I’m so glad you commented on Geoff’s upper register. I love his upper voice. When he hold “no where” it’s probably my favorite note in the whole thing.
Fantastic analysis as always. This was arranged by Layne, their beat boxer btw. I would like to double down on hearing your take of hoist the colours. That was a Geoff arrangement. I've probably listened to it 100 times and am still blown away by the arrangement and performance every time. Their Halo cover is also amazing.
@@mastermonster195able He hits a B0 subharmonic on the Halo theme and that's his lowest note yet according to himself. That B0 to his high at A5 is right at the five octave mark.
@Nate Baker, Geoff's voice is platinum. He should get an award for his pipes and the work he's done to hone his incredible voice. Having said that, Layne does much better (mind you... not just better but much better) arrangements than Geoff. Geoff's arrangements are wildly dynamic... which isn't that dynamic at all. It isnt too difficult to write wild stuff into an arrangement and if it's well executed, it can even sound okay. Geoffs arrangements have one voice finishing the line a different voice started, he's constantly changing up the beat and even the tempo and overall, as a completed work, it sounds like a piece of modern art looks. Blotchy, splattered and generally nonsense. Laynes arrangements may not be as "edgy" - because edgy isn't the point, beautiful music is the point and he's a lot better at producing beautiful music (with plenty of edge) then Geoff is.
He actually displays more of his range here, both at the high and also the low end. Admittedly, the thing he does in the Ursula song is a slide, so that's impressive in its own way.
@@jessicasopranonotes new subscriber. And may I add you have a very lovely singing voice and your range is spot on!! I'm not sure,if you've listen to Tim Faust but he's Incredible :)
I was shocked you didnt touch on his last note which I believe is a E1…. So from a b4 to an e1 … completely sick! Wonderful analysis as usual! Check out hoist the colors by voice play, it’s epic!
I have studied music and have been singing for 50 years. I have never heard another commentator that just brings out every little nuance of a song like you do. Thank you, thank you. I just want you to know how much I appreciate you. I feel like I am sitting in a master’s music education class. Blessings!💗💗💗💗💗
What a wonderful breakdown! I love your analyses, and this is such a fun song to pick apart. Geoff is infamous for that B4-E1 descent at the end (it still blows my mind that he can do- and has done- this live). I agree; this is a spectacular arrangement (care of Layne Stein, the vocal percussionist; he's a madman!) But what I- and many others- believe to be VoicePlay's best arrangement to date is Hoist the Colours, from the Pirates of the Caribbean movies. It would be amazing if you could break down that song- it's a piece that has literally broken reactors all over TH-cam, some of them just shaking their heads in disbelief and walking off camera without a word. It is so engaging and creative; I truly think you'd love it.
I love your analysis. Everyone is floored by the low note but you pointed out the high notes and background rhythm changes, too. Thanks so much for your reaction.
First time I saw this I was in awe. Since I’ve seen this, I’ve watched several videos like yours. And I learn something new from every video I watch. I agree that Geoff’s upper range is outstanding and I think that makes his lower range that much more spectacular.
You: "Ooh... OH! WOOOO!!" Me: "Me, too, girl... Me, too." In all seriousness though, between you and The Charismatic Voice, I have such a greater love and understanding of music and technique. Thank you! I would like to suggest Sierra Eagleson. Her voice is a warm cup of coffee on a cold day.
I have watched at least 4 other reaction videos by very qualified voice coaches/music teachers/etc., and I have to say your analysis is by far the most comprehensive and detailed. I too get carried away by Geoff's low register performance but you rightly point out to us a lot of what else is going on in this performance that altogether make it quite impressive. Thanks so much for your analysis.
I always love your reaction to Voiceplay and Mr. Castellucci! Layne, the beatboxer did this arrangement. Geoff says Layne likes to see how far he can stretch Geoff's voice. Please, please, please do Hoist the Colours next. Geoff arranged it and it is astounding! You will not be disappointed, promise!
Love your VP reaction and breakdown, I would love to see you do more of them. Their arrangements and vocals are sooo amazing! They are hands down my favorite!!
Earl was the one that sang that 'You haven't got a prayer' line. Him, Eli (ellie) and J.None are the 3 children: Lock, Shock and Barrel from the movie. The beatboxer, Layne, is Zero, the ghost dog. Loved your analysis - keep 'em coming! :)
Earl was the tenor 1 for the group before he left for private reasons. They have not replaced him, we still miss him and despite the many people who have featured with them none of them have quite fit that void.
This is actually the most enjoyable and informative reaction I’ve seen of this song. You clearly know what you’re talking about and I really enjoyed learning from you.
I really enjoy your breakdowns. As a former 2nd violin & violist (symphony, chamber, pit, & small ensemble), I love how you quickly pick up details that are often missed (the spectacular arrangement, that descending bass riff, the syncopated background harmonies, etc...). As a string player, I personally love their vocal string pizzicato arpeggio accompaniment portion of this as well, and I agree, they should have awards for Voiceplay's stuff - arrangements, performances, costumes/makeup, videography, all of it. Speaking of, I enthusiastically add my voice to the chorus to urge you to do reactions to Hoist the Colors and the Halo Theme. Two more outstanding videos - intricate harmonic ear candy with lots of cherries on top. You will enjoy them, I have no doubt whatsoever. Your makeup and thick braid is too cute (perfect extension from Devil's Night to Samhain to Dia de los Muertos). New sub, btw. I enjoy your quick pickup of musical detail, ear for harmonic intricacy, and enthusiastic musical geekery; you are lively fun to watch. Thank you. 😊
This is my intro to your page. I appreciate your appreciation and analysis of VoicePlay, who I love. I've subscribed already and am about to check out more of your channel! Looking at your list, I don't see Aurora on it. I bet you would enjoy her stuff. Popularly, she was "The Voice" in Frozen 2. Her personal music is out of this world: she's a Norwegian forest spirit in human form. Her music, and her voice, are something to experience.
As far as a cappella groups in general, VoicePlay is fantastic and any of their songs are worth a listen. As far as Home Free goes, I'm not a fan of country at all, but they still have some really good songs like the Sea Shanty Medley. My favorite Petnatonix song is actually Aha (Imogen Heap cover).
I loved the way you analyzed this song, I was trill seen you dissecting it to reveal the different elements and subtle changes on this magnificent performance by Voiceplay!!!
Really enjoyed this breakdown! Much more in-depth than pretty much any other I've seen. Loved the focus on the tiny little bits that make the whole arrangement work.
Best analysis of this song that I have seen. Love your insights. Only a tiny group of people that I have found on the internet with your kind of knowledge and skill in conveying it clearly to an audience. I am exploring acapella groups and I truly believe Voice Play and Home Free are exceptional artists in every way. It’s terrible that there isn’t a category for them in award shows because they are producing some of the most beautiful and exciting things out there today. So happy I can enjoy them all!
You are soooo far beyond my ability in understanding this masterpiece. Yet I completely appreciate your efforts in analyzing it. Another wonderful analysis, another wonderfull reaction. Love it!
Great job. I subscribed today. That haunting melody at the end of you singing Sergei Rachmaninoff though! Wow! I didn't even know what that was from until now, because I only knew it as the intro to Steve Taylor's song "Harder to believe than not to". Looking forward to more.
"Mr Castelucci you're an alien" I had to laugh because I've had friends I've shown this video to say,things like "How'd he go so high, then so low?, He's obviously not human". The not human part is the consistent theme in the remarks I get.
Really enjoying your analysis, it's a proper one unlike so many reactions out there. And you noticing all of these details. I didn't notice half of them myself.
This song was my introduction to VoicePlay. It took a side trip into TH-cam to see the scene in the movie, and then I had to retrace my steps three more times as VoicePlay covered three other songs from N.B.C. truly inspired work and conceptualization on VoicePlays part , and now I'm well and truly hooked... and Loving it.
OMG yay! This is such a classic for a vocal expert to react to. Im so happy to see this upload and cannot wait to watch your reaction. Awesome channel and videos much love! and Happy Halloween.
I am definitely adding you to my list of music reactors. The analysis and presentation and actual pencil and paper note taking! Subscription definitely earned
I always love your reactions to voiceplay and Geoff's solo work. Another great analysis and I would love to see more reactions from you to vp, geoff or voctave. Love your Halloween makeup too!
You are the best reaction so Far to this amazing voiceplay cover. Thank you Jess !! UR the best ! I saw several reactions to this piece and yours is the best !
Loved your analysis & comments. There is so much to this song, and you detailed a lot of the rhythm and tempo done by the group. Layne does a fantastic job keeping it moving and interesting. Thanks for your on-point analysis
Hoist the Colors (Pirates of the Caribbean 3)is great, so is the one they just released for this Halloween, Friends on the Other Side (Princess and the Frog). Geoff gets down to B0 in their Halo cover.
First of all: great make up👍🙂.. almost as your analysis😉. You hear evrything.. that's why I love your reactions 😍. I hope you will not be cruel and you don't make us wait for your reaction to " Hoist the colours" as long as "Oogie Boogie"..🙂 . Sorry for my possinile mistakes, I'm not good in English as I wish. Best wishes to you👍🥰
His cover of Blackbird gives a good sample of his range at that time.. Since then he's got down to a B0 at least. He is always working on his voice. Pretty sure that it's "if you aren't shaking, there's something very wrong." The subtitles got it wrong. It's Earl Elkins Jnr who sing that line you mentioned. Sadly he has now left the group.
While there are some really good vocal reactors on TH-cam, I feel like I consistently learn more from and am entertained the most by you. Thank you for breaking down this performance!
This song is my favorite by them. So glad you reviewed it because you catch the nuances to things they do that most don't. One of the things I enjoy the most in the song is the range by the group on the last note. Geoff hits that incredibly low note, but it is balanced by Earl (the tenor) who hits an extremely high note. Gives me chills all the time.
As always I love watching your reactions to Voiceplay, and I have to agree with what many other comments have stated……. We want to see you react to their rendition of Hoist the Colors. It’s amazing. This one was arranged by Layne. Hoist the Colors was arranged by Geoff.
Geoff Has his own YouTub channel also. If you wants to hear some of his voice changes and range, he did a cover of “Sixteen Tons”. It’s a folk/country song about Coal Miners and the bind they got into due to the mine owners paying them in credits that could be used in the grocery store and clothing store and hardware store that would be set up in the town that would grow up around the mine. It kept them always in debt. Geoff has 4 different parts that he does and “sits” beside himself while he does all the parts. Really awesome.
EXCELLENT reaction, and YES! Thanks for giving props to Layne Stein’s arrangement. It’s brilliant (his arrangements generally are). Also, glad you caught that Geoff is awesome in his higher register as well. I hope you go on to react to Hoist the Colours (maybe you already have-I’m going to be looking once I’m done here) and some of their other pieces. ALL of these guys bring their own magic to the table. I also love that they actually act out some of their songs, because they’re all so good at it.
as a sometime singer (for fun) and HUGE Voiceplay fan, i truly enjoined your breakdown of this song. I will be looking to see what other songs of theirs that you have reviewed or even some of Geoff's solo work. You have given us great detail in the breakdown without making us need a formal music background in order to understand your review. I cant wait to see more of your work!
I truly admire your ability to pick out all of the subtle nuances in your analyses that I completely miss. It makes re-listening to the songs that much more enjoyable. Please consider doing an analysis of Home Free's cover of Helplessly Hoping. It is nowhere near as complex as this song, but I think you will find it a beautiful arrangement to unravel.
One of the most amazing vocal groups I've had the pleasure of hearing live is "The Real Group". Unfortunately most of the original members have now retired and the replacements, while good, aren't as good in my opinion. But their older stuff, like their Count Basie medley, is absolutely fantastic. Another on I'd recommend is the alto and soprano of the group doing a J. S. Bach invention in Am where the alto sings the left hand keys and the soprano sings the right hand keys. Of their newer stuff, I'd recommend the tribute they did to the SweDanes.
Everyone is going to say it, but their version of Hoist The Colors is truly one of their best ever arrangements. You will be introduced to their newest member Cesar De La Rosa, who replaced J None, and it features Jose Rosario Jr. It’s blown away so many other reactors. Also highly recommend their Halo Theme, where Geoff hits his lowest ever recorded note, a B0! That is also a fantastic arrangement and has a special dedication at the end.
I think I have seen just about reaction out there on this and yours is top notch. I was afraid that you would be too technical, but no - like in Goldilocks, it was just right. Although I don't have any musical training (I flunked clarinet), I have learned so much from reactions. I really appreciate you rewinding to cover your points. And I love seeing those of you with musical chops enjoying this as much as I do. (As much I love Geoff's low notes, I so appreciate the high register and those runs. My favorite parts are the "gambling man" lines and those awesome belts ("I'm the Oogie Boogie man"). Good to know I am not the only one!
The one that sings "You aren't comprehending the situation that you're in" is Earl. J. None is wearing the skeleton shirt and the one in the red shirt is Eli (pronounced "Elly") and Layne is the beatboxer and the one with the the light on his nose
Dear Jess... Yes, this song is fantastic. I already knew that. My comment is about your reaction. WOW. Here’s my analogy: I’m in the old west. I’m a gunslinger. I am REALLY cocky about being the fastest draw in the west. I brag. I boast. Then one day I face off against an unknown bad guy, and I am shot through the heart before my gun even clears the holster. Okay, back to the present…I think I have a really good ear for music. Classical, jazz, rock, barbershop (I know), a cappella… a REALLY good ear. After listening to your reaction, I know that compared to YOU, my ear wouldn’t even clear the holster. Simply a superb reaction! Bravo!!
Geoff said he actually had to train his voice in order to do this full song live. This was an amazing reaction and analysis. Theres always so much going on that you need to watch several different reaction videos to hear all the different goings on and knowing the notes is super interesting to me.
Your breakdowns are just so spot-on, Jess. Loving them. How about a round of Home Free's cover of, "When a Man Loves a Woman." Grab your favorite teddy bear. lol
One with the line - prayer is Earl. He left the group for few years ago. It seems that Earl is back. Geoff has 4 to 5 Octaves with low notes in subharmonics such as last note is an E1.
I’m so glad you commented on Geoff’s upper register. I love his upper voice. When he hold “no where” it’s probably my favorite note in the whole thing.
Love his upper register!
Fantastic analysis as always. This was arranged by Layne, their beat boxer btw. I would like to double down on hearing your take of hoist the colours. That was a Geoff arrangement. I've probably listened to it 100 times and am still blown away by the arrangement and performance every time. Their Halo cover is also amazing.
Yes, Hoist the Colours would be fire for her.
I've read Jeff has a 5 octave range...I don't doubt it s bit!
I enjoy your reaction almost as much as their performance. Well done!
@@mastermonster195able He hits a B0 subharmonic on the Halo theme and that's his lowest note yet according to himself. That B0 to his high at A5 is right at the five octave mark.
@Nate Baker, Geoff's voice is platinum. He should get an award for his pipes and the work he's done to hone his incredible voice. Having said that, Layne does much better (mind you... not just better but much better) arrangements than Geoff. Geoff's arrangements are wildly dynamic... which isn't that dynamic at all. It isnt too difficult to write wild stuff into an arrangement and if it's well executed, it can even sound okay. Geoffs arrangements have one voice finishing the line a different voice started, he's constantly changing up the beat and even the tempo and overall, as a completed work, it sounds like a piece of modern art looks. Blotchy, splattered and generally nonsense. Laynes arrangements may not be as "edgy" - because edgy isn't the point, beautiful music is the point and he's a lot better at producing beautiful music (with plenty of edge) then Geoff is.
After seeing that bit about Geoff's range in the 8-10 minute area, all I can say is this:
Girl, watch their "Little Mermaid" medley.
Right👍🙂
He actually displays more of his range here, both at the high and also the low end.
Admittedly, the thing he does in the Ursula song is a slide, so that's impressive in its own way.
He went from a B4 to an E1 at the end. This was three octaves plus a 5th above. This was beyond epic.
I really can’t wait!! (please do their version of Hoist the Colours next, one of if not the best voiceplay work imo)
I'm no musician, but your breakdowns are always interesting to watch, and your reactions are priceless.... Keep on keeping on 👍🏻👍🏻
Thanks, Mick!
@@jessicasopranonotes new subscriber. And may I add you have a very lovely singing voice and your range is spot on!! I'm not sure,if you've listen to Tim Faust but he's Incredible :)
I was shocked you didnt touch on his last note which I believe is a E1…. So from a b4 to an e1 … completely sick! Wonderful analysis as usual! Check out hoist the colors by voice play, it’s epic!
I have studied music and have been singing for 50 years. I have never heard another commentator that just brings out every little nuance of a song like you do. Thank you, thank you. I just want you to know how much I appreciate you. I feel like I am sitting in a master’s music education class. Blessings!💗💗💗💗💗
Wow, thank you so much, Vicky!
@@jessicasopranonotes you are very welcome.🌹
What a wonderful breakdown! I love your analyses, and this is such a fun song to pick apart. Geoff is infamous for that B4-E1 descent at the end (it still blows my mind that he can do- and has done- this live). I agree; this is a spectacular arrangement (care of Layne Stein, the vocal percussionist; he's a madman!) But what I- and many others- believe to be VoicePlay's best arrangement to date is Hoist the Colours, from the Pirates of the Caribbean movies. It would be amazing if you could break down that song- it's a piece that has literally broken reactors all over TH-cam, some of them just shaking their heads in disbelief and walking off camera without a word. It is so engaging and creative; I truly think you'd love it.
“Mr. Castellucci… You’re an alien!“ Lol, that about sums it up! Everyone here did a bang up job though, I love the high voices in this.
I love your analysis. Everyone is floored by the low note but you pointed out the high notes and background rhythm changes, too. Thanks so much for your reaction.
Thanks for watching Tracy!
First time I saw this I was in awe. Since I’ve seen this, I’ve watched several videos like yours. And I learn something new from every video I watch. I agree that Geoff’s upper range is outstanding and I think that makes his lower range that much more spectacular.
You: "Ooh... OH! WOOOO!!"
Me: "Me, too, girl... Me, too."
In all seriousness though, between you and The Charismatic Voice, I have such a greater love and understanding of music and technique. Thank you! I would like to suggest Sierra Eagleson. Her voice is a warm cup of coffee on a cold day.
I wish I could push a love button, because I LOVE your ability to pick the piece apart and explain what is going on. You are brilliant!
Thank you so much 😀
I have watched at least 4 other reaction videos by very qualified voice coaches/music teachers/etc., and I have to say your analysis is by far the most comprehensive and detailed. I too get carried away by Geoff's low register performance but you rightly point out to us a lot of what else is going on in this performance that altogether make it quite impressive. Thanks so much for your analysis.
Hands down the best analysis of voiceplay/Geoff I've seen yet, and not to mention, you're gorgeous 😋
This is gonna be EPIC!!!!!
The singers are Geoff, Layne - beatbox, J.None, Eli (in red) and Earl (the nasal quality). Layne did the arrangement.
Omg i reached the first comment
It was pure joy to watch your reaction! Thank you. This video is awesome. It was, I believe, the first one I ever saw Voiceplay do.
Glad you enjoyed it!
I always love your reaction to Voiceplay and Mr. Castellucci! Layne, the beatboxer did this arrangement. Geoff says Layne likes to see how far he can stretch Geoff's voice. Please, please, please do Hoist the Colours next. Geoff arranged it and it is astounding! You will not be disappointed, promise!
You’re really gonna love the newer songs from voiceplay. Hoist the colors and friends on the other side are amazing!
Fantastic analysis. And loved your reactions.
Thank you so much, Jim!
Love your VP reaction and breakdown, I would love to see you do more of them. Their arrangements and vocals are sooo amazing! They are hands down my favorite!!
Earl was the one that sang that 'You haven't got a prayer' line. Him, Eli (ellie) and J.None are the 3 children: Lock, Shock and Barrel from the movie. The beatboxer, Layne, is Zero, the ghost dog.
Loved your analysis - keep 'em coming! :)
Thank you!!
Layne the beatboxer mentioned in the above comment does the arrangements for most of their songs including this one
Earl was the tenor 1 for the group before he left for private reasons. They have not replaced him, we still miss him and despite the many people who have featured with them none of them have quite fit that void.
You should do more Voiceplay reactions😭🔥 This one is AMAZING ✨ Love your analysis 😆
This is actually the most enjoyable and informative reaction I’ve seen of this song. You clearly know what you’re talking about and I really enjoyed learning from you.
Thank you so much!
He's an alien, right!? Hahahahaha
Loved the video!!
I really enjoy your breakdowns. As a former 2nd violin & violist (symphony, chamber, pit, & small ensemble), I love how you quickly pick up details that are often missed (the spectacular arrangement, that descending bass riff, the syncopated background harmonies, etc...). As a string player, I personally love their vocal string pizzicato arpeggio accompaniment portion of this as well, and I agree, they should have awards for Voiceplay's stuff - arrangements, performances, costumes/makeup, videography, all of it.
Speaking of, I enthusiastically add my voice to the chorus to urge you to do reactions to Hoist the Colors and the Halo Theme. Two more outstanding videos - intricate harmonic ear candy with lots of cherries on top. You will enjoy them, I have no doubt whatsoever.
Your makeup and thick braid is too cute (perfect extension from Devil's Night to Samhain to Dia de los Muertos).
New sub, btw. I enjoy your quick pickup of musical detail, ear for harmonic intricacy, and enthusiastic musical geekery; you are lively fun to watch. Thank you. 😊
Ur breakdowns are really informative. I love it when u bring out the sheet music or lyrics and get specific. Really excellent, just like this group.
This is my intro to your page. I appreciate your appreciation and analysis of VoicePlay, who I love. I've subscribed already and am about to check out more of your channel!
Looking at your list, I don't see Aurora on it. I bet you would enjoy her stuff. Popularly, she was "The Voice" in Frozen 2. Her personal music is out of this world: she's a Norwegian forest spirit in human form. Her music, and her voice, are something to experience.
His name is Earl, and he was one of the original members of the group if I am not mistaking.
I just CANNOT WAIT
As far as a cappella groups in general, VoicePlay is fantastic and any of their songs are worth a listen. As far as Home Free goes, I'm not a fan of country at all, but they still have some really good songs like the Sea Shanty Medley. My favorite Petnatonix song is actually Aha (Imogen Heap cover).
I love your reactions! So informative 🔥🔥🤗
I appreciate that, Beth!
I loved the way you analyzed this song, I was trill seen you dissecting it to reveal the different elements and subtle changes on this magnificent performance by Voiceplay!!!
You provide spot on and well reasoned commentary.
Yesss, I have beeen hoping for this one for a long time !!!! :)
Jess I watch you then the video but YOUR reaction makes it so MUCH better for me. I just so love ❤ you
Really enjoyed this breakdown! Much more in-depth than pretty much any other I've seen. Loved the focus on the tiny little bits that make the whole arrangement work.
Thanks a bunch!
Your analysis is one the best. Don’t forget the fantastic arpeggios and syncopations of the back ups.
Best analysis of this song that I have seen. Love your insights. Only a tiny group of people that I have found on the internet with your kind of knowledge and skill in conveying it clearly to an audience. I am exploring acapella groups and I truly believe Voice Play and Home Free are exceptional artists in every way. It’s terrible that there isn’t a category for them in award shows because they are producing some of the most beautiful and exciting things out there today. So happy I can enjoy them all!
You are soooo far beyond my ability in understanding this masterpiece. Yet I completely appreciate your efforts in analyzing it.
Another wonderful analysis, another wonderfull reaction. Love it!
Thank you so much!
Fantastic reaction love and respect from the UK 👍👍👍👍👍👍🌟😀😀 amazing channel 👍
Great job. I subscribed today. That haunting melody at the end of you singing Sergei Rachmaninoff though! Wow! I didn't even know what that was from until now, because I only knew it as the intro to Steve Taylor's song "Harder to believe than not to". Looking forward to more.
Nice makeup! Upd. And hairstyle :))
You've got it all sorted out in such detail, it's great.
Que analise fantástica e super detalhista!! Parabéns, muito show!!!😊🤝🙏👏👏👏🇧🇷🎶
"Mr Castelucci you're an alien" I had to laugh because I've had friends I've shown this video to say,things like "How'd he go so high, then so low?, He's obviously not human". The not human part is the consistent theme in the remarks I get.
Really enjoying your analysis, it's a proper one unlike so many reactions out there.
And you noticing all of these details.
I didn't notice half of them myself.
I love your reactions to this video.
Totally agree with Nate Baker's comment. Your reaction was quite informative, thank you. Geoff's range and tone are sublime.
Glad you enjoyed it, Nikki!
I love your enthusiastic reviews. I learn from you too. Personally I find VoicePlay videos exhausting on the first few listens ... so much to take in!
I always LOVE how excited you get when you are having FUN with a new song!!! Thanks again for sharing.
Glad you enjoy it, Gordon!
This song was my introduction to VoicePlay. It took a side trip into TH-cam to see the scene in the movie, and then I had to retrace my steps three more times as VoicePlay covered three other songs from N.B.C. truly inspired work and conceptualization on VoicePlays part , and now I'm well and truly hooked... and Loving it.
Jess, fan-tras-tic job!!!!! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 Thank you over again and again! Your analysis are THE analysis!!!! ☝🏼☝🏼
Excellent review was always. Liked the description of rhythm changes
OMG yay! This is such a classic for a vocal expert to react to. Im so happy to see this upload and cannot wait to watch your reaction. Awesome channel and videos much love! and Happy Halloween.
Outstanding analysis. Loved it.
Awesome analysis!
Your analysis are always so interesting and complexe, I love it
Thank you very much, Jade!
I am definitely adding you to my list of music reactors. The analysis and presentation and actual pencil and paper note taking! Subscription definitely earned
Thank you so much!
I always love your reactions to voiceplay and Geoff's solo work. Another great analysis and I would love to see more reactions from you to vp, geoff or voctave. Love your Halloween makeup too!
Thank you, Jessica!
You are the best reaction so Far to this amazing voiceplay cover. Thank you Jess !! UR the best ! I saw several reactions to this piece and yours is the best !
Thank you, Enrico! 😊
Loved your analysis & comments. There is so much to this song, and you detailed a lot of the rhythm and tempo done by the group. Layne does a fantastic job keeping it moving and interesting. Thanks for your on-point analysis
Thanks for watching, Jim!
As always Jess, amazing reaction. This is one of my favorite videos to watch reactions for and you once again you were the best. Thank you!
Thank you so much for watching!!
Hoist the Colors (Pirates of the Caribbean 3)is great, so is the one they just released for this Halloween, Friends on the Other Side (Princess and the Frog). Geoff gets down to B0 in their Halo cover.
First of all: great make up👍🙂.. almost as your analysis😉. You hear evrything.. that's why I love your reactions 😍. I hope you will not be cruel and you don't make us wait for your reaction to " Hoist the colours" as long as "Oogie Boogie"..🙂 . Sorry for my possinile mistakes, I'm not good in English as I wish. Best wishes to you👍🥰
Great break down and awesome reaction
Thank you, Bryant!
His cover of Blackbird gives a good sample of his range at that time.. Since then he's got down to a B0 at least. He is always working on his voice. Pretty sure that it's "if you aren't shaking, there's something very wrong." The subtitles got it wrong. It's Earl Elkins Jnr who sing that line you mentioned. Sadly he has now left the group.
It's "shaking", yes. Although in this particular context, "shaken" works just about as well, so the difference may not be important.
@@jonadabtheunsightly that is of course true.
Best Boogie’ review ever! ❤ from Italy (bass voice fan 😂)
Amazing!!! 🤯
Wow, what a fantastic reaction 💫💜💫
While there are some really good vocal reactors on TH-cam, I feel like I consistently learn more from and am entertained the most by you. Thank you for breaking down this performance!
That means a lot, thanks!
This song is my favorite by them. So glad you reviewed it because you catch the nuances to things they do that most don't. One of the things I enjoy the most in the song is the range by the group on the last note. Geoff hits that incredibly low note, but it is balanced by Earl (the tenor) who hits an extremely high note. Gives me chills all the time.
As always I love watching your reactions to Voiceplay, and I have to agree with what many other comments have stated…….
We want to see you react to their rendition of Hoist the Colors. It’s amazing.
This one was arranged by Layne. Hoist the Colors was arranged by Geoff.
Thank you for watching! 😁
Geoff Has his own YouTub channel also. If you wants to hear some of his voice changes and range, he did a cover of “Sixteen Tons”. It’s a folk/country song about Coal Miners and the bind they got into due to the mine owners paying them in credits that could be used in the grocery store and clothing store and hardware store that would be set up in the town that would grow up around the mine. It kept them always in debt. Geoff has 4 different parts that he does and “sits” beside himself while he does all the parts. Really awesome.
EXCELLENT reaction, and YES! Thanks for giving props to Layne Stein’s arrangement. It’s brilliant (his arrangements generally are). Also, glad you caught that Geoff is awesome in his higher register as well. I hope you go on to react to Hoist the Colours (maybe you already have-I’m going to be looking once I’m done here) and some of their other pieces. ALL of these guys bring their own magic to the table. I also love that they actually act out some of their songs, because they’re all so good at it.
Cant get enough of that song
I love the video but enjoy watching your reaction 1000 times more.
Glad you enjoy it!
Wow, great analyses. Thx. Suscribed!
Awesome, thank you Andre!
THAT E1 😱❤️
Yes his whole voice and range is really interesting, nice....
as a sometime singer (for fun) and HUGE Voiceplay fan, i truly enjoined your breakdown of this song. I will be looking to see what other songs of theirs that you have reviewed or even some of Geoff's solo work. You have given us great detail in the breakdown without making us need a formal music background in order to understand your review. I cant wait to see more of your work!
Thank you, Trey!
Nice reaction. Interesting to hear all of your points. Enjoying listening to Geoff Castellucci’s range and performances.
I truly admire your ability to pick out all of the subtle nuances in your analyses that I completely miss. It makes re-listening to the songs that much more enjoyable. Please consider doing an analysis of Home Free's cover of Helplessly Hoping. It is nowhere near as complex as this song, but I think you will find it a beautiful arrangement to unravel.
I’ll get to working on that recommendation soon 😊
I believe the sheet music is on his patreon. I know they do that for VoicePlay as well as karioke versions of their music
This was great! I would love for you to do Hoist the Colours next. I would love if you could do a contrast between Oogie Boogie and Hoist the Colours.
One of the most amazing vocal groups I've had the pleasure of hearing live is "The Real Group". Unfortunately most of the original members have now retired and the replacements, while good, aren't as good in my opinion. But their older stuff, like their Count Basie medley, is absolutely fantastic. Another on I'd recommend is the alto and soprano of the group doing a J. S. Bach invention in Am where the alto sings the left hand keys and the soprano sings the right hand keys. Of their newer stuff, I'd recommend the tribute they did to the SweDanes.
Everyone is going to say it, but their version of Hoist The Colors is truly one of their best ever arrangements. You will be introduced to their newest member Cesar De La Rosa, who replaced J None, and it features Jose Rosario Jr. It’s blown away so many other reactors.
Also highly recommend their Halo Theme, where Geoff hits his lowest ever recorded note, a B0! That is also a fantastic arrangement and has a special dedication at the end.
I think I have seen just about reaction out there on this and yours is top notch. I was afraid that you would be too technical, but no - like in Goldilocks, it was just right.
Although I don't have any musical training (I flunked clarinet), I have learned so much from reactions. I really appreciate you rewinding to cover your points. And I love seeing those of you with musical chops enjoying this as much as I do. (As much I love Geoff's low notes, I so appreciate the high register and those runs. My favorite parts are the "gambling man" lines and those awesome belts ("I'm the Oogie Boogie man"). Good to know I am not the only one!
The one that sings "You aren't comprehending the situation that you're in" is Earl. J. None is wearing the skeleton shirt and the one in the red shirt is Eli (pronounced "Elly") and Layne is the beatboxer and the one with the the light on his nose
Dear Jess... Yes, this song is fantastic. I already knew that. My comment is about your reaction. WOW. Here’s my analogy: I’m in the old west. I’m a gunslinger. I am REALLY cocky about being the fastest draw in the west. I brag. I boast. Then one day I face off against an unknown bad guy, and I am shot through the heart before my gun even clears the holster. Okay, back to the present…I think I have a really good ear for music. Classical, jazz, rock, barbershop (I know), a cappella… a REALLY good ear. After listening to your reaction, I know that compared to YOU, my ear wouldn’t even clear the holster. Simply a superb reaction! Bravo!!
The B4-E1 in like 10 seconds at the end is amazing🤯
Geoff said he actually had to train his voice in order to do this full song live. This was an amazing reaction and analysis. Theres always so much going on that you need to watch several different reaction videos to hear all the different goings on and knowing the notes is super interesting to me.
Thank you for watching! I'm glad you enjoyed the video!
You look amazing!
Your breakdowns are just so spot-on, Jess. Loving them. How about a round of Home Free's cover of, "When a Man Loves a Woman." Grab your favorite teddy bear. lol
One with the line - prayer is Earl. He left the group for few years ago. It seems that Earl is back. Geoff has 4 to 5 Octaves with low notes in subharmonics such as last note is an E1.
"you're an alien" yup that is the most honest take of geoff i have seen.
Great reaction and sub😊
Thanks for subbing, Beth!
Check out Geoff Castellucci(the bass)'s cover of Blackbird, which shows more or less his entire range.
Fantastic as always. Can sceleton be stunning? CLEARLY
I guess it takes an amazing singer to react to amazing singers
Good job girl,,,