی میبود...اگر کتاب نفروشن زندگیشون نمیگذره. اگر مدیتیت نفروشن کورسهایی که فقط سخنرانیه نفروشن رندگیشون نمیگذره...
یعنی از منبر اخوندا خسته بودیم😂 درگیر منبر جو شدیم ...معجزاتی که نشون میدن مثل پلاسیبو هست...کدوممون رفتیم سرچ کنیم واقعیت دارن یانه؟طرفی که خوب شده یکسال بعد چطور؟
اصلا ایا مشکلش جسمی بوده؟ یا روان تنی؟
خب حالا راز رو پیدا کردن میفروشن جهت خدمت!!!
خب چرا پیامبران نفروختن و همگی مجبور بودن مثل ادمای عادی کارکنن و عرق بریزن...
فقط کافیه آدم از مسخ بودن بزنه بیرون و کمی منطقش رو بکار ببره ناگهان همه چیز روشن میشه...
Debunking effectively whilst meticulously avoiding making unverifiable claims, opinion-as-fact statements or anything that could be construed as defamation is a great skill. Well done!
thanks
Unfortunately for you and Scott, there are hundreds of studies that confirm what he teaches. You can find a lot of them in his books. Thousands of people with reviews here on TH-cam (nobody was paid for this) and so on ...
“Whether you think you can, or you think you can't--you're right.”
― Henry Ford
@@IbeatGTO I'm sure Joe brings some value to people and is right about some things. There are good benefits of meditative practices and the placebo effect is an incredibly powerful, much misunderstood thing. One of the misunderstandings is that the placebo effect is a 'bad' thing - it's not, it's incredibly good in many ways and has helped innumerable people. I think the point that Scott is making here, as I understand it, is the misrepresentation of science as a support for something lacking in evidence, rather than criticising the thing itself. I don't know anything about aliens, but I am a quantum physicist. I spend my days doing real experiments on real quantum systems and reporting the data. As a scientist, data is essential evidence and the viewing of it is never refused, since it is the only way to make a credible point. Anyone can say anything, but only the evidence matters. The fact that the robot experiment cannot be repeated and all access to the data has been refused tells you what you need to know.
Don't misunderstand me, I would love those conclusions to be true, despite the fact that it was a cruel experiment. I want it to be real. But wanting something and proving it are two very different things.
There is a lot of quantum nonsense around. Quantum mechanics is essentially a mathematical probability theory about subatomic systems. It's a wonderful theory which predicts outcomes with incredible accuracy and consistency. But no-one fully understands why. Anyone who says they do is misleading you. We just don't know yet. Things like the Copenhagen interpretation (made famous by Schrödinger's Cat), the many worlds hypothesis, and so on, are just that - interpretations and hypotheses. Observer effect is intrinsically ill defined because there is no agreement or evidence to support any particular view of what an 'observer' actually is. Many physicists support objective reduction models (such as Roger Penrose) which preclude the necessity of consciousness in the observer entirely.
Sadly, the true wonder of quantum physics is masked by people who pretend they fully understand it. Why not just be honest? It's actually a lot more interesting and fun. I know because I experience the true wonder of quantum physics every day.
Don’t like Joe? Don’t go! Or AG1? Don’t buy! Or ANYONE or ANYTHING ELSE? Then DON’T ENGAGE! 😅😅😅
I'd love to see you do an interview with Stuart Ritchie, author of Science Fictions, How Fraud, Bias, Negligence, and Hype Undermine the Search for Truth.
Id love to talk with him. I have his book on my shelf!!
I just watched a video a bit ago about a girl following her inner guidance and she got herself lost in the woods for 17 days in Hawaii. She’s lucky she’s alive. It’s very huge fortune that she’s alive and she was following her inner voice, her inner intuition and inner guidance whatever you wanna call it, but it comes from this type of thinking.
ok i've watched. a mixed bag. some things i agree with, but you missed the mark at the end. The doctors are the best thing we have? i have had so many bad experiences with doctors and the medical industry in my lifetime that i can't stand the thought of going to one again. I am taking my health into my own hands. Sure if I get into an accident and have a broken bone I'll go to the ER. But for general health concerns my thought is that we are probably MUCH better off tuning in to our inner guidance like that lady who you think is crazy was saying. But she is right! You don't need to spend thousands of dollars to go to a joe dispenza retreat. But that doesn't mean the only alternative is to participate in the broken system in which we are trapped!
I've written a LOT about how mainstream medicine is messed up. And I am working on another one now.
100%
@@megankwisdom The mainstream medicine system is around the 7th leading cause of death according to the nutrition facts Dr.
I'm only 8 mins into this video with a large note book. The first page is already filled with inaccuracies and misrepresentation from the speaker in the video
19:22 I will give you an example (among numerous) of a blatant misrepresentation to put it mildly. Dispenza has never put himself as " the only person who can show you the door to healing " nor does he distrust conventional medicine . In fact, Dispenza said on video conventional medicine is good for acute conditions but not with chronic conditions. He encourages sick attendees to continue seeing their doctors while doing the work as studies show meditation enhances the effect of conventional treatment when compared to placebo. There are many more misrepresentation in the video ie all you need is love and meditation... Complete misunderstanding of what's going on.
I love dr Joe’s teachings, it may not be for everyone, but it has helped me immensely ❤️🙏
It's just blatant lies on Scott's part. I replied to every one of his misrepresentation (put it mildly) on a separate comment.
@@kcopara1his video is helping Dr Joe get attention ❤😆
“The doctors are all the best thing we have…” spoken like a true believer.
And, in many cases, especially acute medical emergencies, this is true.
However, for the vast array of chronic, lifestyle, environmental, and mental emotional health challenges that are the largest disease burden (especially in North America), most doctors, though it’s getting better with younger more integrative medicine practitioners, yet most doctors are useless at finding/exploring root cause solutions.
Just my two cents.
I've written several books on the subject. I agree that western medicine is best at treating acute conditions. They're also often garbage at chronic illness. That said, they're not ALWAYS garbage, and there's great evidence for what cases they're good at treating. There is not a corresponding body of high level evidence based medicine for the integrative folks.
This is the whole point, medicine is not about believing. “Spoken like a true believer”, you are in a cult! 😂
@@sayeretjoez9297if that was true, there would be no placebo effect.
@@sayeretjoez9297if this is true, what do you have to say about the covid vaccines? Where's the evidence that they're "safe & effective"?
Regular doctors rarely know much.
Many people in wheelchairs can get up. Some can even walk a little. So seeing some stranger get up from a wheelchair isn't proof of a "miracle".
Indeed, it's such a classic thing to happen at tent revivals that you should ALWAYS be skeptical of that act.
Personally been meditating for years. Been utilizing Joe’s D videos, books and meditations, have had powerful experiences. Watch Source yourself.
You should try to study and experiment yourself with quantum healing impact on the pain. Many person feel much better after treatment. We are made of energy. Tesla said that 100 years ago and people still do not believe that we are energy sustems
Yes, If Scott was well read with the wisdom of Tesla, he would never be attacking Joe Dispenza. That’s a fact Jack. ✅
@@JORMUNGANDReyeS you are absolutely. Most of the time in human history, people demonize and castigate people and things they don't understand or know little about. This can be clearly inferred from this video and comments from certain folks here.
Knowledge and science is a continuous progression of studies, discoveries and findings...and many scientific discoveries and findings in the past have been met with vigorous opposition by the so-called body of scientists then.
However, everybody, including the creator of this video, is entitled to their opinion but I don't subscribe to the concept of running people down simply because they don't fall within what you consider to be fact or real.
I think you really don’t know what you are talking about. Dr Joe is not a genius, or some entity. However, his teachings and the simplification he explains his work is indeed VERY powerful. I have at least five situations in my life that prove that. And zero it is about him, and 100% about the way to reach this power we all have within. You must have some reason for this battle, I guess I know what it is, but I”ll keep it.
The reason for the battle is that Dispenza is lying to you.
@sgcarney Do you not get that these people have had their own positive experiences from Joe's teaching? That is their evidence. If they experienced it first hand, how could it be a lie? Where is the lie?
@@sgcarneyit’s not black and white situation. In joes teachings there are nuggets of truth but he mixed in a ton of theatrical material in order to monetize the nuggets of truth. It’s just one of the downsides of becoming a “brand”. But no one can deny the overall good effects of meditation when done in a balanced way with someone’s social life, work life, hobby life all integrated into one
Stress dows effect body. But he claims to be a neuroscientist. Where is hus degree? He came from the cult, The School of Enlightment. Which was the Ramatha Cult.
Thank you, I was trying to remember where he came from.
Mate, I really appreciate this video. About five years ago I was into him, and once spoke of his work and did a Dispenza-style meditation at a workshop I did. I regret that now. I stopped believing in his message through a book of his, which thankfully I managed not to have to pay for, where he spoke of things that blew my mind - things like people praying for people they didn't know (which included in the past) and those people have benefits, which, when I did a bit of digging, turned out to be experiments that were not peer-reviewed and were heavily criticised by scientists.
What really turned me against him is what I read about his seminars, which as you note, cost a bomb. Some who attended said that they take the form of listening to him talk for hours on end, very little break time, and very-early-morning meditations led by him. This is all the hallmarks of brainwashing, where you're there with hundreds of others but hardly interact with them, and spend most of your time listening to him, with reduced blood flow due to the long times spent sitting down, with deprived sleep on top of that. It's cult-tactics.
It's a pity, as his message sounds cool. He's a charlatan though. He does a secular version of charismatic/evangelical wave of "healings" or the Toronto Blessing in the 1980s. He's making money out of people's pain and suffering and desire for healing. As you hint at, proper governmental (I would add with non-profit) health care systems would massively reduce the likelihood of people falling for his shite.
thanks for watching!
"of listening to him talk for hours on end" LOL I would be really upset if I paid all this money and did not get to listen to him talk for hours.
This dude doesn’t care he gave a standard automated bot response. He just wants views and money like every joker online, they do have the right but don’t expect to bond with online strangers.
Joe Dispenza Vith his method healed thousands of people !!! That is a fact !!!
Of course, this would be criticised by scientists if people knew they had the ability to heal themselves plus others through the astral plane which is the realm he refers to people would put more trust in themselves ,I completely resonated with his teaching I previously had a business that worked with energy where I would change people's beliefs since they are energy, and parents would book sessions with me to heal their trauma in their children without talking to the children themselves, his teachings are correct, when you know you know, 😇 It's polarity one can't have success without people finding fault
There are "five-sensory" people and "multi-sensory" people (I invite you to explore the writing of Gary Zukov, e.g. "The Seat of the Soul.") You are a "five-sensory" person. You are trying to understand matters of the Quantum physics world (New Science) with Newtonian Physics understanding (Old Science).
The problem with trying to understand the philosophies and teachings of someone like Dr. Joe is that you are using a linear left-brain approach which NEVER is using your complete brain. You have a right hemisphere and a pineal gland, which sits in the center of the brain (aka "the third eye). You have a spirit body which houses the fourth and fifth eyes, from which multi-sensory people see that which five-sensory people cannot.
There is a saying that a person is ALWAYS right in their opinion depending on their frame of reference.
From within YOUR box, you are absolutely right on in everything you say. But there are other boxes. You just have not awakened to their presence.
Exactly
You mentioned the faith healing getting up out of the wheelchair and walking bit. Well let me tell you I witnessed Dispenza claiming this very situation at an event I was a participant. Well I was at that previous event and that woman never got up and walked across the room and she remained in the wheelchair I saw her at the end of this 5 day event. Then I thought if this truly happened why did his crew that films and recorded everything not show this as proof. Catch someone stretching the truth once to many times and well you know they are no longer believable on any level.
If you say something... You come with data... So.... Which event? Where? In which year? The name for the woman... So... Darling... You see some videos and you can't connect the dots.... Make more research!!! There are thousands of people healed by Joe Dispenza.
Finaly someone to put this guy on the spot. Im waiting for this since 2018. Thank you Scott.
I appreciate you being here.
Me too ♥️
Thank you for this. Who is the girl at the 7 minute mark? Did you watch the movie when it was released, if so what are your thoughts after watching it?
Whoever she is, she was wrong, she said Dr Joe is not a Dr , he is, look him up
I just can’t trust anyone with hair plugs.
@@chrisg8995 They're not hair plugs. Joe simply just manifested a brand new hairline via meditation and using quantum physics 😂.
I know Dr. Joe and have worked with him on an event before. Let's see - I bet ..... I bet you have never met him personally? Have never had a discussion with him? Have never been to an event with him speaking? I like Dr. Joe, but it has been almost 20 years since I have been to an event with him. He is affable, and he could care less about whether someone comes to his events or not. There are people of all yokes at his event. I hate to see a good man trolled by you, so I am here to speak for him as I have met him, talked with him, and have attended his events, and he is NOT the person you describe nor are his events attended by lunatic or cult like people - to the extent that these people are present, they are there in the same numbers you would find at ANY public event - football, basketball, etc.
I do not have to meet him in order to make a valid critique of his work. Indeed, it is very common for charlatans to be extremely convincing in person and project an aura of competence which is not really there.
People shouldn't idolize anyone and increase their own critical thinking but those who never did personal growth will fall hard for anyone teaching them what they never learned. And there's NOTHING wrong with the placebo effect if it helps people get better.
The placebo and nocebo effects are real scientific phenomena. There is absolutely a mind body link that is useful in a healing context.
For example, there’s countless experiments where mice under various forms of stress rapidly progress their cancer, and die much faster.
There’s multiple mechanisms for this including, elevated blood glucose, reduced immune response, elevated cortisol, which aid in cancer progression.
Some of the techniques Joe teaches will help reduce stress levels, and encourage healing.
Unfortunately, he goes speculative on the mechanisms. However, it’s looking more likely that neurons are using quantum effects for computation using nanotubes. Nobody knows how the brain actually works.
@@robertbrowning2 🙄
I can get a placebo from anyone, anywhere. I don't need quantum placebos for my quantum nanotubes I can get placebos at Tesco.
Simple mind talking...@@therabbithat
You are right
Ok I made it up to 12 minutes and to be honest I have not learned anything. I do not know if Dispenza is a crook or not but this video is not going to convince me of anything. This video is just full of sarcasm, belittling, and making fun of a subject. Usual "debunking" style video wanting clicks.
Never heard of him until seeing his ad after clicking on of your videos. Must watch now.
His meditations helped me heal my endometriosis. He’s doing great work in the world
Do you have before and after diagnostics I could look at?
A friend of mine attended one of his work shops. During one of the meditations she developed uncontrollable movements FND. None of the staff there offered her any advice or support. Symptoms lasted a while. She later found Cheetah house and Nicole Sachs LCSW for support.
I had my own negative experience at a Vipassana retreat which left me severely disassociated for over a month.
It is very irresponsible for these guru types to promote this type of meditation without communicating the risks AND not offering support on how to resolve potential harm.
There is no need to be worried about body movements during meditation. Many people might have body reactions and everyone can stop it himself, but most of the participants don't even do that because they want to learn how to relax and not to pay attention to it. No one got harmed since we are gathering. 8000 people were in Basel this year, not a single accident or whatever. And the retreat is not the point, very valuable information is in dr Joe's books, there's 100% no harm by reading them
You showed incredible restraint. I am hollering at my screen and my friends, who happened to be here for other reasons and are seeing me watch this, are getting a good laugh out of it.
I recently became a subscriber and find your research to be validating. As a person who has been interested for over 30 plus years in the spiritual realm, and native traditional ceremonies /practices I’ve observed an increasingly number of charlatans. Manipulation and taking advantage of vulnerable seekers by fake healers has become a disturbing trend in the field of alternative medicines. I feel it is essential to develop a healthy discernment and be cautious in giving your power to any human being making fantastical claims . This is tricky in that one of the manipulative techniques is confronting seekers “skepticism “ is that you don’t believe therefore it won’t work for you. We need to becareful, as the trend in spiritual teachings is exploding with individuals , organizations and corporations now vying for your attention and money …
What JD teaches about the roles of the autonomic nervous system (ANS), brain-heart coherence/heart rate variability (HRV), and neuroplasticity is legit. There can be dramatic healing effects when the ANS is regulated, HRV is increased, and neural pathways are rewired to produce health promoting brain chemistry vs. stress chemistry. This is all scientifically proven. Where he loses me is with all the quantum claims, blue beings, and woo nonsense.
Maybe this is the next level that you do not understand now...
@@reluanton6339 If you meditated and experience deep states you soon learn we aren't alone 😊
If you only look to science to figure out how to live you will have a very limited life. Our understanding of how the world works according to science is very elementary.
In order to make sense of your experiences through meditation and changing your mind you have to take some leaps because science can only prove so much at this point.
If stress causes disease why cant getting rid of that stress heal you? You have to be a little open minded and not refuse to believe anything that is not proven by science.
All in all Joe Dispenzas work has transformed how happy I am everyday. His meditations are life changing to say the least. His work is all about breaking bad thought patterns and creating good ones. Weird things like out of body experiences have been documented by people meditating. Should we just throw peoples experiences away because science cant prove it and it seems weird?
100%. I listened only to the first 12 minutes and he did not say one thing to convince me that Dispenza is a crook. I bet Scott does not give any solutions/alternatives at the end of his video or in his other videos, does he? I think he is only bushing for clicks.
Knowing your style of video uploads. I had a premonition weeks ago that you would do a video on dr Dispenza lol
Did you catch the trailer the other day?
😂
15:50 Yes, Please! Make The Video Of Your Uncle & His Research On TM, Scott!
I think you need to dig a little more and really look into look into the power of thought and its physiological consequences. We are barely scratching the surface on this. There’s a lot bad science out there, including really badly designed experiments and procedures that need to be highlighted. The connection you’re making needs closer examination.
Scott, I genuinely hope you read this. Tearing down other people is not going to heal the unresolved trauma you have from the woman who took her life at your silent meditation. Look at the people you aim to tear down: Joe Dispenza, Wim Hof, Joe Rogan. Collectively, they have helped hundreds of millions of people improve their life. For me personally, those three have dramatically changed my life. If you notice in the comments section, the people that agree with you (and there are not many) are commenting in an almost cynical nature. At first I was angry seeing you attempt to build a foundation on someone else’s rubble, but now I actually feel sorry for you. There is no one who is genuinely at peace with themselves that goes about life this way. All the best in your journey of healing.
Thanks for the free psychoanalysis. But you are off the mark. I don’t like liars because liars undermine truth. And truth is important.
@sgcarney Who’s “truth” Scott? After all the time you’ve spent in the spiritual space you’re coming to come on here and start telling people what’s true? Brother - you haven’t even put the pieces of your own puzzle together. Your argument against Wim is the perfect example. You believe your argument is “true” - while thousands of people believe the opposite. Each is convinced. Who’s right? I find it hard to believe that your true purpose in this mission is “because you don’t like liars.” We live in such a world where the overwhelming majority of people cannot be truly honest with themselves - so they search for that dishonesty in others. Your mission is not based on truth and you know it, but you continue to lie to yourself.
Scott feels responsible the woman jumped off the roof in front of him.
The top comments on this video are striking; some think Joe Dispenza is a conman, while others think he's the second coming of Christ.
When I see his posts about 'quantum fields' I could swear it's a parody or some kind of hoax. When people randomly concatenate scientific terminology to impress the gullible, it always reminds me of Feynman's "Cargo Cult Science" essay (check it out if you haven't already)
WHy do you want to try to discredit anyone who is doing good for others? What is wrong with you? Do you have some underlying insecurity that leads you to want to tear people down?
Because they also hurt people.
You re trying to tear people down who helped so many peoples in this world. You look like one very unhappy guy. Why you want to invest so much energy to negativity? There is more beautiful things we can do with our lives. Take care. Sending you some love I guess you need it.
@@jurajbulava4622 telling people the truth is loving them. Tricking them is not.
I'm only 8 minutes and 19 seconds into this video. But, good grief this video is so inaccurate I don't know where to begin. (Edit:The page of my 10.5in X 8 notebook is already full from citing every instance he misrepresent Dispenza in just the first 8 mins and 44 seconds. Inaccuracies:
20:26 Here is another misrepresentation among many. Joe has never said you need aliens or anything outside of you for healing. He has never made aliens the focal point of his workshops. In fact he makes fun (in a light hearted way) of people who use crystals by repeatedly saying it's not needed. You don't need external frequencies, ayahuasca, channeling of anything etc. Amazing Scott Carney didn't find videos of Joe saying this despite there being numerous
How did you cite problems in the 26 seconds you didn’t watch yet?
I said 8 mins and 19 secs never said 26 seconds
you should read your comment again.
I ve been tehnician on his event once and while he were backstage he says:let take them some money from these idiots!and we all laugh there and replied:so many people are so dumb to believe me like i know anyting😂
Calling Joe Dispenza a quack would mean a serious insult to a quack. Perhaps a snake oil salesman title for him won't probably insult real snake oil salesmen out there too much.
He helped aaa looot of people, and still does. He teach people about hope ,and train them to materialize their visualsations..
Very interesting and great pointer! "Just became something looks like science doesn't mean it is science"
Much like science pushing gender affirming care for children.
I enjoyed your Wim Hoff material but this coverage is a little weak. Why don’t you cover a real spiritual science. Let’s say start off with the CIA FOIA document on the use of the Hemi-sync tech for spy craft. Don’t get mis-guided by biases and controlled opposition in your research. Also research the “physics of quality”, Dr. Ibrahim Kareem, Dr. Robert Gilbert. Looking forward to your next video..
Thank you for this. JD has always given me the heebies and I just couldn’t figure out why. Still don’t know exactly why but at least I know I’m not the only one who hasn’t fallen hook line and sinker
Love the cat on the Rumba😂
Videos like that are 100% of the reason I ever bought one. Sadly, my cat never took a ride.
I'd return the cat and get my money back. ;-)
It should be clarified that what kind of technique the robot used to generate randomness. Did it have a special kind of physical component that generates randomness out of quantum effects, or did it just have an ordinary computer inside that computed random numbers with some standard deterministic pseudo-random algorithm?
What’s the win for you?
OH MY GOD FINALLY I HAVE BEEN LOOKING FOR A DEEP DIVE ON THIS CHARLATAN FOREVERRRR
That's all great, but what interests me is, does his healing techniques WORK or not?
As in, did those people with serious conditions who share testimonies actually heal?
@Bobby_101 Yes it works, personally experienced it one has to get into a deep state, google transcendental meditation, once you access that realm , Healing takes place
Dont listen to this guy..
JD is not a hoax
I went from schizophrenia, non working bladder, unable to sleep and having alergies and both sensible hearing and rapid eye movement from extreme stress and super toxic enviroments. Before starting with Joe i spent a lot of money on suplements, from omegas to ashwagandha, b12, magnesium...bro i had so many deficiencies.
So forget about robot and ducklings..
In the first week, i started meditating twice a day. Like in the ad i blew up in the 7th day after waking up in the morning...my bladder started working very very fast, my memory was better and also i had many dreams where once a dream continued shortly after i woke up..
I had many sincronicities and crazy coincidences and i had super arroused heart one night when i just went beserk while i was making music in FL studio...
So i'm not pseudo, i'm very analitical and stoic and i never expected what has happened and after that i had to learn more and more because how i felt and how i was being present directly affects situations i get into.
So this man has to many biases, has blind spots and it is not viable to talk about anything, this is not a game of youtube views.
Carney...you can do better.
What are your credentials Scott Carney?
DOCTORS ARE DEFINITELY NOT THE BEST THING WE HAVE
Are grifters better?
@@sgcarney yes scamming grifters do less harm than doctors.
I agree with most of what you say, but I think, I dont know for sure, that there is a certain amount of study that has been done on the brains of regular meditators. I think I saw a paper on this in passing while looking at others. It most certainly helps with anxiety but im not sure about physical changes to the brain.
I’ve always thought that there was something fishy about this man
This was a fun one to work on.
Me too!
Same lol. Wtf and Scott should release it tomorrow lol
@@delaslight it’s cause you are being hypnotized by him that’s why you think it works. So he got his hair back from the meditations or a hair transplant?
@@cool_beans Same here. Dispenza gives me the heebie jeebies
I truly believe there is higher power than what we see, that doesn’t rely on science and we can’t explain. But does that make it untrue or just questionable? At the end of the day the best scientists at one point believed the Earth was flat. I do agree however there is a lot of conning in the spiritual/anti age/ healing world l so your work is appreciated. What is your opinion on dr Edward Grant and Matias de Stefano?
It’s fine to make guesses at how the world or universe works. But you can’t posit those guesses as facts. That’s the main sin of Dispenza.
this is good writing: "chicken love is not even being used to redirect missiles away from Mass Destruction targets it's not part of the Iron Dome over Israel at least not to my knowledge which brings me back to Dispenza and the general quackery"
I sad to say that I have sold lots of his books in my shop!😡
Gandalf: "Hmmmmmmm......."
Joe Spinoza speaks exactly like Elon Musk. Not the only similarity I might posit.
Glad people are finally talking about this
Brilliant as usual. Would also appreciate if you could look into this guy Matias de Stefano.
I have friends getting sucked into Matias’ world (Joe dispenza’s too) and it’s so concerning ☹️
@@ayeshah8424 Lots of people think he's the best thing since sliced bread. As far as I'm concerned just another grifter and total waffler...bucket loads of absolute nonsense..needs to be called out for what it is
Is there anyway to get in touch with you?
Yes. Sgcarney. Gmail.
I do his meditations daily
It is supportive and useful
He’s got the receipts to back up his claims
Long Live Dr. Joe Dispenza 🙏🏼✌🏼💖✨
Critical thinking is essential. Taking things out of context to discredit something that has massively beneficial and measurable results (meditations or dispensas work) is simply silly.
What's out of context? I'm literally giving you context this whole time.
I was thinking critically while I was reading through "Doctor" Joe Dispenza's book Breaking the Habit of Being Yourself...and I was not convinced that his claims are scientific. Dispenza uses a lot of words that REAL scientists use...but he does not use them appropriately. Quantum this and quantum that.... He is a quack. I read his other book, Becoming Supernatural. He is a fraud.
@@sgcarneyJoe Dispenza have years of experience and work an you want discredit his work wit a few minutes video??? 😅😅😅 You just want click... because his is becoming very well known.... If you do not understand how something work's that doesn't mean it doesn't exist... so... Make more research darling... When a brilliant mind arises there are always opozant who wants money or who don't understand... a brilliant mind. A brilliant mind is not for everyone... And Dr Joe Dispenza have thousands or more people healed !!! That's the scientific evidence!!!
He never convinced me.
The " freaky" medical opinions, are of no importance to me
The Doctors are the best thing we have.......... Good grief you have got to be joking........you spent that whole session tearing apart spiritual paths, which tells me you know nothing of the spiritual life, only what you've read or heard......nothing of experience. And your final comment says it all WTH!.....Hmmmmmm 🤔✨
You're exactly the person I'm trying to reach. Science matters. It can co-exist with spirituality, but only if the spiritual insights cohere with the data.
@@sgcarney does love need to cohere with scientific data?
Quantum mechanics isn't strange because we don't understand it. We don't understand it because large, important parts of it are wrong. Einstein himself had a problem with the difference between how things behaved at the quantum level versus the cosmological level. Most of these problems stem from the foundational belief that matter is composed of very tiny BBs - it isn't. That may be a useful construct, but it fails when it comes to understanding gravity and radiation, especially with regards to light and the sensation of hardness.
The real problem is the better our instruments get, the more the previous equations fail to work, and we have to go chasing some new subatomic particle or spooky things like "dark energy." You can subdivide particles until the cows come home, but I assure you it's turtles all the way down. What's really spooky is how gullible our politicians are; such that, they'll spend trillions of dollars building a machine that creates and then finds the "exact" thing it was purported to create, e.g. the God particle. There's a shock. (Pure crap.) But don't believe me, I've only tested at an above 150 IQ and receive no grants from any University to whom I owe my soul. I'm just a poor electrician and Navy vet who watches lakes to understand the nature of wave patterns and figured out how self-replicating wave patterns are generated. Would it help to remind anyone Einstein did some of his best work as a patent clerk?
I wish you all the best. See you in the next world, and don't be late.
PS Does anybody even recognize that the speed of light squared is a phenomenological impossibility, as are particles with no mass? Really, don't be so gullible.
The placebo effect is real though limited. But if you know it’s a placebo, it doesn’t work. (As well.) So is there any way to take advantage of the placebo without a scam? I’m not defending scams, just genuinely mulling this paradox.
funny how Dispenza's testimonials are always done by extremely confident, articulate people with no stage fright or camera shyness
Why would a person who’s had experiences of positive self development exhibit stage fright or camera shyness?
Um…. It’s the confident people with no stage fright that would go up there. Why would someone with stage fright want to? I’ve seen people say they didn’t want to do a testimonial previously so yeah it’s the ones that are comfortable doing it that are gonna do it. Not everyone who heals wants to do a testimonial. Not everyone is articulate either, some have done testimonials where you can clearly see and hear that they can barely speak or be understood because of whatever condition they have.
Western medicine docs and pharmacy nearly killed me. Caveat Emptor. Gaining Personal responsibility requires some degree of mistrust in solutions being “out there”. Accept you have very little control in life. Discern what you do have control over.
Dr. Dispenza overlays scientific studies on Kriya yoga (rebranded Kriya), and as a result, he has become rich. End of the day, he seems to be helping many people, but I just wish he would acknowledge the source of his success instead of silently hijacking an ancient tradition.
I like your pragmatism even though I am a person who easily married faith with science. I have healthy skepticism to be exact.
In any case, I feel that there indeed is nothing new under the sun. There are so many seld-proclaimed gurus because people still need someone to help them "get to heaven" or to believe in. As people fall away from churches, the land in the laps of these other gurus. It is very interesting to watch.
Joe has always come across as condescending to me. None of this is surprising
What was the programming of the robot?
Go straight till you hit something, then turn?
Go straight for 5 seconds unless you hit something, then turn?
I mean it must react to bumps or it will get stuck at the walls.. And it bumps into a chick following it.. Does that not explain the change in pattern better than the experience of love?
Did you really pronounce the word "esoteric" as "assoteric" somewhere around 8:10?
maybe.
With respect, I clicked on your vid to check out some sensible investigative journalism but you’ve come across as childish and reactive.
I can see that you’ve got what it takes.
Please my friend, stay steady, keep it above the belt, stay positive - even when things feel negative - and stay family - we are all in this together.
If you do that, we’ll come with you for the ride.
Keep up the good work.
Lots of love,
Clay.
Great content as usual. But you should take care more to the focus of your camera. Focus is on the books. 😉
"Assoteric" lmfao
do Johns Hopkins credentials disappear? Has he ever taught at johns Hopkins
I have seen no evidence he ever taught at Johns Hopkins
Scott Carney, have you ever done any real meditation for any real length of time? Well it shows, but bravo for gaining some notoriety and coin off the back of someone who truly is doing something positive.
Yes. I have. I’ve written books on it. I’ve studied many traditions. Do some homework.
WE are not seeing it and using it, ESPECIALLY if they are
thanks
Tobias and Kenny G have never been seen in the same room. Think about that!
I never trusted Dispensa.
City people using duck, chick and chicken synonymously 😁🦆🐥🐔
Joe Dispenza was associated with Jay Z Knight. Strike one. He tells customers they will see "interdimensional beings. Strike two. His endorsement of Quantum University. Strike three.
Note: Erin Eber has made me sleep with the lights on.
I disagree. Dr Joe's books are available in the public library. Read them and decide for yourself. I have read several of his books. The man is not insane
So the blue aliens are real? Has he ever proven he actually broke his back? Where are the X-rays?
I watched this video to inform myself about Dr. Joe Dispenza’s credibility. Unfortunately, I noticed several factual inaccuracies, which raise doubts about the objectivity of the content in this video. This observation comes despite my limited familiarity with Dr. Dispenza's work.
For instance, at minute 9:39, you claim the article is citing "the InnerScience Research Fund says it gave $10 million to researching meditation" and you then explain that this did not happen. However, the article actually says that the InnerScience Research Fund has committed to providing up to $10 million to the University of California San Diego *over the next five years*. This is a significant difference. Upon further review, I found that in 2023 alone, the InnerScience Research Fund granted $2,840,000 to the University of California San Diego.
Because of this, I am concerned about the accuracy of the research presented in this video.
I think most normal people knew he latched on to the word Quantum....Physics..its just marketing...I've listened to him, some of what he says is helpful..but most good marketing people blend truth with nonsense