Effects old fashioned way... Interesting, especially with the fact that first Star Wars movie can be considered as a first step into digital era, creating ILM. Yes, there was some computer graphics in first SW movie, what a shock. What is good about CGI is that it gives you way more freedom to express all that is in your imagination. I mean, can you imagine Cameron's Avatar done the old fashioned way? Lord of the Rings without epic scale battles and CG places? Or a stop motion T-1000?
Actually no, there was not a single computer generated effect in the original starwars because that technology wasn’t available. Everything is drawn on as a mattepainting and the film is bleached where the blue or green screen is to replace that.
In lord of the rings the CGI and practical effects are integrated very well. The orcs are real unlike the dumb clones and droids. Also George used CGI for moments when the characters are talking disconnecting the audience as it is so clearly not real
@@daftbanna7202 The fun thing about the "all was CGI"-complaint is that it's simply wrong. The only two scenes where everything in the background was CG are the droid factory and the talk - scene between Mace, Yoda and Obi-Wan in Episode II, and those only because they weren't in the original Script and added very late. in 90% of all other scenes, most of the buildings, scenery, landscapes, Backgrounds and Sets are Sets, Real-World locations, models or miniatures. The arena of Geonosis in the background ? Model The Hangar where Obi-Wan and Anakin fought Dooku ? Gigantic Set Most outside- and inside shots of Kamino ? Model All Landscape-shots of Mustafar aswell as the Mining-complex are taken on a model, the Lava is just real footage of Lava from Mt Etna, and all inside shots, aswell as the plattforms Anakin and Obi-Wan fight on are sets. The Mountains in the background on Aldeeran are the alps, filmed in switzerland, Theed and Naboo are all models, or real places in Italy. The underwater-landscapes in EpI are models, and remember the scene in EpIII where a bunch of wookies storm towards droids Landing on their beach ? The Wookies were real people in costumes, and the beach a model. The filmed the wookies in Front of a bluescreen, then put the model-landscape behind them. The exact same way they did it back in the OT. Both Obi-Wans and Anakin Jedi-Starfighters from the Beginning of Episode III were live-sized mock-ups, aswell as a additional Cockpit-only Set for scenes from inside. Basically every detailed background or building we saw in close - up from the outside was either a Set or a model, from Utapau to even extremely minor sceneries like Cato-Neimodia. EPIII alone had vastly more models and sets built for it than the entirety of the OT COMBINED. Wether people want to accept it or not, it's very possible that Ep III relied LESS on CG than TFA
It's amazing when you see all the hard work and effort spent, i thank them all for adding another brilliant trilogy to my all time favorite saga :) all those who are always complaining about well.... everything can take their nit-picking and shove it, you'd look fairly stupid after all of these webisodes trying to say they didn't do the work in anycase
Yes, Dooku doing an animated frontflip over the invisible hand's balcony really added to his dignified, sophisticated character. /s Nobody said they didn't do work on the films, nobody. We said that the products we're bad, not that work wasn't done. Get a clue.
@@nerdock4747 I take it you think that Disney Star Wars lightsaber fight choreography has been totally freaking awesome! right? I can actually admit to the flaws of the prequels inspite of the fact that I love them, whereas the people who defend the idiotic movies, games and shows that Disney have produced cannot admit such a thing, they justify everything, every character assassination, every plot hole, every MacGuffin, every instance of zero World building, and dangling the carrot of beloved things past, because they can't create anything new and can only prop up their alleged characters on the backs of ones that are already established, side note: I don't actually care if you like the current stuff or not because at least I actually had a point for a certain type of pathetic fan that has to be dealt with all the time now since I made that comment, what was yours?
Plenty of books on the subject, and most of the old-fashioned special effects can be replicated by observing and practicing. Obviously it'll take time, but if you do put the effort into it it's very doable. I know a person who has done great 50s style effects simply by his fiery hot interest in it.
@@Henry14arsenal2007 No two orcs look exactly alike. Clones are... clones. Identical. At a certain point, it makes sense to use the same performer's body as reference to build a digital model. There's an argument to be made about whether the prequels carried the principle too far, but in theory it's a logical solution to an unconventional situation.
@WarThug13 in the scene where Obi Wan escapes from the Clones, i remember a scene with him falling in the water. But im not entierly sure. Anakin is not in it though.
I wish Lucas would buy Star Wars back or an actual fan would buy Star Wars from Disney. If I had the money I'd do it! The reign of Kathy Kennedy needs to end
In that part all 3 are escaping the CIS ship. Obiwan, anakin, and the senate. They had to cut a big scene because it was about 3+ minutes long if I recall.
@WarThug13 cool! have you seen the Webisode where the Anakin design looks like a mohican? Its really funny i think =) Here is a specific link to that clip: watch?v=OY1IeATZU5Y&feature=related#t=4m26s
And yet the script was horrible, despite all these pompous directors holding their latte's in hand and barking orders at VFX supervisors overlooking extravagant rigs. They don't have a clue how to tell a story.
What a douche, some people did not like the story no matter what it would've been. I remember clearly a lot of people having high regards for the script of this movie. Maybe spend less time criticizing other people work and actually spend 50 bucks on audio equipment so your videos would be almost bearable to watch ?
@@n.d.4317 I know it’s hard to tear into me when I got 1 million views on training videos with 99% approval. Good try though. Im just saying, it sucked. Don’t bite my head off.
Revenge of the Sith is my favourite star wars episode. So I disagree. Some lines are stinkers but for the most part 99% of the scenes and the lines were great. The movie is hilarious and depressing at the same time
Bruh... the whole water sequence getting cut hurts my heart... but it's in the video game
I think it was gas in the ship’s fuel tank but yea
"And they think that ILM does everything."
Ain't it the truth...
Supertron But a lot of times with a little help
ILM is the cornerstone of modern day blockbusters.
Effects old fashioned way... Interesting, especially with the fact that first Star Wars movie can be considered as a first step into digital era, creating ILM. Yes, there was some computer graphics in first SW movie, what a shock. What is good about CGI is that it gives you way more freedom to express all that is in your imagination. I mean, can you imagine Cameron's Avatar done the old fashioned way? Lord of the Rings without epic scale battles and CG places? Or a stop motion T-1000?
True
Actually no, there was not a single computer generated effect in the original starwars because that technology wasn’t available. Everything is drawn on as a mattepainting and the film is bleached where the blue or green screen is to replace that.
@@Marbletrain60GR First use of CG technology was in original Star Wars- Death Star plans in war room sequence.
In lord of the rings the CGI and practical effects are integrated very well. The orcs are real unlike the dumb clones and droids. Also George used CGI for moments when the characters are talking disconnecting the audience as it is so clearly not real
@@daftbanna7202 The fun thing about the "all was CGI"-complaint is that it's simply wrong. The only two scenes where everything in the background was CG are the droid factory and the talk - scene between Mace, Yoda and Obi-Wan in Episode II, and those only because they weren't in the original Script and added very late. in 90% of all other scenes, most of the buildings, scenery, landscapes, Backgrounds and Sets are Sets, Real-World locations, models or miniatures. The arena of Geonosis in the background ? Model
The Hangar where Obi-Wan and Anakin fought Dooku ? Gigantic Set
Most outside- and inside shots of Kamino ? Model
All Landscape-shots of Mustafar aswell as the Mining-complex are taken on a model, the Lava is just real footage of Lava from Mt Etna, and all inside shots, aswell as the plattforms Anakin and Obi-Wan fight on are sets.
The Mountains in the background on Aldeeran are the alps, filmed in switzerland, Theed and Naboo are all models, or real places in Italy. The underwater-landscapes in EpI are models, and remember the scene in EpIII where a bunch of wookies storm towards droids Landing on their beach ? The Wookies were real people in costumes, and the beach a model. The filmed the wookies in Front of a bluescreen, then put the model-landscape behind them. The exact same way they did it back in the OT. Both Obi-Wans and Anakin Jedi-Starfighters from the Beginning of Episode III were live-sized mock-ups, aswell as a additional Cockpit-only Set for scenes from inside.
Basically every detailed background or building we saw in close - up from the outside was either a Set or a model, from Utapau to even extremely minor sceneries like Cato-Neimodia.
EPIII alone had vastly more models and sets built for it than the entirety of the OT COMBINED. Wether people want to accept it or not, it's very possible that Ep III relied LESS on CG than TFA
I like how they show the guys moving the wheels at 3:04 than instead of cutting to obi on the saddle/ blue screen mount they cut to george instead.
lol great find
Fantastic. How I wish George hadn't sold SW to Disney.
What George should have done back then was something like the Disney/Sony Spider-Man deal.
It's amazing when you see all the hard work and effort spent, i thank them all for adding another brilliant trilogy to my all time favorite saga :) all those who are always complaining about well.... everything can take their nit-picking and shove it, you'd look fairly stupid after all of these webisodes trying to say they didn't do the work in anycase
He is lazily sitting down and not engaging with the actors. George has never been a actor director he has always seen them as tools
Heartshapedbox81 lol I totally agree
The Prequels are awesome
@@daftbanna7202 you must be mentally disabled.
Yes, Dooku doing an animated frontflip over the invisible hand's balcony really added to his dignified, sophisticated character. /s
Nobody said they didn't do work on the films, nobody. We said that the products we're bad, not that work wasn't done. Get a clue.
@@nerdock4747 I take it you think that Disney Star Wars lightsaber fight choreography has been totally freaking awesome! right? I can actually admit to the flaws of the prequels inspite of the fact that I love them, whereas the people who defend the idiotic movies, games and shows that Disney have produced cannot admit such a thing, they justify everything, every character assassination, every plot hole, every MacGuffin, every instance of zero World building, and dangling the carrot of beloved things past, because they can't create anything new and can only prop up their alleged characters on the backs of ones that are already established, side note: I don't actually care if you like the current stuff or not because at least I actually had a point for a certain type of pathetic fan that has to be dealt with all the time now since I made that comment, what was yours?
I remember eagerly waiting week to week as a new episode would land on starwars.com.
George is a genius
He's a fucking idiot is what he is
Preston Farley brilliant
daft banna spot on 👌
@@daftbanna7202 why the fuck are you here then you absolute 24 iq halfwit
@@daftbanna7202 better than JJ Abrams and rain Johnson
Awesome Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge of the Sith Video.
2:31
"Cody" is wearing a Stormtrooper's helmet.
Been watching these for hours, thanks so much!
Do you watch them 10 years later ?
This is star wars...respect...
2:31 That's a Stormtrooper helmet.
Unfortunately they never made a single piece of physical clone armor.
4:27 ahh that’s pretty cool
Riksta 09 nice profile pic dude
Apparently you and 50+ others missed the "doing water digitally would have been very expensive" part. :D
Core memory
@Astrodogmedia yeah thats on utapau, this one is onboard grievous' ship, it never made the final cut
"Little bit" *shows massive set lol
i want to see how they remastered the complete old trilogy and the prequels
Amo tu canal
Plenty of books on the subject, and most of the old-fashioned special effects can be replicated by observing and practicing. Obviously it'll take time, but if you do put the effort into it it's very doable. I know a person who has done great 50s style effects simply by his fiery hot interest in it.
lol, i'm fine with the utilization of blue-screens but that was extremely lazy to blue screen the clone-trooper body, like wtf LOL
Darth Maul54sith you dont notice it much though
It’s kinda hard to get thousands of people who are the same size. Let alone get them on screen.
Yet the LOTR crew made thousands pieces of armor for extras. The digital clone armor is very visible in 1080P.
@@Henry14arsenal2007 No two orcs look exactly alike. Clones are... clones. Identical. At a certain point, it makes sense to use the same performer's body as reference to build a digital model. There's an argument to be made about whether the prequels carried the principle too far, but in theory it's a logical solution to an unconventional situation.
@@Henry14arsenal2007 clones have to be the same lotr do not
4:40 cantina theme 2
Are these behind the scenes clips available in HD?
They likely were not filmed in hd
I wonder what would ROTS looked like with todays technologies
Haha, what an ironically perfect title.
@WarThug13 in the scene where Obi Wan escapes from the Clones, i remember a scene with him falling in the water. But im not entierly sure. Anakin is not in it though.
Astrodogmedia th-cam.com/video/0C4EoJq3xLE/w-d-xo.html here’s the scene with Anakin and Obi-Wan in the water
I wish Lucas would buy Star Wars back or an actual fan would buy Star Wars from Disney. If I had the money I'd do it! The reign of Kathy Kennedy needs to end
What is happening at 0:28 did that not make it in the movie? It looks hilarious
.
@@deadsparta6600 hilarious indeed
Yeah this stunt didn’t make it into the movie but it’s still in the deleted scenes.
In that part all 3 are escaping the CIS ship. Obiwan, anakin, and the senate. They had to cut a big scene because it was about 3+ minutes long if I recall.
@WarThug13 And it was one bloody good scene!!! ahahahah poor Lucas...
lol they spent all that time and money making the water scene just to cut it out of the full film
WarThug13 damn do you remember you wrote this comment, 7 years ago:)
@@peterclaeys5402 it's actually 8 years ago
9 years and 3 months
Holy shit that was a long time ago
Did George wear the same shirt every day of set?
Mr Fantaman he probably only got 1 hour of sleep so yeah
when you're a billionaire you really don't care about style
remote control toys and figurines.
What scene were Anakin and Obi wan in water?
It was cut from the final product. It probably just wasn't necessary.
ummm, yeah I know. I'm just saying that it looks a bit like it..
@WarThug13 cool! have you seen the Webisode where the Anakin design looks like a mohican? Its really funny i think =) Here is a specific link to that clip: watch?v=OY1IeATZU5Y&feature=related#t=4m26s
Whats your point? They still spent millions on this scene.
Ive never seen so much green in my life
Have.. have you never gone outside?
@@youseff500 ha...ha....ha
"I Didn't Know There Was This Much Green in the Whole Galaxy." - Rey, The Force Awakens
You have never seen the MCU ?
Should've done more in camera practical effects! the cgi effects today look fake as shit
"lol"
It's called "editing". Look it up.
It actually says "SFX", which stands for sound effects.
justarandomguy1977 It also stands for Special Effects.
4:10 anyone notice it looks like 'sex'
Yes, the point is the time and money that went into it that ended up being wasted. Are you soft in the head or something?
No, people that are 'soft in the head' are called gamers.
Ok Boomer
Prequels behind the scenes is so mich more entertaining than the prequels
What? Are you talking about
Are you autistic???
I wish this much attention was given to the script. Terrible movies
And yet the script was horrible, despite all these pompous directors holding their latte's in hand and barking orders at VFX supervisors overlooking extravagant rigs. They don't have a clue how to tell a story.
What a douche, some people did not like the story no matter what it would've been. I remember clearly a lot of people having high regards for the script of this movie. Maybe spend less time criticizing other people work and actually spend 50 bucks on audio equipment so your videos would be almost bearable to watch ?
@@n.d.4317 I know it’s hard to tear into me when I got 1 million views on training videos with 99% approval. Good try though. Im just saying, it sucked. Don’t bite my head off.
Revenge of the Sith is my favourite star wars episode. So I disagree. Some lines are stinkers but for the most part 99% of the scenes and the lines were great. The movie is hilarious and depressing at the same time