The best way to remove bias is to rate them ALL first, then show which picture was taken by which phone. It seemed like they after choosing samsung, they all tried to guess which was the iphone and it's what they chose.
@@dylanspriddledefense defense defense. But both have beautiful pictures. I tried iPhone and Samsung. Video i would prefer iphone moon shots you know what to choose and I would like to try pixel sadly pixel does not make a phone for our country so hard to have a signal here.
Pixel software clearly hasn't been optimized yet, I expect it will get better in future comparisons. You are completely correct about these guys, great camera video but always picking iPhone. In most of those shots pixel clearly won the night mode
We all know deep inside, secretly, they both wanted to choose iPhone 15 PM but were surprised (perhaps disappointed too?) when it’d turn out to be s23 😂
They always pick which one would be the iPhone and not the better photo. Like in the front cam. They know the iphone have a wider angle lens than s23u but was surprised they gave it to pixel pro. They always say "I think that's the iPhone so I will pick that one" or "this one is definitely the iPhone so this is the one" 😂
I completely agree. Those were terrible pictures selections. They should have the photographers framed their shots and see what the results are. Didn't like this one to be honest
I didn’t actually count them, but the Samsung won more often for me. I’m an iPhone dude. However, I’m still quite pleased with iPhone photography, especially when you add in its video and optical stabilization capabilities.
I thought I'd like the 15 Pro Max photos the most, so I'm surprised the S23 Ultra won more often for me. And I'm shocked at how little I liked the Pixel 8 Pro photos. I've heard so many good things about the Pixel 8 Pro camera, but I ended up liking only 3-4 of the photos the most here.
@@nitrosenpaii2823time is not the factor when getting a better more detailed shot is the goal, pixel destroyed the last photo , definitely agree with the prior comment
@@nitrosenpaii2823maybe you didn't watch the video on 4k check it out , the green colouration on the fence vs the natural white balance on the last one.
IDEA FOR NEXT TIME: Introduce categories first (like portrait, ultrawide, zoom, main camera, low light) and let us decide at the beginning which categories are the most important to us by giving it a ranking (1-5) or maybe even a factor ( x0,5 / 0,75 / 1 / 1,25 / 1,5 ). Then gives us 5-10 pictures of each category to compare. This way everybody can figure out which is the best camera for its own preferences by looking at the ranking or multiply every category with its preselected factor and summing everything up. The way you do it right now is distorted by e.g. the amount of zoom pictures you put in. If you show 10 pictures of 10x zoom, the galaxy would win the comparison easily. Same goes for night or portrait pictures.
*"pro photographers" must leave and bring in some general public because these pro photographers are doing less a blind test and more *"find the iphone so i can make it look good"* ...at this point , given how much these guys are making it obvious they are paid by apple or biased to apple, might as well hire them as apple employees*
Instead of constantly trying to guess which phone it is, I wish they would just choose the best picture, period. It would also be good to rank each photo 1,2,3.
Overall, all the photos are good. However, when we talk about possibilities, since many of the photos have to do with the moment, surprise, only the S23 Ultra manages to maintain absurd quality at 10x. The photos from the s23 ultra, "in the daytime", up to 30x are very good. This flexibility of taking a good photo, sometimes not the best, better, at any distance on the s23 ultra, is fantastic! I love iPhone and Pixel, but being able to play with this on the s23 Ultra is priceless
I feel like you should judge based off good pictures, not selecting the least bad in horrible conditions (x25 of a post at night, like who tf would shoot that day to day). Do pets, do flowers, family photos were great.
S23u is the first good samsung imo. Still got beaten in performance battery and camera by the iphone 15 pro max. Lets see what samsung can do with next years s24u
"got beaten in performance battery and camera" hahah you should watch real comparisons, not "antutu benchmarks", and you'll see thats not true furthermore, battery is really close on each phone + iphone 15 = out in october samsung = will be out in ferbuary MAX (maybe january) so between 3 and 4 months difference samsung last year had the best technology, they had 8 months of advance compared to the others let's see what they will get us next year :) it will break the neck of those iphones@@Randomdude21-e
@@Randomdude21-e But the iPhone is boring, you can't set many settings, with Android I can set a lot to your own wishes. There is also no finger scan, finger scan is the best there is. I love the iPhone, I don't rule out buying it again, I now have the pixel 8 pro. I may still go for the iPhone, although I would rather buy the S24 ultra ;).
Alright this was way more informative than I expected it to be. I am about to buy a new phone and I was leaning towards the iPhone solely because everyone is saying how much better the camera is but after this video I think I am going with the S23. Even when the iPhone is better the S23 is not massively worse :)
Keep in mind these guys often tried to guess which phone, and tried to pick the iPhone, so there was some bias, even though they often picked wrong. One of the guys actually picked the Samsung a heap of times in a row at first until he worked out the characteristics, and started picking the iPhone more. I'm left thinking the iPhone was actually the one they rated worst if you removed their bias. But all up, yep, they are all very close, and you're right, you could chose any of these phones and you can't go wrong as far as pic quality goes.
@@dadthelad Oh I did not care what the "professionals" had to say. I took a piece of paper and scored myself which photos I liked the best. Even for me, the iPhone got more points but most of the time it was a very close call between the pictures :) I never thought of looking for "blind tests" for phone cameras but now I think it's a very handy aid when it comes to making a choice.
Wow, thanks for this comparison! I ended up picking the s23 ultra almost each time. As a pixel user for the past few years, this really made me reconsider my next phone.
So I have an S23 Ultra and it's the most impressive piece of tech I've ever used, bar none. Not just the camera performance, but literally every last bit of this phone. I have literally zero complaints.
@@doudymac*"pro photographers" must leave and bring in some general public because these pro photographers are doing less a blind test and more *"find the iphone so i can make it look good"* ...at this point , given how much these guys are making it obvious they are paid by apple or biased to apple, might as well hire them as apple employees*
Reliable or recyclable? Samsung will consider the 2020 launched, S20Ultra; to be “use at your own risk” at end of 2023. I think Samsung taking $1000 from the customer, and then dropping all support 4 years later, makes no sense. Microsoft’s windows 10, released 2015, will still be getting updates in 2025. Tech companies boast smartphones are now as powerful as a laptop, but they just think you should recycle it at the most 3 to 7 years later?!
@@Commontater2It is not related to the company, but rather to the mobile phone itself. Sometimes the company makes an unusually excellent device. I agree with your opinion that updates are important, as I use a phone from 2018 and the last update was 2 or 3 years ago. Also, I do not buy a phone for $1000 because I believe there is no phone worth this amount, but my intention in my comment is that if I had a choice, I would choose the Ultra 23 from among these phones. Because it really offers excellent specifications and I will not regret it if I use it for 4 years or more, it will be perfect❤
@Commontater2 the support life has been getting longer with each new release, but that's been a criticism of mine as well. I also don't like how they roll the releases versus giving everyone the updates on day one. Samsung is still better than a lot of brands though. For example, I would buy Sony Xperia, but you only get a couple of years of support with them.
@@Commontater2brother apple provides only an year extra and pixel just broke the record most phones dont even give 3 years only these 3 phones do and everyone upgrades their phone every 2-3 years
I think it would be better to just note which one they like and not to tell them till the end which phone they were.. would be a bit of a hassle to tally the score but since they don’t know which phone it is, there wont be any bias.
I ended up liking the S23 Ultra pictures the most. Which is surprising, because I thought I'd end up liking the 15 Pro Max photos the most. The Pixel 8 Pro had the least picks for me.
I have a Samsung and the only thing I don't like is the shutter speed, which is too slow , even in good light the shutter speed is always too slow, there's sometimes blur in photos
Mostly Pixel but I spent most of my day at work either behind camera or photoshop so not typical user I guess. Still surprised by both iP and Samsong in some cases. I assume most people would pick way more iPhone shots. All of them are more than good enough for phone camera.
Great video, but feels like there've been more portraits and extremely dark shots which people use the least. There should have been more regular photos of daylight, indoors, outdoors etc.
For me, the winner is S23 Ultra. These people are looking for the iPhone photo not for the best photo. even though S23 released earlier it's photo quality is best. (I also have an iPhone. but may be I'll try with S23 next time.)
I think that just cause of these guys that are professional photographers they chose the most natural looking photo, s23 Ultra clearly had the best night time shots, day time shots and 2nd best long exposure one they just basically tried to find an excuse to pick the iPhone, as for Video the iPhone wins hands down
I was lucky enough to have been able to test all 3, it's 3 different experiment, they are all good in their way. What i can say it's when you have them in your hand, S23 ultra and 15 Pro Max looks more premium than the Pixel 8 Pro, they have a better quality of build. For an everyday smartphone, iPhone seems to me the best, it's smooth, efficient, very easy to use, has big battery life and has a much more better front camera than the other ones. The S23 Ultra has an incredible screen, it's like a small TV you can bring with you everywhere, One UI is the most complete OS you can have but makes feel a little bit messy, the user experience is behind the other two smartphones in my opinion and like the OS, the photo shooting is very complete, the most complete but messy, it's less practical for an everyday use, a lack of ergonomics. The Pixel 8 Pro has the best OS and probably the best rear camera with the best algorithm, the user experience is just incredible. However, the smartphone itself has a quality of build very limit, it does not look like a premium one, the battery life is also very short for a flagship, the front camera is the least qualitative, Google algorithms doing too much to erase the weakness of the front camera when you make selfie. All the AI integrated into the pixel works but is still very experimental, it's very funny but not really usefull for an everyday use. The impressive evolution of Google and their management of AI makes me think it could become the indisputable number one in a few years.
THIS GUY IS A TOP NOTCH APPLE FANBOY. U CAN'T FOOL US ANYMORE. LET THE PHOTOGRAPHERS SHOOT BY THEMSELVES AND GIVE US THE REVIEWS....PIXEL IS THE FUTURE OF SMART PHONES...
Tru. They should go out with the photographers and let them take the photos with the phones together and then do a review comparison, not the iPhone guy taking the pics too much room for being biased.
I believe all of them have the option to change exposure, shutter speed etc but this was just point-and-shoot kind of test. I might be wrong. I'm a Samsung user, but I really liked iPhone 15's photos more often than not, so I might switch in the future. But truth be told, all these cameras are amazing, they struggle with different issues, but what cam we expect from tiny lenses and sensors. It all comes down to personal preference.
blind test is definitely the way to go when trying to pick a cell phone for their cameras way too many reviews end up biased even if it's just a small amount better yet, if you randomly mixed in other phones / DSLR pics and even multiple of the SAME phone in the same comparison, to get people to really focus on what pic looks best rather than inadvertently picking out which one is from their favorite brand
I'm a photographer as well. I do more portraits and event photography currently. Sony A7 iv as my main shooter. I also have the 8 pro which is very accurate with white balance and more true to life images. some shots i saw here from the device i couldn't agree with. My experienc has been better.
@@navidsami4526it's because this is an Apple fanboi channel it's fine for them if Samsung beat their iPhone since Samsung is always neck to neck with Apple on taking images they don't want another contender to beat their iSheep units that's why.. I got both and in my experience the PX 8 Pro is even better than my S23 Ultra
Try go to camera asistant in samsung and set prioritizing into quality only. The photos are much sharper, less noise and more detail. It is really a big jump than defult setting camera on samsung.
The Pixel 8 Pro will receive a video boost feature in a few months. It will be interesting to compare its video performance with the iPhone 15 Pro Max.
I hope you realize it's a feature that requires Google's servers for it to work at all. I'd prefer a phone to be at its best without the huge reliance on the cloud/servers but yes it'll be an interesting one to see. A bit annoying how some of the generative AI features on the phone need to be connected to Google's servers for them to work and I live in a location where internet is really bad (Australia).
@@toptiertech7291 Just random advice, It's important to buy a phone that meets your needs, rather than just a brand name or logo for thousands of dollars.
The category winners are like iphone for portraits, pixel for night and overall appealing pic is s23 They should give points to photos top pick 1 point 2nd rank get 0.5 or if the second one is a close win then 0.8 points or something like that
is this choosing the best picture or guessing which one is the iphone? because they choose the better pic and then get disappointed because it wasn't the iphone. i'm lost! sometime they choose the best picture but then say "ohh i think this is the ultra so i'm choosing another one". doesn't make sense. the point for me, is to choose the best picture don't matter what kind of phone it is to show or proved that not only the most popular phone have the better camera.
You can really tell that iphone users have that perception of choosing the more natural colors instead of the more vibrant and bright of the Android competition, all did great honestly but from an s23 Ultra user myself I had a pretty good guess to which photos were from it, pixel 8 pro and iPhone did a pretty good job, but there's no beating the more versatile camera of the s23 ultra, the killer zoom, cropped 200mp photo and even the great night mode, I prefer it, the vibrant, contrasty, bright, the picture just looks more alive, great stuff as always! And coming from the " older " device since the pixel and iphone just launched, Samsung doing pretty well
Even as an IPhone user I just have to say that this is THE channel to come to for a guaranteed IPhone win!..😂😂, but SO WHAT. Samsung and Google have their favoured reviewers also. Stuff them for moaning about our channel!..😂😂
Wow was surprised with just how good the smasung photos were glad I ordered one I was deciding which one to get but I just loved the colors the S23 Ultra had so I bought one and I can't wait to receive it
Might be hard to display on video but I would one to see a comparison between Google Pixel Ultra HDR vs Apple HDR HEIC. No one is talking about those features!!!
As a mirrorless cam user, I'm very impressed with my iPhone 15 Pro image quality. It really comes close to a dedicated cam with its "life-like" image quality, considering its small sensor.
@@choloong5989 Do you use an actual mirrorless camera? Because I do so I know what I say. The presence of flares and whatnot isn't the be all and end all of image quality.
I'm a Samsung fanboy due to its flexibility and styling, but I agree that iPhone's camera is a lot better due to its sharpness and more natural colors than Samsung which looks "filtered". You have to own both to really compare. Stop being bitter.
I have a Pixel 7 Pro and I'm surrounded by iPhone 13 and 14 Pro/Max owners. They all tell me my pictures taken with my 7 Pro are better than those taken with their phones when we go on vacation.
For me Iphone and S23 Ultra are the winners both with 15 points. Pixel disappoints with 5 points. I can't wait what the S24 Ultra will bring to the table.
Iphone and galaxy cameras are almost even. Each has strengths in situations where it shines, but the only reason I would say apple Wins overall is its video. They are so far ahead that it aint fair to call anything competition. I am currently using S23U, and my son has a 15PMAX
Im rocking my pixel 7 pro, but humbly I'll admit that the iPhone just has the overall better camera system.. which is crazy because the pixel prides itself in being the best... Back when I knew nothing about the pixel and bought the 3a it was amazing.. my 3a camera was better than almost all the flagships for a fraction of the price.. now it's not that way
Pixel 8 pro will have a feature of detailed image after zooming in, in the January update. The pixel camera gets better after every update, I wish they waited for January to do this comparison vid as the new camera sensor and neural core are still learning the color science. 3 months later the camera will have its full potential.
pixel 7 pro has better color and better detail than pixel 8 pro, pixel 7 pro is sharper when zoomed in that pixel 8 pro, pixel 8 pro portrait mode is worse of all the pixel phones till now. pixel 8 pro has different lenses, than previously tried an tested ones.
@@rushabhshah.2768 you've tested both? I tried the 8 pro at Best buy and just wasn't really impressed.. the AI features will probably come the the 7 pro anyways
iPhone outdid themselves this year. I hope they continue to destroy the competition in photos, they have always been the king of video. Samsung got way too lazy and google is being cheap.
Now just think about that - all of the shots taken by S23 Ultra were made with the lowest available resolution (12 Mpx), while it can be set uo to shot at 50 and 200 Mpx as well. Which phone would win the competition then? :)
The only problem I have with this video is this I have both phones the iPhone and I have the Samsung but any of my photos looks so orange like your, why?
Was interested for me. At the end I figured out that Pixel is far away from Galaxy and iPhone that were very close to each other. I would like to compare it with other similar tests. Would be nice to define category here and make shot at once to put all of them in the same conditions.
I think s23 u won many of them imo bc s23 and iphone 15 was neck and neck whereas pixel felt a little short behind its the colours that prolly make me like the iphone more as 12 pm owner but well done to apple, they rlly stepped up in camera especially w samsung killing it asw this year, pixel minor improvements from last year so ok ig
I can see why you would like the right over the left and vice versa. Idk if he chose the left because he thought it was the iphone but it is a valid answer.
It would be better if they are judging the photos in an objective way basing on their expertise and not as an iSheep with a very obvious bias. Just for that alone, I would not trust their opinions on this matter. This is a biased comparison and is just a waste of time and effort.
Bro, they're literally saying "i think this is the iphone, so I'm going with the iphone." At least try to hide the bias a little better. Good video idea, but bad execution.
Disappointing video in so many ways! Very(!) poor selection of shots, where is the variation? On top of that they were badly executed and the presentation was also weird. Maybe you should have a better photographer plan and take the pictures next time. As for the judgement, it was ok, but I felt the photographers were more interested in guessing the phones than finding the best shot.
@@MrWerewolf69 Are you sure? I've watched like every camera comparison out there and pretty much can tell the iPhone from the others because of the yellowish/warm tint. The ones that the Pixel and s23U won were deserved.
Everyday people aren’t photographers so this is meant to represent the everyday experience of pointing and shooting. If you don’t like the results, maybe the brand you wanted just doesn’t do a good job for ordinary people
I also didn't like they picked a weird scenario. 25X zoom when we know damn well all the photos would be taken with digital zoom. I want comparison with optical zoom. That's the ideal situation.
I left iPhone only because they are really cheaping out on giving more storage - i Love shooting raw and 4k 60p so a 512GB Samsung Fold was cheaper and google photo's manages photos and videos much better than icloud. The way Google allows you to share videos is like sharing a youtube link. Excellent Codecs.
2:28 Notice how on the right one, the horizontal line on the wall is a little wobbly. So when it reaches near the blue logo (the lower one), it almost splits. This looks similar to what you get when you use AI upscale like ESRGAN on Anime. I chose the middle one as it seems to resolve it just enough to get the details while avoiding noise OR a paint like look. With the right one, while the leaves might looks "sharper" at first glance, they really don't seem to contain any more detail. The left one, while having more superficial levels of noise, still retains an overall more realistic look and the horizontal line on the wall is precisely straight
My suggestion is that you take these pictures and then put them aside with ones that a camera took to see which one is closer to what the camera had to offer and which one actually had better colors.
The other phones are just happy to be compared against the masterpiece that’s this iPhone. But if course, there’s no contest: iPhone will always reign supreme 😊
You can tell they are biased iPhone fanboys when starting from the macro leaf photo they tried their hardest not to pick the s23 because they thought they had figured out the color temperature of the s23. After that it just became a game of them trying to choose whatever one was the iPhone regardless if it was the best or not.
![[#2024MAMA] BIGBANG (빅뱅) - 뱅뱅뱅 (BANG BANG BANG) + FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EQsYfiPR9uM/mqdefault.jpg)
The best way to remove bias is to rate them ALL first, then show which picture was taken by which phone. It seemed like they after choosing samsung, they all tried to guess which was the iphone and it's what they chose.
Yeah this would be even more accurate
Very bias
This should be the standard
More fun that way though. The guy even had an iphone on preorder and was thinking about changing it so if anything he should be biased towards iphone.
They tried so hard to not choose S23U😂😂
It's not blind if they are just trying to figure out which is iphone to pick
Thats true still bias to iphone. The title should be finding the iphone image that would be more accurate
After chosing s23ultra a few times, they really tried to find the iPhone.
100% became a game of find the iphone even if the image was worse.
@@dylanspriddledefense defense defense. But both have beautiful pictures. I tried iPhone and Samsung. Video i would prefer iphone moon shots you know what to choose and I would like to try pixel sadly pixel does not make a phone for our country so hard to have a signal here.
Pixel software clearly hasn't been optimized yet, I expect it will get better in future comparisons. You are completely correct about these guys, great camera video but always picking iPhone. In most of those shots pixel clearly won the night mode
Exactly, the images from the S23Ultra were way better.
They did that or not , this is the most biased channel I've seen towards iphone in general
We all know deep inside, secretly, they both wanted to choose iPhone 15 PM but were surprised (perhaps disappointed too?) when it’d turn out to be s23 😂
Yes 23 ultra much pretty photos
They always pick which one would be the iPhone and not the better photo. Like in the front cam. They know the iphone have a wider angle lens than s23u but was surprised they gave it to pixel pro. They always say "I think that's the iPhone so I will pick that one" or "this one is definitely the iPhone so this is the one" 😂
Apple fan boys
Unfortunately it's the otherwise
@mel6444 yes i agree these vloggers are apple fanboys with the girl also
You should do a test where pro photographers take the pictures then you and your family choose… just an idea 👍🏻
Exactly🙌🏽
I completely agree. Those were terrible pictures selections. They should have the photographers framed their shots and see what the results are. Didn't like this one to be honest
@@alerttrics7224THIS GUY THINK WE ARE DUMB..😂😂😂😂
Yeah 👍🏻 nice idea
Agree ✅
I didn’t actually count them, but the Samsung won more often for me. I’m an iPhone dude. However, I’m still quite pleased with iPhone photography, especially when you add in its video and optical stabilization capabilities.
Overall very solid. Rare to get really bad Photos or other problems. Just lacks zoom a bit compared to Samsung but you obviously don't "need" that.
@@hannes6114, largely agree, but I’d probably phrase that as “typically” don’t need longer zoom. That’s an unusual case.
I thought I'd like the 15 Pro Max photos the most, so I'm surprised the S23 Ultra won more often for me. And I'm shocked at how little I liked the Pixel 8 Pro photos. I've heard so many good things about the Pixel 8 Pro camera, but I ended up liking only 3-4 of the photos the most here.
The video iPhone is better than anything from Android. Samsung has a very good photo output but they boost the photos too much
The last image the Pixel was the best easily. These guys must be blind.
Definitely not the iPhone was the better shot not to mention the time it took to take it
@@nitrosenpaii2823time is not the factor when getting a better more detailed shot is the goal, pixel destroyed the last photo , definitely agree with the prior comment
@@nitrosenpaii2823maybe you didn't watch the video on 4k check it out , the green colouration on the fence vs the natural white balance on the last one.
if the fence supposed to be green, then pixel sucks a lot
IDEA FOR NEXT TIME:
Introduce categories first (like portrait, ultrawide, zoom, main camera, low light) and let us decide at the beginning which categories are the most important to us by giving it a ranking (1-5) or maybe even a factor ( x0,5 / 0,75 / 1 / 1,25 / 1,5 ). Then gives us 5-10 pictures of each category to compare. This way everybody can figure out which is the best camera for its own preferences by looking at the ranking or multiply every category with its preselected factor and summing everything up.
The way you do it right now is distorted by e.g. the amount of zoom pictures you put in. If you show 10 pictures of 10x zoom, the galaxy would win the comparison easily. Same goes for night or portrait pictures.
*"pro photographers" must leave and bring in some general public because these pro photographers are doing less a blind test and more *"find the iphone so i can make it look good"* ...at this point , given how much these guys are making it obvious they are paid by apple or biased to apple, might as well hire them as apple employees*
Idea for your comment next time: Don't.
@@ramdas363 😂what’s wrong with that?
Instead of constantly trying to guess which phone it is, I wish they would just choose the best picture, period. It would also be good to rank each photo 1,2,3.
👍
Overall, all the photos are good. However, when we talk about possibilities, since many of the photos have to do with the moment, surprise, only the S23 Ultra manages to maintain absurd quality at 10x. The photos from the s23 ultra, "in the daytime", up to 30x are very good. This flexibility of taking a good photo, sometimes not the best, better, at any distance on the s23 ultra, is fantastic! I love iPhone and Pixel, but being able to play with this on the s23 Ultra is priceless
With that huuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuge shutter lag on S23... you could get tens of photos with iPhone instead of one on from the Samsung.
let's be honest not all the photos were good lol. part of the differences in the photos taken by the 3 phones were the photographer's fault haha
I feel like you should judge based off good pictures, not selecting the least bad in horrible conditions (x25 of a post at night, like who tf would shoot that day to day). Do pets, do flowers, family photos were great.
3 Very iPhone bias characters 😂 just sounds like they were trying to Pic the iPhone 😂
3:09 Seems like the left guy doesn't want to choose the Samsung😂
S23 Ultra is a beast overall. But on the last photo? I find the pixel better, look good, look good ;).
S23u is the first good samsung imo. Still got beaten in performance battery and camera by the iphone 15 pro max. Lets see what samsung can do with next years s24u
"got beaten in performance battery and camera" hahah
you should watch real comparisons, not "antutu benchmarks", and you'll see thats not true
furthermore, battery is really close on each phone
+ iphone 15 = out in october
samsung = will be out in ferbuary MAX (maybe january) so between 3 and 4 months difference
samsung last year had the best technology, they had 8 months of advance compared to the others
let's see what they will get us next year :) it will break the neck of those iphones@@Randomdude21-e
@@Randomdude21-eperformance? no go check some TH-cam video on real life test not some applebench score
@@Randomdude21-e But the iPhone is boring, you can't set many settings, with Android I can set a lot to your own wishes.
There is also no finger scan, finger scan is the best there is.
I love the iPhone, I don't rule out buying it again, I now have the pixel 8 pro.
I may still go for the iPhone, although I would rather buy the S24 ultra ;).
@@Randomdude21-eperformance i might disagree but battery and camera yeah
Alright this was way more informative than I expected it to be. I am about to buy a new phone and I was leaning towards the iPhone solely because everyone is saying how much better the camera is but after this video I think I am going with the S23. Even when the iPhone is better the S23 is not massively worse :)
Keep in mind these guys often tried to guess which phone, and tried to pick the iPhone, so there was some bias, even though they often picked wrong. One of the guys actually picked the Samsung a heap of times in a row at first until he worked out the characteristics, and started picking the iPhone more. I'm left thinking the iPhone was actually the one they rated worst if you removed their bias. But all up, yep, they are all very close, and you're right, you could chose any of these phones and you can't go wrong as far as pic quality goes.
@@dadthelad Oh I did not care what the "professionals" had to say. I took a piece of paper and scored myself which photos I liked the best. Even for me, the iPhone got more points but most of the time it was a very close call between the pictures :) I never thought of looking for "blind tests" for phone cameras but now I think it's a very handy aid when it comes to making a choice.
It has the zoom lens that is a plus 😊 the shutter might make some pics a bit blurry though :)
I am no expert 😉
Wait for 24 ultra
Wow, thanks for this comparison! I ended up picking the s23 ultra almost each time. As a pixel user for the past few years, this really made me reconsider my next phone.
So I have an S23 Ultra and it's the most impressive piece of tech I've ever used, bar none. Not just the camera performance, but literally every last bit of this phone. I have literally zero complaints.
The Galaxy is a more powerful device but the Pixel is a "smarter" smartphone. The Pixel call features and speech recognition are unmatched. 👍
except the Galaxy does the same thing... and did it first, albeit it was only implemented in Korea, but now it's everywhere. @@doudymac
@@doudymac*"pro photographers" must leave and bring in some general public because these pro photographers are doing less a blind test and more *"find the iphone so i can make it look good"* ...at this point , given how much these guys are making it obvious they are paid by apple or biased to apple, might as well hire them as apple employees*
@@soulsbourne True.
I would choose the Ultra because it is a complete, very reliable device in all respects
Thanks ❤
Reliable or recyclable?
Samsung will consider the 2020 launched, S20Ultra; to be “use at your own risk” at end of 2023.
I think Samsung taking $1000 from the customer, and then dropping all support 4 years later, makes no sense.
Microsoft’s windows 10, released 2015, will still be getting updates in 2025.
Tech companies boast smartphones are now as powerful as a laptop, but they just think you should recycle it at the most 3 to 7 years later?!
@@Commontater2It is not related to the company, but rather to the mobile phone itself. Sometimes the company makes an unusually excellent device. I agree with your opinion that updates are important, as I use a phone from 2018 and the last update was 2 or 3 years ago. Also, I do not buy a phone for $1000 because I believe there is no phone worth this amount, but my intention in my comment is that if I had a choice, I would choose the Ultra 23 from among these phones. Because it really offers excellent specifications and I will not regret it if I use it for 4 years or more, it will be perfect❤
Except that the camera is only good at 3x and 10x, all other digital and looked terrible!
@Commontater2 the support life has been getting longer with each new release, but that's been a criticism of mine as well. I also don't like how they roll the releases versus giving everyone the updates on day one. Samsung is still better than a lot of brands though. For example, I would buy Sony Xperia, but you only get a couple of years of support with them.
@@Commontater2brother apple provides only an year extra and pixel just broke the record most phones dont even give 3 years only these 3 phones do and everyone upgrades their phone every 2-3 years
I think it would be better to just note which one they like and not to tell them till the end which phone they were.. would be a bit of a hassle to tally the score but since they don’t know which phone it is, there wont be any bias.
I ended up liking the S23 Ultra pictures the most. Which is surprising, because I thought I'd end up liking the 15 Pro Max photos the most. The Pixel 8 Pro had the least picks for me.
I am not trying to guess which phone it is, but I choose the most eye pleasing pictures and it turns out to be S23 ultra most of the time.
I have a Samsung and the only thing I don't like is the shutter speed, which is too slow , even in good light the shutter speed is always too slow, there's sometimes blur in photos
Yea.. i’ve sold mine.. their software cam updates are bs
U can change it in camera assistant
Mostly Pixel but I spent most of my day at work either behind camera or photoshop so not typical user I guess. Still surprised by both iP and Samsong in some cases. I assume most people would pick way more iPhone shots. All of them are more than good enough for phone camera.
S23 ultra Smartphone of the year! Period
Great video, but feels like there've been more portraits and extremely dark shots which people use the least. There should have been more regular photos of daylight, indoors, outdoors etc.
That's probably because the iphone wins with portraits... So they add more haha
i agree, this is more like a portrait photo blind test
They always tend to make it more favorable for the iPhone.
@@Ogura_Tech this channel does favour iphones....have been noticing this channel for quite some time
@@nitesh14able yes
For me, the winner is S23 Ultra. These people are looking for the iPhone photo not for the best photo. even though S23 released earlier it's photo quality is best. (I also have an iPhone. but may be I'll try with S23 next time.)
You are subjective. This is a blind test with professional photographers what do you want else ?
In the photo of the hummingbird, the iPhone image had a lot of noise and less details and they still chose the iPhone 😂
Professional photographer always will chose photo with true colors, without any tweaks
I think that just cause of these guys that are professional photographers they chose the most natural looking photo, s23 Ultra clearly had the best night time shots, day time shots and 2nd best long exposure one they just basically tried to find an excuse to pick the iPhone, as for Video the iPhone wins hands down
S23 did the best for me the others look great as well
Probably because you own a samsung
@@Randomdude21-esomeone's mad huh
@@solarcj9313 someone might be, but not me
@@Randomdude21-efacts 😂
@@solarcj9313for real 😂
I was lucky enough to have been able to test all 3, it's 3 different experiment, they are all good in their way. What i can say it's when you have them in your hand, S23 ultra and 15 Pro Max looks more premium than the Pixel 8 Pro, they have a better quality of build. For an everyday smartphone, iPhone seems to me the best, it's smooth, efficient, very easy to use, has big battery life and has a much more better front camera than the other ones. The S23 Ultra has an incredible screen, it's like a small TV you can bring with you everywhere, One UI is the most complete OS you can have but makes feel a little bit messy, the user experience is behind the other two smartphones in my opinion and like the OS, the photo shooting is very complete, the most complete but messy, it's less practical for an everyday use, a lack of ergonomics. The Pixel 8 Pro has the best OS and probably the best rear camera with the best algorithm, the user experience is just incredible. However, the smartphone itself has a quality of build very limit, it does not look like a premium one, the battery life is also very short for a flagship, the front camera is the least qualitative, Google algorithms doing too much to erase the weakness of the front camera when you make selfie. All the AI integrated into the pixel works but is still very experimental, it's very funny but not really usefull for an everyday use. The impressive evolution of Google and their management of AI makes me think it could become the indisputable number one in a few years.
They started by choosing S23 Ultra, but when they noticed the iPhone pattern they started to choose it even if some photos were not the best.
THIS GUY IS A TOP NOTCH APPLE FANBOY. U CAN'T FOOL US ANYMORE. LET THE PHOTOGRAPHERS SHOOT BY THEMSELVES AND GIVE US THE REVIEWS....PIXEL IS THE FUTURE OF SMART PHONES...
Jealous?
@@hienho15how can one be jealous of a device that is akin to a Fisher Price toy?
Tru. They should go out with the photographers and let them take the photos with the phones together and then do a review comparison, not the iPhone guy taking the pics too much room for being biased.
Can't please these android fanboy. Offended they don't pick the pictures that they like.
@@errolsmith5634 pls tell the apple fan boys to get their pens and notepads ready. Lol..
the s23 has the one ui 6 update with a bunch of nice camera improvements and the shutter speed can be changed within the settings
I believe all of them have the option to change exposure, shutter speed etc but this was just point-and-shoot kind of test. I might be wrong. I'm a Samsung user, but I really liked iPhone 15's photos more often than not, so I might switch in the future. But truth be told, all these cameras are amazing, they struggle with different issues, but what cam we expect from tiny lenses and sensors. It all comes down to personal preference.
I think u used the pixel 7pro and not the 8 pro. Pixel 8 pro photos are really bright and not as dark and pinkish as what I see in this competition
That's true, i think they used 7 pro bc pixel 8 has better camera. No sense on kin on the sand photo, all video they are trying to find the iphone.
My results:
S23U-16
Pixel- 12
iPhone-7
Mine.
Samsung 17
Iphone 11
Pixel 7
blind test is definitely the way to go when trying to pick a cell phone for their cameras
way too many reviews end up biased even if it's just a small amount
better yet, if you randomly mixed in other phones / DSLR pics and even multiple of the SAME phone in the same comparison, to get people to really focus on what pic looks best rather than inadvertently picking out which one is from their favorite brand
From what it sounds like listening to them talk they are looking to try to pick the iPhone no matter the shot.
I'm a photographer as well. I do more portraits and event photography currently. Sony A7 iv as my main shooter. I also have the 8 pro which is very accurate with white balance and more true to life images. some shots i saw here from the device i couldn't agree with. My experienc has been better.
Same. I am a pixel 8 pro owner and my shots are far better than these. Hmm. Manipulation?!
@@navidsami4526 This is an Apple fanboy channel.
@@navidsami4526it's because this is an Apple fanboi channel it's fine for them if Samsung beat their iPhone since Samsung is always neck to neck with Apple on taking images they don't want another contender to beat their iSheep units that's why.. I got both and in my experience the PX 8 Pro is even better than my S23 Ultra
You're watching a video of iPhone users, who you can tell started playing "find the iPhone."
Bro is just playing guess the iPhone that this point 😂
Happy to see my S23 ultra competing well. I assume the test was done in Android 13, Android 14 improves the camera further I believe.
I think they wanna sell the s24.
@@serrael-182 Nahh they wanna sell only iPhones.
Камера самсунг сто процентов лучше из этих трёх
Why this video has these many portrait shots. Not the regular shots?
Next year the S24 Ultra will beat the iPhone, the iPhone 17 Pro Max will beat the Samsung, and on it goes.
Yes this truth 🎉🎉
But neither will beat the Pixel since it's using software and AI years ahead of the rest. And it will only get better.
@@MarkTomeh Not based on the results though! Some of the Pixel shots looked better but most didn't.
@@MarkTomeh The Pixel is niche.
@@MarkTomehSorry but nope.
Try go to camera asistant in samsung and set prioritizing into quality only. The photos are much sharper, less noise and more detail.
It is really a big jump than defult setting camera on samsung.
The Pixel 8 Pro will receive a video boost feature in a few months. It will be interesting to compare its video performance with the iPhone 15 Pro Max.
iPhone shooting on log is more advanced than you think.
Detail will play a major role
I hope you realize it's a feature that requires Google's servers for it to work at all. I'd prefer a phone to be at its best without the huge reliance on the cloud/servers but yes it'll be an interesting one to see. A bit annoying how some of the generative AI features on the phone need to be connected to Google's servers for them to work and I live in a location where internet is really bad (Australia).
A wise man once said. You buy a phone for what it has now. Not promised features
@@toptiertech7291 Just random advice, It's important to buy a phone that meets your needs, rather than just a brand name or logo for thousands of dollars.
@@raven3696 Still, what google can pull off in a night sight video is incredible.
The category winners are like iphone for portraits, pixel for night and overall appealing pic is s23
They should give points to photos top pick 1 point 2nd rank get 0.5 or if the second one is a close win then 0.8 points or something like that
is this choosing the best picture or guessing which one is the iphone? because they choose the better pic and then get disappointed because it wasn't the iphone. i'm lost! sometime they choose the best picture but then say "ohh i think this is the ultra so i'm choosing another one". doesn't make sense. the point for me, is to choose the best picture don't matter what kind of phone it is to show or proved that not only the most popular phone have the better camera.
I also liked iPhone most of the time. Followed by s23 and then pixel.
Interesting video. Liked it 👍👌
You can really tell that iphone users have that perception of choosing the more natural colors instead of the more vibrant and bright of the Android competition, all did great honestly but from an s23 Ultra user myself I had a pretty good guess to which photos were from it, pixel 8 pro and iPhone did a pretty good job, but there's no beating the more versatile camera of the s23 ultra, the killer zoom, cropped 200mp photo and even the great night mode, I prefer it, the vibrant, contrasty, bright, the picture just looks more alive, great stuff as always! And coming from the " older " device since the pixel and iphone just launched, Samsung doing pretty well
23 ultra is a win. I love the camera, display, battery and performances. It ticks all the boxes for me.
Iphone still beats it in battery performance camera and display brightness, but yeah s23u is great phone
@@Randomdude21-e iPhone is great too. But s23U is the phone of the year.
14:30 Because of the extremely dim f/4.9 aperture of the 10x periscope on the S23 Ultra, it doesn't use it at night.
Before watch these videos, take a look in the channel, this guy is 100% apple fan.
Anyone who thinks this can be biased is clueless...
Great job guys!
Why would it be biased? If anything they should be promoting Samsung which pay generously through their affiliate links unlike Apple.
Even as an IPhone user I just have to say that this is THE channel to come to for a guaranteed IPhone win!..😂😂, but SO WHAT. Samsung and Google have their favoured reviewers also. Stuff them for moaning about our channel!..😂😂
@@stopthefomo I'm saying this because there are kiddies like the one below you wandering around...
@@neilmcguinness4422Sorry but Samsung doesn't have a favoured reviewers.
For me i like the s23 ultra so nice shots!!!love the color and ready to post..
Wow was surprised with just how good the smasung photos were glad I ordered one I was deciding which one to get but I just loved the colors the S23 Ultra had so I bought one and I can't wait to receive it
Might be hard to display on video but I would one to see a comparison between Google Pixel Ultra HDR vs Apple HDR HEIC. No one is talking about those features!!!
13 Pixel, 10 Iphone, 11 Samsung. They are too close, i can't find a trend, maybe i would say that pixel is overall better at night.
False
As a mirrorless cam user, I'm very impressed with my iPhone 15 Pro image quality. It really comes close to a dedicated cam with its "life-like" image quality, considering its small sensor.
Yeah orange skin tone pics
@@pervysage3877 Do you use an actual mirrorless camera? Because I do so I know what I say. Skin color isn't the be all and end all of image quality.
@@mamamia601lol with flares!!
@@choloong5989 Do you use an actual mirrorless camera? Because I do so I know what I say. The presence of flares and whatnot isn't the be all and end all of image quality.
@@mamamia601 lol im a photographer
Omg
You guys are all iphone fans
12:47 clearly the samsung was the best one
You can tell by the colour bias which is which. It’s basically search out the iPhone images
I'm a Samsung fanboy due to its flexibility and styling, but I agree that iPhone's camera is a lot better due to its sharpness and more natural colors than Samsung which looks "filtered". You have to own both to really compare. Stop being bitter.
15 for iPhone
8 for the Samsung
12 for pixel
Thanks
But when u choose the best photo out of all three how bad is the second best? Is there any real difference?
I have a Pixel 7 Pro and I'm surrounded by iPhone 13 and 14 Pro/Max owners. They all tell me my pictures taken with my 7 Pro are better than those taken with their phones when we go on vacation.
The night mode on the iPhone and Samsung were spot on. I know I would have tripped myself in that side walk 😅
Are they picking the photos they like the most or are they trying to choose the photo from their beloved brand?
alternative title : Find the iphone photos.
For me Iphone and S23 Ultra are the winners both with 15 points. Pixel disappoints with 5 points. I can't wait what the S24 Ultra will bring to the table.
Iphone and galaxy cameras are almost even. Each has strengths in situations where it shines, but the only reason I would say apple Wins overall is its video. They are so far ahead that it aint fair to call anything competition. I am currently using S23U, and my son has a 15PMAX
Im rocking my pixel 7 pro, but humbly I'll admit that the iPhone just has the overall better camera system.. which is crazy because the pixel prides itself in being the best... Back when I knew nothing about the pixel and bought the 3a it was amazing.. my 3a camera was better than almost all the flagships for a fraction of the price.. now it's not that way
I still own 3a, compared photos with iphone 12 pro.
3a was awesome
Pixel 8 pro will have a feature of detailed image after zooming in, in the January update. The pixel camera gets better after every update, I wish they waited for January to do this comparison vid as the new camera sensor and neural core are still learning the color science. 3 months later the camera will have its full potential.
pixel 7 pro has better color and better detail than pixel 8 pro, pixel 7 pro is sharper when zoomed in that pixel 8 pro, pixel 8 pro portrait mode is worse of all the pixel phones till now. pixel 8 pro has different lenses, than previously tried an tested ones.
@@rushabhshah.2768 you've tested both? I tried the 8 pro at Best buy and just wasn't really impressed.. the AI features will probably come the the 7 pro anyways
@@rushabhshah.2768 patience, the 8 has just launched, with updates it will surely get better!
iPhone outdid themselves this year. I hope they continue to destroy the competition in photos, they have always been the king of video. Samsung got way too lazy and google is being cheap.
😂
Now just think about that - all of the shots taken by S23 Ultra were made with the lowest available resolution (12 Mpx), while it can be set uo to shot at 50 and 200 Mpx as well. Which phone would win the competition then? :)
Grazie, i tuoi sono i migliori confronti fra fotocamere!
Make a video showcasing how to go from a s23 ultra to iphone 15 pro max
The only problem I have with this video is this I have both phones the iPhone and I have the Samsung but any of my photos looks so orange like your, why?
Thanks for the Comparison 😊
Was interested for me. At the end I figured out that Pixel is far away from Galaxy and iPhone that were very close to each other. I would like to compare it with other similar tests. Would be nice to define category here and make shot at once to put all of them in the same conditions.
I think s23 u won many of them imo bc s23 and iphone 15 was neck and neck whereas pixel felt a little short behind its the colours that prolly make me like the iphone more as 12 pm owner but well done to apple, they rlly stepped up in camera especially w samsung killing it asw this year, pixel minor improvements from last year so ok ig
The very first time I have thoroughly enjoyed a review video and watched a 17 min video for around 25 mins...I too have participated..😄👍
I didn't like the pictures taken here. I don't think they can contribute to judge these cameras well
10:30 did he LEGIT pick the left because he figured out it was the iPhone although the right is CLEARLY better? UNREAL lmfao
I can see why you would like the right over the left and vice versa. Idk if he chose the left because he thought it was the iphone but it is a valid answer.
Any photographer can tell, this is the worst cameras comparsion they can judge from.
Why?
It would be better if they are judging the photos in an objective way basing on their expertise and not as an iSheep with a very obvious bias. Just for that alone, I would not trust their opinions on this matter. This is a biased comparison and is just a waste of time and effort.
You can ignore what they say and be your own jugde and make up your own opinion m
Bro, they're literally saying "i think this is the iphone, so I'm going with the iphone."
At least try to hide the bias a little better.
Good video idea, but bad execution.
Disappointing video in so many ways! Very(!) poor selection of shots, where is the variation? On top of that they were badly executed and the presentation was also weird. Maybe you should have a better photographer plan and take the pictures next time. As for the judgement, it was ok, but I felt the photographers were more interested in guessing the phones than finding the best shot.
Agree! They always pick weird scenarios where iphone is little better or where the competition cant crush it, because it would in normal scenarios.
@@MrWerewolf69 Are you sure? I've watched like every camera comparison out there and pretty much can tell the iPhone from the others because of the yellowish/warm tint. The ones that the Pixel and s23U won were deserved.
Everyday people aren’t photographers so this is meant to represent the everyday experience of pointing and shooting. If you don’t like the results, maybe the brand you wanted just doesn’t do a good job for ordinary people
@@princem5155 So you are saying that ordinary people never ever take indoor shots?
I also didn't like they picked a weird scenario. 25X zoom when we know damn well all the photos would be taken with digital zoom. I want comparison with optical zoom. That's the ideal situation.
I was waiting for it thank you
Funny video where the photographers are just looking for the Samsung and voting against it.😂😂
I preferred their choices too as would anyone with 20/20 vision 😉
iPhone15ProMax - 14
Pixel8Pro - 5
S23Ultra - 14
I left iPhone only because they are really cheaping out on giving more storage - i Love shooting raw and 4k 60p so a 512GB Samsung Fold was cheaper and google photo's manages photos and videos much better than icloud. The way Google allows you to share videos is like sharing a youtube link. Excellent Codecs.
your people today completely don't care about adges separation from the background
2:28 Notice how on the right one, the horizontal line on the wall is a little wobbly. So when it reaches near the blue logo (the lower one), it almost splits. This looks similar to what you get when you use AI upscale like ESRGAN on Anime.
I chose the middle one as it seems to resolve it just enough to get the details while avoiding noise OR a paint like look.
With the right one, while the leaves might looks "sharper" at first glance, they really don't seem to contain any more detail.
The left one, while having more superficial levels of noise, still retains an overall more realistic look and the horizontal line on the wall is precisely straight
That night shot with the tree and the house...ARE YOU BLIND?!
My suggestion is that you take these pictures and then put them aside with ones that a camera took to see which one is closer to what the camera had to offer and which one actually had better colors.
Hi Kidroid fans
Android Users are still Crying & Furious?
But I have s22 Ultra 256GB Snapdragon.
Great video ...great job guys..subbed
Yeah seems like they were trying to figure out which one was the iPhone and going for that photo on most circumstances
The other phones are just happy to be compared against the masterpiece that’s this iPhone. But if course, there’s no contest: iPhone will always reign supreme 😊
You can tell they tried really hard to pick the iPhone every time... Extremely biased test
“That’s a horrible real estate photo” gotta love Ben! Haha 7:28
Hahaha thanks for watching, Serge!
send me some phones, I'll do a few shots for you for variety of images :)
A perfect Apple Fan Boys camera comparison.
😂
It is honestly sad
you should add cropped picture comparison
I can already tell that they still haven't updated the S23U to at least the September patch, definitely not October patch!
The title should not be "Blind Camera Test" it would be more accurate if it would be "Finding the Pictures taken by Iphone" 😂
Thanks for sharing your opinions
You can tell they are biased iPhone fanboys when starting from the macro leaf photo they tried their hardest not to pick the s23 because they thought they had figured out the color temperature of the s23.
After that it just became a game of them trying to choose whatever one was the iPhone regardless if it was the best or not.
The S24 Ultra is the real competitor. Come the S24